Medieval debate poetry

Last updated

Medieval debate poetry was a genre of poems popular in England and France during the late medieval period. The same type of debate poems broadly existed in the ancient and medieval Near Eastern literatures.

Contents

Essentially, a debate poem depicts a dialogue between two natural opposites (e.g. sun vs. moon, winter vs. summer). [1] Although the particulars can vary considerably, this can function as a general definition of the literary form. The debates are necessarily emotionally charged, highlighting the contrasting values and personalities of the participants, and exposing their essentially opposite natures.

On the surface, debate poems typically appear didactic, but under this often lies a genuine dialogue between two equally paired opponents.

History and precedents

Debate poems were common in Mesopotamian Sumerian-language literature [2] [3] (first half of the 3rd millennium BC) and were part of the tradition of Arsacid and Sassanid Persian literature (third century BC - seventh century AD). [3] The biblical book of Job follows the same structure. They featured prominently in the Arabic works of the Abbasid-era belletrist al-Jahiz, who wryly pitted the belly against the back, young male lovers against women, and blacks against whites, and continued in later medieval Islamic Persian literature. [4]

The European debate poem first appeared as a literary form in the eighth and ninth centuries, during the Carolingian Renaissance. Beginning in the late ninth century, European clergymen began writing debate poems in Latin. The first example we have of the form is Conflictus Veris et Hiemis (Contention of Spring and Winter), which was written in the late eighth century and is commonly attributed to Alcuin. [5] This poem formally marks the birth of medieval debate poetry and established a pattern for later poems of the genre – it is light hearted but slightly academic, the exchanges in it are few but succinct, the debate is carefully balanced and the issue at hand is resolved.

At the time, a preoccupation with dichotomies in the world was evident in nearly every type of literature, but only debate poetry was devoted entirely to the exploration of these dichotomies. The idea was that every thing – whether it be concrete, abstract, alive or inanimate – had a natural and logical opposite, and this conception was only bolstered by the religious language being used by the Catholic Church at the time. Oppositions abounded between things like the old and new testament, vice and virtue, sins of the spirit and sins of the flesh, good and evil, God and Satan, human and divine, redemption and damnation. Additionally, this conception was bolstered by the presence of overt dichotomies in the natural world, such as night and day, summer and winter, sea and land, male and female, sun and moon, youth and old age. The purpose of the debate poem, then, is to pit one of these things against its opposite.

Virgil's Eclogues features two shepherds engaging in "a game of wit", [6] and this may be an early form of the debate poems of later centuries. The style of debate depicted in Conflictus Veris et Hiemis can also be seen in the late 14th century Debate of the Body and Soul, where the narrator dreams about a corpse and its spirit arguing over who is responsible for their mutual damnation during life, with each asserting that the other led them astray. Beast fables were also well known in late medieval England, including as The Bestiary and The Fox and the Wolf, some adapted from continental originals. Such animals are referred to in period literature and are depicted on the Bayeux Tapestry.

The genre was dominated by European clergymen until the 12th century, and it wasn't until the 13th century that debate poetry began to flourish in many of the vernacular literatures of Europe, which it did until the 16th century. As the Middle Ages waned, so did the literary form of debate poetry. A small number of debate poems of questionable importance were produced during the Renaissance, and thus the debate poem is primarily a medieval phenomenon. [1]

Texts

Two well-known works in which the animals carry on intellectual debates are The Owl and the Nightingale (13th century), involving a dispute between two birds quarreling over who is more useful to man, and Geoffrey Chaucer's Parliament of Fowls (1382?). In the former the argument is loud and vindictive, with the nightingale condescendingly insulting the owl for having a toneless and depressing singing voice; the owl defends her voice as warning and correcting men, and in turns threatens the nightingale. In Chaucer's shorter and more sentimental poem, a formel (a female eagle) has three suitors who submit their cases to an assembly of birds; the birds all have different agendas and cannot reach a decision, and 'Nature' must finally intervene by giving the formel the right to choose her own spouse. In the end the formel opts to delay being married to anyone for a year.

A similar and probably later poem is The Cuckoo and the Nightingale, by Sir John Clanvowe (1341–1391), a contemporary of Chaucer. This poem also continues the theme of moral dispute by featuring a cuckoo, symbol of female infidelity, debating the nightingale over love. The nightingale advocates love as an ethically uplifting emotion, while the cuckoo claims that love's arbitrariness damages people's lives. The poem ends with the human observer throwing a rock at the cuckoo and the nightingale rewarding him with happiness in marriage.

A poem in which two human, though allegorical, figures engage in a debate is the anonymous Wynnere and Wastoure (c.1352), written in alliterative verse.

Purposes

Neil Cartlidge explains the diversity in Middle English debate poetry, stating that, “the purposes and expectations embodied by Middle English debate-poems are very various, and so too are the social and intellectual contexts implied by their transmission in manuscript” [7] . This explanation can be associated with the scholar’s previous assertion on the traces of Medieval culture in shaping the Middle English debate poetry tradition since these poems not only cover many social issues but also how they are received and transmitted in literature. Accordingly, Jr. Thomas L. Reed in Medieval English Debate Poetry (1990) asserts that the teaching of debate skills in Medieval English education system created a debate culture in the society; thus, “the shared educational and social experience of debate poetry’s authors and audience informed their expectations for and appreciation of the literary genre”. [8] In order to create a similar pot of qualities, several scholars have attempted to sort out particular characteristics of the genre. In her prelude to the Middle English bird debate poem “The Owl and the Nightingale”, Lola Janell Simmons points out to six characteristics of the genre as follows:

First, an introduction briefly describes the setting, the topic of debate and the participants. Second, the pastoral elements are reduced in significance but remain as part of the poem's symbolism. Third, the participants are limited to either humans, animals and plants, or personified abstractions, and the kinds are rarely mixed within the same poem. Fourth, the narrator who over- hears and reports the debate is usually uninvolved and impartial. Fifth, the judge does not always render a final judgment in favour of one or the other disputant. Finally, the argument is normally a formal exchange, frequently degenerating into personal invective but always patterned after rhetorical models of debate. (Cartlidge, Neil. "Debate Poetry." The Encyclopedia of Medieval Literature in Britain (2017): 1-4.) [7]

Echoing Simmons’ generalizing characteristics, some other scholars such as, David Lampe offers the debate poem’s main traits as the “pastoral setting”, existence of “participants and a narrator”, external frames of narration and the employment of humour to convey earnest issues, [9] while Conlee “divides his materials into Body and Soul debates, alliterative debates, didactic and satiric disputations, bird debates and pastourelles” [10] and proposes four types of participants, namely, “‘personified abstractions,’ ‘inanimate objects,’ ‘living things,’ and ‘rival aspects of a single entity’” to categorize the sub-genres of debate poetry. [11]

The Owl and the Nightingale as a Bird Debate Poem

Even though Simmons offers generalizing principles of the debate genre, she also acknowledges that not all works that are discussed under the title of this genre might perfectly fit into these characteristics; therefore, her focus mainly covers a distinctive example named “The Owl and the Nightingale”. [12]

Such poems may simply have been recorded or read for entertainment, or to convey a moral or religious lesson. The Owl and the Nightingale includes extended dialogues on rhetorical skills and has been seen as an instruction in (or possibly a parody of) the teaching of rhetorical technique. For example, both employ the medieval rhetorical tools of appealing to authority (by quoting Alfred the Great) and by attempting to goad the opponent into anger and then a mistake (stultiloquiem). During the eighth and ninth centuries, it was customary for students to debate their masters in schools and universities, and debates in litigation were likewise becoming more popular. These situations – which increased the relevance of the genre – were sometimes alluded to or parodied in debate poems.

The fiery debate in The Owl and the Nightingale is ended with a wren intervening, but critics have variously argued that either the owl or the nightingale is better at employing rhetoric al strategy. One critic, Kathryn Hume (in Cartlidge, XIX), suggests that the poem is itself a moralistic warning against pointless quarreling.

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>The Canterbury Tales</i> Story collection by Geoffrey Chaucer

The Canterbury Tales is a collection of twenty-four stories that runs to over 17,000 lines written in Middle English by Geoffrey Chaucer between 1387 and 1400. It is widely regarded as Chaucer's magnum opus. The tales are presented as part of a story-telling contest by a group of pilgrims as they travel together from London to Canterbury to visit the shrine of Saint Thomas Becket at Canterbury Cathedral. The prize for this contest is a free meal at the Tabard Inn at Southwark on their return.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Common nightingale</span> Species of bird

The common nightingale, rufous nightingale or simply nightingale, is a small passerine bird best known for its powerful and beautiful song. It was formerly classed as a member of the thrush family Turdidae, but is now more generally considered to be an Old World flycatcher, Muscicapidae. It belongs to a group of more terrestrial species, often called chats.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philomela</span> Minor figure in Greek mythology

Philomela or Philomel is a minor figure in Greek mythology who is frequently invoked as a direct and figurative symbol in literary and artistic works in the Western canon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Lydgate</span> English monk and poet (c.1370–c.1451)

John Lydgate of Bury was an English monk and poet, born in Lidgate, near Haverhill, Suffolk, England.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Medieval literature</span> Literary works of the Middle Ages

Medieval literature is a broad subject, encompassing essentially all written works available in Europe and beyond during the Middle Ages. The literature of this time was composed of religious writings as well as secular works. Just as in modern literature, it is a complex and rich field of study, from the utterly sacred to the exuberantly profane, touching all points in-between. Works of literature are often grouped by place of origin, language, and genre.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reynard the Fox</span> Cycle of medieval, allegorical, Belgian fable

Reynard the Fox is a literary cycle of medieval allegorical Dutch, English, French and German fables. The first extant versions of the cycle date from the second half of the 12th century. The genre was popular throughout the Late Middle Ages, as well as in chapbook form throughout the Early Modern period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flyting</span> Exchange of insults in the form of verse

Flyting or fliting, is a contest consisting of the exchange of insults between two parties, often conducted in verse.

<i>Parlement of Foules</i> Poem by Geoffrey Chaucer

The Parlement of Foules, also called the Parlement of Briddes or the Assemble of Foules, is a poem by Geoffrey Chaucer made up of approximately 700 lines. The poem, which is in the form of a dream vision in rhyme royal stanza, contains one of the earliest references to the idea that St. Valentine's Day is a special day for lovers.

<i>Troilus and Criseyde</i> 1380s poem by Geoffrey Chaucer

Troilus and Criseyde is an epic poem by Geoffrey Chaucer which re-tells in Middle English the tragic story of the lovers Troilus and Criseyde set against a backdrop of war during the siege of Troy. It was written in rime royale and probably completed during the mid-1380s. Many Chaucer scholars regard it as the poet's finest work. As a finished long poem, it is more self-contained than the better known but ultimately unfinished The Canterbury Tales. This poem is often considered the source of the phrase: "all good things must come to an end" (3.615).

<i>The Owl and the Nightingale</i> Middle English poem

The Owl and the Nightingale is a twelfth- or thirteenth-century Middle English poem detailing a debate between an owl and a nightingale as overheard by the poem's narrator. It is the earliest example in Middle English of a literary form known as debate poetry.

Tail rhyme is a family of stanzaic verse forms used in poetry in French and especially English during and since the Middle Ages, and probably derived from models in medieval Latin versification.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diwan (poetry)</span> Collection of poems of one author, usually excluding his or her long poems (mathnawī)

In Islamic cultures of the Middle East, North Africa, Sicily and South Asia, a Diwan is a collection of poems by one author, usually excluding his or her long poems (mathnawī).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Clanvowe</span> Anglo-Welsh writer, c. 1341–1391

Sir John Clanvowe was a Welsh diplomat, poet and chamber knight to Richard II. He was born to a Marcher family and was possibly of mixed Anglo-Welsh origin, holding lands that would lie in the present-day Radnorshire district of Powys and in Herefordshire.

The term Middle English literature refers to the literature written in the form of the English language known as Middle English, from the late 12th century until the 1470s. During this time the Chancery Standard, a form of London-based English, became widespread and the printing press regularized the language. Between the 1470s and the middle of the following century there was a transition to early Modern English. In literary terms, the characteristics of the literary works written did not change radically until the effects of the Renaissance and Reformed Christianity became more apparent in the reign of King Henry VIII. There are three main categories of Middle English literature, religious, courtly love, and Arthurian, though much of Geoffrey Chaucer's work stands outside these. Among the many religious works are those in the Katherine Group and the writings of Julian of Norwich and Richard Rolle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dream vision</span> Literary device

A dream vision or visio is a literary device in which a dream or vision is recounted as having revealed knowledge or a truth that is not available to the dreamer or visionary in a normal waking state. While dreams occur frequently throughout the history of literature, visionary literature as a genre began to flourish suddenly, and is especially characteristic in early medieval Europe. In both its ancient and medieval form, the dream vision is often felt to be of divine origin. The genre reemerged in the era of Romanticism, when dreams were regarded as creative gateways to imaginative possibilities beyond rational calculation.

Fables, Ancient and Modern is a collection of translations of classical and medieval poetry by John Dryden interspersed with some of his own works. Published in March 1700, it was his last and one of his greatest works. Dryden died two months later.

<i>The Wedding of Sir Gawain and Dame Ragnelle</i> 15th-century English poem

The Wedding of Sir Gawain and Dame Ragnelle is a 15th-century English poem, one of several versions of the "loathly lady" story popular during the Middle Ages. An earlier version of the story appears as "The Wyfe of Bayths Tale" in Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales, and the later ballad "The Marriage of Sir Gawain" is essentially a retelling, though its relationship to the medieval poem is uncertain. The author's name is not known, but similarities to Le Morte d'Arthur have led to the suggestion that the poem may have been written by Sir Thomas Malory.

Chaucer's influence on 15th-century Scottish literature began towards the beginning of the century with King James I of Scotland. This first phase of Scottish "Chaucerianism" was followed by a second phase, comprising the works of Robert Henryson, William Dunbar, and Gavin Douglas. At this point, England has recognised Scotland as an independent state following the end of the Wars of Scottish Independence in 1357. Because of Scottish history and the English’s recent involvement in that history, all of these writers are familiar with the works of Geoffrey Chaucer.

The Floure and the Leafe is an anonymous Middle English allegorical poem in 595 lines of rhyme royal, written around 1470. During the 17th, 18th, and most of the 19th century it was mistakenly believed to be the work of Geoffrey Chaucer, and was generally considered to be one of his finest poems. The name of the author is not known but the poem presents itself as the work of a woman, and some critics are inclined to take this at face value. The poet was certainly well-read, there being a number of echoes of earlier writers in the poem, including Geoffrey Chaucer, John Lydgate, John Gower, Andreas Capellanus, Guillaume de Lorris, Guillaume de Machaut, Jean Froissart, Eustache Deschamps, Christine de Pizan, and the authors of the "Lai du Trot" and the Kingis Quair.

<i>Troy Book</i> Middle English poem by John Lydgate

Troy Book is a Middle English poem by John Lydgate relating the history of Troy from its foundation through to the end of the Trojan War. It is in five books, comprising 30,117 lines in ten-syllable couplets. The poem's major source is Guido delle Colonne's Historia destructionis Troiae.

References

Footnotes

  1. 1 2 Conlee pg XII
  2. ↑ ETCSL
  3. 1 2 Encyclopaedia Iranica on Drakht-i Asurig
  4. ↑ See Asadi Tusi#Monazerat (Debates) and Safina-yi Tabriz#Debates of inanimate objects
  5. ↑ Conlee pg XIII
  6. ↑ Garbaty pg 555
  7. 1 2 Cartlidge, Neil (3 August 2017). "Debate Poetry". The Encyclopedia of Medieval Literature in Britain: 1–4. doi:10.1002/9781118396957.wbemlb200.
  8. ↑ Bestul, Thomas H. (October 1992). "Middle English Debate Poetry and the Aesthetics of Irresolution.Thomas L. Reed, Jr". Speculum. 67 (4): 1037–1039. doi:10.2307/2863540. ISSN   0038-7134.
  9. ↑ Burt, Kathleen R. Argument in Poetry: (Re)Defining the Middle English Debate in Academic, Popular, and Physical Contexts. Ph.D. Diss., Marquette University, 2014.
  10. ↑ Salmi, Hanna. “Early English Debate Poetry as a Conflict Talk. Diss. PhD Dissertation, University of Turku, Turku/Finland, 2017.
  11. ↑ Dunn, C. E. (2017). Debate in medieval English and middle-Scots poetry (Doctoral dissertation, University of Glasgow.
  12. ↑ Simmons, Lola Janell. Rijte cunde: Nature and Preferment in The Owl and the Nightingale. Diss. Texas Tech University, 1986.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.