Economy of Urartu

Last updated

The economy of Urartu refers to the principles of management of Urartu, the ancient state of Western Asia which existed from the thirteenth to the sixth century BC. It peaked around the eighth century BC but was destroyed with the fall of the state about a century later. [1] The economy of Urartu was typical of ancient Oriental Despotism and was closely associated with that of neighboring Assyria.

Contents

Basics of Urartian economy

State structure

Urartian cuneiform script: "By the glory of God Haldi, king Sarduri II, son of Argishti I, poured 10100 kapi of grain here. Urartian language stone, Erebuni museum a.jpg
Urartian cuneiform script: "By the glory of God Ḫaldi, king Sarduri II, son of Argishti I, poured 10100 kapi of grain here.

Urartu was a typical despotic state of the Ancient Orient. The power of Urartian kings was unlimited. The king was also the supreme commander of the Urartian army, and the supreme priest. [3] Unlike neighboring Assyria and Babylon, Urartu had no significant influence of any universal or religious norms on public life. Consequently, church farms were less important in Urartu than in Mesopotamia; entire cities and regions were considered royal property which dominated the economy. [4]

Administration

Leading administrative positions in Urartu were assumed by the members of royal family, which numbered up to 300 people. Administration of the remote regions was dissimilar as they were inhabited by different ethnic groups. They were headed by the local ruler who was observed by the royal governor. The regions were obliged to regularly provide the king with natural products, such as cattle, grain, etc. Regions closer to the capital were managed directly by the local governor, usually a relative of the king. The governor enjoyed full autonomy and nearly unlimited power, as long as he obeyed the king. As a result, the prosperity and importance of individual regions depended strongly on their rulers. [3]

People

The population of Urartu was a "property" of the king. Rebels from remote provinces were usually enslaved and sent to forced labor. Population was likely obliged to participate in nation building, that is improvement of the royal household, erection of temples and fortresses. A significant part of it enjoyed some freedom, had the opportunity to run their own farm and employ servants or use slaves. [4] A small part of the population, mostly occupying military and court posts, lived on a state allowance. [5]

Trade

The division of labor in agriculture occurred long before the formation of Urartu, and thus the trade relations existed from the early existence of the state. [3] The trade was based on barter rather than money. Wars, especially against Assyria hindered trade, and valuable goods were often seized as war booty or tribute. The church likely participated in trade relations; For example, the religious center of Urartu Musasir was raising livestock both for sacrifice and selling. [6]

The most common trade items were cattle, horses, grain, wine, metals and wood. The natural conditions of the area were favorable for horse breeding, which was important for the military of the entire region, as well as for cultivating grape, whereas metal production was stimulated by the region's rich ore deposits.

Irrigation

19th century sketch of the canal of Menua (or Semiramis). Stone inscription: "by the power of God Haldi, king Menua, the son of Ishpuini, this canal has built...let anyone who will destroy this inscription or says 'I built this canal' be destroyed by the gods." Urartian Menua canal.jpg
19th century sketch of the canal of Menua (or Semiramis). Stone inscription: "by the power of God Ḫaldi, king Menua, the son of Ishpuini, this canal has built...let anyone who will destroy this inscription or says 'I built this canal' be destroyed by the gods."

The crucial factor in Urartu's economy was water, since many regions such as the coast of Lake Van, the valley of the Murat River and Ararat plain were poorly adapted for primitive farming and were productive only with artificial irrigation. As a result, all the king's farm were concentrated around the irrigation canals, which were built through mass mobilization of the population and were one of the main factors of the Urartian prosperity of the 8th century BC. Thanks to the irrigation system, Urartu was self-sufficient with grain and was the major producer and exporter of wine in the region. [3] The system was mostly built during the reign of the kings Ishpuini, Menua, Argishti I, Sarduri II and Rusa I and is still used nowadays, often without substantial reconstruction. [6]

Exceeding 70 km (43 mi) in length, the largest and most important irrigation canal was Menua or Shamiram Canal, [7] which supplied fresh water to the capital of Urartu, the city of Tushpa. The canal crossed the Hoşap River over a dedicated bridge, and in low-lying areas was supported by stonewalls up to 15 meters tall. Many parts of the canal still function. The Urartian irrigation technology was partly borrowed from neighboring Assyria, [3] [6] and was praised by the Assyrians, in particular by king Sargon II. [9]

Ironically, Sargon II also destroyed the Urartian irrigation system in Ulhu during the military campaign of 714 BC, but his letters on the event partly documented the system design. In particular, he mentioned the use of underground stone pipes which were later discovered by the archeologists near another Urartian city, Erebuni. [9] Especially developed were the Urartian irrigation facilities in Rusahinili (a suburb of the capital Tushpa built by Rusa II). They included an artificial lake, which still exists, and a network of underground canals and pipes. The system functioned until the late 19th century, [10] but its design remains unknown and its description written on a tablet by Russes I is as yet undeciphered. [8]

Erebuni museum stone 1291cropped.jpg
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1221a.jpg
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1232b.jpg
Urartian stone pipes from Teishebaini and Erebuni. A typical segment had a length of 1 m, external diameter of 40 cm (16 in), and internal diameter of 11 cm (4 in). The segments fit together forming a pipe. Some segments had slits for cleaning access.Remains of the iron pipes from Teishebaini which were used for water supply from the Hrazdan River and for draining rainwater.

Agriculture

Agriculture was practiced in the Eastern Anatolia since the Neolithic, at least from the 3rd millennium BC, and was well developed by the time of the Urartu Kingdom. Most cultivation tools were made of iron, [3] and the area was well irrigated. Major crops were wheat (mostly Triticum vulgare vill), barley (Hordeum vulgare L.), rye (Secale L.), millet (Panicum miliaceum L. and Panicum italicum L.), sesame (Sesamum orientale), lentils (Lens culinaris) and chickpea (Cicer arietinum). Seeds and remains of these plants were discovered during excavation of the Urartian cities. [5] [6] In addition, Urartian cuneiform tables describe growth of spelt. [3]

Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1266a.jpg
Dish in Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia.jpg
Urartu Fork.jpg
Urartu Spades.jpg
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1225a.jpg
Seeds of wheat (left) and chickpea (right) prepared for the next sowing near Teishebaini and Erebuni. [11] Sketches of the iron pitchfork and plowshare found near Rusahinili (Tushpa) in the 19th century.Remains of iron tools (spade, sickles, plowshare) found near Karmir Blur.
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1224a.jpg
Urartian grain bruiser01.jpg
Urartian grain bruiser02.jpg
Urartian language stone, Erebuni museum 4a.jpg
Urartian language stone, Erebuni museum 6a.jpg
Stone mortar [11] and graters: manual (left) and part of a mill (right). [12] Argishti, the son of Menua, filled this barn with 10100 kapi of grain. [2] [11] Rusa, the son of Erimena, filled this barn with 6848 kapi of grain. [2] [11]

Grains were used for baking bread and brewing beer, and sesame was processed for vegetable oil. Analysis of bread found near Teishebaini suggests its baking method was similar to that still in use in some Caucasus villages. [5] Grains were ground manually or with mills, and the finds in eastern Turkey suggest that Urartu also used water mills. [3] The most common grains were from the genus Panicum , whereas wheat, barley and Hordeum grains were rare and were grown for the king, barter trade and breweries. [3]

The exact value of the Urartian grain measure "kapi" remains unknown. No Urartian sources describe barns with more than 19,000 kapi of grain. The annals of Sarduri II mention 1,022,133 kapi of barley, which might refer to the peak annual production of Urartu. [6]

Gardening

Gardening was less widespread than growth of grain and grape. However, traces of several fruit crops were found in Urartian cities and settlements. They include apple, plum, pomegranate, peach, cherry and walnut. [5] [13] Large gardens were cultivated until the end of the 19th century at Lake Van, near the former Urartu capital. [14]

Traces of beer made from the barley and millet were found in these jars excavated near Karmir Blur (Teishebaini); the brewery was located inside the city fortress. Urartian pottery, Erebuni museum a.jpg
Traces of beer made from the barley and millet were found in these jars excavated near Karmir Blur (Teishebaini); the brewery was located inside the city fortress.

Brewing

Brewing traditions may have been borrowed by Urartians in Assyria. As in Assyria, not only barley but also millet was used for brewing. Xenophon, who traveled through the Eastern Anatolia and Mesopotamia in post-Urartu times (at the turn of the fourth century BC), [15] described a "barley wine" of local residents and ways of its storage and preparation. Beer then was stored in buried pitchers and drunk through a straw. It was strong, but "nice to accustomed people". [6]

Viticulture and wine making

Urartian pottery, Erebuni museum 1a.jpg
Urartian Wine Pottery01a.jpg
Urartian wine jars found at Karmir Blur (left) and Argishtikhinili (right)

Owing to the favorable climate of the Eastern Anatolia and the development of irrigation systems, viticulture was well developed in Urartu. The ancient vines have been identified as Vitis vinifera . [5] [13]

Although raisins were found during the excavations of the Urartian cities, most grapes undoubtedly were processed into wine, which was the most important product of the Urartian economy. Nearby Assyria, where the conditions for grape growth were less favorable than in Urartu, was importing much Urartian wine as tribute, war booty or barter goods. Almost all Urartian cities had a large wine storage, and the one of Teishebaini could hold about 370,000 liters. Before storage, wine (in pitchers) was aged under the sun until it became dense and sweet. Archeological finds suggest that Urartians also used sulfur for curing wine diseases. [3] [13]

Animal breeding

Animal breeding was practiced on the Eastern Anatolia Highland since the Neolithic. It was a major occupation of the pre-Urartian tribe Nairi – the main purpose of Assyrian raids on Nairi settlements in the 2nd millennium BC was stealing cattle. Although animal breeding became secondary to agriculture during the Urartu period, it remained an important branch of economy, and was also used for regular sacrificial services in Urartian religion. The animals bred included cattle (close to Bos primigenius ), bull ( Bos taurus ), buffalo ( Bubalus bubalis ), sheep ( Ovis aries ), goats (the East Caucasian tur, and Capra hircus ), pigs ( Sus scrofa domestica ), Persian gazelle ( Gazella subgutturosa ) and zebu ( Bos indicus ). [3] [5] Archeological finds indicate the presence of milk processing and cheese making in Urartu.

Fragment of the Assyrian bas-relief (bronze, Shalmaneser III period) depicting the theft of horses from Urartu after the successful military campaign Shalmaneser III in 858 BC. Assyrian Urarartian battle captured horses.jpg
Fragment of the Assyrian bas-relief (bronze, Shalmaneser III period) depicting the theft of horses from Urartu after the successful military campaign Shalmaneser III in 858 BC.

Unlike cattle, horses had a strategic military importance and were used for chariots. Horse breeding was a major occupation in Urartu, and, owing to abundant alpine meadows, was better developed than in nearby countries. Urartu horses were highly valued, e.g. by the king Sargon II, and were a major booty target of Assyrian military campaigns. According to excavations, the major horse breed in Urartu was the normal horse Equus caballus. [3] Especially famous for its horses was the province Subhi, on the east coast of Lake Urmia.

Craft

Blacksmithing

The Eastern Anatolia is considered one of the earliest metallurgy centers, and the first evidence of metal processing there dates to the 8th–7th millennium BC, that is, to pre-ceramic times. [16] [17] The region contained rich deposits of copper, iron and lead, though not of the essential tin [18] that favored metal production. Smelting of iron began there much later, around the 2nd millennium BC. [10] [19] Iron ore and ironware was exported from Urartu to Mesopotamia (Assyria), Medes and further to the territory of modern Iran. Iron was a major weaponry material and thus a strategic commodity.

Bronze articles
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armania 1246a.jpg
Spitzhelm urartaisch.JPG
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1251a.jpg
Shield [11] HelmetBowl used at a palace [11]
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1232a.jpg
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1236a.jpg
Erebuni museum 1272cropped.jpg
Left to right: fragments of metal door handles and locks from the fortress of Teishebaini,
crucibles for metal smelting, grindstones (Karmir Blur). [11]

Ceramics and stone processing

Most ceramic products in Urartu were simple, without the painting typical of many other ancient cultures. Only items used in palaces and in religious ceremonies had some ornaments. Ceramic pots were widely used to store and cook food, whereas stoneware was relatively unpopular.

Ceramic items [11]
Urartian pottery, Erebuni museum 3a.jpg
Urartian pottery, Erebuni museum 4a.jpg
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1240c.jpg
A pot for storing dairy productsFuneral urn Oil lamp–in a palace, it was placed on a chandelier.

Weaving

Weaving was well developed in Urartu, as evidenced by ancient texts. For example, in the list of goods taken from Musasir, the Assyrian king Sargon II mentions 130 tunics of various colors made of flax and wool. Some Urartian cuneiform tables also contain inventories of woolen products.

Weaving in Urartu [11]
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1240a.jpg
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1240d.jpg
Erebuni museum, Yerevan, Armenia 1240b.jpg
Cloth remains found near Teishebaini. Iron needles, Arin Berd. Weights for a spindle, Arin Berd.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mannaea</span> Former country

Mannaea was an ancient kingdom located in northwestern Iran, south of Lake Urmia, around the 10th to 7th centuries BC. It neighbored Assyria and Urartu, as well as other small buffer states between the two, such as Musasir and Zikirta.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diauehi</span> Iron Age tribal confederation in the Caucasus

Diauehi (Georgian დიაოხი, Urartian Diauehi, Greek Taochoi, Armenian Tayk, possibly Assyrian Daiaeni) was a tribal union located in northeastern Anatolia, that was recorded in Assyrian and Urartian sources during the Iron Age. It is usually (though not always) identified with the earlier Daiaeni(Dayaeni), attested in the Yonjalu inscription of the Assyrian king Tiglath-Pileser I's third year (1118 BC) and in later records by Shalmaneser III (845 BC). While it is unknown what language(s) they spoke, they may have been speakers of a Kartvelian, Armenian, or Hurrian language.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Menua</span> King of Urartu

Menua, also rendered Meinua or Minua, was the fifth known king of Urartu from c. 810 BC to approximately 786 BC. In Armenian, Menua is rendered as Menua. The name Menua may be connected etymologically to the Ancient Greek names Minos and Minyas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Argishti I of Urartu</span>

Argishti I, was the sixth known king of Urartu, reigning from 786 BC to 764 BC. He founded the citadel of Erebuni in 782 BC, which is the present capital of Armenia, Yerevan. Alternate transliterations of the name include Argishtis, Argisti, Argišti, and Argishtish. Although the name is usually rendered as Argišti, some scholars argue that Argisti is the most likely pronunciation. This is due to the belief that the Urartians used the cuneiform symbol š to voice an s-sound, as opposed to representing the digraph sh.

Rusa I was a King of Urartu. He succeeded his father, king Sarduri II. His name is sometimes transliterated as Rusas or Rusha. He was known to Assyrians as Ursa and possibly Urzana. His birth name may have been Uedipri.

Nairi was the Akkadian name for a region inhabited by a particular group of tribal principalities in the Armenian Highlands, approximately spanning the area between modern Diyarbakır and Lake Van and the region west of Lake Urmia. Nairi has sometimes been equated with Nihriya, known from Mesopotamian, Hittite, and Urartian sources. However, its co-occurrence with Nihriya within a single text may argue against this.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Musasir</span> Ancient city of Urartu

Muṣaṣir, in Urartian Ardini was an ancient city of Urartu, attested in Assyrian sources of the 9th and 8th centuries BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Erebuni Fortress</span> Fortified city, located in Armenia

Erebuni Fortress is an Urartian fortified city, located in Yerevan, Armenia. It is 1,017 metres (3,337 ft) above sea level. It was one of several fortresses built along the northern Urartian border and was one of the most important political, economic and cultural centers of the vast kingdom. The name Yerevan itself is derived from Erebuni.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ishpuini of Urartu</span>

Ishpuini was king of Urartu. He succeeded his father, Sarduri I, who moved the capital to Tushpa (Van). Ishpuini conquered the Mannaean city of Musasir, which was then made the religious center of the empire. The main temple for the war god Haldi was in Musasir. Ishpuini's kingdom was then attacked by the forces of the Assyrian King Shamshi-Adad V. Ishpuini fought and defeated Shamshi-Adad. Ishpuini was so confident in his power that he began using names meaning everlasting glory, including, "King of the land of Nairi", "Glorious King", and "King of the Universe".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sarduri II</span>

Sarduri II was a King of Urartu, succeeding his father Argishti I to the throne. The Urartian Kingdom was at its peak during his reign, campaigning successfully against several neighbouring powers, including Assyria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Urartu–Assyria War</span>

The Urartu–Assyria War was a conflict between the Kingdom of Urartu and the Neo-Assyrian Empire. The war began around 714 BC, with the invasion of Urartu by the Assyrian King Sargon II. Sargon led multiple offensives deep into Urartian territory, amassing numerous victories in the war. Following his death, however, Urartian Kings Argishti II and Rusa II launched many successful counterattacks, reclaiming Urartu's lost territory and gaining some from Assyria. However, their successors suffered multiple major defeats, resulting in Urartu becoming an Assyrian client state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Urartu</span> Iron-Age kingdom of the Ancient Near East

Urartu was an Iron Age kingdom centered around Lake Van in the Armenian Highlands. It extended from the eastern bank of the upper Euphrates River to the western shores of Lake Urmia and from the mountains of northern Iraq to the Lesser Caucasus Mountains. The kingdom emerged in the mid-9th century BC and dominated the Armenian Highlands in the 8th and 7th centuries BC. Urartu frequently warred with Assyria and became, for a time, the most powerful state in the Near East. Weakened by constant conflict, it was eventually conquered by the Iranian Medes in the early 6th century BC. Archaeologically, it is noted for its large fortresses and sophisticated metalwork. Its kings left behind cuneiform inscriptions in the Urartian language, a member of the Hurro-Urartian language family. Since its re-discovery in the 19th century, Urartu, which is commonly believed to have been at least partially Armenian-speaking, has played a significant role in Armenian nationalism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Çavuştepe</span> 8th century BC fortified site in Turkey

Sardurihinilli, also known as Haykaberd or Çavuştepe Kalesi, is an ancient Urartian fortified site located on a ridge on the northeastern edge of the village of Çavuştepe in the Gürpınar district of Van Province in eastern Turkey. It is located approximately 25 kilometers southeast of Van along the road leading to the city of Hakkâri, in a valley once known as Hayots Dzor in historic Armenia. It was founded by the Urartian king Sarduri II some time during his reign in the 8th century BC and is believed to be identical with the fortress of Sardurihurda mentioned in the same king's cuneiform inscriptions.

Sarduri IV was one of the last kings of Urartu, reigning from 615 to 595 BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Art of Urartu</span>

The art of Urartu refers to a historical and regional type of art from Urartu (Ararat), the ancient state of Western Asia which existed in the period from the 13th to the 6th centuries BC in the Armenian Highland. The art of Urartu was strongly influenced by nearby Assyria, the most prominent state of that period in the region. It peaked around the 8th century BC but was mostly looted, scattered and destroyed with the fall of Urartu about a century later.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Menua Canal</span>

The Menua canal, also known as the Semiramis canal or as the Shamiram canal, is a canal joined with a series of hydraulic works such as aqueducts constructed by King Menua of Urartu. It is located to the east of Van, Turkey and runs 56 kilometers, supplying a large region and flowing into Lake Van. It is considered a masterpiece of Anatolian and global hydraulic and architectural engineering.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Argishtikhinili</span> Archaeological site in Armenia

Argishtikhinili was a town in the ancient kingdom of Urartu, established during the expansion of the Urartians in the Transcaucasus under their king Argishti I, and named in his honour. It lasted between the 8th and 6th centuries BC. The ruins of the Argishtikhinili fortifications are 15 kilometres (9 mi) southwest of the present-day town of Armavir, Armenia, between the villages of Nor-Armavir and Armavir in the Armenian marz of Armavir. The town was founded on the left bank of the middle reaches of the Aras River. Over the centuries, the river channel has shifted to several kilometres south of the town.

The Urumu were a tribe attested in cuneiform sources in the Bronze Age. They are often considered to be one of the ancestors of the Armenians being one of the tribes which were part of the Armenian Hayasa-Azzi confederation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Urartu religion</span> Belief system adopted in the ancient state of Urartu

Urartu religion is a belief system adopted in the ancient state of Urartu, which existed from the 8th to 6th centuries BC. It was typical of despotic states from Near East. The Urartu religion was polytheistic in nature and derived from the earlier beliefs of Mesopotamia and Anatolia. As in other beliefs of the ancient East, Urartu had a pantheon of deities, patronizing various phenomena. The main deity was Haldi. The worlds of humans and gods were united through ritual sacrifices. The Urartu religion absorbed the motifs of the tree of life, the serpent and the winged solar disk characteristic of the ancient East. Against the background of Mesopotamian beliefs, Urartu was distinguished by a high level of religious tolerance, which was conditioned by the multinationality of the state.

References

  1. Urartu, Encyclopædia Britannica online
  2. 1 2 3 Арутюнян Н.В., Оганесян К.Л. (1970). "Новые урартские надписи из Эребуни (New Urartian inscriptions from Erebuni)". Вестник древней истории. Moscow. 3: 107–112.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Boris Piotrovsky (1959). Ванское царство (Урарту). Moscow.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  4. 1 2 Меликишвили Г. А. (1951). "Некоторые вопросы социально-экономической истории Наири-Урарту (Some problems of socio-economic History of Nairi-Urartu)". Вестник древней истории. Moscow. 4.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Пиотровский Б.Б. (1950). Кармир-Блур. I Результаты раскопок 1939—1949 (Karmir-Blur I. Results of the excavations of 1939–1949). Yerevan: Academy of Sciences of Armenia.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Арутюнян Н. В. (1964). Земледелие и скотоводство Урарту (Agriculture and animal husbandry of Urartu). Yerevan: Academy of Sciences of Armenia.
  7. 1 2 Moses of Chorene documents a legend of the personal involvement of the purely legendary Assyrian queen Semiramis in the construction of Menua canal and various buildings in Tushpa (modern Van, Turkey), which was known to the 19th century inhabitants of Van, located on the Tushpa place. Boris Piotrovsky (1959). Ванское царство (Урарту). Moscow.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  8. 1 2 Giorgi Melikishvili Урартские клинообразные надписи. Moscow. Academy of Sciences of the USSR, 1960.
  9. 1 2 Igor Diakonov, translation from François Thureau-Dangin, Une relation de la huitième campagne de Sargon, Paris, 1912. Published in Дьяконов И. М. Ассиро-Вавилонские источники по истории Урарту // Вестник древней истории. — Moscow 1951. № 2 — 4.
  10. 1 2 Lehmann-Haupt C.F. Armenien, einst und jetzt. — Berlin: B. Behr, 1910—1931
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Erebuni Museum, Yerevan, Armenia
  12. Museum of Ethnography of Armenia "Sardarapat", Armavir, Armenia
  13. 1 2 3 Пиотровский Б.Б., Джанполадян Л.М. (1956). "Виноделие в Урарту (Wine making in Urartu)". Виноделие и виноградарство в СССР (Winemaking in the USSR). 1.
  14. Matveev SN (1946). Turkey (Asian part – Anatolia). Physical-geographic description. Moscow – Leningrad: Publisher USSR Academy of Sciences.
  15. Xenophon, Anabasis .
  16. Gevorgyan A.TS. (1980). From the history of the ancient metallurgy of the Eastern Anatolia highlands. Yerevan: Academy of Sciences of Armenia.
  17. Cambel H., Braidwood R. (1970). "An Early Farming Village in Turkey". Scientific American. 222 (3): 50. Bibcode:1970SciAm.222c..50C. doi:10.1038/scientificamerican0370-50.
  18. "R.D. Penhallurick in his exhaustive Tin in Antiquity (1986) could find no conclusive proof of any tin-mining in the Bronze Age anywhere near Urartu", notes T. Braun in reviewing M. Chahin, The Kingdom of Armenia (1987) in The Classical Review, 39 (1989:308-311); ancient sources of tin are a miuch discussed subject.
  19. Boris Turayev (1914). History of the Ancient Orient. St. Petersburg.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)

Further reading