Mathematical manuscripts of Karl Marx

Last updated March 13, 2024

The mathematical manuscripts of Karl Marx are a manuscript collection of Karl Marx's mathematical notes where he attempted to derive the foundations of infinitesimal calculus from first principles.

The notes that Marx took have been collected into four independent treatises: On the Concept of the Derived Function, On the Differential, On the History of Differential Calculus, and Taylor's Theorem, MacLaurin's Theorem, and Lagrange's Theory of Derived Functions, along with several notes, additional drafts, and supplements to these four treatises. These treatises attempt to construct a rigorous foundation for calculus and use historical materialism to analyze the history of mathematics.

Marx's contributions to mathematics did not have any impact on the historical development of calculus, and he was unaware of many more recent developments in the field at the time, such as the work of Cauchy. However, his work in some ways anticipated, but did not influence, some later developments in 20th century mathematics. These manuscripts, which are from around 1873–1883, were not published in any language until 1968 when they were published in the Soviet Union alongside a Russian translation. Since their publication, Marx's independent contributions to mathematics have been analyzed in terms of both his own historical and economic theories, and in light of their potential applications of nonstandard analysis.^{[ citation needed ]}

Marx left over 1000 manuscript pages^[1] of mathematical notes on his attempts at discovering the foundations of calculus. The majority of these manuscript pages have been collected into four papers, along with drafts and supplementary notes in the published editions of his collected works.^[2] In these works, Marx attempted to draw analogies between his theories of the history of economics and the development of calculus by constructing differential calculus in terms of mathematical symbols altered by an upheaval that would reveal their meaning.^[3]

On the Concept of the Derived Function

Marx wrote On the Concept of the Derived Function in 1881, just two years before his death.^[4] In this work, he demonstrates the mechanical steps needed to calculate a derivative for several basic functions from first principles.^[4] Despite the fact that Marx's principal sources primarily relied on geometric arguments for the definition of the derivative, Marx's explanations rely much more strongly on algebraic explanations than geometric ones, suggesting he likely preferred to think of things algebraically.^[4] Fahey et al. state that although "We might be alarmed to find a student writing 0/0 ... [Marx] was well aware of what he was doing when he wrote '0/0'."^[4] However, Marx was evidently disturbed by the implications of this, stating that "The closely held belief of some rationalising mathematicians that dy and dx are quantitatively actually only infinitely small, only approaching 0/0, is a chimera".^[4]

On the Differential

In On the Differential, Marx tries to construct the definition of a derivative dy/dx from first principles,^[5] without using the definition of a limit. He appears to have primarily used an elementary textbook written by the French mathematician Boucharlat,^[6]^[5] who had primarily used the traditional limit definition of the derivative, but Marx appears to have intentionally avoided doing so in his definition of the derivative.^[5]

Fahey et al. state that, as evidenced by the four separate drafts of this paper, Marx wrote it with considerable care.^[5]

On the History of Differential Calculus

Fahey et al. state that although Marx never used this term in his mathematical papers, his history of calculus can be understood in terms of thesis, antithesis, synthesis. Marx identified three historical phases of development - the "mystical" differential calculus of Newton and Leibniz, the "rational" differential calculus of d'Alembert, and the "purely algebraic" differential calculus of Lagrange.^[7] However, as Marx was not aware of the work of Cauchy, he did not carry his historical development any further.^[7]

Legacy

Yesterday I found the courage at last to study your mathematical manuscripts even without reference books, and I was pleased to find that I did not need them. I compliment you on your work. The thing is as clear as daylight, so that we cannot wonder enough at the way the mathematicians insist on mystifying it. But this comes from the one-sided way these gentlemen think. To put dy/dx = 0/0, firmly and point-blank, does not enter their skulls.
— Friedrich Engels, Letter from Engels to Marx, London, August 10, 1881 ^[2]

Historian of science Kathryn Olesko states that, contrary to many claims made by both Engels and the publishers of Marx's manuscripts, Marx's work did not "solve the historical and conceptual riddle of calculus".^[3] Mathematician Hubert Kennedy observes that Marx "seems to have been unaware of the advances being made by continental mathematicians in the foundations of differential calculus, including the work of Cauchy"^[8] and that although Marx's study of differentials had "no immediate effect on the historical development of mathematics" he concedes however that at least Engels' claim of "independent discoveries" made by Marx is "certainly justified"^[9] and that Marx's definition of the differential "anticipated [some] 20th century developments in mathematics".^[9]

Joseph Dauben speculates that Marx's developments in calculus may have also contributed to an interest in nonstandard analysis among Chinese mathematicians.^[10]

Editions and translations

Although Engels stated his intent to publish the "extremely important mathematical manuscripts left by Marx" in 1885, it was not until 1933 that parts of the manuscripts were published in Russian—for the journal Under the Banner of Marxism and collection Marxism and Science .^[11] The documents were first fully published in 1968, in both German and Russian, with the latter edited by Sofya Yanovskaya.^[1] An English translation was first published in 1983.

Marx, Karl (1968). S.A. Yanovskaya (ed.). Математические Рукописи (in German and Russian). Retrieved 6 April 2022.
Marx, Karl (1983). Mathematical Manuscripts of Karl Marx. Translated by C. Aronson; M. Meo. London: New Park Publications. ISBN 978-0-86151-000-9 . Retrieved 6 April 2022.
Marx, Karl (2018). Karl Marx: Mathematical Manuscripts. Aakar Books. ISBN 978-93-5002-562-8 . Retrieved 6 April 2022.
Marx, Karl; Alcouffe, Alain (1985). Les manuscrits mathematiques de Marx (in French). Economica. ISBN 978-2-7178-0864-3 . Retrieved 6 April 2022.

Notes

1 2 Kennedy 1977, p. 304-305.
1 2 Marx 1983.
1 2 Olesko 1984.
1 2 3 4 5 Fahey et al. 2009, p. 259-260.
1 2 3 4 Fahey et al. 2009, p. 261.
↑ Boucharlat 1828.
1 2 Fahey et al. 2009, p. 262.
↑ Kennedy 1977, p. 308–309.
1 2 Kennedy 1977, p. 315-316.
↑ Dauben 1998.
↑ Yanovskaya 1968, Preface.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Augustin-Louis Cauchy</span> French mathematician (1789–1857)

Baron Augustin-Louis Cauchy was a French mathematician, engineer, and physicist who made pioneering contributions to several branches of mathematics, including mathematical analysis and continuum mechanics. He was one of the first to state and rigorously prove theorems of calculus, rejecting the heuristic principle of the generality of algebra of earlier authors. He is one of the founders of complex analysis and the study of permutation groups in abstract algebra.

Calculus is the mathematical study of continuous change, in the same way that geometry is the study of shape, and algebra is the study of generalizations of arithmetic operations.

Giuseppe Peano was an Italian mathematician and glottologist. The author of over 200 books and papers, he was a founder of mathematical logic and set theory, to which he contributed much notation. The standard axiomatization of the natural numbers is named the Peano axioms in his honor. As part of this effort, he made key contributions to the modern rigorous and systematic treatment of the method of mathematical induction. He spent most of his career teaching mathematics at the University of Turin. He also wrote an international auxiliary language, Latino sine flexione, which is a simplified version of Classical Latin. Most of his books and papers are in Latino sine flexione, while others are in Italian.

Karl Marx was a German-born philosopher, economist, political theorist, historian, sociologist, journalist, and revolutionary socialist. His best-known works are the 1848 pamphlet The Communist Manifesto and the three-volume Das Kapital (1867–1894); the latter employs his critical approach of historical materialism in an analysis of capitalism and is the culmination of his intellectual efforts. Marx's ideas and theories and their subsequent development, collectively known as Marxism, have exerted enormous influence on modern intellectual, economic and political history.

Analysis is the branch of mathematics dealing with continuous functions, limits, and related theories, such as differentiation, integration, measure, infinite sequences, series, and analytic functions.

In mathematics, differential calculus is a subfield of calculus that studies the rates at which quantities change. It is one of the two traditional divisions of calculus, the other being integral calculus—the study of the area beneath a curve.

Karl Theodor Wilhelm Weierstrass was a German mathematician often cited as the "father of modern analysis". Despite leaving university without a degree, he studied mathematics and trained as a school teacher, eventually teaching mathematics, physics, botany and gymnastics. He later received an honorary doctorate and became professor of mathematics in Berlin.

In mathematics, an infinitesimal number is a quantity that is closer to 0 than any standard real number, but is not 0. The word infinitesimal comes from a 17th-century Modern Latin coinage infinitesimus, which originally referred to the "infinity-th" item in a sequence.

Method of Fluxions is a mathematical treatise by Sir Isaac Newton which served as the earliest written formulation of modern calculus. The book was completed in 1671 and posthumously published in 1736.

The Analyst is a book by George Berkeley. It was first published in 1734, first by J. Tonson (London), then by S. Fuller (Dublin). The "infidel mathematician" is believed to have been Edmond Halley, though others have speculated Sir Isaac Newton was intended.

In calculus, Leibniz's notation, named in honor of the 17th-century German philosopher and mathematician Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, uses the symbols $dx$ and $dy$ to represent infinitely small increments of $x$ and $y$ , respectively, just as $Δ x$ and $Δ y$ represent finite increments of $x$ and $y$ , respectively.

Calculus, originally called infinitesimal calculus, is a mathematical discipline focused on limits, continuity, derivatives, integrals, and infinite series. Many elements of calculus appeared in ancient Greece, then in China and the Middle East, and still later again in medieval Europe and in India. Infinitesimal calculus was developed in the late 17th century by Isaac Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz independently of each other. An argument over priority led to the Leibniz–Newton calculus controversy which continued until the death of Leibniz in 1716. The development of calculus and its uses within the sciences have continued to the present.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sofya Yanovskaya</span> Russian mathematician (1896-1966)

Sofya Aleksandrovna Yanovskaya was a Soviet mathematician and historian, specializing in the history of mathematics, mathematical logic, and philosophy of mathematics. She is best known for her efforts in restoring the research of mathematical logic in the Soviet Union and publishing and editing the mathematical works of Karl Marx.

Hubert Collings Kennedy is an American author and mathematician.

Nonstandard analysis and its offshoot, nonstandard calculus, have been criticized by several authors, notably Errett Bishop, Paul Halmos, and Alain Connes. These criticisms are analyzed below.

A timeline of calculus and mathematical analysis.

This is a timeline of pure and applied mathematics history. It is divided here into three stages, corresponding to stages in the development of mathematical notation: a "rhetorical" stage in which calculations are described purely by words, a "syncopated" stage in which quantities and common algebraic operations are beginning to be represented by symbolic abbreviations, and finally a "symbolic" stage, in which comprehensive notational systems for formulas are the norm.

In calculus, the differential represents the principal part of the change in a function $with respect to changes in the independent variable. The differential is defined by$

Various Marxist authors have focused on Marx's method of analysis and presentation as key factors both in understanding the range and incisiveness of Karl Marx's writing in general, his critique of political economy, as well as Grundrisse andDas Kapital in particular. One of the clearest and most instructive examples of this is his discussion of the value-form, which acts as a primary guide or key to understanding the logical argument as it develops throughout the volumes of Das Kapital.

Michael Heinrich is a German historian of philosophy, political scientist, and mathematician, specialising in the critical study of the development of Marx's thought. Heinrich's work, influenced by Elmar Altvater and the Neue Marx-Lektüre of Hans-Georg Backhaus and Helmut Reichelt is characterised by its focus on the points of ambivalence and inconsistency in the work of Marx. Through this theme, Heinrich challenges both the closed system he identifies with "worldview Marxism", as well as teleological narratives of Marx's intellectual development throughout his life. He is best known for his 1991 study of the theoretical field of classical political economy The Science of Value, his introductory text to the critique of political economy An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Karl Marx's Capital, and his ongoing project to produce a multi-volume biography of Marx, of which the first volume of a projected four was published in 2020.

References

Boucharlat, Jean Louis (1828). An Elementary Treatise on the Differential and Integral Calculus ... Translated ... by R. Blakelock. W. P. Grant. Retrieved 7 April 2022.
Dauben, Joseph W (1998). "Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. III (Berlin, 1998)". Documenta Mathematica. III: 799–809. ISSN 1431-0635. MR 1648209 . Retrieved 2011-09-25.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
Fahey, Charles; Lenard, C.T.; Mills, T.M.; Milne, Lex (2009). "Calculus: A Marxist Approach" (PDF). Gazette of the Australian Mathematical Society. 36 (4): 258–266. Retrieved 6 April 2022.
Kennedy, Hubert C. (1977). "Karl Marx and the foundations of differential calculus". Historia Mathematica . 4 (3): 303–318. doi: 10.1016/0315-0860(77)90058-1 . ISSN 0315-0860. MR 0441649.
Olesko, Kathryn (1984). "Review of The Mathematical Manuscripts of Karl Marx". Isis. 75 (1): 233–234. doi:10.1086/353476. ISSN 0021-1753. JSTOR 232402 . Retrieved 6 April 2022.