Ketenyl anion

Last updated

A ketenyl anion contains a C=C=O allene-like functional group, similar to ketene, with a negative charge on either terminal carbon or oxygen atom, forming resonance structures by moving a lone pair of electrons on C-C-O bond. Ketenes have been sources for many organic compounds with its reactivity despite a challenge to isolate them as crystal. Precedent method to obtain this product has been at gas phase or at reactive intermediate, and synthesis of ketene is used be done in extreme conditions (i.e., high temperature, low pressure). [1] [2] [3] Recently found stabilized ketenyl anions become easier to prepare compared to precedent synthetic procedure. A major feature about stabilized ketene is that it can be prepared from carbon monoxide (CO) reacting with main-group starting materials such as ylides, silylene, and phosphinidene to synthesize and isolate for further steps. As CO becomes a more common carbon source for various type of synthesis, [4] this recent finding about stabilizing ketene with main-group elements opens a variety of synthetic routes to target desired products.

Contents

Synthesis

Gessner et al. first revealed a synthetic route for stabilized ketenyl anion using metalated ylides in 2022. [5] In their paper, upon introducing CO, metalated ylide with posassium cation exchange CO with phosphine group R, also known for carbonylation of ylide. Their isolated ketenyl anion [K(PPh2(=S)CCO] is stable solid for a week under inert atmosphere, and its crystal structure was characterized. An alternate synthetic pathway for synthesizing ketenyl anion from ylide, shown in Figure 2, includes sulfuration on diphenylphosphine group, deprotonation on carbon center, and CO substitution in exchange of triphenylphosphine leaving. This synthesis resulted in 88% isolation of the product. Later in their studies, the ketenyl anion product upon carbonylation can be selective by changing electron-withdrawing ability on a certain leaving group and Lewis acidity of coordinated alkali metal cation. [6] In their example with ylide containing phosphine group and tosyl group (Ts), Gessner et al. was able to produce the ketenyl anion product more selective by modifying those parameters, shown in Figure 2. As R group is more electron-withdrawing group, it becomes more likely to leave than tosyl group. For example, changing R group from cyclohexyl group (Cy) to phenyl group (Ph) favored the ketenyl anion product with R1 group leaving by 76%. This is because phenyl group is less electron rich and less nucleophilic compared to cyclohexyl group, resulting in more stable by itself. [7] For alkali metal cation trend, when triphenylphosphine group is present, changing from M = Li to M = K favored in phosphine group leaving by 9%. Although it is a small effect compared to leaving group effect, this is due to Lewis acidity [8] on metal cations because a stronger Lewis acidic metal cation (Li > K in Lewis acidity) attracts tosyl group to interact, resulting in increasing leaving group ability.

Figure 1. Synthetic scheme of ketenyl anion from ylide upon sulfuration, deprotonation, and carbonylation in order. 88 % yield was reported in this reaction. 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion synthesis 4.png
Figure 1. Synthetic scheme of ketenyl anion from ylide upon sulfuration, deprotonation, and carbonylation in order. 88 % yield was reported in this reaction.
Figure 2: Synthesis of ketenyl anion from CO carbonylation of ylide, reference from Gessner et al.. M = Li, Na, K. R1 = Cy, Ph, p-(CF3)C6H4. 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion synthesis 1.jpg
Figure 2: Synthesis of ketenyl anion from CO carbonylation of ylide, reference from Gessner et al.. M = Li, Na, K. R1 = Cy, Ph, p-(CF3)C6H4.
Figure 3: Synthesis of ketenyl anion using silylene molecules stabilized by silyl group. R = SiMe3, Si Bu3. Charge of both starting materials and product is balanced by cation [K(18-6-crown)] . 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion reactivity 4.jpg
Figure 3: Synthesis of ketenyl anion using silylene molecules stabilized by silyl group. R = SiMe3, Si Bu3. Charge of both starting materials and product is balanced by cation [K(18-6-crown)] .

Inoue et al. presented synthetic route of stabilizing ketene via silica-carbonyl anion, silicon analogue of ketene. [9] They motivated this goals from recent reactivity study of silylene and disilane activating CO and isolating intermediate, hypothesizing that silica-ketenyl anion is also capable to stabilize ketene. [10] [11] [12] While Gessner et al. uses ylides to accept CO, Inoue et al. uses silylene anion with another silyl group substituted to afford insertion of CO or carbonylation at room temperature in exchange of silyl group.

Figure 4: Synthesis of ketenyl anion from CO carbonylation of phosphinidene-carbone. 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion synthesis 2.jpg
Figure 4: Synthesis of ketenyl anion from CO carbonylation of phosphinidene-carbone.

Liu et al. had another approach to stabilize and isolate ketene by using carbene coordinated by phosphinidene. [13] Carbene coordinated by 2,6-diisopropylphenyl(Dipp)-substituted phosphinidene and dinitrogen (N2) perform N2/CO ligand exchange. The starting material is similar to N-heterocyclic carbene with bulky substituents, invented by Bertrand. [14] In their studies, this reaction is concerted and thermodynamically favorable (-47.4 kcal/mol relative to N2-coordinated carbene) on coordinating CO ligand to NHC. This product is stable at room temperature inert atmosphere for a month, and no decomposition while heating in THF at 80 °C for 12 hours was observed.

Structure

Figure 5: General resonance structure of ketenyl anion. Left structure is ketene form while right structure is ynolate form. 5.05 F23 Wiki ketenyl resonance.jpg
Figure 5: General resonance structure of ketenyl anion. Left structure is ketene form while right structure is ynolate form.

As shown in Figure 5, ketenyl anion has two major resonance structures: ketenyl form and ynolate form. Due to the resonance structures, alkali metal cations can be coordinated to either at central carbon atom or terminal oxygen atom depending on its electronic structure. [5] [6] A series of structural analysis revealed both ketene and ynolate structures evenly contribute to the overall electronic structure of ketenyl anion.

From an example in Gessner's paper, the crystal structure of the ketenyl anion K[PPh2(=S)CCO] had the bond length of C-C bond (1.245 Å) and C-O bond (1.215 Å). [5] By comparing these bond length with Pyykkő's analysis on bond, [15] C-C bond is in between double bond and triple bond whereas C-O bond is in between single bond and double bond. In natural bond orbital (NBO) analysis, [16] [17] Wiberg bond index is found to be 2.06 and 1.72 for C-C bond and C-O bond, respectively. These values also suggests that both double and triple bond character for C-C bond (range of 1.20 - 1.34 Å) and both single bond and double bond character for C-O bond (range of 1.24 - 1.38 Å). The characteristic of allene-like (C=C=C) structure is also applied other ketenyl anion compounds so far. Inoue's silica-ketenyl anion product, shown in Figure 3, had Wiberg bond index of 1.68 and 1.76 for Si-C bond and C-O bond, respectively. [9] Their bond indices demonstrate that both Si-C and C-O bonds have part of double bond character that contributes of Si=C=O structure.

This ketenyl anion can dimerize in solid state as oxygen atoms interacts with alkali metal cation. This dimer can be broken up by adding M(18-crown-6) (where M = alkali metal cation), resulting in isolation of single ketenyl anion structure. [5] [9] Intrinsic bond orbitals (IBO) of the molecule [K(PPh2(=S)CCO] reveal molecular orbital describing π-orbital of C-C and C-O and delocalized orbital on oxygen atom.

Figure 6: Intrinsic bond orbitals of K[PPh2(=S)CCO] (CCDC-2201261), calculating by ORCA def2-TZVP basis set. The geometry of the structure was optimized by r SCAN3c method. 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion iboview.png
Figure 6: Intrinsic bond orbitals of K[PPh2(=S)CCO] (CCDC-2201261), calculating by ORCA def2-TZVP basis set. The geometry of the structure was optimized by r SCAN3c method.

The stability of ketenyl anion is come from the decrease of charge on ketene carbon from parent ketene to ketenyl anion. In Gessner's study, parent ketenyl anion [H-C=C=O]- has smaller positive charge (+4.0 e) on C compared to parent ketene [H2C=C=O] (+7.0 e on C). [5] This drops of charge makes the ketene less amphiphilic, leading to a more stable compound.

Reactivity

The advantage of using ketenyl anion molecule is to synthesize desired compound selectively without concerning dimerization before synthesizing a target product. [21] In ylide-ketenyl anion, electrophile can be substituted in exchange of metal to functionalize the ketene moiety at high yield. [5] Since the central carbon is negatively charged, this nucleophilicity enable substitution with a series of electrophilic compounds such as triphenylmethyl group. Some ketenyl anion can further react with other compounds to form a new functional group. For example, after electrophilic substitution of ketenyl anion with triphenylmethyl group, the treatment with water results in formation of carboxylic acid at C=O moiety. Reported compounds from Gessner et al. had more than 90% yield isolated as solid.

Figure 7: Electrophilic substitution of ketenyl anion with a series of substrate, reported in Gessner et al. 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion reactivity 1.jpg
Figure 7: Electrophilic substitution of ketenyl anion with a series of substrate, reported in Gessner et al.

Not only at the central carbon where a cation can be coordinated, other carbon atom and terminal oxygen atom can also be functionalized upon electrophilic substitution. This reactivity allows activation of chemical bonds such as S-S and C=O bonds and new bonds C-S bond and C=C bond. [5] These products requires CO and substrates of interests, which highlight new synthetic pathways of organic compounds at room temperature instead of extreme conditions such as pyrolysis. [2]

Figure 8: Reported reactivity studies on S-S and C=O bond activation by ylide-ketenyl anion by Gessner et al. 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion reactivity 2.jpg
Figure 8: Reported reactivity studies on S-S and C=O bond activation by ylide-ketenyl anion by Gessner et al.

A stabilized ketenyl anion also undergoes dimerization with disubstituted phosphine compound to form a heterocyclic product. [5] In this reaction, an intermediate is proposed to be electrophilic substitution of a disubstituted phosphine compound followed by dimerization.

Figure 9: Reported dimerization of ylide-ketenyl anion upon electrophilic substitution of disubstituted phosphines by Gessner et al. 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion reactivity 3.jpg
Figure 9: Reported dimerization of ylide-ketenyl anion upon electrophilic substitution of disubstituted phosphines by Gessner et al.

In different ketenyl anion compound, cleavage of Csp-H bond, C=N bond, and I2 bond at room temperature were also reported in phosphinidene-stabilized ketene. [13] For I2 cleaving reaction, the mechanism is proposed to be cleavage of the bond at central carbon and migration of I to phosphorus atom.

Figure 10: Reported bond cleavage reactions with phosphinidene-ketenyl anion. Charge of both starting materials and product is balanced by cation [K(18-6-crown)] . 5.05 F23 ketenyl anion reactivity 5.jpg
Figure 10: Reported bond cleavage reactions with phosphinidene-ketenyl anion. Charge of both starting materials and product is balanced by cation [K(18-6-crown)] .

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Allenes</span> Any organic compound containing a C=C=C group

In organic chemistry, allenes are organic compounds in which one carbon atom has double bonds with each of its two adjacent carbon atoms. Allenes are classified as cumulated dienes. The parent compound of this class is propadiene, which is itself also called allene. A group of the structure R2C=C=CR− is called allenyl, while a substituent attached to an allene is referred to as an allenic substituent. In analogy to allylic and propargylic, a substituent attached to a saturated carbon α to an allene is referred to as an allenylic substituent. While allenes have two consecutive ('cumulated') double bonds, compounds with three or more cumulated double bonds are called cumulenes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carboxylic acid</span> Organic compound containing a –C(=O)OH group

In organic chemistry, a carboxylic acid is an organic acid that contains a carboxyl group attached to an R-group. The general formula of a carboxylic acid is often written as R−COOH or R−CO2H, sometimes as R−C(O)OH with R referring to the alkyl, alkenyl, aryl, or other group. Carboxylic acids occur widely. Important examples include the amino acids and fatty acids. Deprotonation of a carboxylic acid gives a carboxylate anion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ketene</span> Organic compound of the form >C=C=O

In organic chemistry, a ketene is an organic compound of the form RR'C=C=O, where R and R' are two arbitrary monovalent chemical groups. The name may also refer to the specific compound ethenone H2C=C=O, the simplest ketene.

An ylide or ylid is a neutral dipolar molecule containing a formally negatively charged atom (usually a carbanion) directly attached to a heteroatom with a formal positive charge (usually nitrogen, phosphorus or sulfur), and in which both atoms have full octets of electrons. The result can be viewed as a structure in which two adjacent atoms are connected by both a covalent and an ionic bond; normally written X+–Y. Ylides are thus 1,2-dipolar compounds, and a subclass of zwitterions. They appear in organic chemistry as reagents or reactive intermediates.

In organic chemistry, a carbanion is an anion in which carbon is negatively charged.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pi backbonding</span> Form of interaction between two atoms

In chemistry, π back bonding is a π-bonding interaction between a filled (or half filled) orbital on one atom and a vacant orbital on an adjacent atom. This type of interaction stabilizes electron rich atoms by allowing them to dissipate charge into neighboring atoms.. It is especially common in the organometallic chemistry of low-valent transition metals with ligands such as carbon monoxide, olefins, or phosphines. Electrons from the metal are used to bond to the ligand, dissipating excess negative charge. Compounds where π back bonding is prominent include Ni(CO)4, Zeise's salt, and molybdenym and iron dinitrogen complexes.

Organosulfur chemistry is the study of the properties and synthesis of organosulfur compounds, which are organic compounds that contain sulfur. They are often associated with foul odors, but many of the sweetest compounds known are organosulfur derivatives, e.g., saccharin. Nature is abound with organosulfur compounds—sulfur is vital for life. Of the 20 common amino acids, two are organosulfur compounds, and the antibiotics penicillin and sulfa drugs both contain sulfur. While sulfur-containing antibiotics save many lives, sulfur mustard is a deadly chemical warfare agent. Fossil fuels, coal, petroleum, and natural gas, which are derived from ancient organisms, necessarily contain organosulfur compounds, the removal of which is a major focus of oil refineries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metal carbonyl</span> Coordination complexes of transition metals with carbon monoxide ligands

Metal carbonyls are coordination complexes of transition metals with carbon monoxide ligands. Metal carbonyls are useful in organic synthesis and as catalysts or catalyst precursors in homogeneous catalysis, such as hydroformylation and Reppe chemistry. In the Mond process, nickel tetracarbonyl is used to produce pure nickel. In organometallic chemistry, metal carbonyls serve as precursors for the preparation of other organometallic complexes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Persistent carbene</span> Type of carbene demonstrating particular stability

A persistent carbene is an organic molecule whose natural resonance structure has a carbon atom with incomplete octet, but does not exhibit the tremendous instability typically associated with such moieties. The best-known examples and by far largest subgroup are the N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHC), in which nitrogen atoms flank the formal carbene.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Germylene</span> Class of germanium (II) compounds

Germylenes are a class of germanium(II) compounds with the general formula :GeR2. They are heavier carbene analogs. However, unlike carbenes, whose ground state can be either singlet or triplet depending on the substituents, germylenes have exclusively a singlet ground state. Unprotected carbene analogs, including germylenes, has a dimerization nature. Free germylenes can be isolated under the stabilization of steric hindrance or electron donation. The synthesis of first stable free dialkyl germylene was reported by Jutzi, et al in 1991.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phosphinidene</span> Type of compound

Phosphinidenes are low-valent phosphorus compounds analogous to carbenes and nitrenes, having the general structure RP. The "free" form of these compounds is conventionally described as having a singly-coordinated phosphorus atom containing only 6 electrons in its valence level. Most phosphinidenes are highly reactive and short-lived, thereby complicating empirical studies on their chemical properties. In the last few decades, several strategies have been employed to stabilize phosphinidenes, and researchers have developed a number of reagents and systems that can generate and transfer phosphinidenes as reactive intermediates in the synthesis of various organophosphorus compounds.

The phosphaethynolate anion, also referred to as PCO, is the phosphorus-containing analogue of the cyanate anion with the chemical formula [PCO] or [OCP]. The anion has a linear geometry and is commonly isolated as a salt. When used as a ligand, the phosphaethynolate anion is ambidentate in nature meaning it forms complexes by coordinating via either the phosphorus or oxygen atoms. This versatile character of the anion has allowed it to be incorporated into many transition metal and actinide complexes but now the focus of the research around phosphaethynolate has turned to utilising the anion as a synthetic building block to organophosphanes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zirconocene</span> Chemical compound

Zirconocene is a hypothetical compound with 14 valence electrons, which has not been observed or isolated. It is an organometallic compound consisting of two cyclopentadienyl rings bound on a central zirconium atom. A crucial question in research is what kind of ligands can be used to stabilize the Cp2ZrII metallocene fragment to make it available for further reactions in organic synthesis.

Aluminium(I) nucleophiles are a group of inorganic and organometallic nucleophilic compounds containing at least one aluminium metal center in the +1 oxidation state with a lone pair of electrons strongly localized on the aluminium(I) center.

1-Phosphaallenes is are allenes in which the first carbon atom is replaced by phosphorus, resulting in the structure: -P=C=C<.

<i>N</i>-Heterocyclic carbene boryl anion Isoelectronic structure

An N-heterocyclic carbene boryl anion is an isoelectronic structure of an N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC), where the carbene carbon is replaced with a boron atom that has a -1 charge. NHC boryl anions have a planar geometry, and the boron atom is considered to be sp2-hybridized. They serve as extremely strong bases, as they are very nucleophilic. They also have a very strong trans influence, due to the σ-donation coming from the boron atom. NHC boryl anions have stronger electron-releasing character when compared to normal NHCs. These characteristics make NHC boryl anions key ligands in many applications, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and more commonly low oxidation state main group element bonding.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Organoberyllium chemistry</span> Organoberyllium Complex in Main Group Chemistry

Organoberyllium chemistry involves the synthesis and properties of organometallic compounds featuring the group 2 alkaline earth metal beryllium (Be). The area remains understudied, relative to the chemistry of other main-group elements, because although metallic beryllium is relatively unreactive, its dust causes berylliosis and compounds are toxic. Organoberyllium compounds are typically prepared by transmetallation or alkylation of beryllium chloride.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stable phosphorus radicals</span>

Stable and persistent phosphorus radicals are phosphorus-centred radicals that are isolable and can exist for at least short periods of time. Radicals consisting of main group elements are often very reactive and undergo uncontrollable reactions, notably dimerization and polymerization. The common strategies for stabilising these phosphorus radicals usually include the delocalisation of the unpaired electron over a pi system or nearby electronegative atoms, and kinetic stabilisation with bulky ligands. Stable and persistent phosphorus radicals can be classified into three categories: neutral, cationic, and anionic radicals. Each of these classes involve various sub-classes, with neutral phosphorus radicals being the most extensively studied. Phosphorus exists as one isotope 31P (I = 1/2) with large hyperfine couplings relative to other spin active nuclei, making phosphorus radicals particularly attractive for spin-labelling experiments.

Pnictogen-substituted tetrahedranes are pnictogen-containing analogues of tetrahedranes with the formula RxCxPn4-x. Computational work has indicated that the incorporation of pnictogens to the tetrahedral core alleviates the ring strain of tetrahedrane. Although theoretical work on pnictogen-substituted tetrahedranes has existed for decades, only the phosphorus-containing species have been synthesized. These species exhibit novel reactivities, most often through ring-opening and polymerization pathways. Phosphatetrahedranes are of interest as new retrons for organophosphorus chemistry. Their strain also make them of interest in the development of energy-dense compounds.

Alkylidene ketenes are a class of organic compounds that are of the form R2C=C=C=O. They are a member of the family of heterocumulenes (R2C=(C)n=O), and are often considered an unsaturated homolog of ketenes (R2C=C=O). Sometimes referred to as methyleneketenes, these compounds are highly reactive and much more difficult to access than ketenes.

References

  1. Robinson, Marin S.; Davico, Gustavo E.; Bierbaum, Veronica M.; DePuy, Charles H. (1994-10-06). "The gas phase ion/molecule chemistry of the carbon- 13 labeled ketenyl and methyl ketenyl anions with CS2, COS, and CO2". International Journal of Mass Spectrometry and Ion Processes. 137: 107–119. doi:10.1016/0168-1176(94)04030-3. ISSN   0168-1176.
  2. 1 2 Allen, Annette D.; Tidwell, Thomas T. (2013-09-11). "Ketenes and Other Cumulenes as Reactive Intermediates". Chemical Reviews. 113 (9): 7287–7342. doi:10.1021/cr3005263. ISSN   0009-2665. PMID   23767795.
  3. Woodbury, Richard P.; Long, Nathan R.; Rathke, Michael W. (January 1978). "Reaction of trimethylsilylketene with strong base. Evidence for ketene enolate formation". The Journal of Organic Chemistry. 43 (2): 376. doi:10.1021/jo00396a057. ISSN   0022-3263.
  4. Fujimori, Shiori; Inoue, Shigeyoshi (2022-02-09). "Carbon Monoxide in Main-Group Chemistry". Journal of the American Chemical Society. 144 (5): 2034–2050. doi:10.1021/jacs.1c13152. ISSN   0002-7863. PMID   35068141. S2CID   246238305.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Jörges, Mike; Krischer, Felix; Gessner, Viktoria H. (2022-12-23). "Transition metal–free ketene formation from carbon monoxide through isolable ketenyl anions". Science. 378 (6626): 1331–1336. doi:10.1126/science.ade4563. ISSN   0036-8075. S2CID   254998217.
  6. 1 2 3 Krischer, Felix; Jörges, Mike; Leung, Tsz‐Fai; Darmandeh, Heidar; Gessner, Viktoria H. (2023-10-09). "Selectivity Control of the Ligand Exchange at Carbon in α‐Metallated Ylides as a Route to Ketenyl Anions**". Angewandte Chemie International Edition. 62 (41). doi: 10.1002/anie.202309629 . ISSN   1433-7851.
  7. "Leaving Groups". Chemistry LibreTexts. 2013-10-02. Retrieved 2023-12-19.
  8. "3.2: Brønsted and Lewis Acids and Bases". Chemistry LibreTexts. 2019-09-04. Retrieved 2023-12-19.
  9. 1 2 3 4 Fujimori, Shiori; Kostenko, Arseni; Scopelliti, Rosario; Inoue, Shigeyoshi (July 2023). "Synthesis, isolation and application of a sila-ketenyl anion". Nature Synthesis. 2 (7): 688–694. doi:10.1038/s44160-023-00283-w. ISSN   2731-0582. S2CID   257975059.
  10. Wang, Yuwen; Kostenko, Arseni; Hadlington, Terrance J.; Luecke, Marcel-Philip; Yao, Shenglai; Driess, Matthias (2019-01-09). "Silicon-Mediated Selective Homo- and Heterocoupling of Carbon Monoxide". Journal of the American Chemical Society. 141 (1): 626–634. doi:10.1021/jacs.8b11899. ISSN   0002-7863. S2CID   54564960.
  11. Xiong, Yun; Yao, Shenglai; Szilvási, Tibor; Ruzicka, Ales; Driess, Matthias (2020-01-16). "Homocoupling of CO and isocyanide mediated by a C,C′-bis(silylenyl)-substituted ortho-carborane". Chemical Communications. 56 (5): 747–750. doi: 10.1039/C9CC08680C . ISSN   1364-548X.
  12. Cowley, Michael J.; Ohmori, Yu; Huch, Volker; Ichinohe, Masaaki; Sekiguchi, Akira; Scheschkewitz, David (2013-12-09). "Carbonylation of Cyclotrisilenes". Angewandte Chemie International Edition. 52 (50): 13247–13250. doi:10.1002/anie.201307450. ISSN   1433-7851. PMID   24307015.
  13. 1 2 3 4 Wei, Rui; Wang, Xin‐Feng; Ruiz, David A.; Liu, Liu Leo (2023-04-03). "Stable Ketenyl Anions via Ligand Exchange at an Anionic Carbon as Powerful Synthons**". Angewandte Chemie International Edition. 62 (15): e202219211. doi:10.1002/anie.202219211. ISSN   1433-7851. PMID   36807666.
  14. Lavallo, Vincent; Dyker, C. Adam; Donnadieu, Bruno; Bertrand, Guy (2008-07-07). "Synthesis and Ligand Properties of Stable Five‐Membered‐Ring Allenes Containing Only Second‐Row Elements". Angewandte Chemie International Edition. 47 (29): 5411–5414. doi:10.1002/anie.200801176. ISSN   1433-7851. PMID   18551494.
  15. Pyykkö, Pekka; Atsumi, Michiko (2009-11-23). "Molecular Double‐Bond Covalent Radii for Elements Li–E112". Chemistry – A European Journal. 15 (46): 12770–12779. doi:10.1002/chem.200901472. ISSN   0947-6539. PMID   19856342.
  16. Glendening, Eric D.; Landis, Clark R.; Weinhold, Frank (January 2012). "Natural bond orbital methods". WIREs Computational Molecular Science. 2 (1): 1–42. doi:10.1002/wcms.51. ISSN   1759-0876. S2CID   95586513.
  17. Bridgeman, Adam J.; Cavigliasso, Germán; Ireland, Luke R.; Rothery, Joanne (2001-01-01). "The Mayer bond order as a tool in inorganic chemistry". Journal of the Chemical Society, Dalton Transactions (14): 2095–2108. doi:10.1039/B102094N. ISSN   1364-5447.
  18. Knizia, Gerald (2013-11-12). "Intrinsic Atomic Orbitals: An Unbiased Bridge between Quantum Theory and Chemical Concepts". Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation. 9 (11): 4834–4843. arXiv: 1306.6884 . doi:10.1021/ct400687b. ISSN   1549-9618. PMID   26583402. S2CID   17717923.
  19. Knizia, Gerald; Klein, Johannes E. M. N. (2015-04-27). "Electron Flow in Reaction Mechanisms—Revealed from First Principles". Angewandte Chemie International Edition. 54 (18): 5518–5522. doi:10.1002/anie.201410637. ISSN   1433-7851. PMID   25737294.
  20. "r2SCAN-3c: A "Swiss army knife" composite electronic-structure method". pubs.aip.org. Retrieved 2023-12-11.
  21. Huisgen, Rolf; Otto, Peter (September 1968). "The mechanism of dimerization of dimethylketene". Journal of the American Chemical Society. 90 (19): 5342–5343. doi:10.1021/ja01021a090. ISSN   0002-7863.