The Pubs Code Regulations 2016

Last updated

The Pubs Code etc. Regulations 2016 [1] were introduced by the UK Government as part of the Small Business Enterprise and Employment Act 2015. [2] The code was passed on 14 June 2016 [3] and implemented on 21 July 2016. [4]

Contents

The code regulates the relationship between pub tenants and the large pub owning companies, known as pubcos. A pubco rents out a pub to a tenant and then sells them the pubs supplies, known as tied products This makes the pub what is called a Tied house. The tenant is obligated to buy these supplies from the pubco.

The code establishes the right of a tied tenant to take a free of tie rent option at certain trigger points, known as the Market Rent Only (MRO) option. The code also mandates that the affected pubcos must provide information to new tenants on how the landlord / tenant relationship is conducted.

The code applies only to tenants of pubcos owning over 500 pubs The regulated pubcos are: [5]

Background

It was deemed necessary to regulate the business relationships as an imbalance of power and bad business practices had been identified by several business select committees. They had bee investigating the problems ince 2004. The evidence proved that the renting of tied pubs was unfair and in need of reform. [6]

A large survey from CGA Strategy showed some 2/3rd's of tied tenants were earning very little profit from their pubs. [7] Despite clear recommendations by all previous select committees to create statutory powers and re-balance "risk and reward" the government opted for a self-regulatory approach This approach was announced in Nov 2011 [8] by the then Minister and Under Secretary of State Ed Davey MP.

Self Regulation (PIRRS & PICAS)

A package of self-regulation was proposed by the pubcos this was to include an Independent Framework Code (IFC) [9] and for all pub companies offering a tied rent to have a company code, a rent review scheme (PIRRS) [10] and a dispute resolution service (PICAS). [11] Despite many previous opportunities the pubcos were unable to create enough meaningful change to the letting of pubs under self-regulation route, the BBPA (pubcos trade body - although Greene King are not members.) [12] did not have the power to effect swift changes despite clear promises to Government that they would.

This was further highlighted during the 2011 BIS select committee:

"The BBPA has shown itself to be impotent in enforcing its own timetable for reform and the supposed threat of removing the membership of pub companies who did not deliver was hollow. The voluntary withdrawal from the BBPA by Greene King, which has suffered no reputational loss as a result, clearly demonstrates that fact." [13]

Six revisions of the Framework Code have been published but none of them made any attempt to ensure that was an equitable split of profits between licensees and pubcos (the no worse off principle). At a meeting of the Parliamentary Save the Pub Group the Chief Executive of the BBPA said "it is not the role of the BBPA to look at tenants’ profit". [14] It was this refusal to consider tenant profitability which underlined the failure of the self-regulatory approach to deliver on key issues. At the same time pressure from campaigning Tenant groups began to gather pace under the Fair Deal for your Local banner [15] and meant further scrutiny from government was inevitable.

Pubs Advisory Service (PAS)

The government also wanted to see the trade create a "pubs advisory service" to help new entrants to the pubs trade with independent advice. The British Institute of Innkeeping, working with the Federation of Licensed Victuallers Associations, was reported in 2012 to be offering access to its Pubs Advisory Service. [16] A rival company operating under the PAS name was created and launched by trade figures in May 2012. [16] [17]

Government consults again (2013)

The government held a new consultation in 2013, once again looking into the relationship between tenants and their pubcos. This time carried out by the Business Innovation and Skills department [18] and not the select committees as had been the case in previous years. The outcome of that consultation was that the Government concluded from over 8000 responses that self-regulation had failed to make enough progress since 2004 (when first offered to the select committee by pubco's) and that a new statutory pubs code was required to address the failures in the sector [19] thereby overturning the policy outlined by Ed Davey back in 2011.

The government opted for a de minimis approach i.e. only those companies with over 1% of the market (500 pubs) would be subject to regulation.

(MRO) New Clause 2 Nov 2014

The government established in the wake of the consultation two principles for the draft bill

The draft bill still had no clear mechanism as to how this would be achieved. [20] MP Greg Mulholland [21] (who had helped lead the Fair Deal for Your Local campaign) proposed a new clause to the draft bill to rectify this, his proposal was called the Market Rent Only option or MRO as it is now commonly referred to.

On 18 November 2014 [22] a vote was called and despite a three line whip the vote turned out to be a historic defeat for government by 284 votes to 259 [23] and New Clause 2 with MRO was added to the Bill.

Pubs Code Adjudicator (PCA)

The Pubs Code requires an Adjudicator and one was appointed by the BIS on 2016/03/10 [24] The current adjudicator is Paul Newby who was a director of Fleurets. [25] His appointment is not without controversy [26] as he previously acted during his time at Fleurets for some of the companies he is now to regulate. [27] Although he also acted for tenants, his case load when he left Fleurets included six cases acting for the pubcos he is to regulate and sevenacting for tenants. [28]

The British Pub Confederation (BPC), which claims to represent more publicans than any other organisation, [29] has said that its members [30] will advise their tenant members not to accept Mr Newby in their cases., [29] whereas the Association of Licensed Multiple Retailers (ALMR) which represents multiple pub operators running about 4,000 tied tenanted pubs [28] has welcomed Mr Newby's appointment. [31] Following two sessions of oral evidence firstly from Mr Newby, then in a joint session of representatives from Punch, Enterprise, the PAS and the BPC, the BIS committee wrote to the Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy on 21 July 2016 calling for Mr Newby to be replaced on the grounds of a perception in tenants' eyes of conflict of interest. [32] No evidence was taken from the ALMR. On the same date the Adjudicator published his conflict of interest policy and register of interests. [33] A spokesman for the Adjudicator was quoted in the Morning Advertiser (a trade journal) on 1 August 2016 as saying that the Commissioner for Public Appointments had reviewed the case and was satisfied that the appointments panel was correct to conclude that there were no conflicts of interest which would prevent Mr Newby from doing the job. [34] The Minister is yet to respond.

Pubs Code in Scotland

Becomes an Act:

The Tied Pubs (Scotland) Bill passed the Scottish Parliament by a vote of 111 for, 0 against and 0 abstentions. The Bill became law on 5 May 2021. The Scottish Government will consult on the creation of the actual code wording in the second half of 2021

The Pubs Code regulation does not apply to tenants of the large pub-owning companies if the pub they rent is in Scotland however a new Scottish bill proposes a code which will go further than the English and Welsh code. During the introduction of legislation in England and Wales, the Scottish government undertook a separate consultation with the outcome showing that unlike in other parts of the United Kingdom, no one pub model in Scotland is significantly advantaged over another and in turn, no legislative action was required. This changed in 2020 and The FSB said in its response "against this context, the Scottish Government’s commissioned research on the pub sector, which found that no part of the sector was ‘unfairly disadvantaged’, seems insufficient grounds to rule out legislative action"

The Law Society of Scotland said in its response when looking at competition grounds "that where the operating model of a pub tenancy arrangement is such that effective wholesale prices of beer and other products are driven significantly above market value, the cost may be borne by consumers."

A few pub companies in Scotland have signed up to a voluntary code arranged by its membership organisation the BBPA which forms a concession made to tied tenants, it is not a universal offer as not all tied pub companies in Scotland signed up to a code, the SBPA (Scottish Beer and Pub Association) launched its version in 2016 which its members publish. Previously, the voluntary code was managed by the GB-wide Pubs Governing Body (PGB). [35]

Recent Developments: On 27 November 2020 the Tied Pubs Bill passed stage one by a huge majority, 107 For 0 Against, the Scottish Minister Jamie Hepburn announced during the debate that the Scots Government would now be backing the bill. The Tied Pubs (Scotland) Bill became an Act on 5 May 2021.

Sustainable business plans

The Code introduces a mandatory requirement for business plans with the intention being to stop unachievable business models from being used in the letting of tied public houses.

The regulations place the onus upon any pub company letting a tied pub to ensure the business plan presented by a prospective tenant is sustainable. It requires that any reports of the trading costs and other relevant data for tied pubs are being supplied upfront.

Related Research Articles

Adjudication is the legal process by which an arbiter or judge reviews evidence and argumentation, including legal reasoning set forth by opposing parties or litigants, to come to a decision which determines rights and obligations between the parties involved.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Housing association</span> Organisations providing low-cost "social housing"

In Ireland and the United Kingdom, housing associations are private, non-profit making organisations that provide low-cost "social housing" for people in need of a home. Any budget surplus is used to maintain existing housing and to help finance new homes and it cannot be used for personal benefit of directors or shareholders. Although independent, they are regulated by the state and commonly receive public funding. They are now the United Kingdom's major providers of new housing for rent, while many also run shared ownership schemes to help those who cannot afford to buy a home outright.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ofcom</span> British government agency

The Office of Communications, commonly known as Ofcom, is the government-approved regulatory and competition authority for the broadcasting, telecommunications and postal industries of the United Kingdom.

The Postcode Address File (PAF) is a database that contains all known "delivery points" and postcodes in the United Kingdom. The PAF is a collection of over 29 million Royal Mail postal addresses and 1.8 million postcodes. It is available in a variety of formats including FTP download and compact disc, and was previously available as digital audio tape. As owner of the PAF, Royal Mail is required by section 116 of the Postal Services Act 2000 to maintain the data and make it available on reasonable terms. A charge is made for lookup services or wholesale supply of PAF data. Charges are regulated by Ofcom. It includes small user residential, small user organisation and large user organisation details. There have been requests as part of the Open Data campaign for the PAF to be released by the government free of charge.

Property management is the operation, control, maintenance, and oversight of real estate and physical property. This can include residential, commercial, and land real estate. Management indicates the need for real estate to be cared for and monitored, with accountability for and attention to its useful life and condition. This is much akin to the role of management in any business.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tied house</span> Pub tied into a specific brewery

In the United Kingdom, a tied house is a public house required to buy at least some of its beer from a particular brewery or pub company. That is in contrast to a free house, which is able to choose the beers it stocks freely.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Consumer Credit Act 1974</span> An Act of Parliament from the United Kingdom in 1974

The Consumer Credit Act 1974 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom that significantly reformed the law relating to consumer credit within the United Kingdom.

Ei Group plc, formerly known as Enterprise Inns plc, is the largest pub company in the UK, with around 5,000 properties, predominantly run as leased and tenanted pubs. Ei Group plc is headquartered in Solihull, West Midlands. It was listed on the London Stock Exchange until it was acquired by Stonegate Pub Company in March 2020.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Punch Pubs</span> Pub and bar operator in the United Kingdom

Punch Pubs & Co is a pub and bar operator in the United Kingdom, with around 1,300 leased pubs. It is headquartered in the traditional brewing centre of Burton upon Trent in Staffordshire. It was listed on the London Stock Exchange as a constituent of the FTSE SmallCap Index until its sale in 2016 for £403m to a private equity fund, Patron Capital, acting in concert with Heineken International who acquired 1,900 of Punch's pubs as part of the deal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">House in multiple occupation</span>

A house in multiple occupation (HMO), or a house of multiple occupancy, is a British English term which refers to residential properties where ‘common areas’ exist and are shared by more than one household.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Land reform in Scotland</span> Ongoing political and legal process in Scotland

Land reform in Scotland is the ongoing process by which the ownership of land, its distribution and the law which governs it is modified, reformed and modernised by property and regulatory law.

Consumer Affairs Victoria (CAV) is a government agency that protects and promotes the interests of consumers and is based in the Australian state of Victoria. It is responsible for reviewing and advising the Victorian Government on consumer legislation and industry codes; advising and educating consumers, tenants, traders and landlords on their rights, responsibilities and changes to the law; registering and licensing businesses and occupations; conciliating disputes between consumers and traders, tenants and landlords; and enforcing and ensuring compliance with consumer laws. It is a business unit of the Department of Justice and Community Safety.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Landlord and Tenant Act 1985</span> United Kingdom legislation

The Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 is a UK Act of Parliament on English land law. It sets minimum standards in tenants' rights against their landlords.

The Supply of Beer Order 1989 and The Supply of Beer Order 1989, commonly known as the Beer Orders, were Statutory Instruments made by the United Kingdom Secretary of State for Trade and Industry in December 1989.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Advertising Standards Authority (United Kingdom)</span> Advertising regulation authority in the United Kingdom

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) is the self-regulatory organisation of the advertising industry in the United Kingdom. The ASA is a non-statutory organisation and so cannot interpret or enforce legislation. However, its code of advertising practice broadly reflects legislation in many instances. The ASA is not funded by the British government, but by a levy on the advertising industry.

Stonegate Pub Company is the largest pub company in the UK, operating around 4,800 managed, leased and tenanted pubs. It is owned by TDR Capital. The head office is based in Solihull, UK, and the company is registered in the Cayman Islands.

The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) is a statutory body under the jurisdiction of Ministry of Finance, Government of India and is tasked with regulating and licensing the insurance and re-insurance industries in India. It was constituted by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority Act, 1999, an Act of Parliament passed by the Government of India. The agency's headquarters are in Hyderabad, Telangana, where it moved from Delhi in 2001.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scottish Land Commission</span>

The Scottish Land Commission was established by the Scottish Government following the passage of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016 by the Scottish Parliament; the Commission also incorporates the work of the Tenant Farming Commissioner. The Lands Commissioners, who constitute the Commission, have functions relating to land in Scotland, so that they address issues which relate to ownership of land, land rights, management of land, and use of land. The Tenant Farming Commissioner has the aim of improving the relationship between tenant farmers and land owners, and can create codes of practice, provide practical guidance, and must consult on such matters. The Tenant Farming Commissioner cannot be an agricultural landlord or agricultural tenant, and will develop codes of practice which are in addition to the law and the jurisdiction of the Scottish Land Court.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Enterprise, Markets and Small Business</span>

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Enterprise, Markets and Small Business is a Ministerial position in the Department for Business and Trade in the British government. It is currently held by Kevin Hollinrake.

References

  1. ↑ "Pubs Code and adjudicator - GOV.UK".
  2. ↑ "Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015".
  3. ↑ "legislation.gov.uk" (PDF).
  4. ↑ "Pubs adjudicator website".
  5. ↑ MorningAdvertiser.co.uk. "Q&A: Pubs code and MRO option".
  6. ↑ "Pub Companies".
  7. ↑ "camra.org.uk/documents/10180/21560/Response%20from%20CAMRA%20-%20Pub%20Companies%20and%20Tenants%20Consultation.pdf/d3b88743-f320-47eb-9293-896b2afddfa2".
  8. ↑ "Ed Davey writes… Glass half full – or half empty?".
  9. ↑ "BBPA Home - Industry Briefings - UK Pub Industry Framework Code of Practice".
  10. ↑ "BBPA Home - Industry Briefings - Pub Independent Rent Review Scheme".
  11. ↑ "BBPA Home - Industry Briefings - Pubs Independent Conciliation and Arbitration Service".
  12. ↑ "BBPA - Home".
  13. ↑ http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/SN06740/SN06740.pdf [ bare URL PDF ]
  14. ↑ "Mulholland calls for statement from Minister on self regulatory solution following admission from BBPA that they have no role in tenant profitability".
  15. ↑ "Fair Deal for Your Local".
  16. 1 2 "Trade experts launch their own Pubs Advisory Service in response to Government". morningadvertiser.co.uk. 2 May 2012.
  17. ↑ Wright, Chris (30 March 2020). "What is the PAS? - Pubs Advisory Service". pubs.expert.
  18. ↑ "Department for Business, Innovation & Skills - GOV.UK". 12 September 2012.
  19. ↑ "Pub companies and tenants consultation - Consultations - GOV.UK". 22 April 2013.
  20. ↑ MorningAdvertiser.co.uk (4 June 2014). "Statutory code: Fair Pint slams 'ludicrous' BBPA stance on free-of-tie option".
  21. ↑ "Greg Mulholland MP".
  22. ↑ "Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Bill — New Clause 2 — Pubs Code: Market Rent Only Option for Tenants of Large Pub-Owning Businesses — 18 Nov 2014 at 15:45 — The Public Whip".
  23. ↑ "PMA article 20 November 2014". 20 November 2014.
  24. ↑ "Pubs Code Adjudicator appointed - Press releases - GOV.UK".
  25. ↑ Limited, Fleurets. "Fleurets - About".
  26. ↑ MorningAdvertiser.co.uk (2 May 2016). "Update: Campaigners refuse to meet new Pubs Code Adjudicator".
  27. ↑ Allen, Kate (10 March 2016). "UK's new pubs adjudicator 'is conflicted'". Financial Times.
  28. 1 2 "Oral evidence to BIS select committee 10 May 2016".
  29. 1 2 "BPC website".
  30. ↑ "IBS systems website includes list of BPC members".
  31. ↑ "PMA 10 March 2016". 10 March 2016.
  32. ↑ "BIS committee website".
  33. ↑ "Adjudicator website". 8 August 2022.
  34. ↑ "Morning Advertiser 29 July 2016 as updated 1 August 2016". 28 July 2016.
  35. ↑ "Scottish Pubs Code - Scottish Beer & Pub Association". 14 November 2019.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.