Plantagenet Alliance

Last updated
Richard III, reigned 1483-1485 King Richard III.jpg
Richard III, reigned 14831485

The Plantagenet Alliance was a small grouping of individuals claiming to be descendants of the House of Plantagenet. The Alliance was formed in 2013 shortly after the discovery and identification of the remains of Richard III, the last Plantagenet king of England who died in 1485, in order to advance their views on the location of Richard's reburial. Reports of the number of members of the Alliance varied between fifteen and around forty.

Contents

In 2013 and 2014 the group campaigned to have Richard re-interred at York Minster, believing that, as his collateral descendants, [note 1] they knew his wishes. They referred to themselves as "his Majesty's representatives and voice". However, historians disputed that there was any evidence that Richard III wanted to be buried in York. The Plantagenet Alliance's standing to represent Richard was also challenged on the basis that he would have had many millions of other living collateral descendants whose views were not necessarily represented by the Alliance.

The Alliance's activities included initiating a judicial review of decisions taken by the Ministry of Justice relating to the proposed re-interment in Leicester. The Alliance lost the judicial review in 2014 and the campaign to have Richard's remains buried in York failed. The group has not been publicly active since the loss of the court case. Richard III's remains were finally re-interred within the interior of the Leicester Cathedral on 26 March 2015.

Background and formation

The archaeological dig at a council car park in Leicester, which resulted in the discovery of Richard III's remains Grey Friars July 2013 excavation.jpg
The archaeological dig at a council car park in Leicester, which resulted in the discovery of Richard III's remains

In September 2012, an archaeological dig led by the University of Leicester resulted in the remains of Richard III, who was killed at the Battle of Bosworth Field in 1485, being discovered underneath a council car park in Leicester. [3] The Ministry of Justice announced in February 2013 that the university had the authority to determine the location of Richard's reburial under the terms of the licence it had been granted to carry out the archaeological exhumation. [4] The University of Leicester subsequently confirmed that it had always been its intention that the remains should be re-interred in Leicester Cathedral. [4]

According to a BBC report and The Guardian journalist Joshua Rozenberg, Stephen Nicolay, a descendant of Richard III's sister, founded the Plantagenet Alliance shortly after confirmation, in February 2013, that it had been Richard's remains that had been discovered the previous year. [5] [6] According to the BBC report and Rozenberg, Nicolay formed the group with other "collateral [non-direct] descendants" with the aim of having Richard buried at York Minster. [5] [6] However, Vanessa Roe, another member of the group, told Prospect Magazine , in an interview, that the Plantagenet Alliance came about as a result of her contacting York City Council after she had seen a Channel 4 documentary about the exhumation and identification of Richard III's remains. [7] The council had put her in touch with others who claimed to be related to Richard. [7]

Name and composition

The Alliance is a group of individuals who believe they are descendants of relatives of Richard III. [8] Specifically they claim to be 16th, 17th and 18th great-nieces and great-nephews of Richard. [9] The Alliance took their name from the House of Plantagenet, the medieval royal dynasty, [10] of which Richard III was the last king. [11] In March 2013, it was reported that they numbered fifteen, [8] but a subsequent report, in December 2013, stated that there were "around forty" in the Alliance. [7] The full group has never met in person. [7]

Prominent members include Stephen Nicolay, Vanessa Roe and Charles Brunner. Nicolay, a self-employed gardener, is a 16th great-nephew of Richard through his sister, Anne of York. [6] He was unaware of his relationship to Richard until late 2011 and he received confirmation that he was a 16th great-nephew in early 2012. [9] Vanessa Roe, who runs a small farm near York and works with young people with disabilities, [7] is a 16th great-niece of Richard III. [12] She is descended from Richard's brother, George, Duke of Clarence and has said that she has always been aware of her Plantagenet ancestry. [7] Roe has been described as the "group's spokesperson". [5] Charles Brunner is an American and owns a night-club in Kansas. [7] He is a 17th great-nephew of the king, [13] and a descendant of Richard's sister, Anne of York. [14] He has been described as "one of the leaders" of the Alliance. [7]

Views

The competing locations for Richard III's reburial
Leicester Cathedral exterior.jpg
Leicester Cathedral, where Richard was re-interred in March 2015
York.mstr..jpg
York Minster, favoured by the Plantagenet Alliance but not chosen

In February 2013, the Plantagenet Alliance issued a statement declaring its views on the burial place of Richard III:

The Plantagenet Alliance does hereby most respectfully demand that the remains of King Richard III, the last Plantagenet King of England and our mutual, collateral ancestor, be returned to the City of York for ceremonial reburial. We believe that such an interment was the desire of King Richard in life and we have written this statement so that his inferred wishes may be fully recognised. [15]

The group claims to speak on behalf of Richard III and to know his wishes by virtue of their claimed family connection. [5] It described itself as "his Majesty's representatives and voice". [16] The BBC referred to the group feeling "an almost supernatural bond" with Richard [5] and Charles Brunner called it an "ancestral memory". [7] Vanessa Roe stated in 2013:

Who do we think we are? We don't think we are anyone we know who we are. We are the collateral [non-direct] descendants of Richard III, we speak on behalf of him, the only people who can speak on behalf of him…we decided he needed someone to fight for him…Many of us have grown up knowing about Richard, we know what he wanted. [5]

The group claimed it was Richard's "wish" to be buried in York and called for his re-interment to take place within York Minster. [17] [18] In support of their belief, the alliance pointed to his connections with Yorkshire: he grew up in the county, was known as "Richard of York" prior to becoming king and visited York often during his reign. [8]

Campaign

e-Petition

The Alliance launched a UK Government online "e-Petition" in 2013 in support of their call to have Richard re-buried in York. [19] e-Petitions that receive at least 100,000 signatures become eligible to have their proposal debated in Parliament. [20] However, when the Alliance petition closed on 24 September 2013 it failed to achieve the necessary target, having received only 31,276 signatures. [19]

Litigation

In 2013, the Plantagenet Alliance commenced judicial review proceedings, complaining that they had not been consulted on Richard's place of burial thereby violating their human rights, and which resulted in a court hearing in May 2014. [3] [6] [21] In March 2013, Matthew Howarth of the Leeds firm of solicitors, Gordons, announced that he had written to the Ministry of Justice on behalf of the Plantagenet Alliance claiming that the Ministry had breached Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights in the terms of the archaeological exhumation licence it had issued to the University of Leicester. [8] Article 8 includes the right to respect for family life, and is considered to be one of the convention's most open-ended provisions. [22] The Alliance's claim was specifically that their human rights had been breached because they had not been consulted on the place of reburial. [21] The licence specified that re-interment was to be in Leicester, and they claimed the failure to consult them, as Richard's relatives, violated their Article 8 rights. [8] [21]

Chris Grayling, the Secretary of State for Justice at the time, criticised the Plantagenet Alliance, calling their case "nonsensical". Chris Grayling Official.jpg
Chris Grayling, the Secretary of State for Justice at the time, criticised the Plantagenet Alliance, calling their case "nonsensical".

Chris Grayling, the Secretary of State for Justice at the time, rejected the claim and the Alliance therefore commenced proceedings for judicial review of the Ministry of Justice's decision not to consult on the terms of the licence. [6] The litigation was undertaken by the Alliance's solicitors, Gordons, and by their counsel, Gerard Clarke and Tom Cleaver of Blackstone Chambers, on a contingency fee basis that is, they would only have their fees paid if they win and the court consequently orders that the other side has to pay their legal costs. [6] The proceedings were brought by a company called Plantagenet Alliance Limited, [23] owned and controlled solely by Stephen Nicolay, and which The Telegraph subsequently described as "a 'front' company...with no assets, to avoid being hit with legal costs." [15]

At a preliminary hearing in August 2013 the court gave permission to the Alliance to proceed with the judicial review and granted them a full "protective costs order". [6] The protective costs order meant that the Alliance would not have to pay the Ministry's legal costs even if the Alliance lost the case. [6] [note 2] The judge explained that such orders were granted in judicial review cases where it was in the public interest for the courts to hear the case and it might "otherwise be stifled for lack of financial means". [6]

In May 2014 the case was heard by three High Court judges who ruled in favour of the Ministry of Justice. The judges said there was no "legitimate expectation" that Richard's "collateral descendants would be consulted after centuries in relation to an exhumed historical figure". [3] They also concluded that any consultation was "not capable of sensible limit" since Richard's collateral descendants could number millions of people. [3]

After the decision, Vanessa Roe said that the judgment meant there was "no justice" for Richard III. [25] Chris Grayling, on the other hand, criticised the Plantagenet Alliance for bringing the case, saying that it was "a group with tenuous claims to being relatives of Richard III" and that he was "frustrated and angry" that they had "taken up so much time and public money." [26] He added that:

This nonsensical case is a perfect example of how the system of judicial review is being misused – and at ridiculous expense to taxpayers. Judicial review is, and must remain, an important way to hold authorities to account but we have to do something to stop challenges like this exploiting the system. [15]

The legal costs of the Ministry of Justice and Leicester City Council, which was also a party to the case, amounted to £175,000. Together with the expense of a three-day court hearing the total likely cost to the British taxpayer has been estimated to be in excess of £200,000. [15]

Other reactions

In response to the Alliance's claims, historians said that there was no evidence that Richard III wanted to be buried in York. [16] Mark Ormrod of the University of York expressed scepticism over the idea that Richard had devised any clear plans for his own burial. [27] The standing of the Plantagenet Alliance was also challenged. Mathematician Rob Eastaway calculated that Richard III may have millions of living collateral descendants, saying that "we should all have the chance to vote on Leicester versus York". [28]

Although the Alliance lost their judicial review case, the High Court ruling is cited as authority in administrative law for when there is or is not a legal duty to consult those affected by administrative governmental decisions. [29] [30]

Re-interment in Leicester

Plans for the reburial had been "on hold" while the outcome of the court case was awaited. [3] The Dean of Leicester had called the Plantagenet Alliance's challenge "disrespectful", and said that the cathedral would not be investing funding in the re-interment project until the matter was resolved. [31] Once the High Court decision rejecting the Alliance's claim was issued in May 2014, Tim Stevens, the then Bishop of Leicester, announced that the re-interment would proceed at Leicester Cathedral the following spring. [3] [32] The re-interment took place on 26 March 2015. [33]

See also

Notes

  1. A collateral descendant, in contrast to a lineal descendant, is someone who is not directly descended from the individual in question but, instead, shares a common ancestor with that individual; for example, they may be descended from the individual’s brother, sister, aunt or uncle. [1] Richard III died without leaving any lineal descendants. [2]
  2. Normally in UK litigation, the "Indemnity Rule" applies and the "loser" pays the "winner's" costs. [24]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard III of England</span> King of England from 1483 to 1485

Richard III was King of England from 26 June 1483 until his death in 1485. He was the last king of the House of York and the last of the Plantagenet dynasty. His defeat and death at the Battle of Bosworth Field, the last decisive battle of the Wars of the Roses, marked the end of the Middle Ages in England.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard of York, 3rd Duke of York</span> 15th-century English noble

Richard of York, 3rd Duke of York, also named Richard Plantagenet, was a leading English magnate and claimant to the throne during the Wars of the Roses. He was a member of the ruling House of Plantagenet by virtue of being a direct male-line descendant of Edmund of Langley, King Edward III's fourth surviving son. However, it was through his mother, Anne Mortimer, a descendant of Edward III's second surviving son, Lionel of Antwerp, that Richard inherited his strongest claim to the throne, as the opposing House of Lancaster was descended from John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster, the third surviving son of Edward III. He also inherited vast estates and served in various offices of state in Ireland, France and England, a country he ultimately governed as Lord Protector during the madness of King Henry VI.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">House of York</span> Cadet branch of the House of Plantagenet

The House of York was a cadet branch of the English royal House of Plantagenet. Three of its members became kings of England in the late 15th century. The House of York descended in the male line from Edmund of Langley, 1st Duke of York, the fourth surviving son of Edward III. In time, it also represented Edward III's senior line, when an heir of York married the heiress-descendant of Lionel, Duke of Clarence, Edward III's second surviving son. It is based on these descents that they claimed the English crown. Compared with its rival, the House of Lancaster, it had a superior claim to the throne of England according to cognatic primogeniture, but an inferior claim according to agnatic primogeniture. The reign of this dynasty ended with the death of Richard III of England at the Battle of Bosworth Field in 1485. It became extinct in the male line with the death of Edward Plantagenet, 17th Earl of Warwick, in 1499.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leicester Cathedral</span> Church in Leicestershire, United Kingdom

The Cathedral Church of Saint Martin, Leicester, commonly known as Leicester Cathedral, is a Church of England cathedral in Leicester, England and the seat of the Bishop of Leicester. The church was elevated to a collegiate church in 1922 and made a cathedral in 1927 following the establishment of a new Diocese of Leicester in 1926.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ricardian (Richard III)</span> Person interested in rehabilitating the reputation of Richard III of England

Ricardians are people who dispute the negative posthumous reputation of King Richard III of England. Richard III has long been portrayed unfavourably, most notably in Shakespeare's play Richard III, in which he is portrayed as murdering his 12-year-old nephew Edward V to secure the English throne for himself. Ricardians believe these portrayals are false and politically motivated by Tudor propaganda.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">House of Plantagenet</span> Angevin royal dynasty that ruled England in the middle ages

The House of Plantagenet was a royal house which originated from the lands of Anjou in France. The family held the English throne from 1154 to 1485, when Richard III died in battle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard of Eastwell</span>

Richard Plantagenet or Richard of Eastwell was a reclusive bricklayer who was claimed to be a son of Richard III, the last Plantagenet King of England.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle</span> Royal chapel in Windsor Castle, England

St George's Chapel at Windsor Castle in England is a castle chapel built in the late-medieval Perpendicular Gothic style. It is both a Royal Peculiar and the Chapel of the Order of the Garter. St George's Chapel was founded in the 14th century by King Edward III and extensively enlarged in the late 15th century. It is located in the Lower Ward of the castle. The castle has belonged to the monarchy for almost 1,000 years and was a principal residence of Elizabeth II before her death. The chapel has been the scene of many royal services, weddings and burials – in the 19th century, St George's Chapel and the nearby Frogmore Gardens superseded Westminster Abbey as the chosen burial place for the British royal family. The running of the chapel is the responsibility of the dean and Canons of Windsor who make up the College of Saint George. They are assisted by a clerk, verger and other staff. The Society of the Friends of St George's and Descendants of the Knights of the Garter, a registered charity, was established in 1931 to assist the college in maintaining the chapel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wars of the Roses</span> Dynastic civil war in England from 1455 to 1487

The Wars of the Roses (1455–1487), known at the time and for more than a century after as the Civil Wars, were a series of civil wars fought over control of the English throne in the mid-to-late fifteenth century. These wars were fought between supporters of two rival cadet branches of the royal House of Plantagenet: Lancaster and York. The wars extinguished the male lines of the two branches, leading to the Tudor family inheriting the Lancastrian claim to the throne. Following the war, the Houses of Lancaster and York were united, creating a new royal dynasty and thereby resolving their rival claims. For over thirty years, there were greater and lesser levels of violent conflict between various rival contenders for control of the English monarchy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Greyfriars, Leicester</span> Franciscan friary in England – dissolved 1538

Greyfriars, Leicester, was a friary of the Order of Friars Minor, commonly known as the Franciscans, established on the west side of Leicester by 1250, and dissolved in 1538. Following dissolution the friary was demolished and the site levelled, subdivided, and developed over the following centuries. The locality has retained the name Greyfriars particularly in the streets named "Grey Friars", and the older "Friar Lane".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Exhumation and reburial of Richard III of England</span> 2012 archaeological event

The remains of Richard III, the last English king killed in battle, were discovered within the site of the former Grey Friars Priory in Leicester, England, in September 2012. Following extensive anthropological and genetic testing, the remains were ultimately reinterred at Leicester Cathedral on 26 March 2015.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philippa Langley</span> British writer, producer, and Ricardian

Philippa Jayne Langley is a British writer, producer, and Ricardian, who is best known for her role in the discovery and exhumation of Richard III in 2012, for which she was awarded an MBE. Langley has written books, and appeared in film-length documentaries, on the subject of the search for Richard III, as well as being portrayed in the 2022 drama film, The Lost King.

David Baldwin was a British historian, author and former university lecturer, who lived near Leicester, England.

Benjamin Broadbent (1813–1862) was an English master builder, stonemason, and architect. In 1840 in Leicester, he formed the company Broadbents Ltd, a busy which serviced builders' merchants and roofing contractors. He was also associated with Broadbent and Hawley, stone and marble masons and gravestone cutters. Broadbent built his home, Victoria House, in 1861 in Humberstone. The large estate included a mansion house, stables, coach house, winery, orchard, conservatories and outbuildings. His first wife was the daughter of a farmer from Dodleston, Cheshire called Anne Wright and they had four children. The eldest, also Benjamin, inherited the family business. His second wife was Mary Geary and they had six children. Three years after his death, Victoria House was purchased by the Leicester Corporation to establish the Leicester Borough Asylum, which became the Towers Hospital.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Ashdown-Hill</span> English medieval historian

Louis John Frederick Ashdown-Hill MBE FSA, commonly known as John Ashdown-Hill, was an independent historian and author of books on late medieval English history with a focus on the House of York and Richard III of England. Ashdown-Hill died on 18 May 2018; he had had motor neurone disease for some time.

Kevin SchürerFAcSS FRGS is a British historian, genealogist and statistician, previously Pro-Vice Chancellor of Research and Enterprise, who teaches at the University of Leicester. He specialises in the historical demography, the history of the family and migration in nineteenth-century England and Wales.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Turi King</span> Canadian-British professor of genetics

Turi Emma King is a Canadian-British professor of Public Engagement and Genetics at the University of Leicester. She led the DNA verification during the exhumation and reburial of Richard III of England. She is also known for featuring with Stacey Dooley on the BBC Two genealogy series, DNA Family Secrets.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">King Richard III Visitor Centre</span> Museum in Leicester, England

King Richard III Visitor Centre is a museum in Leicester, England that showcases the life of King Richard III and the story of the discovery, exhumation, and reburial of his remains in 2012-2015.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Annette Carson</span> British non-fiction writer and biographer (born 1940)

Annette Josephine Carson is a British non-fiction author specialising in history, biography and aviation, with a particular interest in King Richard III. Since 2002 she has also been an advocate for UK state pension parity for UK expatriates.

<i>The Lost King</i> British 2022 comedy-drama film

The Lost King is a 2022 British biographical film directed by Stephen Frears. Written by Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope, it is based on the 2013 book The King's Grave: The Search for Richard III by Philippa Langley and Michael Jones. It is a dramatisation of the story of Philippa Langley, the woman who initiated the search to find King Richard III's remains under a car park in Leicester, and her treatment by the University of Leicester in the claiming of credit for the discovery. Coogan and Harry Lloyd also feature in the cast.

References

  1. Purver, Jonathan M. (2017). Family Law Update. Wolters Kluwer. p. 168. ISBN   978-1-4548-7286-3.
  2. Wagner, John A.; Schmid, Susan Walters (2012). Encyclopedia of Tudor England. ABC-CLIO. p. 582. ISBN   978-1-59884-298-2.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Davies, Caroline (23 May 2014). "Richard III's descendants lose battle over reburial in Leicester". The Guardian . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  4. 1 2 Troughton, Adrian (7 February 2013). "Richard III set to be buried in Leicester as university makes final decision". Leicester Mercury . Archived from the original on 25 December 2014. Retrieved 26 March 2013.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Watson, Greig (13 September 2013). "The Plantagenet Alliance: Who do they think they are?". BBC . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Rozenberg, Joshua (15 November 2013). "Why Chris Grayling should bury his appeal against Richard III ruling". The Guardian . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Knight, Sam (13 December 2013). "Where should Richard III lie?". Prospect Magazine . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 Kennedy, Maev (26 March 2013). "Richard III's distant relatives threaten legal challenge over burial". The Guardian . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  9. 1 2 "Plantagenet Alliance Ltd. v. Secretary of State for Justice and Others". Judgment (Approved Text) [2014] EWHC 1662. Courts & Tribunals Judiciary. 23 May 2014. Retrieved 27 March 2015.
  10. Ridge, Mian (29 September 2013). "Richard III: a maligned king's reburial becomes a sordid affair". The Christian Science Monitor . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  11. Hicks, Michael. "Richard III, King of England". Encyclopædia Britannica . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  12. "Richard III burial row campaigners march through York". BBC News. 6 May 2014. Retrieved 27 March 2015.
  13. Walker, Tim (2 March 2013). "Duke of Gloucester's concern for Richard III's 'dignity'". The Daily Telegraph . Retrieved 27 March 2015.
  14. "King Richard III: family's descendants want York reburial". BBC News. 8 February 2013. Retrieved 27 March 2015.
  15. 1 2 3 4 Barrett, David (16 June 2014). "Richard III legal challenge lands taxpayer with £175,000 legal bill". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 16 June 2014. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  16. 1 2 Pitts, Mike (November–December 2013). "Richard III update: a coffin, walls and reburial". British Archaeology. No. 133. pp. 6–7.
  17. "King Richard III burial row heads to High Court". BBC News. 1 May 2013. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  18. "Richard III: King's reburial row goes to judicial review". BBC News. 16 August 2013. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  19. 1 2 Mohamed, Majid (25 September 2013). "Row over burial site for King Richard III: Parliamentary petition calling for debate on final resting place misses target". The Independent . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  20. "E-Petitions and the Backbench Business Committee". UK Parliament website. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  21. 1 2 3 Hall, Melanie (27 March 2013). "Richard III reburial plans breach human rights, say descendants". The Daily Telegraph . Archived from the original on 30 March 2013. Retrieved 3 April 2015.
  22. Elizabeth Wicks; Bernadette Rainey; Clare Ovey (12 June 2014). Jacobs, White and Ovey: the European Convention on Human Rights. Oxford University Press. p. 334. ISBN   978-0-19-965508-3.
  23. Cleaver, Tom (29 August 2013). "The High Court Rides to the Aid of Richard III". UK Constitutional Law Association. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  24. Gary Slapper; David Kelly (24 April 2014). The English Legal System: 2014-2015. Routledge. p. 731. ISBN   978-1-317-69937-8.
  25. "'No justice' for Richard III says 16th great-niece". ITV News. 23 May 2014. Retrieved 27 March 2015.
  26. Sherwin, Adam (23 May 2014). "Richard III relatives lose High Court battle as judge rules king should be given 'dignified' burial". The Independent . Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  27. Ormrod, Mark (5 February 2013). "A burial fit for a King". University of York. Retrieved 7 May 2013.
  28. "Richard III: More or Less examines how many descendents he could have". BBC News. 19 August 2013. Retrieved 24 August 2013.
  29. Donelly, Catherine (2017). "Participation and Expertise: Judicial Attitudes in Comparative Perspective". In Ackerman, Susan-Rose; Lindseth, Peter; Emerson, Blake (eds.). Comparative Administrative Law. p. 381. ISBN   9781784718664.
  30. Stanton, John; Prescott, Craig (2020). Public Law. p. 519. ISBN   9780198852278.
  31. "Richard III remains: Reinterment delay 'disrespectful'". BBC News. 16 July 2013. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  32. "Richard III reburial court bid fails". BBC News. 26 March 2015. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  33. "Richard III: Leicester Cathedral reburial service for king". BBC News. 26 March 2015. Retrieved 26 March 2015.