Malaysian football naturalisation scandal

Last updated

In September 2025, FIFA has imposed fines and suspension to seven players who have played for the Malaysia national football team. The world governing body has alleged that the Football Association of Malaysia (FAM) have provided forged documents for seven foreign-born Malaysian players. [1] FAM has denied wrongdoings and has appealed the sanctions.

Contents

Background

In 2018, the Malaysia national football team dropped to 178th place in the FIFA rankings, its lowest ever. [2] This prompted the Football Association of Malaysia (FAM) to begin scouting for "heritage players" or players of foreign origin who are asked to changed sporting nationality to be able to play for the national team either through residency or Malaysian ancestry. [3]

From 2018 to October 2025, 23 footballers have been granted Malaysian citizenship. [3] [4]

2025 naturalisation of seven players

Rodrigo Holgado, an Argentine who was one of the seven players that was nautralised by Malaysia under forged documents Rodrigo Holgado Universidad Catolica v Coquimbo Unido 20230723 01.jpg
Rodrigo Holgado, an Argentine who was one of the seven players that was nautralised by Malaysia under forged documents

In January 2025, the Crown Prince of Johor Tunku Ismail Sultan Ibrahim announced that six to seven "heritage players" had been identified for possible inclusion in the national football team. He expressed hope that the Malaysian government would assist them in obtaining Malaysian passports to enable their participation in the 2027 AFC Asian Cup qualifiers.

Tunku Ismail also owns Johor Darul Ta'zim F.C. (JDT), a club that he has heavily financed and which has maintained dominance in Malaysian domestic football for over a decade. [2] Between March to June 2025, the FAM processed the FIFA eligibility for seven players by submitting their and their grandparents birth certificates. FIFA cleared the players and were ruled eligible to play for the Malaysian national team. [2] [5]

The seven players were:

All featured in Malaysia's 4–0 win against Vietnam in the 10 June 2025 AFC Asian Cup qualifiers match. [3]

FIFA investigation and sanctions

FIFA received a anonymous complaint a day after the Vietnam game disputing the eligibility of the seven players. [6] In August 2025, FIFA opened disciplinary proceedings agaisnt the FAM. This action was not known to the general public. [2]

On 26 September, FIFA announced its imposing a fine of CHF 350,000 (approximately RM 1.9 million) on FAM, while the seven player received an individual fine of CHF 2,000 (about RM 10,560) and a 12 month suspension from all football related activities. [7] This was when the scandal became known to the public. [2]

FIFA released an official report on 6 October detailing falsifications concerning the players' eligibility, including the alleged birthplaces of their grandparents. While the FAM claimed that the seven players had grandparents born in Malaysia, FIFA discovered that their grandparents had in fact been born in Argentina, Brazil, Spain and the Netherlands. [8] [9]

Reactions

The scandal has put the FAM as well as the Ministry of Home Affairs and the National Registration Department (NRD), the government agencies responsible for handling Malaysian citizenship has been subject of scrutiny from Malaysia football fans and legislators. [10] [11] The FAM acknowledged "technical errors" on the document submission but maintained that the seven players are Malaysian citizens. [12]

Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail says that the issue is about the seven players' compliance under FIFA eligibility rules rather than their citizenship. He says that birth certificates are not required for naturalisation under Malaysia's Constitution and maintained that the players satisfied the prerequisites required to obtain citizenship which includes good conduct, the required residency period and Malaysian Malay proficiency using ministerial discretion on residency requirements. [11] [13]

Tunku Ismail and former sports minister Khairy Jamaluddin questioned the FIFA sanctions. Tunku Ismail alleged that an external party might have influenced the world football body. Both questioned FIFA's apparent reversal since the seven players were already cleared to play. [12] The NRD denied involvement in the alleged falsification of documents. [14]

Criticism of government priorities

The scandal also drew attention to the plight of stateless individuals in Malaysian states such as Sabah, [15] as well as the complex citizenship status of foundlings born in Malaysia and children born to unmarried Malaysian mothers. Critics pointed out the opaque citizenship process in Malaysia, noting that individuals with genuine ties to the country are often denied citizenship. In contrast, citizenship were readily granted to foreigners under questionable circumstances, including cases involving falsified documents for football players. This raised concerns about the government's misplaced priorities. [3]

References

  1. Koh Ewe (7 October 2025). "Fifa accuses Malaysia of faking players' citizenship records". BBC News. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 "Fans, critics say 'many unanswered questions' on Malaysia football scandal, as minister defends citizenship process". CNA. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Lopez, Leslie (10 October 2025). "FIFA's fraud findings go beyond football scandal, with political ramifications for Malaysia". CNA. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  4. Azmi, Hadi (9 October 2025). "Fifa claims Malaysia cheated but players are citizens, minister says". South China Morning Post. Archived from the original on 9 October 2025. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  5. "Malaysia to lodge immediate appeal after receiving full FIFA ban report: Timeline in full". ESPN.com. 7 October 2025. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  6. Bhwana, Petir Garda (8 October 2025). "FIFA Sanctions Seven Naturalized Players and Malaysian Football Association". Tempo. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  7. "FIFA Sanctions On FAM: AFC Awaits Football Tribunal Verdict". bernama.com. Bernama. 27 September 2025. Retrieved 27 September 2025.
  8. Onyeagwara, Nnamdi (7 October 2025). "Malaysia to appeal FIFA sanction over alleged fake documents for seven players". nytimes.com. The Athletic. Archived from the original on 7 October 2025. Retrieved 7 October 2025 via The New York Times.
  9. Ewe, Koh (7 October 2025). "Fifa accuses Malaysia of faking players' citizenship records". www.bbc.com. BBC News. Archived from the original on 7 October 2025. Retrieved 7 October 2025.
  10. "Malaysia defends naturalization process for banned players as scandal widens". Asahi Shimbun. Reuters. 9 October 2025. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  11. 1 2 "Malaysia defends naturalisation process for banned football players as scandal widens". The Straits Times. 9 October 2025. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  12. 1 2 "Malaysia's football association admits 'technical error' in document submission for 7 naturalised players banned by FIFA". CNA. 29 September 2025. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  13. "Fifa rules not tied to citizenship process, says Saifuddin". The Malaysian Reserve. 10 October 2025. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  14. Kumar, B. Nantha (11 October 2025). "Fifa's 'forged document' claims don't involve NRD, source claims". Malaysiakini. Retrieved 14 October 2025.
  15. Augustin, Sean (11 October 2025). "FAM fiasco shows fake glory prioritised over human rights, says activist". Free Malaysia Today. Retrieved 14 October 2025.