This Is Only a Test

Last updated
This Is Only a Test
Smoking Popes - This Is Only a Test cover.JPG
Studio album by
the Smoking Popes
ReleasedMarch 15, 2011 (2011-03-15)
Recorded2010
Genre Pop punk, alternative rock, indie rock
Length36:58
Label Asian Man
Producer Matt Allison, Smoking Popes
Smoking Popes chronology
It's Been a Long Day
(2010)		This Is Only a Test
(2011)

This Is Only a Test is the sixth studio album by the Chicago-based pop punk band the Smoking Popes, released March 15, 2011 through Asian Man Records. It was produced by Matt Allison and is their first album with drummer Neil Hennessy, who joined the band in 2008. It is a concept album, with all of the songs written from the perspective of a single teenage boy dealing with the growing pains of adolescence. [1] [2] [3] Singer, guitarist, and songwriter Josh Caterer described it as "kind of a concept album about a teenage life. All of the songs are written from the point of view of a high school student, and they explore aspects of teenage life. This would be [about] a contemporary teenager. It's not specifically autobiographical of my high school experience. Obviously, those things are incorporated into what I write, but I tried to create a character who is the protagonist in these songs." [4]

Contents

Concept and writing

This Is Only a Test explores themes of identity, musical aspirations, love, and teen suicide. [5] The idea to write a concept album about teenage life came to Caterer while thinking about successful contemporary bands who cited the Smoking Popes as an influence:

I was thinking about some of the younger bands who claim Smoking Popes as one of their influences and have gone onto become very successful in this generation. I [thought about] how their music is different than ours, and what they're doing differently than what we've done. I realized that one of the things I've never done is write from an explicitly teenage point of view--even when I was a teenager. I was always trying to pretend like I was older. I was trying to emulate the kind of perspective and sophistication of the older generation. It occurred to me that it would be funny if now, while I'm in my late 30s, I would actually start writing songs from a teenage perspective. As soon as that thought occurred to me, I got ideas for, like, the first five songs on the record. They just sort of started coming to me. So I went home and started writing and they just came out. That became the beginning of the next record. [4]

With the idea in place to write from a teenage perspective, "the individual songs came really quickly", said Caterer, "I wrote a song a day for five days. That's half the album in less than a week. I never write that fast! Each song stands alone as a snapshot from this kid's life. The story doesn't unfold like a narrative. It's more like a collage." [5] According to Caterer, the album's main character is not autobiographical, but "definitely a creation. He's not me. Well...he's similar to me, but he's not limited by the realities of my own experience. I created a character that basically has the same view of the world that I had when I was in high school, but he’s his own person and he does some things that I never did." [5]

Recording and promotion

This Is Only a Test was recorded at Atlas Studios in Chicago beginning in April 2010. [6] The album's title and release date were announced that November. [7] In February 2011 the band streamed the song "Punk Band" exclusively through Alternative Press , followed several weeks later by streaming the entire album through Punknews.org. [8] [9] The band embarked on a supporting tour of the United States from February to April of that year. [10] A music video for "Punk Band" premiered March 1, 2011. [11]

Reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
Allmusic [1] Star full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar empty.svg
Alternative Press [2] Star full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar half.svgStar empty.svg
Punknews.org [3] Star full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar half.svgStar empty.svg

Rick Anderson of Allmusic gave This Is Only a Test four stars out of five, remarking that "While [the songs] deal with some predictable themes — obsessive and unrequited love ('Wish We Were,' 'Diary of a Teen Tragedy'); ambivalence about the future ('College'); mono ('I've Got Mono'), and rock & roll itself ('Punk Band') — [Josh] Caterer addresses them with a refreshing lack of either eye-rolling or rhapsodic mystification." [1] He also praised the band's musical maturity, noting "the blend of smoothly crooning vocals and meat-and-potatoes, punk-inflected pop that has always been the hallmark of the Smoking Popes' sound and has only become tighter, richer, and more hook-wise over the years." [1] Jon Gilbertson of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel compared the album's concept to The Who's Quadrophenia , which also structured its themes around the difficulties of teenage life: "Although This Is Only a Test doesn't try to match Quadrophenia, it does convey the same realization that there's no such thing, for the young, as the folly of youth. And Caterer's voice, perhaps the most tunefully expressive in the entire pop-punk subgenre, brings across the way small things grow gigantic under the influence of hormones." [12]

Bryne Yancey of Alternative Press was critical of the band's musical divergences on the album, stating that "Unfortunately, much like adolescence itself, This Is Only a Test isn't without its moments of awkwardness. Whether it's piano-heavy power ballads ('College'), spoken-word verses written as diary entries ('Diary of a Teen Tragedy') or five-minute electronic tracks about not being able to participate in P.E. class ('Excuse Me, Coach'), Smoking Popes occasionally veer off their tried and true template of catchy, soulful pop-punk, and do so with mixed results." [2] However, he noted that "there are still plenty of hooks to be found on the album, especially it its loaded first half", comparing the band to Weezer and calling the album "a mostly successful experiment." [2] Tori of Punknews.org had similar criticisms, saying of "Excuse Me, Coach" that "I'm not sure what they were thinking, and I'm not sure I want to know", and calling the spoken-word verses in "Diary of a Teen Tragedy" "downright cringeworthy": "The reality remains that the Caterer brothers are not high schoolers. Hearing a man in his late 30s sing about how he can't get a prom date is a little off-putting." [3] However, he called these "small complaints", concluding that "Aside from a couple blunders, This Is Only a Test is a thoroughly enjoyable pop-rock album. At a brisk 10 songs totaling less than 40 minutes, it leaves you wanting more. Plenty to sing along to here." [3]

Track listing

All tracks are written by Josh Caterer.

No.TitleLength
1."Wish We Were"2:39
2."How Dangerous"3:24
3."This Is Only a Test"3:39
4."College"4:19
5."Punk Band"2:45
6."Freakin Out"3:40
7."Diary of a Teen Tragedy"4:03
8."Excuse Me, Coach"4:42
9."I've Got Mono"3:26
10."Letter to Emily"4:21
Total length:36:58

Personnel

[13]

Band

Additional musicians

Production

Related Research Articles

<i>The Art of Drowning</i> (album) 2000 studio album by AFI

The Art of Drowning is the fifth studio album by American rock band AFI. It was released on September 19, 2000, through Nitro Records. Between June and August 2001, the group performed on the Warped Tour.

<i>Black Sails in the Sunset</i> 1999 studio album by AFI

Black Sails in the Sunset is the fourth studio album by American rock band AFI. It was released on May 18, 1999 through Nitro Records. With the addition of guitarist Jade Puget as a permanent member, it is the first AFI album to feature the current line-up of the band.

<i>Revolutions per Minute</i> (Rise Against album) 2003 studio album by Rise Against

Revolutions per Minute is the second studio album by American rock band Rise Against, released on April 8, 2003 by Fat Wreck Chords. After establishing a fanbase with their 2001 debut The Unraveling, the band members wanted to record an album that distinguished themselves from other Fat Wreck Chords bands of the time. They chose Bill Stevenson and Jason Livermore to produce the album, with whom they developed a strong rapport. Recording took place from November to December 2002 at The Blasting Room in Fort Collins, Colorado.

Smoking Popes American pop punk band

The Smoking Popes is an American pop punk band from the northwest suburbs of Chicago, Illinois, formed in 1991. They play punk-influenced pop music with crooning vocals. The core of the group is composed of brothers Matt Caterer, Josh Caterer and Eli Caterer.

Josh Caterer is a Chicago-area musician, best known as the lead singer, lead guitarist, and principal songwriter of punk band The Smoking Popes, which he founded in 1991 along with his brothers, Eli Caterer and Matt Caterer. Caterer has also written and recorded a considerable body of Christian and gospel music. In addition to the Smoking Popes, he founded the blues band Jackson Mud.

<i>Get Fired</i> 1993 studio album by the Smoking Popes

Get Fired is the debut album by the Chicago-based pop punk band the Smoking Popes, released in 1993 by Johann's Face Records. It was recorded in 1993 at Sonic Iguana Studios in Lafayette, Indiana with recording engineer Mass Giorgini. The raw production and punk rock sound of the album are in contrast to the higher production values and more pop-leaning sound of the band's later works.

<i>2</i> (Smoking Popes EP) 1993 EP by the Smoking Popes

2 is the third EP by the Chicago-based pop punk band the Smoking Popes, released independently in 1993. It was recorded in 1992 at Solid Sound Studio in Hoffman Estates, Illinois with recording engineer Phil Bonnet, the same location and engineer used for their previous EP Break Up.

Alkaline Trio / Smoking Popes single by Alkaline Trio and Smoking Popes

Alkaline Trio / Smoking Popes is a split single by the Chicago-based rock bands Alkaline Trio and Smoking Popes. It was distributed to attendees at a New Year's Eve performance by both bands at the Metro Chicago on December 31, 2006 – January 1, 2007. The single features each band covering one of the other's songs, with Alkaline Trio covering the Smoking Popes' "Off My Mind" and the Smoking Popes covering Alkaline Trio's "Blue Carolina".

Smoking Popes discography

The discography of the Smoking Popes, a Chicago-based pop punk band, consists of six studio albums, two live albums, two compilation albums, six EPs, five singles, one video album, and four music videos.

<i>Destination Failure</i> 1997 studio album by the Smoking Popes

Destination Failure is the third album by the Chicago-based pop punk band the Smoking Popes, released August 26, 1997 by Capitol Records. It was their second, and final, album for Capitol and their last before their nearly seven-year hiatus; their covers album The Party's Over was rejected by Capitol and the Smoking Popes disbanded in December 1998, reuniting in November 2005 to record At Metro. Destination Failure was not as successful as the band's previous album Born to Quit; it failed to chart despite the release a single and music video for "I Know You Love Me". The album was recorded at the Chicago Recording Company and at Conway Studios in Hollywood with producer Jerry Finn and recording engineer Phil Bonnet. Bonnet had worked with the band since early in their career, engineering and producing their EPs Break Up and 2 as well as Born to Quit.

<i>Born to Quit</i> 1994 studio album by the Smoking Popes

Born to Quit is the second album by the Chicago-based pop punk band the Smoking Popes, originally released in 1994 by Johann's Face Records and re-released in 1995 through Capitol Records. It became their only release to chart, reaching #37 on Billboard's Top Heatseekers chart, partly on the strength of the single "Need You Around" which reached #35 on the Modern Rock Tracks chart.

<i>Stay Down</i> (album) 2008 studio album by Smoking Popes

Stay Down is the fifth studio album by Chicago pop punk group Smoking Popes. Released on Curb Appeal Records on August 5, 2008, it was the band's first studio album since their 2005 reunion and their first album of original material since 1997's Destination Failure. It's the only Smoking Popes album to feature drummer Ryan Chavez, who joined the band in 2006.

<i>Ghosts</i> (The Marked Men album) 2009 studio album by The Marked Men

Ghosts is the fourth album by the Denton, Texas punk rock band The Marked Men, released January 27, 2009 by Dirtnap Records. Like their previous albums, the band recorded, produced, and mixed it themselves in a converted shed in their hometown of Denton.

I Was a Teenage Anarchist 2010 single by Against Me!

"I Was a Teenage Anarchist" is a song by the Gainesville, Florida-based punk rock band Against Me!, released as the first single from their 2010 album White Crosses. The single was released as a four-track digital download through various online music stores on April 6, 2010, including the additional album track "Rapid Decompression" and two B-sides from the album's sessions, "One by One" and "Bitter Divisions". A 7" single was released on April 17 in conjunction with Record Store Day, with an acoustic version of "I Was a Teenage Anarchist" featuring as the B-side.

Need You Around Smoking Popes song

"Need You Around" is a song by the Chicago-based pop punk band the Smoking Popes, released as the second single from their 1994 album Born to Quit. The album was originally released by Johann's Face Records in 1994, and "Need You Around" received radio play on Chicago's Q101 and Los Angeles' KROQ. When Born to Quit was re-released in July 1995 by Capitol Records after the band signed to that label, "Need You Around" and "Rubella" were remixed by Thom Wilson for release as singles. A music video for "Need You Around" was filmed, and the song was featured in the soundtrack of the film Clueless. It became the only Smoking Popes song to chart, reaching #35 on Billboard's Modern Rock Tracks.

<i>Chamberlain Waits</i> 2010 studio album by The Menzingers

Chamberlain Waits is the second studio album by American punk rock band The Menzingers. The album was voted the best release of 2010, by Australian radio show Bullying The Jukebox.

<i>There Are Rules</i> 2011 studio album by The Get Up Kids

There Are Rules is the fifth studio album by American rock band The Get Up Kids, the band's first studio album release since 2004's Guilt Show. After their initial reunion, the band decided to challenge themselves to write and record an album in only two weeks without using any digital technology. Ultimately, due to conflicting schedules, they dropped the two-week deadline and recorded over several months in 2009 and 2010. Much of the album was recorded in the same sessions as their first post-reunion release, Simple Science, the song "Keith Case" being featured on both.

<i>Suburbia Ive Given You All and Now Im Nothing</i> 2011 studio album by The Wonder Years

Suburbia I've Given You All and Now I'm Nothing is the third studio album by American rock band The Wonder Years.

Loma Prieta (band)

Loma Prieta is an American hardcore punk band that formed in 2005. The group is based in San Francisco, California and derived their name from the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake. Most of the group's early material was released on their own record label named Discos Huelga. Loma Prieta has toured the US, Mexico, Canada, Europe and Japan. They share members with Punch. Their often dark and emotionally charged music blends a range of styles, most prominently screamo and powerviolence.

Birds in Row

Birds in Row is a French hardcore punk band that formed in 2009 in Laval and is composed of three members, "T.", "Q." and "B.". They signed to Deathwish Inc. in 2011 and released their debut album You, Me & the Violence in 2012.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Anderson, Rick. "Review: This Is Only a Test". Allmusic . Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Yancey, Bryne (2011-03-15). "Review: This Is Only a Test". Alternative Press . Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Tori (2011-03-15). "Review: Smoking Popes - This Is Only a Test". Punknews.org. Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  4. 1 2 Albers, Lucy (2011-02-11). "A conversation with Josh Caterer of Smoking Popes". Alternative Press . Retrieved 2010-02-24.
  5. 1 2 3 "Bio". smokingpopes.net. Smoking Popes. Retrieved 2011-03-22.
  6. ↑ "Smoking Popes currently in the studio". Punknews.org. 2010-04-23. Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  7. ↑ Yancey, Bryne (2010-11-24). "Smoking Popes announce title, release date for new album". Punknews.org. Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  8. ↑ Heisel, Scott (2011-02-11). "Exclusive Stream: Smoking Popes 'Punk Band'". Alternative Press . Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  9. ↑ Yancey, Bryne (2011-02-25). "Streams: Smoking Popes: 'This Is Only a Test'". Punknews.org. Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  10. ↑ Yancey, Bryne (2011-01-25). "Tours: Smoking Popes (US)". Punknews.org. Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  11. ↑ Yancey, Bryne (2011-03-01). "Videos: Smoking Popes: 'Punk Band'". Punknews.org. Retrieved 2011-03-21.
  12. ↑ Gilbertson, Jon M. (2011-03-17). "Smoking Popes: This Is Only a Test". Milwaukee Journal Sentinel . Retrieved 2011-03-22.
  13. ↑ This Is Only a Test (CD liner). Smoking Popes. Monte Sereno, California: Asian Man Records. 2011.CS1 maint: others (link)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.