Council at Fili

Last updated
Painting by Alexei Kivshenko "Military Council at Fili" (1880) Kutuzov fili.jpg
Painting by Alexei Kivshenko "Military Council at Fili" (1880)
Council at Fili
Invisible Square.svg
Invisible Square.svg
Mapscaleline.svg
200km
125miles
Berezina
8
Invisible Square.svg
Maloyaro-
slavets
7
Invisible Square.svg
Moscow
6
Invisible Square.svg
Borodino
5
Invisible Square.svg
Minard.png
See Moscou on the map, see also Attrition warfare against Napoleon

The Council at Fili was a military council, which was convened on 13 September 1812 after the Battle of Borodino during the French invasion of Russia by Commander-in-Chief Mikhail Kutuzov in the village of Fili, west of Moscow. The question was asked whether, after the orderly retreat from the Battle of Borodino that Napoleon had won despite great losses of the Grand Armee, to give another battle near Moscow or to abandon the city without a fight. [1]

Contents

On the eve of the council

On the eve of the council, formations of the Russian Army were located west of Moscow to give battle to Napoleon's troops. The position had been chosen by General Leonty Bennigsen. Barclay de Tolly had inspected the battlefield on horseback and came to the conclusion that the position was fatal to the formations of the Russian army. The same conclusions after him came, having traveled to the location of the Russian troops, to Alexei Ermolov and Karl Tol.[ citation needed ]

Course of the council in Fili

The council was attended by generals Mikhail Barclay de Tolly, Leonty Bennigsen, who was delayed on the way, Dmitry Dokhturov, Alexei Ermolov, Peter Konovnitsyn, Alexander Osterman-Tolstoy, Nikolay Raevsky, who was very late, [lower-alpha 1] Karl Tol, Fedor Uvarov, and General Paisiy Kaysarov who was on duty that day. [lower-alpha 2] There was no protocol. The main sources of information about the council are the memoirs of Raevsky and Ermolov, as well as a letter from Nikolai Longinov to Semyon Vorontsov in London.

Bennigsen, who opened the meeting, formulated a dilemma – to give battle in an unfavorable position or to surrender the ancient capital to the enemy. Kutuzov corrected him that it was not about saving Moscow, but about saving the army, since you can count on victory only if the combat-ready army is preserved. Barclay de Tolly proposed retreating to the Vladimirsky Tract and further to Nizhny Novgorod, so that in the event of Napoleon's turn to Petersburg, he would have time to block his path.

In his speech, Bennigsen announced that the retreat makes senseless the bloodshed of Borodino. The surrender of the sacred to the Russian city will undermine the fighting spirit of the soldiers. Great will be purely material losses from the ruin of noble estates. Despite the onset of darkness, he proposed to regroup and attack the Grande Armée without delay. Bennigsen's proposal was supported by Yermolov, Konovnitsyn, Uvarov and Dohturov.

The first to speak in the debate was Barclay de Tolly, who criticized the position near Moscow and suggested retreating: "Having saved Moscow, Russia is not saved from a cruel, ruinous war. But if we save the army, the hopes of the Fatherland are not yet destroyed, and the war... can continue with convenience: the prepared troops will have time to join in different places outside Moscow". [2]

Osterman-Tolstoy, Raevsky and Tol spoke for the fact that Russia is not in Moscow. The latter pointed out that the army exhausted by the battle of Borodino was not ready for a new equally large-scale battle, especially since many commanders were disabled by wounds. At the same time, the army's retreat along the streets of Moscow will make a painful impression on the townspeople. To this Kutuzov objected that "the French army will dissolve in Moscow like a sponge in the water", and offered to retreat to the Ryazan road.

Savrasov's painting "House of Council at Fili" Izba soveta v Filiakh.jpg
Savrasov's painting "House of Council at Fili"

Kutuzov, based on the minority opinion present, decided against engaging in battle from an unfavorable position and chose to abandon Moscow. He echoed Barclay de Tolly's sentiment that "with the loss of Moscow, Russia is still not lost" to preserve the army for ongoing warfare and to move closer to available reserves. This decision required significant courage due to the immense responsibility of surrendering the historical capital to the enemy, which could lead to his resignation as commander-in-chief. The reaction of the court to this decision was unpredictable.

After the council in Fili

At the end of the council, Kutuzov summoned the quartermaster-general Dmitry Lanskoy and ordered him to ensure the supply of food on the Ryazan road. At night, the adjutant of Kutuzov heard him cry. The army, which was preparing for battle, was ordered to retreat, causing widespread bewilderment and grumbling. Retreat in the city was carried out at night. Authorities in Moscow, led by Count Fedor Rostopchin, were taken aback at the decision to retreat.

After two day crossings, the Russian army turned from the Ryazan road to Podolsk onto the old Kaluga road, and from there onto the new Kaluga one. As part of the Cossacks continued to retreat to Ryazan, the French scouts were disoriented, and Napoleon for 9 days had no idea about the whereabouts of the Russian troops. [3]

Memory of the council

The Council at Fili was described by Leo Tolstoy in the novel War and Peace. Based on the Tolstoy literary basis, the artist Alexei Kivshenko painted two paintings of the same content depicting the main characters on the 70th anniversary of the council, the first in 1880 (stored in the Russian Museum), the second in 1882 (Tretyakov Gallery). [4]

In the tradition of Tolstoy and Kivshenko, the council is depicted in the epic of Sergei Bondarchuk "War and Peace" (1967). For reasons of economy of timing, among all the council members in the film, the word was given only to Kutuzov and Bennigsen (the latter speaks Russian on the movie screen, which he did not actually speak). [5]

The hut of the peasant Mikhail Frolov (often mistakenly called Andrei Sevastyanovich Frolov or, following Leo Tolstoy, Andrei Sevastyanov), [6] in which the council took place, burned down in 1868 but was restored in 1887. Since 1962, it is a branch of the Borodino Panorama Museum. The initial appearance of the hut is reliably known thanks to a number of studies carried out in the 1860s by Alexei Savrasov.

See also

Explanatory Notes

  1. When Raevsky arrived at the meeting, Ermolov briefly brought him up to date.
  2. In some sources, among those present, Matvey Platov and Mikhail Miloradovich were mistakenly mentioned.

Notes

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pyotr Bagration</span> Russian general (1765–1812)

Prince Pyotr Ivanovich Bagration was a Russian general and prince of Georgian origin, prominent during the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Borodino</span> 1812 battle during the French invasion of Russia

The Battle of Borodino took place near the village of Borodino on 7 September [O.S. 26 August] 1812 during Napoleon's invasion of Russia. The Grande Armée won the battle against the Imperial Russian Army, but failed to gain a decisive victory and suffered tremendous losses. Napoleon fought against General Mikhail Kutuzov, whom the Emperor Alexander I of Russia had appointed to replace Barclay de Tolly on 29 August [O.S. 17 August] 1812 after the Battle of Smolensk. After the Battle of Borodino, Napoleon remained on the battlefield with his army; the Imperial Russian forces retreated in an orderly fashion southwards. Because the Imperial Russian army had severely weakened the Grande Armée, they allowed the French occupation of Moscow, using the city as bait to trap Napoleon and his men. The failure of the Grande Armée to completely destroy the Imperial Russian army, in particular Napoleon's reluctance to deploy his Imperial Guard, has been widely criticised by historians as a huge blunder, as it allowed the Imperial Russian army to continue its retreat into territory increasingly hostile to the French. Approximately a quarter of a million soldiers were involved in the battle, and it was the bloodiest single day of the Napoleonic Wars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michael Andreas Barclay de Tolly</span> Russian general (1761–1818)

Prince Michael Andreas Barclay de Tolly was a Russian Field Marshal who figured prominently in the Napoleonic Wars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mikhail Kutuzov</span> Field Marshal of the Russian Empire

Prince Mikhail Illarionovich Golenishchev-Kutuzov-Smolensky was a Field Marshal of the Russian Empire. He served as a military officer and a diplomat under the reign of three Romanov monarchs: Empress Catherine II, and Emperors Paul I and Alexander I. Kutuzov was shot in the head twice while fighting the Turks and survived the serious injuries seemingly against all odds. He defeated Napoleon as commander-in-chief using attrition warfare in the Patriotic war of 1812. Alexander I, the incumbent Tsar during Napoleon's invasion, would write that he would be remembered amongst Europe's most famous commanders and that Russia would never forget his worthiness.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Levin August von Bennigsen</span> German general serving Russia (1745–1826)

Levin August Gottlieb Theophil, Grafvon Bennigsen was a German general in the service of the Russian Empire. Bennigsen made a name for himself in Russian history as the man who fought Napoleon Bonaparte with distinction at the Battle of Eylau; but, suffering from ill-health, he was then defeated at Friedland several months later. Bennigsen also played a pivotal role in decisively defeating Napoleon in the War of the Sixth Coalition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Pułtusk (1806)</span> 1806 Battle during the War of the Fourth Coalition

The Battle of Pułtusk took place on 26 December 1806 during the War of the Fourth Coalition near Pułtusk, Poland. Despite their strong numerical superiority and artillery, the Russians suffered the French attacks, before retiring the next day having suffered greater losses than the French, disorganizing their army for the rest of the year.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Smolensk (1812)</span> 1812 battle during the French invasion of Russia

The Battle of Smolensk was the first major battle of the French invasion of Russia. It took place on 16–18 August 1812 and involved about 45,000 men of the Grande Armée under Emperor Napoleon I against about 30,000 Russian troops under General Barclay de Tolly. Napoleon occupied Smolensk by driving out Prince Pyotr Bagration's Second Army. The French artillery bombardment burned the city to the ground. Of 2,250 buildings, 84% were destroyed with only 350 surviving intact. Of the city's 15,000 inhabitants, about 1,000 were left at the end of the battle inside the smoking ruins. With over 15,000 casualties, it was one of the bloodiest battles of the invasion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dmitry Dokhturov</span> Russian general (1756–1816)

Dmitry Sergeyevich Dokhturov was a Russian infantry general and a prominent military leader during the Patriotic War of 1812.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Tarutino</span> 1812 battle during the French invasion of Russia

The Battle of Tarutino was a part of Napoleon's invasion of Russia. In the battle, Russian troops under the general command of Bennigsen, on instructions from Kutuzov, launched an attack and defeated French troops under the command of Joachim Murat. The battle is sometimes called the Battle of Vinkovo or the Battle of the Chernishnya after the local river. Many historians claim that the latter name is more fitting because the village of Tarutino was 8 km from the described events.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fire of Moscow (1812)</span> Part of the French invasion of Russia

During the French occupation of Moscow, a fire persisted from 14 to 18 September 1812 and all but destroyed the city. The Russian troops and most of the remaining civilians had abandoned the city on 14 September 1812 just ahead of French Emperor Napoleon's troops entering the city after the Battle of Borodino. The Moscow military governor, Count Fyodor Rostopchin, has often been considered responsible for organising the destruction of the sacred former capital to weaken the French army in the scorched city even more.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Saltanovka</span> 1812 battle during the French invasion of Russia

The Battle of Saltanovka, also known as the Battle of Mogilev, took place on 23 July 1812 during the early stages of the 1812 French invasion of Russia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bagration flèches</span> Historic field fortifications near Borodino, Moscow Oblast, Russia

The Bagration flèches are three historic military earthworks named after General Pyotr Bagration, who ordered their construction. They served as the pivotal strongholds on the Russian left flank during the Battle of Borodino on 7 September [O.S. 26 August] 1812. Located south-west of the village of Semyonovskoye, the flèches consisted of two lunettes and one redan. The opposing French and Russian armies stormed the flèches eight times in the course of the battle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">French invasion of Russia</span> 1812 conflict during the Napoleonic Wars

The French invasion of Russia, also known as the Russian campaign and in Russia as the Patriotic War of 1812, was initiated by Napoleon with the aim of compelling the Russian Empire to comply with the continental blockade of the United Kingdom. Widely studied, Napoleon's incursion into Russia stands as a focal point in military history, recognized as among the most devastating military endeavors globally. In a span of fewer than six months, the campaign exacted a staggering toll, claiming the lives of nearly a million soldiers and civilians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Order of battle of the French invasion of Russia</span>

This is the order of battle of the French invasion of Russia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Vitebsk (1812)</span> 1812 battle during the French invasion of Russia

The battle of Vitebsk, sometimes spelled Witepsk, was a military engagement that took place on 26 and 27 July 1812 during the French invasion of Russia. The battle put a French force, under the command of Emperor Napoleon I, in combat with Russian rearguard forces under General Petr Konovnitsyn and Peter von der Pahlen and ended with the Russian forces making a strategic retreat from the battlefield.

<i>The Ballad of Uhlans</i> 2012 Russian film

The Ballad of Uhlans is a 2012 Russian historical adventure film directed by Oleg Fesenko, and stars Sergei Bezrukov, Anna Chipovskaya, Anton Sokolov and Vladimir Gostyukhin.

Kutuzov is a 1943 Soviet drama film directed by Vladimir Petrov.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">French occupation of Moscow</span> 1812 occupation during the French invasion of Russia

French Emperor Napoléon Bonaparte's Grande Armée occupied Moscow from 14 September to 19 October 1812 during the Napoleonic Wars. It marked the summit of the French invasion of Russia. During the occupation, which lasted 36 days, the city was devastated by fire and Napoleon ordered a systematic looting of the churches to fill his war chest with silver.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alexander Chechenskiy</span>

Alexander Nikolayevich Chechenskiy was a Russian major general in the Russian imperial cavalry of Chechen descent. He participated in the War of the Fourth Coalition and Patriotic War of 1812 among many other conflicts.

References