Hafez al-Assad's cult of personality

Last updated

Portrait of Assad raising the Syrian flag over Quneitra in 1974. Around him is a joyful crowd of Syrian citizens with flowers and smiles. Syrian propaganda image that is part of the personality cult of Hafez al-Assad.webp
Portrait of Assad raising the Syrian flag over Quneitra in 1974. Around him is a joyful crowd of Syrian citizens with flowers and smiles.

Hafez al-Assad's cult of personality was developed to incredible proportions. Numerous portraits, frescoes, images on money and statues of the dictator Assad, who ruled Ba'athist Syria from 1970 to 2000, could be seen everywhere. The Assad regime had complete control over all mass media and all spheres of life in Syria, effectively spreading its cult of personality. Although Assad was not a Stalinist, he built a personality cult on the Stalinist model. [1] [2] [3]

Contents

Coming to power and first actions

Syrian army general Hafez al-Assad came to power in 1970 after a successful and bloodless coup against the regime of Salah Jadid, Syria's first neo-Ba'athist leader. According to Patrick Seale, Assad's rule "began with an immediate and considerable advantage: the government he displaced was so detested that any alternative came as a relief". [4] He first tried to establish national unity, which he felt had been lost under the leadership of Michel Aflaq and Salah Jadid. [5] Assad differed from his predecessor at the outset, visiting local villages and hearing citizen complaints. [5] The Syrian people felt that Assad's rise to power would lead to change; [6] one of his first acts as ruler was to visit Sultan al-Atrash, father of the Aflaqite Ba'athist Mansur al-Atrash, to honor his efforts during the Great Arab Revolution. [5] He made overtures to the Writers' Union, rehabilitating those who had been forced underground, jailed or sent into exile for representing what radical neo-Ba'athists called the reactionary classes. [5] Although Assad did not democratize the country, he eased the government's repressive policies. [7]

But in the 1980s, after a recent Muslim Brotherhood uprising (which had been brutally suppressed), his regime hardened: Assad resumed its version of militaristic Leninism, repealing liberalization introduced when Assad came to power. [8] These years were characterized by an even greater expansion of Assad's personality cult.

Creation and ideas of the cult of personality

Ideas of the personality cult

Anti Camp-David agreement demonstration in Yousef al-Azm square in Damascus. The huge portrait of Assad catches the eye. Anti Kamp-David agreement demonstration in Damascus, Syria.jpg
Anti Camp-David agreement demonstration in Yousef al-Azm square in Damascus. The huge portrait of Assad catches the eye.

Assad began an intense consolidation of power (known as Assadization), and part of this included the formation of a personality cult, so he was able to quickly develope a state-sponsored cult of personality in order to maintain power. Because he wanted to become an Arab leader, he often represented himself as a successor to Egypt's Gamal Abdel Nasser, having risen to power in November 1970, a few weeks after Nasser's death. He modelled his presidential system on Nasser's, hailed Nasser for his pan-Arabic leadership, and in public he displayed photographs of Nasser alongside posters of himself. [9] Assad also demonstrated his admiration for Salah ad-Din, a Muslim Kurdish leader who in the 12th century unified the Muslim East and defeating the Crusaders in 1187 and subsequently conquered Jerusalem. Assad displayed a large painting of Salah ad-Din's tomb in Damascus in his office and issued a currency bill featuring Salah ad-Din. In his speeches and conversations, Assad frequently hailed Salah ad-Din's successes and his victory over the Crusaders while equating Israel with the Kingdom of Jerusalem, the Crusaders' state. [10]

Assad developed a Stalinist-style personality cult around him; which depicted him as the father figure of Syrian nation. Ba'ath party loyalists designated him as "Al-Abad"; an Arabic terminology with deep religious dimensions. Linguistically, ''Al-Abad'' means "forever, infinite and immortality" and religious clerics use this term in relation to Divine Attributes. By designating Assad as "Al-Abad", Syrian Ba'ath Movement ideologically elevated Hafez al-Assad as its "Immortal", "god-like figure" who is supposed to represent the state as well as the Syrian nation itself. Another meaning of Al-Abad is "permanent", which is used in state propaganda to denote the perpetual status quo of an "eternal political order" created by Hafez al-Assad, who continues to live in Assadist ideology. [11] Arab Socialist Ba'ath party initially manufactured Hafez al-Assad's cult of Arab socialist heroism in consultancy with Soviet state propagandists, mimicking the pervasive personality cults prevalent across Soviet Bloc dictatorships like Communist Romania and North Korea. [12] [13]

Hafez Assad, "the father of the nation". Hafez Assad during military ceremony in Syria.jpg
Hafez Assad, "the father of the nation".

Beginning as a tool to bind every Syrian citizen with the obligation of undying loyalty (bay'ah) to Assad in 1970s, the propaganda was further intensified and personalist depictions reached new heights during the 1980s. Often, to prove their loyalty, ballots in presidential elections were demonstratively marked with blood. Also, on referendum days, solemn marches and celebrations with partisan songs and dances took place all over Syria all day long. [14] The personality cult portrayed Assad as a farmer, a worker surrounded and loved by children, a humble party worker, and especially often a strong military leader. [14] The state began re-writing Syrian history itself, with the Ba'ath party deifying Hafez al-Assad as their "leader for eternity" ["qa'iduna ila l-abad"] and portraying him as "the second Saladin" who guarantees Arab peoples victory over Zionist Crusaders. Through kindergarten, school books, educational institutions and Baathist media; Assadist propaganda constructed the image of a homogenous Arab nation protected by a fatherly leader revelling under the "cult of Saladin". Assad regime venerates Hafez al-Assad's personalist iconography perpetually in the public and private spheres of everyday Syrian life. [15] [16] After Hafez's death, the personality cult was extended to his son, Bashar al-Assad. Monuments, pictures, statues, symbols and billboards of both the leaders extensively pervade Syrian society, designed to consolidate the notion of "Assad's Syria". Observers view the state propaganda efforts as a strategy for securing the compliance of the masses and identifying Syrian nationhood with the Assad dynasty. [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] In addition to Assad's ambition to turn Syria into a regional power and to himself become a pan-Arab leader, Assad calculated that working for Arab unity and stepping up the struggle against Israel were likely to strengthen his legitimacy and leadership among the various sections of the Syrian population. [22] Ba'athist propaganda portrayed Hafez al-Assad as a strong leader whose wisdom was "beyond the comprehension of the average citizen." [23] Syrian state propaganda also cast Assadism (state ideology since 1970, based on the ideas and thinking of Hafez Assad) as a neo-Ba'athist current that evolved Ba'athist ideology with the needs of the modern era. [24] The cult of personality portrayed Assad as a defender of the Palestinians against Israel, as a strong military leader, as a wise, modest and just leader of the country.

A standard Syrian school notebook in the 1980s. It have images of the president Assad and the emblem of the ruling Ba'ath party. A standard Syrian school notebook in the 1980s.jpg
A standard Syrian school notebook in the 1980s. It have images of the president Assad and the emblem of the ruling Ba'ath party.

Portraits of Assad, often depicting him engaging in heroic activities, were placed in public spaces. He named numerous places and institutions after himself and members of his family. In schools, children were taught to sing songs of adulation about Hafez al-Assad. Teachers began each lesson with the song "Our eternal leader, Hafez al-Assad". [25] Assad was sometimes portrayed with apparently divine properties. Sculptures and portraits depicted him alongside the prophet Mohammad, and after his mother's death, the government produced portraits of her surrounded by a halo. Syrian officials were made to refer to him as 'the sanctified one' (al-Muqaddas). [25] This strategy was also pursued by Assad's son and next dictator, Bashar al-Assad. [26] Hafez named myriad numbers of places and institutions in Syria after himself and other members of his family, such as Lake Assad, an artificial reservoir filled during his time in office. School students were taught Ba'athism and Assadist ideas through a course known as "Political Arab Sociology". [27] Propaganda and the cult of personality of Assad were also promoted through Ba'athist youth organizations such as the Revolutionary Youth Union or RYU (membership in which was mandatory). Since Hafez al-Assad's seizure of power in 1970; state propaganda has promoted a new national discourse based on unifying Syrians under "a single imagined Ba'athist identity" and Assadism. [28] Fervently loyalist paramilitaries known as the Shabiha (tr. ghosts) deify the Assad dynasty through slogans such as There is no God except Bashar! (Arabic: لا إله الا بشار) and pursue psychological warfare against non-conformist populations. Many books have been written in praise of Hafez al-Assad. [29]

Middle East Insight magazine says: "In no other country in recent memory ... not Mao's China, nor Tito's Yugoslavia, has the intensity of the personality cult reached such extremes. Asad's image, speaking, smiling, listening, benevolent or stern, solemn or reflective, is everywhere. Sometimes there are half a dozen pictures of him in a row. His face envelops telephone poles and trucks, churches and mosques. His is the visage a Syrian sees when he opens his newspaper." [30] [31]

Soldiers carry the portrait of the Assad during a parade. Soldiers carry the portrait of Syrian president Hafez Assad during a military parade (2).jpg
Soldiers carry the portrait of the Assad during a parade.

Outside of Syria

Assad also had his supporters and something of a personality cult outside Syria, most notably in neighboring Lebanon. [32] From 1976 to 2005, the Syrian Arab Army was able to occupy much of Lebanon, where soldiers hung portraits of Assad and helped Lebanese citizens do the same. And it wasn’t just portraits: in territory controlled by Syria and its ally Hezbollah, there were also huge billboards with portraits of Assad. [33] Hezbollah, for its part, depicted Assad on its propaganda posters next to the organization’s longtime leader, Hassan Nasrallah, showing the two men’s long-standing partnership.

The influence of historical events

Yom Kippur war

The Yom Kippur War has been a very important component in Government propaganda and the personality cult of Hafez Assad.

In October 6, 1973, Syria, along with Egypt (led by Anwar Sadat), went to war against Israel. Initially, the two Arab armies made significant gains on both fronts, but later, in the face of vastly superior Israeli forces, lack of coordination, and severe misunderstandings with Egypt, Syria lost its military gains, while Israel advanced deeper into Syria, to the Bashan salient.

Another portrait of iconic moment of Assad raising Syrian flag over Quneitra. Hafez al-Assad raising flag over Quneitra at June 26, 1974 (colorized photo).jpg
Another portrait of iconic moment of Assad raising Syrian flag over Quneitra.

The main reason for the reversal of fortune was Egypt's operational pause from 7 to 14 October. [34] After capturing parts of the Sinai, the Egyptian campaign halted and the Syrians were left fighting the Israelis alone. [35] The Egyptian leaders, believing their war aims accomplished, dug in. [36] While their early successes in the war had surprised them, War Minister General Ahmad Ismail Ali advised caution. [36] In Syria, Assad and his generals waited for the Egyptians to move. [36] When the Israeli government learned of Egypt's modest war strategy, it ordered an "immediate continuous action" against the Syrian military. [36] According to Patrick Seale, "For three days, 7, 8, and 9 October, Syrian troops on the Golan faced the full fury of the Israeli air force as, from first light to nightfall, wave after wave of aircraft swooped down to bomb, strafe and napalm their tank concentration and their fuel and ammunition carriers right back to the Purple Line." [37]

However, unlike in the Six-Day War, the Syrian Arab Army was not routed. While Egypt withdrew from the war by signing unilateral agreements with Israel, Assad continued a war of attrition against Israel, inflicting losses on it and blocking the possibility of increasing Israeli gains. Assad's skill as a cool, proud, tough, and shrewd negotiator in the post war period enabled him to gain the town of Kuneitra and the respect and admiration of many Arabs. Assad signed a disengagement agreement with Israel only in May 1974, emerging from the war as a resilient and strong player. In June, 26, Assad raised the Syrian flag in a grand and public manner over Kuneitra, which he had received after the war, and which became an important symbol of the personality cult. [38] Propaganda and cult of personality portrayed this war as a clear victory for Assad. Many of his followers now regarded Assad as the new pan-Arab leader, and a worthy successor of Nasser. [39]

Collapse of the Eastern bloc

When the communist governments in the Eastern Bloc collapsed, an ideological crisis within the government arose. [40] However, Assad and his supporters hit back, stating that because of the "Corrective Movement under the leadership of the warrior Hafez al-Assad", the principles of economic and political pluralism, which had been introduced "some two decades" beforehand, safeguarded the Syrian government from the possibility of collapse. [41]

Cult after Hafez death

The cult of personality continued to exist even after Hafez al-Assad's death in 2000, when his son, Bashar al-Assad, came to power. After Hafez's death, 40 days of mourning were declared in Syria, as well as outside Syria, in a number of Arab countries: Lebanon (7 days), Egypt, Jordan, Oman, Palestine, Libya, Iran, Morocco, United Arab Emirates, Yemen, Kuwait and Qatar (all of them 3 days of mourning). [42] [43] [44] [45] Syria also saw mass demonstrations in memory of Hafez and in support of Bashar al-Assad.

Bashar al-Assad portrait Portrait of the Syrian president Bashar al-Assad.jpg
Bashar al-Assad portrait

Bashar continued the cult of his father, whose portraits and statues remained hanging everywhere, but they were also joined by portraits of Bashar himself. As a result, the cult of personality as such continued to exist, albeit without its leader. Bashar continued this tradition and began to appear in numerous portraits himself, sometimes next to his father or older brother, Bassel. In general, Bashar did not introduce anything radically new, doing the same things for his cult as his father. However, Bashar did not want to be feared (as his father was feared), but respected and admired, so he created the image of a modest reformer. His associates even gave him a new title: "hope." [46] To be admired, Bashar sought to appear modest and impressive at the same time. Rumors about his work ethic, love of technology and modest behavior, his love of modernity, posters that magically appeared against his will - all this was actively promoted by propaganda. [46] However, the desire to build such an image did not force Bashar to abandon the military dictatorship regime inherited from his father - the state continued to carry out mass repressions against people who deviated even slightly from the predetermined line or proposed undesirable changes. [46]

Bashar's personality cult gained momentum after the Cedar Revolution in Lebanon in 2005, which led to the forced withdrawal of all Syrian troops from the country. [46] Propaganda songs were composed in honor of Bashar al-Assad. [47] Bashar's portrait was sometimes even painted onto the national flag, [48] [49] and some tanks had a stencil of Bashar's face (sometimes Hafez's) on their night vision lights. Soldiers demonstrated their loyalty at parades, holding numerous portraits of the two Assads and shouting slogans ("With our souls, with our blood, we sacrifice ourselves for you, Bashar!" [50] [51] [52] , "God, Syria, and Bashar!" [53] and others). [54] [55] [56] However, similar phenomena also occurred during his father's rule. [57]

End of the cult

The end of the personality cult coincided with the end of the Assad regime. From late November to December 7, 2024, Syrian opposition forces carried out a large-scale military operation against Assad's forces, very quickly pushing it out of almost all major cities and ultimately capturing the capital Damascus.

Syrians with opposition flag on the tank, abandoned by SAAF in Damascus. Syrians standing on the tank, abandoned by Assad's forces, December of 2024.jpg
Syrians with opposition flag on the tank, abandoned by SAAF in Damascus.

After the fall of the regime, an event called "De-Assadization" emerged [58] - the mass destruction of any symbols of the Assad regime, especially statues and portraits. The new transitional government led by opposition forces also began operations against former members of the Assad government or others who fell under suspicion, in the western parts of the country, historically populated by Alawites - the main popular support of the Assad regime. Demands for revenge from the Sunni majority were increasingly heard. [59] Transitional government conducted a mass murders of alawites as an revenge for 50 years of rule by the Alawite minority, which led to increased support of the Assad loyalists and formation of more alawite militias. [60] After the fall of the regime, former members of the Assad's army and Alawites began an armed insurgency, attacking the troops of the transitional government, and witnessed anti-Alawite massacres.

See also

References

  1. Phillips, Christopher (2013). Everyday Arab Identity: The Daily Reproduction of the Arab World. Routledge. ISBN   978-0-415-68488-0.
  2. Beaumont, Justin (2018-10-26). The Routledge Handbook of Postsecularity. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-315-30781-7.
  3. Ḥen, Hili Mudriḳ-Even; Boms, Nir T.; Ashraph, Sareta (2020-01-09). The Syrian War: Between Justice and Political Reality. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-1-108-48780-1.
  4. Seale, Patrick (1995). Asad of Syria: the struggle for the Middle East (1. paperback print., rev ed.). Berkeley, Calif.: Univ. of California Press. ISBN   978-0-520-06976-3.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Seale 1990, p. 170.
  6. Seale 1990, p. 190.
  7. Seale 1990, p. 171.
  8. Hinnebusch 2001, p. 98.
  9. Reich 1990, p. 57.
  10. Reich 1990, pp. 57–58.
  11. Bader Eddin, Eylaf (8 November 2022). "Al-Abad: On the Ongoing". Middle East Journal of Culture and Communication. 15 (4): 367–372. doi: 10.1163/18739865-01504004 . S2CID   253455744.
  12. Coughlin, Con (2023-06-22). Assad: The Triumph of Tyranny. Pan Macmillan. ISBN   978-1-5290-7490-1.
  13. Dagher, Sam (2019-05-28). Assad or We Burn the Country: How One Family's Lust for Power Destroyed Syria. Little, Brown. ISBN   978-0-316-55670-5.
  14. 1 2 Mahfoud, Nawara; Halasa, Malu; Omareen, Zaher (2014-06-16). Syria Speaks: Art and Culture from the Frontline. Saqi. ISBN   978-0-86356-792-6.
  15. Gruber, Christiane; Haugbolle, Sune (2013). "3: Memory and Ideology: Images of Saladin in Syria and Iraq". Visual Culture in the Modern Middle East: Rhetoric of the Image. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press. pp. 57–75. ISBN   978-0-253-00884-8.
  16. Sayfo, Omar (15 February 2017). "From Kurdish Sultan to Pan-Arab Champion and Muslim Hero: The Evolution of the Saladin Myth in Popular Arab Culture". The Journal of Popular Culture. 50 (1): 65–83. doi:10.1111/jpcu.12503. hdl: 1874/361826 via Wiley Online Library.
  17. L. Stanton, Andrea (2012). "Al-Assad, Hafez". Cultural Sociology of the Middle East, Asia, and Africa: An Encyclopedia. California: Sage. pp. 233–235. ISBN   978-1-4129-8176-7.
  18. A. Reilly, James (2018). "7: Thirty Years of Hafez Al-Assad". Fragile Nation, Shattered Land: The Modern History of Syria. London: I.B. Tauris. pp. 160–162, 169. ISBN   978-1-78453-961-0.
  19. Bonsen, Sabrina (2019). "2: Theoretical Framework, State of Research and Method". Martyr Cults and Political Identities in Lebanon. Muhlacker, Germany: Springer. p. 9. ISBN   978-3-658-28097-0.
  20. Suzanne Kassab, Elizabeth (2019). "3: Tanwir Debates in Syria in the 1990s". Enlightenment on the Eve of Revolution: The Egyptian and Syrian Debates. Columbia University Press. pp. 172–173. ISBN   9780231549677.
  21. Pipes, Daniel (1995). "1: Assad's Post-Soviet Predicament". Syria Beyond the Peace Process. Washington Institute for Near East Policy. pp. 6, 7. ISBN   0-944029-64-7.
  22. Reich 1990, pp. 56–57.
  23. Kheir, Karen Abul (2010). Korany, Bahgat; Hilāl, ʻAlī al-Dīn (eds.). The Foreign Policies of Arab states: The Challenge of Globalization. An AUC Forum for International Affairs edition. The American University in Cairo Press. p. 423. ISBN   978-977-416-360-9.
  24. Dam, Nikolaos van (2011). 10: Conclusions: The struggle for power in Syria: politics and society under Asad and the Ba'th Party (4 ed.). London: I. B. Tauris. ISBN   978-1-84885-760-5.
  25. 1 2 Pipes, Daniel (1996). Syria beyond the peace process. Policy Papers. Washington, DC: Washington Institute for Near East Policy. ISBN   978-0-944029-64-0.
  26. Zisser 2006, p. 50.
  27. "المنهاج السوري الحديث: تعلّم الماركسية في 45 دقيقة". Al-Akhbar (in Arabic). 26 February 2014. Retrieved 29 December 2017.
  28. Carlos BC, Juan (9 December 2021). "The Assad Family Has Been Shaping Syria for 50 Years". Fair Observer. Archived from the original on 9 December 2021.
  29. Eddin, Eylaf Bader (2023-11-20). Translating the Language of the Syrian Revolution (2011/12). Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co KG. ISBN   978-3-11-076769-8.
  30. "Middle East Insight". Middle East Insight . 4. International Insight, Incorporated. 1985.
  31. Maʿoz, Mosheh; Asad Hafis (1988). Asad: the sphinx of Damascus; a political biography. New York: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. ISBN   978-1-55584-062-4.
  32. الدهيبي, جنى. "من حافظ إلى بشار الأسد.. هكذا سقط النظام السوري في لبنان أيضا". الجزيرة نت (in Arabic). Retrieved 2025-07-07.
  33. AP Archive (2015-07-21). "Youtube - LEBANON: SYRIAN LEADER ASSAD MOURNED" . Retrieved 2025-07-07.
  34. Seale 1990, p. 205.
  35. Seale 1990, p. 207.
  36. 1 2 3 4 Seale 1990, p. 208.
  37. Seale 1990, p. 209.
  38. "SYRIA: PRESIDENT ASSAD RAISES THE SYRIAN FLAG OVER KUNEITRA". British Pathé. Retrieved 2025-03-30.
  39. Reich, Bernard, ed. (1990). Political leaders of the contemporary Middle East and North Africa: a biographical dictionary. New York: Greenwood Press. ISBN   978-0-313-26213-5.
  40. Ziser, Eyal (2001). Asad's legacy: Syria in transition. London: C. Hurst. ISBN   978-1-85065-445-2.
  41. Zisser 2001, p. 47.
  42. "Bashar Al_Assad – THE FUNERAL OF PRESIDENT HAFEZ ASSAD". Archived from the original on 6 October 2014.
  43. "Kuna :: Egypt Mourns the Death of Al-Assad 10/06/2000".
  44. Sachs, Susan (11 June 2000). "TRANSITION IN SYRIA; Apprehension and Hope for Stability in Mideast". The New York Times.
  45. "CNN Transcript – Special Event: The Death of Hafez Al-Assad – June 10, 2000". Archived from the original on 8 April 2022. Retrieved 6 May 2022.
  46. 1 2 3 4 "20 years ago today, Bashar Assad inherited Syria". Rime Allaf. Retrieved 2025-07-07.
  47. Carl M. Bellman (2017-11-11). "God, Syria and Bashar!". Youtube. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  48. Joshua Keating (2013-09-13). "Does the U.S. Recognize Assad as Legitimate Now? Did it Ever Not?". Slate. ISSN   1091-2339.
  49. "Syrian army establishes full control over Handarat Camp in Aleppo". Mehr News Agency. 2016-09-24. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  50. AFP. "Syrian president slams US sanctions in speech to parliament". The Times of Israel . ISSN   0040-7909 . Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  51. "Inside the Alaa M. Trial #81: "We Sacrifice Ourselves With Our Blood And Soul, O Bashar"". Syria Justice & Accountability Centre. 2024-08-14. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  52. "Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad: The World Has a Problem with Pan-Arabism and Islam; Israel Assassinated Yasser Arafat". MEMRI. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  53. "President Assad makes first public address on unrest". France 24. 2011-03-30. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  54. admin (2018-03-09). "Units of Syrian Arab Army celebrates the March 8th Revolution". Syrian Arab News Agency. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  55. "Three-phase plan to discharge soldiers in Syria". Enab Baladi. 2024-06-27. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  56. "What's new in Syrian regime's administrative order on military service". Enab Baladi. 2024-06-11. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  57. Aldoughli, Rahaf (2017-12-13). "Syrian nationalism is all about masculinity". The Conversation. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  58. Beeri, Tal (2024-12-30). "Southern Syria – Prominent Figures in the Rebel Leadership". Alma Research and Education Center. Retrieved 2025-04-14.
  59. Fahim, Kareem; Zakaria, Zakaria; Bisset, Victoria; Ledur, Júlia; Shapiro, Leslie; Klimentov, Mikhail; Loveluck, Louisa; Kelly, Meg; Piper, Imogen (2025-01-01). "Alawites live in fear as Syrian rebels hunt members of Assad's regime". The Washington Post. ISSN   0190-8286 . Retrieved 2025-04-14.
  60. "Analysis: Continued chaos in Syria: Iraqi militias and an Alawite insurgency - FDD's Long War Journal". 2025-01-30. Archived from the original on 30 January 2025. Retrieved 2025-04-14.

Sources