The Battle of the Roses

Last updated

The Battle of the Roses
The Rugby Match, The Roses Match
The Roses Match.jpg
Artist William Barnes Wollen
Completion date1895 (1895)
Location Twickenham Stadium, Twickenham, Greater London, England
Owner Yorkshire Rugby Football Union

The Battle of the Roses also known as The Rugby Match or The Roses Match is an 1895 portrait by artist William Barnes Wollen. It is based on the rugby union match between the representative sides of Yorkshire and Lancashire played at Fallowfield, Manchester on 24 November 1894. It depicts the Yorkshire team in the all-white strip attacking while the Lancashire team in the hooped red and white jerseys and black shorts try to prevent a pass being made. The action on the pitch takes place in front of a packed stadium.

Contents

History

The painting was commissioned by Newcastle-on-Tyne based partnership of Mawson, Swan & Morgan and it was completed by Wollen in 1895 and was exhibited at the 1896 Royal Academy Summer Exhibition (catalogue number 673). [1] Many of the players sat specially for Wollen while other players were based on previous portraits of them. [2] It was one of the pieces selected to appear in Cassell's Royal Academy Pictures 1896 edition. [3] Subsequent to the Royal Academy exhibition the portrait is known to have been on display in West Yorkshire and Newcastle in 1896–1898 but the subsequent whereabouts of the portrait are unknown until 1957 when members of the Yorkshire Rugby Football Union found the portrait in a second-hand shop in Newcastle. They bought the picture for £25 and it was displayed in the Otley R.U.F.C. clubhouse until the 1960s when it was moved to its current location in the West stand at Twickenham Stadium. [4]

Ghost legend

The picture was cleaned and restored by Denis Bynon of HS Bynon & Son Picture Restorers. [5] Examined under a specific light showed overpaint on the picture at this time to show that at least one player who has subsequently been overpainted from the picture. One suggestion made was that Wollen painted out players who, in 1895, took part in the schism of rugby and left rugby union to join the Northern Rugby Football Union (later to become the Rugby Football League). The story of these ghosts took root and was repeated as the truth on TV and in the press until it was pointed out that had Wollen painted out all the players who moved codes that there would only be a couple of players left in the picture. [6] Other suggestions are that the painter forgot to include the referee in the original and simply chose to replace one of the players with the referee figure or that the players were expected to make a financial donation to appear in the picture and the one who didn't pay up was removed from the final portrait. None of these suggestions has ever been substantiated and Wollen's motives for the changes are unknown. [4] [7]

Accuracy and 2020 reappraisal

Until 2020 historians, including rugby specialist Tony Collins considered that the picture featured the rugby union match between the representative sides of Yorkshire and Lancashire played at Park Avenue, Bradford on 25 November 1893 but noted that at least 11 of the players in the picture have been identified as taking part in the 1893 match but others who have been identified didn't, most notably Alf Barraclough, the player making the pass, and Thomas Dobson, the rightmost player in the picture. The referee in the picture has been identified as George Rowland Hill then the secretary of the Rugby Football Union but the actual referee of the game was T Potts from Durham. [7]

With the greater availability of contemporary newspapers for study Collins is now of the opinion that the painting is based on the game between the two counties at Fallowfield stadium, Manchester on 24 November 1894. [8] A review of the painting while it was on public display in Huddersfield in 1896 gives a full description of the painting identifying many of the players illustrated, the match, location and the identity of many rugby officials who appear in the crowd. [9] One remaining discrepancy is the referee as match reports record the referee as Irish referee, R. G. Warren. [10]

Related Research Articles

The 1895–96 Northern Rugby Football Union season was the first ever season of semi-professional rugby football, which formed the foundation of the modern-day sport of rugby league. Twenty-two Northern English teams from both sides of the Pennines broke away from the Rugby Football Union to create and compete in their own competition.

Barron Kilner was an English rugby union footballer who played in the 1880s, and rugby union administrator of the 1890s. He played at representative level for England, and Yorkshire, and at club level for Wakefield Trinity, as a forward, e.g. front row, lock, or back row. Prior to 27 August 1895, Wakefield Trinity was a rugby union club. Barron Kilner was also Mayor of Wakefield in 1899.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Dobson (rugby)</span> England international rugby union, league footballer and sprinter

Thomas Hyde Dobson was an English rugby union footballer, professional sprinter, and professional rugby league footballer who played in the 1890s. He played representative level rugby union (RU) for England and Yorkshire, and at club level for Undercliffe RFC, Laisterdyke RFC, Bowling RFC, and Bradford FC, as a centre, i.e. number 12, or 13, and club level rugby league (RL) for Bradford FC, as a wing. As a sprinter, primarily in Northern England, he won over £200 in prizes, Prior to Tuesday 27 August 1895, Bradford FC was a rugby union club, it then became a rugby league club, and since 1907 it has been the association football (soccer) club Bradford Park Avenue.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Toothill</span> England international rugby union & league footballer

John Thomas Toothill was an English rugby union, and professional rugby league footballer who played in the 1890s. He played representative level rugby union (RU) for England and Yorkshire, and at club level for Bradford FC, as a forward, e.g. front row, lock, or back row, and club level rugby league (RL) for Bradford FC, as a forward, during the era of contested scrums. Prior to Tuesday 27 August 1895, Bradford FC was a rugby union club, it then became a rugby league club, and since 1907 it has been the association football (soccer) club Bradford Park Avenue.

Roger Walker was a rugby union forward who played club rugby for Manchester Rugby Club and international rugby for England. Walker later became the President of the Rugby Football Union, and in that role accompanied the British Isles team on their 1896 tour of South Africa.

Alfred "Alf" Barraclough was a rugby union, and professional rugby league footballer who played in the 1890s. He played representative level rugby union (RU) for Yorkshire, and at club level for Manningham FC (captain), and representative level rugby league (RL) for Yorkshire, and at club level for Manningham FC. Prior to Tuesday 27 August 1895, Manningham was a rugby union club, it then became a rugby league club, and since Friday 29 May 1903 it has been the association football (soccer) club Bradford City.

Tyldesley was a rugby league club in Tyldesley, Lancashire, England.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brighouse Rangers RFC</span> Defunct English semi-professional rugby league club

Brighouse Rangers was a rugby league club in Brighouse, West Yorkshire, England.

The 1941–42 Northern Rugby Football Union season was the third season of the rugby league’s Wartime Emergency League necessitated by the Second World War. With fewer clubs than the previous season the Rugby Football League (RFL) took the decision to amalgamate the two county leagues into one joint league. The season started with 18 clubs but finished with 17 after Broughton Rangers withdrew in January 1942. The single division championship was won by Dewsbury, who had finished the season in first position and then defeated Bradford Northern in the play-off final.

Runcorn FC was a rugby league club. Having formed in 1876 and played rugby union as members of the RFU, they joined the Northern Union in 1895, just several days after it was founded, and played in the league from 1895–96 to 1917–18.

The Yorkshire Rugby Football Union is the governing body responsible for rugby union in the historic county of Yorkshire, England. It is one of the constituent bodies of the national Rugby Football Union having formed in 1869, the union was formerly called Yorkshire County Club.

The 1910–11 Yorkshire Cup was a knock-out competition between rugby league clubs from the county of Yorkshire. The actual area was at times increased to encompass other teams from outside the county such as Newcastle, Mansfield, Coventry, and even London (in the form of Acton & Willesden. The competition always took place early in the season, in the Autumn, with the final taking place in December 1910 was the sixth occasion on which the Yorkshire Cup competition was held. This year saw a new name on the trophy. Wakefield Trinity won by beating the previous season's winners, Huddersfield by the score of 8-2. The match was played at Headingley, Leeds, now in West Yorkshire. The attendance was 19,000 and receipts were £696. This was Huddersfield's second appearance in what would be seven appearances in eight consecutive finals between 1909 and 1919

The 1911–12 Yorkshire Cup was the seventh occasion on which the Yorkshire Cup competition, a Rugby league tournament, was held. This year saw a previous winner, Huddersfield, win the trophy by beating Hull Kingston Rovers by the score of 22-10

The 1937–38 Yorkshire Cup was the thirtieth occasion on which the Yorkshire Cup competition had been held.

The 1940–41 Yorkshire Cup was held in spring 1941.

The 1941–42 Yorkshire Cup was the thirty-fourth occasion on which the Yorkshire Cup competition had been held. Organised by the Rugby Football League (RFL), the Yorkshire Cup was a knock-out competition between the professional rugby league clubs from the county of Yorkshire. Under the wartime emergency rules the RFL was operating to, teams from Lancashire were invited to participate as the Lancashire Cup was not played. The Cup was played for by 14 teams from Yorkshire and two from Lancashire.

The 1992 Yorkshire Cup was the eighty-fifth and last occasion on which the Yorkshire Cup competition had been held. Wakefield Trinity won the trophy by beating Sheffield Eagles by the score of 29-16

The 1939–40 Northern Rugby Football League season was an emergency season of English rugby league fixtures necessitated by the outbreak of the Second World War. The regular league season had started at the end of August 1939, but on the outbreak of war all sport was suspended. When government permission for sport to be resumed was given, the league was reorganised into two regional competitions, Yorkshire and Lancashire. The winners of each league playing against each other to decide the overall champions. The Yorkshire competition was won by Bradford Northern who beat Swinton, winners of the Lancashire competition, in the two-legged league final.

Graham Findlay was a Scottish rugby union player. He later became an international referee and was the 23rd President of the Scottish Rugby Union.

The County Championship was a representative competition of British counties in rugby league between 1895 and 1983.

References

  1. "The Royal Academy. Second Notice" . Edinburgh Evening News . No. 7187. 9 May 1896. p. 4 via British Newspaper Archive.
  2. "Exhibition of a football picture in Huddersfield" . Huddersfield Daily Chronicle. No. 8, 889. 25 January 1896. p. 8 via British Newspaper Archive.
  3. "Literature" . Derby Mercury. No. 9467. 17 June 1896. p. 6 via British Newspaper Archive.
  4. 1 2 "The Ghost in the Painting". Rugby History. Rugby Football Union. 14 February 2016. Archived from the original on 14 December 2017. Retrieved 13 December 2017.
  5. Nichol, Sara (10 September 2015). "How North East man Denis Bynon repaired some of the greatest art treasures". ChronicleLive. Retrieved 15 February 2023.
  6. Collins, Tony (1996). "Myth and reality in the 1895 rugby split". The Sports Historian. Routledge. 16 (1): 33. doi:10.1080/17460269609446392.
  7. 1 2 Morgan, Piers (1996). "Comment on Myth and reality in the 1895 rugby split by Tony Collins". The Sports Historian. Routledge. 17 (2): 112–113.
  8. Tony Collins (4 January 2021). "147. The Ghost Player at the Roses Match". Soundcloud (Podcast). Event occurs at 6:45. Retrieved 4 January 2021.
  9. ""The Battle of the Roses"" . Huddersfield Daily Examiner . No. 8, 727. 23 January 1896. p. 4 via British Newspaper Archive.
  10. "Lancashire v. Yorkshire" . Huddersfield Daily Examiner. No. 8, 372. 26 November 1894. p. 3 via British Newspaper Archive.