Sentimental Tommy

Last updated

Sentimental Tommy
Sentimental Tommy - Exhibitors Herald, March 19, 1921.jpg
Advertisement
Directed by John S. Robertson
Written by Josephine Lovett (scenario)
Based onSentimental Tommy
by James M. Barrie
Produced by Famous Players–Lasky
Starring Gareth Hughes
May McAvoy
George Fawcett
Mabel Taliaferro
Cinematography Roy Overbaugh
Distributed by Paramount Pictures
Release date
  • May 29, 1921 (1921-05-29)(U.S.)
Running time
75+ minutes at 8 reels (7,575 ft)
CountryUnited States
Language Silent (English intertitles)

Sentimental Tommy is a 1921 lost American silent drama film directed by John S. Robertson and based on the novels "Sentimental Tommy" and "Tommy and Grizel" by J.M. Barrie. The film served as a star vehicle for actor Gareth Hughes; early versions of the film featured Mary Astor, however her scenes were removed before release. [1]

Contents

Plot

Though the film is considered lost, much of the plot can still be gleaned from various film publications released at the same time as the movie, along with the contents of the novels themselves. [2]

Grizel constantly experiences tragedies from a young age. She is ostracized by all the children of the town. Her mother, The Painted Lady, dies, leading to Dr. Gemmell making her his housekeeper. Her luck seems to turn up when Tommy Sandys and his sister come to town. Tommy is very friendly towards her, however Grizel still keeps her distance.

Many years pass, and Tommy is now a famous London author. He visits the town of his youth once again, and finds Grizel heartbroken because of the loss of the doctor. Tommy tries deciding for himself whether he loves Grizel - but he can't decide. So, he returns back to London. With his absence, Grizel goes insane from heartbreak. Tommy, finally deciding he loves her, returns to Grizel. They marry, but Tommy fears that once Grizel is cured she will no longer love him. Over two years, Tommy slowly helps her - until finally she is cured. Tommy tells her that he cared for her out of his love for her. This pleases Grizel, and for the first time in many years she is happy.

Cast

Reception

Sentimental Tommy: L-R Gareth Hughes, Mae McAvoy, Leila Frost Sentimental Tommy, 1921 silent feature, Paramount Pictures.jpg
Sentimental Tommy: L-R Gareth Hughes, Mae McAvoy, Leila Frost

“I fear it is quite useless to tell anybody who did not see Sentimental Tommy how good May McAvoy was. I can only say that Grizel was the most moving revelation of the gifts of a fresh and hitherto unknown young actress that I have ever encountered…Beauty and pity were the great elements in it, and all seemed to well up as it were spontaneously from the depths of an inexhaustible sensibility.” —Literary critic and film historian Edward Wagenknecht. [3]

The film received mixed reviews upon its release on May 29, 1921. The Minneapolis Morning Tribune expressed admiration for the film's acting; calling out director John S. Robertson for this "very fine film," [4] it noted in particular the film's handling of emotion. The review also remarked that Hughes, a popular Welsh actor, was a big hit with the fans.

According to The Philadelphia Inquirer : "There is the tender, elusive quality, the charm and the pathos, the humor, the quality which could bring one to tears while smiling." [5] The reviewer called the depiction of Tommy growing from child to man as "simply spectacular." Variety stated that it must have been "a great pleasure" [6] to record a movie that is so fine and expresses admiration the translation of the book to screen. The reviewer notes that Tommy is a "profound character in this film particular," [6] and praises the film's direction. People were infatuated with the actor behind Tommy's character, Gareth Hughes, and believed that he well portrayed the Tommy people knew and loved in the novel.

The Christian Science Monitor stated the film "respects its original novel that was printed years prior to the movie." [7] The author of the article states how Tommy's story is told with "numerous titles but, happily, they are written by someone with an active intelligence." The reviewer likened the film to The Four Horsemen , The Ole Swimming Hole and Thrums of Long Island.

Robert E. Sherwood, from Life reviewed Sentimental Tommy with a list of pros and cons. He mentioned that the director, John S. Robertson, displayed a "commendable degree of good taste throughout." [8] This "perfect interpretation" [9] of the novel led him to say that he was surprised how well the film turned out, considering the unusual settings in the novel. The one thing that bothered Sherwood was that the film was "far too long." [9]

Negative reviews included one that ran in The Minneapolis Morning Tribune , where the headline read: "Reviewer calls happy ending only real weakness of screen version." [10] Life expressed dissatisfaction with the top ten movies of 1921, Sentimental Tommy among them, suggesting that an unwritten law has landed these "trendy movies" at the top. [10]

Footnotes

  1. Progressive Silent Film List: Sentimental Tommy at silentera.com
  2. "Sentimental Tommy: Has a Place Among Year's Best Pictures". Film Daily. Vol. 16, no. 3. New York City: Wyd's Films and Film Folks, Inc. April 3, 1921. p. 2. Retrieved March 18, 2014.
  3. Wagenknecht, 1962 p. 230: Ellipsis concerns a brief comparison to Jean Simmons. And: “[I]f the touching perfection of a pure girl’s limitless devotion was ever bared upon the screen in all its moving, vulnerable nakedness, it was in that performance and in that film.”
  4. "Diversion A-Plenty In The Motion Picture Theaters". The Minneapolis Morning Tribune. July 3, 1921.
  5. The Philadelphia Inquirer: 52. May 22, 1921.{{cite journal}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
  6. 1 2 "Sentimental Tommy". Variety: 41. April 1, 1921.
  7. "Motion Pictures". The Christian Science Monitor: 11. May 4, 1921.
  8. Sherwood, Robert E. (December 29, 1921). "The Silent Drama". Life. p. 24.
  9. 1 2 Sherwood, Robert E. (April 14, 1921). "The Silent Drama". Life. p. 540.
  10. 1 2 The Minneapolis Morning Tribune. July 3, 1921. p. 45.{{cite news}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bessie Love</span> American actress (1898–1986)

Juanita Horton, better known as Bessie Love, was an American-British actress who achieved prominence playing innocent, young girls and wholesome leading ladies in silent and early sound films. Her acting career spanned nearly seven decades—from silent film to sound film, including theatre, radio, and television—and her performance in The Broadway Melody (1929) earned her a nomination for the Academy Award for Best Actress.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mary Astor</span> American actress (1906–1987)

Lucile Vasconcellos Langhanke, better known professionally as Mary Astor, was an American actress. Although her career spanned several decades, she may be best remembered for her performance as Brigid O'Shaughnessy in The Maltese Falcon (1941).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mary Miles Minter</span> American actress (1902–1984)

Mary Miles Minter was an American actress, and one of the leading ladies who established the early Hollywood star system. She appeared in 53 silent films from 1912 to 1923.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mae Marsh</span> American actress

Mae Marsh was an American film actress whose career spanned over 50 years.

Edward (Charles) Wagenknecht was an American literary critic and teacher who specialized in 19th century American literature. He wrote and edited many books on literature and movies, and taught for many years at various universities, including the University of Chicago and Boston University. He also contributed many book reviews and other writings to such newspapers as the Boston Herald, The New York Times, and the Chicago Tribune and to such magazines as The Yale Review and The Atlantic Monthly.

<i>Atonement</i> (2007 film) 2007 film by Joe Wright

Atonement is a 2007 romantic war drama film directed by Joe Wright and starring James McAvoy, Keira Knightley, Saoirse Ronan, Romola Garai, and Vanessa Redgrave. It is based on the 2001 novel of the same name by Ian McEwan. The film chronicles a crime and its consequences over six decades, beginning in the 1930s. It was produced for StudioCanal and filmed in England. Distributed in most of the world by Universal Studios, it was released theatrically in the United Kingdom on 7 September 2007 and in North America exactly three months later on 7 December 2007.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gertrude Astor</span> American actress (1887–1977)

Gertrude Astor was an American motion picture character actress, who began her career playing trombone in a woman's band.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gareth Hughes</span> British actor

Gareth Hughes was a Welsh stage and silent screen actor. Usually cast as a callow, sensitive hero in Hollywood silent films, Hughes got his start on stage during childhood and continued to play youthful leads on Broadway.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kathleen Clifford</span> American actress

Kathleen Clifford was an American vaudeville and Broadway stage and film actress of the early twentieth century. She was known for her skills as a male impersonator.

<i>Enchantment</i> (1948 film) 1948 romantic film directed by Irving Reis

Enchantment is a 1948 American romantic drama film directed by Irving Reis and starring David Niven, Teresa Wright and Evelyn Keyes. It was produced by Samuel Goldwyn, and based on the 1945 novel A Fugue in Time by Rumer Godden.

<i>Romola</i> (film) 1924 film

Romola is a 1924 American silent drama film directed by Henry King and shot on location in Italy. The film stars Lillian Gish, Dorothy Gish, William Powell, and Ronald Colman, and is based on the 1863 George Eliot novel of the same name.

<i>The Blue Mountains Mystery</i> 1921 film

The Blue Mountains Mystery is a lost 1921 Australian silent film directed by Raymond Longford and co-directed by Lottie Lyell.

The Enchanted Cottage is a 1924 American silent drama film directed by John S. Robertson based upon a 1923 play by Arthur Wing Pinero.

<i>The White Rose</i> (1923 film) 1923 film

The White Rose is a 1923 American silent drama film directed by D. W. Griffith. The film was written, produced, and directed by Griffith, and stars Mae Marsh, Ivor Novello, Carol Dempster, and Neil Hamilton. Though this film is extant, it is one of Griffith's rarely seen films.

<i>Mrs. Wiggs of the Cabbage Patch</i> (1919 film) 1919 film by Hugh Ford

Mrs. Wiggs of the Cabbage Patch is a 1919 silent American comedy-drama film produced by Famous Players–Lasky Corporation and distributed through Paramount Pictures. Directed by Hugh Ford, the film stars Marguerite Clark and is based on the 1904 Broadway play by Anne Crawford Flexner, which itself is taken from the novel of the same name by Alice Hegan Rice.

<i>Forget Me Not</i> (1922 film) 1922 silent film by W. S. Van Dyke

Forget Me Not, also known as Forget-Me-Not, is a 1922 American silent melodrama film directed by W. S. Van Dyke and distributed by Metro Pictures. The film starred Bessie Love and Gareth Hughes. It is considered a lost film.

<i>Everything for Sale</i> (1921 film) 1921 film

Everything for Sale is a 1921 American silent drama film directed by Frank O'Connor, in his directorial debut, and written by Hector Turnbull. The film stars May McAvoy, A. Edward Sutherland, Kathlyn Williams, Edwin Stevens, Richard Tucker, and Betty Schade. The film was released on September 25, 1921, by Paramount Pictures.

<i>A Homespun Vamp</i> 1922 film by Frank OConnor

A Homespun Vamp is a 1922 American silent drama film directed by Frank O'Connor and written by Harvey F. Thew and Hector Turnbull. The film stars May McAvoy, Darrell Foss, Lincoln Stedman, Josephine Crowell, Charles Stanton Ogle, Guy Oliver and Helen Dunbar. The film was released on February 12, 1922, by Paramount Pictures.

<i>The Woman Under Oath</i> 1919 American film

The Woman Under Oath is a 1919 American silent mystery film directed by John M. Stahl and starring stage star Florence Reed. As with the previous Stahl and Reed film, Her Code of Honor, it was produced by Tribune Productions and released by United Picture Theatres of America Incorporated.

<i>Her Reputation</i> (1923 film) 1923 film

Her Reputation is a 1923 silent film drama directed by John Griffith Wray and starring May McAvoy. It was produced by Thomas H. Ince and released through Associated First National.

References