| Year(s) elected | Name | Notes |
|---|
| 1216 | Daniel, son of Nicholas | - |
| 1230-33 | John, son of the Dean | - |
| 1245-51 | Peter Scot | - |
| 1245-51 | Peter Scot | - |
| 1252-58 | Henry of Carliol | - |
| 1258-59 | Thomas of Carliol | - |
| 1259 | Nicholas Scot | - |
| 1260 | Thomas of Carliol | - |
| 1260-63 | Henry of Carliol | - |
| 1264-65 | Thomas of Carliol | - |
| 1271 | John, son of Roger | - |
| 1272 | Thomas of Carliol | - |
| 1273 | Nicholas Scot | - |
| 1274 | Henry Scot | - |
| 1275-76 | John, son of Roger | - |
| 1277 | Henry Scot | - |
| 1278 | Thomas of Carliol | - |
| 1279-80 | John, son of Roger | - |
| 1281 | Robert of Mitford | - |
| 1282-85 | Henry Scot | - |
| 1286-87 | John son of Roger | - |
| 1288-89 | Henry Scot | - |
| 1290 | John Scot | - |
| 1291-92 | Hugh of Carliol | - |
| 1293 | Henry Scot | - |
| 1294 | Hugh of Carliol | - |
| 1295-97 | John Scot | - |
| 1298-99 | Henry Scot | - |
| 1300-02 | Peter Graper | - |
| 1303-04 | Nicholas of Carliol | - |
| 1305-08 | Richard of Emeldon | - |
| 1309 | Nicholas of Carliol | - |
| 1310 | Sir Nicholas Scot | - |
| 1311-12 | Richard of Emeldon | - |
| 1313 | Thomas of Carliol | - |
| 1314-20 | Richard of Emeldon | - |
| 1321 | Sir Nicholas Scot | - |
| 1322-29 | Richard of Emeldon | - |
| 1330 | William of Burneton | - |
| 1331-32 | Richard of Emeldon | - |
| 1333 | John of Denton | Murdered by burgesses, 1344 |
| 1334 | Richard of Acton | - |
| 1335 | Hugh of Hecham | - |
| 1336-37 | John of Denton | Murdered by burgesses, 1344 |
| 1338 | Robert of Shilvington | - |
| 1339 | Walran of Lumley | - |
| 1340 | John of Denton | Murdered by burgesses, 1344 |
| 1341 | Robert of Shilvington | - |
| 1342 | Robert of Haliwell | - |
| 1343-44 | Richard of Galeway | - |
| 1345 | Robert of Shilvington | - |
| 1346-47 | Peter Graper | - |
| 1348-49 | Robert of Angerton | - |
| 1350-51 | Gilbert of Duxfield | - |
| 1352 | Peter Graper | - |
| 1353-60 | William Del Strother | - |
| 1361-62 | John De La Chambre | - |
| 1363-64 | Robert of Angerton | - |
| 1364 | Richard of Stanhope | - |
| 1365 | Sir William of Acton | - |
| 1366 | John of Stanhope | - |
| 1367-68 | Sir William of Acton | - |
| 1369-70 | Robert of Angerton | - |
| 1371 | John De La Chambre | - |
| 1372 | Sir William of Acton | - |
| 1373 | John of Bulkham | - |
| 1374 | John of Refham | - |
| 1375-76 | John of Bulkham | - |
| 1377-78 | Richard of Stanhope | - |
| 1379-81 | William of Bishopdale | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne 1378, 1381, 1388, 1390 and 1391 |
| 1382 | Robert Oliver | - |
| 1383 | John of Bulkham | - |
| 1384 | Stephen Whitgray | - |
| 1385 | Adam of Bulkham | - |
| 1386 | Robert Plummer | - |
| 1387 | John of Bulkham | - |
| 1388 | Robert of Raynton | - |
| 1389 | John of Horton | - |
| 1390-92 | William of Bishopdale | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne 1378, 1381, 1388, 1390 and 1391 |
| 1393-95 | Laurence of Acton | - |
| 1396-97 | Sampson Harding | - |
| 1398 | William Johnson |
| 1399-1400 | Henry Karlell | Merchant. MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1388,1394 MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne 1378, 1381, 1388, 1390 and 1391 |
| 1400 | Roger Thornton | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne 1399, 1411, 1417 and 1419 |
| 1401 | Robert Cherden | - |
| 1402-05 | Roger Thornton | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne 1399, 1411, 1417 and 1419 |
| 1406 | Robert Gabefore | - |
| 1407 | William Esyngton | - |
| 1408-09 | William Langton | - |
| 1410 | - | - |
| 1411-12 | William Langton | - |
| 1413-15 | Robert Hebburn (d) | - |
| 1416-17 | Roger Thornton | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1399,1411,1417 and 1419 |
| 1418-19 | John Strother | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne 1417, 1419 and 1421 |
| 1420 | John Bywell | - |
| 1421 | John Strother | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne 1417, 1419 and 1421 |
| 1422 | John Wall | Merchant. MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1420 |
| 1423-25 | Roger Thornton | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1399,1411,1417 and 1419 |
| 1426 | William Ellerby | - |
| 1427 | John Wall | - |
| 1428 | Laurence Acton | - |
| 1429 | John Rodes | - |
| 1430 | John Rodes | - |
| 1431 | John Rodes | - |
| 1432 | Laurence Acton | - |
| 1433 | Laurence Acton | - |
| 1434 | Richard Hall | - |
| 1435 | Robert Whelpington | - |
| 1436 | Richard Hall | - |
| 1437 | Laurence Acton | - |
| 1438 | Robert Whelpington | - |
| 1439 | John Clark | - |
| 1440 | John Chambers | - |
| 1441 | William Harding | - |
| 1442 | Thomas Warde | - |
| 1443 | John Musgrave | - |
| 1444 | William Harding | - |
| 1445 | William Jay | - |
| 1446 | William Harding | - |
| 1447 | William Harding | - |
| 1448 | John Ward | - |
| 1449 | William Harding | - |
| 1450 | John Ward | - |
| 1451 | Robert Baxter | - |
| 1452 | William Harding | - |
| 1453 | John Carlell | - |
| 1454 | John Richardson | - |
| 1455 | John Richardson | - |
| 1456 | John Richardson | - |
| 1457 | John Richardson | - |
| 1458 | John Pendreth | - |
| 1459 | John Richardson | - |
| 1460 | Robert Baxter | - |
| 1461 | John Richardson | - |
| 1462 | Allen Bird | - |
| 1463 | Allen Bird | - |
| 1464 | John Nixon | - |
| 1465 | Allen Bird | - |
| 1466 | John Nixon | - |
| 1467 | William Blaxton | - |
| 1468 | John Nixon | - |
| 1469 | Richard Stevenson | - |
| 1470 | William Blaxton | - |
| 1471J | ohn Nixon | - |
| 1472 | William Blaxton | - |
| 1473 | William Blaxton | - |
| 1474 | Nicholas Haynyng | - |
| 1475 | John Carlell | - |
| 1476 | John Carlell | - |
| 1477 | John Coke | - |
| 1478 | Robert Chambers | - |
| 1479 | John Sample | - |
| 1480 | John Carlell | - |
| 1481 | George Carr | - |
| 1482 | John Coke | - |
| 1483 | John Carlell | - |
| 1484 | George Carr | - |
| 1485 | Richard Chamber | - |
| 1486 | George Carr | - |
| 1487 | George Carr | - |
| 1488 | Thomas Lockwood | - |
| 1489 | George Carr | - |
| 1490 | Peter Bewick | - |
| 1491 | George Carr | - |
| 1492 | George Carr | - |
| 1493 | George Carr | - |
| 1494 | George Bird | - |
| 1495 | George Bird | - |
| 1496 | George Bird | - |
| 1497 | Robert Harding | - |
| 1498 | George Carr | - |
| 1499 | Robert Brigham | - |
| 1500 | George Carr | - |
| 1501 | Bertram Younghusband | - |
| 1502 | George Carr | - |
| 1503 | John Snowe | - |
| 1504 | Christopher Brigham | - |
| 1505 | Christopher Brigham | - |
| 1506 | George Bird | - |
| 1507 | Bertram Younghusband | - |
| 1508 | Robert Baxter | - |
| 1509 | John Brandling | - |
| 1510 | Thomas Riddell | - |
| 1511 | George Bird (d) | - |
| 1511 | Christopher Brigham | - |
| 1512 | John Brandling | - |
| 1513 | John Blaxton | - |
| 1514 | Thomas Horsley | Founder of Royal Grammar School, Newcastle |
| 1515 | Roger Dent | - |
| 1516 | John Brandling | - |
| 1517 | Edward Baxter | - |
| 1518 | Edward Baxter | - |
| 1519 | Thomas Horsley | Founder of Royal Grammar School, Newcastle |
| 1520 | John Brandling | - |
| 1521 | Thomas Riddell | - |
| 1522 | Edward Baxter | - |
| 1523 | Edward Baxter | - |
| 1524-25 | Thomas Horsley | Founder of Royal Grammar School, Newcastle |
| 1526 | Thomas Riddell | - |
| 1527 | John Blaxton | - |
| 1528 | Edward Swinburn | - |
| 1529 | James Lawson | - |
| 1530 | Gilbert Middleton | - |
| 1531 | Robert Brandling | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1545,1547,1553,1555 and 1563 |
| 1532 | Henry Anderson | - |
| 1533 | Thomas Horsley | Founder of Royal Grammar School, Newcastle |
| 1534 | Ralph Carr | - |
| 1535 | Thomas Baxter | - |
| 1536 | Robert Brandling | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1545,1547,1553,1555 and 1563 |
| 1537 | John Sanderson | - |
| 1538 | Andrew Bewick | - |
| 1539 | Henry Anderson | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1529 |
| 1540 | James Lawson | - |
| 1541 | John Hilton | - |
| 1542 | Henry Anderso | - |
| 1543 | Robert Brandling | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1545,1547,1553,1555 and 1563 |
| 1544 | Robert Lewen | - |
| 1545 | George Davell | - |
| 1546 | Henry Anderson | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1529 |
| 1547 | Sir Robert Brandling | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1545,1547,1553,1555 and 1563 |
| 1548 | Mark Shafto | - |
| 1549 | Cuthbert Ellison | - |
| 1550 | Robert Brigham | - |
| 1551 | Bartram Anderson | - |
| 1552 | Robert Lewen | - |
| 1553 | Cuthbert Blunt | - |
| 1554 | Cuthbert Ellison | - |
| 1555 | Richard Hodgson | - |
| 1556 | Christopher Mitford | - |
| 1557 | Bartram Anderson | - |
| 1558 | Oswald Chapman | - |
| 1559 | Robert Ellison | - |
| 1560 | Cuthbert Musgrave | - |
| 1561 | John Wilkinson | - |
| 1562 | William Dent | - |
| 1563 | Bartram Anderson | - |
| 1564 | Sir Robert Brandling | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1545,1547,1553,1555 and 1563 |
| 1565 | William Carr | - |
| 1566 | Richard Hodgson | - |
| 1567 | Robert Anderson | - |
| 1568 | Henry Brandling | - |
| 1569 | Christopher Mitford | - |
| 1570 | Robert Ellison | - |
| 1571 | William Jenison | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1571, 1572 and 1584 |
| 1572 | Thomas Liddell | Merchant, Sheriff of Newcastle in 1563-64. Father of Thomas Liddell, Mayor 1597-98 and 1609-10. |
| 1573 | William Selby | - |
| 1574 | John Watson | - |
| 1575 | Henry Anderson | - |
| 1576 | Henry Brandling | - |
| 1577 | Robert Barker | - |
| 1578 | Mark Shafto | - |
| 1579 | Roger Rawe | - |
| 1580 | Richard Hodgson | - |
| 1581 | William Jenison | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1571, 1572 and 1584 |
| 1582 | William Riddell | - |
| 1583 | Henry Anderson | - |
| 1584 | Henry Mitford | - |
| 1585 | Robert Barker | - |
| 1586 | Henry Chapman | - |
| 1587 | Edward Lewe | - |
| 1588 | Roger Nicholson | - |
| 1589 | William Selby | - |
| 1590 | Robert Atkinson | - |
| 1591 | George Farnaby | - |
| 1592 | Roger Rawe | - |
| 1593 | Lionel Maddison | - |
| 1594 | Henry Anderson | - |
| 1595 | William Riddell | - |
| 1596 | Ralph Jenison (d) | - |
| 1596 | Henry Chapman | - |
| 1597 | Thomas Liddell | Merchant, Sheriff of Newcastle 1592-93. Son of Thomas Liddell (d.1577), Mayor 1572-73. Father of Sir Thomas Liddell, 1st Baronet, Mayor 1625, 1634, and 1636. |
| 1598 | George Farnaby | - |
| 1599 | William Jenison | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1601 and 1614 |
| 1600 | George Selby | - |
| 1601 | Francis Anderson | - |
| 1602 | Robert Dudley | - |
| 1603 | William Warmouth | - |
| 1604 | Thomas Riddel | - |
| 1605 | Lionel Maddison | - |
| 1606 | George Selby | - |
| 1607 | James Clavering | - |
| 1608 | Henry Chapman | - |
| 1609 | Thomas Liddell | Merchant, Sheriff of Newcastle 1592-93. Son of Thomas Liddell (d.1577), Mayor 1572-73, and father of Sir Thomas Liddell, 1st Baronet.. |
| 1610 | William Jenison | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1601 and 1614 |
| 1611 | George Selby | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1601-14 |
| 1612 | Francis Anderson | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1660–1679 |
| 1613 | Sir Henry Anderson | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1614–1628 |
| 1614 | William Warmouth | - |
| 1615 | Francis Burrell | - |
| 1616 | Sir Thomas Riddell | - |
| 1617 | Lionel Maddison | - |
| 1618 | James Clavering | - |
| 1619 | Sir Peter Riddell | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1624-29 |
| 1620 | Henry Chapman | - |
| 1621 | William Jenison | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1601 and 1614 |
| 1622 | George Selby | - |
| 1623 | Henry Bowes | - |
| 1624 | William Hall | - |
| 1625 | Thomas Liddell | - |
| 1626 | Alexander Davison | - |
| 1627 | Henry Chapman | - |
| 1628 | Robert Bewick | - |
| 1629 | John Clavering | - |
| 1630 | Robert Anderson | - |
| 1631 | William Warmouth | - |
| 1632 | Sir Lionel Maddison | - |
| 1633 | Ralph Cole | - |
| 1634 | Ralph Cock | - |
| 1635 | Sir Peter Riddell | - |
| 1636 | Thomas Liddell | - |
| 1637 | John Marlay | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1661-1673 |
| 1638 | Alexander Davison | - |
| 1639 | Robert Bewick | - |
| 1640 | Sir Nicholas Cole, Bart | - |
| 1641 | Sir Nicholas Cole, Bart | - |
| 1642-4 | Sir John Marley | |
| 1644 | Henry Warmouth | - |
| 1645 | John Blaxton | - |
| 1646 | Henry Dawson | - |
| 1647 | Thomas Ledger | - |
| 1648 | Thomas Bonner | - |
| 1649 | William Dawson | - |
| 1650 | George Dawson | - |
| 1651 | Thomas Bonner | - |
| 1652 | Henry Dawson (d) | - |
| 1652 | George Dawson | - |
| 1653 | William Johnson | - |
| 1654 | William Johnson | - |
| 1655 | Robert Shaftoe | - |
| 1656 | Henry Rawling | - |
| 1657 | George Dawson | - |
| 1658 | Mark Milbank | - |
| 1659 | Thomas Bonner | - |
| 1660 | John Emmerson | - |
| 1661 | Sir John Marley | - |
| 1662 | Francis Anderson | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1660–1679 |
| 1663 | Sir James Clavering | MP for Durham, 1656-58 |
| 1664 | Sir Francis Liddel | Son of Sir Thomas Liddell, 1st Baronet who had been Mayor in 1626-27 and 1636-37. Sir Francis had served as Sheriff of Newcastle in 1640. |
| 1665 | Henry Maddison | - |
| 1666 | William Blackett | Businessman. MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1673 and 1679 |
| 1667 | Henry Brabant | - |
| 1668 | Ralph Jennison | - |
| 1669 | Thomas Davison | - |
| 1670 | William Carr | - |
| 1671 | Ralph Grey | - |
| 1672 | Mark Milbank | - |
| 1673 | Timothy Davison | - |
| 1674 | Thomas Jennison | - |
| 1675 | Francis Anderson | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1660–1679 |
| 1676 | Sir Ralph Carr | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1679, 1881, 1689 and 1690 |
| 1677 | Robert Roddam | - |
| 1678 | Matthew Jeffryson | - |
| 1679 | George Morton | - |
| 1680 | Sir Nathaniel Johnson | - |
| 1681 | Timothy Robson | - |
| 1682 | Nicholas Fenwick | - |
| 1683 | William Blackett | - |
| 1684 | William Aubone | - |
| 1685 | Sir Henry Brabant | - |
| 1686 | Nicholas Cole | - |
| 1687 | John Squire (r) | - |
| 1687 | Sir William Creagh | - |
| 1688 | William Hutchinson (r) | - |
| 1688 | Nicholas Ridley | - |
| 1689 | William Carr | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1690–1710 |
| 1690 | William Ramsey | - |
| 1691 | Matthew White | - |
| 1692 | Thomas Wasse | - |
| 1693 | Sir Ralph Carr | - |
| 1694 | Joseph Atkinson | - |
| 1695 | Timothy Robson | - |
| 1696 | George Whinfield | - |
| 1697 | Nicholas Fenwick | - |
| 1698 | Sir William Blackett | - |
| 1699 | Robert Eden | - |
| 1700 | George Henderson | - |
| 1701 | William Ramsey | - |
| 1702 | William Carr | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1690–1710 |
| 1703 | Matthew White | - |
| 1704 | Thomas Wasse | - |
| 1705 | Sir Ralph Carr | - |
| 1706 | Nicholas Ridley | - |
| 1707 | Joseph Atkinson | - |
| 1708 | Robert Fenwick | - |
| 1709 | George Whinfield (d) | - |
| 1709 | Jonathan Rodham | - |
| 1710 | William Ellison | - |
| 1711 | Matthew Fetherstonhaugh | - |
| 1712 | Henry Reay | - |
| 1713 | Richard Ridley | - |
| 1714 | Edward Johnson | - |
| 1715 | Henry Dalston | - |
| 1716 | Ralph Reed | - |
| 1717 | Francis Rudstone | - |
| 1718 | Sir William Blackett | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1710–28 |
| 1719 | Joseph Green | - |
| 1720 | Nicholas Fenwick | - |
| 1721 | Francis Johnson | - |
| 1722 | William Ellison | - |
| 1723 | Matthew Fetherstonhaugh | - |
| 1724 | William Carr | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1722–27, 1729–34 |
| 1725 | Nathaniel Clayton | - |
| 1726 | Nicholas Fenwick | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1727-47 |
| 1727 | Cuthbert Fenwick | - |
| 1728 | Stephen Coulson | - |
| 1729 | Henry Reay | - |
| 1730 | Francis Rudston | - |
| 1731 | Robert Sorsbie | - |
| 1732 | Richard Ridley | - |
| 1733 | Matthew Ridley | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1747-74 |
| 1734 | William Ellison | - |
| 1735 | Sir Walter Blackett, Bart | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1734–77 |
| 1736 | Nicholas Fenwick | - |
| 1737 | William Carr | - |
| 1738 | Nathaniel Clayton | - |
| 1739 | Cuthbert Fenwick | - |
| 1740 | Edward Collingwood | - |
| 1741 | Robert Sorsbie | - |
| 1742 | John Simpson | - |
| 1743 | Ralph Sowerby | - |
| 1744 | John Ord (d) | - |
| 1744 | Matthew Ridley | - |
| 1745 | Cuthbert Smith | - |
| 1746 | Nicholas Fenwick | - |
| 1747 | NicholasFenwick | - |
| 1748 | Sir Walter Blackett, Bart | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1734–77 |
| 1749 | Robert Sorsbie | - |
| 1750 | Ralph Sowerby | - |
| 1751 | Matthew Ridley | - |
| 1752 | Henry Partis | - |
| 1753 | Henry Eden | - |
| 1754 | Cuthbert Smit | - |
| 1755 | William Clayton | - |
| 1756 | Sir Walter Blackett, Bart | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1734–77 |
| 1757 | Matthew Bell | - |
| 1758 | Ralph Sowerby | - |
| 1759 | Matthew Ridley | - |
| 1760 | Henry Partis | - |
| 1761 | Aubone Surtees | - |
| 1762 | Cuthbert Smith | - |
| 1763 | William Clayton | - |
| 1764 | Sir Walter Blackett, Bart | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1734–77 |
| 1765 | John Erasmus Blackett | Businessman |
| 1766 | Matthew Scafe | - |
| 1767 | Edward Mosley | - |
| 1768 | John Baker | - |
| 1769 | Francis Forster | - |
| 1770 | Aubone Surtees | - |
| 1771 | Sir Walter Blackett, Bart | MP for Newcastle-upon-Tyne, 1734–77 |
| 1772 | John Erasmus Blackett | Businessman |
| 1773 | Matthew Scafe (d) | - |
| 1773 | Edward Mosley | - |
| 1774 | Sir Matthew White Ridley, 2nd Baronet | MP for Morpeth, 1768 and Newcastle, 1774 |
| 1775 | Charles Atkinson | - |
| 1776 | John Baker | - |
| 1777 | John Hedley | - |
| 1778 | Hugh Hornby | - |
| 1779 | Francis Forster | - |
| 1780 | John Erasmus Blackett | - |
| 1781 | Edward Mosley | - |
| 1782 | Sir Matthew White Ridley, 2nd Baronet | MP for Morpeth, 1768 and Newcastle, 1774 |
| 1783 | Charles Atkinson | - |
| 1784 | James Rudman | - |
| 1785 | William Yielder | - |
| 1786 | Francis Johnson | - |
| 1787 | William Cramlington | - |
| 1788 | John Hedley | - |
| 1789 | Hugh Hornby | - |
| 1790 | John Erasmus Blackett | Businessman |
| 1791 | Sir Matthew White Ridley, 2nd Baronet | MP for Morpeth, 1768 and Newcastle, 1774 |
| 1792 | James Rudman | - |
| 1793 | William Yielder | - |
| 1794 | Francis Johnson | - |
| 1795 | Richard Chambers | - |
| 1796 | William Cramlington | - |
| 1797 | Anthony Hood | - |
| 1798 | John Wallis | - |
| 1799 | Robert Shafto Hedley | - |
| 1800 | Archibald Reed | - |
| 1801 | Joseph Forster | - |
| 1802 | Thomas Clennell | - |
| 1803 | Thomas Smith | - |
| 1804 | Robert Clayton | - |
| 1805 | Henry Cramlington | - |
| 1806 | Archibald Reed | - |
| 1807 | Anthony Hood | - |
| 1808 | Joseph Forster | - |
| 1809 | Isaac Cookson, jnr. | - |
| 1810 | Thomas Burdon | - |
| 1811 | George Forster | - |
| 1812 | Robert Clayton | - |
| 1813 | Thomas Smith | - |
| 1814 | Benjamin Sorsbie | - |
| 1815 | Henry Cramlington | - |
| 1816 | Sir Thomas Burdon | - |
| 1817 | Robert Clayton | - |
| 1818 | Joseph Forster | - |
| 1819 | Archibald Reed | - |
| 1820 | George ForsterJ | - |
| 1821 | Aubone Surtees | - |
| 1822 | Robert Bell | - |
| 1823 | William Wright | - |
| 1824 | Henry Cramlington | - |
| 1825 | George Forster | - |
| 1826 | Archibald Reed | - |
| 1827 | Benjamin Sorsbie | - |
| 1828 | Robert Bell | - |
| 1829 | George Shadforth | - |
| 1830 | Archibald Reed | - |
| 1831 | Archibald Reed | - |
| 1832 | John Brandling | - |
| 1833 | Henry Bell | - |
| 1834 | John Lionel Hood | - |
| 1835 | Charles John Bigge | - |
| 1836 | Joseph Lamb | - |
| 1837 | Thomas Emerson Headlam | - |
| 1838 | John Fife | - |
| 1839 | John Carr | - |
| 1840 | John Ridley | - |
| 1841 | James Hodgson | - |
| 1842 | Thomas Dunn | - |
| 1843 | Sir John Fife | - |
| 1844 | Addison Langhorn Potter | - |
| 1845 | Thomas Emerson Headlam | - |
| 1846 | James Archbold | - |
| 1847 | Stephen Lowrey | - |
| 1848 | James Dent Weatherley | Former Captain of 60th Royal Rifles |
| 1849 | Joseph Crawhall | - |
| 1850 | William Armstrong | Corn merchant and improver of the River Tyne |
| 1851 | James Hodgson | - |
| 1852 | Nathaniel Grace Lambert | - |
| 1853 | Ralph Dodds | - |
| 1854 | Isaac Lowthian Bell | Ironmaster |
| 1855 | Ralph Park Philipson | - |
| 1856 | Edward Nathaniel Grace | Sheriff, 1854 |
| 1857 | Anthony Nichol | - |
| 1858 | Joseph Laycock | - |
| 1859 | John Blackwell | - |
| 1860 | Henry Ingledew | - |
| 1861 | Joseph Armstrong | - |
| 1862 | Isaac Lowthian Bell | Ironmaster |
| 1863 | Thomas Hedley | - |
| 1864 | Edward Mosley Perkins | - |
| 1865 | Ralph Dodds | - |
| 1866 | William Hunter | - |
| 1867 | Henry Angus | - |
| 1868 | James Morrison | - |
| 1869 | James Morrison | - |
| 1870 | Richard Burdon Sanderson | - |
| 1871 | Thomas Leslie Gregson | - |
| 1872 | Richard Cail | - |
| 1873 | Addison Potter | - |
| 1874 | Addison Potter | - |
| 1875 | William Haswell Stephenson | - |
| 1876 | John Oliver Scott | Alderman, Magistrate, Shipping Owner, Coal Sites Owner, In Mayoral Office for the visit of General Ulysses S. Grant to the North East of England in 1877, (Also in office as Sheriff 1874-75) |
| 1877-78 | Thomas Robinson | - |
| 1879 | Richard Cail | - |
| 1880-81 | Jonathan Angus | - |
| 1882 | Thomas George Gibson | - |
| 1883 | Henry William Newton | Surgeon and Alderman |
| 1884 | William Haswell Stephenson | - |
| 1885 | Benjamin Chapman Browne | - |
| 1886-87 | |
| 1877-78 | Thomas Robinson | - |
| 1879 | Richard Cail | - |
| 1880-81 | Jonathan Angus | - |
| 1882 | Thomas George Gibson | - |
| 1883 | Henry William Newton | - |
| 1884 | William Haswell Stephenson | - |
| 1885 | Benjamin Chapman Browne | - |
| 1886 | Sir Benjamin Chapman Browne | - |
| 1887 | William Davies Stephens | - |
| 1888 | Thomas Richardson | - |
| 1889 | Thomas Bell | - |
| 1890 | Joseph Baxter Ellis | - |
| 1891 | William Sutton | - |
| 1892 | Edward Culley | - |
| 1893 | Stephen Quin | - |
| 1894 | William Haswell Stephenson | - |
| 1895 | Riley Lord | - |
| 1896 | John Goolden | - |
| 1897 | Thomas Barkas Sanderson | - |
| 1898 | George Harkus | - |
| 1899 | Sir Riley Lord | - |
| 1900 | John Beattie | - |
| 1901 | Henry William Newton | - |
| 1902 [5] | Sir William Haswell Stephenson | - fourth term |
| 1903 | Andrew Peter Anderson | - |
| 1904 | Joseph Baxter Ellis | - |
| 1905 | Sir Joseph Baxter Ellis | - |
| 1906 | John Matthew Oubridge | - |
| 1907 | William John Sanderson | - |
| 1908 | John James Forster | - |
| 1909 | Sir William Haswell Stephenson | - |
| 1910 | Sir William Haswell Stephenson | - |
| 1911 | Sir William Haswell Stephenson | - |
| 1912 | John Frederick Weidner | - |
| 1913 | Johnstone Wallace | - |
| 1914 | John Fitzgerald | Brewer |
| 1915-7 | George Lunn | Liberal Party politician |
| 1918 | Arthur Munro Sutherland | Shipowner and philanthropist |
| 1919 | Walter Lee | - |
| 1920 | Thomas William Rowe | - |
| 1921 | Richard Henry Millican | - |
| 1922 | William Bramble | - |
| 1923 | Stephen Easten | - |
| 1924 | Walter Lee | - |
| 1925 | Anthony Oates | - |
| 1926 | Arthur William Lambert | - |
| 1927 | Stephen Easten | - |
| 1928 | Arthur William Lambert | - |
| 1929 | Joseph Stephenson | - |
| 1930 | David Adams | - |
| 1931 | John George Nixon jnr. | - |
| 1932 | Joseph William Leech | - |
| 1933 | John Leadbitter | - |
| 1934 | Robert Stanley Dalgleish | - |
| 1935 | William Locke | - |
| 1936 | John Grantham | - |
| 1937 | Gilbert Oliver | - |
| 1938 | William Robert Wallace | - |
| 1939 | Adamson Dawson Russell | - |
| 1940 | Adamson Dawson Russell | - |
| 1941 | George Dixon | - |
| 1942 | Walter Thompson | - |
| 1944 | Thomas Clements | - |
| 1945 | James Alexander Clydesdale | - |
| 1946 | James Pearson | - |
| 1947/8 | Thomas McCutcheon | - |
| 1949 | AaronCharlton Curry | - |
| 1950 | Norman Hackworth Chapman | - |
| 1951 | William McKeag | - |
| 1952 | Violet Hardisty Grantham | - |
| 1953 | William McKeag | - |
| 1954 | Robert Mould-Graham | - |
| 1955 | Henry Waller | - |
| 1956 | Aaron Charlton Curry (d) | - |
| 1956 | Violet Hardisty Grantham | - |
| 1957 | John William Telford | - |
| 1958 | Dorothy Ann Fitzpatrick | - |
| 1959 | Catherine Campbell Scott | - |
| 1960 | Gladys Robson | - |
| 1961 | Henry Russell | - |
| 1962 | George Jacobson | - |
| 1963 | Henry Simm (d) | - |
| 1963 | Peter Henry Renwick | - |
| 1964 | Peter Henry Renwick | - |
| 1965 | Theresa Science Russell | - |
| 1966 | Jonathan Farries Burton | - |
| 1967 | Albert Roy Hadwin | - |
| 1968 | Robert Skinner Gray | - |
| 1969 | William Ritchie Samuel Forsyth | - |
| 1970 | William Harding | - |
| 1971 | Madge Elaine Graham | - |
| 1972 | Arthur Grey | - |
| 1973 | Arthur Grey | - |
| 1974 | Margaret Collins | Honorary Freeman in 1980, represented St. Lawrence until 1982 |
| 1975 | Iris Margaret Steedman | Represented West City Ward until 1992. Honorary Alderman 1992 Awarded an MBE in 1999. |
| 1976 | Hugh Jackson White | Represented Blakelaw Ward until 1987. |
| 1977 | Thomas Watson Collins | Honorary Freeman in 1980 Represented Monkchester Ward to 1987. Honorary Alderman in 1987. |
| 1978 | Doris Alma Starkey | Represented Elswick Ward until 1981. |
| 1979 | Margaret Stevens Murray | Represented Moorside Ward until 1983. |
| 1980 | John Charlton Kerrigan | Represent Woolsington Ward until 1997. Honorary Alderman in 1997. |
| 1981 | Bennie Abrahams | Represented Monkchester Ward until 1986. Honorary Alderman in 1986. |
| 1982 | Thomas William Yellowley | Represented Benwell Ward until his death in 1995 |
| 1983 | Arthur Fletcher Stabler | Represent West City Ward until his death in 1997 |
| 1984 | Norman Stockdale | Represented Walker Ward until his death in 1987 |
| 1985 | Royston Craig Burgess | Represented Walker Ward until his death in 1987 |
| 1986 | James Peter Laing | Represented Fawdon Ward until 2004. Honorary Alderman 2005 |
| 1987 | Stanley John Clark Allan | Represented Woolsington Ward until his death in 1991 |
| 1988 | Derek Webster | Represented Lemington Ward until 1990 |
| 1989 | Terence Cooney | Represented Fenham Ward until his death in 2008. |
| 1990 | Cuthbert Stephenson | Represented Denton Ward until 1996. Honorary Alderman in 1996 |
| 1991 | Thomas Johnston Marr | Represented Byker Ward until his death in 1998 |
| 1992 | Cecil Arthur Cook | Represented Benwell Ward until his death in 2002 |
| 1993 | Joan Margaret Lamb | Represented Scotswood Ward until 2000. Honorary Alderman in 2000 |
| 1994 | Robert Crofton Brown | Represented Newburn Ward until his death in 1996 |
| 1995 | Bernard Rice | Represent Walkergate Ward until 2004. Honorary Alderman in 2005 |
| 1996 | Leslie Alexander Russell | Represented Monkchester Ward until 1999. Honorary Alderman in 1999. |
| 1997 | Mary Isabel Nixon | Represented Newburn Ward until her death in 2002 |
| 1998 | Thomas Daniel Marshall | Represented Newburn Ward until 2004. Honorary Alderman in 2005. |
| 1999 | John Cunningham | Represented Walker Ward until his death in July 2003 |
| 2000 | Peter John Stuart Thomson | Represented Elswick Ward until 2004 |
| 2001 | Mary Jane Carr | Represented Denton Ward until 2004. |
| 2002 | John Marshall | Represented Wingrove Ward until 2004. Honorary Alderman in 2008 |
| 2003 | Margaret Richardson Carter | Represented Kenton Ward until 2012. |
| 2004 | George William Douglas | Represented Walker Ward until 2007. Honorary Alderman in 2007. |
| 2005 | David Serge Slesenger | Represented East Gosforth Ward until 2018 |
| 2006 | Diane Margaret Packham | Represented Parklands Ward until 2017 |
| 2007 | Peter John Arnold | Represented Denton Ward until 2010 |
| 2008 | David Leslie Wood | Represented Walker Ward as of 2019 |
| 2009 | Michael Cookson | Represented East Gosforth ward to 2011 |
| 2010 | Brenda Hindmarsh | Represented Fawdon & West Gosforth Ward as of 2019 |
| 2011 | Geoff O'Brien | Represented Westgate Ward |
| 2012 | Jackie Slesenger | Represented West Gosforth until 2018 |
| 2013 | Margaret Wood | Represented Walker Ward as of 2019 |
| 2014 | George Pattison | Represented Kingston Park South and Newbiggin Hall Ward as of 2019 |
| 2015 | Ian Graham | Represented Castle Ward until 2018 |
| 2016 | Hazel Stephenson | Represented Benwell and Scotswood Ward as of 2019 |
| 2017 | Linda Wright | Represented Callerton & Throckley Ward as of 2019 |
| 2018 | David Down | Represented Parklands Warduntil 2019 |
| 2019 | David Cook | Represented Lemington Ward as of 2019 |
