| Year | Detail |
|---|
| 1959 (1) | 1 goal for Waterford; 5 goals for Kilkenny |
| 1959 (2) | 3 goals for Waterford,; 1 goal for Kilkenny |
| 1960 | 2 goals for Wexford |
| 1961 | 1 goal for Dublin |
| 1962 | 3 goals for Tipp; 2 for Wexford |
| 1963 | 4 goals for Kilkenny; 6 for Waterford |
| 1964 | 5 goals for Tipp; 2 for Kilkenny |
| 1965 | 2 goals for Tipp |
| 1966 | 3 goals for Cork; 1 goal for Kilkenny |
| 1967 | 3 goals for Kilkenny; 2 goals for Tipp |
| 1968 | 5 goals for Wexford; 3 goals for Tipp |
| 1969 | 2 goals for Kilkenny; 2 goals for Cork |
| 1970 | Tony Doran X2 (first goal of the game after 4 minutes and his team's last goal, in the second half), Dan Quigley (first half, third goal of the game) Pat Quigley X2 (with two minutes left of the first half; then in the second half) for Wexford; Eddie O'Brien X3 (after 11 minutes; later in the first half; after an hour), Charlie Cullinane (first half, fourth goal of the game), Willie Walsh (90 seconds into the second half), Charlie McCarthy (second half) for Cork |
| 1971 | Noel O'Dwyer (after 19 minutes, first goal of the game), John Flanagan (first half, two minutes after Keher's first goal), Roger Ryan X2 (both second half, sixth goal of the game, less than two minutes after Byrne's goal, followed by eighth goal of the game), and Dinny Ryan (second half, second last goal of the game before Keher completed the goals) for Tipp; Eddie Keher X2 (first half, a minute after O'Dwyer's opening goal of the game and at the end, last goal of the game), Mossy Murphy (fourth goal of the game, a minute before half-time), Ned Byrne (fifth goal of the game, in the 45th minute) and Kieran Purcell (second half, seventh goal of the game) for Kilkenny |
| 1972 | Ray Cummins X2 (4 minutes and second half, 30 seconds after Keher's first goal), Mick Malone X2 (32? minutes and second half, third goal of the game), S. O'Leary for Cork; Eddie Keher X2 (both second half, fourth goal of the game and "with thirteen minutes left") and Frank Cummins (last goal of the game) for Kilkenny |
| 1973 | Pat Delaney for Kilkenny (first half); Mossie Dowling (later than six minutes into the second half) for Limerick |
| 1974 | 3 goals for Kilkenny; 1 goal for Limerick |
| 1975 | Frank Burke (18th minute) and P. J. Qualter (second half, between Keher's two goals) for Galway; Eddie Keher X2 (three minutes into the second half and a p 20 minutes from the end) for Kilkenny; |
| 1976 | 2 goals for Cork; 4 goals for Wexford |
| 1977 | 1 goal for Cork; 3 goals for Wexford |
| 1978 | Kevin Fennelly (first half) and Billy Fitzpatrick (second half, immediately after Barry-Murphy's goal) for Kilkenny; Jimmy Barry-Murphy (about 13 minutes from the end) for Cork |
| 1979 | L. O'Brien and M. Brennan for Kilkenny; Noel Lane for Galway |
| 1980 | Bernie Forde (after two and half minutes) and P. J. Molloy (second goal of the game) for Galway; Éamonn Cregan X2 (first half, second half) and J. McKenna (second half) for Limerick |
| 1981 | 2 goals for Offaly, incl. a Johnny Flaherty handpassed goal |
| 1982 | C. Heffernan X2 and G. Fennelly for Kilkenny; E. O'Donoghue for Cork |
| 1983 | R. Power and L. Fennelly for Kilkenny; Seánie O'Leary and Tomás Mulcahy for Cork |
| 1984 | Seánie O'Leary X2 (game's first goal in first half, game's third goal in second half) and Kevin Hennessy (second half, second goal of the game) for Cork; Mark Corrigan (end of second half) for Offaly |
| 1985 | 2 goals for Offaly; 1 goal for Galway |
| 1986 | John Fenton (after eight minutes), Kevin Hennessy X2 (the first shortly after Fenton's, the second after Commins's and before Molloy's in the second half), Tomás Mulcahy (second half) for Cork; John Commins (goalkeeper, eight minutes from the end) and P. J. Molloy (a minute from the end) for Galway |
| 1987 | Noel Lane for Galway (63rd minute to make it 1.11 to 0.9) |
| 1988 | Noel Lane for Galway |
| 1989 | Declan Ryan (after 18 minutes), Nicky English X2, Pat Fox for Tipp; Brian Donnelly, Aidan McCarry, Donal Armstrong for Antrim |
| 1990 | Kevin Hennessy (after 48 seconds), Tomás Mulcahy (nine minutes into the second half), Mark Foley (second half), John Fitzgibbon X2 (less than 90 seconds apart, in the second half) for Cork; Joe Cooney (first half) and Brendan Lynskey (second half) for Galway |
| 1991 | 1 goal for Tipp (Michael Cleary?) |
| 1992 | D. J. Carey, L. McCarthy and J. Power for Kilkenny; G. Manley for Cork |
| 1993 | P. J. Delaney and A. Ronan for Kilkenny; L. Burke for Galway |
| 1994 | D. Quigley X2 for Limerick; Johnny Dooley, Joe Dooley, Pat O'Connor for Offaly |
| 1995 | Johnny Pilkington (in the second half) and Michael Duignan for Offaly; Éamonn Taaffe for Clare, in the second half |
| 1996 | T. Dempsey for Wexford |
|
