Disappearance of Timothy MacColl

Last updated

Timothy MacColl
Born
Timothy Andrew MacColl

1984 (1984)
Killin, Stirlingshire, Scotland
Disappeared27 May 2012 (aged 28)
Port Rashid, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
Status Missing for 11 years, 1 month and 25 days
SpouseRachael MacColl
Children3
Parent
  • Sheena MacColl (mother)
Military career
AllegianceFlag of the United Kingdom.svg  United Kingdom
Service/branchNaval Ensign of the United Kingdom.svg  Royal Navy
Years of service2005–2012
Rank Leading seaman
Service number D257698W

Timothy Andrew MacColl (born 1984) was a Royal Navy leading seaman who disappeared early on the morning of 27 May 2012 in the Port Rashid area of Dubai.

Contents

His disappearance was investigated by the police in Dubai and by the Royal Navy. In 2014, the Royal Navy issued a death certificate listing death by drowning, despite there being no evidence of this and contrary to his wife's wishes.

Disappearance

MacColl was serving aboard the Type 23 frigate HMS Westminster as part of the ship's seven-month security mission in the Middle East. [1] The ship docked in Port Rashid, Dubai on 26 May 2012 and left four days after MacColl's disappearance on 31 May. [2] MacColl spent an earlier part of the day swimming at the Seafarers Mission in Dubai before he and some of his shipmates went out drinking in the town. [3]

The last time that MacColl was accounted for was when they were at the Rock Bottom Café in the Deira area of Bur Dubai. MacColl was put into a taxi to take him back to the ship at 2:00 am local time by some of his shipmates. [4] The drive time between the Rock Bottom Café and where HMS Westminster was docked was about 15 minutes. [5] He never made it on board the ship and there have been possible sightings of MacColl getting into a taxi at 3:00 am local time to head back into Bur Dubai. [6]

Investigation

The Royal Navy reported him missing later that same day. An investigation was launched by the Dubai Police Force and two Counter Terrorism Command officers from the United Kingdom were flown out to Dubai to assist in this. Members of HMS Westminster walked the route that the taxi should have taken between the Rock Bottom Café and the location of the ship's berth and also talked to local people in the area. [5] The port area was searched by divers, dogs and helicopters with heat-seeking equipment, but nothing was found. [3] The police in Dubai interviewed the taxi driver who dropped MacColl off at a tea shack in the port area. [3]

Checks were made at police stations, hospitals, mortuaries, medical centres and prisons with there being no record of him. His wife Rachael said that the disappearance was completely out of character and that she had arranged to talk to her husband via Skype later on in the same day that he went missing. [7]

MacColl never appeared in a Skype call with his wife Rachael as arranged, but she was not informed of his disappearance for 72 hours. She has criticised the Royal Navy for the delay. [8]

MacColl's family have also been openly critical of the Royal Navy and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office's investigation into his disappearance. They say that they have often been met with a wall of silence, that no information is being passed along and that the Ministry of Defence prevented MacColl's shipmates from wearing yellow ribbons as a tribute to their missing co-worker. [9] Rachael MacColl and Neil Cunningham (MacColl's uncle, who is a detective constable in Hampshire) flew out to Dubai in January 2013.

After the new witnesses came forward, they asked MacColl's former shipmates if they knew anything at all. Cunningham was quoted as saying "197 members of the ship's company in and around Dubai for eight days – I'm sure there's more information that can assist us and encourage the Dubai Police to carry on the investigation." [10]

Theories

The belief held by the Royal Navy is that MacColl fell into the sea near to where HMS Westminster was berthed, and drowned. This is what they have recorded on his death certificate. However, a new theory came to light when new witnesses recalled seeing another taxi turn up at the ship with MacColl getting in and returning to Dubai. [11] [12]

Subsequent events

When HMS Westminster returned to dock in the United Kingdom at Portsmouth, the crew were instructed to leave a space when they stand on the deck as they were cheered on by family and friends. The lining of the deck, known as Procedure Alpha, is traditional when returning to port for Royal Navy ships. [13]

In February 2013, Rachael MacColl closed down the Facebook group associated with her husband's disappearance. The group had attracted over 100,000 people and offered up lots of information, but Rachael MacColl said that it just reminded her of what she and her children had lost. By that point, it had been over a year since the family had last seen Timothy MacColl due to him setting sail for the naval mission that HMS Westminster was undertaking. Rachael MacColl described the website as having an adverse effect on all of their lives. [14]

Two years later, in May 2014, Leading Seaman MacColl was declared dead. His death certificate lists his death as being due to drowning. His wife maintains that MacColl "is disappeared, not missing" and contested the notion that he died by drowning and disagreed with the Navy about declaring death. [15] The Navy maintain that this was necessary to enable his wife to claim his pension, and she was also served notice that she must vacate her military Service Family Accommodation (SFA) at Gosport as she no longer had an entitlement to it, as is normal procedure for all spouses. [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gosport</span> Coastal town in Hampshire, England

Gosport is a town and non-metropolitan borough, on the south coast of Hampshire, South East England. At the 2021 Census, its population was 81,952. Gosport is situated on a peninsula on the western side of Portsmouth Harbour, opposite the city of Portsmouth, to which it is linked by the Gosport Ferry. Gosport lies south-east of Fareham, to which it is linked by a Bus Rapid Transit route and the A32. Until the last quarter of the 20th century, Gosport was a major naval town associated with the defence and supply infrastructure of His Majesty's Naval Base (HMNB) Portsmouth. As such over the years extensive fortifications were created.

HMS <i>Illustrious</i> (R06) Invincible-class aircraft carrier

HMS Illustrious was a light aircraft carrier of the Royal Navy and the second of three Invincible-class ships constructed in the late 1970s and early 1980s. She was the fifth warship and second aircraft carrier to bear the name Illustrious, and was affectionately known to her crew as "Lusty". In 1982, the conflict in the Falklands necessitated that Illustrious be completed and rushed south to join her sister ship HMS Invincible and the veteran carrier HMS Hermes. To this end, she was brought forward by three months for completion at Swan Hunter Shipyard, then commissioned on 20 June 1982 at sea en route to Portsmouth Dockyard to take on board extra stores and crew. She arrived in the Falklands to relieve Invincible on 28 August 1982 in a steam past. Returning to the United Kingdom, she was not formally commissioned into the fleet until 20 March 1983. After her South Atlantic deployment, she was deployed on Operation Southern Watch in Iraq, then Operation Deny Flight in Bosnia during the 1990s and Operation Palliser in Sierra Leone in 2000. An extensive re-fit during 2002 prevented her from involvement in the 2003 Iraq War, but she was repaired in time to assist British citizens trapped by the 2006 Lebanon War.

HMS <i>Argyll</i> (F231) Type 23 frigate

The third and current HMS Argyll is a Type 23 Duke-class frigate. She is currently the oldest serving Type 23 frigate in the Royal Navy. Like all of her class she is named after a British dukedom, in this case that of Argyll. HMS Argyll was laid down in March 1987 by Yarrow Shipbuilders at Glasgow, and launched in 1989 by Lady Wendy Levene, sponsored by the Worshipful Company of Paviors. She was commissioned in May 1991. Argyll is currently based at HMNB Devonport.

HMS <i>Westminster</i> (F237) Frigate of the Royal Navy

HMS Westminster is a Type 23 frigate of the Royal Navy, and the second ship to bear the name. She was launched on 4 February 1992 and named for the Dukedom of Westminster.

HMS <i>Kent</i> (F78) Type 23 Duke class frigate

HMS Kent is a Type 23 Duke class frigate of the Royal Navy, and the twelfth ship to bear the name, although formally she is named after the dukedom rather than the county. Sponsored by Princess Alexandra, The Hon. Lady Ogilvy, Kent was launched on 28 May 1998 and commissioned on 8 June 2000 under the command of then Commander John Clink. She was the first ship to enter Royal Navy service in the 21st century and the first Royal Navy warship with a female Executive Officer, Lt Cdr Vanessa Jane Spiller, appointed in April 2001.

HMS <i>Chatham</i> (F87) Frigate of the Royal Navy

HMS Chatham was a Batch 3 Type 22 frigate of the British Royal Navy. She was decommissioned on 8 February 2011.

HMS <i>Argonaut</i> (F56) Leander-class frigate

HMS Argonaut (F56) was a Leander-class frigate that served with the Royal Navy from 1967 to 1993. She took part in the Falklands War in 1982, sustaining damage and casualties in action.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Great storm of 1703</span> English extratropical cyclone

The great storm of 1703 was a destructive extratropical cyclone that struck central and southern England on 26 November 1703. High winds caused 2,000 chimney stacks to collapse in London and damaged the New Forest, which lost 4,000 oaks. Ships were blown hundreds of miles off-course, and over 1,000 sea men died on the Goodwin Sands alone. News bulletins of casualties and damage were sold all over England – a novelty at that time. The Church of England declared that the storm was God's vengeance for the sins of the nation. Daniel Defoe thought it was a divine punishment for poor performance against Catholic armies in the War of the Spanish Succession.

HMS <i>Clyde</i> (P257)

HMS Clyde was an offshore patrol vessel and was the tenth Royal Navy vessel to carry the name. She was launched on 14 June 2006 in Portsmouth Naval Base by VT Group shipbuilders in Portsmouth and is the fourth vessel of the River class, with a displacement of 2,000 tonnes and a 30 mm Oerlikon KCB gun in place of the 20 mm gun fitted to Tyne River-class ships. Clyde was decommissioned on the 20 December 2019 at HMNB Portsmouth and was returned to her owners at BAE Systems Maritime - Naval Ships, although the ship remained under lease from BAE Systems to the Royal Navy until the end of March 2020. In August 2020 Clyde was transferred to the Kingdom of Bahrain.

HMS <i>Alliance</i> (P417) Amphion class submarine of the Royal Navy

HMS Alliance(P417/S67) is a Royal Navy A-class, Amphion-class or Acheron-class submarine, laid down towards the end of the Second World War and completed in 1947. The submarine is the only surviving example of the class, having been a memorial and museum ship since 1981.

HMS <i>Invincible</i> (1765) Ship of the line of the Royal Navy

HMS Invincible was a 74-gun third-rate ship of the line of the Royal Navy, launched on 9 March 1765 at Deptford. Invincible was built during a period of peace to replace ships worn out in the recently concluded Seven Years' War. The ship went on to serve in the American War of Independence. May, 1778 under command of Capt. Anthony Parry. Fought at the battles of Cape St Vincent in 1780, and under the command of Captain Charles Saxton, the Battles of the Chesapeake in 1781 and St Kitts in 1782.

Captain Temple Hardy was an English naval officer active during the French Revolutionary Wars. He commanded a battalion of sailors during the invasion of the Cape Colony in 1795.

HMS <i>Unity</i> (N66) Submarine of the Royal Navy

HMS Unity was a U-class submarine, of the first group of that class constructed for the Royal Navy. The submarine entered service in 1938 and performed war patrols during the Second World War. On 29 April 1940, Unity was accidentally rammed and sunk in Blyth, Northumberland's harbour.

HMS <i>Urge</i> British submarine

HMS Urge was a British U-class submarine, of the second group of that class, built by Vickers Armstrong, Barrow-in-Furness. She was laid down on 30 October 1939, and was commissioned on 12 December 1940. From 1941–1942 she formed part of the 10th Submarine Flotilla based in Malta and spent most of her career operating in the Mediterranean, where she damaged and sank enemy warships and merchant vessels and undertook both SBS and SIS special operations. She was commanded by Lieutenant-Commander Edward Philip Tomkinson, DSO, RN. She was lost with all hands and a number of naval passengers on 27 April 1942 after striking a German mine off Malta.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Customs and traditions of the Royal Navy</span>

There are many customs and traditions associated with the Royal Navy of the United Kingdom. Many of these traditions have carried on to other Commonwealth navies, such as Canada, India, Australia and New Zealand. These include formal customs such as separate crests associated with ships, ensigns and fleet reviews. There are also several less formal customs and traditions, including Naval slang commonly referred to as Jack Speak and the traditional games of Uckers and Euchre.

<i>Brown on Resolution</i> (film) 1935 film by Anthony Asquith, Walter Forde

Brown on Resolution is a 1935 film adaptation of the 1929 C. S. Forester novel Brown on Resolution, with John Mills in his first lead role playing the title role. The film is also notable for being the first film to use actual Royal Navy ships. The plot is centred on the illegitimate son of a British naval officer helping to bring about the downfall of a German cruiser during World War I.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Royal Navy Burying Ground (Halifax, Nova Scotia)</span>

The Royal Navy Burying Ground is part of the Naval Museum of Halifax and was the Naval Hospital cemetery for the North America and West Indies Station at Halifax, Nova Scotia. It is the oldest military burial ground in Canada. The cemetery has grave markers to those who died while serving at Halifax and were treated at the Naval medical facility or died at sea. Often shipmates and officers had the grave markers erected to mark the deaths of the crew members who died while in the port of Halifax.

Simon Parkes was a British leading seaman in the Royal Navy who went missing in Gibraltar in 1986. Parkes was serving aboard HMS Illustrious when he disappeared whilst on shore leave in the dependency. In 2001, Parkes' disappearance gained renewed interest when it was noted that convicted murderer Allan Grimson also worked on Illustrious at the same time.

The Institute of Naval Medicine is the main research centre and training facility of the Royal Navy Medical Service.

Rear-Admiral Sir Henry Hart was a British naval officer and diplomat of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. After a brief stint in the East India Company he joined the Royal Navy in 1796 on Sir Edward Pellew's frigate HMS Indefatigable, participating in the action of 13 January 1797 before following Pellew to the ship of the line HMS Impetueux where he experienced a mutiny before taking part in a number of cutting out expeditions and the Ferrol Expedition. At the Peace of Amiens Hart transferred to the ship of the line HMS Foudroyant in the Mediterranean Sea where he was promoted to lieutenant and joined Sir John Gore's frigate HMS Medusa, in which he participated in the action of 5 October 1804 before sailing to India in 1805. There he was reunited with Pellew who made him his flag lieutenant and appointed him to a succession of acting commands, including to that of the frigate HMS Caroline in which he played an important role in the Raid on Griessie in 1807.

References

  1. Hyslop, Leah (8 August 2012). "Ship of missing sailor Timothy MacColl sails home". The Daily Telegraph . Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  2. "British sailor Timmy MacColl missing in Dubai". BBC News. 1 June 2012. Retrieved 28 November 2016.
  3. 1 2 3 4 "Wife's heartache as missing Gosport sailor Timmy MacColl is declared dead". The News . Portsmouth. 26 May 2014. Retrieved 28 November 2016.
  4. "Memorial service for missing sailor Timmy MacColl". BBC News. 12 June 2014. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  5. 1 2 "Scottish sailor Timothy MacColl missing in Dubai 'wants to be found', says wife". Daily Record . Glasgow. 4 June 2012. Retrieved 28 November 2016.
  6. "Timothy MacColl: New Appeal For Missing Sailor". Sky News. 27 May 2013. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  7. "Royal Navy sailor missing in Dubai". The Guardian . Press Association. 1 June 2012. Retrieved 28 November 2016.
  8. "Timmy MacColl: Wife criticises missing sailor probe". BBC News. 31 October 2012. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  9. "MoD branded incompetent in search for missing sailor". The Scotsman . 16 August 2012. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  10. "Timmy MacColl: Missing sailor's family appeals to crew". BBC News. 6 June 2013. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  11. "First birthday of daughter Tim never saw". The Sunday Post . 29 September 2013. Retrieved 28 November 2016.
  12. "Missing sailor's wife loses hope". The Herald . Glasgow. 8 February 2013. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  13. "Joy tinged with sadness as Westminster returns home without one of her family". Navy News . 13 August 2012. Archived from the original on 4 May 2018. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  14. "Gosport sailor Timmy MacColl's wife says she must move on". BBC News. 7 February 2013. Retrieved 29 November 2016.
  15. "Sailor is declared officially dead by the navy". The Herald. 26 May 2014. Retrieved 29 November 2016.