Girl Shy

Last updated

Girl Shy
Advertisement from Motion Picture News
Directed by Fred C. Newmeyer
Sam Taylor
Produced by Harold Lloyd
Written by Thomas J. Gray (titles)
Sam Taylor (story)
Tim Whelan (story)
Ted Wilde (story)
Starring Harold Lloyd
Jobyna Ralston
Cinematography Walter Lundin
Edited by Allen McNeil
Distributed by Pathé Exchange
Release date
March 28, 1924 (New York premiere)
  • April 20, 1924 (1924-04-20)
Running time
80-82 minutes
CountryUnited States
Languages Silent film
English intertitles
Budget$400,000 (estimated) [1]
Box office$1,550,000 [2] [3]
The full film

Girl Shy is a 1924 romantic comedy silent film starring Harold Lloyd and Jobyna Ralston. The movie was written by Sam Taylor, Tim Whelan and Ted Wilde and was directed by Fred C. Newmeyer and Taylor. In 2020, the film entered the public domain. [4]



Harold Meadows (Lloyd) is a tailor's apprentice for his uncle in Little Bend, California. He is so shy around women that he can barely speak to them (to stop his stuttering, his uncle has to blow a whistle). Despite this, Harold writes a "how to" book for young men entitled The Secret of Making Love, detailing how to woo different types of young women, such as "the vampire" and "the flapper" (in scenes that parodied two other popular films of the time, Trifling Women and Flaming Youth [ citation needed ]), and takes a train to see a publisher in Los Angeles.

Harold Lloyd as Harold Meadows, a shy and awkward writer Harold Meadows.jpg
Harold Lloyd as Harold Meadows, a shy and awkward writer

The same day, rich young Mary Buckingham (Ralston) boards the same train after her automobile breaks down in Little Bend. No dogs are allowed aboard, so she hides her Pomeranian under her shawl, but her pet jumps off as the train pulls away. Harold rescues her dog and helps Mary hide it from the conductor. She sees his manuscript, so he starts telling her about his book, overcoming his stuttering in his enthusiasm. They become so absorbed in each other that neither realizes that the train has reached its final destination and everyone else has departed. Upon returning home, Mary rejects the latest in a string of marriage proposals from persistent suitor Ronald DeVore, "the kind of a man that men forget". Mary's savvy mind has long ago realized that the arrogantly-selfish and much-older Ronald does not truly love her, but would merely want her as a trophy wife with a large inheritance.

After her car is repaired, Mary intentionally detours through Little Bend repeatedly, hoping to see Harold again. On one such trip, Ronald is also along for the ride, and his unwanted attentions cause Mary to swerve and get her car stuck near the outskirts of Little Bend. While Ronald walks back to town for a tow, Mary goes for a walk and happens to reunite with Harold. After telling Mary about the remainder of his book, Harold informs her that he is going to see the publisher, Roger Thornby, in a few days to deliver a new chapter that will be about her. They agree to meet again afterward. Meanwhile, back in Little Bend, Ronald runs into a middle-aged woman who asks if he is finally going to introduce her to his family, but he stalls her, then rides away in the tow-vehicle.

Advertisement from Motion Picture News Girl Shy advertisement.jpg
Advertisement from Motion Picture News

Mr. Thornby's professional readers find Harold's book hilariously absurd, so he rejects it. Without any royalty money, Harold figures he cannot ask the accustomed-to-a-posh-lifestyle Mary to marry him. So, feeling too ashamed to admit the truth to Mary, he pretends that he was only using her as part of his research --- "I tell that to all the girls I meet --- to get ideas." Heartbroken, Mary impulsively agrees to marry Ronald, even though she knows that he will never really show her the innocent warmth and sincere kindness that Harold always had. Afterward, though, one of Mr. Thornby's senior employees convinces him that, if the staff liked the book so much, there must be a market for it, so Thornby decides to publish it as "The Boob's Diary".

A few days later, a depressed Harold gets a letter from the publisher, but just rips it up without opening it, assuming that it is a rejection notice. Fortunately, his uncle notices that one of the paper-scraps is part of an advance royalty check for $3,000; the accompanying letter states that the book will be published as a comedy. At first, Harold is outraged, but then he realizes that his having this large cash-sum means that he can propose to Mary after all. However, when he sees a newspaper headline announcing Mary and Ronald's wedding that same day at her family's estate, he gives up. By chance, the same woman whom Ronald had met a few days earlier walks in and, seeing the newspaper story, tearfully exclaims that she is Ronald's wife. As proof, she shows Harold a locket with the couple's wedding portrait and the engraved words "to my wife" that Ronald had given her two years earlier. (It is never revealed why the wealthy Ronald had married a working-class woman, but it was likely simple greed --- perhaps this lady was the beneficiary of a sizeable life-insurance policy or upcoming inheritance, and so Ronald had secretly married the lady in hopes of accessing her future fortune. Ronald had not informed his family about his marriage to this currently-of-modest-income lady lest they would disapprove; he may also have told his new wife not to let anyone know of their marriage, either, fearing that the lady's benefactor would exclude her from his will if he learned that she now had a rich husband who could provide for her. After meeting the super-affluent Buckingham family and being accepted by Mary's parents as a prospective son-in-law, however, Ronald had simply ceased contact with his wife, knowing that her inheritance would be a paltry sum compared to what Mary would receive.)

Harold embarks on a frenzied headlong dash, involving bootleggers, car chases and multiple changes of vehicle (from missing the train to various cars to a trolley to a police motorcycle to a horse-drawn wagon to horseback), through the countryside and along the crowded streets of Culver City and Los Angeles. Arriving at the Buckingham Estate with mere seconds to spare, Harold bursts in on the wedding ceremony where Ronald is just on the point of putting the wedding-ring on the tearfully-unhappy Mary's finger, but Harold cannot stop stuttering long enough to expose Ronald's intended bigamy. So Harold simply carries Mary off. When they are alone, he tells her about Ronald's secret and shows her the locket. Immensely relieved that she does not have to marry the dislikable Ronald after all, and gratefully realizing that Harold has proven himself to indeed be the caring and chivalrous gentleman whom she had always thought he was, Mary gets Harold to propose to her (with an assist from a passing mail carrier's whistle, which Mary blows to stop Harold's stuttering), and she accepts.


Harold Lloyd and Jobyna Ralston in Girl Shy Still from Girl Shy 04.jpg
Harold Lloyd and Jobyna Ralston in Girl Shy


This was Lloyd's first independent production after his split with Hal Roach. It is what Lloyd called a "character story" (as opposed to a "gag film"), and is notable for containing fewer of the stunts which characterize Lloyd's other films throughout most of its length, and instead focusing more on the relationship between Lloyd and Ralston. However, the lengthy finale of the film is one of the most exhilarating, non-stop action sequences of Lloyd's career.[ citation needed ]

It was also the second of six consecutive movies pairing Harold Lloyd and Jobyna Ralston, who left Hal Roach Studios as well to continue working with Lloyd. Unlike the normal style for filmed romances prior to Girl Shy, both Ralston and Lloyd were featured in comedic scenes.

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>The Happy Ending</i> 1969 film by Richard Brooks

The Happy Ending is a 1969 drama film written and directed by Richard Brooks, which tells the story of a repressed housewife who longs for liberation from her husband and daughter. It stars Jean Simmons, John Forsythe, Shirley Jones, Lloyd Bridges and Teresa Wright.

<i>The Wedding Singer</i> 1998 film by Frank Coraci

The Wedding Singer is a 1998 American romantic comedy film directed by Frank Coraci, written by Tim Herlihy, and produced by Robert Simonds for US$18 million and grossed $80.2 million in the United States and $123.3 million worldwide. The film stars Adam Sandler, Drew Barrymore, and Christine Taylor. It tells the story of a wedding singer who falls in love with a waitress.

Jobyna Ralston American actress

Jobyna Ralston was an American stage and film actress. She had a featured role in the first Oscar-winning film, Wings in 1927, but is perhaps best remembered today for her on-screen chemistry with Harold Lloyd, with whom she appeared in seven movies.

<i>The Freshman</i> (1925 film) 1925 film

The Freshman is a 1925 American silent comedy film that tells the story of a college freshman trying to become popular by joining the school football team. It stars Harold Lloyd, Jobyna Ralston, Brooks Benedict, and James Anderson. It remains one of Lloyd's most successful and enduring films.

<i>Why Worry?</i> 1923 film

Why Worry? is a 1923 American silent comedy film directed by Fred Newmeyer and Sam Taylor and starring Harold Lloyd.

<i>For Heavens Sake</i> (1926 film) 1926 comedy silent film by Sam Taylor

For Heaven's Sake is a 1926 comedy silent film directed by Sam Taylor and starring Harold Lloyd. Commercially, it was one of Lloyd's most successful films and the 12th highest-grossing film of the silent era, pulling in $2,600,000.

<i>The Kid Brother</i> 1927 silent comedy film

The Kid Brother is a 1927 American silent comedy film starring Harold Lloyd. It was successful and popular upon release and today is considered by critics and fans to be one of Lloyd's best films, integrating elements of comedy, romance, drama, and character development. Its storyline is an homage to a 1921 film called Tol'able David, although it is essentially a re-make of a little-known 1924 Hal Roach feature, The White Sheep, starring Glenn Tryon.

<i>Dogs of War!</i> (film) 1923 film

Dogs of War! is a 1923 silent short subject, the fourteenth entry in Hal Roach's Our Gang series. Directed by Robert F. McGowan, the two-reel short was released to theaters in July 1923 by Pathé Exchange. The short was filmed alongside Why Worry?, a feature comedy produced by Roach and starring Harold Lloyd, who makes a cameo appearance in Dogs of War as himself.

<i>Hot Water</i> (1924 film) 1924 film

Hot Water is a 1924 American silent comedy film directed by Fred C. Newmeyer and Sam Taylor and starring Harold Lloyd.

<i>Montana Moon</i> 1930 film

Montana Moon is a 1930 Pre-Code comedy, drama, musical, western film starring Joan Crawford, Johnny Mack Brown, and Ricardo Cortez. The film focuses on the budding relationship between a city girl and a rural cowboy. The film introduced the concept of the singing cowboy to the screen.

<i>Haunted Spooks</i> 1920 film by Hal Roach, Alfred J. Goulding

Haunted Spooks is a 1920 American silent Southern Gothic comedy film produced and co-directed by Hal Roach, starring Harold Lloyd and Mildred Davis.

<i>Get Out and Get Under</i> 1920 film by Hal Roach

Get Out and Get Under is a 1920 American silent comedy film directed by Hal Roach and starring Harold Lloyd and Mildred Davis.

Special Delivery is a 1927 American silent comedy film directed by Roscoe Arbuckle, starring Eddie Cantor, written by Cantor, John F. Goodrich and George Marion Jr.. It was released by Paramount Pictures.

<i>Now or Never</i> (1921 film) 1921 film

Now or Never is a 1921 American short comedy film starring Harold Lloyd and directed by Hal Roach and Fred C. Newmeyer.

<i>Rockabye</i> (1932 film) 1932 film

Rockabye is a 1932 American pre-Code drama film directed by George Cukor. The screenplay by Jane Murfin is based on a play by Lucia Bronder.

Jobyna Howland

Jobyna Howland was an American stage and screen actress.

<i>Welcome Danger</i> 1929 film

Welcome Danger is a 1929 American pre-Code comedy film directed by Clyde Bruckman and starring Harold Lloyd. A sound version and silent version were filmed. Ted Wilde began work on the silent version, but became ill and was replaced by Bruckman.

<i>Gigolo</i> (film) 1926 film

Gigolo is a 1926 American silent romance drama film produced by Cecil B. DeMille and released by Producers Distributing Corporation. William K. Howard directed and Rod La Rocque and Jobyna Ralston star. The film is based on a novel, Gigolo, by Edna Ferber.

Little Mickey Grogan is a 1927 American comedy-drama film directed by James Leo Meehan and written by Dwight Cummins, Dorothy Yost and Charles Kerr. The film stars Frankie Darro, Lassie Lou Ahern, Jobyna Ralston, Carroll Nye, Eugene Jackson, William Scott and Vadim Uraneff. The film was released on December 27, 1927, by Film Booking Offices of America.

<i>Some Mothers Boy</i> 1929 silent film

Some Mother's Boy is a 1929 American silent drama film directed by Duke Worne and starring Mary Carr, Jason Robards Sr. and Jobyna Ralston.


  1. Vance, Jeffrey; Lloyd, Suzanne (2002). Harold Lloyd: Master Comedian. New York: Harry N Abrams. p. 115. ISBN   0-8109-1674-6.
  2. Quigley Publishing Company "The All Time Best Sellers", International Motion Picture Almanac 1937-38 (1938) p 942 accessed April 19, 2014
  3. "WHICH CINEMA FILMS HAVE EARNED THE MOST MONEY SINCE 1914?". The Argus . Melbourne. March 4, 1944. p. 3 Supplement: The Argus Weekend magazine. Retrieved August 6, 2012 via National Library of Australia.
  4. "All the books, movies and music that are public domain in 2020". ABC NEWS. January 3, 2020. Retrieved March 22, 2020.