Joseph Maraachli case

Last updated
Joseph Maraachli
Born(2010-01-22)January 22, 2010
Windsor, Ontario, Canada
DiedSeptember 27, 2011(2011-09-27) (aged 1)
Windsor, Ontario, Canada
Parent(s)Moe and Sana Maraachli

The Joseph Maraachli case refers to an international controversy over the life of Joseph Maraachli, commonly known as Baby Joseph, a Canadian infant who was diagnosed with a rare progressive and incurable neurological disorder called Leigh's disease. After Canadian doctors refused to perform a tracheotomy, calling the procedure invasive and futile, Joseph's parents fought to have him transferred to the United States, arguing that while Joseph's disease was terminal, a tracheotomy would extend his life and allow him to die at home. After several months and efforts by American anti-abortion groups, Joseph was transferred to a Catholic hospital in St. Louis, Missouri, where the procedure was performed.

Contents

The successfully-obtained procedure extended Joseph's life for several months. Joseph died on Tuesday, September 27, 2011, at his home. [1] [2]

History

Background

Joseph Maraachli was born on January 22, 2010. [3] His parents, Moe Maraachli and Sana Nader, immigrated to Canada from Lebanon in the 1990s, settling in Windsor, Ontario. [4]

In 2002, the couple's 18-month-old daughter, Zina, died from a degenerative disorder. [5] After undergoing a tracheotomy, she was taken home and cared for by her parents for her final six months. [5] Then when she was near death, her parents took her back to the hospital, hoping to make her as comfortable as possible. [6]

Moe Maraachli once repaired computers, but gave up this work to take care of his wife Sana, who has lupus. [4] The couple depended on Sana's disability payments and support from her family. [4]

Beginning of medical issues

When Joseph was around three months old, his parents said they noticed he couldn't eat or breathe properly, and he wouldn't open his eyes or cry. [3] In June 2010, they took him to a hospital in Michigan, a few miles away from Windsor, which is located directly on the Canada–United States border. [3] At the Michigan hospital, he was diagnosed with a metabolic brain disease that the doctor said would make him developmentally delayed, and was treated, his health reportedly improving. [3] However, in the car on the way back from a family trip to Toronto in October 2010, he stopped breathing, so he was rushed to an emergency room in Ingersoll and later transferred to the London Health Sciences Centre (LHSC) in London, Ontario. [4]

Parents and doctors disagree

Tests and examinations on Joseph were carried out by eight specialists over a few weeks following his transfer to the LHSC. [4] The doctors concluded that he was suffering from a "severe and progressively deteriorating neurological state" and was in a persistent vegetative state. [4] They were in "unanimous agreement" that he did not have any chance of recovering and that there were no treatment options available to help him. [4]

The parents disputed the conclusion that Joseph was in a persistent vegetative state, saying he responded to being tickled and jostled when he felt discomfort. [3] The family wanted a tracheotomy for him, believing it would allow him to breathe on his own, and thus be taken out of the hospital so he could "die peacefully with mom, dad at home." [7] They hoped the procedure could prolong Joseph's life by up to six months because it had extended his older sister Zina's life by six months when she was dying of the same condition. [6] [8] The couple also stated that, if their son was able to live longer due to the procedure, he would die "when God says he should." [4]

The doctors at the hospital refused to perform a tracheotomy because they said it would needlessly protract Joseph's death and increase the risk of infection, pneumonia, and other complications. [4] Since the time of Zina's tracheotomy, more had been learned about the condition, leading doctors to conclude it was not appropriate in Joseph's case. [9] Dr. Douglas Fraser, a pediatric critical care specialist and the lead doctor handling the case, proposed that Joseph's breathing tube be removed, with the expectation that he would die soon afterward from his inability to breathe unaided. [4] His parents refused to agree to this proposal. [4]

London Heath Services Centre directed the case to the Consent and Capacity Board of Ontario. It explained in a statement that it sought the Board's decision on "whether or not Joseph’s parents were complying with the principles for substitute decision-making under the provincial Health Care Consent Act in refusing to consent to the proposed treatment plan." [10]

The hearing before the Board took place in January 2011. [4] On January 22, the Board released its decision, holding that the course of action in the child's "best interests" would be "removal of the endotracheal tube without replacement, a Do Not Resuscitate order and palliative care." [10]

The parents were ordered to consent to the removal of the breathing tube. [4] They decided to appeal the Board's decision in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, retaining a lawyer, Geoff Snow, through legal aid. [4] [11] The case was heard by Justice Helen Rady on February 17, 2011. [12] An hour after the lawyers delivered their arguments, Justice Rady returned with her decision, upholding the Board's decision as "reasonable" and dismissing the family's appeal. [9] [12]

Removal of the breathing tube had been scheduled for the morning of February 18, but Rady moved the date to February 21, stating the intent of giving the family "adequate time to say their good-byes." [9] [12] The family was ordered to give consent for the breathing tube's removal by February 21. [13]

On February 20, the family fired Snow, as he did not advise pursuing an appeal of Rady's ruling. [14] With the support of Alex Schadenberg of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition, they took on a new lawyer, Mark Handelman. [4] The family refused to consent to the breathing tube's removal, and thus it was not removed on February 21. [13] Handelman attempted to negotiate Joseph's transfer to the Children's Hospital of Michigan in Detroit. [4] The Children's Hospital initially accepted the request, but later chose to reject the request after receiving the baby's medical file. [4]

On February 28, the London Health Services Centre put out a media release, stating it was willing to transfer Joseph to his home but would remove the ventilator once he was there. [6] Handelman confirmed that the hospital had made such an offer, but objected to its public disclosure, stating it had been presented during confidential negotiations. [6] He said Joseph's parents had already rejected the offer prior to the media release, considering it "unacceptable." [6]

On March 1, it was revealed that Handelman was no longer representing the family, though he did not disclose the reason. [15] The family retained another lawyer, Claudio Martini, on March 5, and he announced the following week that they planned to file an appeal of the Superior Court decision. [16]

Transfer to the United States

Various anti-abortion organizations such as Priests for Life, the Terri Schiavo Life & Hope Network, and the American Center for Law and Justice, among others, began helping the family and began negotiating in March 2011 with hospitals around the United States to have Joseph transferred. Priests for Life announced it had secured a jet which was standing by to immediately fly the family to any American hospital willing to care for Joseph. [17]

On March 14, 2011, Priests for Life announced it had secured a transfer to SSM Cardinal Glennon Children's Medical Center, a non-profit Catholic hospital in St. Louis, Missouri, declaring victory in the "battle against the medical bureaucracy in Canada." [18] Priests for Life also announced it would pay for Joseph's medical care at Cardinal Glennon.

Once Joseph was in Cardinal Glennon, Priests for Life said hospital officials were happy that Joseph was breathing mostly on his own, but the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported that "Cardinal Glennon officials said they were 'puzzled' by those claims and said Joseph remained on a ventilator." [19]

On March 21, 2011, doctors performed a tracheotomy on Joseph. He was expected to remain in the hospital for seven to ten days, then be transferred to a St. Louis pediatric specialty hospital, then be sent home with his family. [20] Maraachli and Nader are an interfaith couple, being Muslim and Catholic, respectively; Maraachli said he wanted his son to be "raised in the religion of his mother." [21]

Diagnosis

Doctors at the SSM Cardinal Glennon Children's Medical Center diagnosed Joseph with Leigh's disease, a rare neurometabolic disorder which causes the degeneration of the central nervous system. The disease is usually inherited, but no genetic link for Joseph was found after his parents were tested. [20] The doctors at the SSM hospital said the tracheotomy they performed gave Joseph a more stable airway, extra mobility and comfort, and protected his lungs. [22]

Going home

On April 21, 2011, Joseph was transported from the hospital in St. Louis to his home in Windsor, Ontario. [23] Priests for Life paid for all of the medical bills incurred and the return flight home. [23]

According to his father, at home Joseph was breathing on his own and showed signs of consciousness, such as opening his eyes or moving around in response to touch; his father also said that he thought that Joseph knew when he was holding him. [24] Brother Paul O'Donnell, a friend of the Maraachli family, says he had seen Joseph turn his head to his father when his father spoke, and to his mother when his mother spoke, and also said he had seen him throw temper tantrums such as when his diaper was changed. [22] At one point in the presence of a Vancouver Sun reporter, Joseph's father held out his finger and Joseph grabbed it. [24]

With Joseph home, his father said, "I feel victorious. I feel I won and my baby's alive." [24] O'Donnell described Joseph's condition at home as a miracle. [22] Joseph's father said the fact that he had to travel to St. Louis to get care for his son angered him. However, the Vancouver Sun reported that he was positive about the outcome of his and others' efforts, and said he didn't think about when his son would die, but left that up to God. [24]

Death

Joseph lived another six months after the tracheotomy, breathing on his own, and died peacefully in his sleep on September 27, 2011, at the age of 20 months. [25] [26] He had been living at home with his family since April 21, 2011. [25] Frank Pavone said, "This young boy and his parents fulfilled a special mission from God. Amidst a Culture of Death where despair leads us to dispose of the vulnerable, [the Maraachli family] upheld a Culture of Life where hope leads us to welcome and care for the vulnerable." [26]

A private funeral for Joseph was held on September 28. [26] He was buried beside his sister Zina at a cemetery in Windsor. [26]

Aftermath

On October 4, 2011, the Maraachlis held a press conference with the Terri Schiavo Life & Hope Network in which Moe Maraachli said he was considering a request for an investigation [27] and a lawsuit against the Canadian doctors who refused to treat and release Joseph, noting that the family incurred over $46,000 in legal fees during the ordeal. [28] Maraachli said he was angry at the Canadian doctors but thankful for the Cardinal Glennon "angel doctors". [27]

Maraachli said Joseph wasn't suffering or in pain at home. [28] Maraachli said he wants the Canadian medical system to change so that doctors are required to more seriously consider the wishes of the family of a dying family member. [28] He said he would "go after" the Canadian doctors. Maraachli had a message for Joseph:

"I made a promise to my son: I will give you back your human rights and dignity if you pass away or not...Fly and tell God about what happened with you and about the doctor that tried to kill you. Your life touched the world." [28] [29]

Impact

The case became a focal point for the ethical debate over the extent to which end-of-life care should be provided. [2] The case draws many parallels to the Terri Schiavo case, where a court ordered the removal of the feeding tube of a woman in a vegetative state, in compliance with the consent authorized by her husband, despite protests from her parents. Schiavo subsequently died of dehydration. The Terri Schiavo Life & Hope Network, a foundation founded by Schiavo's family, was involved in the Maraachli case. [30] The international anti-abortion community rallied around the family, offering support and money to help pay for the medical costs. [24]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karen Ann Quinlan</span> American medical–legal case

Karen Ann Quinlan was an American woman who became an important figure in the history of the right to die controversy in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Life support</span> In medicine

Life support comprises the treatments and techniques performed in an emergency in order to support life after the failure of one or more vital organs. Healthcare providers and emergency medical technicians are generally certified to perform basic and advanced life support procedures; however, basic life support is sometimes provided at the scene of an emergency by family members or bystanders before emergency services arrive. In the case of cardiac injuries, cardiopulmonary resuscitation is initiated by bystanders or family members 25% of the time. Basic life support techniques, such as performing CPR on a victim of cardiac arrest, can double or even triple that patient's chance of survival. Other types of basic life support include relief from choking, staunching of bleeding by direct compression and elevation above the heart, first aid, and the use of an automated external defibrillator.

The right to die is a concept based on the opinion that human beings are entitled to end their life or undergo voluntary euthanasia. Possession of this right is often understood that a person with a terminal illness, incurable pain, or without the will to continue living, should be allowed to end their own life, use assisted suicide, or to decline life-prolonging treatment. The question of who, if anyone, may be empowered to make this decision is often the subject of debate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Terri Schiavo case</span> American right-to-die legal case

The Terri Schiavo case was a series of court and legislative actions in the United States from 1998 to 2005, regarding the care of Theresa Marie Schiavo, a woman in an irreversible persistent vegetative state. Schiavo's husband and legal guardian argued that Schiavo would not have wanted prolonged artificial life support without the prospect of recovery, and in 1998, he elected to remove her feeding tube. Schiavo's parents disputed her husband's assertions and challenged Schiavo's medical diagnosis, arguing in favor of continuing artificial nutrition and hydration. The highly publicized and prolonged series of legal challenges presented by her parents, which ultimately involved state and federal politicians up to the level of President George W. Bush, caused a seven-year delay before Schiavo's feeding tube was ultimately removed.

The case of Sun Hudson concerned Wanda Hudson and her infant son, who was allowed to die via removal of his breathing tube, contrary to her wishes.

The legislative, executive, and judicial branches, of both the United States federal government and the State of Florida, were involved in the case of Terri Schiavo. In November 1998 Michael Schiavo, husband of Terri Schiavo, first sought permission to remove his wife's feeding tube. Schiavo had suffered brain damage in February 1990, and in February 2000 had been ruled by a Florida circuit court to be in a persistent vegetative state. Her feeding tube was removed first on April 26, 2001, but was reinserted two days later on an appeal by her parents, Bob and Mary Schindler.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph O'Dwyer</span> American physician

Joseph O'Dwyer was an American physician. He developed a valuable system of intubation in diphtheria cases. O'Dwyer is often cited as the "father of laryngeal intubation in croup".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frank Pavone</span> American laicized Catholic priest, anti-abortion leader (born 1959)

Frank Anthony Pavone is an American anti-abortion activist and former Catholic priest. He is the national director of Priests for Life and the chairman and pastoral director of its Rachel's Vineyard project. He is also the president of the National Pro-Life Religious Council, an umbrella group of various anti-abortion Christian denominations, and the pastoral director of the Silent No More campaign.

Anthony David Bland was a supporter of Liverpool injured in the Hillsborough disaster. He suffered severe brain damage that left him in a persistent vegetative state as a consequence of which the hospital, with the support of his parents, applied for a court order allowing him to "die with dignity". As a result, he became the first patient in English legal history to be allowed to die by the courts through the withdrawal of life-prolonging treatment including food and water for the injuries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Children's Hospital at London Health Sciences Centre</span> Hospital in Ontario, Canada

The Children's Hospital at London Health Sciences Centre is a children's hospital in London, Ontario, Canada that provides paediatric care for patients from the London metropolitan area and the rest of Southwestern Ontario.

Haleigh Poutre is an American woman who became the subject of a legal controversy regarding the removal of life support for patients in persistent vegetative states. In 2006, eleven-year-old Poutre awoke from a coma shortly before she was scheduled to be removed from life support. Poutre had a severe brain injury thought to be caused by abuse by her adoptive mother. The case brought about many changes in the Massachusetts Department of Social Services, both in the way they handle reports of child abuse as well as their policies on end-of-life care for children in their custody.

Child euthanasia is a form of euthanasia that is applied to children who are gravely ill or have significant birth defects. In 2005, the Netherlands became the first country since the end of Nazi Germany to decriminalize euthanasia for infants with hopeless prognosis and intractable pain. Nine years later, Belgium amended its 2002 Euthanasia Act to extend the rights of euthanasia to minors. Like euthanasia, there is world-wide public controversy and ethical debate over the moral, philosophical and religious issues of child euthanasia.

<i>Madrigal v. Quilligan</i>

Madrigal v. Quilligan was a federal class action lawsuit from Los Angeles County, California, involving sterilization of Latina women that occurred either without informed consent, or through coercion. Although the judge ruled in favor of the doctors, the case led to better informed consent for patients, especially those who are not native English speakers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph DeLee</span> American physician

Joseph Bolivar DeLee was an American physician who became known as the father of modern obstetrics. DeLee founded the Chicago Lying-in Hospital, where he introduced the first portable infant incubator. Early in his career, he was associated with the medical school at Northwestern University. After 1929, he was employed by the medical school at the University of Chicago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jahi McMath case</span> US legal case involving brain death

Jahi McMath was a thirteen-year-old girl who was declared brain dead in California following surgery in 2013. This led to a bioethical debate engendered by her family's rejection of the medicolegal findings of death in the case, and their efforts to maintain her body using mechanical ventilation and other measures. Her parents considered these measures to constitute life support, while her doctors considered this to be futile treatment of a deceased person. In October 2014, the McMath family attorney made the unprecedented request that Jahi McMath's brain death declaration be overturned. The attorney later withdrew this request, saying he wanted time for the court-appointed medical expert and his own medical experts to confer. In March 2015, McMath's family filed a malpractice lawsuit against Children's Hospital Oakland and against the surgeon who performed McMath's surgery, indicating they were prepared to argue as part of the lawsuit that McMath was not dead, but profoundly disabled. The family lawyer stated that a preliminary second death certificate was issued on June 22, 2018, listing extensive bleeding relating to liver failure as the cause of death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charlie Gard case</span> 2017 UK best interests legal case

The Charlie Gard case was a best interests case in 2017 involving Charles Matthew William "Charlie" Gard, an infant boy from London, born with mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome (MDDS), a rare genetic disorder that causes progressive brain damage and muscle failure. MDDS has no treatment and usually causes death in infancy. The case became controversial because the medical team and parents disagreed about whether experimental treatment was in the best interests of the child.

Baby M was the pseudonym of an Australian girl named Allison who was born with severe birth defects, whose treatment and eventual death caused significant controversy and international discussion about the medical ethics of disabled newborns. Right to Life activists accused her parents and the hospital of murdering the infant, leading to a lengthy legal inquest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alfie Evans case</span> 2018 UK legal case

Alfie James Evans, was an infant boy from Liverpool with an undiagnosed neurodegenerative disorder, later revealed to be GABA-transaminase deficiency. The medical team and the child's parents disagreed about whether to maintain his life support or to withdraw it, resulting in a legal battle. Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust sought a declaration that continued mechanical ventilation was "unkind and inhumane", and not in the child's best interests. Alfie's parents, Kate James and Thomas Evans, contested the application.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fertility fraud</span> Non-consensual fertility treatments

Fertility fraud is the failure on the part of a fertility doctor to obtain consent from a patient before inseminating her with his own sperm. This normally occurs in the context of people using assisted reproductive technology (ART) to address fertility issues.

References

  1. ↑ "'Baby Joseph' Dies in His Canadian Home Surrounded by Family". FoxNews.com. September 28, 2011.
  2. 1 2 Hutchison, Courtney. 'Baby Joseph' Dies at Home After Long Treatment Battle, ABC News Medical Unit, Sept. 28, 2011. Retrieved 2011-10-12.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Sabriya Rice (February 25, 2011). "Canadian family fights to move baby on life support to U.S." CNN.com.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Sonja Puzic (February 26, 2011). "On god's time". The Windsor Star. Archived from the original on January 21, 2015.
  5. 1 2 Blythe Bernhard (March 16, 2011). "'Let him breathe,' baby's dad implores". St. Louis Post-Dispatch.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 Jonathan Sher (March 1, 2011). "Hospital disclosure muddies baby case". London Free Press.
  7. ↑ "Windsor parents want sick child to die at home". CBC.ca. February 17, 2011.
  8. ↑ Jim Salter (April 21, 2011). "Baby returns home to Canada after treatment in U.S." Seattle Times.
  9. 1 2 3 Jane Sims (February 18, 2011). "Judge orders baby off life-support". Global BC.
  10. 1 2 "Just the Facts: Medical, Legal and Ethical Issues". London Health Services Centre.
  11. ↑ Sonya Puzic (February 18, 2011). "Appeal denied: Baby to die in hospital". Toronto Sun.
  12. 1 2 3 Sonja Puzic (February 18, 2011). "Couple lose appeal to bring baby home". Edmonton Journal. Archived from the original on January 18, 2013.
  13. 1 2 Pat Hewitt (February 21, 2011). "Windsor family refuses court order to let baby die". The Toronto Star.
  14. ↑ "Dying baby's breathing tube removal delayed". CBC News. February 21, 2011.
  15. ↑ Kate Dubinski; Jonathan Sher (March 2, 2011). "Lawyer off Baby Joseph case". London Free Press.
  16. ↑ Chris Thompson (March 9, 2011). "Baby's family files new appeal". The Windsor Star. Archived from the original on September 19, 2012.
  17. ↑ Kate Dubinski (March 4, 2011). "Jet at ready to move Baby Joseph". Toronto Sun.
  18. ↑ "EXCLUSIVE: 'Baby Joseph' Gets Second Chance at Life in U.S". FoxNews.com. March 14, 2011.
  19. ↑ Bernhard, Blythe (March 15, 2011). "Dying infant's surgery raises ethical questions". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. Retrieved March 19, 2011.
  20. 1 2 Sabriya Rice (March 21, 2011). "'Baby Joseph' receives tracheotomy at St. Louis hospital". CNN.com.
  21. ↑ Benjamin Mann (March 25, 2011). "Godfather: Baby Joseph's baptism shows life's eternal destiny". Catholic News Agency.
  22. 1 2 3 Neil Katz (April 22, 2011). "Who has right to tell Baby Joseph to die?". CBS News.
  23. 1 2 "'Baby Joseph' Flying Home to Canada". FoxNews.com. April 21, 2011.
  24. 1 2 3 4 5 'I feel victorious,' says Baby Joseph's father
  25. 1 2 Maggie Schneider; Sabriya Rice (September 29, 2011). "'Baby Joseph,' focus of treatment dispute, dies in his sleep". CNN.com.
  26. 1 2 3 4 "Priest says Baby Joseph 'fulfilled mission". CBC News. September 28, 2011.
  27. 1 2 No word on possible lawsuit
  28. 1 2 3 4 Baby Joseph’s family seeks probe
  29. ↑ Baby Joseph's parents say 'shame on doctors'
  30. ↑ Canadian family fights to move baby on life support to U.S.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.