Comely Stakes

Last updated
Comely Stakes
Grade II race
Location Aqueduct Racetrack
Queens, New York
Inaugurated1945
Race type ThoroughbredFlat racing
Website NYRA – Aqueduct Racetrack
Race information
Distance1 mile (8 furlongs)
TrackDirt, left-handed
QualificationThree-year-old fillies
WeightAssigned
Purse$200,000

The Comely Stakes is an American Thoroughbred horse race held annually at Aqueduct Racetrack in Queens, New York. Open to three year old fillies, it is raced on dirt over a distance of one mile. The Grade III event offers a purse of $200,000. [1]

Contents

The race was named in honor of the filly Comely, who, in a remarkable performance as a two-year-old, defeated older male horses in winning the first running of the Fall Highweight Handicap in 1914. Going into 2019, she remains the only two-year-old to win the Fall Highweight Handicap and one of only a few two-year-olds to defeat older horses in a major stakes race. [2]

Inaugurated in 1945 at Jamaica Race Course, it was raced there through 1951 and again in 1959. For 1952 and 1953 it was hosted by the Empire City Race Track in Yonkers and Belmont Park in 1976, 1981, 1984, and again in 1985. There was no race run from 1954 to 1958. When revived in 1959 the race was open to two-year-olds of either sex and won by the 1960 Preakness Stakes winner, Bally Ache. [3] On April 30, 1975 the superstar filly and future Hall of Fame inductee Ruffian won the Comely by eight lengths in stakes record time. [4]

On May 11, 1985, Abigail Fuller became the first female jockey to win the Comely Stakes. She was aboard Mom's Command, a future Hall of Fame filly bred and raced by her father, Peter Fuller. [5]

The Comely was run in two divisions in 1953, 1963, and 1970.

Records

Speed record:

Most wins by a jockey:

Most wins by a trainer:

Most wins by an owner:

Winners

Year
Winner
Age
Jockey
Trainer
Owner
Dist.
(Miles)
Time
Win$
Gr.
2022Sixtythreecaliber3Kendrick Carmouche Thomas M. Amoss My Racehorse Stable & Spendthrift Farm 1+18 M1:53.89$175,000G3
2021Bees and Honey3 Jose Lezcano J. Reeve McGaughey Gainesway Farm & Andrew Rosen 1+18 M1.54.41$200,000G3
2020Mrs.Danvers3 Jose Lezcano Claude R. McGaughey III Allen Stables Inc.1+18 M1.50.09$100,000G3
2019Bellera3 John R. Velazquez Todd A. Pletcher Mathis Stables1+18 M1:52.91$110,000G3
2018Blamed3 Julien Leparoux William I. Mott Cleber J. Massey1+18 M1:51.98$120,000G3
2017Actress3 José Ortiz Jason Servis Gary & Mary West1+18 M1:52.66$150,000G3
2016Verve's Tale3 Paco Lopez Barclay Tagg Charles E. Fipke 1+18 M1:51.89$150,000G3
2015 Forever Unbridled 3 John R. Velazquez Dallas Stewart Charles E. Fipke 1+18 M1:50.75$180,000G3
2014Snowbell3 Luis Saez Thomas Albertrani Godolphin Racing 1+18 M1:52.59$240,000G3
2013Wedding Toast3 Javier Castellano Kiaran McLaughlin Godolphin Racing 1+18 M1:49.92$240,000G3
2012Broadway's Alibi3 Javier Castellano Todd A. Pletcher E. Paul Robsham Stables 1 M1:36.52$150,000G3
2011Hot Summer3 Luis Saez David J. FawkesHarold L. Queen1 M1:35.58$90,000G3
2010Touching Beauty3 Mike Luzzi James A. Jerkens Gainesway Farm & Joseph M. Cornacchia1 M1:37.90$60,000G3
2009Dream Play3 Eddie Castro Kiaran McLaughlin Stewart Armstrong1 M1:39.51$90,000G2
2008Sherine3 Alan Garcia Anthony W. Dutrow Zayat Stables 1 M1:37.25$90,000G2
2007Boca Grande3 Mike E. Smith Claude R. McGaughey III Phipps Stable 1 M1:36.54$90,000G2
2006 Miraculous Miss 3 Kent Desormeaux Steve Klesaris Puglisi Stables & Steve Klesaris1 M1:36.67$90,000G2
2005Acey Deucey3 Diane Nelson John D. MorrisonJeffrey Tucker1 M1:35.95$90,000G2
2004Society Selection3 Jorge Chavez H. Allen Jerkens Irving & Majorie Cowan1 M1:35.89$67,200G3
2003Cyber Secret3 Shaun Bridgmohan Richard E. Dutrow Jr. Goldfarb et al.1 M1:35.97$64,740G3
2002Bella Bellucci3 Gary Stevens Neil D. Drysdale Michael Tabor 1 M1:33.50$64,920G3
2001 Two Item Limit 3 Richard Migliore Stephen L. DiMauro Joseph Graffeo1 M1:36.17$66,060G3
2000March Magic3 Richard Migliore Richard Violette Jr. Ralph M. Evans1 M1:36.79$65,460G3
1999Madison's Charm3 Jean-Luc Samyn Thomas A. HauswaldDonald A. Adam1 M1:35.54$65,520G3
1998Fantasy Angel3 Jorge Chavez Martin D. Wolfson Martin L. Cherry1 M1:37.44$69,300G3
1997Dixie Flag3 Jean-Luc Samyn H. Allen Jerkens Bohemia Stable 1 M1:36.96$66,120G3
1996Little Miss Fast3 Jorge Chavez Juan SereyJames A. Riccio1 M1:36.58$65,940G3
1995Nappelon3 Jorge Chavez Rene ArayaR Kay Stable1 M1:36.26$64,440G2
1994Dixie Luck3Filiberto Leon H. Allen Jerkens Bohemia Stable 1 M1:37.02$66,240G2
1993Private Light3 Robbie Davis Claude R. McGaughey III Ogden Mills Phipps 1+116 M1:44.19$68,280G2
1992 Saratoga Dew 3 Herb McCauley Gary Sciacca Charles F. Engel1 M1:37.22$69,480G2
1991 Meadow Star 3 Chris Antley LeRoy Jolley Carl Icahn 1 M1:38.00$67,560G2
1990Fappaburst3 Jacinto Vásquez Philip G. Johnson Susan Kaskel7 F1:21.60$49,770G2
1989Surging3 Ángel Cordero Jr. D. Wayne Lukas H. Joseph Allen 7 F1:23.00$52,290G2
1988Avie's Gal3 Jorge Velásquez John J. Lenzini Jr. John Cioci7 F1:22.40$95,550G2
1987Devil's Bride3 Rafael Meza John Gosden Oak Cliff Stable7 F1:23.60$65,790G3
1986Misty Drone3 Jacinto Vásquez Alton H. Quanbeck Maud McDougald 7 F1:24.00$59,940G3
1985 Mom's Command 3 Abigail Fuller Edward T. Allard Peter D. Fuller 7 F1:22.20$55,170G3
1984Wild Applause3 Pat Day MacKenzie Miller Rokeby Stable 7 F1:23.20$52,110G3
1983Able Money3 Antonio Graell Anthony RussoFaith Donnelly7 F1:23.80$35,580G3
1982Nancy Huang3 Jorge Velásquez Howard M. Tesher H. Joseph Allen 7 F1:24.40$34,860G3
1981Expressive Dance3 Don MacBeth LeRoy Jolley Diana M. Firestone 7 F1:23.40$35,220G3
1980Cybele3 Cash Asmussen LeRoy Jolley Diana M. Firestone 7 F1:22.60$27,225G3
1979Countess North3 Ángel Cordero Jr. Stephen A. DiMauro Michael Rutherford7 F1:23.40$25,725G3
1978Mashteen3 Ruben Hernandez Laz Barrera Leslie Combs II 7 F1:23.00$25,665G3
1977Bring Out The Band3 Don Brumfield James W. Murphy Hickory Tree Stable 7 F1:23.60$22,650G3
1976Tell Me All3 John Ruane H. Allen Jerkens Hobeau Farm 7 F1:23.20$22,080G3
1975 Ruffian 3 Jacinto Vásquez Frank Y. Whiteley Jr. Locust Hill Farm7 F1:21.20$16,755G3
1974Clear Copy3Daryl MontoyaJerome HirschLeon J. Hekimian7 F1:24.40$17,670G3
1973Java Moon3 Ángel Cordero Jr. Lou Rondinello Darby Dan Farm 7 F1:22.80$17,610G3
1972Stacey d'Ette3 John Ruane Dave Erb Dave Erb 7 F1:21.60$16,290
1971 Forward Gal 3 Michael Hole Warren A. Croll Jr. Aisco Stable 7 F1:23.40$20,460
1970-1Predictable3 Robert Ussery Edward A. Neloy Wheatley Stable 7 F1:24.00$14,852
1970-2Royal Signal3 Braulio Baeza Stephen A. DiMauro Mrs. Lawrence W. Knapp Jr.7 F1:24.00$15,015
1969 Ta Wee 3 Eddie Belmonte John A. Nerud Tartan Stable 7 F1:22.60$18,492
1968Best In Show3 Heliodoro Gustines John H. SkirvinClearview Stable7 F1:22.40$19,240
1967Gala Honors3 Braulio Baeza Clyde Troutt Ada L. Rice 7 F1:25.00$18,947
1966Swift Lady3 John L. Rotz Burley Parke Harbor View Farm 7 F1:23.60$18,785
1965 What a Treat 3 John L. Rotz Sylvester E. Veitch George D. Widener Jr. 7 F1:24.80$17,680
1964Face The Facts3 Manuel Ycaza James W. Maloney William Haggin Perry 7 F1:23.80$18,525
1963-1Pams Ego3 Milo Valenzuela J. P. "Sammy" Smith Clear Springs Stable 7 F1:23.80$11,456
1963-2 Lamb Chop 3 Braulio Baeza James W. Maloney William Haggin Perry 7 F1:24.40$11,326
1962Upswept3 Braulio Baeza Robert L. Dotter James Cox Brady Jr. 7 F1:24.60$15,438
1961Seven Thirty3 Hedley Woodhouse Bert Mulholland George D. Widener Jr. 7 F1:24.20$15,112
1960Irish Jay3 Eddie Arcaro James E. Fitzsimmons Wheatley Stable 7 F1:23.00$18,680
1959 Bally Ache 2 David Erb Jimmy Pitt Leonard D. Fruchtman5 F0:59.20$11,362
1954 –1958Race not held
1953-1 La Corredora 4 Ira Hanford Carl Hanford Marian W. O'Connor1+18 M1:45.20$18,987
1953-2Home Made3 Eric Guerin Bill Winfrey Alfred Gwynne Vanderbilt Jr. 1+18 M1:45.20$19,237
1952Devilkin3 William Boland Max Hirsch John W. Hanes1+18 M1:44.60$20,250
1951 Bed O' Roses 4 Eric Guerin Bill Winfrey Alfred Gwynne Vanderbilt Jr. 1+18 M1:44.60$20,250
1950Siama3 Ovie Scurlock Moody Jolley Cain Hoy Stable 1+18 M1:45.00$20,700
1949Lithe3Herb LindbergFrank S. Barnett Hal Price Headley 1+18 M1:45.20$20,200
1948 Conniver 4 Eric Guerin William Post Harry La Montagne 1+18 M1:45.00$19,225
1947Elpis3Larry HansmanWillie Booth William G. Helis Sr. 1+18 M1:44.20$16,700
1946Bonnie Beryl3 Hedley Woodhouse James E. Fitzsimmons Belair Stud 1+18 M1:44.20$15,615
1945Moon Maiden7 Wayne D. Wright Hirsch Jacobs Isidor Bieber1+18 M1:45.40$15,615

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ruffian (horse)</span> American-bred champion Thoroughbred racehorse

Ruffian was an American Thoroughbred racehorse who won ten consecutive races, including the Acorn, Mother Goose and Coaching Club American Oaks, then known as the American Triple Tiara. She was in the lead at every point of call in every race she ever ran and set new stakes records in each of the eight stakes races she won. Her dominating wins caused her to be named the American Champion filly at both ages two and three. In July 1975, she entered a highly anticipated match race with Kentucky Derby winner Foolish Pleasure, in which she broke down. Surgery was attempted but Ruffian reacted poorly and exacerbated the injuries while coming out of anesthesia. As a result, she was euthanized.

The Acorn Stakes is an American Grade I race at Belmont Park in Elmont, New York for three-year-old Thoroughbred fillies. It is raced on dirt over a distance of one mile with a current purse of $500,000. It is the first leg of the US Triple Tiara and is followed by the Coaching Club American Oaks then the Alabama Stakes. The filly must win all three races to win the Triple Tiara, as well as the third leg of the "National" Triple Tiara.

The Coaching Club American Oaks is a race for thoroughbred three-year-old fillies and the second leg of the Triple Tiara of Thoroughbred Racing. Originally run at Belmont Park, the Grade I $500,000 stakes race was moved to Saratoga Race Course in 2010.

The Ruffian Stakes is a Grade II American thoroughbred horse race for fillies and mares ages four-years-old and older run over a distance of one mile on a dirt track scheduled annually in early May at Belmont Park in Elmont, New York.

The New York Stakes is a Grade I American thoroughbred horse race for fillies and mares aged four-years-old and older run over a distance of one and one-quarter miles on the turf scheduled annually in early June at Belmont Park in Elmont, New York. The current purse is $750,000.

The Golden Rod Stakes is an American Thoroughbred horse race held annually in late November at Churchill Downs in Louisville, Kentucky. A Grade II event open to two-year-old fillies, it is currently contested on dirt over a distance of 1+116 miles. The namesake goldenrod is the official flower of the state of Kentucky,.

The Barbara Fritchie Stakes is an American race for Thoroughbred horses run at Laurel Park Racecourse in February. A Grade III event, this race is open to fillies and mares age four and up. It is run at seven furlongs on the dirt and offers a purse of $250,000. Originally a handicap, the race is currently run under allowance weight conditions.

The Las Flores Stakes is an American Thoroughbred horse race held annually during the first week of April at Santa Anita Park in Arcadia, California. In 2015, due to the 2013 closing of Hollywood Park Racetrack and extensive rescheduling, the race was run in early March. Open to fillies and mares age four and older, the Grade III event is contested on Pro-Ride synthetic dirt over a distance of six and one half furlongs.

The Fall Highweight Handicap is an American Thoroughbred horse race held annually near the end of November at Aqueduct Racetrack in Queens, New York. Currently run at a distance of 6 furlongs, it is open to horses three years of age and older under handicap conditions. The race was given its current Grade III status in 2009 by the American Graded Stakes Committee.

Comely was an American Thoroughbred racehorse. She was bred by James R. Keene who sold her in a package deal to James Butler, owner of the Empire City Race Track. Butler had bought the entire 1912 crop produced by Keene's Castleton Stud.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mom's Command</span> American-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Mom's Command was a multiple Grade I-winning American Thoroughbred race horse. In a two-year career, she won eleven of her sixteen races. In 1985, she was voted American Champion Three-Year-Old Filly at the Eclipse Awards.

The Modesty Stakes is a Grade III American Thoroughbred horse race run annually at Churchill Downs in Louisville, Kentucky.

Bally Ache was an American Thoroughbred racehorse who won the Preakness Stakes in 1960 but died later that year. In her book American Classic Pedigrees (1914–2002), author Avalyn Hunter wrote that Bally Ache was "a crowd favorite" who "won hearts by his sheer determination."

The What A Summer Stakes is an American Thoroughbred horse race held annually in January at Laurel Park Racecourse in Laurel, Maryland. The race is open to fillies and mares four years old and up and is run at six furlongs on the dirt.

What A Summer was an American Thoroughbred Champion racehorse who defeated both male and female competitors. She was bred in Maryland by Milton Polinger. She was a gray out of the mare Summer Classic who was sired by Summer Tan. Her sire was What Luck, a multiple stakes winning son of U.S. Racing Hall of Fame inductee Bold Ruler. What A Summer is probably best remembered for her win in the Grade II $65,000 Black-Eyed Susan Stakes over stakes winners Dearly Precious and Artfully on May 14, 1976.

The Black Helen Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race run annually at Hialeah Park Race Track in Hialeah, Florida, from 1941 through 2001. Open to fillies and mares age three and older, the Grade II event was raced on turf at a distance of a mile and an eighth.

The Hibiscus Stakes was an American Thoroughbred horse race run annually at Hialeah Park Race Track in Hialeah, Florida from 1936 through 2001 when the racetrack ceased operations. In its final years, the race was run in mid May for fillies and mares, age three and up. Previously, it was a seven furlong race for three-year-old fillies from 1977 to 1994, but before that it was run each January at six furlongs on dirt for three-year-olds of either sex and was one of the first important races for those looking to get to the Kentucky Derby, first leg of the United States Triple Crown of Thoroughbred Racing|U.S. Triple Crown series.

The Juvenile Stakes was a Thoroughbred horse race run for 109 years between 1874 and 1984. First run on June 13, 1874, it was an important part of Jerome Park's "Spring Meeting." The race was designed to show which were the top two-year-olds at that point in the calendar.

Disguise was an American Thoroughbred racehorse who won the 1900 Jockey Club Stakes in England but is best remembered for his success as a sire.

Abigail Fuller is a retired thoroughbred horse racer who primarily competed between the early 1980s to early 2000s. While competing in graded stakes races, Fuller won two Grade III events, one Grade II event and four Grade I events. Fuller won the majority of her graded stakes with Mom's Command between 1984 to 1985. Fuller was the 1985 Filly Triple Crown champion with her wins at the Mother Goose Stakes, Acorn Stakes and the Coaching Club American Oaks.

References

  1. "Comely Stakes". New York Racing Association (NYRA). 2018-11-23. Retrieved 2018-12-16.
  2. "History Challenge: Comely enjoyed remarkable season in 1914". Daily Racing Form (DRF). 2014-11-21. Retrieved 2018-12-22.
  3. "Bally Ache Dies At Breeding Farm". New York Times. 1960-10-30. Retrieved 2018-12-22.
  4. "On the 30th Anniversary of Ruffian's Last Race". Equus Magazine. 2005-07-05. Retrieved 2018-12-22.
  5. "Mom's Command Takes Comely by 4½". New York Times. 1942-06-27. Retrieved 2018-12-22.