Rahim Rostami (born 16 June 1991 in Narest, Iran) is an Iran-born asylum seeker who became known to the public in Norway via national TV station NRK in the investigative journalism "NRK Brennpunkt" programs where he in twice appeared in programs focusing on Senjehesten Asylum Seeker Reception Center where he came forward as spokesperson for criticism from the residents. The Brennpunkt programs pointed out unacceptable conditions at this reception center, which was later closed-down.[1]
Following the Brennpunkt programs, Rostami and three other residents were moved to another reception center, allegedly to regain calm at the center.[2]
Rostami came to Norway as a minor. His asylum application was based on fear of persecution and the consequences of a death penalty following an in absentia judgement in Iran that he became aware of after he fled.[3] The Norwegian Norwegian Directorate of Immigration (UDI) and the Immigration Appeals Board (UNE) found the documentation to not be credible, and turned down the asylum application.
As Rostami attempted to open a bank account, the bank notified the immigration authorities,[4] and he was arrested by the National Police Immigration Service and deported to Teheran, where he was handed over to Iranian authorities, who imprisoned him in Evin prison with a bail option that was shortly after withdrawn.
Status
Rostami was imprisoned in Evin prison, Teheran from 10 ,2011 to 20 June, 2011, when he was released on bail to await trial.[5]
In June 2011, Rostami's attorney Cecilie Schjatvet said: "There is no doubt that the death penalty against Rahim Rostami is real". The bail sum was almost 90,000 Euro.[6]
Background
Rahim Rostami grew up in Iranian Kurdistan
Rostami comes from the village Narest in the western Iran. He came to Norway 17 years old as an unaccompanied minor. Rahim fled from Iran in August 2008, via Turkey and Greece to Norway, and applied for asylum in October 2008.
According to article[3] in the weekly magazine Ny Tid the asylum application was in part founded on an in absentia judgement from Iran that UDI and UNE considered false, and consequently did not take into consideration in the evaluation of the asylum application.[7]
During his first year at the reception center, Rostami learned Norwegian. During a public meeting at Skrolsvik on the island of Senja, he held an appeal in Norwegian on the unacceptable conditions at the reception center.[8][9]
Asylum application in Norway
Rostami applied for asylum in Norway 12 October, 2008. His application was initially evaluated and turned down by the Norwegian Directorate of Immigration (UDI) 9 October, 2009, and the rejection was sustained by the Norwegian Immigration Appeals Board 5. July 2010. Rostami was then ordered to leave the country within 4 August, 2010. A revocation request was filed, but the Immigration Appeals Board sustained their decision 9 February, 2011, the same date he was detained by the National Police Immigration Service. He was deported to Iran the next day.
Senjehesten asylum reception center / support from the locals
Rahim leaves Senjehesten reception center 3 November 2009
Rostami became known to Norwegian media through the national TV station NRK, in the investigative journalism "Brennpunkt" programs where he in twice appeared in programs focusing on Senjehesten Asylum Seeker Reception Center. The center had received extensive criticism for that the center manager countered in both programs and also later.[10] The criticism focused on the center manager running illegal shop activities in the center, reprehensible conditions in the sanitary installations, inadequate technical maintenance, lacking activation opportunities, that a driver (already paid to do the job) demanded payment for driving residents to the nearest village Finnsnes, and that the center manager was insufficiently available. Prior to the opening of the center, the locals had warned UDI against giving operating permit to a person that was previously convicted for economic crimes and had run bankrupt several times.[11] A person formerly in charge of activities at Senjehesten that was dismissed from his position and tok the dismissal to the court was awarded his job back, and a financial compensation. Senjehesten reception center was later closed down following continuous dissatisfaction from UDI regarding how the center was run.[1] Following the Brennpunkt program showing 18-year-old Rostami in front of an enthusiastic audience at a public meeting, he and three other residents was ordered to move from the center against own wish,[12] and instead sent to Oscarsgata reception center in Vadsø.[13] Rostami's former guardian Frode Olsen reacted strongly on the moving order, and opened his home for free for Rostami, who then lost his financial support from UDI when moving out of the center.
Former guardian Frode Olsen
– Rahim has never been involved in any episodes at the reception center. He has behaved exemplary. All he has done is to be spokesperson for the asylum seekers at Senjehesten. That is why they ordered him to Vadsø, Frode Olsen said to NRK.[14]
Arrest, imprisonment and deportation
While the immigration authorities processed the revocation request towards the UNE rejection, Rostami lived with friends in the Oslo region. In February 2011, a bank notified the immigration authorities that Rostami attempted to open a bank account bankkonto.[4] He was detained in the bank by the National Police Immigration Service 9 February 2011, the same day UNE rejected the revocation request. After one night at Trandum Detention Center Rostami was deported to Teheran with police escort 10 February 2011, arriving 11. February at around 1 pm. He was there handed over to Iranian authorities, who immediately arrested him.
Imprisonment in Iran
Evin prison
Rostami was immediately detained after hand-over to Iranian authorities at Teheran Khomeini airport, and transported to Evin prison, a known torture prison north west of Teheran where regime critics are held. The prison is notorious for torturing political prisoners, initially documented in 2004 by Human Rights Watch in the report "Like the Dead in Their Coffins": Torture, Detention, and the Crushing of Dissent in Iran[15] published on the web page of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
Rostamis family was 1. March 2011 notified that he was imprisoned against a bail sum of 10 million rials (almost 90 000 Euro), an enormous sum, but was two weeks later notified that the bail option was withdrawn, as Rostami was indicted for «crimes against national security». He is said to have spent several weeks in solitary confinement in Evin prison.[3]
Iranian authorities' actions against potential regime opponents
Symbol of the 2009 Green Movement
Iranian authorities have since the 2009 election tightened the grip around oppositional groups and individuals, and hits hard down on anyone suspected of disloyalty against the regime. Asylum seekers are pointed out as a group that by fleeing from Iran has shown such disloyalty, which is documented by The Norwegian Country of Origin Information Centre - Landinfo in a note published on their web site 19. April 2011.[16]
Iranian surveillance of opposition groups in Norway has been known for years, and the Iranian objectives of such surveillance is assumed to be to monitor and hinder any opposition against Iran in Europe. The activities of spies among Iranian asylum seekers in Norway has at several occasions been referred in Norwegian media,[17] lately in a report at national TV broadcaster NRK 30 March 2011,[18] around six weeks after Rahim Rostamis was deported. It describes how Iranian authorities attempt to recruit asylum seekers in Norway in order to infiltrate political exile groups in Norway.
The Iranian embassy in Oslo denied this categorically in a press release 1. April 2011 where they say that this is fiction influenced by the Zionist lobby, and that the purpose is to undermine the bilateral relations between Norway and Iran.[19]
Reactions to the Rostami case in the public
Reactions from engaged individuals
The xenophobia expressed by some persons in the village of Skrollsvika on island of Senja felt when the asylum center was established was turned to a concern for the welfare or the residents of Senjehesten reception center. Following the first Brennpunkt program[8] UDI ordered the center to arrange a public information meeting, where the strong local concerns for the conditions at the center were expressed.[20]
The local reactions after the deportation of Rostami have also been strong. After the case became national news, mainly through the articles of the weekly magazine Ny Tid, social media have been used extensively in the engagement for Rostami's case, both on Facebook[21] and in the more serious Norwegian internet discussion forums such as NyeMeninger.no and Verdidebatt.no:
"UNE claims without basis – sim sala bim!" [33][34]
Characteristic for the engagement amongst those who know Rostami is the letter 9-year-old Torgeir sent to the King: "We have been told that his life is in danger and I am very afraid that they will hurt him in the prison".[35]
In a note on her blog,[36] author and former paperless and evicted Maria Amelie describes how the situation of the paperless has become visible in an entirely new way, referring amongst other to Rahim Rostami:
Less than a year ago there were no organizations, Facebook groups, very few that followed up asylum cases such as with Rahim Rostami where they remembered his birthday while he was in a prison. There was little knowledge to the paperless subclass. Today so much is different. [Information on the] paperless are in the media and on the streets - Palestinians, Iranians and Ethiopians. People that regardless of nationality has a strong association to Norway. People that regardless of the quality of their papers do not want to leave a country that they have become fond of. That gives me hope. Because one thing is when the paperless and their opinions become visible and they dear to come forward with their stories. Another thing is when the people of Norway become engaged on their behalf and also no longer wants to be invisible.
Reactions from NGOs
Several Norwegian Non-governmental organizations mentioned Rahim Rostamis case as it became publicly known. When UNE director Terje Sjeggestad in an interview in the Rostami case with Ny Tid 8 April 2011[37] claimed that the Immigrations Appeal Board (UNE) is "a human rights organization with more competence on the area than other organizations in Norway", it triggered strong reactions from Amnesty Norway, the Norwegian Centre for Human Rights and the Norwegian Helsinki Committee for Human Rights.[38]
A line of Norwegian NGOs (Antirasistisk Senter, Norsk Folkehjelp, Norsk Organisasjon for Asylsøkere (NOAS), Selvhjelp for innvandrere og flyktninger (SEIF), Den norske Helsingforskomité, Redd Barna, Peoplepeace, Rådgivningsgruppa i Trondheim, KFUK-KFUM Global og Juridisk rådgivning for kvinner (JURK)) on 7. April 2011 made a joint petition to Norwegian authorities with three demands:[39]
Norwegian engagement and pressure on Iranian authorities to get Rahim Rostami out of prison
Stop deportations to Iran until a review of the Rostami case had been done
Upon his release, get Rahim Rostami safely back to Norway
In addition, several of those organizations made statements on their web pages::
Synne Skouen in Aftenposten[40] Why are Strasbourg [European Court of Human Rights] rulings needed before the advice of our own human rights' experts are heard? Do we have to accept «errors» sending life scared 19-year olds back to prison and death? What does it take before "the cup is full"?
Human rights lawyer Mohammad Mostafaei in Dagbladet[41] It is known that Rostami was politically active, and Iran performs massive surveillance of Iranians in Norway, it is therefore incomprehensible that they could return Rostami to Iran.
Former guardian Frode Olsen at NRK[42] We don't know what is happening. We hear scary stories from Iranian prisons. I am very worried for him.
Mahmood Amiry-Moghaddam, leader of Iran Human Rights, to weekly magazine Ny Tid[3] This is decidedly the most serious case we have seen. All signals say that Rostami is in acute risk of his life. We ask Norwegian authorities to do all that is in their power to save his life.
Secretary of state in Ministry of Justice and Public SecurityPål Lønseth to weekly magazine Ny Tid[43] The Department of Justice has requested from the Immigration Appeals Board (UNE) a statement on this case. UNE has reported they are working on verifying whether the claims are correct. I am satisfied with that. It is a serious matter if it should be shown that misjudgments have led to the return of a person in need of protection.
Human rights advocate Mahmood Amiry-Moghaddam to Iran Human Rights[44] It is not clear what charges are raised against him, but the fact that the Iranian authorities have refused to release him on bail indicates that his case is serious. Iranian authorities have recently signalized that Iranians who have sought asylum abroad should be charged for "dissemination of false propaganda against the Islamic Republic of Iran" and punished for that. This means that seeking asylum by itself could be a reason for the Iranian authorities to subject the asylum seekers who are extradited to Iran, to persecution, imprisonment and ill-treatment.
Human rights advocate Mahmood Amiry-Moghaddam to Nettavisen[45] We do not know the charges against him, but the fact that he is held in Evin without bail option is very serious. We know how easy it is for Iranian authorities to execute people.
UNE-director Terje Sjeggestad in Aftenposten[46] Synne Skouen i her article 6. April made uncritical claims that 19-year-old Rahim Rostami has been returned to persecution in Iran."
Terje Sjeggestad is known for his harsh reactions towards criticism:
Human rights advocate Mahmood Amiry-Moghaddam to Nettavisen[47] The new indictment against him is based on his participation to opposition meetings while he was in Norway. This shows that Iranian authorities monitor the activities of Iranians abroad, and uses it against them when they return to the country. Norwegian authorities must take into account such potential consequences when deporting Iranian asylum seekers to Iran.
Attorney Cecilie Schjatvet to weekly magazine Ny Tid [6] ([48] English translation) There is no doubt that the indictment and death penalty against Rahim Rostami are real, and that the return to Iran has put his life at risk. The Rahim case demonstrates that the methods used by Norwegian immigration authorities in this case to verify whether a person is in need of protection or not, are unsuitable. Even if Rostami has been sent out of the country, Norway has a clear responsibility. Norwegian authorities should follow international law, saying that they have an obligation to rectify the situation.
The deputy leader of The Liberal Party of Norway Helge Solum Larsen to ukemagasinet Ny Tid [6] ([48] English translation) Deportations to Iran should not happen at all, knowing the current situation in that country. I have no confidence in the government's policy on this subject.
Synne Skouen in Aftenposten[49] Where are you, Minister of Justice Knut Storberget? We want you to throw around and do what Norwegian authorities according to attorney Schjatvet is er committed to through international law, that is «to rectify the situation». Now you must, quickly as hell, find out what that could be.
Reaction from the Immigration authorities
The immigration authorities have following the deportation of Rostami argued in the media that their decision was correct, based on the information they hold. UNE-director Terje Sjeggestad also claimed in an interview with weekly magazine Ny Tid that UNE is a human rights organization,[37] to which the "regular" human rights organizations responded negatively in unison.[38]
After Secretary of State Pål Lønseth of the Department of Justice told Ny Tid that UNE had been asked for a statement on the Rostami case, UNE published in their web page 19. April 2011 the statement "Claims without coverage",[7] where they refuted all critical remarks made through the media in relation to the deportation of Rostami. They write: "The circumstances of the case, as they have been portrayed in the media, are significantly different from what UNE decisions are based on."
Two days later, 21. April 2011, Foreign Minister Jonas Gahr Støre published the press release "Increase in brutal public executions in Iran"[50] where he puts forward: "One of the world society's most important sources of information on executions [in Iran] is therefore Iranian human rights organizations and -defenders. These groups and individuals are on a daily basis subject of threats, harassment and imprisonment. "
An article later published on the internet discussion forum NyeMeninger.no criticized the UNE statement of 19. April, and claimed that UNEs claims could be refuted on all points.[33] The writer ended the article with: "Sorry, UNE - the only irrefutable in your declaration is the title, as this was truly a collection of claims without coverage."
Intervention from United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
Following the media coverage of the Rostami case, the UNHCR office in Geneva sent a request to UNE 4. April 2011 requesting a complete copy of the file, with reference to their role as surveillance authority according to article 35 of the Refugee convention of 1951 and the annexed protocol of 1967, and the Norwegian Immigration Act §98.
Landinfo - the information source of the Norwegian foreign authorities
In the wake of Rahim Rostamis forced deportation and imprisonment in Iran questions and criticism have been raised around the use of information from the Norwegian Country of Origin Information Centre - Landinfo. Until 19. April 2011 the latest updated official information on Iran from Landinfo was dated as far back as to 2007, and thus contained no information on the severely deteriorating conditions in Iran after the Iranian presidential election in 2009, the Green Revolution and the intensification from the clerical regime of actions against the opposition.
This missing updating has been subject of criticism at previous occasions from lawyers, The Iranian Refugee Council in Norway, Norwegian NGOs and the Norwegian Church.[51][52]
On 19 April 2011 Landinfo published a report documenting the increased threat for turned-down asylum seekers returning to Iran. Much of the information in this report was based on material already published on UNHCR web pages, and the Rahim Rostami case was mentioned in the report.[16]
General country information on Iran was in May 2011 removed from the web pages of Landinfo, and replaced by a link to the Swedish information web portal, explained by lack of resources for giving a satisfactory continuous updating on the situation.
This substantiates the fact that the information upon which the deportation decision for Rahim Rostami was taken, was based on outdated information in the situation in Iran.
Related Research Articles
Erna Solberg is a Norwegian politician and the current Leader of the Opposition. She served as the 35th prime minister of Norway from 2013 to 2021, and has been Leader of the Conservative Party since May 2004.
Per Sandberg is a Norwegian politician for the Capitalist Party and formerly the Progress Party who served as the Norwegian Minister of Fisheries from 2015 to 2018. Sandberg was a member of the Norwegian parliament from 1997 to 2017, and served as chair of the parliamentary standing committees on Justice, and Transport and Communications. He has additionally held the position of first deputy leader of the Progress Party from 2006 to 2018. In 1997 he was convicted of assault and battery of an asylum seeker. His status as a convicted felon has made him controversial in Norwegian politics.
Raymond Johansen is a Norwegian politician for the Labour Party. He served as Governing Mayor of Oslo from 2015 to 2023. A former member of the Socialist Left Party, Johansen previously served as the Oslo city commissioner for transport and environment from 1992 to 1995, when his party withdrew from the city cabinet. After joining Labour, he served as the party secretary from 2009 to 2015.
Sven-Roald Nystø is a Lule Sámi politician from Storå in Tysfjord, Norway. He has worked for the Lule Sámi cultural and language center Árran as a senior advisor.
Peder Are Nøstvold Jensen is a Norwegian far-right counter-jihad blogger who writes under the pseudonym Fjordman. Jensen wrote anonymously as Fjordman starting in 2005, until he disclosed his identity in 2011. He has been active in the counter-jihad movement, which argues that multiculturalism, particularly Muslim mass immigration, poses an existential threat to Western civilization. He has promoted this belief in a self-published book titled Defeating Eurabia, and stated that "Islam, and all those who practice it, must be totally and physically removed from the entire Western world".
Per-Willy Trudvang Amundsen is a Norwegian politician for the Progress Party who served as Minister of Justice from December 2016 to January 2018. He previously served as state secretary in the Ministry of Local Government and Regional Development from 2013, and represented Troms in the Norwegian parliament from 2005 until 2013. He was re-elected in 2017.
Sylvi Listhaug is a Norwegian politician who has been the leader of the Progress Party since 2021.
Mazyar Keshvari is an Iranian-born Norwegian former politician for the Progress Party and a convicted felon who is serving two prison sentences for fraud and violent threats. He was elected as a substitute member of the Norwegian parliament for the city of Oslo in 2013, representing the right-wing and anti-immigration Progress Party, and attended parliamentary sessions from 2013 to 2018 as the substitute of the mandate holder Siv Jensen who has been on leave from parliament during her government service. As a politician he was known for taking a hard stance on immigration, calling for a complete ban on further immigration to Norway, a stop to the practice of accepting asylum seekers in Norway, and the deportation of immigrants convicted of crimes. In 2019 he was convicted of aggravated fraud for defrauding the Norwegian parliament and in 2020 he was sentenced to 11 months imprisonment. He left the Norwegian parliament following his indictment in 2018 and also left the Progress Party in October 2019. In 2019 he was also arrested and charged with making violent threats, and he was convicted and sentenced to an additional four months in prison in 2020.
Odd Karsten Tveit is a Norwegian journalist, writer and economist. His speciality is the Middle East, a subject on which he has written several books. Tveit has been a foreign correspondent for the Norwegian Broadcasting Corporation (NRK) in the Middle East through three periods, from 1979 to 1983, from 1990 to 1994, and from 2003 to 2007.
Fredrik Stang Heffermehl was a Norwegian jurist, writer and peace activist. He worked as a lawyer and civil servant from 1965 to 1982 and was the first secretary-general of the Norwegian Humanist Association from 1980 to 1982. He later made his mark as a writer and activist for peace and against nuclear arms. He was the honorary president, and president, of the Norwegian Peace Council, a vice president of the International Peace Bureau, and a vice president of the International Association of Lawyers against Nuclear Arms.
In 2017, Norway's immigrant population consisted of 883,751 people, making up 16.8% of the country's total population. Of this number, 724,987 are foreign-born, while 158,764 are Norwegian-born with foreign-born parents. The ten most common countries of origin of immigrants residing in Norway are Poland (97,197), Lithuania (37,638), Sweden (36,315), Somalia (28,696), Germany (24,601), Iraq (22,493), Syria (20,823), Philippines (20,537), Pakistan (19,973) and Eritrea (19,957). The immigrant population comprises people from a total of 221 countries and autonomous regions, but 25% of the immigrants are from one of four migrant groups: Polish, Lithuanians, Swedes and Somalis.
Kebabnorsk, also known as Kebab Norwegian or Norwegian multiethnolect, is a language variant of Norwegian that incorporates words and grammatical structures from languages spoken by immigrants to Norway such as Turkish, Kurdish, Arabic, Urdu, Pashto, Persian, Punjabi, Tamil, and Chilean Spanish, as well as English. The multiethnolect differs from an ethnolect because it is spoken not by one particular ethnic group, but by the many varying immigrant populations in Norway, drawing elements from each of their respective languages. The Norwegian multiethnolect emerged from immigrant youth communities, particularly those in eastern neighborhoods of Oslo, and has spread to broader youth populations through permeation of mainstream Norwegian media. The term sociolect is also useful when discussing this variant, because sociological factors such as age, neighborhood, ethnic identity, and gender play important roles in classifying and understanding Norwegian multiethnolect.
The Minister of Health and Care Services is a councilor of state and chief of the Norway's Ministry of Health and Care Services. Since 19 April 2024 the position has been held by Jan Christian Vestre of the Labour Party. The ministry is responsible for healthcare and care services, with the state's healthcare activities being carried out by four regional health authorities. Major institutions subordinate to the ministry include the Directorate for Health, the Board of Health Supervision, the Institute of Public Health, the Medicines Agency, the Radiation Protection Authority, the Labour and Welfare Service and the Food Safety Authority.
Madina Salamova, better known by the pseudonym Maria Amelie, is a Russian-born writer, blogger and entrepreneur who lived as an illegal immigrant in Norway between 2002 and 2011. She was deported from Norway to Russia on 24 January 2011.
International Reporter (IR) (Norwegian: Internasjonal Reporter, IR) is a Norwegian non-governmental organisation, working to improve and expand Norwegian media coverage of Africa, Asia and Latin-America. It encourages journalistic cooperation across borders as well as the use of non-western sources.
Hassan Abdi Dhuhulow was a Norwegian-Somalian Islamist terrorist and Al-Shabaab-member who was one of four perpetrators of the 2013 Westgate shopping mall attack in Nairobi, Kenya that killed 67 people.
Christine O'Moore is a former Greek-Orthodox priest, musician artist and trans woman recognized for her humanitarian work and social activism. She is known for her writings and discourses on religion and society, social justice, human rights and participation in inter-faith dialogue. O'Moore has appeared in the media regularly, especially in Norway and Greece, since 2006. She has been the subject of several documentaries and in various programs in Europe and the United States for her work with refugees.
Somalis in Norway are citizens and residents of Norway who are of Somali descent. They are the biggest African migration group in Norway. 36.5% of Somalis in Norway live in the capital Oslo. Almost all Somali in Norway have come to Norway as refugees from the Somali Civil War. In 2016, Somalis were the largest non-European migrant group in Norway.
Marte Mjøs Persen is a Norwegian politician from the Labour Party. She served as minister of labour and social inclusion from 2022 to 2023, and minister of petroleum and energy from 2021 to 2022. She served as the mayor of Bergen from 2015 until being elected to the Storting in 2021.
References
Most of the references are in Norwegian language only. Please use Google translate or similar services if you do not read Norwegian.
1 2 "Påstander uten dekning". Web page of Norwegian Immigration Directorate, UDI. 19 April 2011. Archived from the original on 5 January 2012. Retrieved 30 October 2011.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
