Pickwick Club collapse

Last updated
Pickwick Club collapse
DateJuly 4, 1925
TimeAround 3:30 AM
LocationPickwick Club
6 Beach Street Boston United States
Coordinates 42°21′05″N71°03′43″W / 42.35139°N 71.06194°W / 42.35139; -71.06194
Deaths44
Accused12
ChargesManslaughter and maintaining a common nuisance
VerdictNot Guilty

The Pickwick Club collapse occurred in Boston, Massachusetts United States on July 4, 1925. It killed 44 people, making it the deadliest building collapse in Boston's history and the second deadliest accident in Boston (behind the Summer Street Bridge disaster) at that time. [1]

Contents

Background

The Pickwick Club was located in the former Hotel Dreyfus on Beach Street in downtown Boston. [2] The building was owned by the estate of Arthur R. Rosenthal and managed by Nathan Ginsburg. Ginsburg leased the property to the Schulte Company, which sublet it to Hyman Bloomberg who in turn sublet part of it to the Barry brothers, who ran the Pickwick Club. [3]

The Pickwick Club opened in December 1924 and was managed by Timothy and Daniel Barry. During its first months of operation, the club was located on the first floor, the site of the former Cafe Dreyfus. In March 1925 it moved to the second floor to make room for Greenwich Village Club, a cafe that closed after a couple of months. [4] The Pickwick Club closed for a couple of weeks following an April 13, 1925 fire that occurred in another part of the building. Fire Chief Daniel F. Sennott believed that the building was not badly damaged and building inspector James J. Hendrick declared the building to be safe. [3] [5]

Timothy Barry had connections to the city's political, newspaper, and legal circles, however the club instead attracted a seedy crowd and gained a reputation as a social center for members of the criminal underworld. The club attempted to remove the criminal element by only allowing those with membership cards to enter, however the management's leniency in issuing cards created the opposite effect. During its brief history, the club was the site of a stabbing and more than one liquor raid. Although there was reportedly liquor on the premises, there were no charges ever made against management. [4]

Collapse

On July 3, 1925, the club hosted about 200 patrons for a before-the-Fourth dance. [2] [6] The event was to last until 4 am the following day. Around 3:30 am there were about 50 to 60 couples dancing when the ceiling above the dance floor collapsed. [2] [6] After the ceiling fell, a wall collapsed and destroyed the entire interior of the building. Those who remained on the dance floor were then thrown down to the ground floor. Some patrons were able to escape through windows, down ladders raised by members of the Boston Fire Department, or through the next building. Members of the BFD and the Boston Police Department, as well as ambulances from the Boston City Hospital, Haymarket Relief Hospital, and the BPD quickly rushed to the scene. Emergency personnel reported that all but the first floor had collapsed and estimated that over forty people were trapped under debris. [2] All of the bodies were removed by 12:30 pm on July 6 and the death toll was established at 43. [7] On July 9, an additional victim died in the hospital, which brought the final death toll to 44. [8]

The grand jury investigation began on July 6, 1925. [9] After 70 hours of deliberation during which 86 witnesses were called, the grand jury indicted nine men for manslaughter, three for manslaughter and maintaining a common nuisance, and one for maintaining a common nuisance. [10] [11] Those indicted were:

All 12 defendants were tried together. Judge Henry T. Lummus presided over the trial. [12] Assistant district attorney George Alpert was the lead prosecutor. Joseph F. O'Connell, Daniel J. Gallagher, Francis Murray, Albert W. Hurwitz, John P. Feeney, Elisha Greenhood, Thomas N. Creed, and Charles Fay represented the defendants. [13]

Guy C. Emerson, an engineer asked by Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas C. O'Brien to investigate the cause of the collapse, testified that the building fell "due to a failure of the concrete piers under the foundation" and "due to a lack of lateral bracing on their easterly side". [14] The prosecution had a second engineer, John O. DeWolf, who concurred with Emerson's findings and stated that the lack of bracing to the wall caused the collapse. [15]

George Washington Goethals, an engineer best known for supervising the construction of the Panama Canal, testified for Hendrick. According to Goethals, the cause of the collapse was the failure of Pier 2 to support the load it was supposed to bear, calling it "the rottenest piece of concrete I ever saw". He contended that lateral bracing would not have prevented the collapse. [16] Edwin K. MacNutt, a chemist at the Watertown Arsenal, testified that analysis of the concrete in Pier 2 showed no bonding between the cement and gravel, which would render the pier unable to hold its load. This would in turn bring extra weight on the other piers and bring down the wall. [17]

On August 7, 1925, Judge Lummus ordered a directed verdict of not guilty for 10 of the 12 defendants. [18] The trial ended on August 12, 1925 and after a half-hour of deliberation, the two remaining defendants, Hendrick and Perkins, were found not guilty. Following the verdict, Lummus stated that he concurred with the jury and there never was sufficient evidence these defendants had been willfully, recklessly or wantonly negligent”. [19]

See also

Related Research Articles

Louise Woodward, born in 1978 (age 45–46), is a British former au pair, who at the age of 18 was charged with murder, but was subsequently convicted of the involuntary manslaughter of eight-month-old baby Matthew Eappen, in Newton, Massachusetts, United States of America.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tobin Bridge</span> Bridge between Boston and Chelsea, Massachusetts

The Maurice J. Tobin Memorial Bridge is a cantilever truss bridge that spans more than two miles (3.2 km) from Boston to Chelsea over the Mystic River in Massachusetts, United States. The bridge is the largest in New England. It is operated by the Massachusetts Department of Transportation and carries U.S. Route 1. It was built between 1948 and 1950 and opened to traffic on February 2, 1950, replacing the former Chelsea Bridge. The 36-foot (11 m)-wide roadway has three lanes of traffic on each of the two levels with northbound traffic on the lower level and southbound traffic on the upper level.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clevedon Pier</span> Grade I listed pier in North Somerset, UK

Clevedon Pier is a seaside pier in the town of Clevedon, Somerset, England on the east shore of the Severn Estuary. It was described by Sir John Betjeman, as "the most beautiful pier in England" and was designated a Grade I listed building in 2001.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Skyline Towers collapse</span> 1973 construction accident

On March 2, 1973, the 26-story Skyline Plaza condominium building, under construction in Bailey's Crossroads in Fairfax County, Virginia, collapsed, killing 14 construction workers and injuring 35 others.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Gordon Wells</span> American politician

Henry Gordon Wells was a lawyer and a Republican politician in Massachusetts and New Hampshire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Structural integrity and failure</span> Ability of a structure to support a designed structural load without breaking

Structural integrity and failure is an aspect of engineering that deals with the ability of a structure to support a designed structural load without breaking and includes the study of past structural failures in order to prevent failures in future designs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2013 Philadelphia building collapse</span> Building collapse in Philadelphia, United States of America

On June 5, 2013, a building undergoing demolition collapsed onto the neighboring Salvation Army Thrift Store at the southeast corner of 22nd and Market streets in Center City Philadelphia, trapping a number of people under the rubble. The store was open and full of shoppers and staff. Seven people died and fourteen others were injured in the incident.

Bad Elk v. United States, 177 U.S. 529 (1900), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that an individual had the right to use force to resist an unlawful arrest and was entitled to a jury instruction to that effect.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Mancovitz</span> American politician

David Mancovitz was an American attorney and politician from Boston, Massachusetts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ghost Ship warehouse fire</span> 2016 California underground warehouse party inferno

On December 2, 2016, at about 11:20 p.m. PST, a fire started in a former warehouse that had been unlawfully converted into an artist collective with living spaces in Oakland, California, which was hosting a concert with 80–100 attendees. The blaze killed 36 people, making it the deadliest fire in the history of Oakland. The building, located in the Fruitvale neighbourhood, was zoned for only industrial purposes; residential and entertainment uses were prohibited. It was also the deadliest building fire in the United States since The Station nightclub fire in 2003, the deadliest in California since the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and the deadliest mass-casualty event in Oakland since the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Daniel H. Coakley</span> American politician

Daniel Henry Coakley was an American Democratic politician and attorney from Massachusetts. He was a key figure in early 20th century Boston politics, as an ally to District Attorney Joseph C. Pelletier and as an on-again-off-again ally to Mayor James Michael Curley. As an attorney, Coakley took part in numerous badger game extortion schemes and was disbarred in 1922 for deceit, malpractice, and gross misconduct.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Garrett H. Byrne</span> American lawyer and politician

Garrett H. Byrne was an American lawyer and politician who served as District Attorney of Suffolk County, Massachusetts, from 1952 to 1979.

Hugh Anthony Cregg was an American lawyer and politician who served as District Attorney of Essex County, Massachusetts, from 1931 to 1959.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sherman L. Whipple</span> American attorney (1862–1930)

Sherman Leland Whipple was an American attorney who was one of Boston's leading trial lawyers during his lifetime.

Joseph A. Tomasello (1883–1936) was an American contractor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arcadia Hotel fire</span> 1913 hotel fire in Boston, Massachusetts

The Arcadia Hotel fire occurred on December 3, 1913 in a flophouse on the corner of Washington and Laconia Streets in Boston's South End. The fire killed 28 persons, making it the deadliest in Boston at that time, passing the Great Boston Fire of 1872.

The Beverly rooming house fire took place at the Elliott Chambers, a low-rent rooming house in Beverly, Massachusetts, on July 4, 1984. Prosecutors alleged that the fire was set by a man whose ex-girlfriend dated someone who lived in the building, eventually convicting James Carver of second-degree murder and arson. It was the deadliest arson fire in Massachusetts, the deadliest fire in the state since the Cocoanut Grove fire in 1942, and the deadliest fire in Beverly's history. Carver maintains his innocence and hearings for a retrial were conducted in April 2024.

The Amsden Building collapse occurred on July 23, 1906, in Framingham, Massachusetts. 12 people were killed when the building, which was under construction, suddenly collapsed. A thirteenth person later died from injuries suffered in the accident. The building's contractor and architect were indicted for manslaughter, but the charges were later dropped by the district attorney.

The Preble Box Toe Company explosion occurred on November 8, 1928, at the company's factory in Lynn, Massachusetts. Eleven people died in the blast and resulting fires and another nine later died from their injuries, making it the deadliest explosion to occur in Greater Boston.

Winfield Scott Peters was an American lawyer and politician who served as District Attorney of Essex County, Massachusetts from 1899 to 1911.

References

  1. ↑ "Is Next to Largest Disaster in History of Greater Boston". The Boston Daily Globe. July 6, 1925.
  2. 1 2 3 4 "Hundreds May Be Dead in Pickwick Club Crash". The Boston Daily Globe. July 4, 1925.
  3. 1 2 "Pickwick Trial Moves Slowly". The Boston Daily Globe. July 23, 1925.
  4. 1 2 Harris, Henry W. (July 5, 1925). "Pickwick Club Lure Lay in Its Mystery". The Boston Daily Globe.
  5. ↑ "Pickwick Club Declared Safe". The Boston Daily Globe. July 29, 1925.
  6. 1 2 Sibley, Frank P. (July 5, 1925). "12 Bodies Taken From Pickwick Club Ruins as Searchers Place Toll of Death at 40". The Boston Daily Globe.
  7. ↑ "Identification of All But Two". The Boston Daily Globe. July 6, 1925.
  8. ↑ "Disaster Probe Again Delayed". The Boston Daily Globe. July 10, 1925.
  9. ↑ "Grand Jury Probe Begins". The Boston Daily Globe. July 6, 1925.
  10. ↑ "Trial of Pickwick Club Case Opens in Suffolk Superior Court". The Lowell Sun. July 23, 1925.
  11. ↑ "Seven Pickwick Case Jurors Chosen This Afternoon". The Boston Daily Globe. July 20, 1925.
  12. ↑ "To Try Pickwick Men Together". The Boston Daily Globe. July 17, 1925.
  13. ↑ "Jury to get All Collapse Cases". The Boston Daily Globe. July 16, 1925.
  14. ↑ "Grand Jury Probe Begins". The Boston Daily Globe. July 6, 1925.
  15. ↑ "Second Expert Supports First". The Boston Daily Globe. August 6, 1925.
  16. ↑ "Goethals Blames Pier for Pickwick Collapse". The Boston Daily Globe. August 11, 1925.
  17. ↑ "Complete Testimony in Pickwick Club Case". The Boston Daily Globe. August 12, 1925.
  18. ↑ "10 Freed in Boston Crash". The New York Times. August 8, 1925.
  19. ↑ ""Not Guilty" Says Pickwick Jury". The Boston Daily Globe. August 13, 1925.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.