Question in the Form of an Answer

Last updated
Question in the Form of an Answer
Putsquestionintheformofananswer.jpg
Studio album by
ReleasedJune 6, 2000 [1]
Recorded1999–2000, Los Angeles, California
Genre Hip hop
Length73:41
Label Om Records
Producer
People Under the Stairs chronology
The Next Step
(1998)
Question in the Form of an Answer
(2000)
American Men Vol. 1
(2000)
Singles from Question in the Form of an Answer
  1. "Youth Explosion"
    Released: 2000
  2. "The Cat"
    Released: 2000
  3. "We'll Be There"
    Released: November 2000

Question in the Form of an Answer is the second studio album by the People Under the Stairs. Recorded following their first world tour, the album was their first release on Om Records [2] (the label would later re-release the duo's first album the following year). The release spawned three singles, each selling their entire first pressing run of 15,000 copies, and a second world tour.

Contents

Background

In 1999, People Under The Stairs signed a four-album deal with Om Records, and the title of their second album, Question in the Form of an Answer, came to them while driving up to San Francisco to meet with the Om staff. Om offered them a cash advance on the record deal, and the group immediately went to a local record store, Groove Merchant, and used the money to buy a large number of records, several of which would contain samples that wound up being used on the record. [3]

Recording

Planned as a logical extension of their first record, Question in the Form of an Answer opened with the same music sample that the previous album closed on. Also similar to the first album, Question... was self-recorded at Thes One's Los Angeles home, and utilized the same instrumentation - namely, Thes One's Akai MPC3000 and Double K's E-mu SP-1200.

Despite the similarities, the music departed from the sound of the debut album. Thes One and Double K's knowledge of sampling techniques had grown during the intervening years between the first two albums, and the music on their second release contained more complex filtering techniques, sound manipulation, and analogue recording techniques. [3] "Earth Travelers", the first music track made for the album, incorporates a large number of layers, including high- and low-pass filters, resonance, horn loops, and drum loops. The creation of a portion of the track can be seen on the bonus DVD which accompanies PUTS' 2006 release Stepfather .

The lyrics also toned down the more aggressive themes and battle rap sensibilities of their first album, and instead, the rhymes covered topics including record collecting, recreational drinking and marijuana use (which was at its peak for the group during the recording of this album [4] ), and making music. This album also contained fewer guest MCs than The Next Step, and every record since Question... has continued this practice.

In the same manner as "San Francisco Knights" from the group's first album, People Under The Stairs decided to include a true personal story, "July 3rd", on their second release as well. On July 3, 1999, Thes One was hit by a minivan while crossing the street at the corner of W 3rd St and S Hobart Blvd in Los Angeles, and the driver of the minivan attempted to kidnap him and drive away. Several bystanders, including a video store security guard, stopped the man, and a bloodied Thes One was taken to the hospital.

This album is the only People Under The Stairs release to contain a hidden track. The hidden track on this album consists of two minutes of "shout outs" to friends and fellow hip hop artists.

Reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusic Star full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar empty.svgStar empty.svg [1]
Entertainment Weekly B+ [5]
PopMatters (favorable) [6]

The album received positive, but subdued, reviews upon its release. Entertainment Weekly called the album "intelligent and funky", [5] and AllMusic dubbed Question... "a very solid hip-hop album from top to bottom". PopMatters was much more enthusiastic in its review, calling PUTS' second album "a thoroughly fresh celebration of hip-hop" and "a funky blast of fresh air". [6]

Track listing

All songs written by Christopher "Thes One" Portugal and Michael "Double K" Turner, except where noted.

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Intro" 1:48
2."Crazy Live" 3:26
3."Youth Explosion" 4:39
4."Suite For Creeper" 3:46
5."Sterns To Western (feat. Capn’ Kidd Lexus)"C. Portugal, M. Turner, B. Collins3:56
6."Code Check" 3:36
7."Blowin Wax" 4:35
8."Give Love A Chance" 4:30
9."Stoned Youth Truth" 0:18
10."Yehaw Partystyles" 2:45
11."Get Drunk" 0:35
12."43 Labels I Like" 1:50
13."King Kuff" 0:46
14."E Business (feat. JazMak)"C. Portugal, M. Turner, A. Satchel4:38
15."Zignaflyinblow" 2:18
16."July 3rd" 3:51
17."Stay Home" 3:21
18."Earth Travelers" 4:34
19."The Cat" 3:44
20."Electric Laddy" 0:15
21."We’ll Be There" 5:26
22."Fredly Advice†" 8:16

†The track "Fredly Advice" is only 1:46, with a hidden bonus track occurring at the 6-minute mark.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ultramagnetic MCs</span> American hip hop group

The Ultramagnetic MCs is an American hip hop group based in the Bronx, New York City. Founded by Kool Keith, the group also includes Ced Gee, TR Love, and Moe Love. Tim Dog became an unofficial member in 1989. In 1990, DJ Jaycee was added as a road manager and backup DJ. Big.D was put down with the crew by Kool Keith in 1989. A former member, Rooney Roon, was fired following an assault arrest. Beat-boxer Rahzel was also involved with the group early in its career. The group's work was associated with unorthodox sampling, polysyllabic rhymes, and bizarre lyrical imagery.

The new school of hip hop was a movement in hip hop music, beginning in 1983–84 with the early records of Run–D.M.C., Whodini, and LL Cool J. Predominantly from Queens and Brooklyn, it was characterized by drum machine-led minimalism, often tinged with elements of rock; rapped taunts, boasts, and socio-political commentary; and aggressive, self-assertive delivery. In song and image, its artists projected a tough, cool, street b-boy attitude. These elements contrasted sharply with funk and disco, novelty hits, live bands, synthesizers, and party rhymes of artists prevalent in the early 1980s. Compared to their older hip hop counterparts, new school artists crafted more cohesive LPs and shorter songs more amenable to airplay. By 1986, their releases began to establish hip hop in the mainstream.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eric B. & Rakim</span> American hip hop duo

Eric B. & Rakim were an American hip hop duo formed on Long Island, New York, in 1986, composed of DJ Eric B. and rapper Rakim. They first received acclaim for their 1987 debut album Paid in Full, which featured versions of the popular singles "Eric B. Is President" and the title track. They followed with three successful albums: Follow the Leader (1988), Let the Rhythm Hit 'Em (1990), and Don't Sweat the Technique (1992).

Jazz rap is a fusion of jazz and hip hop music, as well as an alternative hip hop subgenre, that developed in the late 1980s and early 1990s. AllMusic writes that the genre "was an attempt to fuse African-American music of the past with a newly dominant form of the present, paying tribute to and reinvigorating the former while expanding the horizons of the latter." The rhythm was rooted in hip hop over which were placed repetitive phrases of jazz instrumentation: trumpet, double bass, etc. Groups involved in the formation of jazz rap included A Tribe Called Quest, Digable Planets, De La Soul, Gang Starr, The Roots, Jungle Brothers, and Dream Warriors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">People Under the Stairs</span> American former hip hop duo

People Under the Stairs was an American hip hop duo from Los Angeles, California, formed in 1997 and disbanded in 2019. Since their inception, the group consisted solely of Christopher Portugal and Michael Turner. The group employed a DIY work ethic of sampling, MCing, DJing, and producing all of their output.

<i>Critical Beatdown</i> 1988 studio album by Ultramagnetic MCs

Critical Beatdown is the debut studio album by American hip hop group Ultramagnetic MCs, released on October 4, 1988, by Next Plateau Records. Production for the album was handled primarily by the group's rapper and producer Ced-Gee, who employed an E-mu SP-1200 sampler as the album's main instrument. Music journalists have noted the album for its innovative production, funk-based samples, self-assertive themes, and clever lyrical rhymes by Ced-Gee and rapper Kool Keith.

<i>The Next Step</i> (People Under the Stairs album) 1998 studio album by People Under the Stairs

The Next Step is the debut studio album by People Under the Stairs, released on March 24, 1998. The duo was responsible for nearly every aspect of the album's production and initial release. Quick sales of the album and its sole single, "The Next Step II", also helped to get the group noticed by the label Om Records, with whom the group produced four other albums and found greater success.

<i>...Or Stay Tuned</i> 2003 studio album by People Under the Stairs

...Or Stay Tuned is the fourth studio album by the People Under the Stairs and their final release on Om Records until 2009's Carried Away. The group's shortest album, it was originally marketed as an EP release and called a "mini-album" in the liner notes. In the years since the album's release, the group has counted it among their main album catalog, as it was released on double-vinyl and meets the criteria for being full-length. The album also produced one single, "Yield".

Om Records is an American record label, established in 1995, which releases electronic music, dance music and hip hop. The label was founded in San Francisco in 1995 by Chris Smith. Om Records releases both artist albums and compilations, including the Om Lounge and Mushroom Jazz series. Om's roster of artists includes Groove Armada, Underworld, Dirty Vegas, Bassnectar, Indiana Taurus, J Boogie, People Under The Stairs, Samantha James, Amp Live, Greenskeepers, Hot Toddy, and Wagon Cookin. Past artists have included Kaskade, Wolfgang Gartner, Ladybug Mecca, and Juan Atkins.

<i>Stepfather</i> (album) 2006 studio album by People Under the Stairs

Stepfather is the fifth album by the People Under the Stairs. The album signified a departure from the group's previous, Golden age hip hop sound, and the album introduced a more widely varied array of sample sources. The album also spawned two singles, "Tuxedo Rap" and "Pass The 40".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thes One</span> American rapper

Christopher Cesar Portugal, best known as Thes One, was one half of hip hop duo People Under the Stairs, serving as a vocalist/MC, producer, engineer and business manager. He has produced and engineered 8 albums for People Under the Stairs that have sold in excess of 100,000 units in the U.S. alone since 2000, have appeared on the U.S. and International Billboard charts numerous times, as well as numerous remixes and singles for other artists across the globe with numerous appearances as guest vocalist. As a business manager, he has coordinated and managed 21+ successful world tours for People Under the Stairs and co-founded the independent artist-run Tres Records label. He also designs and builds recording studios and custom gear. His musical aliases include Lord Radio.

<i>Fun DMC</i> 2008 studio album by People Under the Stairs

Fun DMC is the sixth album by People Under the Stairs. The album was a concept album and, at the time of its release, the most widely reviewed and lauded of the group's catalog. In support of the album, PUTS released two singles, as well as the group's first music video for "The Wiz". For the release of the album, the group again chose an independent label, Gold Dust Media.

<i>Carried Away</i> (People Under the Stairs album) 2009 studio album by People Under the Stairs

Carried Away is the seventh studio album by People Under the Stairs. The group chose to release the album on the independent label, Om Records, which they had last been on for 2003's ...Or Stay Tuned. The album is a mixture of the Golden age hip hop sound of their earlier Om releases, and a continuation of the more expansive sample-sourcing of their last two albums. Carried Away produced three singles and two music videos, and the album continued the tradition of a steady stream of positive reviews for the group.

<i>O.S.T.</i> (album) 2002 studio album by People Under the Stairs

O.S.T. is the third album by the People Under the Stairs. The album was again produced in Thes One's home entirely by the duo, and it was finally released in June 2002 on Om Records. The album produced three singles, including "Acid Raindrops", one of the group's most successful songs and a constant staple at live shows.

<i>American Men Vol. 1</i> 2000 compilation album by People Under the Stairs

American Men Vol. 1 is the first compilation album by People Under the Stairs. It is a combination of outtakes from the group's first two albums, songs produced for other local Los Angeles recording artists, and one live track from the 2000 Glastonbury festival.

<i>The Om Years</i> 2008 compilation album by People Under the Stairs

The Om Years is the second compilation album by People Under the Stairs. It is a combination of popular tracks from the group's first four albums, and also includes extra b-sides and rarities.

<i>Highlighter</i> (album) 2011 studio album by People Under the Stairs

Highlighter is the eighth album by the People Under the Stairs, and the first one released on Thes One's artist-cooperative label, Piecelock 70. With the exception of an iTunes-only EP, the album was released without accompanying singles or music videos. In the months following the release of Highlighter, PUTS embarked on yet another tour in support of the album.

<i>Lifestyle Marketing</i> 2007 studio album by Thes One

Lifestyle Marketing is the debut studio album by producer and musician Thes One. It is an instrumental concept album consisting almost entirely of samples taken from radio and television advertising jingles created by Herb Pilhofer of Sound 80 Incorporated.

<i>12 Step Program</i> (album) 2014 studio album by People Under the Stairs

12 Step Program is the ninth album by the People Under the Stairs. It is the second album entirely self-distributed using Thes One's artist-cooperative label, Piecelock 70, and it is also the group's shortest record to be marketed as a full-length album upon its release. 12 Step Program is also the group's first album since their second album, Question in the Form of an Answer, that uses only samples and no live instrumentation.

Michael Turner, best known as Double K, was an American rapper, producer and DJ. As one half of the hip hop duo People Under the Stairs, he appeared on 12 studio albums in addition to a number of singles, extended plays and compilations. He also released one instrumental solo album, Clinophobia (2017), under his moniker L.A. Mike.

References

  1. 1 2 Question in the Form of an Answer at AllMusic
  2. "Way Back: Question in the Form of an Answer (2000)". Tribe Called Trav. 2020-06-06. Retrieved 2023-10-09.
  3. 1 2 Portugal, Christopher (August 2013). 10 Years Of Thes One. Booklet accompanying box set release.
  4. "Backstage Interview with People Under the Stairs in San Francisco". The Point of the Rhyme. 2011-11-01. Archived from the original on 2013-12-08. Retrieved 2014-02-23.
  5. 1 2 "Question in the Form of an Answer (album review)". Entertainment Weekly . 2000-06-16. Retrieved 2016-07-16.
  6. 1 2 Heaton, Dave (June 2000). "People Under the Stairs: Question in the Form of an Answer (album review)". PopMatters . Retrieved 2016-07-16.