Year | Association | Category | Nominated work | Result | Ref |
---|
2001 | Russian Guild of Film Critics | Best Foreign Actor | The Believer | Won | |
2002 | Chicago Film Critics Association | Most Promising Performer | The Believer and Murder by Numbers | Nominated | |
2006 | Best Actor | Half Nelson | Nominated | [53] |
Dallas–Fort Worth Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | |
National Society of Film Critics | Best Actor | Nominated | |
New York Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | Nominated | |
Online Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Nominated | [54] |
St. Louis Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | |
Toronto Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | [55] |
Vancouver Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | Nominated | |
2007 | Chicago Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Lars and the Real Girl | Nominated | |
St. Louis Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | |
2010 | Chicago Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Blue Valentine | Nominated | [56] |
Critics' Choice Movie Awards | Best Actor | Nominated | [6] |
Detroit Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Nominated | [56] |
London Film Critics' Circle | Actor of the Year | Nominated | [57] |
Online Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Nominated | [58] |
2011 | Denver Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Crazy, Stupid, Love | Nominated | |
Detroit Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [59] |
Dublin Film Critics' Circle | Best Actor | Drive | Nominated | |
London Film Critics' Circle | Actor of the Year | Nominated | [60] |
St. Louis Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | [61] |
Women Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | Nominated | |
Women Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | The Ides of March | Nominated | |
2016 | Alliance of Women Film Journalists | Best Actor | La La Land | Nominated | [62] [63] |
Austin Film Critics Association | Nominated | [64] [65] |
Dallas–Fort Worth Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | [66] |
Detroit Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Nominated | [67] |
Florida Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | Nominated | [68] |
Houston Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Nominated | [69] |
Online Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Nominated | [70] |
San Diego Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Nominated | [71] |
Best Comedic Performance | The Nice Guys | Won |
San Francisco Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | La La Land | Nominated | [72] |
St. Louis Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | [73] |
Vancouver Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | Nominated | [74] |
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Nominated | [75] |
2023 | Alliance of Women Film Journalists | Best Actor in a Supporting Role | Barbie | Won | [76] |
Astra Film Awards | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [77] |
Atlanta Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actor | Won [a] | [78] |
Austin Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [79] |
Boston Society of Film Critics | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [80] |
Chicago Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [81] |
Chicago Indie Critics | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [82] |
Critics Association of Central Florida | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [83] |
Columbus Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Performance | Nominated | [84] |
Denver Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [85] |
DiscussingFilm Critic | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [86] |
Dublin Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | Nominated | [87] |
Family Film Awards | Outstanding Actor in a Feature Film | Nominated | [88] |
Georgia Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [89] |
Greater Western New York Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [90] |
Gotham Awards | Outstanding Supporting Performance | Nominated | [91] |
Hawaii Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [92] |
Hollywood Music In Media Awards | Song – Onscreen Performance (for "I'm Just Ken") | Nominated | [93] |
Houston Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [94] |
Indiana Film Journalists Association | Best Supporting Performance | Nominated | [95] |
Iowa Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [96] |
Kansas City Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [97] |
Las Vegas Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [98] |
Latino Entertainment Journalists Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [99] |
London Critics Circle Film Awards | Supporting Actor of the Year | Nominated | [100] |
Los Angeles Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [101] |
Michigan Movie Critics Guild | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [102] |
Minnesota Film Critics Alliance | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [103] |
Music City Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [104] |
National Society of Film Critics | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [105] |
New York Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [106] |
North Carolina Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [107] |
North Dakota Film Society | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [108] |
North Texas Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [109] |
Oklahoma Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [110] |
Online Association of Female Film Critics | Best Supporting Male | Nominated | [111] |
Online Film and Television Association | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [112] |
Online Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [113] |
Phoenix Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [114] |
Phoenix Film Critics Society | Best Actor in a Supporting Role | Won | [115] |
Portland Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [116] |
San Diego Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Runner-up | [117] |
Best Comedic Performance | Nominated |
San Francisco Bay Area Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [118] |
Seattle Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [119] |
St. Louis Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [120] |
Toronto Film Critics Association | Outstanding Supporting Performance | Won | [121] |
UK Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Won | [122] |
Utah Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Performance, Male | Nominated | [123] |
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | Nominated | [124] |
2024 | Astra Film Awards | Best Picture | The Fall Guy | Runner-up | [125] |
Best Actor | Runner-up |