One Hundred Years of Homosexuality

Last updated
One Hundred Years of Homosexuality: and other essays on Greek love
One Hundred Years of Homosexuality.jpg
Cover, showing Jose de Madrazo Santander's painting The Death of the Spanish Rebel Viriathus
Author David M. Halperin
LanguageEnglish
SeriesThe New Ancient World
Subject Homosexuality
Publisher Routledge
Publication date
1990
Publication placeUnited States
Media typePrint (Hardcover and Paperback)
Pages230
ISBN 978-0415900973

One Hundred Years of Homosexuality: and other essays on Greek love is a 1990 book about homosexuality in ancient Greece by the classicist David M. Halperin, in which the author supports the social constructionist school of thought associated with the French philosopher Michel Foucault. The work has been praised by several scholars, but criticized by others, some of whom have attributed to Halperin the view that the coining of the word "homosexuality" in the nineteenth century brought homosexuality into existence[ clarification needed ]. The book was often reviewed alongside John J. Winkler's The Constraints of Desire (1990).

Contents

Summary

In Halperin's view, the introduction of the term "homosexual" in the 1892 English translation of Richard von Krafft-Ebing's Psycopathia sexuallis by Charles Gilbert Chaddock marks an important change in the treatment and consideration of homosexuality. [1] Halperin believes that the appearance of the English translation of the first volume of Foucault's The History of Sexuality in 1978, together with the publication of the classicist Kenneth Dover's Greek Homosexuality the same year, marked the beginning of a new era in the study of the history of sexuality. [2] Halperin suggests that The History of Sexuality may be the most important contribution to the history of western morality since Friedrich Nietzsche's On the Genealogy of Morality (1887). [3]

Publication history

One Hundred Years of Homosexuality was first published in 1990 by Routledge. [4]

Reception

Mainstream media

One Hundred Years of Homosexuality received a mixed review from the classicist Jasper Griffin in The New York Review of Books and a positive review from the philosopher Martha Nussbaum in The Times Literary Supplement . Both reviewed the book alongside John J. Winkler's The Constraints of Desire (1990). [5] [6]

Griffin called Halperin's work learned but suggested that he exaggerated ideas drawn from Foucault. Griffin wrote that Halperin did not "succeed in disproving the natural reading of a number of Greek texts, which is that some forms of sexual activity were discountenanced, and that some people were categorized by their sexual activities." [5] Halperin responded that it was not his aim to demonstrate that sexual stigma did not exist in Ancient Greece. In reply, Griffin accused Halperin of inconsistency on the issue. [7]

Nussbaum called Halperin and Winkler "judicious and discriminating classical scholars" with a "mastery of the relevant types of evidence" superior to that of Foucault. She described their books as "important collections" that were "meticulous and reliable in scholarship, clear in argument." She credited Halperin with providing "careful scholarly arguments" and making a "wide-ranging use of the evidence." [6]

Gay media

One Hundred Years of Homosexuality was reviewed in the New York Native , [8] and received subsequent discussions there, one of which presented the book alongside Winkler's The Constraints of Desire (1990). [9] [ incomplete short citation ] [10] [ incomplete short citation ] The book was also reviewed by Michael Schwartz in OutWeek and the novelist John Gilgun in the James White Review, [11] [12] and discussed by the novelist Andrew Holleran in Christopher Street and the poet Jason Schneiderman in The Gay & Lesbian Review Worldwide . [13] [14]

Schneiderman, responding to the playwright Larry Kramer's criticism of queer theory and the refusal of academics associated with it "to believe that homosexuality has been pretty much the same since the beginning of human history", credited Halperin with offering the strongest objection to a "universal notion" of homosexuality. [14]

Academic journals

One Hundred Years of Homosexuality received a negative review from the critic Camille Paglia in Arion . [15] The book was also reviewed by the classicist Kenneth Dover in Classical Review, [16] Richard Hoffman in the Journal of Homosexuality , [17] John F. Makowski in Classical World , [18] Philip Holden in Canadian Literature , [19] David Cohen in Classical Philology , [20] and Peter Laipson in Comparative Studies in Society and History , [21] and discussed by Carolyn Dinshaw in GLQ . [22]

Paglia noted that the book had been praised by numerous scholars. However, she strongly disagreed with their assessment of it, and accused Halperin of poor scholarship, careerism, and over-valuing Foucault's ideas. Paglia found the work pretentious and confused, and expressed dismay at Nussbaum's positive review. She criticized Halperin for implying that homosexuals and homosexuality did not exist until the word "homosexuality" was coined and for basing conclusions about the views of classical Athenians on Aristophanes' speech in Plato's Symposium, noting that "Aristophanes is a literary characters and not the real-life man on which he was based". She contrasted the book unfavorably with John J. Winkler's The Constraints of Desire (1990), which she described as a "closely associated" work. However, she also criticized Winkler on various grounds. [15]

Dinshaw described One Hundred Years of Homosexuality as a "polemical book". [22]

Other evaluations

The journalist Neil Miller commended the book for its lucidity, [23] while the literature scholar Leonard Barkan called it "brilliant". [24] In Forms of Desire (1990), the philosopher Edward Stein called Halperin's reservations about scientific research "provocative and highly contentious". [25] In The Mismeasure of Desire (1999), Stein wrote that Halperin's views about the development of contemporary categories of sexual orientation are not universally shared: while Halperin maintains that the word "homosexual" was coined by Karl-Maria Kertbeny in 1869 and attaches significance to this event, others, such as John Boswell, argue that the concept the word refers to has existed for centuries. [26] The sociologist Gary W. Dowsett observed that Halperin, like Foucault in The History of Sexuality, redraws "the terms of our understanding of ancient male-to-male sexual activity and man-boy love", and that he does so with a "view to the politics of the late twentieth century". Dowsett saw Halperin's views as following those of both Foucault and the poet and literary critic John Addington Symonds, maintaining that all three present a censored and overly idealized picture of homosexuality and sexual activity in general. [27] The neuroscientist Simon LeVay observed in Queer Science (1996) that the title of One Hundred Years of Homosexuality, "encapsulates...the notion that homosexuality was brought into existence by the invention, in the late nineteenth century, of the word used to define it." LeVay criticized Halperin's social constructionist arguments, arguing that the concept of homosexuality can exist without the word and that homosexuality itself exists independently of the concept. He further considered Halperin's interpretation of the Symposium "strained", noting that while according to Halperin's interpretation Aristophanes divided men-loving men into youths who love adult men and adult men who love youths, Levay thought that Aristophanes represented the two kinds of love as "different stages on a single life course." LeVay suggested that Halperin's form of social constructionism replaces consciousness with "a highly linguistic self-consciousness". [28]

The psychologist Jim McKnight observed that Halperin is one of several critics of evolutionary explanations of homosexuality who "argue that homosexuality is not an innate but rather an acquired behavior and that Darwinistic explanations are spurious or ultimately misguided". McKnight granted the possibility that Halperin and the other critics may be correct. [29] Nussbaum credited Halperin with providing a good discussion of the relevance of the idea that homosexuality is a cultural construct to ancient Greek culture. [30] The economist Richard Posner described Halperin's view that homosexuality was "invented" by European psychiatrists as a thesis representative of social constructionism. [31] The classicist Bruce Thornton endorsed Paglia's criticisms of Halperin and Winkler. [32] Timothy F. Murphy wrote in Gay Science (1997) that while Halperin claims that erotic preferences are no more fundamental than dietary preferences and should therefore be explained in cultural rather than biological terms, dietary habits themselves can be explained partly in terms of inherent human needs for proteins, fats, and sugars. He criticized Halperin for claiming that the discovery of a gene for homosexuality would refute his ideas about the cultural determination of sexual object-choice, since social constructionism can be interpreted as claiming that sexual orientation is inevitably influenced by social forces and thus does not rule out scientific investigation of the origins of homosexuality. [33]

Related Research Articles

<i>The History of Sexuality</i> Four-volume book by Michel Foucault

The History of Sexuality is a four-volume study of sexuality in the Western world by the French historian and philosopher Michel Foucault, in which the author examines the emergence of "sexuality" as a discursive object and separate sphere of life and argues that the notion that every individual has a sexuality is a relatively recent development in Western societies. The first volume, The Will to Knowledge, was first published in 1976; an English translation appeared in 1978. The Use of Pleasure, and The Care of the Self, were published in 1984. The fourth volume, Confessions of the Flesh, was published posthumously in 2018.

<i>Greek Homosexuality</i> (book) 1978 book by Kenneth Dover

Greek Homosexuality is a book about homosexuality in ancient Greece by the classical scholar Kenneth Dover, in which the author uses archaic and classical archaeological and literary sources to discuss ancient Greek sexual behavior and attitudes. He addresses the iconography of vase paintings, the speeches in the law courts, and the comedies of Aristophanes, as well as the content of other literary and philosophical source texts.

<i>Life Against Death</i> 1959 book by Norman O. Brown

Life Against Death: The Psychoanalytical Meaning of History is a book by the American classicist Norman O. Brown, in which the author offers a radical analysis and critique of the work of Sigmund Freud, tries to provide a theoretical rationale for a nonrepressive civilization, explores parallels between psychoanalysis and Martin Luther's theology, and draws on revolutionary themes in western religious thought, especially the body mysticism of Jakob Böhme and William Blake. It was the result of an interest in psychoanalysis that began when the philosopher Herbert Marcuse suggested to Brown that he should read Freud.

<i>Eros and Civilization</i> 1955 book by Herbert Marcuse

Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud is a book by the German philosopher and social critic Herbert Marcuse, in which the author proposes a non-repressive society, attempts a synthesis of the theories of Karl Marx and Sigmund Freud, and explores the potential of collective memory to be a source of disobedience and revolt and point the way to an alternative future. Its title alludes to Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents (1930). The 1966 edition has an added "political preface".

<i>Gay Science</i> 1997 book by Timothy F. Murphy

Gay Science: The Ethics of Sexual Orientation Research is a 1997 book by the philosopher Timothy F. Murphy about scientific research on sexual orientation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David M. Halperin</span> American academic

David M. Halperin is an American theorist in the fields of gender studies, queer theory, critical theory, material culture and visual culture. He is the cofounder of GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies, and author of several books including Before Pastoral (1983) and One Hundred Years of Homosexuality (1990).

<i>Virtually Normal</i> 1995 book by Andrew Sullivan

Virtually Normal: An Argument About Homosexuality is a book about the politics of homosexuality by the political commentator Andrew Sullivan, in which the author criticizes four different perspectives on gay rights in American society, which he calls the "Prohibitionist", "Liberationist", "Conservative", and "Liberal" views, seeking to expose internal inconsistencies within each of them. He also criticizes the philosopher Michel Foucault and gay rights activists he considers influenced by Foucault, and argues in favor of same-sex marriage and an end to the don't ask, don't tell policy, which banned service by openly gay people in the US military. However, he makes a case against legislation aimed at preventing private discrimination against gay people.

<i>The Assault on Truth</i> 1984 book by Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson

The Assault on Truth: Freud's Suppression of the Seduction Theory is a book by the former psychoanalyst Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson, in which the author argues that Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis, deliberately suppressed his early hypothesis, known as the seduction theory, that hysteria is caused by sexual abuse during infancy, because he refused to believe that children are the victims of sexual violence and abuse within their own families. Masson reached this conclusion while he had access to several of Freud's unpublished letters as projects director of the Sigmund Freud Archives. The Assault on Truth was first published in 1984 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux; several revised editions have since been published.

<i>A Separate Creation</i> 1996 book by Chandler Burr

A Separate Creation: The Search for the Biological Origins of Sexual Orientation, also published with the subtitle How Biology Makes Us Gay, is a 1996 book about the development of sexual orientation by the journalist Chandler Burr. It received mainly positive reviews, commending it as a useful discussion of scientific research on sexual orientation and the politics surrounding the issue.

<i>Homosexuality: A Philosophical Inquiry</i> 1988 book by Michael Ruse

Homosexuality: A Philosophical Inquiry is a 1988 book by the philosopher Michael Ruse, in which the author discusses different theories of homosexuality, evaluates the moral status of homosexual behavior, and argues in favor of gay rights.

<i>Lesbian/Woman</i> 1972 book by Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon

Lesbian/Woman is a work by the feminist and gay rights activists Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon, in which the authors discuss what it means to be a lesbian. The book was influential and is considered a foundational text of lesbian feminism. Reviewers believed that it benefited from its authors' personal experience as lesbians, and endorsed its criticisms of the treatment of lesbians by religious and professional organizations.

<i>The Homosexual Matrix</i> 1975 book by Clarence Arthur Tripp

The Homosexual Matrix is a book by American psychologist Clarence Arthur Tripp, in which the author discusses the biological and sociological implications of homosexuality, and also attempts to explain heterosexuality and bisexuality. The book was first published in 1975 by McGraw-Hill Book Company; it was republished in a revised edition in 1987. Based on his review of the evidence, Tripp argues that people do not become homosexual due to factors such as hormone levels, fear of the opposite sex, or the influence of dominant and close-binding mothers, and that the amount of attention fathers give to their sons has no effect on the development of homosexuality. He criticizes Sigmund Freud and argues that psychoanalytic theories of the development of homosexuality are untenable and based on false assumptions. He maintains that sexual orientation is not innate and depends on learning, that early puberty and early masturbation are important factors in the development of male homosexuality, and that a majority of adults are heterosexual because their socialization has made them want to be heterosexual. He criticizes psychotherapeutic attempts to convert homosexuals to heterosexuality and argues in favor of social tolerance of homosexuality and non-conformist behavior in general.

<i>Gay, Straight, and the Reason Why</i> 2011 book by Simon LeVay

Gay, Straight, and the Reason Why: The Science of Sexual Orientation is a book by the neuroscientist Simon LeVay and published by Oxford University Press. The book received mainly positive reviews, praising it for LeVay's wide-ranging overview of scientific research on sexual orientation. In 2012, it received the Bullough Book Award for the most distinguished book written for the professional sexological community published in a given year.

<i>The Sexual Brain</i> 1993 book by Simon LeVay

The Sexual Brain is a 1993 book about brain mechanisms involved in sexual behavior and feelings, and related topics such as sexual orientation, by the neuroscientist Simon LeVay. The book was praised as a well-written work on science. However, some reviewers pointed out factual errors, and stated that LeVay failed to prove that homosexuality has a biological basis.

<i>Sexuality and Its Discontents</i> 1985 book by Jeffrey Weeks

Sexuality and Its Discontents: Meanings, Myths, and Modern Sexualities is a 1985 book about the politics and philosophy of sex by the sociologist Jeffrey Weeks. The book received positive reviews, crediting Weeks with explaining the theories of sexologists and usefully discussing controversial sexual issues. However, Weeks was criticised for his treatment of feminism and sado-masochism.

<i>Sex and Reason</i> 1992 book by Richard Posner

Sex and Reason is a 1992 book about human sexuality by the economist and federal judge Richard Posner, in which the author attempts to explain sexual behavior in economic terms and discusses a range of controversial subjects related to sex, proposing reforms in American laws.

<i>What Wild Ecstasy</i> 1997 book by John Heidenry

What Wild Ecstasy: The Rise and Fall of the Sexual Revolution is a 1997 book about the sexual revolution by John Heidenry. The book received mixed reviews. It was described as interesting and Heidenry was complimented for his discussions of figures such as Bob Guccione, Hugh Hefner, Larry Flynt, and Reuben Sturman. However, he was criticized for his research methods. He was accused of plagiarism because of the use he made of material by other writers, receiving criticism in particular from the journalist Philip Nobile. Critics also wrote that he focused disproportionately on pornography and gave insufficient attention to feminism and women's issues.

<i>The Science of Desire</i> 1994 book by Dean Hamer

The Science of Desire: The Search for the Gay Gene and the Biology of Behavior is a 1994 book by the geneticist Dean Hamer and the journalist Peter Copeland, in which the authors discuss Hamer's research into the genetics of homosexuality.

<i>The Homosexualization of America</i> 1982 book by Dennis Altman

The Homosexualization of America, The Americanization of the Homosexual is a 1982 book about LGBT rights in the United States by the gay rights activist Dennis Altman, in which the author discusses the emergence of gay people as a minority group. The book received positive reviews, crediting Altman with providing a useful discussion of gay people in the United States.

<i>Sambia Sexual Culture</i> 1999 book by Gilbert Herdt

Sambia Sexual Culture: Essays from the Field is a 1999 book about the Simbari people and their sexual practices by the anthropologist Gilbert Herdt. The book received negative reviews, accusing Herdt of being biased in his approach and his conclusions. In the book the Simbari people are called Sambia people

References

  1. ↑ Halperin 1990, p. 15.
  2. ↑ Halperin 1990, p. 4.
  3. ↑ Halperin 1990, p. 62.
  4. ↑ Halperin 1990, p. iv.
  5. 1 2 Griffin 1990, pp. 6–12.
  6. 1 2 Nussbaum 1990, pp. 571–573.
  7. ↑ Halperin 1990.
  8. ↑ New York Native 1989, p. 34.
  9. ↑ New York Native 1990, p. 33.
  10. ↑ New York Native 1990, p. 23.
  11. ↑ Schwartz 1990, pp. 64–65.
  12. ↑ Gilgun 1990, p. 2.
  13. ↑ Holleran 1990, pp. 4–7.
  14. 1 2 Schneiderman 2010, p. 12.
  15. 1 2 Paglia 1992, pp. 170–248.
  16. ↑ Dover 1991, p. 161.
  17. ↑ Hoffman 1991, pp. 87–101.
  18. ↑ Makowski 1991, p. 407.
  19. ↑ Holden 1991, p. 200.
  20. ↑ Cohen 1992, pp. 145–160.
  21. ↑ Laipson 1992, pp. 636–644.
  22. 1 2 Dinshaw 2006, pp. 5–6.
  23. ↑ Miller 2006, p. 621.
  24. ↑ Barkan 1991, p. 22.
  25. ↑ Stein 1992, p. 100.
  26. ↑ Stein 1999, p. 100.
  27. ↑ Dowsett 1996, p. 254.
  28. ↑ LeVay 1996, pp. 56, 297.
  29. ↑ McKnight 1997, pp. 1–2.
  30. ↑ Nussbaum 1997, pp. 27, 39.
  31. ↑ Posner 1997, p. 186.
  32. ↑ Thornton 1997, p. 256.
  33. ↑ Murphy 1997, pp. 22–23.

Bibliography

Books
Journals
  • Cohen, David (1992). "One hundred years of homosexuality (Book Review)". Classical Philology . 87. – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Dinshaw, Carolyn (2006). "The history of GLQ, Volume 1". GLQ . 12 (1): 5–26. doi:10.1215/10642684-12-1-5. S2CID   144681805. – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Dover, Kenneth (1991). "One hundred years of homosexuality, and other essays on Greek love (Book Review)". Classical Review. 41 (1). – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Gilgun, John (1990). "Coming Out Under Fire/The Construction of Homosexuality/One Hundred Years of Homosexuality (Book)". James White Review. 8 (1). – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Griffin, Jasper (1990). "Love and Sex in Greece". The New York Review of Books . 37 (5).
  • Hoffman, Richard (1991). "One Hundred Years of Homosexuality and Other Essays on Greek Love/The Constraints of Desire: The Anthropology of Sex and Gender in Ancient Greece (Book)". Journal of Homosexuality . 21 (3). – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Holden, Philip (1991). "One hundred years of homosexuality, and other essays on Greek love (Book Review)". Canadian Literature . 131. – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Holleran, Andrew (1990). "Predecessors". Christopher Street . 12 (11). – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Laipson, Peter (1992). "One hundred years of homosexuality (Book Review)". Comparative Studies in Society and History . 34 (4). – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Makowski, John F. (1991). "One hundred years of homosexuality, and other essays on Greek love (Book Review)". Classical World . 84. – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Nussbaum, Martha (1990). "The bondage and freedom of Eros". The Times Literary Supplement (4548).
  • Schneiderman, Jason (2010). "In Defense of Queer Theory". The Gay & Lesbian Review Worldwide . 17 (1). – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • Schwartz, Michael (1990). "Greek Love". OutWeek (37). – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • "Our oral history, and Greek love". New York Native (331). 1989. – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • "On 'the cultural poetics of desire'". New York Native (355). 1990. – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
  • "Recently published". New York Native (362). 1990. – via  EBSCO's Academic Search Complete (subscription required)
Online articles
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.