Cretacladoides

Last updated

Cretacladoides
Temporal range: Valanginian
41598 2020 77964 Fig1 HTML.png
Holotype tooth of Cretacladoides noricum
Scientific classification Red Pencil Icon.png
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Chondrichthyes
Order: Symmoriiformes
Family: Falcatidae
Genus: Cretacladoides
Feichtinger et al. 2018
Type species
Cretacladoides ogiveformis
Feichtinger et al., 2018
Species
  • C. ogiveformis(Feichtinger et al., 2018)
  • C. noricum(Feichtinger et al., 2018)

Cretacladoides ("cladodont likeness from the Cretaceous") is a genus of chondrichthyan, possibly a falcatid, found in France and Austria. Known solely from teeth, mainly found in the Klausrieglerbach locality of Austria, it consists of two species, C. ogiveformis and C. noricum. Assuming a falcatid identity, it is the most recent member of the family, which otherwise became extinct at the end of the Carboniferous.

Contents

History of discovery

The teeth of Cretacladoides were discovered on a field trip by palaeontologist Alexander Lukeneder in 2012. The limestone in which it was found yielded a diverse tooth assemblage, and was dissolved in acetic acid so they could be extracted. In total, 7 kg of limestone contained roughly 88 diagnosable teeth, including 41 teeth that undoubtedly belonged to elasmobranchs. While some of these had been described in a prior paper, the others were mounted on stubs, coated with gold and scanned with an electron microscope at the Palaeontological Department of the University of Vienna. [1]

The generic name of Cretacladoides is a combination of the words Cretaceous, cladodont, and the Greek word "εἶδος" (oides) which means "similar," or "likeness," alluding to its age and similarities to the teeth of Palaeozoic cladodontomorph chondrichthyans. [1]

Description

Life restorations of Falcatus, which Cretacladoides may have resembled. Falcatus.jpg
Life restorations of Falcatus , which Cretacladoides may have resembled.

The teeth of Cretacladoides are multicuspid in structure, with a cladodont-like crown, and measure less than 1 millimetre (0.10 cm) in width and height. The main cusp is triangular, and flanked by either two or three pairs of lateral cusplets. The first pair of cusplets is very small, while the second reaches three quarters of the main cusp's height. The third pair, when present, is roughly half the size of the second pair. The cutting edges are apparently continuous between the apex of the main cusps and the cusplets. In profile view, all cusps are inclined inwards. The labial crown face possesses either an ogive-shaped enameloid structure on the main cusp, or two converging ridges, depending on which tooth it is. [1]

Viewed from the base, the root is D-shaped, possessing a small labial budge beneath the main cusp. From a lingual view, the root face has a well-developed protuberance below the main cusp. One pair of foramina opens laterally to this protuberance, while the second pair is below a notch which separates the second and third lateral cusplets. The aboral root face possesses two foramina, one central to the root face and the other in line with the main cusp towards the mouth. [1]

Palaeoecology

The Klausrieglerbach locality is known to have had at least three other named chondrichthyans, of the genera Altusmirus , Natarapax and Smiliteroscyllium . The former is a ground shark, [2] Smiliteroscyllium is a carpet shark, [2] and Natarapax may be a ctenacanthid. [1] The teeth of a galeomorph shark of uncertain affinities have also been found. [2] Ammonites of the genera Karsteniceras and Olcostephanus have been found, with the former being represented by shells and aptychi, as well as lower beaks of an ammonite resembling Lamellaptychus . [3] Calpionellids and dinoflagellates are also known from the same locality. [1]

Late Survival

Assuming that Cretacladoides is a member of the Falcatidae, a family of symmoriiform chondrichthyans that otherwise became extinct in the Carboniferous, it implies the existence of a ghost lineage. [1] One explanation put forward by its describers is that it occupied deep-sea habitats, which allowed its line to survive the Permian–Triassic extinction event and leave very few fossils. [1] Indeed, the deep-sea palaeoenvironment of the Klausrieglerbach locality was a dysoxic deep-sea environment, meaning it had very little oxygen. [4] It was described in conjunction with a possible ctenacanthid, Natarapax trivortex , which may indicate an additional ghost lineage in France. [1] [5]

The interpretation of Cretacladoides as a falcatid was contested by Ivanov (2022), who argued that teeth of Cretacladoides only superficially resemble teeth of Paleozoic falcatids. The author noted the differences in the morphology of the tooth crown of Paleozoic and putative Cretaceous falcatids (different shape of cusps, which are separated from each other in Paleozoic teeth and connected to each other in Cretaceous teeth; cutting edge weakly developed or missing in Paleozoic teeth, but well-developed in Cretaceous teeth) and in the structure of their tooth base. Ivanov considered it more likely that putative falcatid teeth described from the Early Cretaceous of Europe should be attributed to neoselachians instead. [6]

Related Research Articles

Chondrichthyes Class of jawed cartilaginous fishes

Chondrichthyes is a class that contains the cartilaginous fishes that have skeletons primarily composed of cartilage. They can be contrasted with the Osteichthyes or bony fishes, which have skeletons primarily composed of bone tissue. Chondrichthyes are jawed vertebrates with paired fins, paired nares, scales, and a heart with its chambers in series. Extant chondrichthyes range in size from the 10 cm finless sleeper ray to the 10 m whale shark.

<i>Cladoselache</i>

Cladoselache is an extinct genus of shark-like chondrichthyan from the Late Devonian (Famennian) of North America. Growing to several meters in length, it is considered to have been a fast-moving and fairly agile marine predator due to its streamlined body and deeply forked tail. Cladoselache is one of the best known of the early chondrichthyans in part due to an abundance of well preserved fossils, discovered in the Cleveland Shale on the south shore of Lake Erie. In addition to the skeleton, the fossils were so well preserved that they included traces of skin, muscle fibers, and internal organs, such as the kidneys.

<i>Orthacanthus</i> Extinct genus of sharks

Orthacanthus is an extinct genus of fresh-water xenacanthid sharks, named by Louis Agassiz in 1836, ranging from the Upper Carboniferous until the Lower Permian. Orthacanthus had a nektobenthic life habitat, with a carnivorous diet. Multiple sources have also discovered evidence of cannibalism in the diet of Orthacanthus and of "filial cannibalism" where adult Orthacanthus preyed upon juvenile Orthacanthus. The genus Orthacanthus has been synonymized with Dittodus, Didymodus, and Diplodus.

<i>Helicoprion</i> Genus of fossil fishes

Helicoprion is an extinct genus of shark-like eugeneodont fish. Almost all fossil specimens are of spirally arranged clusters of the individuals' teeth, called "tooth whorls", which in life were embedded in the lower jaw. As with most extinct cartilaginous fish, the skeleton is mostly unknown. Fossils of Helicoprion are known from a 20 million year timespan during the Permian period from the Artinskian stage of the Cisuralian to the Roadian stage of the Guadalupian. The closest living relatives of Helicoprion are the chimaeras, though their relationship is very distant. The unusual tooth arrangement is thought to have been an adaption for feeding on soft bodied prey, and may have functioned as a deshelling mechanism for hard bodied cephalopods such as nautiloids and ammonoids. In 2013, systematic revision of Helicoprion via morphometric analysis of the tooth whorls found only H. davisii, H. bessonowi and H. ergassaminon to be valid, with some of the larger tooth whorls being outliers.

<i>Stethacanthus</i> Extinct genus of cartilaginous fishes

Stethacanthus is an extinct genus of shark-like holocephalians which lived from the Late Devonian to Late Carboniferous epoch, dying out around 298.9 million years ago. Fossils have been found in Asia, Europe and North America.

Xenacanthida Extinct order of sharks

Xenacanthida is an order of prehistoric sharks that appeared during the Lower Carboniferous period. The order includes the families Xenacanthidae, Diplodoselachidae, and Orthacanthidae. The most notable members of the group are the genera Xenacanthus and Orthacanthus. Some Xenacanthida may have grown to lengths of 5 m (16 ft). Most forms had large serrated spines extending backwards from the neck. Xenacanthus had characteristic teeth. Most xenacanths died out at the end of the Permian in the Permian Mass Extinction, with only a few forms surviving into the Triassic period. They were native to freshwater, marginal marine and shallow marine habitats.

Symmoriiformes Extinct order of cartilaginous fishes

Symmoriiformes is an extinct order of holocephalians. Originally named Symmoriida by Zangerl (1981), it has subsequently been known by several other names. Lund (1986) synonymized the group with Cladodontida, while Maisey (2008) corrected the name to Symmoriiformes in order to prevent it from being mistaken for a family. The symmoriiform fossils record appear at the beginning of the Carboniferous. Most of them died out at the start of the Permian, but Dwykaselachus is known from the Artinskian-Kungurian of South Africa. Teeth described from the Valanginian of France and Austria indicate that members of the family Falcatidae might have survived until the Early Cretaceous; however, these teeth were also argued to be more likely neoselachian teeth.

<i>Falcatus</i> Extinct genus of cartilaginous fishes

Falcatus is an extinct genus of falcatid chondrichthyan which lived during the early Carboniferous Period in Bear Gulch bay in what is now Montana.

Falcatidae Extinct family of cartilaginous fishes

Falcatidae is a family of Paleozoic holocephalians. Members of this family include Falcatus, a small fish from the Bear Gulch Limestone of Montana. The family first appeared around the start of the Carboniferous, and there is some evidence that they survived well into the early Cretaceous, though its putative Cretaceous members were also argued to be more likely neoselachians.

Hybodontiformes Extinct order of sharks

Hybodontiformes, also called hybodonts, are an extinct subset of Elasmobranchii which existed from the late Devonian to the Late Cretaceous. They form the group of sharks closest to neoselachians, the clade of modern sharks and rays. Hybodonts were named and are distinguished based on their conical tooth shape. They comprised the main group of Jurassic sharks in Europe and North America. They survived into the Late Cretaceous before going extinct, possibly due to competition from other sharks. Lonchidion was one of the last hybodonts — its distinctive serrated fine spines occur in freshwater deposits from Wyoming alongside the fossils of the last non-avian dinosaurs, including Tyrannosaurus rex and Triceratops. Hybodontiformes are identified in the fossil record predominantly based on distinct teeth and fin spines. They were known to live in both fresh and salt water environments.

<i>Cardabiodon</i> Extinct genus of sharks

Cardabiodon is an extinct genus of large mackerel shark that lived about 95 to 91 million years ago (Ma) during the Cenomanian to Turonian of the Late Cretaceous. It is a member of the Cardabiodontidae, a family unique among mackerel sharks due to differing dental structures, and contains the two species C. ricki and C. venator. Cardabiodon fossils have been found in Australia, North America, England, and Kazakhstan. It was likely an antitropical shark that inhabited temperate neritic and offshore oceans between 40° and 60° paleolatitude, similar to the modern porbeagle shark.

<i>Cladodus</i> Extinct genus of cartilaginous fishes

Cladodus is an extinct genus of cartilaginous fishes in the family Cladoselachidae. As the name implies, they are a type of cladodont, primitive sharks with teeth designed to snag fish and swallow them whole, instead of sawing off chunks to swallow.

Cladodont

Cladodont is the term for a common category of early Devonian shark known primarily for its "multi-cusped" tooth consisting of one long blade surrounded by many short, fork-like tines, designed to catch food that was swallowed whole, instead of being used to saw off chunks of meat like many modern sharks. The skinny teeth would puncture and grasp the prey, keeping it from wriggling free.

Synechodontiformes Extinct order of sharks

Synechodontiformes is an extinct order of prehistoric sharks, known from the Permian to the Paleogene. They are a stem-group of Neoselachii, the group that contains modern sharks and rays. They were previously considered a paraphyletic grouping, but recent studies have recovered the group as monophyletic. Members of the clade are united by two synapomorphies, "pseudopolyaulacorhize tooth root pattern present; labial root depression in basal view present". The oldest possible member of the clade are teeth from the early Permian (Cisuralian) of the Ural Mountains.

This list of fossil fish described in 2018 is a list of new taxa of jawless vertebrates, placoderms, acanthodians, fossil cartilaginous fish, bony fish, and other fish of every kind that are scheduled to be described during the year 2018, as well as other significant discoveries and events related to paleontology of fish that are scheduled to occur in 2018.

Altusmirus is an extinct genus of ground shark from the Early Cretaceous age of Austria. There is only one known species, A. triquetrus, named by Iris Fuchs in 2018. It was related to Fornicatus.

Ctenacanthiformes Extinct order of cartilaginous fishes

Ctenacanthiformes is an extinct order of chondrichthyan fish. They possessed ornamented fin spines and cladodont dentition. Members of the family Ctenacanthidae may have survived into the Cretaceous based on teeth found in deep water deposits of Valanginian age in France and Austria.

Ctenacanthidae Prehistoric family of cartilaginous fishes

Ctenacanthidae is an extinct family of prehistoric sharks in the order Ctenacanthiformes. Species of the different genera are found in strata ranging from Devonian to Cretaceous, with a worldwide distribution.

Ctenacanthoidea Prehistoric family of cartilaginous fish

Ctenacanthoidea is an extinct superfamily of prehistoric sharks. These nectonic carnivores of actively mobile appeared 407 Ma ago, and managed to survive until the early Cretaceous. Miocene record, Wodnika ocoyae is later considered as concretion. Its distribution is practically worldwide.

<i>Lebachacanthus</i>

Lebachacanthus is a genus of extinct Xenacanthid shark known from the early Permian. During the late Paleozoic, xenacanths ruled the freshwater swamps and bogs of the world, preying on small amphibian-like animals.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Iris Feichtinger, Andrea Engelbrecht, Alexander Lukeneder & Jürgen Kriwet (2018) New chondrichthyans characterised by cladodont-like tooth morphologies from the Early Cretaceous of Austria, with remarks on the microstructural diversity of enameloid, Historical Biology, 32:6, 823-836, DOI: 10.1080/08912963.2018.1539971
  2. 1 2 3 Iris Fuchs; Andrea Engelbrecht; Alexander Lukeneder; Jürgen Kriwet (2018). "New Early Cretaceous sharks (Chondrichthyes, Elasmobranchii) from deep-water deposits of Austria". Cretaceous Research. 84: 245–257. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2017.11.013.
  3. Alexander Lukeneder (2014) "Cretaceous ammonites from Upper Austria."
  4. Alexander Lukeneder (2003) "The Karsteniceras level: dysoxic ammonoid beds within the Early Cretaceous (Barremian, Northern Calcareous Alps, Austria)." Vienna.
  5. Guillaume Guinot, Sylvain Adnet, Lionel Cavin, Cappetta Henri; (2013). Cretaceous stem chondrichthyans survived the end-Permian mass extinction. Nature communications. 4. 2669. 10.1038/ncomms3669.
  6. Ivanov, A. O. (2022). "New late Carboniferous chondrichthyans from the European Russia". Bulletin of Geosciences. 97 (2): 219–234. doi:10.3140/bull.geosci.1845.