Paul Cosgrove | |
---|---|
Member of Parliament for York—Scarborough | |
In office 1980 federal election – 1984 federal election | |
Preceded by | Paul McCrossan (1978–1980) |
Succeeded by | Paul McCrossan (1984–1988) |
3rd Mayor of Scarborough,Ontario | |
In office 1973–1978 | |
Preceded by | Robert W. White |
Succeeded by | Ken Morrish |
Personal details | |
Born | December 30,1934 |
Political party | Liberal |
Profession | Judge (resigned from the bench) |
Paul James Cosgrove, PC (born December 30,1934),is a former Canadian jurist as well as a former politician.
A lawyer by profession,Cosgrove entered municipal politics and served as mayor of the Toronto suburb of Scarborough,Ontario from 1973 until 1978.
Cosgrove entered federal politics running as the Liberal Party candidate in York—Scarborough in a 1978 by-election for a seat in the House of Commons of Canada. He was defeated in that run,as well as in the 1979 election.
In the 1980 election,however,Cosgrove was elected,and was appointed Minister of Public Works,Minister responsible for Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation and Minister responsible for National Capital Commission in the Canadian Cabinet of Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau.
He was reassigned in a 1982 cabinet shuffle to the position of Minister of State for Finance. He was dropped from the Cabinet in August 1983 but remained an MP until the dissolution of parliament the next year.
Cosgrove retired from the House of Commons to accept an appointment by John Turner to the bench of the Ontario Superior Court on July 9,1984,shortly after Parliament was dissolved for the 1984 election. Cosgrove's judicial circuit was in eastern Ontario with his court based in Brockville,Ontario.
In 1999,Judge Cosgrove stayed charges of murder against Julia Elliott after a 22-month trial. He ruled that the Crown attorney,police and a deputy attorney general had committed 150 constitutional violations,findings that were unanimously rejected by the Ontario Court of Appeal in the fall of 2003 with the Court ordering a new trial. Julia Elliott subsequently pleaded guilty to manslaughter. [1]
As a result,the attorney-general of Ontario,Michael Bryant filed a complaint against Cosgrove,calling him unfit to be a judge,and accusing him of sullying reputations and of having "vilified the state". As a result of the complaint,Cosgrove was suspended pending a hearing into his conduct that was scheduled for December 2004. Cosgrove complained to the Canadian Judicial Council that the scheduled hearing was unconstitutional and damaging to judicial independence. His lawyer claimed that Bryant's action created a situation in which the Attorney-General could punish judges for making controversial decisions,since a complaint by an Attorney-General automatically would result in suspension pending a hearing. According to Cosgrove's lawyer:
According to The Globe and Mail newspaper,Cosgrove's affidavit warned that judges might become afraid to criticize or rule against the Crown if they thought a vindictive attorney-general could,in effect,end their careers simply by lodging a complaint. The consequences of this were argued to be so negative that the process effectively permitted an attorney-general to become "the judge in his own cause". .
Both the Canadian Superior Courts Judges Association and the Ontario Criminal Lawyers' Association supported Cosgrove's case.
In October,2005,the trial division of the Federal Court of Canada ruled in favor of Judge Cosgrove and stripped the attorney-general of the power to force the Canadian Judicial Council to conduct hearings that could remove judges from the bench.
The federal court ruling temporarily halted the proceedings against Judge Cosgrove who had been on a paid leave of absence since Bryant's April 2004 request for a disciplinary hearing. On March 12,2007,however,the appellate division of the Federal Court of Canada reversed the trial division,and found against Justice Cosgrove. The Federal Court of Appeal set aside the decision of the Federal Court,dismissed the application for judicial review,and referred the matter back to the Inquiry Committee of the Canadian Judicial Council.
On December 4,2008,in a 4-1 decision,a committee of the Canadian Judicial Council found grounds for recommending to the federal justice minister that Cosgrove be removed from office.
The full Canadian Judicial Council,made up of the 22 of Canada's chief justices and senior judges,met to consider the committee's recommendation and,on March 31,2009,formally recommended to Parliament that Cosgrove be removed saying that "We find that Justice Cosgrove has failed in the execution of the duties of his judicial office and that public confidence in his ability to discharge those duties in the future has been irrevocably lost." The decision also stated that "We find that there is no alternative measure to removal that would be sufficient to restore public confidence in the judge in this case." This was the second time in the council's history that it has recommended the removal of a judge. [2] The same recommendation was made in 1996 in regards to then Justice Jean Bienvenue who resigned rather than wait for Parliament to decide his fate. [3]
On April 2,2009,Cosgrove resigned from the bench. If he had not done so,and had also not taken the option of making an application to the Federal Court for a judicial review of the finding, [3] the House of Commons and Senate would have had to vote on whether to remove him from office,something which has never happened since Canadian confederation. [4]
A King's Counsel is a senior lawyer appointed by the monarch of some Commonwealth realms as a "Counsel learned in the law". When the reigning monarch is a woman,the title is Queen's Counsel (QC).
The Supreme Court of Canada is the highest court in the judicial system of Canada. It comprises nine justices,whose decisions are the ultimate application of Canadian law,and grants permission to between 40 and 75 litigants each year to appeal decisions rendered by provincial,territorial and federal appellate courts. The Supreme Court is bijural,hearing cases from two major legal traditions and bilingual,hearing cases in both official languages of Canada.
The chief justice of Canada is the presiding judge of the nine-member Supreme Court of Canada,the highest judicial body in Canada. As such,the chief justice is the highest-ranking judge of the Canadian court system. The Supreme Court Act makes the chief justice,a Crown in Council appointment,meaning the Crown acting on the advice of the prime minister and minister of justice. The chief justice serves until they resign,turn 75 years old,die,or are removed from office for cause. By tradition,a new chief justice is chosen from among the court's incumbent puisne justices.
Newton Wesley Rowell,was a Canadian lawyer,politician,judge,and lay leader in the Methodist Church. Rowell led the Ontario Liberal Party from 1911 to 1917 and put forward a platform advocating temperance. Rowell's Liberals failed to oppose the Whitney government's passage of Regulation 17 which restricted the teaching of the French language in schools and alienated the province's French-Canadian minority.
Roland Roy McMurtry was a Canadian lawyer,judge and politician in Ontario. He was a Progressive Conservative member of the Legislative Assembly of Ontario from 1975 to 1985,serving in the cabinet of Bill Davis as Attorney General and as Solicitor General. After leaving politics,McMurtry was High Commissioner of Canada to the United Kingdom between 1985 and 1988. He became a judge in 1991 and was appointed Chief Justice of Ontario in 1996. McMurtry retired from the bench in 2007 and returned to the private practice of law.
Julian Fantino,,is a Canadian retired police official and former politician. He was the Conservative Party of Canada Member of the Parliament of Canada for the riding of Vaughan following a November 29,2010 by-election,until his defeat in 2015. On January 4,2011,Fantino was named Minister of State for Seniors;on May 18,2011,he became Associate Minister of National Defence;on July 4,2012,he was named Minister for International Cooperation. Fantino served as the Minister of Veterans Affairs from 2013 until 2015,when he was demoted to his earlier post of Associate Minister of National Defence following sustained criticism of his performance at Veterans Affairs. He was defeated by Liberal candidate Francesco Sorbara in the 2015 election.
Victor Toews is a Canadian politician and jurist. Toews is a justice of the Court of King's Bench of Manitoba. He represented Provencher in the House of Commons of Canada from 2000 until his resignation on July 9,2013,and served in the cabinet of Prime Minister Stephen Harper,most recently as Minister of Public Safety. He previously served in the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba from 1995 to 1999,and was a senior cabinet minister in the government of Gary Filmon. Prior to his appointment to the judiciary,Toews was a member of the Conservative Party of Canada.
The court system of Canada is made up of many courts differing in levels of legal superiority and separated by jurisdiction. In the courts,the judiciary interpret and apply the law of Canada. Some of the courts are federal in nature,while others are provincial or territorial.
The Attorney General of Ontario is the chief legal adviser to His Majesty the King in Right of Ontario and,by extension,the Government of Ontario. The Attorney General is a senior member of the Executive Council of Ontario and oversees the Ministry of the Attorney General –the department responsible for the oversight of the justice system in the province of Ontario. The Attorney General is an elected Member of Provincial Parliament who is appointed by the Lieutenant Governor of Ontario on the constitutional advice of the Premier of Ontario. The Ministry is the largest justice system in Canada and one of the largest in North America.
The Canadian Judicial Council is the national council of the judiciary of Canada,overseeing the country's federal judges.
The Ontario Court of Justice is the provincial court of record for the Canadian province of Ontario. The court sits at more than 200 locations across the province and oversees matters relating to family law,criminal law,and provincial offences.
The Supreme Court of Canada was founded in 1875 and has served as the final court of appeal in Canada since 1949. Its history may be divided into three general eras. From its inception in 1875 until 1949,the Court served as an intermediate appellate court subject to appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in Britain. Following 1949,the Court gained importance and legitimacy as the court of last resort in Canada,establishing a greater role for the Canadian judiciary. In 1982,the introduction of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms significantly changed the role of the Court in Canadian society,by providing the Court with greater powers of oversight over Parliament and through formal recognition of civil rights including aboriginal rights and equality rights.
The Court of King's Bench for Saskatchewan is the superior trial court for the Canadian province of Saskatchewan.
Judicial appointmentsin Canada are made by the federal government or provincial government. Superior and federal court judges are appointed by federal government,while inferior courts are appointed by the provincial government.
The Judicial Commission of New South Wales is an independent statutory corporation of the New South Wales Government that provides sentencing information and continuing education to and examines complaints made against judicial officers in New South Wales,Australia.
Horace Harvey was a lawyer,jurist,and a Chief Justice of Alberta,Canada.
Kevin Mark Murphy is a Canadian musician and criminal lawyer,best known as a co-founder of the Ottawa-based music group,Singing Fools.
Sidney Bryan Linden is a former Chief Judge of the Ontario Court of Justice and a judicial reformer and administrator in the province of Ontario,Canada.
Robin Camp is a former Federal Court of Canada judge. Camp was the subject of a high-profile removal hearing before the Canadian Judicial Council for his role in a 2014 sexual assault trial that he presided over. The judicial committee recommended that he be removed from the bench. In 2018 Camp was reinstated into the Law Society of Alberta.
Valin v Langlois is a Canadian constitutional law decision from the Supreme Court of Canada,concerning the jurisdiction of the federal Parliament over federal elections,as well as the constitutional jurisdiction of the provincial superior courts. The Court held that the Parliament of Canada has sole jurisdiction to enact laws regulating federal elections,including provisions for controverted elections. The Court also held that the provincial superior courts have general jurisdiction over questions of federal and provincial law,and that Parliament could give provincial courts jurisdiction to apply federal laws.