Eternal generation of the Son

Last updated
God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made; of the same essence as the Father. -- Nicene Creed Pleiades large.jpg
God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made; of the same essence as the Father. — Nicene Creed

The eternal generation of the Son is a Trinitarian doctrine, which is defined as a necessary and eternal act of God the Father, in which he generates (or begets) God the Son through communicating the whole divine essence to the Son. Generation is not defined as an act of the will, but is by necessity of nature. [2] [3] To avoid anthropomorphistic understandings of the doctrine, theologians have defined it as timeless, non-bodily, incomprehensible and not as a communication without but within the Godhead. [4] [5] [6] The view is affirmed by the Roman Catholic Church, [7] Eastern Orthodoxy [8] and Protestantism as is evident in the Westminster Confession [9] the London Baptist Confession [10] and by Lutheran confessions [11] among others.

Contents

The doctrine has been an important part of Nicene Trinitarianism, however some modern theologians have proposed different models of the Trinity, wherein eternal generation is no longer seen as necessary and thus rejected. [12]

History

The doctrine of eternal generation has been affirmed by the Athanasian creed, [13] the Nicene creed [14] and by church fathers such as Athanasius of Alexandria, Augustine, Basil of Caesarea [15] [16] [17] [18] being mentioned explicitly first by Origen of Alexandria. [19]

The doctrine was often disputed by the Socinians, arguing that the sonship of Christ is not derived from his eternal begetting. [20] [21] The view has also been disputed by some modern theologians, including some Social Trinitarians, such as William Lane Craig. [22] [23] Other trinitarian theologians to have criticized the view include Charles Ryrie, [24] John MacArthur (although later recanting of his position) [25] and J. Oliver Buswell among others. [26] [27] The doctrine was also disputed by the popular Evangelical theologian Wayne Grudem, arguing that the doctrine is derived from a misunderstanding of the Greek word monogenes ('μονογενής'). [12] However, he later recanted of his opposition to the doctrine of eternal generation. [28]

Scripture

Those who teach the traditional doctrine of eternal generation have often used texts such as Proverbs 8:23, [29] Psalm 2:7, Micah 5:2, John 5:26, John 1:18, 3:16, Colossians 1:15, 2 Corinthians 4:4 and Hebrews 1:3. [30] [31] The ideas of 'image' and 'radiance' expressed in these texts have been argued to imply the idea of generation. Additionally, the idea of being 'begotten' in Psalm 2:7 and John 3:16 has been applied by theologians to support eternal begetting or generation. [32] The text of John 5:26 is one of the most central texts used to defend the idea of eternal generation, which references the Son being granted to have 'life in himself' by the Father. [33] [34] [31] However, the idea that these texts teach the doctrine of eternal generation has been disputed by its critics. The critics of the theory such as William Lane Craig have argued that it introduces subordinationism into the Godhead. A major issue in the debate is the translation of the Greek term monogenes, translated as 'only begotten'. Those who hold to eternal generation generally argue the word to involve an idea of derivation or begetting, while its critics have denied that the word has such connotations. [35] [12]

Characteristics

In his Reformed Dogmatics, 19th-century Dutch Reformed theologian Herman Bavinck presages an enumeration of the characteristics of the eternal generation of the Son by emphasising the classical attribution of 'life' to God, stating that he is not an 'abstract, fixed, monadic, solitary substance, but a plenitude of life'. This is rooted in the Biblical attribution of generation in a fatherly sense to God, for example, For as the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself (John 5:26). In addition, the Son bears names that denote this relation to the Father, including firstborn, only-begotten and image ('χαρακτηρ') as in Hebrews 1:3, in which the Son is said to be the express image of God's person. Thus while Bavinck is cautious not to associate the imperfection and sensuality of earthly generation with the eternal generation of the Son, he nevertheless asserts the relevance of the analogy to the divine being. [36]

God's fecundity is a beautiful theme, one that frequently recurs in the church fathers. God is no abstract, fixed, monadic, solitary substance, but a plenitude of life. It is his nature (οὐσια) to be generative (γεννητικη) and fruitful (καρπογονος). It is capable of expansion, unfolding, and communication. Those who deny this fecund productivity fail to take seriously the fact that God is an infinite fullness of blessed life. All such people have left is an abstract deistic concept of God, or to compensate for this sterility, in pantheistic fashion they include the life of the world in the divine being. Apart from the Trinity even the act of creation becomes inconceivable. For if God cannot communicate himself, he is a darkened light, a dry spring, unable to exert himself outward to communicate himself to creatures. [36]

Given this emphasis on the 'life' of God, Bavinck enumerates three major characteristics of the eternal generation which are characteristic of Nicene orthodoxy, in contrast to Arianism which the Nicene Creed opposes.

  1. The generation of the Son is spiritual. That is, it is simple, without division, separation or flux. God expresses himself completely in the person of the Logos, the express image of his person (Hebrews 1:3). A common analogy of eternal generation is human speech; as human thought is expressed in speech, so God expresses his being in the Logos (which means 'speech', 'word' or 'reason'). Yet it is an imperfect analogy, since the expression of God's being in the Son is total and indivisible, For as the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself (John 5:26). The Arians, in contrast, alleged that generation necessitates separation, division and passion, such that the Son cannot be consubstantial with the Father. [36]
  2. The Father generates the Son out of the very same being of the Father. As it states in the Nicene Creed, 'God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made; of the same essence as the Father.' [37] The Son was not created by the Father, rather he was generated out of the Father's being in eternity. Generation is thus not so much a work of the Father, but the very nature of the Father, in harmony with his knowledge, will and power as a perfect expression of his being. In this sense it can be said that Christ is over all, God blessed for ever (Romans 9:5). In Arianism, the Son is not generated but created by the Father out of nothing, which means that he is a creature. [36]
  3. The generation is eternal. If the Son does not possess his sonship or generation of the Father eternally, than neither is the Father eternal. In other words, the very fact that the Father is eternally the Father necessitates that the Son is eternally the Son. Indeed, to deny the eternal generation of the Son would rob the Father of his eternal nature as the Father, since there would have been a prior time in which the Father was not the Father but something else, only later generating the son and thus becoming the Father. Generation is an everlasting act of God, eternally occurring as an aspect of the eternally generative nature of the Father. The Son is therefore everlastingly begotten. In Arianism, the Son is said to not have existed at some point, and further was brought about or created at some point.

See also

Related Research Articles

Arianism is a Christological doctrine considered heretical by all modern mainstream branches of Christianity. It is first attributed to Arius, a Christian presbyter who preached and studied in Alexandria, Egypt. Arian theology holds that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, who was begotten by God the Father with the difference that the Son of God did not always exist but was begotten/made before time by God the Father; therefore, Jesus was not coeternal with God the Father, but nonetheless Jesus began to exist outside time.

<span title="Latin-language text"><i lang="la">Filioque</i></span> Latin term meaning "and from the Son" appended to the Nicene Creed

Filioque, a Latin term meaning "and from the Son", was added to the original Nicene Creed, and has been the subject of great controversy between Eastern and Western Christianity. The term refers to the Son, Jesus Christ, with the Father, as the one shared origin of the Holy Spirit. It is not in the original text of the Creed, attributed to the First Council of Constantinople (381), which says that the Holy Spirit proceeds "from the Father" without the addition "and the Son".

In Christian theology, Sabellianism is the belief that there is only one Person in the Godhead. For example, Hanson defines Sabellianism as the "refusal to acknowledge the distinct existence of the Persons" and "Eustathius was condemned for Sabellianism. His insistence that there is only one distinct reality (hypostasis) in the Godhead, and his confusion about distinguishing Father, Son and Holy Spirit laid him open to such a charge." Condemned as heresy, Sabellianism has been rejected by the majority of Christian churches.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trinity</span> Christian doctrine that God is three persons

The Christian doctrine of the Trinity is the central doctrine concerning the nature of God in most Christian churches, which defines one God existing in three, coeternal, consubstantial divine persons: God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit, three distinct persons (hypostases) sharing one essence/substance/nature (homoousion).

Nontrinitarianism is a form of Christianity that rejects the mainstream Christian theology of the Trinity—the belief that God is three distinct hypostases or persons who are coeternal, coequal, and indivisibly united in one being, or essence. Certain religious groups that emerged during the Protestant Reformation have historically been known as antitrinitarian.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">God the Son</span> Second person of the Trinity in Christian theology

God the Son is the second Person of the Trinity in Christian theology. According to Christian doctrine, God the Son, in the form of Jesus Christ, is the incarnation of the eternal, pre-existent divine Logos through whom all things were created. Although the precise term "God the Son" does not appear in the Bible, it serves as a theological designation expressing the understanding of Jesus as a part of the Trinity, distinct yet united in essence with God the Father and God the Holy Spirit.

Beginning with three synods convened between 264 and 269 in the matter of Paul of Samosata, more than thirty councils were held in Antioch in ancient times. Most of these dealt with phases of the Arian and of the Christological controversies. For example, the Catholic Encyclopedia article on Paul of Samosata states:

It must be regarded as certain that the council which condemned Paul rejected the term homoousios; but naturally only in a false sense used by Paul; not, it seems because he meant by it a unity of Hypostasis in the Trinity, but because he intended by it a common substance out of which both Father and Son proceeded, or which it divided between them, — so St. Basil and St. Athanasius; but the question is not clear. The objectors to the Nicene doctrine in the fourth century made copious use of this disapproval of the Nicene word by a famous council.

Hypostasis, from the Greek ὑπόστασις (hypóstasis), is the underlying, fundamental state or substance that supports all of reality. It is not the same as the concept of a substance. In Neoplatonism, the hypostasis of the soul, the intellect (nous) and "the one" was addressed by Plotinus. In Christian theology, the Holy Trinity consists of three hypostases: that of the Father, that of the Son, and that of the Holy Spirit.

Binitarianism is a Christian theology of two persons, personas, or aspects in one substance/Divinity. Classically, binitarianism is understood as a form of monotheism—that is, that God is absolutely one being—and yet with binitarianism there is a "twoness" in God, which means one God family. The other common forms of monotheism are "unitarianism", a belief in one God with one person, and "trinitarianism", a belief in one God with three persons.

Homoiousios is a Christian theological term, coined in the 4th century to identify a distinct group of Christian theologians who held the belief that God the Son was of a similar, but not identical, essence with God the Father.

Homoousion is a Christian theological term, most notably used in the Nicene Creed for describing Jesus as "same in being" or "same in essence" with God the Father.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Incarnation (Christianity)</span> Belief that Jesus was made flesh by being conceived in the womb of a woman

In Christian theology, the doctrine of incarnation teaches that the pre-existent divine person of Jesus Christ, God the Son, the second person of the Trinity, and the eternally begotten Logos, took upon human nature and "was made flesh" by being conceived in the womb of a woman, the Virgin Mary, also known as the Theotokos. The doctrine of the incarnation then entails that Jesus was at the same time both fully God and fully human.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Subordinationism</span> Assertion that the Son and the Holy Spirit are subordinate to God the Father in nature and being

Subordinationism is a Trinitarian doctrine wherein the Son is subordinate to the Father, not only in submission and role, but with actual ontological subordination to varying degrees. It posits a hierarchical ranking of the persons of the Social Trinity, implying ontological subordination of the persons of the Son and the Holy Spirit. It was condemned as heretical in the Second Council of Constantinople.

Social trinitarianism is a Christian interpretation of the Trinity as consisting of three persons in a loving relationship, which reflects a model for human relationships. The teaching emphasizes that God is an inherently social being. Human unity approaches conformity to the image of God's unity through self-giving, empathy, adoration for one another, etc. Such love is a fitting ethical likeness to God, but is in stark contrast to God's unity of being. Those who are often associated with this term include Jürgen Moltmann, Miroslav Volf, Elizabeth Johnson, Leonardo Boff, John Zizioulas and Catherine LaCugna.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trinitarianism in the Church Fathers</span>

Debate exists as to whether the earliest Church Fathers in Christian history believed in the doctrine of the Trinity – the Christian doctrine that God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit are three distinct persons sharing one homoousion (essence).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pre-existence of Christ</span> Existence of Christ before his incarnation as Jesus

The pre-existence of Christ asserts the existence of Christ prior to his incarnation as Jesus. One of the relevant Bible passages is John 1 where, in the Trinitarian interpretation, Christ is identified with a pre-existent divine hypostasis called the Logos. There are nontrinitarian views that question the aspect of personal pre-existence, the aspect of divinity, or both.

The position of the Eastern Orthodox Church regarding the Filioque controversy is defined by their interpretation of the Bible, and the teachings of the Church Fathers, creeds and definitions of the seven Ecumenical Councils, as well as the decisions of several particular councils of the Eastern Orthodox Church.

Kevin N. Giles is an Australian evangelical Anglican priest and theologian who was in parish ministry for over 40 years. He and his family live in Melbourne, Australia. Giles studied at Moore Theological College in Sydney, Durham University, England and Tubingen University, Germany. He has a Doctor of Theology degree from the Australian College of Theology.

Arian creeds are the creeds of Arian Christians, developed mostly in the fourth century when Arianism was one of the main varieties of Christianity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eternal procession of the Holy Spirit</span>

The Eternal procession of the Holy Spirit is a theological concept in trinitarianism that describes the relationship of the Holy Spirit within the Holy Trinity. The doctrine of the eternal procession of the Holy Spirit is related to the doctrine of the eternal generation of the Son, however in Christian theology procession is viewed as being mysteriously different from generation in order to distinguish the Holy Spirit from the Son.

References

  1. ↑ "Nicene Creed | Christian Reformed Church". www.crcna.org. Retrieved 2024-08-19.
  2. ↑ "God the Son". Tabletalk. 2019-12-01. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  3. ↑ Hodge, Charles. Outlines of Theology. The eternal generation of the Son is commonly defined to be an eternal personal act of the Father, wherein by necessity of nature, not by choice of will, he generates the person (not the essence) of the Son, by communicating to him the whole indivisible substance of the Godhead, without division, alienation, or change, so that the Son is the express image of His Father's person, and eternally continues, not from the Father, but in the Father, and the Father in the Son
  4. ↑ Hodge, Charles. Outlines of Theology. In order to guard their doctrine of derivation and eternal generation from all gross anthropomorphic conceptions, they carefully maintained that it was—(1) αχρονος timeless, eternal; (2) ασωματως not bodily, spiritual; (3) αορατοςinvisible; (4) αχωριστως not a local transference, a communication not without but within the Godhead ; (5) απαθως without passion or change; (6) παντελως ακαταληπτος, altogether incomprehensible.
  5. ↑ Gatewood, Timothy. "The Catholic Puritan: John Owen on Eternal Generation - Credo Magazine". credomag.com. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  6. ↑ "[Common Places]: Pro-Nicene Theology: Eternal Generation". Zondervan Academic. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  7. ↑ "Part 1 Section 2 Chapter 1 Article 1 Page 2 | USCCB". usccb.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20. And, since the Father has through generation given to the only-begotten Son everything that belongs to the Father, except being Father, the Son has also eternally from the Father, from whom he is eternally born, that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son.
  8. ↑ "The Orthodox Faith - Volume I - Doctrine and Scripture - The Symbol of Faith - Son of God". www.oca.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  9. ↑ "Of God and of the Holy Trinity - Westminster Confession of 1646 - Study Resources". Blue Letter Bible. Retrieved 2023-11-20. the Father is of none, neither begotten, nor proceeding; the Son is eternally begotten of the Father, (Jhn 1:14; Jhn 1:18); the Holy Ghost eternally proceeding from the Father and the Son, (Jhn 15:26; Gal 4:6).
  10. ↑ "Of God and the Holy Trinity". The 1689 Baptist Confession of Faith. 2017-05-31. Retrieved 2023-11-20. the Father is of none, neither begotten nor proceeding; the Son is eternally begotten of the Father;29 the Holy Spirit proceeding from the Father and the Son;30
  11. ↑ "BookOfConcord.org". bookofconcord.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20. l with us according to the humanity; that He is in all respects like us, excepting sin; that He was begotten before the world out of the Father according to the deity, but that the same person was in the last<
    II. That the Father is begotten of no one; the Son of the Father; the Holy Ghost proceeds from Father and Son.
  12. 1 2 3 Giles, Kevin (2012-05-07). The Eternal Generation of the Son: Maintaining Orthodoxy in Trinitarian Theology. InterVarsity Press. ISBN   978-0-8308-3965-0.
  13. ↑ "CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: The Blessed Trinity". newadvent.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  14. ↑ Parkison, Samuel. "The Only Begotten God - Credo Magazine". credomag.com. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  15. ↑ "Trinitarian Agency and the Eternal Subordination of the Son: An Augustinian Perspective". The Gospel Coalition. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  16. ↑ Wedgeworth, Steven (2020-04-15). "Athanasius on the Simple God And Eternal Generation". The Gospel Coalition | Canada. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  17. ↑ Graham, Wyatt (2022-02-13). "Impassibility Makes Sense of Our Faith in the Father and Son". The Gospel Coalition | Canada. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  18. ↑ Giles, Kevin (2012-05-07). The Eternal Generation of the Son: Maintaining Orthodoxy in Trinitarian Theology. InterVarsity Press. ISBN   978-0-8308-3965-0.
  19. ↑ "Bavinck On Eternal Generation - The Heidelblog". heidelblog.net. 2014-08-28. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  20. ↑ Michial (2016-06-10). "Muller: The Reformed Affirmed Eternal Generation Against The Socinians - The Heidelblog". heidelblog.net. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  21. ↑ "John Owen Defended Eternal Generation Against The Socinians - The Heidelblog". heidelblog.net. 2020-10-24. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  22. ↑ "Is God the Son Begotten in His Divine Nature? | Reasonable Faith". www.reasonablefaith.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  23. ↑ "Responding to Craig's Proposals On The Eternal Generation Of The Son". theaquilareport.com. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  24. ↑ Ryrie, Charles C. (1999-01-11). Basic Theology: A Popular Systematic Guide to Understanding Biblical Truth. Moody Publishers. ISBN   978-1-57567-498-8.
  25. ↑ "Reexamining the Eternal Sonship of Christ". Grace to You. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  26. ↑ "Eternally Begotten Son". Catholic Answers. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  27. ↑ Erickson, Millard J. (2009). Who's Tampering with the Trinity?: An Assessment of the Subordination Debate. Kregel Academic. ISBN   978-0-8254-9918-0.
  28. ↑ Parkison, Samuel. "How Then Shall We Theologize? - Credo Magazine". credomag.com. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  29. ↑ "Proverbs 8:23, the Eternal Generation of the Son and the History of Reformed Exegesis". reformation21.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  30. ↑ "What is the Doctrine of Eternal Generation?". Phoenix Seminary. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  31. 1 2 Sanders, Fred; Swain, Scott R. (2017-11-21). Retrieving Eternal Generation. Zondervan Academic. ISBN   978-0-310-53788-5.
  32. ↑ "The Person of the Holy Spirit Part 1: The Person of the Holy Spirit | Walvoord.com". walvoord.com. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  33. ↑ Johnson, Keith (2017-06-16). "Is the Eternal Generation of the Son a Biblical Idea?". The Gospel Coalition. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  34. ↑ "Series in Christology". walvoord.com. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  35. ↑ "Is God the Son Begotten in His Divine Nature? | Reasonable Faith". reasonablefaith.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  36. 1 2 3 4 Bavinck, Herman (2004). Reformed Dogmatics: God and Creation. Translated by Bolt, John; Vriend, John. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Academic. 2.308-310.
  37. ↑ "Nicene Creed | Christian Reformed Church". www.crcna.org. Retrieved 2024-08-01.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.