Judicial Committee of the Privy Council and the Irish Free State

Last updated

Until 1933, Article 66 of the Constitution of the Irish Free State permitted appeals of decisions of the Supreme Court of the Irish Free State [n 1] to be made to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) in London. [2] [3] This was a requirement of the Anglo-Irish Treaty of 1921, which underpinned the creation of the Irish Free State. The treaty specified that the Free State's constitutional status would be the same as Canada, another British Dominion, whose local courts allowed further appeal to the JCPC.

Contents

While Article I of the 1921 treaty said the Free State's "constitutional status" would match all the existing Dominions (Canada, Union of South Africa, Australia, New Zealand), Article II said "the relationship of the Crown or the representative of the Crown" to the Free State would match Canada. [4] Although Article II ought to have covered the JCPC, in negotiations on the 1922 Free State constitution, the Lloyd George government allowed the provisional Irish government to use the model of South Africa, a unitary state with fewer JCPC appeals than Canada, a federal state for which the JCPC often heard cases of dispute between federal and provincial governments. [5] [6] [7] Kevin O'Higgins predicted there would "not be two or three appeals in a century, where appeals [would] only be granted in very special cases, raising matters other than purely Irish interests, raising international issues of the first importance". [5]

The Cumann na nGaedheal governments of 1922–32 sought to minimise appeals to the Privy Council as undermining the autonomy of the Free State and giving fuel to its republican opponents. An additional impetus was that JCPC members included former politicians who were now Lords of Appeal, among them prominent unionists Lord Carson, Viscount Sumner, and Viscount Cave. [8] [9] In the event Carson and Sumner recused themselves from Free State cases; however, Cave did not and ruled against Cumann na nGaedheal in several cases. [8] Conversely, Southern Irish unionists regarded the JCPC as a safeguard against tyranny of the majority, a fear which Irish nationalists insisted was unfounded.

Article XII of the 1921 treaty provided for a three-person Irish Boundary Commission to finalise the border between the Free State and Northern Ireland. In 1924, when Craigavon's Stormont government refused to appoint Northern Ireland's commissioner, MacDonald's Westminster government referred to the JCPC the question of whether it could either force Stormont to nominate or make one in its stead. [10] The JCPC corresponded with Cosgrave's Dublin government, which chose to view the matter as internal to the UK and refused to be a party to the deliberations. [11]

At the Imperial Conferences of 1926 and 1930, Cosgrave's governments attempted to secure the abolition of JCPC appeal; although neither conference explicitly agreed to this, the 1930 conference led to the UK Parliament recognising Dominion parliaments as its equals via the Statute of Westminster 1931. In the runup to that UK statute, Cosgrave's government prepared two bills for the Free State Oireachtas (parliament): one to remove Article 66 from the constitution, and the other to make any Supreme Court decision final. [12] The bills had not been introduced by the 1932 general election after which Fianna Fáil came to power after and began removing British and monarchist elements from the constitution. The Constitution (Amendment No. 22) Act 1933 abolished the right of appeal to the JCPC. The JCPC itself ruled in 1935 that the Free State Oireachtas had the power to do so under the Statute of Westminster.

List of referrals

Judicial Committee of the Privy Council cases relating to the Irish Free State
Date [n 2] Case Legal citations TypeJusticesNotes
25 July 1923
  1. R. (Bowman) v Joseph Healy and Major Thomas William Marshall Fuge
  2. Alexander E. Hull and Co. v Mary Anne McKenna
  3. The "Freeman's Journal" Limited v Follum Traesliberi
  4. The "Freeman's Journal" Limited v Erik Fernstrom
[1923] 57 ILT & SJ 173, 197
[1926] 2 IR 402		Appeal from Court of Appeal in Ireland (leave denied [n 3] ) Haldane, Buckmaster, Parmoor The first Free State petitions. [13] [14]
  1. Bowman v. Healy appealed the refusal of insurance officer Fuge and umpire Healy to apply the Unemployment Insurance Act 1920 to Inchicore railway works employees laid off during a strike by others on the Great Southern and Western Railway. [15] The state was a party, and Hugh Kennedy appeared at the JCPC with John A. Costello, later his successor as Free State Attorney General. Lionel Curtis, at Kennedy's request, persuaded the JCPC registrar to have that petition heard first of the four listed. The case was withdrawn before decision. [16] [17]
  2. McKenna was hit by a lorry after stepping into the roadway where the footpath was blocked by Hull's hoarding. [18] [14] The lorry driver, Harry Stephens, was a party to the original case but not the appeal petition. [14]
  3. The Freeman's Journal newspaper paid less than the agreed amount for newsprint after a steep fall in global prices. [18] [14]
  4. Similar to Follum, involving a different newsprint supplier. [18] [14]

The decision in cases 2, 3, and 4 (often cited as Hull v. McKenna) was to refuse leave to appeal on the basis that there was no automatic right of appeal and that the questions at issue were internal matters for the Free State. [16] [14]

31 July 1924In the Matter of the Reference as to the Tribunal under Article 12 of the Schedule appended to the Irish Free State Agreement Act 1922. Cmd. 2214 [n 4] [20] [21] Special reference Dunedin, Blanesburgh, Lawrence Jenkins, Lyman Duff, Adrian Knox Four questions were submitted in advance and a supplementary question during the JCPC hearing beginning 22 July 1924. The answers were transmitted to the UK government by Maurice Hankey, secretary to the JCPC. The substance was that there was no way "under existing law" to bring the Irish Boundary Commission into being without the co-operation of the Northern Ireland government. [11] [20]
27 December 1925James O'Callaghan v. Charles O'Sullivan[1925] 1 IR 90
[1926] 2 IR 586		Appeal from Supreme Court (leave denied) Cave, Dunedin, Shaw O'Callaghan contested in forma pauperis his dismissal as parish priest of Eyeries by O'Sullivan, Catholic Bishop of Ardfert and Aghadoe. [22]
27 December 1925Lynham v Butler[1925] 2 IR 82Appeal from Supreme Court (leave granted)Cave, Dunedin, ShawThe JCPC granted leave to appeal a Supreme Court ruling on the Land Act 1923, but the Land Act 1926 was rushed through the Oireachtas to make explicit the interpretation given by the Supreme Court judgment, obviating the need for JCPC consideration. [6]
22 June 1926 [23] Martin Fitzgerald v. Commissioners of Inland Revenue [1926] 2 IR 182, 585Appeal from Supreme Court (leave denied)Haldane, Dunedin, Atkinson, Phillimore A tax case for compensation for damage from the 1916 Rising. [24]
3 May 1927John Howard Wigg and Robert Oliver Cochrane v The Attorney General of the Irish Free State 1927 UKPC 45
1927 AC 674		Appeal from Supreme Court (heard; overturned verdict)Cave, Haldane, Finlay, DunedinQuestioned the applicability to Free State civil servants who had previously been employed by the Dublin Castle administration of a change to the UK Superannuation Act's civil service scheme effected by a Treasury minute of 20 March 1922. The minute was after the Provisional Government was created on 16 January but before the Irish Free State (Agreement) Act 1922 transferred control of the Irish civil service from 1 April. [2]
13 November 1928In the matter of certain questions relating to the payment of compensation to Civil Servants under Article X of the Articles of Agreement for a Treaty between Great Britain and Ireland 1928 UKPC 85 Special reference Reading, Phillimore, Hanworth, Alness, Anglin Special reference due to the Free State government's refusal to enforce the JCPC decision in the Wigg case. In response to both decisions, the Irish and British governments agreed to amend the 1921 treaty. [2] [25]
10 April 1930The Performing Right Society, Limited v The Urban District Council of Bray 1930 UKPC 36 Appeal from Supreme Court (heard; overturned verdict) Sankey, Blanesburgh, Hanworth, Thankerton, Russell Overturned a 1928 Supreme Court decision that the Copyright Act 1911 had not been carried over from UK to Free State law. In the interim, the Oireachtas had passed the Copyright (Preservation) Act 1929 to replicate the 1911 Act. [26]
6 June 1935Robert Lyon Moore and others v The Attorney General for the Irish Free State and others [Petition] 1935 UKPC 34
1935 1 IR 472 		Appeal from Supreme Court (leave denied)Sankey, Atkin, Tomlin, Macmillan, Wright Moore and the other plaintiffs represented the Erne Fishery Company in a fishing rights case begun in 1925, in which the Supreme Court ruled against the company in 1933. [27] The appeal to the JCPC was filed before the bill to abolish such appeals was introduced, and heard after the bill had been enacted as the Constitution (Amendment No. 22) Act 1933. Whereas abolition statutes in other Commonwealth countries usually allowed appeals already pending to proceed to the JCPC, the 1933 act made no such exception. Conformant to Irish law that the JCPC no longer had jurisdiction, the Supreme Court refused to transmit the case files to the JCPC and the Attorney-General of the Irish Free State was not represented at its proceedings. The JCPC ruled in 1935 that it no longer had jurisdiction because the 1933 act was legitimate. The Oireachtas in 1934 had passed a law enabling the Erne Fishery Company to regain possession of the disputed fishing rights. [28]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Irish Free State</span> State in north-west Europe from 1922 to 1937

The Irish Free State was a state established in December 1922 under the Anglo-Irish Treaty of December 1921. The treaty ended the three-year Irish War of Independence between the forces of the Irish Republic – the Irish Republican Army (IRA) – and British Crown forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">W. T. Cosgrave</span> 1st president of the Irish Executive Council from 1922 to 1932

William Thomas Cosgrave was an Irish Fine Gael politician who served as the president of the Executive Council of the Irish Free State from 1922 to 1932, leader of the Opposition in both the Free State and Ireland from 1932 to 1944, leader of Fine Gael from 1934 to 1944, founder and leader of Fine Gael's predecessor, Cumann na nGaedheal, from 1923 to 1933, chairman of the Provisional Government from August 1922 to December 1922, the president of Dáil Éireann from September 1922 to December 1922, the minister for Finance from 1922 to 1923 and minister for Local Government from 1919 to 1922. He served as a Teachta Dála (TD) from 1921 to 1944. He was a Member of Parliament (MP) for the Kilkenny North constituency from 1918 to 1922.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Governor-General of the Irish Free State</span> Representative of the monarch of the Irish Free State from 1922 to 1936

The Governor-General of the Irish Free State was the official representative of the sovereign of the Irish Free State from 1922 to 1936. By convention, the office was largely ceremonial. Nonetheless, it was controversial, as many Irish Nationalists regarded the existence of the office as offensive to republican principles and a symbol of continued British involvement in Irish affairs, despite the Governor-General having no connection to the British Government after 1931. For this reason, the office's role was diminished over time by the Irish Government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constitution of the Irish Free State</span> 1922 Irish Free State constitution

The Constitution of the Irish Free State was adopted by Act of Dáil Éireann sitting as a constituent assembly on 25 October 1922. In accordance with Article 83 of the Constitution, the Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922 of the British Parliament, which came into effect upon receiving the royal assent on 5 December 1922, provided that the Constitution would come into effect upon the issue of a Royal Proclamation, which was done on 6 December 1922. In 1937 the Constitution of the Irish Free State was replaced by the modern Constitution of Ireland following a referendum.

The Government of the 7th Dáil or the 6th Executive Council was formed after the 1932 general election held on 16 February. It was led by Fianna Fáil leader Éamon de Valera as President of the Executive Council, taking office after ten years of government led by W. T. Cosgrave of Cumann na nGaedheal. De Valera had previously served as President of Dáil Éireann, or President of the Republic, from April 1919 to January 1922 during the revolutionary period of the Irish Republic.

There were two Governments of the 6th Dáil, which was elected at the September 1927 general election held on 15 September 1927. The 4th Executive Council and the 5th Executive Council were both minority governments of Cumann na nGaedheal led by W. T. Cosgrave as President of the Executive Council.

The Government of the 5th Dáil or the 3rd Executive Council was formed after the June 1927 general election held on 9 June 1927. It was led by W. T. Cosgrave, leader of Cumann na nGaedheal, as President of the Executive Council, who had led the government since August 1922.

The Government of the 4th Dáil or the 2nd Executive Council was the Executive Council of the Irish Free State formed after the general election held on 27 August 1923. It was a minority Cumann na nGaedheal government led by W. T. Cosgrave as President of the Executive Council.

The Government of the 3rd Dáil was first both concurrently the 2nd Provisional Government and the 5th Ministry of Dáil Éireann, formed after the 1922 general election held on 16 June 1922, and then the 1st Executive Council of the Irish Free State, formed after the establishment of the Irish Free State. They were led by W. T. Cosgrave, who had become the leader of the Pro-Treaty wing of Sinn Féin and on 27 April 1923 became the first leader of the Cumann na nGaedheal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1932 Irish general election</span> Election to the 7th Dáil

The 1932 Irish general election to the 7th Dáil was held on Tuesday, 16 February, following the dissolution of the 6th Dáil on 29 January by Governor-General James McNeill on the advice of President of the Executive Council W. T. Cosgrave. The general election took place in 30 parliamentary constituencies throughout the Irish Free State for 153 seats in Dáil Éireann. It was the first election held in the Irish Free State since the Statute of Westminster 1931 removed the authority of the United Kingdom parliament to legislate for the Dominions, including the Irish Free State.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">June 1927 Irish general election</span> Election to the 5th Dáil

The June 1927 Irish general election was to elect the 5th Dáil held on Thursday, 9 June following the dissolution of the 4th Dáil on 23 May 1927. It was the first election contested by Fianna Fáil, which had been formed a year earlier when Éamon de Valera, leader of the abstentionist Anti-Treaty Sinn Féin, failed to convince the party to take their seats if and when the Oath of Allegiance were abolished. Most of Sinn Féin's TDs, as well as the bulk of its support, shifted to Fianna Fáil. The impact of this shift saw Sinn Féin all but decimated; it was reduced to five seats. This was for many years the end of the party as a major force in the southern part of the island; it would not win more than 10 seats at an election until 2011, by which time it had undergone fundamental transformation. This election cemented Fianna Fáil as a major party; it and Cumann na nGaedheal/Fine Gael remained the two largest parties in Ireland until 2011.

The Executive Council was the cabinet and de facto executive branch of government of the 1922–1937 Irish Free State. Formally, executive power was vested in the Governor-General on behalf of the King. In practice, however, it was the Council that governed, since the Governor-General was bound to act on its advice. The Executive Council included a prime minister called the President of the Executive Council and a deputy prime minister called the Vice-President. A member of the Council was called an executive minister, as distinct from an extern minister who had charge of a department without being in the Council.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adoption of the Constitution of Ireland</span> Plebiscite approving the Constitution of Ireland

The current Constitution of Ireland came into effect on 29 December 1937, repealing and replacing the Constitution of the Irish Free State, having been approved in a national plebiscite on 1 July 1937 with the support of 56.5% of voters in the then Irish Free State. The Constitution was closely associated with Éamon de Valera, the President of the Executive Council of the Irish Free State at the time of its approval.

In the Irish Free State, an extern minister, formally a Minister who shall not be a Member of the Executive Council, was a minister who had charge of a department but was not a member of the Executive Council. Extern ministers were individually nominated by Dáil Éireann, whereas of the Executive Council only the President was: he in turn nominated the other members. All ministers were formally appointed by the Governor-General. The Executive Council included the senior ministers, exercised cabinet collective responsibility, and had to be TDs ; the extern ministers filled more junior technocratic roles, and need not be legislators, though in fact all were TDs. In practice, all ministers formed a united administration, and no extern ministers were appointed after 1927.

The 3rd Dáil was elected at the 1922 general election on 16 June and met on 9 September. On its formation, it was a Constituent Assembly in a Provisional Parliament. From 6 December 1922, Dáil Éireann was the lower house of the Oireachtas in the Irish Free State. Members of the Dáil are known as TDs. The 3rd Dáil was dissolved by Governor-General Tim Healy on 9 August 1923, at the request of the President of the Executive Council W. T. Cosgrave. The 3rd Dáil lasted 335 days.

The granting, reserving or withholding of the Royal Assent was one of the key roles, and potentially one of the key powers, possessed by the Governor-General of the Irish Free State. Until it was granted, no bill passed by the Oireachtas could complete its passage of enactment and become law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922</span> UK Parliamentary Act to recognise in UK law the 1922 Irish Free State constitution

The Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922 was an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom, passed in 1922 to enact in UK law the Constitution of the Irish Free State, and to ratify the 1921 Anglo-Irish Treaty formally.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">September 1927 Irish general election</span> Election to the 6th Dáil

The September 1927 Irish general election to the 6th Dáil was held on Thursday, 15 September, following the dissolution of the 5th Dáil on 25 August by Governor-General Tim Healy on the request of President of the Executive Council W. T. Cosgrave.

The Constitution Act 1933 was an Act of the Oireachtas of the Irish Free State amending the Constitution of the Irish Free State and the Constitution of the Irish Free State Act 1922. It removed the Oath of Allegiance required of members of the Oireachtas (legislature) and of non-Oireachtas extern ministers.

The Constitution Act 1933 was an Act of the Oireachtas of the Irish Free State amending the Constitution of the Irish Free State which had been adopted in 1922. It abolished the right of appeal from the Supreme Court of the Irish Free State to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. It was part of a series of constitutional changes the Fianna Fáil government led by Éamon de Valera had initiated after coming to office in 1932 which reduced the connections between the Irish Free State and the United Kingdom.

References

Footnotes

  1. ↑ The Supreme Court was created by statute in 1924, prior to which the 1922 constitution preserved the Court of Appeal in Ireland created in 1877, Article 66 applying to its decisions. [1]
  2. ↑ Date of the final JCPC action (denial of leave, issuing of opinion, ruling, etc.)
  3. ↑ The petition in Bowman v. Healy was withdrawn rather than denied.
  4. ↑ UK National Archives citation CAB 24/168/28 [formerly CP 426 (24)] [19]

Sources

Citations

  1. ↑ Constitution of the Irish Free State Article 75; Henchy, Seamus (1962). "Precedent in the Irish Supreme Court". The Modern Law Review. 25 (5): 547. ISSN   0026-7961. JSTOR   1092346.
  2. 1 2 3 Maguire, Martin (2008). "5: Cumann na nGaedheal and the civil service, 1923–32". The Civil Service and the Revolution in Ireland 1912-1938: Shaking the Blood-stained Hand of Mr Collins' (PDF). Manchester University Press. pp. 182–195. ISBN   9781781702611 . Retrieved 17 April 2018.
  3. ↑ Constitution of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) Act, 1922 Schedule 1, Article 66: "nothing in this Constitution shall impair the right of any person to petition His Majesty for special leave to appeal from the Supreme Court to His Majesty in Council or the right of His Majesty to grant such leave"
  4. ↑ Constitution of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) Act, 1922; Schedule 2
  5. 1 2 "In Committee on the Constitution of Saorstat Eireann Bill. — Article 65". Dáil debates. Oireachtas. 10 October 1922. Vol. 1 No. 20 p.25 cc.1401–1416. Retrieved 17 April 2018.
  6. 1 2 "Public Business. - Land Bill, 1926—Second Stage". Dáil Éireann (4th Dáil) debates. Houses of the Oireachtas. 3 February 1926. Retrieved 17 April 2018.
  7. ↑ Viscount Cave (3 March 1926). "Appeal From The Irish Free State Courts". Hansard. HL Deb vol 63 c404. Retrieved 17 April 2018. I dare say he was told also that the Free State would be like South Africa, a unitary State, so that the questions which frequently arise, for instance, in Canada between the Dominion and Provinces would not arise in the Irish Free State, and that accordingly the number of appeals would be less than they are in the case of Canada.
  8. 1 2 Mohr, Thomas (2010). "Lord Cave, the Privy Council and Ireland". UCD Working Papers in Law, Criminology & Socio-Legal Studies (Research Paper 42/2010). doi:10.2139/ssrn.1713114.
  9. ↑ Towey 1977 p.367
  10. ↑ Rankin, K. J. (2006). "The provenance and dissolution of the Irish boundary commission" (PDF). IBIS Working Papers. Institute for British-Irish Studies, University College Dublin (79): 14.
  11. 1 2 Executive Council (1924). "Correspondence between the Registrar of the Privy Council and His Excellency the Governor-General of the Irish Free State : on matters arising out of article 12 of the Treaty" (PDF). Documents Laid. Oireachtas Library. Retrieved 2 June 2020.
  12. ↑ Mohr 2002b pp.194–195
  13. ↑ Mohr 2002b p.190
  14. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Status of Free State Courts; Right of Appeal to Privy Council" . Weekly Irish Times. 4 August 1923. p. 2. Retrieved 31 May 2020.
  15. ↑ "The Inchicore Case Again" . The Irish Times. 13 April 1923. p. 3. Retrieved 31 May 2020.
  16. 1 2 Towey 1977 pp.368–370
  17. ↑ McCullagh, David (2010). "Chapters 2 and 3". The Reluctant Taoiseach: A Biography of John A. Costello. Gill & Macmillan. ISBN   978-0-7171-5163-9 . Retrieved 31 May 2020.
  18. 1 2 3 Mohr 2002b fn.4
  19. ↑ "Memorandum: Irish Boundary Commission" . Catalogue. UK National Archives. 31 July 1924. Retrieved 10 December 2019.
  20. 1 2 Hudson, Manley O. (January 1925). "The Irish Boundary Question". The American Journal of International Law. 19 (1): 150–155. doi:10.2307/2189090. JSTOR   2189090.
  21. ↑ Reprinted in Quekett, Arthur S. (1933). The Constitution Of Northern Ireland. Vol. Part II. Belfast: HMSO. pp.  171-175. Retrieved 10 December 2019.
  22. ↑ Hughes 1931 p.80 fn.1; Murdoch, Henry (December 2004). "Beating the Bishop: O'Callaghan v O'Sullivan" (PDF). Law Society Gazette. Dublin. 98 (10): 10. Retrieved 29 May 2020.
  23. ↑ Hughes 1931 p.85 fn.1
  24. ↑ Mohr 2002b pp.191–192
  25. ↑ "Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act 1929". electronic Irish Statute Book (eISB). Retrieved 31 May 2020.; "In Committee on Finance — Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Bill, 1929 — Second Stage". Dáil Éireann (6th Dáil) debates. Oireachtas. 11 July 1929. Retrieved 31 May 2020.
  26. ↑ Clark, Robert; Shúilleabháin, Máire Ní (2010). Intellectual Property Law in Ireland. Kluwer Law International. p. 32 s.1.22. ISBN   9789041133021 . Retrieved 17 April 2018.
  27. ↑ Mohr 2002b, Parts I, V, VI
  28. ↑ "S.R. & O. No. 177/1934 - River Erne (Tidal Waters) Order, 1934". Irish Statute Book . Retrieved 24 April 2018.; "Fisheries (Tidal Waters) Bill, 1934—Second Stage". Dáil Éireann Debates. 25 May 1934. pp. Vol.52 No.14 p.4 cc.1817–1850. Retrieved 24 April 2018.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.