Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea

Last updated

"Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea"
Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea.jpg
Single by The Go-Betweens
B-side "This Girl, Black Girl"
ReleasedOctober 1983
RecordedAugust 1983
Genre
Length3:25
Label Rough Trade
Songwriter(s) Robert Forster [1]
Producer(s) John Brand
The Go-Betweens singles chronology
"Cattle and Cane"
(1983)
"Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea"
(1983)
"Part Company"
(1984)

"Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea" was originally released as a stand-alone single by Australian indie group The Go-Betweens. It was released as a 7" vinyl record on the Rough Trade Records label in the United Kingdom in October 1983, with "This Girl, Black Girl" as the B-side. It reached No. 24 on the UK Independent Singles Chart. [2] Another recording of the song was included as the final track on the band's 1984 album, Spring Hill Fair .

Contents

Background

Robert Vickers was recruited into the band in February 1982. Following short tours of Switzerland, Britain and Germany, they went to the studio between 4 and 7 May 1983 and recorded "Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea" and "Newton Told Me" with John Brand producing. [3] The Go-Betweens then returned to Australia to promote Before Hollywood and "Cattle and Cane". Upon returning to England in August 1983 the band went back into the studio with John Brand and re-recorded "Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea", together with "This Girl, Black Girl". [3] The details are not clear as to why the recording was redone but it may have been related to ongoing difficulties with their label, Rough Trade. [3]

McLennan said of the song, "If you think about it it's quite simple.'O' is an abbreviation for of...if you think of the metaphor of how the sea erodes the rock to make sand. I don't mean to be condescending, but I think it's quite beautiful." [4]

Critical reception

In a review in The Age newspaper, Chris Johnston said ""Man O'Sand" is typically (Grant) McLennan and (Robert) Forster in that it wraps up a simple sentiment in obtuse poetic constructs. It's a break-up song. Forster wrote the lyrics: I want you back, I want you back, I want you back, because I feel no better, feel no better, feel no better. Perhaps she was someone he went swimming with and perhaps he refused to swim. Perhaps she was mysterious like the depths of the ocean and he was certain and grounded." [5]

Steve Bell of TheMusic.com.au states "While musically the song is all terse and fiery post-punk and features excellent percussion from Morrison to offset Forster’s deft guitar lines, the lyrics are desperate and pleading but couched in vaguely highbrow imagery – hyper-literacy was always one of the band’s strengths, yet seemed easily confused with pretence by the more casual listener. It’s a great song but it seems slightly incongruous now that it was chosen as a viable radio single given what was airing at the time (although the single version was a slightly more urgent alternate take and slightly abridged compared to the album version)." [6]

In a review of Spring Hill Fair , Allmusic's Ned Raggett describes the song's "pounding chorus one of the band's best captured moments of desperation." [7] He goes on to state ""Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea" was recorded in a mood of, as Robert Forster later described it, "let's burn this land." And burn the band did, in its own soaring, strong way, Forster's guitar reaching a prime post-punk fire and kick, clear, ringing, wiry, but not trying to imitate the Edge." and "The Robert Vickers/Lindy Morrison combination gets as speedy and blunt as it ever did on the chorus, Forster almost spitting out the syllables of the title with desperation." [8]

NME was less complimentary at the time of release, saying the band, "seem reluctant to colour their jagged guitar soundscape with commercial poptones. They have a detachment from that strand of their sound that borders on sarcasm and it prevents their music attaining a fulsome, rounded finish." [9]

Track listing

Original 7" Vinyl release

All tracks are written by G. McLennan, R. Forster [1] .

No.TitleLength
1."Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea"3:25
2."This Girl, Black Girl"2:31

Release history

RegionDateLabelFormatCatalogue
United KingdomOctober 1983 Rough Trade 7" vinylBEG 159

Credits

The Go-Betweens
Production

Related Research Articles

The Go-Betweens Australian rock band

The Go-Betweens were an Australian indie rock band formed in Brisbane, Queensland, in 1977. The band was co-founded and led by singer-songwriters and guitarists Robert Forster and Grant McLennan, who were its only constant members throughout its existence. Drummer Lindy Morrison joined the band in 1980, and its lineup would later expand to include bass guitarist Robert Vickers and multi-instrumentalist Amanda Brown. Vickers was replaced by John Willsteed in 1987, and the quintet lineup remained in place until the band split two years later. Forster and McLennan reformed the band in 2000 with a new lineup that did not include any previous personnel aside from them. McLennan died on 6 May 2006 of a heart attack and the Go-Betweens disbanded again. In 2010, a toll bridge in their native Brisbane was renamed the Go Between Bridge after them.

Tuff Monks were a short-lived band consisting of Nick Cave, Mick Harvey and Rowland S. Howard with Robert Forster, Lindy Morrison and Grant McLennan. Their only release was the 1982 7" 45 rpm single "After the Fireworks", on the Australian label, Au Go Go Records. The lead track was co-written by Cave, Forster and McLennan.

Belinda "Lindy" Morrison is an Australian musician originally from Brisbane, Queensland. She was the drummer in indie rock group the Go-Betweens from 1980 to 1989, appearing on all the band's releases from their first LP in 1981 until their first break up on 26 December 1989. Their song "Cattle and Cane", from the 1983 album Before Hollywood, was selected by the Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA) as one of the Top 30 Australian songs of all time. In 2008, their 16 Lovers Lane album was highlighted on the Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) TV's The Great Australian Albums series as a classic example of 1980s rock music. The Go-Betweens reformed during 2000–2006 without Morrison.

Grant McLennan 20th and 21st-century Australian singer

Grant William McLennan was an Australian alternative rock singer-songwriter-guitarist. He co-founded the Go-Betweens with Robert Forster in Brisbane in 1977. In addition to his work with the Go-Betweens, he issued four solo albums: Watershed (1991), Fireboy (1992), Horsebreaker Star (1994) and In Your Bright Ray (1997). He also undertook side-projects and collaborations with other artists. McLennan received a number of accolades recognising his achievements and contributions as songwriter and lyricist. In May 2001, the Australasian Performing Right Association listed "Cattle and Cane" (1983), written by McLennan, as one of their top 30 Australian songs of all time. McLennan died of a heart attack at the age of 48 and was survived by his fiancée, Emma Pursey.

<i>Before Hollywood</i> 1983 studio album by The Go-Betweens

Before Hollywood is the second album by Australian rock band The Go-Betweens, released in May 1983. The album reached No. 2 on the UK Independent Charts and a single, "Cattle and Cane" reached No. 4. In 2001 "Cattle and Cane" was voted as one of the 30 all-time best Australian songs in an Australasian Performing Right Association poll of 100 music industry personalities.

<i>Spring Hill Fair</i> 1984 studio album by The Go-Betweens

Spring Hill Fair is The Go-Betweens' third album, released on 27 September 1984 in the UK on Sire Records. The LP was recorded during a "very wet May" at Studio Miraval in Le Val, France. Prior to the recording of the album, bass player Robert Vickers had joined the group, enabling Grant McLennan to move to lead guitar. The original release consisted of ten songs. In 2002, Circus released an expanded CD which included a second disc of ten bonus tracks and a music video for the song, "Bachelor Kisses".

<i>Tallulah</i> (The Go-Betweens album) 1987 studio album by The Go-Betweens

Tallulah is the fifth album by The Go-Betweens. It was released in May 1987 in the UK on Beggars Banquet Records. Prior to the recording of the album, the group had expanded to a five-piece with the addition of multi-instrumentalist Amanda Brown. The original release consisted of ten songs. In 2004, LO-MAX Records released an expanded CD which included a second disc of ten bonus tracks and music videos for the songs, "Right Here" and "Bye Bye Pride".

Robert Forster (musician) Musical artist

Robert Derwent Garth Forster is an Australian singer-songwriter, guitarist and music critic. In December 1977 he co-founded an indie rock group, The Go-Betweens, with fellow musician, Grant McLennan. In 1980 Lindy Morrison joined the group on drums and backing vocals and by 1981 Forster and Morrison were also lovers. In 1988, Streets of Your Town, co-written by McLennan and Forster, became the band's biggest chart hit in both Australia and the United Kingdom. The follow-up single, "Was There Anything I Could Do?", was a No. 16 hit on the Billboard Modern Rock Tracks chart in the United States. In December 1989, after recording six albums, The Go-Betweens disbanded. Forster and Morrison had separated as a couple earlier and Forster began his solo music career from 1990.

"Cut It Out" is a song by the Australian alternative band The Go-Betweens that was released as the second single their fifth studio album Tallulah. It was released as a 7" and 12" vinyl single on the Beggars Banquet label in the United Kingdom on 11 May 1987, with "Time in the Desert" as the B-side.

Cattle and Cane 1983 single by The Go-Betweens

"Cattle and Cane" is a song by the Australian alternative rock band The Go-Betweens, released as the first single from their second album Before Hollywood. It was released as a single in the United Kingdom by Rough Trade Records in February 1983 and reached No. 4 on the UK Independent Chart. The single and album were both released in Australia on Stunn, a small label allied with EMI. The Stunn pressings were of poor quality and their distribution limited.

Bachelor Kisses 1984 single by The Go-Betweens

"Bachelor Kisses" is a song by the Australian alternative rock band The Go-Betweens that was released as the second single from their third album Spring Hill Fair in 1984. The single was issued in the UK and Australia on Sire Records. "Bachelor Kisses" was the Go-Betweens' first real attempt at a commercial single.

Lee Remick (The Go-Betweens song) 1978 single by The Go-Betweens

"Lee Remick" is the debut single by Australian indie group The Go-Betweens. It was released in September 1978 by the Australian independent record label, Able Label, with only 700 copies of the 7" vinyl record produced.

Spring Rain (The Go-Betweens song) 1986 single by The Go-Betweens

"Spring Rain" is a song by the Australian alternative rock band The Go-Betweens that was released as the lead single from their fourth album Liberty Belle and the Black Diamond Express in 1986. The single was issued by Beggars Banquet in the UK and Truetone in Australia, failing to chart in the UK, but reached number 92 in Australia.

Bye Bye Pride 1987 single by The Go-Betweens

"Bye Bye Pride" is a song by Australian alternative band The Go-Betweens that first appeared on their fifth studio album Tallulah. It was released as a 7" and 12" vinyl single on the Beggars Banquet label in the United Kingdom in August 1987, with "The House That Jack Kerouac Built" as the B-side. In Australia it was released in 1987 by True Tone Records, with "Time In The Desert" as the B-Side. "Time In The Desert" was originally released as the B-side of the band's earlier single, "Cut It Out". True Tone subsequently in 1988 re-released the single with a new B-side, "The Clarke Sisters".

Right Here (The Go-Betweens song) 1987 single by The Go-Betweens

"Right Here" is a song by the Australian alternative band The Go-Betweens that was released as the lead single from their fifth album Tallulah. It was released as a 7" and 12" vinyl single on the Beggars Banquet label in the United Kingdom on 23 February 1987, with "When People Are Dead" as the B-side. In Australia it was released by True Tone Records, also as a 7" and 12" single. It was also released In Germany by Rebel Rec. and in the United States as a promotional single by Big Time Records.

Head Full of Steam 1986 single by The Go-Betweens

"Head Full of Steam" is a song by the Australian alternative rock band The Go-Betweens that was released as the second single from their fourth album Liberty Belle and the Black Diamond Express. It was released as a 7" and 12" vinyl single on the Beggars Banquet label in the United Kingdom in May 1986, with "Don't Let Him Come Back" as the B-side. In Australia it was released in 1987 by True Tone Records, with "Little Joe" as the B-Side.

Part Company 1984 single by The Go-Betweens

"Part Company" is a song by the Australian alternative rock band The Go-Betweens that was released as the first single from their third album Spring Hill Fair. The single was issued in August 1984 by Sire Records with "Just a King in Mirrors" as the B-side. In the UK a 12" single was also released on Sire. The single failed to make an impact on the charts.

Hammer the Hammer 1982 single by The Go-Betweens

"Hammer the Hammer" was released as a stand-alone single by Australian indie group The Go-Betweens. It was released as a 7" vinyl record on the Missing Link Records label in Australia in June 1982 and by Rough Trade Records in the United Kingdom in July, with "By Chance" as the B-side. Forster considered that "By Chance" was a personal break-through for him. Pitchfork Media describes "By Chance" as sounding "more than a bit like the early Smiths.

"Love Goes On" is a song by the Australian indie rock group The Go-Betweens issued as the third and final single from their 1988 album 16 Lovers Lane. The song was released in January 1989 by Beggars Banquet Records in the UK, with "Clouds" as the B-side. "Love Goes On" was the last single issued by the band before their split in December 1989.

Going Blind (The Go-Betweens song) 2000 single by Australian indie group

"Going Blind" is a song by the Australian indie rock band The Go-Betweens that was released as the lead single from their seventh album The Friends of Rachel Worth. It was released as a CD single by W. Minc Records in Australia, on the Circus Records label in the United Kingdom and Jetset Records in the United States in September 2000. "Going Blind" was The Go-Betweens' first single since "Love Goes On" in 1989.

References

  1. 1 2 "'Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea' at APRA search engine". Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Archived from the original on 17 November 2015. Retrieved 7 July 2015. Note: User may have to click on 'Search again' and provide details at 'Enter a title:', e.g. Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea; or at 'Performer:' The Go-Betweens.
  2. Lazell, Barry (1997). Indie Hits 1980-1989. Cherry Red Books. ISBN   0-9517206-9-4. Archived from the original on 7 July 2010.
  3. 1 2 3 Nichols, David (2003). The Go-Betweens. Verse Chorus Press. ISBN   978-1-891241-16-1.
  4. Blake Gumprecht. "The Go-Betweens: Past Hope, Past Care, Past Help?". Rock's Backpages.
  5. Johnston, Chris (21 February 2014). "Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea". The Age . Retrieved 23 July 2015.
  6. Bell, Steve (26 September 2014). "Look Back At The Go-Betweens' 1984 Classic 'Spring Hill Fair'". TheMusic.com.au. Retrieved 23 July 2015.
  7. Raggett, Ned. "Spring Hill Fair - The Go-Betweens". Allmusic . Retrieved 23 July 2015.
  8. Raggett, Ned. "The Go-Betweens - Man O'Sand to Girl O'Sea". Allmusic . Retrieved 24 July 2015.
  9. "Man O'Sand To Girl O'Sea (Rough Trade)". NME: 24. 15 October 1983.