Trachilos footprints

Last updated
Rock slab with the footprints Trachilos Fussspuren 06.jpg
Rock slab with the footprints

The Trachilos footprints are possibly tetrapod footprints which show hominin-like characteristics from the late Miocene on the western Crete, close to the village of Trachilos, west of Kissamos, in the Chania Prefecture. [1] Researchers describe the tracks as representing at least one apparent bipedal [1] hominin or an unknown primate. The stratum in which the footprints were found was dated to about 5.7 million years ago, which predates the previously earliest discovered hominin footprints by about two million years. Later studies show that the footprints might be more than 6 million years old. [2] The researchers of the tracks suggest that it may imply the possibility of hominin evolution outside of Africa, contrary to the current theory. [1]

Contents

Discovery

The tracks were originally discovered by Gerard D. Gierliński, from the Polish Research Institute in Warsaw [3] in 2002. During a visit to Trachilos on Crete, Gierliński found the tracks, and as he was not planning on staying in Trachilos, he recorded the footprints to investigate them in the future. In 2012 Gierliński received permission from the Greek government to research the area, returning to Trachilos with other researchers to explore the tracks in detail. [4] [5] The researchers used methods such as laser scans and 3D imaging of the footprints, and compared them to apes and bears as well as humans. [4] [1]

Dates

The tracks were dated by using the underlying rock bed, predominantly sedimentary, and foraminifera. [1] The study explains, "The coastal rocks at Trachilos[,] lie within the Platanos Basin, and present a succession of shallow marine late Miocene carbonates and siliciclastics[...] At the top, this marine succession terminates abruptly in the coarse-grained terrigenous sedimentary rocks of the Hellenikon Group[.]" [1] The study continues, stating that the sedimentary rocks would have been created around 5.6 million years ago, at the time of the Messinian salinity crisis (mya). [1] The researchers also found evidence of foraminifera, which were dated at 8.5 mya and 3.5 mya. [1] Given the date of the sedimentary rocks and the foraminifera samples, the researches created an approximate interval of 8.5 mya to 5.6 mya. [1] As the rock sediment containing the tracks resembled that of Hellenikon minerals, the tracks were estimated to be 5.7 mya within the given interval. [1]

In 2021, further research was published in regard to dating by Kirscher et al. Cyclostratigraphic data based on magnetic susceptibility indicated that the Trachilos footprints are about 6.05 Ma old, which is 350,000 years older than was found previously. [6] This puts the Trachilos footprints in the same period as the fossils of Orrorin tugenensis from Kenya.

Characteristics

The footprints were measured to range at 94-223 mm (3.7-8.8 inches) long and determined to be oriented in a south-west direction. [1] There are clear pressure indexes, resembling that of a modern Homo sapiens plantigrade structure. [1] The researchers also determined the presence of five digits in the imprints, classifying the track maker as pentadactyl, and lacking claws. [1] As there was no visible evidence of forelimbs from the tracks, the track maker was identified as bipedal. [1] Through 3D printing and laser scanning, there are impressions found which indicate a ball region, a pulling up motion of the foot, a hallux, and small possible gaps between the first and other digit impressions. [1] Poorly preserved prints lack these gaps, however. [1] The lateral digit impressions become progressively smaller so that the digital region as a whole is strongly asymmetrical. [1] The impression of the hallux has a narrow neck and bulbous asymmetrical distal pad, indicating that the tracks were entaxonic. [1] Morphometric analysis showed the footprints to have outlines that are distinct from modern non-hominin primates and resemble those of hominins. [1]

While younger than fossil records of hominins such as Sahelanthropus , found in Chad and dated around seven million years ago, the discovery potentially challenges the generally accepted theory that all early hominins were only present in Africa. [1] The print morphology suggests that the trackmaker could be a basal member of the clade Hominini, but as Crete is some distance outside the known geographical range of pre-Pleistocene hominins, [1] researchers say that there is also a possibility that they represent a hitherto unknown late Miocene primate that convergently evolved human-like foot anatomy. [1]

News and controversy

When Gierliński and his team tried to publish the study, they received harsh criticism due to the findings going against the widely-accepted theory of early hominins evolving in Africa alone. According to the study, the Trachilos footprints may represent an early hominin or primate species that may have evolved hominin-like feet independently, outside of Africa. [1] It also suggests the possibility of convergent evolution, wherein unrelated species adapt similar traits and characteristics to each other. [1] [7] Although convergent evolution is not an implausible explanation of the hominin-like trackways,[ dubious – discuss ], strong evidence is needed to support this interpretation. [1] There were doubts if the tracks were footprints at all. [5] This resulted in rejections from many scientific journals when offered to publish the study's findings.

In an interview at the CBC News, researchers claimed that while they were trying to publish their work about the footprints at high-profile publications they got "ferociously aggressive responses", criticism and rejection from reviewers and editors. According to the researchers, “Basically, it wasn't a true peer review process at all,” “They were just trying to shut us down.” [5] After multiple rejections from other publications, the study was eventually published in the journal, "Proceedings of the Geologists' Association." [5] [1]

Shortly after the research about the footprints was published, eight prints were chiseled out of the rock and stolen. [8] According to the newspaper Proto Thema , the culprit was a high school teacher, who was later arrested by Crete authorities at Kasteli, Chania. [8] [5] The prints were later found in his house and on a farm.

David Begun, a paleoanthropologist at the University of Toronto, Canada, argues that the footprints might not necessarily belong to a human ancestor, despite its appearance. Similarly, Robin Crompton, a biological anthropologist at the University of Liverpool, England, believes that although the footprints belong to a bipedal organism, they might not be human ancestors but “made by a member of the great ape clade”. Multiple fossilized footprints must be found and analyzed in order to accurately categorize the tracks by species. [4] [9]

Meldrum and Sarmiento (2018) who studied the Trachilos prints (ichnites) did not agree with Gierlinski et al. (2017) that these ichnites were made by a primate or even a vertebrate. Principally, Gierlinski et al. did not provide objective criteria for identifying prints as primate prints. The prints show no consistent and repetitive details that could identify them as being made by a primate, or even an animal with bilateral symmetry. Fatally, Gierlinski et al. did not explore alternative agents that could have produced the prints and provided no explanation as to how their analyses of print outlines deals with missing data and comparisons of non-homologous print outlines. Meldrum and Sarmiento concluded that there was insufficient evidence to argue the prints were made by an animal with bilateral symmetry. The Trachilos ichnites could have been made by non-vertebrate lifeforms or could even be the result of non-organic agents. [10]

Willem Jan Zachariasse and Lucas J. Lourens reestimated the footprints as to have originated at the Late Pliocene (3 mya) and question if hominids had created the footprints or if they were footprints. They argue that the shallow marine setting could not have been travelled across by hominins or bipedal primates but "in case they did, wave action must have erased them unless the tracks were made at the high tide line during a low sea level stand at the climax of one of the glacial periods that occurred every 41 kyr in this time span". Further, they state "Crete was an island since the Late Tortonian but the present outline and geographic setting dates from the Late Pliocene with the deep Levantine Basin to the south and the marine South Aegean Basin (SAB) to the north. The latter basin formed in the Late Miocene by slab roll-back driven extension of the Aegean lithosphere and was ~ 1000 m deep north of Crete (DSDP Site 378) during the Late Pliocene. The Late Pliocene SAB separated Crete from mainland Greece and Turkey by stretches of deep water of minimally 100 km wide according to the time–space reconstructions of the Aegean lithosphere in Van Hinsbergen and Schmid. Occurrences of deep marine Late Pliocene sediments on the islands of Kythira in between Crete and the Peloponnese, and Karpathos in between Crete and Turkey prove that these islands could not have been used as steppingstones for biped dispersal, let alone that they have been part of land bridges". [11]

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>Ardipithecus</i> Extinct genus of hominins

Ardipithecus is a genus of an extinct hominine that lived during the Late Miocene and Early Pliocene epochs in the Afar Depression, Ethiopia. Originally described as one of the earliest ancestors of humans after they diverged from the chimpanzees, the relation of this genus to human ancestors and whether it is a hominin is now a matter of debate. Two fossil species are described in the literature: A. ramidus, which lived about 4.4 million years ago during the early Pliocene, and A. kadabba, dated to approximately 5.6 million years ago. Initial behavioral analysis indicated that Ardipithecus could be very similar to chimpanzees, however more recent analysis based on canine size and lack of canine sexual dimorphism indicates that Ardipithecus was characterised by reduced aggression, and that they more closely resemble bonobos.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bipedalism</span> Terrestrial locomotion using two limbs

Bipedalism is a form of terrestrial locomotion where a tetrapod moves by means of its two rear limbs or legs. An animal or machine that usually moves in a bipedal manner is known as a biped, meaning 'two feet'. Types of bipedal movement include walking or running and hopping.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Neogene</span> Second geologic period in the Cenozoic Era 23–2.6 million years ago

The Neogene is a geologic period and system that spans 20.45 million years from the end of the Paleogene Period 23.03 million years ago (Mya) to the beginning of the present Quaternary Period 2.58 million years ago. The Neogene is sub-divided into two epochs, the earlier Miocene and the later Pliocene. Some geologists assert that the Neogene cannot be clearly delineated from the modern geological period, the Quaternary. The term "Neogene" was coined in 1853 by the Austrian palaeontologist Moritz Hörnes (1815–1868). The earlier term Tertiary Period was used to define the span of time now covered by Paleogene and Neogene and, despite no longer being recognized as a formal stratigraphic term, "Tertiary" still sometimes remains in informal use.

<i>Orrorin</i> Postulated early hominin discovered in Kenya

Orrorin is an extinct genus of primate within Homininae from the Miocene Lukeino Formation and Pliocene Mabaget Formation, both of Kenya.

The Pliocene is the epoch in the geologic time scale that extends from 5.333 million to 2.58 million years ago. It is the second and most recent epoch of the Neogene Period in the Cenozoic Era. The Pliocene follows the Miocene Epoch and is followed by the Pleistocene Epoch. Prior to the 2009 revision of the geologic time scale, which placed the four most recent major glaciations entirely within the Pleistocene, the Pliocene also included the Gelasian Stage, which lasted from 2.588 to 1.806 million years ago, and is now included in the Pleistocene.

<i>Australopithecus</i> Genus of hominin ancestral to modern humans

Australopithecus is a genus of early hominins that existed in Africa during the Pliocene and Early Pleistocene. The genera Homo, Paranthropus, and Kenyanthropus evolved from some Australopithecus species. Australopithecus is a member of the subtribe Australopithecina, which sometimes also includes Ardipithecus, though the term "australopithecine" is sometimes used to refer only to members of Australopithecus. Species include A. garhi, A. africanus, A. sediba, A. afarensis, A. anamensis, A. bahrelghazali and A. deyiremeda. Debate exists as to whether some Australopithecus species should be reclassified into new genera, or if Paranthropus and Kenyanthropus are synonymous with Australopithecus, in part because of the taxonomic inconsistency.

<i>Australopithecus afarensis</i> Extinct hominid from the Pliocene of East Africa

Australopithecus afarensis is an extinct species of australopithecine which lived from about 3.9–2.9 million years ago (mya) in the Pliocene of East Africa. The first fossils were discovered in the 1930s, but major fossil finds would not take place until the 1970s. From 1972 to 1977, the International Afar Research Expedition—led by anthropologists Maurice Taieb, Donald Johanson and Yves Coppens—unearthed several hundreds of hominin specimens in Hadar, Ethiopia, the most significant being the exceedingly well-preserved skeleton AL 288-1 ("Lucy") and the site AL 333. Beginning in 1974, Mary Leakey led an expedition into Laetoli, Tanzania, and notably recovered fossil trackways. In 1978, the species was first described, but this was followed by arguments for splitting the wealth of specimens into different species given the wide range of variation which had been attributed to sexual dimorphism. A. afarensis probably descended from A. anamensis and is hypothesised to have given rise to Homo, though the latter is debated.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Laetoli</span> National Historic Site of Tanzania

Laetoli is a pre-historic site located in Enduleni ward of Ngorongoro District in Arusha Region, Tanzania. The site is dated to the Plio-Pleistocene and famous for its Hominina footprints, preserved in volcanic ash. The site of the Laetoli footprints is located 45 km south of Olduvai gorge. The location and tracks were discovered by archaeologist Mary Leakey and her team in 1976, and were excavated by 1978. Based on analysis of the footfall impressions "The Laetoli Footprints" provided convincing evidence for the theory of bipedalism in Pliocene Hominina and received significant recognition by scientists and the public. Since 1998, paleontological expeditions have continued under the leadership of Amandus Kwekason of the National Museum of Tanzania and Terry Harrison of New York University, leading to the recovery of more than a dozen new Hominina finds, as well as a comprehensive reconstruction of the paleoecology. The site is a registered National Historic Sites of Tanzania.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hominini</span> Tribe of mammals

The Hominini form a taxonomic tribe of the subfamily Homininae ("hominines"). Hominini includes the extant genera Homo (humans) and Pan and in standard usage excludes the genus Gorilla (gorillas).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Middle Awash</span> UNESCO World Heritage Site in Ethiopia

The Middle Awash is a paleoanthropological research area in the northwest corner of Gabi Rasu in the Afar Region along the Awash River in Ethiopia's Afar Depression. It is a unique natural laboratory for the study of human origins and evolution and a number of fossils of the earliest hominins, particularly of the Australopithecines, as well as some of the oldest known Olduwan stone artifacts, have been found at the site—all of late Miocene, the Pliocene, and the very early Pleistocene times, that is, about 5.6 million years ago (mya) to 2.5 mya. It is broadly thought that the divergence of the lines of the earliest humans (hominins) and of chimpanzees (hominids) was completed near the beginning of that time range, or sometime between seven and five mya. However, the larger community of scientists provide several estimates for periods of divergence that imply a greater range for this event, see CHLCA: human-chimpanzee split.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fossil track</span> Fossilized footprint (ichnite)

A fossil track or ichnite is a fossilized footprint. This is a type of trace fossil. A fossil trackway is a sequence of fossil tracks left by a single organism. Over the years, many ichnites have been found, around the world, giving important clues about the behaviour of the animals that made them. For instance, multiple ichnites of a single species, close together, suggest 'herd' or 'pack' behaviour of that species.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Footprint</span> Impressions or images left behind by a person walking or running

Footprints are the impressions or images left behind by a person walking or running. Hoofprints and pawprints are those left by animals with hooves or paws rather than feet, while "shoeprints" is the specific term for prints made by shoes. They may either be indentations in the ground or something placed onto the surface that was stuck to the bottom of the foot. A "trackway" is a set of footprints in soft earth left by a life-form; animal tracks are the footprints, hoofprints, or pawprints of an animal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bird ichnology</span>

Bird ichnology is the study of avian life traces in ornithology and paleontology. Such life traces can include footprints, nests, feces and coproliths. Scientists gain insight about the behavior and diversity of birds by studying such evidence.

<i>Ardipithecus ramidus</i> Extinct hominin from Early Pliocene Ethiopia

Ardipithecus ramidus is a species of australopithecine from the Afar region of Early Pliocene Ethiopia 4.4 million years ago (mya). A. ramidus, unlike modern hominids, has adaptations for both walking on two legs (bipedality) and life in the trees (arboreality). However, it would not have been as efficient at bipedality as humans, nor at arboreality as non-human great apes. Its discovery, along with Miocene apes, has reworked academic understanding of the chimpanzee–human last common ancestor from appearing much like modern-day chimpanzees, orangutans and gorillas to being a creature without a modern anatomical cognate.

Ileret is a village in Marsabit County, Kenya. It is located in Northern Kenya, on the eastern shore of Lake Turkana, north of Sibiloi National Park and near the Ethiopian border.

The chimpanzee–human last common ancestor (CHLCA) is the last common ancestor shared by the extant Homo (human) and Pan genera of Hominini. Estimates of the divergence date vary widely from thirteen to five million years ago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kay Behrensmeyer</span> American taphonomist and paleoecologist

Anna Katherine "Kay" Behrensmeyer is an American taphonomist and paleoecologist. She is a pioneer in the study of the fossil records of terrestrial ecosystems and engages in geological and paleontological field research into the ecological context of human evolution in East Africa. She is Curator of Vertebrate Paleontology in the Department of Paleobiology at the Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of Natural History (NMNH). At the museum, she is co-director of the Evolution of Terrestrial Ecosystems program and an associate of the Human Origins Program.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Early expansions of hominins out of Africa</span> First hominin expansion into Eurasia (2.1–0.1 Ma)

Several expansions of populations of archaic humans out of Africa and throughout Eurasia took place in the course of the Lower Paleolithic, and into the beginning Middle Paleolithic, between about 2.1 million and 0.2 million years ago (Ma). These expansions are collectively known as Out of Africa I, in contrast to the expansion of Homo sapiens (anatomically modern humans) into Eurasia, which may have begun shortly after 0.2 million years ago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kanapoi</span>

Kanapoi is a paleontological site in the Kenyan Rift Valley, to the southwest of Lake Turkana. Fossils were first found at Kanapoi in the 1960s by a Harvard expedition, and later by expeditions from the National Museums of Kenya.

Miocallicebus is an extinct genus of New World monkeys from the Middle Miocene. Its remains have been found at the Konzentrat-Lagerstätte of La Venta in the Honda Group of Colombia. The type species is Miocallicebus villaviejai.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Gierliński, Gerard D.; Niedźwiedzki, Grzegorz; Lockley, Martin G.; Athanassiou, Athanassios; Fassoulas, Charalampos; Dubicka, Zofia; Boczarowski, Andrzej; Bennett, Matthew R.; Ahlberg, Per Erik (2017-10-01). "Possible hominin footprints from the late Miocene (c. 5.7 Ma) of Crete?". Proceedings of the Geologists' Association. 128 (5): 697–710. Bibcode:2017PrGA..128..697G. doi: 10.1016/j.pgeola.2017.07.006 . hdl: 20.500.12128/3647 . ISSN   0016-7878.
  2. ↑ Kirscher, Uwe; El Atfy, Haytham; Gärtner, Andreas; Dallanave, Edoardo; Munz, Philipp; Niedźwiedzki, Grzegorz; Athanassiou, Athanassios; Fassoulas, Charalampos; Linnemann, Ulf; Hofmann, Mandy; Bennett, Matthew (2021-10-11). "Age constraints for the Trachilos footprints from Crete". Scientific Reports . 11 (1): 19427. Bibcode:2021NatSR..1119427K. doi: 10.1038/s41598-021-98618-0 . ISSN   2045-2322. PMC   8505496 . PMID   34635686. S2CID   238637829.
  3. ↑ “Footprints Hint That Humans Are from Europe.” New Scientist , vol. 235, no. 3142, 2017, p. 9., doi : 10.1016/S0262-4079(17)31747-5.
  4. 1 2 3 Caperton Morton, Mary (December 11, 2017). "Mysterious Miocene bipedal footprints found in Crete". Earth Magazine .
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Chung, Emily (February 23, 2018). "One Hell of an Impression". CBC News.
  6. ↑ Kirscher, U., El Atfy, H., Gärtner, A. et al., Age constraints for the Trachilos footprints from Crete. Sci Rep 11, 19427 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-98618-0
  7. ↑ Kirk, John Thomas Osmond (2007). Science & Certainty. Csiro Publishing. pp. pg. 79. ISBN   978-0-643-09391-1.
  8. 1 2 "Local High School Teacher Arrested for Fossil Footprints Theft in Crete". themanews.com.
  9. ↑ "Evolution: Ancient Footprint in Crete Raises Questions". Newsweek. 2017-09-01. Retrieved 2022-10-14.
  10. ↑ Meldrum, Jeff; Sarmiento, Esteban (2018-08-01). "Comments on possible Miocene hominin footprints". Proceedings of the Geologists' Association. 129 (4): 577–580. Bibcode:2018PrGA..129..577M. doi:10.1016/j.pgeola.2018.05.006. ISSN   0016-7878. S2CID   134963777.
  11. ↑ Zachariasse, Willem Jan; Lourens, Lucas J. (2022-11-02). "About the age and depositional depth of the sediments with reported bipedal footprints at Trachilos (NW Crete, Greece)". Scientific Reports. 12 (1): 18471. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-23296-5 . ISSN   2045-2322. PMC   9630425 . PMID   36323766.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.