Intellectual dark web

Last updated

The intellectual dark web (IDW) is a loose affiliation of academics and social commentators who oppose what they perceive as the influence of left wing identity politics and political correctness in higher education and mass media.

Contents

Individuals and publications associated with the term reject what they view as authoritarianism and ostracism within mainstream progressive movements in Western countries. This includes opposition to deplatforming, boycotts, and online shaming, which are perceived as threats to freedom of speech.

Origin and usage

Eric Weinstein in 2010 EricWeinstein.JPG
Eric Weinstein in 2010

The term "intellectual dark web" was coined as a joke [1] by mathematician and venture capitalist Eric Weinstein and popularized by New York Times opinion editor Bari Weiss. [2] [3] It has been used to refer to various academics and social commentators who express concerns over the perceived excesses of left-wing identity politics and political correctness. [2] [3] Media studies scholar John Postill argues that Weiss's essay, titled "Meet the Renegades", was a "defining media event" that offered an identity and cast of characters for the "anti-woke movement" to follow. [3]

The first recorded usage of the term was on a 2017 episode of Sam Harris's podcast, when Weinstein used it to refer to a group of thinkers, including Weinstein and Harris, who used digital media to offer alternatives to mainstream media narratives. [3] This occurred after Weinstein's brother, biologist Bret Weinstein, resigned in 2017 from his position as professor of biology at the Evergreen State College in response to protests against his criticism of a campus event that asked white students to stay off campus, as opposed to the previous annual tradition of black students voluntarily absenting themselves. [4]

Derek Beres argues for Big Think that other controversies, dating back to 2014, should also be viewed as antecedents to the IDW. These include a debate between Harris and Ben Affleck on Real Time with Bill Maher in October 2014, the publication of "Google's Ideological Echo Chamber" by James Damore in August 2017, and Cathy Newman's interview of Jordan Peterson on Channel 4 News in January 2018, each of which related to controversial topics such as Islamic extremism and workplace diversity policies. [5]

Membership and ideology

The IDW comprises an ideologically diverse network of commentators who share an opposition to left-wing identity politics and political correctness. [3] [6] Other issues of concern include postmodernism and "cultural Marxism", which are perceived as contributing to moral relativism and the suppression of free speech. [7]

In her essay, Weiss characterized IDW members as "iconoclastic thinkers" [8] who had found audiences online after being "purged" from institutions that had become "hostile to unorthodox thought". [3] Eric Weinstein described the IDW as being opposed to "the gated institutional narrative" of the mainstream media and political elites. [1] IDW figures often use alternative media, including podcasts and newsletters, to build identification with audiences who are disillusioned with mainstream media and politics by branding themselves as reasonable thinkers and reinforcing narratives of political polarization. [9] According to Weiss, many IDW members identify as atheist, including Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Sam Harris, and Steven Pinker - all New Atheists. Commentators such as Douglas Murray, Maajid Nawaz, Joe Rogan, and Dave Rubin are also included. [2] Other notable IDW members according to Weiss include Bret and Eric Weinstein, Jordan Peterson, Ben Shapiro, Heather Heying, and Christina Hoff Sommers. [3]

While IDW members tend to not espouse overt white supremacy and ethnonationalism, their beliefs overlap with those of the white-nationalist alt-right movement, such as in debates over gender identity, feminism, men's rights, and race science. [2] IDW commentators tend to dismiss issues of transgender rights and racial and gender inequality as the concerns of leftist "social justice warriors" while welcoming some gay men, such as Murray and Rubin, into their ranks. [2] A 2019 study by Ribeiro et al. examining patterns of user comments on YouTube videos described the IDW as a "gateway to the far right". [2] Jacob Hamburger argues in the Los Angeles Review of Books that the IDW belongs to a neoconservative tradition of attacks on "political correctness" that began during the Reagan era, associated with commentators such as Allan Bloom, Roger Kimball, Dinesh D’Souza, David Brooks, Irving Kristol, and Norman Podhoretz. [6] Hamburger describes leftists along with liberals and progressives as the "primary adversaries" of the IDW. [6]

Some IDW members describe themselves as liberals in opposition to what they perceive as the excesses and indifference of the American Left, while others lean to the right. [10] Those who have been linked to the IDW are generally critical of what they perceive as "conformist" liberals, and some have been associated with the alt-lite and the alt-right. [11] Political scientist Daniel W. Drezner argues that the IDW contributes to polarization because of its need to appeal to a primarily right-wing audience, despite the political leanings of individual members. [12] The Guardian characterized the IDW as "strange bedfellows" that comprise the "supposed thinking wing of the alt-right". [13]

Nick Fouriezos of Ozy magazine describes IDW as "a growing school of thought that includes a collection of mostly left-leaning professors, pundits and thinkers united in their criticism of the modern social justice movement as authoritarian and illogical." [10] Liberals who have been labelled as being part of the IDW often credit the Enlightenment with vast improvements in human welfare since the 18th century, and see Enlightenment values such as freedom of speech and individual rights as threatened by both political correctness on the left, and Trumpism and religious conservatism on the right. [10]

Reception

Criticism of the IDW has come primarily from the left and support from the right. [6] [14] Jonah Goldberg, writing in the National Review , said the "label is a bit overwrought", writing that it struck him "as a marketing label – and not necessarily a good one. ... It seems to me this IDW thing isn't actually an intellectual movement. It's just a coalition of thinkers and journalists who happen to share a disdain for the keepers of the liberal orthodoxy." [15] Henry Farrell, writing in Vox , expressed disbelief that conservative commentator Ben Shapiro or neuroscientist Sam Harris, both claimed to be among the intellectual dark web by Weiss, could credibly be described as either purged or silenced. [16] Weiss' fellow New York Times columnist Paul Krugman noted the irony of claiming popular intellectual oppression by the mainstream, while publishing in the Times, among the most prominent newspapers in the nation, [17] although Weiss did not herself claim to be part of the IDW [8] and would depart the Times almost exactly one year later over the same issues central to figures in it. [18] David French contended many of the critics were missing the point, and were instead inadvertently confirming "the need for a movement of intellectual free-thinkers." [19]

In 2019, a study from the Federal University of Minas Gerais found a pattern of migration of viewers who comment on YouTube videos, from commenting on clips associated with the IDW and the "alt-lite" to commenting on more "right-wing and/or alt-right" videos. The study looked at over 331,000 videos that an algorithm had classified as right-wing, analyzed 79 million YouTube comments, and found a group that migrated from IDW channels to "alt-lite" channels, and then the alt-right channels. The subjects who left comments at an IDW channel were more likely to graduate after a few years to leaving significantly more comments on alt-right channels than the control group. The study's authors said they were not intending to "point fingers", but to draw attention to the effects of YouTube's recommendation algorithm. [20] [21]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pundit</span> Someone who offers their opinion via mass media

A pundit is a person who offers opinion in an authoritative manner on a particular subject area, usually through the mass media.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sam Harris</span> American philosopher and neuroscientist (born 1967)

Samuel Benjamin Harris is an American philosopher, neuroscientist, author, and podcast host. His work touches on a range of topics, including rationality, religion, ethics, free will, neuroscience, meditation, psychedelics, philosophy of mind, politics, terrorism, and artificial intelligence. Harris came to prominence for his criticism of religion, and he is known as one of the "Four Horsemen" of New Atheism, along with Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and Daniel Dennett.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Douglas Murray (author)</span> British author and political commentator (born 1979)

Douglas Murray is a British neoconservative political commentator, cultural critic, and journalist. He founded the Centre for Social Cohesion in 2007, which became part of the Henry Jackson Society, where he was associate director from 2011 to 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dave Rubin</span> American political commentator (born 1976)

David Joshua Rubin is an American libertarian-conservative political commentator. He is the creator and host of The Rubin Report, a political talk show on YouTube and on the network BlazeTV. Launched in 2013, his show was originally part of TYT Network, until he left in 2015, in part due to widening ideological differences. Previously, Rubin, who is gay, hosted LGBT-themed talk shows, including The Ben and Dave Show from 2007 to 2008 and The Six Pack from 2009 to 2012, both of which he co-hosted with Ben Harvey. Rubin has written two books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jordan Peterson</span> Canadian clinical psychologist (born 1962)

Jordan Bernt Peterson is a Canadian psychologist, author, and media commentator. He began to receive widespread attention in the late 2010s for his views on cultural and political issues. Often characterized as conservative, Peterson has described himself as a classic British liberal and a traditionalist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eric Weinstein</span> American financial executive (born 1965)

Eric Ross Weinstein is an American investor and financial executive. As of 2021, he was managing director for the American venture capital firm Thiel Capital. Weinstein hosts a podcast called The Portal, coined the term "intellectual dark web", and has proposed a theory of everything called "Geometric Unity" that has largely been met with skepticism in the scientific community.

The Dark Enlightenment, also called the neo-reactionary movement, is an anti-democratic, anti-egalitarian, and reactionary philosophical and political movement. The term "Dark Enlightenment" is a reaction to the Age of Enlightenment and an apologia for the popular conception of the Dark Ages.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alt-right</span> Far-right white nationalist movement

The alt-right is a far-right, white nationalist movement. A largely online phenomenon, the alt-right originated in the United States during the late 2000s before increasing in popularity and establishing a presence in other countries during the mid-2010s, and has been declining since 2017. The term is ill-defined and has been used in different ways by academics, journalists, media commentators, and alt-right members themselves.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carl Benjamin</span> British YouTuber and political commentator (born 1979)

Carl Benjamin, also known by his online pseudonym Sargon of Akkad, is a British right-wing YouTuber and political commentator. A former member of the Eurosceptic UK Independence Party (UKIP), he was one of its unsuccessful candidates for the South West England constituency at the 2019 European Parliament election.

Cultural Marxism is a far-right antisemitic conspiracy theory that misrepresents Western Marxism as being responsible for modern progressive movements, identity politics, and political correctness. The conspiracy theory posits that there is an ongoing and intentional academic and intellectual effort to subvert Western society via a planned culture war that undermines the supposed Christian values of traditionalist conservatism and seeks to replace them with culturally liberal values.

Quillette is an online magazine founded by Australian journalist Claire Lehmann. The magazine primarily focuses on science, technology, news, culture, and politics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Angela Nagle</span> Irish writer and academic (born 1984)

Angela Nagle is an American-born Irish academic and non-fiction writer who has written for The Baffler, Jacobin, and others. She is the author of the book Kill All Normies, published by Zero Books in 2017, which discusses the role of the internet in the rise of the alt-right and incel movements. Nagle describes the alt-right as a dangerous movement but also criticizes aspects of the left that she says have contributed to the alt-right's rise. Since 2021, she has been publishing articles on a wide range of personal, political and cultural topics via the online publishing platform Substack.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bret Weinstein</span> American podcaster and author

Bret Samuel Weinstein is an American podcaster, author, and former professor of evolutionary biology. He served on the faculty of Evergreen State College from 2002 until 2017, when he resigned in the aftermath of a series of campus protests about racial equity at Evergreen, which brought Weinstein to national attention. Like his brother Eric Weinstein, he was named as a member of the intellectual dark web in a 2018 New York Times essay by columnist Bari Weiss. Weinstein has been criticized for making false statements about COVID-19 treatments and vaccines, and for spreading misinformation about HIV/AIDS.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Claire Lehmann</span> Australian writer (born 1985)

Claire Lehmann is an Australian journalist, publisher, and the founding editor of Quillette.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">ContraPoints</span> American YouTuber (born 1988)

Natalie Wynn is an American left-wing YouTuber, political commentator, and cultural critic. She is best known for her YouTube channel, ContraPoints, where she creates video essays exploring a wide range of topics such as politics, gender, ethics, race, and philosophy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Responses to the alt-right</span>

Opponents of the alt-right have not reached a consensus on how to deal with it. Some opponents emphasized "calling out" tactics, labelling the alt-right with terms like "racist", "sexist", "homophobic", and "white supremacist" in the belief that doing so would scare people away from it. Many commentators urged journalists not to refer to the alt-right by its chosen name, but rather with terms like "neo-Nazi". There was much discussion within U.S. public discourse as to how to avoid the "normalization" of the alt-right. The activist group Stop Normalizing, which opposes the normalization of terms like alt-right, developed the "Stop Normalizing Alt Right" Chrome extension. The extension went viral shortly after the release of Stop Normalizing's website. The extension changes the term "alt-right" on webpages to "white supremacy". The extension and group were founded by a New York-based advertising and media professional under the pseudonym George Zola.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michael Brooks (political commentator)</span> American talk show host (1983–2020)

Michael Jamal Brooks was an American talk show host, writer, left-wing political commentator, and comedian. While co-hosting The Majority Report with Sam Seder, he launched The Michael Brooks Show in August 2017 and provided commentary for media outlets, making regular appearances on shows such as The Young Turks. Brooks contributed to various publications, including HuffPost, The Washington Post, Al Jazeera, openDemocracy, and Jacobin. His book Against the Web: A Cosmopolitan Answer to the New Right was published by Zero Books in April 2020.

Alt-tech is a collection of social networking services and Internet service providers popular among the alt-right, far-right, and others who espouse extremism or fringe theories, typically because they employ looser content moderation than mainstream platforms. The term "alt-tech" is a portmanteau of "alt-right" and "Big Tech". Starting around 2015, some prominent conservatives and their supporters began to use alt-tech platforms because they had been banned from other social media platforms. Alt-tech platforms describe themselves as protectors of free speech and individual liberty, which researchers and journalists have alleged may be a dog whistle for antisemitism and terrorism.

Bronze Age Pervert, also known as BAP or B.A.P., is a pseudonymous far-right Internet personality, associated with the manosphere. The media has identified Costin Vlad Alamariu, a Romanian-American, as the person behind the pseudonym.

The alt-right pipeline is a proposed conceptual model regarding internet radicalization toward the alt-right movement. It describes a phenomenon in which consuming provocative right-wing political content, such as antifeminist or anti-SJW ideas, gradually increases exposure to the alt-right or similar far-right politics. It posits that this interaction takes place due to the interconnected nature of political commentators and online communities, allowing members of one audience or community to discover more extreme groups. This process is most commonly associated with and has been documented on the video platform YouTube, and is largely faceted by the method in which algorithms on various social media platforms function through the process recommending content that is similar to what users engage with, but can quickly lead users down rabbit-holes. The effects of YouTube's algorithmic bias in radicalizing users has been replicated by one study, although two other studies found little or no evidence of a radicalization process.

References

  1. 1 2 Kelsey, Darren (2020). "Archetypal Populism: The 'Intellectual Dark Web' and the 'Peterson Paradox'". In Kranert, Michael (ed.). Discursive Approaches to Populism Across Disciplines: The Return of Populists and the People. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. p. 174. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-55038-7_7. ISBN   978-3-030-55038-7.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Sheedy, Matt (2022). Owning the Secular: Religious Symbols, Culture Wars, Western Fragility. Routledge Focus on Religion. London: Routledge. pp. 89–90. doi:10.4324/9781003031239. ISBN   978-0-367-46802-6.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Postill, John (2024). "Introduction". The Anthropology of Digital Practices: Dispatches from the Online Culture Wars. New York: Routledge. pp. 7–8. doi:10.4324/9781003335238-1. ISBN   978-1-003-85133-2.
  4. ↑ Svrluga, Susan; Heim, Joe (June 1, 2017). "Threat shuts down college embroiled in racial dispute" . The Washington Post . Archived from the original on May 26, 2019. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
  5. ↑ Beres, Derek (March 27, 2018). "5 key moments that led to the rise of the Intellectual Dark Web". Big Think. Archived from the original on March 26, 2019. Retrieved September 11, 2019.
  6. 1 2 3 4 Hamburger, Jacob (July 18, 2018). "The 'Intellectual Dark Web' Is Nothing New". Los Angeles Review of Books. Archived from the original on March 27, 2019. Retrieved October 5, 2024. Despite their various differences, all members of the movement believe their ideas are being stifled by an epidemic of 'political correctness.' [...] These thinkers ought not to be allowed to pretend that its ideas are, historically speaking, anything other than conservative.
  7. ↑ Sheedy (2022), pp. 89–90: "For some IDW figures, the influence of postmodernism and 'cultural Marxism' is said to be particularly dangerous, contributing to moral relativism, political correctness, and the stifling of free speech."
  8. 1 2 Weiss, Bari (May 8, 2018). "Meet the Renegades of the Intellectual Dark Web" . The New York Times. Archived from the original on January 31, 2020. Retrieved May 8, 2018.
  9. ↑ Baker, Stephanie Alice; Maddox, Alexia (2022). "From COVID-19 Treatment to Miracle Cure: The Role of Influencers and Public Figures in Amplifying the Hydroxychloroquine and Ivermectin Conspiracy Theories during the Pandemic". M/C Journal. 25 (1). doi: 10.5204/mcj.2872 . ISSN   1441-2616.
  10. 1 2 3 Fouriezos, Nick (August 10, 2020). "American Fringes: The Intellectual Dark Web Declares Its Independence". Ozy. Archived from the original on September 19, 2020. Retrieved September 5, 2020.
  11. ↑ Finlayson, Alan (2021). "Neoliberalism, the Alt-Right and the Intellectual Dark Web". Theory, Culture & Society. 38 (6): 167–190. doi: 10.1177/02632764211036731 . ISSN   1460-3616. S2CID   239690708.
  12. ↑ Drezner, Daniel W. (May 11, 2018). "The Ideas Industry meets the intellectual dark web" . PostEverything. The Washington Post. Archived from the original on May 29, 2019. Retrieved October 5, 2024.
  13. ↑ "The 'Intellectual Dark Web' – the supposed thinking wing of the alt-right". The Guardian. May 9, 2018. Archived from the original on June 10, 2019. Retrieved June 25, 2019.
  14. ↑ Bowden, Blaine (May 6, 2019). "Yes, The Intellectual Dark Web Is Politically Diverse". Areo. Archived from the original on August 5, 2019. Retrieved July 30, 2019.
  15. ↑ Goldberg, Jonah (May 8, 2018). "Evaluating the 'Intellectual Dark Web'". National Review . Archived from the original on July 15, 2020. Retrieved June 25, 2019.
  16. ↑ Farrell, Henry (May 10, 2018). "The 'Intellectual Dark Web,' explained: what Jordan Peterson has in common with the alt-right". Vox. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
  17. ↑ Bonazzo, John (August 5, 2018). "NY Times 'Intellectual Dark Web' Story Savaged on Twitter—Even by Paper's Staffers". The New York Observer . Archived from the original on July 22, 2019. Retrieved June 25, 2019.
  18. ↑ Pompeo, Joe (July 14, 2020). "In Dramatic Exit From the Times, Bari Weiss Makes Bid for Woke-Wars Martyrdom". Vanity Fair . Retrieved October 29, 2022.
  19. ↑ French, David A. (May 11, 2018). "Critics Miss the Point of the 'Intellectual Dark Web'". National Review . Archived from the original on August 13, 2019. Retrieved June 25, 2019.
  20. ↑ Dickson, EJ (August 28, 2019). "Study Shows How the 'Intellectual Dark Web' Is a Gateway to the Far Right" . Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on September 21, 2019. Retrieved September 25, 2019.
  21. ↑ Ribeiro, Manoel Horta; Ottoni, Raphael; West, Robert; Almeida, Virgílio A F; Meira Meira, Wagner (2020). "Auditing radicalization pathways on YouTube". Proceedings of the 2020 Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency. New York: Association for Computing Machinery. pp. 131–141. doi: 10.1145/3351095.3372879 . ISBN   9781450369367. S2CID   201316434.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.