Thistle SALM

Last updated

The Thistle SALM (Single Anchor Leg Mooring) was a tanker loading facility that allowed oil from the Thistle oilfield to be transported to land where a submarine export pipeline did not yet exist. It was also the site of the 8 August 1979 Wildrake diving accident that killed two divers. [1] [2] and the 21 January 1981 Stena Seaspread diving accident (non-fatal). [3]

Contents

Development

In February 1975, Burmah Oil decided to develop the Thistle SALM. It was conceived by Exxon, designed by Single Buoy Moorings, Inc. of Monaco and built by Motherwell Bridge Offshore in Leith, Scotland. It cost $6.4 million to build (equivalent to $25 million in 2023), and in March 1977 it was set into position by divers from Sub Sea International. [4]

SALM components Thistle SALM.png
SALM components

The SALM had three major components: a 182-foot (55 m) upper section called the buoy, a 335-foot (102 m) long middle section called the riser, and a hex-shaped gravity base which anchored the facility to the seabed to prevent it from drifting away. From head to toe it was 545 feet (166 m) long. Two articulated “universal joints” allowed the buoy and the riser to pivot in rough water. [5]

During operation, the Thistle Alpha platform fed oil to the SALM through a pair of 16-inch (41 cm) pipelines. This hard piping ran up the base from opposing sides and terminated at the bottom of the riser near the first U-joint articulation. From that point the oil bridged the articulation through a pair of very thick 16-inch flexible jumper hoses, then continued up the riser through more hard piping, and over the riser-buoy articulation through another set of jumper hoses. From there, the oil flowed through product hoses to the shuttle tanker which was moored to the buoy.

Damage

The SALM was installed in March 1977, but did not go into operation until February 1978 when Thistle Alpha began producing oil. [6] Then, on 15 October 1978, a pin-hole leak was discovered in some pipework on the inside of the buoy during a routine maintenance inspection. Preparations were undertaken to fix the leak, but poor weather conditions interrupted the repair work.

Over the winter months the pin-hole leak developed into a split, and a crack in the 16-inch pipework outside the buoy allowed water and oil to flood the central trunkway. [7] This caused the buoy to lose more of its buoyancy. The loss of buoyancy in turn caused the upper U-joint to go into compression which allowed the 2,404-pound (1,090 kg) U-joint pin to wrench itself free. [8]

On 17 January 1979, it was reported that the buoy was not standing up straight anymore. A diver was sent down to investigate and discovered that the U-joint pin had fallen out. The only thing keeping the buoy from floating away were the jumper hoses bridging the articulation. Three days later, after the buoy sustained more flooding, a diver reported that the buoy was now actually grounding on top of the riser. [9]

Recovery operation

Alarmed by this news, the owners of the SALM, British National Oil Corporation, immediately notified Chuck Alexander, the project engineer responsible for the 1977 installation of the SALM, and ordered him to mount an emergency rescue of the 340-metric ton buoy before it sustained irreparable damage, or worse, broke free and became a shipping hazard.

Alexander flew to Aberdeen, and by the next day he was taken out to the diving support vessel Tender Carrier in the Thistle Field. On board the Carrier, Alexander ultimately decided to have the jumper hoses blown off with explosives. Explosives experts were brought out to the ship with their gear and divers placed clamshell charges around the jumper hoses. On 23 January 1979, the signal was given and Alexander heard a bang and saw bubbles come to the surface. A diver was sent down to have a look and discovered that, although both charges had gone off, only one of the hoses had been cut.

With the buoy listing even more precariously, divers undertook the dangerous task of unbolting the remaining hose. Shackles were attached to the top of the buoy, and the buoy was raised out of the water and placed onto the deck of the Pearl Marine. [10]

BNOC ordered an inspection of the top of the riser to see if it had sustained any damage. An ROV (Remotely Operated Vehicle—a kind of mobile robot with a video camera) was sent down to make a video inspection, and the report came back that the riser had sustained no damage to it. With the emergency over, the inspection tape was mailed to Alexander in London.

Several weeks later, Alexander viewed the tape and discovered that one of the clamshell charges had blown a big hole in the top of the riser. The explosion had also rocked one of the 16-inch flow lines out of its clamps, displacing it 30 feet (9 m) below its original position. [11] BNOC would later contract the massive semi-submersible workshop, Narwhal, on a “no cure, no pay” basis to remove the riser and take it to shore. [12]

On 20 March 1979, BNOC authorized the repair and re-installation of the Thistle SALM. [13] Five months later, divers Richard A. Walker and Victor F. "Skip" Guiel Jr. were killed during the re-installation of the SALM in the Wildrake diving accident.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Buoy</span> Floating structure or device

A buoy is a floating device that can have many purposes. It can be anchored (stationary) or allowed to drift with ocean currents.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Surface marker buoy</span> Buoy towed by a scuba diver to indicate the divers position

A surface marker buoy, SMB, dive float or simply a blob is a buoy used by scuba divers, at the end of a line from the diver, intended to indicate the diver's position to people at the surface while the diver is underwater. Two kinds are used; one (SMB) is towed for the whole dive, and indicates the position of the dive group throughout the dive, and the other, a delayed surface marker buoy, DSMB or decompression buoy, is deployed towards the end of the dive as a signal to the surface that the divers have started to ascend, and where they are going to surface. Both types can also function as a depth reference for controlling speed of ascent and accurately maintaining depth at decompression stops. Surface marker buoys are also used by freedivers in open water, to indicate the approximate position of the diver when submerged. They may also be used to support a catch bag or fish stringer by underwater hunters and collectors. A DSMB is considered by recreational scuba divers and service providers to be a highly important item of safety equipment, yet its use is not part of the entry level recreational diver training for all training agencies, and there are significant hazards associated with incompetent use.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dive boat</span> Boat used for the support of scuba diving operations

A dive boat is a boat that recreational divers or professional scuba divers use to reach a dive site which they could not conveniently reach by swimming from the shore. Dive boats may be propelled by wind or muscle power, but are usually powered by internal combustion engines. Some features, like convenient access from the water, are common to all dive boats, while others depend on the specific application or region where they are used. The vessel may be extensively modified to make it fit for purpose, or may be used without much adaptation if it is already usable.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Atmospheric diving suit</span> Articulated pressure resistant anthropomorphic housing for an underwater diver

An atmospheric diving suit (ADS), or single atmosphere diving suit is a small one-person articulated submersible which resembles a suit of armour, with elaborate pressure joints to allow articulation while maintaining an internal pressure of one atmosphere. An ADS can enable diving at depths of up to 2,300 feet (700 m) for many hours by eliminating the majority of significant physiological dangers associated with deep diving. The occupant of an ADS does not need to decompress, and there is no need for special breathing gas mixtures, so there is little danger of decompression sickness or nitrogen narcosis when the ADS is functioning properly. An ADS can permit less skilled swimmers to complete deep dives, albeit at the expense of dexterity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Umbilical cable</span> A cable and/or hose bundle which supplies required consumables to a remote user

An umbilical cable or umbilical is a cable and/or hose that supplies required consumables to an apparatus, like a rocket, or to a person, such as a diver or astronaut. It is named by analogy with an umbilical cord. An umbilical can, for example, supply air and power to a pressure suit or hydraulic power, electrical power and fiber optics to subsea equipment and divers.

Buddy breathing is a rescue technique used in scuba diving "out-of-gas" emergencies, when two divers share one demand valve, alternately breathing from it. Techniques have been developed for buddy breathing from both twin-hose and single hose regulators, but to a large extent it has been superseded by safer and more reliable techniques using additional equipment, such as the use of a bailout cylinder or breathing through a secondary demand valve on the rescuer's regulator.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Canoe and kayak diving</span> Recreational diving from a canoe or kayak

Canoe diving and Kayak diving are recreational diving where the divers paddle to a diving site in a canoe or kayak carrying all their gear in or on the boat to the place they want to dive. Canoe or kayak diving gives the diver independence from dive boat operators, while allowing dives at sites which are too far to comfortably swim, but are sufficiently sheltered.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Single buoy mooring</span> Offshore mooring buoy with connections for loading or unloading tankers

A Single buoy mooring (SrM) is a loading buoy anchored offshore, that serves as a mooring point and interconnect for tankers loading or offloading gas or liquid products. SPMs are the link between geostatic subsea manifold connections and weathervaning tankers. They are capable of handling any tonnage ship, even very large crude carriers (VLCC) where no alternative facility is available.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diving equipment</span> Equipment used to facilitate underwater diving

Diving equipment, or underwater diving equipment, is equipment used by underwater divers to make diving activities possible, easier, safer and/or more comfortable. This may be equipment primarily intended for this purpose, or equipment intended for other purposes which is found to be suitable for diving use.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Commercial offshore diving</span> Professional diving in support of the oil and gas industry

Commercial offshore diving, sometimes shortened to just offshore diving, generally refers to the branch of commercial diving, with divers working in support of the exploration and production sector of the oil and gas industry in places such as the Gulf of Mexico in the United States, the North Sea in the United Kingdom and Norway, and along the coast of Brazil. The work in this area of the industry includes maintenance of oil platforms and the building of underwater structures. In this context "offshore" implies that the diving work is done outside of national boundaries. Technically it also refers to any diving done in the international offshore waters outside of the territorial waters of a state, where national legislation does not apply. Most commercial offshore diving is in the Exclusive Economic Zone of a state, and much of it is outside the territorial waters. Offshore diving beyond the EEZ does also occur, and is often for scientific purposes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scuba skills</span> The skills required to dive safely using a self-contained underwater breathing apparatus.

Scuba skills are skills required to dive safely using self-contained underwater breathing apparatus, known as a scuba set. Most of these skills are relevant to both open-circuit scuba and rebreather scuba, and many also apply to surface-supplied diving. Some scuba skills, which are critical to divers' safety, may require more practice than standard recreational training provides to achieve reliable competence.

<i>Wildrake</i> diving accident Fatal offshore diving accident in Scotland, 1979

The Wildrake diving accident was an incident in Scotland in August 1979 that killed two American commercial divers. During a routine dive in the East Shetland Basin of the North Sea, the diving bell of the diving support vessel MS Wildrake became separated from its main lift wire at a depth of over 160 metres (520 ft). Although the bell was eventually recovered by Wildrake, its two occupants, 32-year-old Richard Arthur Walker and 28-year-old Victor Francis "Skip" Guiel Jr., died of hypothermia. The accident resulted in extensive subsequent litigation and led to important safety changes in the diving industry.

The Star Canopus diving accident was an incident in Scotland in November 1978 that killed two British commercial divers. During a routine dive beside the Beryl Alpha platform in the North Sea, the diving bell of the diving support vessel MS Star Canopus was lost when its main lift wire, life support umbilical, and guide wires were severed by an anchor chain of the semi-submersible Haakon Magnus. The bell dropped to the seabed at a depth of over 100 metres (330 ft). Its two occupants, 25-year-old Lothar Michael Ward and 28-year-old Gerard Anthony "Tony" Prangley, were unable to release the bell's drop weight in order to return to the surface because it was secured to the bell frame with secondary locking pins. Since there was not a bell stage to keep the bottom door of the bell off the seabed, the divers could not exit the bell to release the pins. Despite the efforts of three rescue vessels – Intersub 4, Tender Carrier, and Uncle John – the bell was not recovered for over thirteen hours, by which time Ward and Prangley had died of hypothermia and drowning.

<i>Stena Seaspread</i> diving accident Saturation diving bell incident with successful rescue in the North Sea in 1981

The Stena Seaspread diving accident occurred on 21 January 1981, when a diving bell containing two divers had its umbilical cord severed. Both divers were rescued.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Outline of underwater diving</span> List of articles related to underwater diving grouped by topical relevance

The following outline is provided as an overview of and topical guide to underwater diving:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Index of underwater diving: N–Z</span> Alphabetical listing of underwater diving related topics

The following index is provided as an overview of and topical guide to underwater diving: Links to articles and redirects to sections of articles which provide information on each topic are listed with a short description of the topic. When there is more than one article with information on a topic, the most relevant is usually listed, and it may be cross-linked to further information from the linked page or section.

Diving procedures are standardised methods of doing things that are commonly useful while diving that are known to work effectively and acceptably safely. Due to the inherent risks of the environment and the necessity to operate the equipment correctly, both under normal conditions and during incidents where failure to respond appropriately and quickly can have fatal consequences, a set of standard procedures are used in preparation of the equipment, preparation to dive, during the dive if all goes according to plan, after the dive, and in the event of a reasonably foreseeable contingency. Standard procedures are not necessarily the only courses of action that produce a satisfactory outcome, but they are generally those procedures that experiment and experience show to work well and reliably in response to given circumstances. All formal diver training is based on the learning of standard skills and procedures, and in many cases the over-learning of the skills until the procedures can be performed without hesitation even when distracting circumstances exist. Where reasonably practicable, checklists may be used to ensure that preparatory and maintenance procedures are carried out in the correct sequence and that no steps are inadvertently omitted.

References

  1. "Two divers die trapped 500ft under the sea". The Herald (Glasgow). August 9, 1979.
  2. "Two dead in diving bell". The Scotsman. August 9, 1979.
  3. "Divers in Bell Rescue". Press and Journal (Scotland). January 22, 1981.
  4. Alexander, Chuck (March 1977). "Thistle A, Single Anchor Leg Mooring Project Assessment": 129.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  5. Alexander 1977 , p. 63
  6. Alexander 1977 , p. 20
  7. Alexander, Chuck (November 1979). "Thistle A, Single Anchor Leg Mooring Repair and Reinstallation": 14.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  8. Alexander 1979 , p. section 1.1.1
  9. Alexander 1979 , p. section 1.1
  10. Alexander 1979 , p. section 2.1
  11. Alexander 1979 , p. 9
  12. Alexander 1979 , p. 16
  13. Alexander 1979 , p. 9