Malcontents (Low Countries)

Last updated

The Malcontents in the context of the Eighty Years' War or the Dutch Revolt were a faction of Catholic nobles in Hainaut and Artois who openly opposed William the Silent, also known as William of Orange, the leader of the States General of the Netherlands in the Union of Brussels of the Habsburg Netherlands during the period after the adoption of the Pacification of Ghent. They formed the Union of Arras in January 1579 and negotiated a separate peace with the Spanish Crown, represented by the royal governor-general Alexander Farnese, Duke of Parma, in the form of the Treaty of Arras (1579), signed on 17 May 1579.

Contents

History

After the provinces of the Habsburg Netherlands in 1576 formed a united front against their overlord, Philip II of Spain, when they concluded the Pacification of Ghent and the Union of Brussels, they soon achieved most of their goals as Philip and his new governor-general Don Juan saw no other option than to accept those treaties and remove the mercenaries of the Spanish Army of Flanders from the country. The rebelling provinces of Holland and Zeeland were reunited with the rest of the country under the government of the States General and the Council of State in which Orange was the leading noble. Under the Pacification of Ghent Calvinists in Holland and Zeeland received freedom of religion next to the Catholic Church that was to remain the dominant religion in the other provinces. But soon Calvinists in other provinces demanded freedom of religion also, and adherents of both religions started to use force against one another. This caused great unrest in the conservative Catholic provinces of the South, like Hainaut and Artois (but also Namur and Luxembourg) where the Catholic nobility saw its position and that of their church threatened. [1]

Conquest of Menen by the Malcontents, 24 september 1578 Menen veroverd door de Malcontenten, 1578.JPG
Conquest of Menen by the Malcontents, 24 september 1578
Conquest of Kortrijk by the Malcontents and Philip, Count of Egmont, 27 february 1580 Malcontenten.jpg
Conquest of Kortrijk by the Malcontents and Philip, Count of Egmont, 27 february 1580

When the Calvinists seized power in several Flemish and Brabant cities, like Ghent (where they founded a Calvinist republic), Bruges and Antwerp and started to repress Catholics in those cities, Walloon irregular troops in the employ of the army of the States General (the precursor of the Dutch States Army) mutinied. They became known as "Malcontents", [Note 1] when they seized the city of Menen on 6 September 1578 under the command of Emanuel Philibert de Lalaing (commonly referred to as "Montigny" in the literature), the brother of the stadtholder of Hainaut, Philip de Lalaing, 3rd Count of Lalaing. This "coup" enhanced the reputation of Montigny appreciably among Catholic partisans, [2] and his troops were soon reinforced with the mercenary troops of the Duke of Anjou, who left the country dejectedly in the Summer of 1578. Many of the commanders of the States Army that was destroyed by Parma in the Battle of Gembloux (1578) also flocked to Montigny's banner, like Antoine de Goignies (commonly known as "La Motte"), who had become governor of Gravelines for the States General, but was in secret communication with Don Juan. [3]

From a designation of Montigny's irregulars the word "Malcontents" soon became a kind of "nom de gueux" for partisans of the Catholic cause in general, as opposed to the Calvinist faction, and the moderate "Politiques" around William of Orange. Montigny and his brother Philip, using Philip's power base in Hainaut, started communications between Parma (after Don Juan died in October 1578) and the States of Hainaut and Artois, and a number of city governments (Lille, Arras, Orchies, and Douai, together forming French Flanders), under the influence of the governor of Lille, Adrien d'Ognies, seigneur de Willerval. This led to a congress of representatives of those political entities in Arras that on 6 January 1579 subscribed to a declaration in which the "machinations" of the Calvinists and the "weak" religious-peace policies of William were denounced, and the participants swore to uphold the Catholic religion and to support each other in this endeavor. This alliance became known as the Union of Arras. [4]

Finally, the members of the Union started formal peace negotiations with Parma, which issued in the signing of the Treaty of Arras (1579) on 17 May 1579. In a sense this was a triumph of the great nobles who had before 1566 opposed Cardinal Granvelle, but at the price of a permanent breach between the Northern Netherlands (united in the Union of Utrecht) and the Southern Netherlands that would soon evolve from the Union of Arras to the Spanish Netherlands. [5]

Notes and references

Notes

  1. Possibly in reference to the contemporaneous French Malcontents, though the term was also used in contemporaneous Scotland in contradistinction with "Biencontents". Cf. Kerr-Peterson, Miles and Steven J. Reid (2016). James VI and Noble Power in Scotland 1578-1603. Routledge. ISBN   9781351982870 . Retrieved 30 November 2018.

Related Research Articles

The Union of Utrecht was a treaty signed on 23 January 1579 in Utrecht, Netherlands, unifying the northern provinces of the Netherlands, until then under the control of Habsburg Spain.

The Union of Arras was an alliance between the County of Artois, the County of Hainaut and the city of Douai in the Habsburg Netherlands in early 1579 during the Eighty Years' War. Dissatisfied with the religious policies of rebel leader Prince of Orange and the States General of the Netherlands, and especially the rise of the radical Calvinist Republic of Ghent since October 1577, they signed a declaration on 6 January 1579 about their intent to offer a vigorous defense of the Roman Catholic religion against what they saw as encroachments by Calvinists in other provinces. These signatories would begin negotiations for a separate peace with the Spanish Crown, which resulted in the Treaty of Arras of 17 May 1579.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eighty Years' War</span> War in the Habsburg Netherlands (c. 1566/1568–1648)

The Eighty Years' War or Dutch Revolt was an armed conflict in the Habsburg Netherlands between disparate groups of rebels and the Spanish government. The causes of the war included the Reformation, centralisation, excessive taxation, and the rights and privileges of the Dutch nobility and cities.

The Pacification of Ghent, signed on 8 November 1576, was an alliance between the provinces of the Habsburg Netherlands. The main objectives were to remove Spanish mercenaries who had made themselves hated by all sides due to their plundering, and to promote a formal peace with the rebellious provinces of Holland and Zeeland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">County of Artois</span> Historic province of the Kingdom of France

The County of Artois was a historic province of the Kingdom of France, held by the Dukes of Burgundy from 1384 until 1477/82, and a state of the Holy Roman Empire from 1493 until 1659.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Gembloux (1578)</span> Battle during the Eighty Years War

The Battle of Gembloux took place at Gembloux, near Namur, Low Countries, between the Spanish forces led by Don John of Austria, Governor-General of the Spanish Netherlands, and a rebel army composed of Dutch, Flemish, English, Scottish, German, French, and Walloon soldiers under Antoine de Goignies, during the Eighty Years' War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Maastricht (1579)</span> Part of the Eighty Years War

The siege of Maastricht was a battle of the Eighty Years' War which lasted from March 12 to July 1, 1579. The Spanish were victorious.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Habsburg Netherlands</span> Entire period of Habsburg rule in the Low Countries (1482-1797)

Habsburg Netherlands was the Renaissance period fiefs in the Low Countries held by the Holy Roman Empire's House of Habsburg. The rule began in 1482, when the last Valois-Burgundy ruler of the Netherlands, Mary, wife of Maximilian I of Austria, died. Their grandson, Emperor Charles V, was born in the Habsburg Netherlands and made Brussels one of his capitals.

Robert de Melun, viscount of Ghent and marquis of Roubaix, was a nobleman from the Low Countries who fought in the Eighty Years' War.

Emanuel Filibert van Lalaing was a noble and army commander from the Low Countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Borgerhout</span> 1579 battle of the Eighty Years War

The Battle of Borgerhout was a battle during the Eighty Years' War, of the Spanish Army of Flanders led by Alexander Farnese, Prince of Parma, upon a fortified camp at the village of Borgerhout, near Antwerp, where several thousand French, English, Scottish, and Walloon soldiers in service of the recently created Union of Utrecht were stationed. It took place during the reconquest by the armies of Philip II of Spain of the Burgundian Netherlands, whose different provinces had united in 1576 under the Pacification of Ghent to drive out the foreign troops and to grant religious liberty to Protestants.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Treaty of Arras (1579)</span> 1579 peace treaty between Spain and Artois, Hainaut, and Walloon Flanders

The Treaty of Arras of 17 May 1579 was a peace treaty concluded between the Spanish Crown, represented by Alexander Farnese, Duke of Parma, and representatives of the County of Hainaut, the County of Artois, and the cities of Douai, Lille, Orchies and Arras, all members of the Union of Arras, that had been formed on the 6 January 1579.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carel Hendrik Theodoor Bussemaker</span> Dutch historian

Carel Hendrik Theodoor Bussemaker was a Dutch historian who held chairs in history at the University of Groningen and the University of Leiden.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Calvinist Republic of Ghent</span>

The Calvinist Republic of Ghent was a Calvinist republic that existed between 1577 and 1584 in the Flemish independent city of Ghent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jan van Hembyse</span> Flemish politician

Jan van Hembyse or Hembyze was a Flemish politician and popular leader, with a demagogic tendency, who together with François van Ryhove brought about the Calvinist Republic of Ghent and for two periods led that regime in the early stage of the Dutch Revolt and the Eighty Years' War as it unfolded in the County of Flanders.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Ghent (1583–1584)</span> 1583–1584 siege

The siege of Ghent during the Eighty Years' War by Spanish general Alexander Farnese, Prince of Parma, lasted from October 1583 to 17 September 1584. It was the end phase of the so-called Calvinist Republic of Ghent, which had controlled most of the County of Flanders since radical Protestants seized power on 28 October 1577, claiming a leading role for the city of Ghent in the struggle against the Spanish royal forces and Malcontent Catholics.

Mathieu Moulart (1536–1600), alternatively Moullart or Moulard, was an abbot and bishop in the Habsburg Netherlands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eighty Years' War, 1576–1579</span> Third phase of the Eighty Years War

The period between the Pacification of Ghent, and the Unions of Arras and Utrecht constituted a crucial phase of the Eighty Years' War between the Spanish Empire and the rebelling United Provinces, which would become the independent Dutch Republic. Sometimes known as the "general revolt", the period marked the only time of the war where the States–General of all Seventeen Provinces of the Habsburg Netherlands, except Luxemburg, were in joint active political and military rebellion against the Spanish Imperial government through the Pacification of Ghent. The Pacification formulated several agreements amongst the rebellious provinces themselves, and laid down their demands – including the immediate withdrawal of foreign troops from the Netherlands, restitution of old rights and privileges, and self-rule – to king Philip II of Spain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eighty Years' War, 1579–1588</span> Fourth phase of the Eighty Years War

The years 1579–1588 constituted a phase of the Eighty Years' War between the Spanish Empire and the United Provinces in revolt after most of them concluded the Union of Utrecht on 23 January 1579, and proceeded to carve the independent Dutch Republic out of the Habsburg Netherlands. It followed the 1576–1579 period, in which a temporary alliance of 16 out of the Seventeen Provinces' States–General established the Pacification of Ghent as a joint Catholic–Protestant rebellion against the Spanish government, but internal conflicts as well as military and diplomatic successes of the Spanish Governors-General Don Juan of Austria and Alexander Farnese, Duke of Parma split them apart, finally leading the Malcontent County of Artois, County of Hainaut and city of Douai to sign the Union of Arras on 6 January 1579, reverting to Catholicism and loyalty to the Spanish crown.

References

  1. Blok, pp. 129-131
  2. Lettres, p. 17, note 1
  3. Blok, pp. 131-132
  4. Blok, p. 133
  5. Blok, pp. 134-139

Sources