Homeless encampment sweeps

Last updated
Homeless encampment sweep in Washington, D.C. National Park Service Eviction of Homeless Tents Encampments, Washington DC 09.jpg
Homeless encampment sweep in Washington, D.C.

A homeless encampment sweep is the forced removal of homeless people and their property from a public area. It is a frequently-used strategy to mitigate issues related to homelessness. [1] Often called "encampment resolutions" or "clean-ups" by local governments, they are alternatively labeled "sweeps" by advocacy groups. [2] The term's use ranges from referring to routine sanitation cleanups, which displace homeless residents for a few hours, to the permanent dislocation of individuals or communities. [3]

Contents

In recent years, the number of encampments swept across the United States has soared in response to public and political pressures. [4] The strategy is highly controversial among groups who work with homeless communities, who argue that sweeps are inhumane, ineffective, and sever crucial connections to care. [5]

Justifications

Homeless encampments are often cited as hazardous to public health and safety. They can also harm nearby business interests. [6]

Many cities allow for encampment sweeps only in conjunction with a patchwork of services. Leading with offers of shelter is a consistent policy among outreach workers in many major U.S. cities, including San Francisco. However, in San Francisco in 2023, 64% of encampment residents declined offers of shelter, while the year saw only a 22% increase in people connected to shelter. [7] The high rate of shelter refusal could have a number of causes. In a survey conducted by the Los Angeles Times, a high percentage of homeless people said that they would accept housing offers, but fewer than 20% would accept a shelter offer in the same large room as others. They cited privacy, safety, cleanliness, and conflicts with staff as key justifications for rejecting this kind of shelter offer. [3]

Supporters of sweeping argue that residents are often given adequate notice to safely move along with their possessions in tow. In California, for instance, state agencies are required to warn residents at least 48 hours in advance, and store their belongings for at least 60 days. They are also instructed to coordinate with local service providers. These requirements can be overridden only in instances where the encampment poses an "imminent threat" to life, health, safety, or infrastructure. [5]

Effectiveness

Homeless encampment sweeps have contested effectiveness at mitigating the impacts of homelessness in communities. While they remove encampments from their immediate surroundings, often in response to crime complaints, research has shown that complaints remain at the same level 30 days after a sweep. [8]

In a Los Angeles Times survey, respondents said that more than half of sweeps involved police contact, and only 15% involved a non-police homelessness outreach worker. [3] Most respondents were moved more than once over the six-month course of the survey. As the critical finding of the study, the same percentage of people who received housing (9% of respondents) were ticketed by the police after a sweep. [3] Citations and tickets which complement sweeps can be a severe economic burden for residents who are otherwise struggling financially, which can contribute to future struggles with homelessness. [9]

Use in recent history

In the past three decades, American cities have increasingly turned to "quality of life" laws to maintain public order among different urban populations. [9] These laws generally criminalize the use of public spaces to sit, sleep, beg, or store personal items. Noteworthy laws that prohibit behaviors related to homelessness include Los Angeles' 41.18, Houston's Charitable Feeding Ordinance, and the City of Grants Pass' prohibition "from using a blanket, pillow, or cardboard box for protection from the elements." [10] [11]

These quality of life ordinances often constitute the criminalization of homelessness as defined by the National Coalition for the Homeless, which "prohibit life-sustaining activities such as sleeping/camping, eating, sitting, and/or asking for money/resources in public spaces." [12]

In San Francisco, whose robust homeless population is commonly attributed to the California housing shortage, quality of life offenses are first subject to fines, then, if repeated or left unaddressed, misdemeanor charges. [13] Researchers like UCLA sociologist Chris Herring argue that the financial charges associated with encampment sweeping compound economic burdens for homeless people, while merely "shuffling" them across space. [9]

During the COVID-19 pandemic

The use of encampment sweeps by municipal governments has spiked precipitously since the COVID-19 pandemic, correlating with surges in homelessness across U.S. cities. Researchers have linked the increase in homelessness with the persistent national housing shortage, rent hikes, and the conclusion of pandemic government relief programs. [14]

Several U.S. cities continued encampment sweeps during the COVID-19 pandemic despite CDC guidelines, which advised cities to let homeless residents shelter-in-place until individual housing units were available. Causing homeless residents to disperse would only disrupt relationships with healthcare providers and increase the likelihood of outbreak, said the agency in 2020. [15] While some were only temporarily displaced for cleaning, like residents in Denver, others returned to find their tent sites bulldozed or replaced with permanent landscaping. [15]

Since Grants Pass v. Johnson

In California, the largest state with the highest number of homeless people, aggressive moves to sweep major cities have followed the Grants Pass ruling. [16] On July 25, 2024, Governor Gavin Newsom released an executive order directing "state agencies to move urgently to address dangerous encampments." [17] In response, mayors in San Jose, San Francisco, and San Diego lauded Newsom for his call to action. [18] As San Francisco's Mayor London Breed told reporters, beginning in August 2024, the city was "going to make them so uncomfortable on the streets of San Francisco that they have to take our offer." She intensified, "We will be using law enforcement to cite, and those citations can get progressive and can lead to a misdemeanor." [19]

The mayoral responses in many cities follow a public interest in addressing homelessness. Business owners and Republicans also supported Newsom's order. [18]

Confiscation of belongings

Encampment sweeps often involve the confiscation or destruction of personal belongings. Many cities have created facilities to store possessions taken during encampment sweeps. However, unhoused residents have often reported that encampment clearing crews have broad discretion over which objects are stored versus being thrown away. [20]

Commonly taken possessions include tents, sleeping bags, food items, and medical supplies. Government identification documents are commonly taken as well, though many cities require that workers store it. Nonetheless, service workers often discuss difficulties coordinating food and health benefits with homeless clients whose identification was confiscated in a sweep. [20]

Impacts on physical, social, and mental well-being

Disruptions to medical care

Sweeps can lead to the confiscation of medications and medical devices critical for physical safety. In one instance in Sacramento, Greg Adams experienced a seizure and subsequent head injury after losing his seizure medication to a sweep crew. In Little Rock, a man called Steven, whose experience with frostbite led to the amputation of his feet, had all his belongings confiscated in a sweep. He got frostbite again shortly after. [20]

Confiscated medical devices logged in storage facility records include: an oxygen tank, one dose of Narcan, 4 packages of diapers, a motor wheelchair, five COVID tests, and a blood sugar monitor. [20]

Sweeps are also argued to disrupt connections to care, contributing to increased drug overdoses and deaths. [8]

Heightened mortality

In one study performed at the University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus and in coordination with the National Health Care for the Homeless Council, the CDC, and the CDC Foundation, a simulation model was developed predicting health effects of consistent sweeps on a drug-injecting population over ten years. The model drew from data in 23 U.S. cities. [21]

Modeling the outcomes of consistent sweeping versus no sweeping, the study found that encampment sweeps could contribute to a 15-25% increase in deaths over ten years. In hundreds of simulations, the study found no scenario in which consistent sweeps had a neutral or positive impact on the health outcomes of the studied population.

Compromised trust

Service providers such as Kevin Lindamood, CEO of Baltimore's Health Care for the Homeless, believe that sweeps harmfully undermine trust in service providers. [8] If present, they can be accused of being complicit, whereas if absent, they can be seen as failing to adequately support their clients.

Encampment residents who have experienced sweeps may have decreased trust in the police, resulting in the avoidance of calling 911 in emergencies. The mistrust of law enforcement can contribute to both a physical vulnerability to violence, as well as a psychological feeling of insecurity. [8]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gavin Newsom</span> Governor of California since 2019

Gavin Christopher Newsom is an American politician and businessman serving since 2019 as the 40th governor of California. A member of the Democratic Party, he served as the 49th lieutenant governor of California from 2011 to 2019 and the 42nd mayor of San Francisco from 2004 to 2011.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Homeless shelter</span> Service agency that provides temporary residence for homeless people

Homeless shelters are a type of service that provides temporary residence for homeless individuals and families. Shelters exist to provide residents with safety and protection from exposure to the weather while simultaneously reducing the environmental impact on the community.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tent city</span> Temporary housing facility

A tent city is a temporary housing facility made using tents or other temporary structures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Art Agnos</span> American politician (born 1938)

Arthur Christ Agnos is an American politician. He served as the 39th mayor of San Francisco, California from 1988 to 1992 and as the Regional Head of the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development from 1993 to 2001.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">San Francisco Proposition N (2002)</span> Care Not Cash: 2002 SF measure replacing homeless cash aid with services, led by Gavin Newsom

Care Not Cash was a San Francisco ballot measure approved by the voters in November 2002. Primarily sponsored by Gavin Newsom, then a San Francisco supervisor, it was designed to cut the money given in the General Assistance programs to homeless people in exchange for shelters and other forms of services. The major intent of this measure was to prevent the cash grants given to be used for purchasing drugs and alcohol, and to strongly encourage homeless people to enter shelters or housing and obtain counseling and other services.

Housing First is a policy that offers unconditional, permanent housing as quickly as possible to homeless people, and other supportive services afterward. It was first discussed in the 1990s, and in the following decades became government policy in certain locations within the Western world. There is a substantial base of evidence showing that Housing First is both an effective solution to homelessness and a form of cost savings, as it also reduces the use of public services like hospitals, jails, and emergency shelters. Cities like Helsinki and Vienna in Europe have seen dramatic reductions in homelessness due to the adaptation of Housing First policies, as have the North American cities Columbus, Ohio, Salt Lake City, Utah, and Medicine Hat, Alberta.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Homelessness</span> Lacking stable, safe, functional housing

Homelessness, also known as houselessness or being unhoused or unsheltered, is the condition of lacking stable, safe, and functional housing. It includes living on the streets, moving between temporary accommodation with family or friends, living in boarding houses with no security of tenure, and people who leave their homes because of civil conflict and are refugees within their country.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mayoralty of Gavin Newsom</span> 42nd Mayor of San Francisco, 2004–2011

The mayoralty of Gavin Newsom began when Democrat Gavin Newsom was elected Mayor of San Francisco in 2003, succeeding Willie Brown. Newsom, who was 36 when he took office, became San Francisco's youngest mayor in over a century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Todd Gloria</span> Mayor of San Diego since 2020

Todd Rex Gloria is an American politician serving as the 37th mayor of San Diego since 2020. As mayor, he is the chief executive officer of the City of San Diego. He is a member of the Democratic Party.

The Joe Rodota Trail is a 8.5-mile paved rail trail in Sonoma County, California that spans from near the intersection of Mill Station Road and Highway 116 in Sebastopol to the area of West 3rd Street and Roberts Avenue in Santa Rosa. The trail provides a safety separation for pedestrians and bicycles from motor vehicle traffic on the parallel California State Route 12/Luther Burbank Memorial Highway.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">London Breed</span> Mayor of San Francisco since 2018

London Nicole Breed is an American politician who is the 45th and current mayor of San Francisco, serving since 2018. She was supervisor for District 5 and was president of the Board of Supervisors from 2015 to 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Homelessness in the San Francisco Bay Area</span>

The San Francisco Bay Area comprises nine northern California counties and contains five of the ten most expensive counties in the United States. Strong economic growth has created hundreds of thousands of new jobs, but coupled with severe restrictions on building new housing units, it has resulted in a statewide housing shortage which has driven rents to extremely high levels. The Sacramento Bee notes that large cities like San Francisco and Los Angeles both attribute their recent increases in homeless people to the housing shortage, with the result that homelessness in California overall has increased by 15% from 2015 to 2017. In September 2019, the Council of Economic Advisers released a report in which they stated that deregulation of the housing markets would reduce homelessness in some of the most constrained markets by estimates of 54% in San Francisco, 40 percent in Los Angeles, and 38 percent in San Diego, because rents would fall by 55 percent, 41 percent, and 39 percent respectively. In San Francisco, a minimum wage worker would have to work approximately 4.7 full-time jobs to be able to spend less than 30% of their income on renting a two-bedroom apartment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Homelessness in California</span>

The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development estimated that more than 181,399 people were experiencing homelessness in California in January 2023. This is one of the highest per capita rates in the nation, with 0.46% of residents estimated as being homeless. More than two-thirds of homeless people in California are unsheltered, which is the highest percentage of any state in the United States. 49% of the unsheltered homeless people in the United States live in California. Even those who are sheltered are so insecurely, with 90% of homeless adults in California reporting that they spent at least one night unsheltered in the past six months.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Homelessness in New Mexico</span> New Mexico, US

Homelessness is a serious issue throughout the state of New Mexico. Through a demographic examination it becomes evident that New Mexico has a high proportion of ethnographies that are currently and historically socioeconomically disadvantaged. Native Americans as a proportion of the US population represent the second highest amongst all States with only Alaska having a higher ratio, while it also has a large Hispanic population. Homelessness is a direct cause from an individual not being able to provide themselves with the most basic of necessities to maintain a healthy life hence having a higher proportion of individuals in poverty places a greater risk of an individual becoming homeless.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">COVID-19 and homelessness</span> Effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on homeless people

Homeless individuals are more likely to contract COVID-19 than those with permanent housing access. This is due to the environments that homeless people live in, which often suffer overcrowding and/or a lack of access to adequate sanitation. Homeless individuals are also more likely to suffer underlying health conditions, which increases the risk of death caused by COVID-19. The closure of public facilities has negatively impacted the homeless population, as reduced access to toilet facilities and support services has affected their hygiene and mental health respectively. Initiatives have been introduced by governments and at local levels in attempts to reduce the impact on the homeless.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2020 Minneapolis park encampments</span> Homeless encampments in city parks

The U.S. city of Minneapolis featured officially and unofficially designated camp sites in city parks for people experiencing homelessness that operated from June 10, 2020, to January 7, 2021. The emergence of encampments on public property in Minneapolis was the result of pervasive homelessness, mitigations measures related to the COVID-19 pandemic in Minnesota, local unrest after the murder of George Floyd, and local policies that permitted encampments. At its peak in the summer of 2020, there were thousands of people camping at dozens of park sites across the city. Many of the encampment residents came from outside of Minneapolis to live in the parks. By the end of the permit experiment, four people had died in the city's park encampments, including the city's first homicide victim of 2021, who was stabbed to death inside a tent at Minnehaha Park on January 3, 2021.

Mass. and Cass, also known as Methadone Mile or Recovery Road, is an area in Boston, Massachusetts, located at and around the intersection of Melnea Cass Boulevard and Massachusetts Avenue. Due to its concentration of neighborhood services providing help, the area around Mass. and Cass has long attracted a large number of people struggling with homelessness and drug addiction, especially after the closure of facilities on Long Island in Boston Harbor. It has been characterized as "the epicenter of the region's opioid addiction crisis".

41.18, also known as Los Angeles Municipal Code, Section 41.18(d), is an ordinance in Los Angeles mandating by law that there will be no "sitting, lying, or sleeping, or ... storing, using, maintaining, or placing personal property in the public right-of-way."

References

  1. ↑ Bartolo, James. "'Cleanup' or 'sweep'?: City to clear homeless encampments near Fountain Creek in Pueblo". Pueblo Chieftain. Retrieved 2024-11-23.
  2. ↑ Bartolo, James. "'Cleanup' or 'sweep'?: City to clear homeless encampments near Fountain Creek in Pueblo". Pueblo Chieftain. Retrieved 2024-11-22.
  3. 1 2 3 4 "Homeless camp sweeps result in police citations as often as housing offers, survey finds". Los Angeles Times. 2023-12-14. Retrieved 2024-11-23.
  4. ↑ "Cities crack down on homeless encampments. Advocates say that's not the answer". AP News. 2023-11-28. Retrieved 2024-11-22.
  5. 1 2 Kendall, Marisa (2024-07-25). "Gavin Newsom orders state agencies to move homeless people out of camps — but to where?". CalMatters. Retrieved 2024-11-22.
  6. ↑ "Sept. News: Encampment Policy Action Alert, N. Berkeley BART Funding Update & More". Rashi Kesarwani. 2024-09-09. Retrieved 2024-12-13.
  7. ↑ "2023 Report: San Francisco Encampment Teams Helped More People into Shelter". www.sf.gov. Retrieved 2024-12-13.
  8. 1 2 3 4 National Health Care for the Homeless Council (December 1, 2022). "Impact of Encampment Sweeps on People Experiencing Homelessness" (PDF). National Health Care for the Homeless Council. Retrieved December 13, 2024.
  9. 1 2 3 Grant, Kelli (2024-08-22). "Policing the Unhoused: Study Reveals the Harsh Realities of Complaint-Oriented Policing in San Francisco". Mad In America. Retrieved 2024-11-23.
  10. ↑ Shilcutt, Katharine. "It's Now Illegal to Feed [More Than Five] Homeless People [at Once] on Public Property". Houston Press. Retrieved 2024-12-13.
  11. ↑ "The Supreme Court will decide whether local anti-homeless laws are 'cruel and unusual'". PBS News. 2024-01-12. Retrieved 2024-12-13.
  12. ↑ "Civil Rights & Criminalization of Homelessness - National Coalition for the Homeless". National Coalition for the Homeless - Building a movement to End Homelessness. 2022-12-28. Retrieved 2024-11-23.
  13. ↑ "Legislative Analyst Report - Processing 'Quality of Life' Violations". sfbos.org. Retrieved 2024-11-23.
  14. ↑ "Amid end to COVID help, homelessness surging in many cities". AP News. 2022-10-06. Retrieved 2024-11-22.
  15. 1 2 Rodgers, Jakob (2020-06-26). "Sweeps Of Homeless Camps Run Counter To COVID Guidance And Pile On Health Risks". KFF Health News. Retrieved 2024-11-23.
  16. ↑ Levin, Sam (2023-12-19). "California's homelessness crisis is the worst in the US. But who is struggling the most?". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2024-12-09.
  17. ↑ "Governor Newsom orders state agencies to address encampments in their communities with urgency and dignity". Governor of California. 2024-07-25. Retrieved 2024-12-09.
  18. 1 2 Kendall, Marisa (2024-07-25). "Newsom orders state agencies to move homeless people out of camps — but to where?". Santa Rosa Press Democrat. Retrieved 2024-12-09.
  19. ↑ Johnson, Sydney (2024-08-06). "'The Rhetoric Is Amplified': SF Homeless Sweeps a Focal Point of Mayor's Race". www.kqed.org. Retrieved 2024-12-09.
  20. 1 2 3 4 Rota, Matt. "Swept Away: What Cities Really Take When They Sweep Homeless Encampments". ProPublica. Retrieved 2024-12-13.
  21. ↑ Rabell, Laura (2023-04-10). "Study Shows Involuntary Displacement of People Experiencing Homelessness May Cause Significant Spikes in Mortality, Overdoses and Hospitalizations". National Health Care for the Homeless Council. Retrieved 2024-12-13.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.