Gulliver's nightclub fire

Last updated
Gulliver's nightclub fire
Location Port Chester, New York
Coordinates 41°00′50″N73°39′22″W / 41.0139°N 73.6561°W / 41.0139; -73.6561
DateJune 30, 1974 (1974-06-30)
Early Morning
Attack type
Arson
Deaths24
Injured32
PerpetratorPeter J. Leonard
MotiveTo cover up burglary at adjacent bowling alley

The Gulliver's nightclub fire occurred in the early hours of June 30, 1974, on the border of Port Chester, New York and Greenwich, Connecticut. The fire killed 24 patrons and injured 19 patrons and 13 firemen. [1] The fire was caused by arson in an adjacent bowling alley that had been aimed at covering up a minor burglary there.

Contents

The venue

The restaurant was formally known as Gulliver's Restaurant Inc. and opened in 1971. [2] [3] It attracted crowds of young people, particularly Connecticut residents, since while both states had a drinking age of 18, NY had last call much later. "For decades, youths from southern Connecticut, where the drinking age was 18 since 1972, had flocked to this part-leafy, part-scruffy miniature city so they could take advantage of New York's later last call hour." [2] The restaurant was originally the Old Post Grill, but that burned in 1962; then it was Lucy's, which had a fire in 1968. [2] The building was owned by the Port Chester Electrical Construction Corporation. [4]

The building housing Gulliver's was on the border of Port Chester and Greenwich and so spanned the county and state line between Westchester County, New York and Fairfield County, Connecticut. [5] Gulliver's was a restaurant and bar with its entrance on the Greenwich side. Most of Gulliver's was considered on the New York side, and had been inspected by Port Chester fire authorities two months before the fire. [6] The other businesses in the building were considered to be in Greenwich and had not been inspected since 1964 when the last equipment was installed. [6]

On the main floor of Gulliver's was a dining room, main bar and the kitchen. Down a short but fairly narrow flight of stairs was the lower level where the lounge was. In this area was a sunken dance floor. It was in this lower level where the late night discotheque took place. [5] On the ground floor there was also a small barber shop and a retail store for clothing, called The Clothes Post. [7] More importantly, there was a bowling alley that took up almost half the building. [5]

Fire

There were about 200 young people in the lower level lounge at the time of the fire, just before 1 a.m. [5] The band was the Creation, and included Paul Caravello [8] [7] (who would later become drummer of Kiss under the name Eric Carr, a.k.a. The Fox). They stopped playing the song "I Wanna Know Your Name" after a waitress told them she smelled smoke. They calmly announced "There's a small fire. Please walk out quietly." [9] The thick smoke spread so quickly that it appeared the lights had gone out. At this point, there was a panic; because of the heat, patrons on the dance floor were unable to climb the only stairs to the main floor. Paul Caravello went back into the melee to help his four bandmates who had become trapped: John and Sarita Henderson, Damon DeFeis (brother of soprano Doreen DeFeis and Virgin Steele vocalist David DeFeis), and George D. Chase. Though he was able to locate and rescue John and Sarita, the three of them having to climb over quite a few bodies in order for them to escape (because if they had tried to make for the exit in the dressing room, like Sarita had wanted, none of them would have gotten out of there), nothing could be done for Damon or George in time. The authorities never did figure out exactly where the fire started, but according to them, the flash point was somewhere near the wall separating the bar and bowling alley, under the bandstand, and that’s where George and Damon’s bodies were found. They had chosen to remain there in order to help direct the evacuation rather than try to save themselves first. Both Creation's keyboard player (Damon) and lead singer (George) perished along with 22 other patrons, crew, friends and fans. [5] [8] [10] [7] [11] [12]

Nineteen fire companies responded to the incident, mainly from the Port Chester and Greenwich Fire Departments, but from other Westchester and Connecticut municipalities as well. Initial attempts to enter the building were hampered by intense heat and smoke. [5] Various reports claim it took about 90 minutes [5] to four hours [8] to get the fire under control.

Victims

Most of the 24 victims were found at the foot of the stairs, with some others on the sunken dance floor. [5]

Due to most victims not being local, there is little commemoration of the tragedy. [13]

Investigation

The county medical examiner reported that many of the bodies were so charred that dental work was the only way of identifying the victims. [14]

Autopsies revealed that all the victims died from asphyxiation. This quashed rumors that victims had been trampled to death. [15] Also, some electric clocks were found in the rubble stopped at 1:50 showing that power had been on during the fire and that a total blackout had not occurred. [15]

The source of the fire initially appeared to be the nursery of the bowling alley, which was located in the basement under the clothing store. [15] The exact location of the start of the fire proved to be very important, since it determined whether New York or Connecticut authorities had responsibility for the final investigation. [16]

Peter J. Leonard of Greenwich, an unemployed laborer and high school dropout who was 22 years old, was arrested by Connecticut authorities on July 12, 1974 on charges of setting the fire. [17] Authorities stated that he was a frequent patron of the bowling alley and had been there early in the evening and then left when the alleys closed, returning later through a rooftop skylight with the intention of burglarizing the business. [18] On July 16, it was announced that final building surveys revealed that the part of the nursery where the fire was set as well as the skylight where Leonard entered the alleys were both in New York State. [19]

The bowling alley where the fire started had gone without government fire inspections for five years before the fire. [20] [11] The cause of this lapse appeared to be an agreement written in 1961 from the Connecticut State Fire Marshal to both municipalities involved that was forgotten about after the retirement of a Port Chester fire inspector in 1969. [20] [11] The agreement stated that Port Chester would take responsibility for inspecting the bowling alley because most of it was in New York State. [20] [11] Officials in Port Chester questioned the legality of the agreement after the fire, saying the parties who drew it up had no legal authority to do so. [20] [11]

Criminal

Once it was determined that the fire was set in New York, extradition was sought to bring the suspect from Connecticut to New York. Leonard waived extradition and was indicted by a Westchester County Grand Jury on July 30 on 28 counts, consisting of 24 murder charges (one for each victim), arson, burglary and two counts of petit larceny. [21] The theory of the crime was that Leonard had burglarized some cigarette vending machines in the bowling alley and set the fire to cover up the burglary. [1] [12]

Leonard pleaded guilty just before his trial was due to start on June 16, 1975. Then, on his sentencing hearing on July 16, he tried to withdraw the plea. The judge refused the request to withdraw the plea and sentenced Leonard to 15 years to life imprisonment. [22] The judge commented that Leonard had performed "stupid actions in attempting to cover up a third-rate burglary by arson, resulting in Westchester's worst tragedy." He also said "You're certainly not an all American boy, but you're not a vicious killer either." [22]

On July 19, 1977, the guilty verdict for murder was overturned by the Appellate Court, because his confession was found to have been coerced. [23]

He was then convicted by a jury on September 7, 1978 after 812 hours of deliberation on all 28 counts of the indictment. [24] This guilty verdict was overturned on December 16, 1985 because the Appellate Division found that self-incriminating statements had been made without a lawyer present. [25]

On March 25, 1986, prosecutors allowed Leonard to plead guilty to second degree manslaughter. [26] [12] On April 9, 1986, he was sentenced to 15 years. [26] Under New York law, inmates with good records were released after serving two thirds of their sentence, therefore he qualified for release soon afterwards. [26] [12]

Civil

The first civil lawsuit began July 5, 1974 when a lawyer representing the husband of one of the victims, Jonetta Horsey, who perished in the fire, filed papers starting a $2 million suit. [27] The filing asked that the attorney be included in the fire investigation. [27]

By July 8, 1974, nine families had retained counsel for possible lawsuits. [28]

On July 9, 1974, an attorney representing six families who lost loved ones filed a notice of claim for $12 million with the Village of Port Chester. [29] The notice contended that Port Chester "was negligent and careless in failing to make proper and sufficient inspections" of both the restaurant and bowling alley. [29] [11] Even though the bowling alley was almost entirely in Connecticut, the attorney filing the papers said the fact that it adjoined the restaurant (which was mostly in New York) made it Port Chester's responsibility. [29]

On July 15, 1974, it was reported that Greenwich would be served with a notice of claim for $16 million on behalf of 8 victims of the fire. [16]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Greenwich, Connecticut</span> Town in Connecticut, United States

Greenwich is a town in southwestern Fairfield County, Connecticut, United States. At the 2020 census, it had a population of 63,518. Greenwich is a principal community of the Bridgeport–Stamford–Norwalk–Danbury metropolitan statistical area, which comprises all of Fairfield County, and is part of the Western Connecticut Planning Region. The town is the southwesternmost municipality in both the State of Connecticut and the six-state region of New England. The town is named after Greenwich, a royal borough of London in the United Kingdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Port Chester, New York</span> Village in New York, United States

Port Chester is a village in the U.S. state of New York and the largest part of the town of Rye in Westchester County by population. At the 2010 U.S. census, the village had a population of 28,967 and was the fifth-most populous village in New York State. In 2019, its population grew to a census-estimated 29,342 residents. Located in southeast Westchester, Port Chester forms part of the New York City metropolitan statistical area. Port Chester borders Connecticut and the town of Greenwich to the east. It is one of only 12 villages in New York still incorporated under a charter; other villages either incorporated or reincorporated under the provisions of Village Law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rye Brook, New York</span> Village in New York, United States

Rye Brook is a village in Westchester County, New York, United States, within the town of Rye. The population was 9,347 at the 2010 census.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rye (town), New York</span> Town in New York, United States

Rye is a town in Westchester County, New York, United States. The population was 49,613 at the 2020 United States census over 45,928 at the 2010 census. It is a separate municipality from the city of Rye. The Town of Rye contains two villages – Port Chester and Rye Brook – and the Rye Neck section of the village of Mamaroneck. Port Chester, Rye Brook and Rye Neck comprise the entire area of the town of Rye.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">New Roc City</span> Shopping mall in New York, United States

New Roc City, also known as New Rochelle Center, is an entertainment, retail and residential complex in the Downtown section of the city of New Rochelle in Westchester County, New York. It is located at 33 LeCount Place, between Main Street North and Main Street South. The center was built on the site of the former New Rochelle Mall, which closed in 1992.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sheffield Ski Village</span> Dry ski slope in Sheffield, England

Sheffield Ski Village was an artificial ski slope complex in the Parkwood Springs area of Sheffield, England which operated from 1988 until it was destroyed by fire in 2012. It was believed to be the largest artificial ski resort in Europe with a sports shop, bar, restaurant and a range of slopes which included a Snowflex nursery slope, a Dendix recreational slope and a freestyle park consisting of a half pipe, hip jump, kicker, a quarter pipe and various grind rails.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Byram, Connecticut</span> Census-designated place in Connecticut, United States

Byram is a neighborhood/section and census-designated place (CDP) in the town of Greenwich in Fairfield County, Connecticut, United States. It had a population of 4,146 at the 2010 census, and a census-estimated population of 4,216 in 2018. An endcap of Connecticut's Gold Coast, Byram is the southernmost point in the town of Greenwich and the U.S. state of Connecticut. It is separated from Port Chester, Westchester County, New York, by the Byram River. Byram was once known as East Port Chester.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">New York State Route 120A</span> Highway in New York and Connecticut

New York State Route 120A (NY 120A) is a state highway in southern Westchester County, New York, in the United States. It serves as an alternate route to the southern half of NY 120 running along the New York–Connecticut state line. The southern terminus of the route is at NY 120 in Harrison. Its northern terminus is at NY 120 in North Castle. Most of the 8.55-mile (13.76 km) route straddles the New York–Connecticut state line, and part of the route is physically located in Connecticut. However, this part of the highway is not recognized by Connecticut as "Route 120A", and is considered to be part of NY 120A by the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Port Chester station</span> Metro-North Railroad station in New York

Port Chester station is a commuter rail station on the Metro-North Railroad New Haven Line, located in Port Chester, New York. The station is the northernmost station on the line in New York before crossing into Connecticut. The station has two high-level side platforms, each 10 cars long, serving the outer tracks of the four-track Northeast Corridor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Greenwich, Connecticut</span>

The history of Greenwich, Connecticut, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Byram River</span> River in New York, United States

The Byram River is a 13.9-mile (22.4 km) long river spanning southeast New York state and southwestern Connecticut in the United States. It has a 29-square-mile (75 km2) drainage basin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Ryan (53rd Congress)</span> American politician

William Ryan was an American banker and businessman who served one term as a U.S. Representative from New York from 1893 1895.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Cartoon Museum</span> American museum dedicated to cartoons, comic strips and animation

The National Cartoon Museum was an American museum dedicated to the collection, preservation and exhibition of cartoons, comic strips and animation. It was the brainchild of Mort Walker, creator of Beetle Bailey. The museum opened in 1974, and went through several name changes, relocations, and temporary closures, before finally closing for good in 2002.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pat's Hubba Hubba</span> Restaurant in Port Chester, New York, United States

Pat's Hubba Hubba, also known as "Hubba's", was a late-night greasy spoon chili restaurant located at 24 North Main Street in the village of Port Chester in Westchester County, New York. Near the New York-Connecticut border, Hubba's catered to the local bar scene by staying open until 5:00 am on the weekends, and at least 3:00 am on weeknights.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William E. Ward House</span> Historic house on Connecticut-New York state line in United States

The William E. Ward House, known locally as Ward's Castle, is located on Magnolia Drive, on the state line between Rye Brook, New York and Greenwich, Connecticut, United States. It is a reinforced concrete structure built in the 1870s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Japanese School of New York</span> Primary and middle school in Greenwich, Connecticut, United States

The Japanese School of New York, also known as The Greenwich Japanese School (GJS), is a Japanese elementary and junior high school, located in Riverside, Greenwich, Connecticut, near New York City.

Carmel Academy was a Jewish private school in Greenwich, Connecticut, serving grades Kindergarten through 8. Also including transitional Kindergarten The school originally was located in Port Chester, New York.

George Atwood Slater was an American lawyer and politician from New York.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">New York and Stamford Railway</span> Railway in New York, United States

The New York and Stamford Railway was a streetcar line that connected the Westchester County suburbs of New Rochelle, Larchmont, Mamaroneck, Harrison, Rye, and Port Chester, with the Connecticut suburbs of Greenwich and Stamford. The company was formed in 1901 when the New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad combined the Larchmont Horse Railway Company with the Port Chester Street Railroad Company. The Larchmont Horse Railway Company was founded in 1888 by the Larchmont Manor Company to construct a line from the New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad Larchmont train station to its development 1.2 miles from town. The line was rebuilt for electric operation and extended to Harrison in 1901. The Port Chester Street Railroad opened in 1898 serving Port Chester, New York. The trolley line was soon extended west through Rye to Harrison in 1901. The two companies were merged that summer to form the New York and Stamford Railway. Trackage rights over the Westchester Electric Railroad were obtained for access to New Rochelle.

References

  1. 1 2 Berger, Joseph (July 1, 1999). "25 Years Later, Disco Fire Haunts Its Survivors". New York Times. Retrieved July 7, 2013.
  2. 1 2 3 Teichgraeber, Kathleen (July 1, 1974). "24 die in blaze at Gulliver's; D.A. launches full-scale probe". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 12.
  3. blrggh, Super Elite KISS Fan (August 17, 2015). "Gulliver's Nightclub Picture". www.kissfaq.com. Retrieved January 31, 2024.
  4. "Fire crossed border?". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 1, 1974. p. 2.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Montgomery, Paul L. (July 1, 1974). "Terror-Stricken Throng Rushes for Narrow Stairway to Exit". New York Times.
  6. 1 2 Plunkett, R.B. Jr. (July 2, 1974). "Inspections late". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 14.
  7. 1 2 3 r/KISS, ballbering71 (June 30, 2022). "Throwback Thursday: (06/30/74) Eric Carr (far left in photo) survives the Gulliver's nightclub fire, but two members of his band, Creation, do not - details in comments". www.reddit.com. Retrieved January 31, 2024.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  8. 1 2 3 Kelly, Tom (July 1, 1974). "Fire in N.Y. Discotheque Fatal to 24 Persons". Unknown newspaper. Associated Press. Retrieved July 7, 2013.
  9. Stanton, Sydney; Bissel, Elaine (July 1, 1974). "Band warned of fire". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. p. 3.
  10. Stevenson, H.L. (July 1, 1974). "New York Suburban 'Disco' Fire Kills 24 Merrymakers". Unknown Newspaper. United Press International. Retrieved July 7, 2013.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Special, Robert Lindsey (July 2, 1974). "Site of 24 Deaths Lacked A Fire Detection System". www.nytimes.com. Retrieved January 31, 2024.
  12. 1 2 3 4 lugnut, 2,000 Man, baby! (July 13, 2006). "Eric Carr in 'The Encyclopedia of Dead Rock Stars'". www.KissFAQ.com. Retrieved January 31, 2024.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  13. Berger, Joseph (July 1, 1999). "25 Years Later, Disco Fire Haunts Its Survivors" . Retrieved September 6, 2019 via NYTimes.com.
  14. "Only teeth can tell ID". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 1, 1974. pp. 2B.
  15. 1 2 3 Greenhouse, Linda (July 3, 1974). "Inquiry Indicates Fire Fatal to 24 Started in Nursery". New York Times.
  16. 1 2 Moss, Brian (July 15, 1974). "N.Y., Conn. await report of surveyors". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. p. 1.
  17. Carmody, Deirdre (July 17, 1974). "Westchester to Charge Man With Murder in Bar Fire That Killed 24 on New York-Connecticut Border". New York Times.
  18. Moss, Brian (July 12, 1974). "Arson in Gulliver's tragedy?". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 12.
  19. "Leonard charged with murder". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 16, 1974. p. 1.
  20. 1 2 3 4 Moss, Brian (July 16, 1974). "Snarl in fire check?". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 10.
  21. "Greenwich Suspect Indicted in Deaths Of 24 at Gulliver's". New York Times. July 31, 1974.
  22. 1 2 "A Connecticut Man Gets 15-Year Term For Fire Killing 24". New York Times. July 17, 1975.
  23. Seigel, Max H. (July 20, 1977). "Appeals Court Upsets Conviction In Port Chester Fire Fatal to 24". New York Times.
  24. "Murder Guilt Ruled". The Spokesman-Review. Spokane, Washington. Associated Press. September 8, 1978. p. 12. Retrieved July 8, 2013.
  25. "Appeal Is Planned In Arson Murders". The New York Times. December 18, 1985. Retrieved July 8, 2013.
  26. 1 2 3 "Sentenced man to be freed". Record-Journal. Meriden, Connecticut. United Press International. April 10, 1986. p. 38. Retrieved July 8, 2013.
  27. 1 2 "Lawsuit looms in Gulliver's fire". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 6, 1974. p. 1.
  28. Moss, Brian (July 9, 1974). "Possible fire lawsuits spreading". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. p. 1.
  29. 1 2 3 Moss, Brian (July 10, 1974). "$12 million claim hits village". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 12.