Sarah Murnaghan lung transplant controversy

Last updated

The Sarah Murnaghan lung transplant controversy began in late May 2013, when the parents of a ten-year-old Philadelphia area girl with cystic fibrosis, Sarah Murnaghan, launched a campaign to change the under-12 policy of the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS), which they asserted was age discrimination. Her plight received considerable media attention, particularly because Kathleen Sebelius, Secretary of Health and Human Services, refused to intervene to grant an exception to the rule.[ citation needed ]

Contents

Background

The system organizing lung transplants in the United States was overhauled in 2004 and again in 2008. The system gives those over the age of twelve a lung allocation score, which is used to prioritize patients for transplant based partially on the urgency of their need. However, children under twelve are granted lungs on a first-come, first-served basis. In addition, there are far fewer donor lungs available for children under the age of twelve than there are for adults – between 10 and 20 as opposed to 1,700 in a given year.

Murnaghan's parents argued that she needed a lung transplant or else she would die in a matter of weeks but that this was not possible because existing rules give higher priority for adult donor lungs to children who are at least twelve years old. Her parents argued that, although she only had a few weeks to live, under current UNOS transplant policy did not qualify for adult donor lungs although it is now possible to downsize adult lungs for transplantation into children.

Kathleen Sebelius refused to grant an exception to the rule. In response to Sebelius's argument that a review of the policies would need to take place before the rule could be changed, congressman Tom Price argued that such a process would take an entire year to complete and that the girl would be dead by that time. At the time of her transplant in June 2013, Murnaghan had been waiting on the transplant list for about eighteen months. [1]

Health conditions

Because of the side effects of antibiotics she had to take to treat her cystic fibrosis, Murnaghan developed permanent hearing loss. [2] [3] She also has osteoporosis and cystic fibrosis-related diabetes. [4] [5] [6]

Controversy

While the family portrayed their daughter's case as one of bureaucracy getting in the way of lung transplantation that should have been (and later was) awarded based on her extreme necessity and limited time left to live should she not obtain the transplant, some bioethicists questioned this depiction. For example, Arthur Caplan said, "In general, the road to a transplant is still to let the system decide who will do best with scarce, lifesaving organs." [7]

He explained that children do not get put on the adult lung transplant list because "The reason kids get lower priority for lungs is that adult lungs rarely fit, so you have to use only a part of one. Using only a lobe from an adult cadaver donor negatively impacts the chance of survival." [8]

Similarly, Stuart Sweet of the lung transplant program at St. Louis Children's Hospital contended, "the issue here is really about how we designed this system to try to make it fair for everyone waiting for lungs. There are ways of working through this that don't involve breaking the rules." [9]

The New England Journal of Medicine

This controversy came to a head on July 24, 2013, when a perspective piece was published in The New England Journal of Medicine regarding the debate over under-12 allocation rules. The piece, written by Karen Ladin and Douglas Hanto, noted that "...as a treatment for cystic fibrosis (the most common diagnosis among pediatric candidates for lung transplants), transplantation has been shown in several retrospective studies to have only marginal benefit (although some data suggest otherwise)." However, they also pointed out that a valid argument exists for those who wish to change the rules, specifically: "Younger patients who meet the size requirements and could benefit from adult lungs should be considered eligible." [10]

Chest

A study published in the Chest , noted that high lung allocation score (above 75) is associated with increased morbidity and mortality following transplantation. [11] Murnaghan had a lung allocation score of 91 out of 100 upon her first transplant. [12] Her second lung allocation score was 87 out of 100. [5]

American Journal of Transplantation

An article posted in the American Journal of Transplantation authored by Dr. Sweet and Dr. Barr in December 2013 discussed points brought up by the Murnaghan family. First they stated, "Indeed, the pool of adult transplant candidates is more than 50 times larger than the number of pediatric candidates. So the actual number of lungs recovered from donors under 12 reflects both donor availability and candidate demand. In fact, roughly 5% of the 400+ donors each year under 12 provide lungs compared to more than 35% of the 400+ adolescent donors (Figure 1). It is unlikely that donor characteristics are solely responsible for the lower percentage. Thus one area of focus for the pediatric lung transplant community should be to explore tapping into this apparent opportunity."

They also stated, "The second concept propagated by this story is that lobar transplant from adult donors is the best solution to the (perceived) lack of lung donors for children under 12. Although this option may be appropriate for children in circumstances where experienced transplant surgeons and physicians counsel the family that waiting for suitably sized donor organs from a pediatric donor is not feasible, the reality is that there are limited data supporting this approach for young children (in the most widely referenced series, the youngest recipient of an adult deceased donor lobar transplant was 9 years old) [3]. Moreover, the authors' experience with living donor lobar transplant suggests that size matching is critical to successful outcome. Thus, a change to the allocation system that encourages increased use of lobar transplant for young children would be premature." [13]

Annals of Internal Medicine

In the September 3, 2013 issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine, bioethicist Scott Halpern wrote the following regarding the decision to give Murnaghan receiving an adult lung as a result of Judge Michael Baylson's restraining order against the DHHS: "This intervention sets a troubling precedent. The court did not seek evidence to assess the merit of the age-discrimination claim...The rule undoubtedly disadvantaged Murnaghan, but the court's response exalted her and another child above a national policy, suggesting either failure to recognize that preferential treatment for some recipients will adversely affect others (who may not be much older than 12) or that the court considered these 2 children's lives more valuable than others'. Neither of these explanations is satisfying." [14]

Pediatrics

In 2014, Pediatrics asked multiple bioethicists if they thought Judge Baylson made the right decision to override the UNOS allocation system give Murnaghan access to adult lungs. Two bioethicists, Jennifer DeSante and Arthur Caplan, told the journal that "In the Murnaghan case, Judge Baylson claimed that the UNOS pediatric lung allocation policy was "arbitrary", capricious, and based on inadequate evidence...What the judge saw as arbitrary, UNOS experts saw as a policy reflective of the inadequate evidence concerning transplants for children versus adequate evidence supporting the efficacy of adult lung transplants." [15]

Ruling

On June 5, 2013, Judge Michael Baylson of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania District Court directed Sebelius to temporarily suspend the under-12 rule following an emergency hearing. Judge Baylson stated in a memo regarding the issue of the temporary restraining order, "the Court concluded that issuance of the TRO was very much in the interest of the public as well as the Plaintiffs and Sarah ... [F]inally, this Court did not in any way, shape, or form dictate when or whether Murnaghan should receive a lung transplant." [16]

Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) responded by making a temporary, one-year appeals process for children under the age of 12 whose doctors feel may benefit from adult lungs. This temporary appeals process expired on June 30, 2014. [17]

Transplants

On June 12, 2013, Murnaghan underwent what would be the first of two double lung transplants. She received these lungs from an adult donor. In a statement immediately following the surgery, her family said, "The surgeons had no challenges resizing and transplanting the donor lungs – the surgery went smoothly, and Sarah did extremely well." [18]

This first pair of lungs, however, failed within hours of completion of the operation, necessitating the transplantation of a second pair of adult lungs on June 15, 2013. Murnaghan was placed on an ECMO machine on June 12, 2013, until her second transplant on June 15, 2013.[ citation needed ]

According to the Associated Press, the second set of lungs were infected with pneumonia, but the girl's condition was too dire to wait for another set of lungs to become available. Surgeons were able to remove the infected portion before the transplant. After the transplant, Murnaghan was able to take a few breaths on her own after doctors removed her breathing tube. [19] However, she quickly needed breathing assistance, and the tube was reinserted. It was later discovered that her diaphragm had become paralyzed. [20]

Complications

After her second transplant, Murnaghan developed pneumonia in her right lung. [21]

ABC News reported that "A healthier patient might have turned down the lungs and waited for a better pair, but Sarah was out of options, so they went ahead with the operation." [22] She needed a diaphragm plication (folding and suturing to tighten the diaphragm) and a Nissen fundoplication. [23]

Departure from hospital

On August 27, 2013, Murnaghan returned home from Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, where she had been staying since February 19. [24]

She is undergoing physical therapy at home as part of her recovery and continues to struggle with compression fractures in her spine. However, according to her mother, Murnaghan is able to breathe off the ventilator for twelve hours a day.[ citation needed ]

As of 2018, Sarah Murnaghan has diabetes, cystic fibrosis and her ongoing hearing loss. [25]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cystic fibrosis</span> Autosomal recessive disease mostly affecting the lungs

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is a rare genetic disorder that affects mostly the lungs, but also the pancreas, liver, kidneys, and intestine. Long-term issues include difficulty breathing and coughing up mucus as a result of frequent lung infections. Other signs and symptoms may include sinus infections, poor growth, fatty stool, clubbing of the fingers and toes, and infertility in most males. Different people may have different degrees of symptoms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Organ transplantation</span> Medical procedure in which an organ is removed from one body and placed in the body of a recipient

Organ transplantation is a medical procedure in which an organ is removed from one body and placed in the body of a recipient, to replace a damaged or missing organ. The donor and recipient may be at the same location, or organs may be transported from a donor site to another location. Organs and/or tissues that are transplanted within the same person's body are called autografts. Transplants that are recently performed between two subjects of the same species are called allografts. Allografts can either be from a living or cadaveric source.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transplant rejection</span> Rejection of transplanted tissue by the recipients immune system

Transplant rejection occurs when transplanted tissue is rejected by the recipient's immune system, which destroys the transplanted tissue. Transplant rejection can be lessened by determining the molecular similitude between donor and recipient and by use of immunosuppressant drugs after transplant.

A heart–lung transplant is a procedure carried out to replace both heart and lungs in a single operation. Due to a shortage of suitable donors and due to the fact that both heart and lung have to be transplanted together, it is a rare procedure; only about a hundred such transplants are performed each year in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dorothy Hansine Andersen</span> American physician (1901–1963)

Dorothy Hansine Andersen was an American physician, pediatrician, and pathologist who first identified cystic fibrosis. She was the first to describe the disease, and name it. In 1939, she was awarded the E. Mead Johnson Award for her identification of the disease. In 2002, she was inducted into the National Women's Hall of Fame.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lung transplantation</span> Surgical procedure in which a patients diseased lungs are partially or totally replaced

Lung transplantation, or pulmonary transplantation, is a surgical procedure in which one or both lungs are replaced by lungs from a donor. Donor lungs can be retrieved from a living or deceased donor. A living donor can only donate one lung lobe. With some lung diseases, a recipient may only need to receive a single lung. With other lung diseases such as cystic fibrosis, it is imperative that a recipient receive two lungs. While lung transplants carry certain associated risks, they can also extend life expectancy and enhance the quality of life for those with end stage pulmonary disease.

Mackenzie Rosman is an American actress. She is known for her television role as Ruthie Camden on The WB's long-running drama series 7th Heaven.

Laura Elizabeth Rothenberg was an American author. She wrote a memoir describing her life with cystic fibrosis called Breathing for a Living.

The lung allocation score (LAS) is a numerical value used by the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) to assign relative priority for distributing donated lungs for transplantation within the United States. The lung allocation score takes into account various measures of a patient's health in order to direct donated organs towards the patients who would best benefit from a lung transplant.

Mary Ellen Beck Wohl was Chief of the Division of Respiratory Diseases at Children's Hospital Boston, and served as Associate Director of the General Clinical Research Center until 2002. Since the 1962, when she first joined the staff at Children's Hospital, Wohl specialized in the respiratory diseases of children. She was also a leader in the field of clinical research on cystic fibrosis. She developed a number of techniques to evaluate the function of the lungs in young children and is the author of many research papers in this field.

Orla Tinsley is a journalist, campaigner and multimedia artist from County Kildare in Ireland.

<i>65_Redroses</i> 2009 Canadian film

65_RedRoses is a 2009 documentary film about Eva Markvoort, a young woman from New Westminster, British Columbia, who suffered from cystic fibrosis. Directed by Philip Lyall and Nimisha Mukerji, it follows Markvoort as she lives her life undaunted by her disease, waiting for a lung transplant while blogging about her experiences.

Eva Markvoort was a young woman from New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada who died from cystic fibrosis at the age of 25. She blogged about her life, family and experiences, including undergoing a lung transplant and her subsequent transplant rejection, in her blog "65_Redroses," which is also the name of a documentary film about her, 65 Redroses.

ABO-incompatible (ABOi) transplantation is a method of allocation in organ transplantation that permits more efficient use of available organs regardless of ABO blood type, which would otherwise be unavailable due to hyperacute rejection. Primarily in use in infants and young toddlers, research is ongoing to allow for increased use of this capability in adult transplants. Normal ABO-compatibility rules may be observed for all recipients. This means that anyone may receive a transplant of a type-O organ, and consequently, type-O recipients are one of the biggest beneficiaries of ABO-incompatible transplants. While focus has been on infant heart transplants, the principles generally apply to other forms of solid organ transplantation.

Claire E. Wainwright is a paediatric respiratory physician and professor of pediatrics, residing and working in Queensland. She commenced her medical training in London and completed her specialist training at the Royal Children's Hospital, Brisbane. She is now head of the Cystic Fibrosis Service at the Queensland Children's Hospital and a professor of pediatric medicine at the University of Queensland, Australia. Wainwright has published numerous academic papers focusing upon her main area of interest; the impacts of fungal infections upon children with cystic fibrosis. However, her interests also expand to include other airway complications within children.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emphysema</span> Medical condition

Emphysema is any air-filled enlargement in the body's tissues. Most commonly emphysema refers to the enlargement of air spaces (alveoli) in the lungs, and is also known as pulmonary emphysema.

Queva Griffin was an Irish poet with cystic fibrosis. Griffin was a double organ recipient, the first person under 25 to survive a heart-lung double transplant. She published a book of poetry as a fundraiser for the costs associated with her illness. She was named Young Person of the Year in 1998 for her courage during the transplant process. She died in 2003, after picking up an infection.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Claire Wineland</span> American activist and author (1997–2018)

Claire Lucia Wineland was an American activist, author, speaker and social media personality. Through her non-profit organization, Claire's Place Foundation, she provided support to children and families affected by cystic fibrosis (CF). She died from a blood clot one week after receiving a double lung transplant at the age of 21.

<i>Five Feet Apart</i> 2019 film by Justin Baldoni

Five Feet Apart is a 2019 American romantic drama film directed by Justin Baldoni and written by Mikki Daughtry and Tobias Iaconis. The film was inspired by Claire Wineland, who suffered from cystic fibrosis. Haley Lu Richardson and Cole Sprouse play two young patients with cystic fibrosis who try to have a relationship despite being forced to stay six feet apart from each other. The film was released in the United States on March 15, 2019 by CBS Films via Lionsgate. It received mixed reviews from critics and grossed $92 million worldwide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hassenfeld Children's Hospital</span> Childrens Hospital in NY, United States

Hassenfeld Children's Hospital (HCH) at NYU Langone is a pediatric acute-care children's hospital located on the NYU Langone Health campus in Manhattan, New York. Hassenfeld Children's Hospital has 102 pediatric beds and is located in the Helen L. and Martin S. Kimmel Pavilion. It is directly affiliated with the pediatrics department of the New York University Grossman School of Medicine. The hospital treats infants, children, teens, and young adults aged 0–21, with some programs treating up until age 25. While not a trauma center, Hassenfeld Children's Hospital contains the KiDS Emergency Department to treat children with injuries.

References

  1. ↑ Norman, Brett; Millman, Jason (June 5, 2013). "Sarah Murnaghan lung transplant case: Sebelius ordered to make exception on transplant". Politico . Retrieved August 31, 2013.
  2. ↑ Todt, Ron (May 27, 2013). "Pa. Girl's Parents Challenge Lung Donor Rule". Bigstory.ap.org. Retrieved 2014-02-08.
  3. ↑ "Dying girl intubated as she awaits lung transplant – Fox News". Fox News . Retrieved January 11, 2014.
  4. ↑ "Sarah Murnaghan goes home to Newtown Square - Philly.com". 27 August 2013. Retrieved 11 Jan 2014.
  5. 1 2 "Murnaghan Family: Sarah Had To Have Second Transplant After First Set Of Lungs Failed « CBS Philly". 2013-06-28. Retrieved January 11, 2014.
  6. ↑ "Murnaghan Family to OPTN/UNOS: Stop Age Discrimination!". Online.wsj.com. Retrieved January 11, 2014.
  7. ↑ Dale, Mary Claire; Ritter, Malcolm (June 12, 2013). "Sarah Murnaghan's Surgery Deemed A Success". Huffington Post . Associated Press. Retrieved August 31, 2013.
  8. ↑ Caplan, Arthur (June 5, 2013). "Who should decide if Sarah will get lungs? Not politicians or bureaucrats, bioethicist says". NBC News . Retrieved August 31, 2013.
  9. ↑ McCullough, Marie (May 26, 2013). "Phila. family fights lung-donor rule for dying girl". Philly.com. Retrieved August 31, 2013.
  10. ↑ Ladin, K.; Hanto, D.W. (2013). "Rationing Lung Transplants — Procedural Fairness in Allocation and Appeals". New England Journal of Medicine. 369 (7): 599–601. doi:10.1056/NEJMp1307792. PMID   23883330.
  11. ↑ Russo, MJ; et al. (March 2010). "High lung allocation score is associated with increased morbidity and mortality following transplantation". Chest. 137 (3): 651–57. doi:10.1378/chest.09-0319. PMC   2832864 . PMID   19820072.
  12. ↑ Carroll, Jason (June 13, 2013). "Girl's long-awaited lung transplant complete". CNN. Retrieved August 11, 2015.
  13. ↑ Sweet, S. C.; Barr, M. L. (2014). "Pediatric Lung Allocation: The Rest of the Story". American Journal of Transplantation. 14 (1): 11–12. doi: 10.1111/ajt.12546 . PMID   24330200.
  14. ↑ Halpern, Scott D. (September 3, 2013). "Turning Wrong Into Right: The 2013 Lung Allocation Controversy". Annals of Internal Medicine. 159 (5): 358–9. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-159-5-201309030-00684 . PMID   23797998.
  15. ↑ deSante, J; Caplan, A; Hippen, B; Testa, G; Lantos, JD (July 2014). "Was Sarah Murnaghan treated justly?". Pediatrics. 134 (1): 155–62. doi:10.1542/peds.2013-4189. PMID   24918227. S2CID   26205168.
  16. ↑ Ruling by Judge Baylson, pepperlaw.com; accessed July 26, 2017.
  17. ↑ "Clarification: Lung Transplant-Pennsylvania story". Bigstory.ap.org. Retrieved January 11, 2014.
  18. ↑ Dale, Maryclaire; Bitter, Malcolm (June 12, 2013). "Sarah Murnaghan's Surgery Deemed A Success". Huffington Post . Associated Press. Retrieved August 31, 2013.
  19. ↑ Loviglio, Joann (July 8, 2013). "Sarah Murnaghan now has pneumonia in one lung". NBC News . Retrieved September 2, 2013.
  20. ↑ Martinez, Michael (June 27, 2013). "Sarah Murnaghan struggles without breathing tube, so it's re-inserted". CNN . CNN. Retrieved September 19, 2012.
  21. ↑ "Sarah is 'making small steps' after lung transplant, her mom says". Philly.com. 10 July 2013. Retrieved January 11, 2014.
  22. ↑ Lupkin, Sydney (July 8, 2013). "Sarah Murnaghan Develops Pneumonia in One Lung". ABC News . Retrieved September 2, 2013.
  23. ↑ "Sarah Murnaghan's Road To Recovery". 2013-08-27. Retrieved January 11, 2014.
  24. ↑ Lupkin, Sydney (August 27, 2013). "Sarah Murnaghan, 11, Home After Controversial Lung Transplant". ABC News . Retrieved September 2, 2013.
  25. ↑ McCullough, Marie (10 September 2018). "A historic adult-to-child lung transplant saved their daughter, who's now a thriving teen". Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved 2019-01-30.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.