Pact of Forgetting

Last updated

The Pact of Forgetting (Spanish : Pacto del Olvido) is the political decision by both leftist and rightist parties of Spain to avoid confronting directly the legacy of Francoism after the death of Francisco Franco in 1975. [1] The Pact of Forgetting was an attempt to move on from the Civil War and subsequent repression and to concentrate on the future of Spain. [2] In making a smooth transition from autocracy and totalitarianism to democracy, the Pact ensured that there were no prosecutions for persons responsible for human rights violations or similar crimes committed during the Francoist period. On the other hand, Francoist public memorials, such as the mausoleum of the Valley of the Fallen, fell into disuse for official occasions. [3] Also, the celebration of "Day of Victory" during the Franco era was changed to "Armed Forces Day" so respect was paid to both Nationalist and Republican parties of the Civil War.

Contents

The pact underpinned the transition to democracy of the 1970s [4] and ensured that difficult questions about the recent past were suppressed for fear of endangering 'national reconciliation' and the restoration of liberal-democratic freedoms. Responsibility for the Spanish Civil War, and for the repression that followed, was not to be placed upon any particular social or political group. "In practice, this presupposed suppressing painful memories derived from the post civil war division of the population into 'victors' and 'vanquished'". [5] While many historians accept that the pact served a purpose at the time of transition, [6] there is more controversy as to whether it should still be adhered to. Paul Preston takes the view that Franco had time to impose his own version of history, which still prevents contemporary Spain from "looking upon its recent violent past in an open and honest way". [7] In 2006, two-thirds of Spaniards favored a "fresh investigation into the war". [8]

Historical background

"It is estimated that 400,000 people spent time in prisons, camps, or forced labor battalions". [9] Some historians believe that the repression committed by the Francoist State was most severe and prevalent in the immediate years after the Spanish Civil War and through the 1940s. During this time of the repression, there was an escalation of torture, illegal detention, and execution. This style of repression remained frequent until the end of the Spanish State. Especially during 1936–1939, Nationalist Forces seized control of cities and towns in the Franco-led military coup and would hunt down any protesters or those who were labeled as a threat to the government and believed to sympathize with the Republican cause. [10] "Waves of these individuals were condemned on mere hearsay without trial, loaded onto trucks, taken to deserted areas outside city boundaries, summarily shot, and buried in mass, shallow graves that began dotting the Spanish countryside in the wake of the advancing Nationalist." [11]

Advances in DNA technology gave scope for the identification of the remains of Republicans executed by Franco supporters. The year 2000 saw the foundation of the Association for the Recovery of Historical Memory which grew out of the quest by a sociologist, Emilio Silva-Barrera, to locate and identify the remains of his grandfather, who was shot by Franco's forces in 1936. Such projects have been the subject of political debate in Spain, and are referenced for example in the 2021 film Parallel Mothers . There have been other notable references to the Civil War in the arts since the year 2000 (for example, Javier Cercas' 2001 novel Soldiers of Salamis ). However, the subject of the Civil War had not been "off limits" in the arts in previous decades; for example, Francoist repression is referenced in the 1973 film Spirit of the Beehive,[ citation needed ] and arguably[ by whom? ] the pact is mainly a political construct.

The clearest and most explicit expression of the Pact is the Spanish 1977 Amnesty Law. [12]

The Pact was challenged by the socialist government elected in 2004, which under prime minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero passed the Historical Memory Law. Among other measures, the Historical Memory Law rejected the legitimacy of laws passed and trials conducted by the Francoist regime. The Law repealed some Francoist laws and ordered the removal of remaining symbols of Francoism from public buildings. [8]

The Historical Memory Law has been criticised by some on the left (for not going far enough) and also by some on the right (for example, as a form of "vengeance"). [13] After the Partido Popular took power in 2011 it did not repeal the Historical Memory Law, but it closed the government office dedicated to the exhumation of victims of Francoist repression. [14] Under Mariano Rajoy, the government was not willing to spend public money on exhumations in Spain, [15] although the Partido Popular supported the repatriation of the remains of Spanish soldiers who fought in the Blue Division for Hitler.

In 2010 there was a judicial controversy pertaining to the 1977 Spanish Amnesty Law. Spanish judge Baltasar Garzón challenged the Pact of Forgetting by saying that those who committed crimes against humanity during the Spanish State are not subject to the amnesty law or statutes of limitation. Relatives of those who were executed or went missing during the Franco regime demanded justice for their loved ones. Some of those who were targeted and buried in mass graves during the Franco regime were teachers, farmers, shop owners, women who did not marry in church and those on the losing side of war. [16] However, the Spanish Supreme Court challenged the investigations by Garzón. They investigated the judge for alleged abuse of power, knowingly violating the amnesty law, following a complaint from Miguel Bernard, the secretary general of a far-right group in Spain called "Manos Limpias". Bernard had criticized Garzón by saying: [17]

[Garzón] cannot prosecute Francoism. It's already history, and only historians can judge that period. He uses justice for his own ego. He thought that, by prosecuting Francoism, he could become the head of the International Criminal Court and even win the Nobel Peace Prize.

Although Garzón was eventually cleared of abuse of power in this instance, the Spanish judiciary upheld the Amnesty Law, discontinuing his investigations into Francoist crimes. [7]

In 2022 the Democratic Memory Law enacted by the government of Pedro Sánchez further dealt with the legacy of Francoism and included measures such as to make the government responsible for exhuming and identifying the bodies of those killed by the fascist regime and buried in unmarked graves, to create an official register of victims and to remove a number of remaining Francoist symbols from the country.

International implications

The United Nations has repeatedly urged Spain to repeal the amnesty law, for example in 2012, [18] and most recently in 2013. [19] This is on the basis that under international law amnesties do not apply to crimes against humanity. According to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Article 7, "no one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment". [20] Furthermore, Judge Garzón had drawn attention to Article 15, which does not admit political exceptions to punishing individuals for criminal acts. It has also been argued that crimes during the Franco era, or at least those of the Civil War period, were not yet illegal. This is because international law regarding crimes of humanity developed in the aftermath of the Second World War and for crimes prior to that period the principle of nullum crimen sine lege , or "no crime without a law", could be said to apply. [20]

In 2013, an Argentinian judge was investigating Franco-era crimes under the international legal principle of universal justice. [19] [21]

In Poland, which underwent a later democratic transition, the Spanish agreement not to prosecute politically-motivated wrongdoing juridically and not to use the past in daily politics was seen as the example to follow. [22] In the 1990s the progressive media hailed the Spanish model, which reportedly refrained from revanchism and from the vicious circle of "settling accounts". [23] The issue was highly related to the debate on "decommunization" in general and on "lustration" in particular; the latter was about measures intended against individuals involved in the pre-1989 regime. Liberal and left-wing media firmly opposed any such plan, and they referred the Spanish pattern as the civilized way of moving from one political system to another. [24] In a debate about transition from communism, held by two opinion leaders Vaclav Havel and Adam Michnik, the Spanish model was highly recommended. [25] Later, the policies of prime minister Zapatero were viewed as dangerous "playing with fire", [26] and pundits ridiculed him as the one who was "rattling with skeletons pulled from cupboards" and "winning the civil war lost years ago"; they compared him to Jarosław Kaczyński [27] and leaders of allegedly sectarian, fanatically anti-communist, nationalistic, Catholic groupings. [28] However, during the 2010s the left-wing media were gradually abandoning their early criticism of prime minister Zapatero; [29] they were rather agonizing about Rajoy and his strategy to park the "historical memory" politics in obscurity. [30] With the threat of "lustration" now gone, progressist authors have effectively made a U-turn; currently they are rather skeptical about the alleged "pact of forgetting" [31] and advocate the need to make further legislative steps advanced by the Sánchez government on the path towards "democratic memory". [32] The Polish right, which in the 1990s was rather muted about the solution adopted in Spain, since then remains consistently highly critical about the "historical memory" politics of both PSOE and PP governments. [33]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adam Michnik</span> Polish historian and public intellectual (born 1946)

Adam Michnik is a Polish historian, essayist, former dissident, public intellectual, as well as co-founder and editor-in-chief of the Polish newspaper, Gazeta Wyborcza.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Francoist Spain</span> Period of Spanish history (1936–1975)

Francoist Spain, also known as the Francoist dictatorship, was the period of Spanish history between 1936 and 1975, when Francisco Franco ruled Spain after the Spanish Civil War with the title Caudillo. After his death in 1975 due to heart failure, Spain transitioned into a democracy. During Franco's rule, Spain was officially known as the Spanish State.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Baltasar Garzón</span> Spanish former judge (born 1955)

Baltasar Garzón Real is a Spanish former judge. He served on Spain's central criminal court, the Audiencia Nacional, and was the examining magistrate of the Juzgado Central de Instrucción No. 5, which investigates the most important criminal cases in Spain, including terrorism, organised crime, and money laundering. In 2011, he was suspended from judicial activity and in 2012 he was convicted of illegal wiretapping and disbarred for a period of 11 years. During this time, Garzón legally assisted Julian Assange. In the landmark case Baltasar Garzón v. Spain (2021), the United Nations Human Rights Committee found that Garzón's trial in Spain was "arbitrary" and violated the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

An amnesty law is any legislative, constitutional or executive arrangement that retroactively exempts a select group of people, usually military leaders and government leaders, from criminal liability for the crimes that they committed. More specifically, in the 'age of accountability', amnesty laws have come to be considered as granting impunity for the violation of human rights, including institutional measures that preclude the prosecution for such crimes and reprieve those crimes already convicted, avoiding any form of accountability.

Lustration in Poland is the policy of limiting the participation of former communists – especially of informants of the communist secret police – during 1944–1990, in successor governments or even in civil-service positions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">White Terror (Spain)</span> Assassinations and mass murders during the Spanish Civil War

In the history of Spain, the White Terror describes the political repression, including executions and rapes, which were carried out by the Nationalist faction during the Spanish Civil War (1936–1939), as well as during the first nine years of the regime of General Francisco Franco. In the 1936–1945 period, Francoist Spain had many officially designated enemies: supporters of the Second Spanish Republic (1931–1939), liberals, socialists of different stripes, Protestants, intellectuals, homosexual people, Freemasons, Jews, and Basque, Catalan, Andalusian, and Galician nationalists.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Historical Memory Law</span> Spanish law passed in 2007 dealing with the legacy of Francoism

Law 52/2007, commonly known as Historical Memory Law, recognises and broadens "the rights and establishes measures in favour of those who suffered persecution or violence during the civil war and the dictatorship." It was passed by the Congress of Deputies on 31 October 2007, on the basis of a bill proposed by the PSOE government of Prime Minister José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero. The Historical Memory Law principally recognizes the victims on both sides of the Spanish Civil War, gives rights to the victims and the descendants of victims of the Civil War and of the subsequent dictatorship, and formally condemns the repressions of the Franco regime.

Manos Limpias is an association founded in Madrid in 1995 by Spanish lawyer and extreme right activist Miguel Bernad Remón. It represents employees in Spanish public services. Bernad entered politics as a protege of Blas Piñar, during his tenure as the Fuerza Nueva and National Front party secretary. The group takes its name from the Mani Pulite judicial investigation into political corruption in Italy held in the early 1990s and led by Antonio Di Pietro.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Law of Political Responsibilities</span>

The Law of Political Responsibilities was a law issued by Francoist Spain on 13 February 1939 two months before the end of the Spanish Civil War. The law targeted all supporters of the Second Spanish Republic and penalized membership in the Popular Front of the defeated republic.

Luciano Varela Castro is a senior Spanish judge, magistrate of the Spanish Supreme Court from 2007 to 2019. He was born at Pontevedra, Galicia, in 1948 and is married with four children.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stefan Michnik</span> Polish judge (1929–2021)

Stefan Michnik was a military judge of the Soviet-dominated regime in post-World War II Poland, and a captain in the communist Polish People's Army. He was involved in the politically-motivated arrest, trial, imprisonment and/or execution of a number of Polish anti-communist fighters and activists. Many of those persecuted by Michnik also fought against Nazi Germany during World War II, as members of the Polish resistance.

Unión Militar Democrática was a clandestine Spanish organisation of military officers in the late- and post-Francoist Spain era.

The Spanish 1977 Amnesty Law is a law passed by the Parliament of Spain and given royal assent on October 15, 1977, two years after Francisco Franco's death. The Law freed political prisoners and permitted those exiled to return to Spain, but also guaranteed impunity for those who participated in crimes, during the Civil War, and in Francoist Spain. The law is still in force, and has been used as a reason for not investigating and prosecuting Francoist human rights violations.

The lost children of Francoism were the children abducted from Republican parents, who were either in jail or had been assassinated by Nationalist troops, during the Spanish Civil War and Francoist Spain, and later from random citizens or girls confined in the notorious Women's Protection Board. The kidnapped children were sometimes also victims of child trafficking and forced adoption.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Corruption in Spain</span>

Political corruption is a large concern in Spain. Political corruption is defined as the action or inaction of one or more real persons managing public resources for their own or a third party's benefit to the detriment of all the citizens they should serve and benefit. Transparency International Global Corruption Barometer 2013 shows that the surveyed households consider political parties, Parliament and the judiciary the most corrupt institutions. In fact, the Spanish population considers corruption their second biggest problem, only eclipsed by unemployment. Following Spain's return to democracy after the end of the Franco dictatorship, the judiciary became an independent branch of government. In the early part of the 21st century this independent judiciary is active in pursuing political corruption.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sociological Francoism</span> Continuing social characteristics of Francoism in Spain

Sociological Francoism is an expression used in Spain which attests to the social features of Francoism that lingered in Spanish society after the death of Francisco Franco in 1975 and continue to the present day.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Women prisoners in Francoist Spain</span>

Women prisoners in Francoist Spain were often there because of specific repression aimed at women. During the Civil War, many women were in prison because family members had Republican sympathies or the authorities wanted to lure out male Republican affiliated relatives; it was not a result of anything the women did themselves. The Law of Political Responsibilities, adopted on 13 February 1939, made such repression easier and was not formally removed from the Criminal Code until 1966. Prisoners and people in concentration camps, both male and female, would total over three quarters of a million by the end of the Spanish Civil War. Of these, 14,000 women were held in the Las Ventas Model prison in Madrid.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Andrés Saliquet</span> Spanish military personnel (1877–1959)

Andrés Saliquet Zumeta, Marquis of Saliquet was a Spanish soldier who participated in the failed military coup against the Second Republic, which gave rise to the Spanish Civil War. During the war he took charge of the Army of the center, a unit that contained troops of the Nationalist faction from the Tagus River to Madrid, Guadarrama and the Universal Mountains.

The Law of Democratic Memory is a law in Spain which came into effect in October 2022, concerning the legacy of Francoist Spain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emilio Silva</span> Spanish sociologist, journalist, activist

Emilio Silva Barrera is a Spanish sociologist, journalist, and activist for the recovery of Historical Memory. He is one of the founders and president of the Association for the Recovery of Historical Memory (ARMH), a collective that has been searching for the mass graves of victims of repression in the Francoist zone during the Spanish Civil War and the subsequent Franco dictatorship.

References

  1. ↑ Encarnación, Omar G. (2014-01-22). "Forgetting, in Order to Move On". New York Times . Retrieved 2017-10-07.
  2. ↑ Poggiloi, Sylvia (2010-08-04). "In Spain, A Crusading Judge Opens Old Wounds". NPR. Retrieved 2017-10-07.
  3. ↑ Rigby, Andrew (2000). "Amnesty and Amnesia in Spain". Peace Review. 12 (1): 73–79. doi:10.1080/104026500113845. S2CID   143449787.
  4. ↑ Tremlett, Giles (2008). Ghosts of Spain. Travels through Spain and its silent past. Bloomsbury. p. 79. ISBN   978-0-8027-1674-3.
  5. ↑ Alberto Reig Tapia, Memoria de la guerra civil, Madrid 1999, quoted in The Splintering of Spain, p.9, Cambridge University Press, 2005
  6. ↑ Labanyi, Jo. "Memory and Modernity in Democratic Spain: The Difficulty of Coming to Terms with the Spanish Civil War". Poetics Today. 28 (1).
  7. 1 2 Tremlett, Giles (March 2012). "The Spanish Holocaust by Paul Preston – review". The Guardian . www.guardian.co.uk. Retrieved November 17, 2013.
  8. 1 2 Stuart, Paul (2006). "Spain: "Law of historical memory" continues cover-up of Franco's crimes". World Socialist Web Site.
  9. ↑ Davis, Madeline (2005). "Is Spain Recovering its Memory? Breaking the Pacto del Olvido". Human Rights Quarterly. 27 (3): 858–880. doi:10.1353/hrq.2005.0034. S2CID   143878908.
  10. ↑ Guarino, Angela M. (January 2010). "Chasing Ghosts: Pursuing Retroactive Justice for Franco-Era Crimes Against Humanity". Boston College International and Comparative Law Review. 33 (1): 64.
  11. ↑ Guarino, Angela M. (January 2010). "Chasing Ghosts: Pursuing Retroactive Justice for Franco-Era Crimes Against Humanity". Boston International and Comparative Law Review. 33 (1): 64–65.
  12. ↑ Casanova, Julián; Gil Andrés, Carlos (2014). Twentieth-century Spain. A History. Translated by Douch, Martin. Cambridge University Press. p. 310. ISBN   978-1-107-60267-0. OCLC   870438787.
  13. ↑ Abend, Lisa (17 October 2008). "At Last, Spain Faces Up to Franco's Guilt". Time . Retrieved 22 September 2020.
  14. ↑ "Rajoy cierra la Oficina de Víctimas". Archived from the original on March 4, 2012. Retrieved August 29, 2012.
  15. ↑ "El gobierno elimina en 2013". Público . Europa Press . Retrieved September 29, 2012.
  16. ↑ Poggioli, Sylvia. "In Spain, A Crusading Judge Opens Old Wounds". NPR .
  17. ↑ Poggiloli, Sylvia. "In Spain, A Crusading Judge Opens Old Wounds". NPR.
  18. ↑ "Spain must lift amnesty". AlertNet, Reuters. Archived from the original on April 16, 2013. Retrieved August 17, 2012.
  19. 1 2 "UN presses Spain". 2013. Retrieved 17 November 2013.
  20. 1 2 Guarino, Angela M. (January 2010). "Chasing Ghosts: Pursuing Retroactive Justice under Franco-Era Crimes Against Humanity". Boston College International and Comparative Law Review. 33 (1): 71–72. ISSN   0277-5778. OCLC   643642745.
  21. ↑ Judge confiscates passports of two Franco-era security officers wanted in Argentina El País (English edition).
  22. ↑ Passent, Daniel (2010-08-12). "Zbrodnie Zapatero". Polityka.
  23. ↑ Tryc-Ostrowska, Małgorzata (1995-11-21). "Bez rozdrapywania ran i porachunków". Rzeczpospolita.
  24. ↑ Opioła, Wojciech (2016). "Współczesna hiszpańska polityka pamięci". Przegląd Narodowościowy. 5 (1): 214.
  25. ↑ Michnik, Adam; Havel, Vaclav (1993). "Confronting the Past: Justice or Revenge?". Journal of Democracy. 4 (1): 20–27. doi:10.1353/jod.1993.0009. S2CID   154740873.
  26. ↑ Stasiński, Piotr (2005-05-21). "Hiszpańska szafa pełna trupów". Gazeta Wyborcza.
  27. ↑ Michnik, Adam (2002-02-03). "Polityka kłamstw historycznych". Gazeta Wyborcza.
  28. ↑ Stasiński, Piotr (2010-07-05). "Socjaliści Zapatero myślą lekko, polscy nie powinni". Gazeta Wyborcza.
  29. ↑ Stasiński, Maciej (2013-10-31). "Hiszpańska lewica chce przenieść dyktatora Francisco Franco do zwykłego grobu". Gazeta Wyborcza.
  30. ↑ Okraszewski, Maciej (2018-11-07). "Ekshumacja gen. Franco. Lepiej późno niż wcale". Polityka.
  31. ↑ Okraszewski, Maciej (2018-07-20). "Szczątki generała Franco precz, czyli socjaliści rządzą Hiszpanią po nowemu". Gazeta Wyborcza.
  32. ↑ Stasiński, Maciej (2020-09-17). "Hiszpania chce ustawowo zabliźnić rany wojny i dyktatury Franco". Gazeta Wyborcza.
  33. ↑ Miłkowski, Tadeusz (2020). "La transición española en el espejo deformante de la política polaca del siglo XXI". In Mazurek, Jerzy (ed.). Transición en retrospectiva (in Spanish). Varsovia. pp. 67–78. ISBN   978-83-7901-234-3.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.