First Scutari-Ottoman War

Last updated
First Scutari-Ottoman War
AlbanianpashaliksV2.png
Territory held by Kara Mahmud at the height of his power in 1785.
Date1785-1789
Location
Result Inconclusive
Territorial
changes
Pashalik of Scutari loses large parts of its territories held outside of the Sanjak of Scutari.
Belligerents

Flag of Mahmut Pasha Bushatli - 1796.svg Pashalik of Scutari


Pashalik of Berat (switched to opposing side in 1787)
Commanders and leaders
Kara Mahmud Pasha
Ahmed Pasha 
Abdülhamid I (d. 1789)
Selim III
Çavuşoğlu Mehmed Pasha 
Aydoslu Mehmed Pasha
Selim Pasha 
Ali Pasha Tepelena
Cezayirli Gazi Hasan Pasha
Mehmed Pasha Qausholli 
Ahmet Kurt Pasha   X
Ibrahim Bey of Tirana
Units involved
Shkodran Army
Hoti tribe
Malsors
Ottoman Army
Strength
unknown unknown
Casualties and losses
unknown unknown

The First Scutari-Ottoman War was a conflict between Kara Mahmud Pasha, the Pasha of the de facto independent Pashalik of Scutari, and the Ottoman Empire. The war was caused by the expansionist policies of Kara Mahmud, which threatened the central government of the Ottoman Empire.

Contents

Background

During potential Ottoman conflicts with Austria and Russia, Kara Mahmud rebelled against Ottoman authority, causing turmoil in the western territories. [1] The governor of Shkodra reinforced his control, extending his influence even to Manastir. [1] Reports indicate Mahmud challenged the governor of Rumelia and seized funds meant for Belgrade's Janissary troops. The disfunctional Ottoman judiciary system and corruption among judges contributed to Kara Mahmud's rise. [1] He presented himself as an authoritative figure to restore order, gaining support against disruptive notables. Kara Mahmud's interference in Bosnia, where he replaced officials with his puppets, created a crisis for the Sublime Porte. Alliance with the Pasha of Berat, Ahmed Kurt Pasha, expanded the influence of the Bushatlis. Despite the Ottoman government's desire to punish Mahmud, resource constraints and his autonomous rule hindered action. [1] The passive stance continued until the end of 1785, prompting the Bushatlis to prepare for the impending confrontation. [1]

Timeline

Battle on the Kosovo field

In August 1785, the Sultan, alarmed by the growing power of Kara Mahmud and on account of his seditious activities, dismissed him from office as Mutasarrif and gave the order to the armies of the two Balkan eyalets (provinces) of Rumelia and of Bosnia, to march on Shkodër. [2] The Rumelian Army first tried to penetrate to Shkodër through the Dibra region, where it was ambushed and forced to take another route through Kosovo. [3] However, Kara Mahmud through his rapid movements, encountered the Rumelian army before it had time to join with that of Bosnia, and in the Battle he had with it at the Kosovo field, routed it entirely. [2] The decisive defeat of the Rumelian armies persuaded the Wali of Bosnia to retreat without coming to any clash whatsoever with Kara Mahmud. [2] [3] After the Battle, during the period from April 1786 to March 1787, the Uprising of Kara Mahmud faced minimal resistance from both the opposing forces and the military contingents led by the viziers of Rumelia and Bosnia. [4]

Kara Mahmud's offensive

Kara Mahmud's campaign in Macedonia and Kosovo

In May 1787, Kara Mahmud Pasha took the initiative in the battle against the Ottomans. He departed from Scutari with 6,000 soldiers. [5] In Kosovo he first defeated and subdued the Pasha of Yakova. [6] Afterwards, along with his brother Ahmet Pasha, he met the forces of Mehmed Pasha Çausholli near Manastir (Bitola), numbering 20,000 men, ultimately defeating them decisively in Battle. [6] [5] Subsequently, Ahmet Pasha launched an attack on the Vali of Rumelia in Skopje, emerging victorious and taking control of the city. [6]

Kara Mahmud's campaign in Bosnia

Kara Mahmud's advancement through the Balkans reached its peak when his Armies besieged Sarajevo. [6] In this case, the Sublime Porte declared him a rebel and ordered Mehmet Pasha Çausholli to replace him. [6] However, the decision against him was put into effect in May 1787 when rumors in Istanbul suggested that the Pasha was planning to attack Edirne (Adrianople) with 25,000 soldiers. [6] These rumors had significant impact in Istanbul, leading to calls for a jihad against the rebellious Pasha. The Shaykh al-Islām issued a fatwa declaring the Pasha a rebel, while Sultan Abdülhamid I sought his execution. [6] Kara Mahmud's brother Ahmed Pasha effectively countered the Bosnian troops advancing from the north, achieving victory over them. However, in 27 August 1787, Kara Mahmud's operations in the Bosnia eyalet came to a halt when Ahmed Pasha was betrayed and decapitated by his own soldiers. [6] [7]

Ottoman Counteroffensive

Ali Pasha Tepelena's campaigns

Ali Pasha Tepelena, formerly aligned with the Bushatlis against Kurd Ahmed Pasha, emerged as a prominent figure in southern Albania and a formidable leader among the Tosks. [8] Despite his involvement in numerous atrocities and village burnings, the Sublime Porte appointed him as the governor of Trikala, strategically leveraging his military prowess. This decision proved effective, as Ali Pasha Tepelena, demonstrated exceptional leadership, tipping the balance in favor of the central government. [8]

Initially, he achieved a significant victory by breaking the defensive forces of the Bushatlis in Ohrid, notably beheading Kara Mahmud's cousin and sending his head to Istanbul. Subsequently, Ali Pasha Tepelena daringly intervened in Elbasan, quelling the resistance posed by Bushati's forces and securing central Albania for the Ottoman Empire. [8] With the demise of Kurd Ahmed Pasha in 1787, while the war was still going on, Ali Pasha solidified his status as the most influential figure in southern Albania. [8]

In recognition of his contributions to the campaign, the Sublime Porte extended unwavering support to Ali Pasha, assigning other commanders under his authority and providing substantial financial backing. [8] His pivotal role in the campaign against Kara Mahmud likely played a crucial part in his subsequent ascent to become the preeminent power magnate in the region. [8]

Revolt in Ulcinj

The Sublime Porte effectively crushed the resistance of the rebels in Shkodra. As they approached Mahmud's castle, the intervention of Cezayirli Gazi Hasan Pasha sparked an uprising in Ulcinj against the Bushatlis. [7] Ultimately, the Shkodran garrison under the command of the fourteen-year-old nephew of Kara Mahmud, Mehmed Beg, would be defeated, and Mehmed Beg would be handed over to the Ottoman authorities. [7]

Siege of Scutari

The Ottomans gathered 30,000 to 60,000 men under the command of Aydoslu Mehmed Pasha of Rumelia, Selim Pasha of Bosnia, and Ali Pasha of Yanina to besiege the Rozafa castle, where Kara Mahmud Pasha took refuge with 60 to 200 of his soldiers. [2] [9] During the siege, the defending Albanians attempted to break the siege by launching several attacks on the Ottoman armies that had surrounded the castle from all sides. [9] Rozafa endured the bombardment by Turkish artillery for a staggering 80 days. [9] However, on November 25, 1787, Kara Mahmud feigned submission, left the fortress with his loyal followers, and along the way, seized the imperial artillery, which was then turned against the Ottomans. [2] [9] His lurking army and his Malsor allies quickly gathered, ambushing the fleeing Pashas, resulting in a humiliating defeat for the Ottoman troops. [2] [9] Furthermore, all Turkish garrisons in Albania were individually attacked and defeated. Selim Pasha, the Wali of Bosnia, who had been on his way to retreat with 15,000 Bosniaks, was simultaneously dealt a significant blow by the Hoti tribe and was killed in battle. [9] Mehmed Pasha Qausholli suffered a similar fate, when Shkodran Malsors, allied to Kara Mahmud, captured him in battle and decapitated him. [10] Overall, the Ottomans lost around 6,000 men. [11] [9]

Aftermath of the Siege of Scutari

Economic blockade by the Ottomans

Following the victory of Kara Mahmud Pasha in the siege of Scutari, Kara Mahmud faced a challenging turn of events as the Sublime Porte perceived him as a threat. Consequently, they deemed it imperative to eliminate him at any cost. In December, the central government demanded the handover of the Bushatlis from the people of Scutari, threatening severe consequences if not complied with. [12] While military force wasn't immediately employed in Shkodra, the Sublime Porte imposed an economic blockade on all commercial activities and issued arrest decrees for Shkodran merchants attempting trade in other regions. Mustafa Pasha of Toptanis, who was given the title of Pasha , became the executor of these measures, extending his control over central Albania. [12]

Kara Mahmud's first Offensive in Central Albania and Montenegro

Faced with opposition from rival Albanian pashas, Kara Mahmud sought to neutralize internal threats in the Pashalik, preventing potential surprise attacks. His confrontation with the central government was viewed by some Muslims as a challenge to Sultan Abdülhamid's authority, and his close associates were discovered plotting the assassination of Kara Mahmud under the influence of the new Pasha of Bosnia, Mirialem Ebubekir Pasha. [12] After eliminating the conspirators, Mahmud moved northward, where he executed the Pasha of Işbuzi for betrayal. [12] Fearing retaliation from the Sublime Porte and a revolt from his own subjects, Mahmud fortified his castle with a substantial arsenal and sent his brother, Ibrahim Pasha, to break the blockade imposed by Mustafa Toptani. [12] Despite Ibrahim's efforts with allies Kahraman Beg of Tirana and Mahmud Beg of Kavaje, Mustafa Pasha of Toptanis emerged victorious in all Battles. [12] The allies of Kara Mahmud, sheltered in Durrës, awaited Kara Mahmud's assistance, but he remained cautious due to the precarious situation in Scutari. [12] Despite hopes for a imperial pardon from Istanbul amid its wars with Austria and Russia, none was granted, and the influence of Kara Mahmud in central Albania waned. [12]

Negotiations with the Austrians and Russians

Faced with the deteriorating situation, Kara Mahmud initiated negotiations with foreign powers, seeking support against the Ottomans. Both Russia and Austria expressed interest, with the Russians offering military assistance and naval support. [12] The Austrians, closer geographically and with a Catholic presence in Scutari, proposed recognizing Mahmud as the "King of Albania" in exchange for opposing the Ottomans. Despite these tempting offers, Kara Mahmud remained passive, awaiting forgiveness from the Sublime Porte. [12] Surrounded by enemies, including his rival Mustafa Pasha of Toptanis, Kara Mahmud aimed to make peace with the Ottomans. [12] As a gesture of goodwill, he offered a gift to the Sultan: the heads of an Austrian delegation that had come to negotiate collaboration. [12] This act, while serving as proof of Mahmud's loyalty to the Sultan, also aimed to regain the trust of his Muslim subjects. [12]

Kara Mahmud's second Offensive in Central Albania and Montenegro

This strategic move played a crucial role in pacifying the Muslim population in Scutari, which had been supportive during the siege. [12] With newfound support, Kara Mahmud, along with his allies, marched into central Albania and managed to defeat Mustafa Pasha of the Toptanis. [12] Subsequently, Kara Mahmud marched north towards Ulcinj and punished his former allies, burning down their palaces in Tivar (Bar) and leaving his supporters in charge. [12]

Imperial Pardon from the Sultan and the end of the War

The Sublime Porte learned of events in its western provinces through reports from an English ambassador detailing Kara Mahmud's negotiations with the Austrians. [13] The ambassador noted the killing of Austrian emissaries after talks and the potential revolt involving Austrian soldiers joining the Montenegrins. [13] However, Kara Mahmud's swift military intervention prevented the spread of Austrian influence, safeguarding not only his district but also the territorial integrity of the Ottoman Empire. [13] Despite his efforts, the Sublime Porte did not grant Kara Mahmud forgiveness for his political shift, a stance maintained until Selim III ascended the throne. [13] The Ottomans, struggling in the war against two empires, faced defeats exacerbated by conflicts with provincial magnates like Kara Mahmud. The Sublime Porte expended resources to eliminate defiant notables, contributing to the challenges in fighting European powers. [13]

Governor Abdi Pasha of Rumelia sought Kara Mahmud's pardon in exchange for his services on the front, recommending him for appointment to the Belgrade or Bosnian front. Cezayirli Gazi Hasan Pasha also negotiated with Kara Mahmud, acting as guarantors for his loyalty. [13] Despite the Ottomans' desperate circumstances, Mahmud was not officially forgiven, but commanders appealed to appoint him as governor of Bosnia, emphasizing the severity of the situation. [13] In response to appeals, Sultan Selim III offered forgiveness in exchange for Kara Mahmud's loyalty and participation on the Bosnian front with 20,000 soldiers. Mahmud received his pardon on 14 August 1789, brought by his nephew and Mahmud Beg of Kavaja. [13]

Aftermath

With the imperial pardon from the Sublime Porte, Kara Mahmud joined the war against the Austrians on the Ottoman side and quickly mobilized a large army. [13] He was appointed the Commander of Yeni Pazar and marched towards Kosovo, intending to gather more soldiers needed against the Austrians. [13] In Bosnia, he was ordered by Governor Mehmed Pasha to move to Izvornik. Despite initial successes against the Austrians, harsh conditions forced Kara Mahmud to retreat to Scutari. [13]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ottoman Albania</span> Period in Albanian history from the 14th to the 20th century

Ottoman Albania refers to a period in Albanian history from the Ottoman conquest in the late 15th century to the Albanian declaration of Independence and official secession from the Ottoman Empire in 1912. The Ottomans first entered Albania in 1385 upon the invitation of the Albanian noble Karl Thopia to suppress the forces of the noble Balša II during the battle of Savra. They had some previous influence in some Albanian regions after the battle of Savra in 1385 but not direct control. The Ottomans placed garrisons throughout southern Albania by 1420s and established formal jurisdiction in central Albania by 1431. Even though The Ottomans claimed rule of all Albanian lands, most Albanian ethnic territories were still governed by medieval Albanian nobility who were free of Ottoman rule. The Sanjak of Albania was established in 1420 or 1430 controlling mostly central Albania, while Ottoman rule became more consolidated in 1481, after the fall of Shkodra and League of Lezhe with the country being mostly free in the period of 1443–1481. Albanians revolted again in 1481 but the Ottomans finally controlled Albania by 1488.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ali Pasha of Ioannina</span> Albanian ruler (1740–1822)

Ali Pasha or Ali Pasha of Tepelena, commonly known as Ali Pasha of Ioannina, was an Albanian ruler who served as Ottoman pasha of the Pashalik of Yanina, a large part of western Rumelia, which under his rule acquired a high degree of autonomy and even managed to stay de facto independent. The capital of the Pashalik was Ioannina, which along with Tepelena were Ali's headquarters. Conceiving his territory in increasingly independent terms, Ali Pasha's correspondence and foreign Western correspondence frequently refer to the territories under Ali's control as "Albania", which by Ali's definition included central and southern Albania, and parts of mainland Greece; in particular, most of the district of Epirus and the western parts of Thessaly and Macedonia. He managed to stretch his control over the sanjaks of Yanina, Delvina, Vlora and Berat, Elbasan, Ohrid and Monastir, Görice, and Tirhala. Ali was granted the Sanjak of Tirhala in 1787, and he delegated in 1788 its government to his second born Veli Pasha, who also became Pasha of the Morea Eyalet in 1807. Ali's eldest son Muhtar Pasha was granted the Sanjak of Karli-Eli and the Sanjak of Eğriboz in 1792, stretching for the first time Ali's control down to Livadia and the Gulf of Corinth, except Attica. Muhtar Pasha also became governor of the Sanjak of Ohrid in 1796–7 and of the Sanjak of Vlora and Berat in 1810.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alemdar Mustafa Pasha</span> Ottoman military commander (died 1808)

Alemdar Mustafa Pasha was an Ottoman military commander and grand vizier.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kara Mahmud Pasha</span> Albanian governor

Kara Mahmud Pasha was a hereditary Ottoman Albanian governor (mutasarrıf) of the Pashalik of Scutari and de jure ruler of Albania. He belonged to the Ottoman Albanian Bushati family.

Ibrahim Bushati or Ibrahim Bushat Pasha was a noble of the Bushati family in Ottoman controlled Albania near the city of Shkodër. Brother of Kara Mahmud Bushati, the Ottoman appointed governor of Shkodër, Albania. During his rule in Shkodra, Ibrahim was appointed Beylebey of Rumelia in 1805 and took part in the attempt to crush the First Serbian Uprising under Karađorđe Petrović after the Battle of Ivankovac. Ibrahim Bushati is also known to have aided Ali Pasha on various occasions. In fact Ali Pasha's two sons Muktar Pasha and Veil Pasha are known to have served under the command of Ibrahim Bushati in 1806.

Mustafa Pasha Bushatli, called Ishkodrali, was a semi-independent Albanian Ottoman statesman, the last hereditary governor of the Pashalik of Scutari. In 1810 he succeeded Ibrahim Bushati and ruled Shkodër until 1831.

The Bushati were a prominent Ottoman-Albanian family that ruled the Pashalik of Scutari from 1757 to 1831.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pashalik of Scutari</span> 1757–1831 autonomous and de facto independent pashalik

The Pashalik of Scutari, Iskodra, or Shkodra (1757–1831), was an autonomous and de facto independent pashalik created by the Buşatlı family from the previous Sanjak of Scutari, which was situated around the city of Shkodër in modern-day Albania and large majority of modern-day Montenegro. At its peak during the reign of Kara Mahmud Bushati the pashalik encompassed much of Albania, most of Kosovo, western Macedonia, southeastern Serbia and most of Montenegro. Up to 1830 the Pashalik of Shkodra controlled most of the above lands including Southern Montenegro.

Mehmed Pasha Bushati was the governor of the Pashalik of Scutari and founder of the Bushatli dynasty of Shkodër

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Albanian Pashaliks</span> Three semi-independent pashaliks ruled by Albanian pashas from 1756 to 1831

The Albanian Pashaliks were three semi-independent pashaliks ruled by Albanian pashas from 1760 to 1831 and covering the territory of modern Albania, Kosovo, most of Montenegro, southern Serbia, western North Macedonia and most of mainland Greece. The degree of independence of these pashaliks varied over time, from semi-autonomous to de facto independent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ottoman–Venetian War (1463–1479)</span> Series of conflicts fought between the Ottoman Empire and the Republic of Venice from 1463 to 1479

The First Ottoman–Venetian War was fought between the Republic of Venice with its allies and the Ottoman Empire from 1463 to 1479. Fought shortly after the capture of Constantinople and the remnants of the Byzantine Empire by the Ottomans, it resulted in the loss of several Venetian holdings in Albania and Greece, most importantly the island of Negroponte (Euboea), which had been a Venetian protectorate for centuries. The war also saw the rapid expansion of the Ottoman navy, which became able to challenge the Venetians and the Knights Hospitaller for supremacy in the Aegean Sea. In the closing years of the war, however, the Republic managed to recoup its losses by the de facto acquisition of the Crusader Kingdom of Cyprus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sanjak of Scutari</span> 1479–1913 Ottoman administrative unit in north Albania

The Sanjak of Scutari or Sanjak of Shkodra was one of the sanjaks of the Ottoman Empire. It was established after the Ottoman Empire acquired Shkodra after the siege of Shkodra in 1478–9. It was part of the Eyalet of Rumelia until 1867, when it became a part, together with the Sanjak of Skopje, of the newly established Scutari Vilayet. In 1912 and the beginning of 1913 it was occupied by members of the Balkan League during the First Balkan War. In 1914 the territory of Sanjak of Scutari became a part of the Principality of Albania, established on the basis of the peace contract signed during the London Conference in 1913.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Shkodra</span> Battle during the First Ottoman-Venetian War

The siege of Shkodra took place from May 1478 to April 1479 as a confrontation between the Ottoman Empire and the Venetians together with the League of Lezhe and other Albanians at Shkodra and its Rozafa Castle during the First Ottoman-Venetian War (1463–1479). Ottoman historian Franz Babinger called the siege "one of the most remarkable episodes in the struggle between the West and the Crescent". A small force of approximately 1,600 Albanian and Italian men and a much smaller number of women faced a massive Ottoman force containing artillery cast on site and an army reported to have been as many as 350,000 in number. The campaign was so important to Mehmed the Conqueror that he came personally to ensure triumph. After nineteen days of bombarding the castle walls, the Ottomans launched five successive general attacks which all ended in victory for the besieged. With dwindling resources, Mehmed attacked and defeated the smaller surrounding fortresses of Žabljak Crnojevića, Drisht, and Lezha, left a siege force to starve Shkodra into surrender, and returned to Constantinople. On January 25, 1479, Venice and Constantinople signed a peace agreement that ceded Shkodra to the Ottoman Empire. The defenders of the citadel emigrated to Venice, whereas many Albanians from the region retreated into the mountains. Shkodra then became a seat of the newly established Ottoman sanjak, the Sanjak of Scutari. The Ottomans held the city until Montenegro captured it in April 1913, after a six-month siege.

Battle of Martinići was the battle between Montenegro and Pashalik of Scutari which took place on the outskirts of the village Martinići, near Spuž, Montenegro.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Çapanoğlu dynasty</span>

The Çapanoğlu dynasty, also Cebbarzâdeler, Çaparzâdeler and Çaparoğulları, is Turkish dynasty that originates in the 17th-century Ottoman Empire and was once one of the most prominent Ottoman families. They became one of the most powerful dynasties in the empire in the 18th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Canikli family</span> Turkish Feudal Family

The Canikli family or Canikli dynasty was a prominent Ottoman family. The family had a notable feud with the Çapanoğlu, with whom they clashed for supremacy in Anatolia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sanjak of Durrës</span> Sanjak of the Ottoman Empire

The Sanjak of Durrës was one of the sanjaks of the Ottoman Empire. It was named for its capital Durrës and was also known as the Sanjak of Durazzo from its capital's Italian name. The sanjak was composed of the kazas of Durrës, Tirana, Shijak, Kavajë, and Krujë. The Sanjak of Durrës formed the southern half of the Vilayet of Scutari. The northern half was the Sanjak of Scutari. Durrës Sanjak also bordered the sanjaks of Manastir and Dibra to its northeast and the sanjak of Elbasan to the east and south. Its western border was the Adriatic Sea. Its terrain is generally flat and plain. Only the eastern parts of the kazas of Tirana and Kavajë were mountainous.

The First Scutari-Berat War was a military conflict between the Pashalik of Scutari under Mehmed Pasha Bushati against the Pashalik of Berat under Ahmet Kurt Pasha, who fought over the Sanjak of Durrës.

The Scuatri invasion of Montenegro, was a military campaign launched by Kara Mahmud Pasha, the head of the Pashalik of Scutari, against the Prince-Bishopric of Montenegro, as well as the Montenegrin tribes of Old Montenegro, Paštrovići and Brda. The campaign also included the capture of Spuž, a castle which was administered by the Bosnian Pasha, Ibrahim Pasha of Spuž.

The Second Scutari-Berat War was a military invasion launched by Mustafa Pasha of the Pashalik of Scutari against the Pashalik of Berat under Ahmet Kurt Pasha.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Gjeli 2018, p. 91-92.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Frashëri, Kristo (1964). The History of Albania: A Brief Survey. pp. 104–105.
  3. 1 2 "Shkëlqimi dhe rënia e Karamahmud Pashë Bushatliut". www.forumishqiptar.com. Retrieved 2023-11-05.
  4. "PASHALLËQET E MËDHA SHQIPTARE". historia.shqiperia.com. Retrieved 2023-11-05.
  5. 1 2 Palairet, Michael (2016-02-08). Macedonia: A Voyage through History (Vol. 2, From the Fifteenth Century to the Present). Cambridge Scholars Publishing. p. 90. ISBN   978-1-4438-8849-3.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Jazexhi 2018, p. 9.
  7. 1 2 3 Gjeli 2018, p. 96.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Gjeli 2018, p. 94-95.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Gopčević, Spiridion (1914). Geschichte von Montenegro und Albanien. unknown library. Gotha : F.A. Perthes. p. 104.
  10. Jazexhi 2018, p. 10.
  11. Galaty, Michael L.; Bejko, Lorenc (2023-09-12). Archaeological Investigations in a Northern Albanian Province: Results of the Projekti Arkeologjik i Shkodrës (PASH): Volume One: Survey and Excavation Results. University of Michigan Press. ISBN   978-1-951538-73-6.
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Gjeli 2018, p. 98-102.
  13. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Gjeli 2018, p. 102-104.

Sources