| Year | Champion | Margin of
victory | Runner-up | Tournament location | Notes |
|---|
| 2025 | Christian Brand (4) | 2 | Ryan Bilby
Kenny Hess | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | |
| 2024 | Todd Duncan (a) | 1 | Will Evans | Edgewood Country Club, Sissonville | |
| 2023 | Ryan Bilby (a) | 2 | Mason Williams | Berry Hills Country Club, Charleston | |
| 2022 | Christian Brand (3) | 3 | David Bradshaw | Stonewall Jackson Resort, Roanoke | |
| 2021 | David Bradshaw (12) | 3 | Mason Williams | Pete Dye Golf Club, Bridgeport | |
| 2020 | Kenneth Hess | 1 | Thaddeus Obecny II | The Resort at Glade Springs, Daniels | |
| 2019 | David Bradshaw (11) | 8 | Josef Dransfeld | Parkersburg Country Club, Parkersburg | |
| 2018 | David Bradshaw (10) | 6 | Will Evans | The Resort at Glade Springs, Daniels | |
| 2017 | David Bradshaw (9) | 3 | Davey Jude | Edgewood Country Club, Sissonville | |
| 2016 | David Bradshaw (8) | 4 | Tad Tomblin (a) | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | |
| 2015 | Christian Brand (2) | — | David Bradshaw | Berry Hills Country Club, Charleston | Brand won a three-hole playoff. |
| 2014 | Christian Brand | 3 | David Bradshaw | The Resort at Glade Springs, Daniels | |
| 2013 | David Bradshaw (7) | 4 | Sam O'Dell (a) | Parkersburg Country Club, Parkersburg | |
| 2012 | Jonathan Clark (2) | 6 | David Bradshaw
Christian Brand | Edgewood Country Club, Sissonville | |
| 2011 | David Bradshaw (6) | — | Bob Friend | Pines Country Club, Morgantown | Bradshaw won a three-hole playoff. |
| 2010 | David Bradshaw (5) | 1 | Tim Fisher (a) | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | |
| 2009 | David Bradshaw (4) | — | John Ross | Oglebay Park, Wheeling | Bradshaw won a three-hole playoff. |
| 2008 | Barry Evans | 3 | David Bradshaw | Berry Hills Country Club, Charleston | |
| 2007 | David Bradshaw (3) | 1 | Three players | Lakeview Country Club, Morgantown | |
| 2006 | David Bradshaw (2) | 1 | Three players | The Resort at Glade Springs, Daniels | |
| 2005 | Craig Berner | — | Barry Evans | The Raven Golf Club, Snowshoe | Berner won a three-hole playoff. |
| 2004 | David Bradshaw (a) | 1 | Jonathan Clark | Edgewood Country Club, Sissonville | |
| 2003 | Brad Westfall (5) | — | Pat Carter (a) | Pines Country Club, Morgantown | Westfall won a three-hole playoff. |
| 2002 | Brad Westfall (4) | 3 | Sam O'Dell (a) | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | |
| 2001 | Jonathan Clark | 1 | Brad Westfall | Berry Hills Country Club, Charleston | |
| 2000 | Brad Westfall (3) | 4 | Steve Shrawder | Pete Dye Golf Club, Bridgeport | |
| 1999 | John Ross (2) | 7 | Jonathan Clark | Guyan Golf and Country Club, Huntington | |
| 1998 | Scott Davis (4) | 5 | John Ross | Edgewood Country Club, Sissonville | |
| 1997 | John Ross | 3 | Gary Blake
Scott Davis | The Resort at Glade Springs, Daniels | |
| 1996 | Barney Thompson (3) | — | John Ross | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | Thompson won on the first playoff hole. |
| 1995 | Scott Davis (3) | 5 | Greg Meade | Canaan Valley Resort State Park, Canaan Valley | |
| 1994 | Brad Westfall (2) | — | Scott Davis | Oglebay Park, Wheeling | Westfall won on the first playoff hole. The first round was rained out. |
| 1993 | Harold Payne (a) (4) | 2 | Brad Westfall | Pipestem Resort State Park, Summers County | |
| 1992 | Brad Westfall | 8 | Eric Shaffer (a) | Pines Country Club, Morgantown | |
| 1991 | Mike White (2) | 1 | Bob Bird | Moundsville Country Club, Moundsville | |
| 1990 | Scott Davis (2) | 1 | Mike White | Bridgeport Country Club, Bridgeport | |
| 1989 | Todd Satterfield (a) | — | Mike White | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | Satterfield won on the first playoff hole. |
| 1988 | Harold Payne (a) (3) | 3 | Ned Weaver | Williams Country Club, Weirton | |
| 1987 | Harold Payne (a) (2) | 8 | Cleve Coldwater | The Resort at Glade Springs, Daniels | |
| 1986 | Harold Payne (a) | 2 | Scott Davis
Ed Vietmeier | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | |
| 1985 | Buddy Cook | 3 | Four players | Guyan Golf and Country Club, Huntington | |
| 1984 | Linden Meade (2) | 1 | Ken Lacy | Fincastle Country Club, Bluefield, Virginia | |
| 1983 | Jim Fankhauser (a) | 3 | John Ross | Parkersburg Country Club, Parkersburg | |
| 1982 | Scott Davis | 2 | Linden Meade | Wheeling Country Club, Wheeling | |
| 1981 | Matt Cooke (a) | 8 | Benny Bowles | Berry Hills Country Club, Charleston | |
| 1980 | Mike White | 4 | Barry Fleming
Darrell Kestner | Fincastle Country Club, Bluefield, Virginia | |
| 1979 | Benny Bowles | 1 | William C. Campbell (a) | Williams Country Club, Weirton | |
| 1978 | Barney Thompson (2) | 9 | Jim Jamieson | The Greenbrier, White Sulphur Springs | |
| 1977 | Barry Fleming | 2 | Mark Wheaton
Randy Hillis (a) | Canaan Valley Resort State Park, Canaan Valley | |
| 1976 | Terry Smith | 4 | Doug Ray | Preston Country Club, Kingwood | |
| 1975 | Barney Thompson | 2 | Terry Smith | Canaan Valley Resort State Park, Canaan Valley | |
| 1974 | Blake Watt (a) | 2 | Jerry Walker | Moundsville Country Club, Moundsville | |
| 1973 | Sam Snead (17) | 8 | Scott Bess | Bridgeport Country Club, Bridgeport | |
| 1972 | Sam Snead (16) | 2 | Barney Thompson | South Hills Golf Club, Parkersburg | |
| 1971 | Sam Snead (15) | 1 | Billy Capps | Bel Meadow Golf Club, Mount Clare | The first round was rained out. |
| 1970 | Sam Snead (14) | 12 | Joe Taylor | Sandy Brae Golf Club, Amma | |
| 1969 | Joe Taylor (3) | 1 | Horace Ervin | Meadowbrook Recreation Club, Charleston | |
| 1968 | Sam Snead (13) | 5 | Billy Capps | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | The first and final rounds were rained out. |
| 1967 | Sam Snead (12) | — | Roy Shreves | Moundsville Country Club, Moundsville | Snead won on the third playoff hole. |
| 1966 | Sam Snead (11) | 10 | Tom Cassady | South Hills Golf Club, Parkersburg | |
| 1965 | Joe Taylor (2) | 10 | George Hoffer | Lakeview Country Club, Morgantown | |
| 1964 | George Hoffer (2) | 8 | Joe Taylor | Par Mar Pines, Parkersburg | |
| 1963 | Linden Meade | 1 | Don Stickney | Kanawha Country Club, South Charleston | |
| 1962 | Ed Tutwiler (a) (3) | 1 | Joe Taylor | Sleepy Hollow Golf Club, Hurricane | |
| 1961 | Sam Snead (10) | 5 | Al Atkins | Riviera Country Club, Lesage | |
| 1960 | Sam Snead (9) | 1 | Art Wall Jr. | Spring Valley Country Club, Huntington | |
| 1959 | No tournament |
| 1958 | Sam Snead (8) | 14 | William C. Campbell (a) | Lakeview Country Club, Morgantown | The final round were rained out. |
| 1957 | Sam Snead (7) | 22 | Mike Krak | Berry Hills Country Club, Charleston | |
| 1956 | Ed Tutwiler (a) (2) | 7 | Joe Taylor | The Greenbrier, White Sulphur Springs | |
| 1955 | William C. Campbell (a) (3) | 5 | Ed Tutwiler (a) | Guyan Country Club, Huntington | |
| 1954 | Joe Taylor | 10 | Ed Tutwiler (a) | Williams Country Club, Weirton | |
| 1953 | William C. Campbell (a) (2) | 4 | Sam Snead | Parkersburg Country Club, Parkersburg | |
| 1952 | Sam Snead (6) | 9 | Ed Tutwiler (a) | The Greenbrier, White Sulphur Springs | |
| 1951 | Ed Tutwiler (a) | 6 | Ray Vaughan, Jr. | White Oak Country Club, Oak Hill | |
| 1950 | William C. Campbell (a) | 13 | Larry Wiechman | Parkersburg Country Club, Parkersburg | |
| 1949 | Sam Snead (5) | 18 | George Hoffer | Spring Valley Country Club, Huntington | |
| 1948 | Sam Snead (4) | 10 | George Hoffer | Wheeling Country Club, Wheeling | |
| 1947 | George Hoffer | 1 | Rut Coffey | The Greenbrier, White Sulphur Springs | |
| 1946 | Rut Coffey | 10 | Roy Blizzard (a) | Moundsville Country Club, Moundsville | |
| 1945 | Arnold Browning | 2 | Jules Blanton | Greenbrier Valley Country Club, Lewisburg | First round abandoned due to hailstorm. |
| 1944 | Joe Reposkey | 1 | Andy Brawley (a) | Preston Country Club, Kingwood | |
| 1943 | Clem Wiechman (4) | 2 | D. G. Rangeley (a) | Black Knight Country Club, Beckley | |
| 1942 | Clem Wiechman (3) | 1 | Ray Vaughan, Jr. | Meadowbrook Recreation Club, Charleston | |
| 1941 | Clem Wiechman (2) | 3 | Johnny Javins | The Greenbrier, White Sulphur Springs | |
| 1940 | Bill Swing | 2 | Arnold Browning | Guyan Country Club, Huntington | |
| 1939 | Clem Wiechman | 4 | Earl Tolley | Bluefield Country Club, Bluefield | |
| 1938 | Sam Snead (3) | 11 | Art Clark | Cedar Rocks, Elm Grove | |
| 1937 | Sam Snead (2) | 12 | Art Clark | Kanawha Country Club, Charleston | |
| 1936 | Sam Snead | 5 | Art Clark | Guyan Country Club, Huntington | The tournament was reduced to three rounds, due to the second round being rained out. |
| 1935 | Rader Jewett (2) | 2 | Horace Brand | Clarksburg Country Club, Clarksburg | |
| 1934 | Rader Jewett | 11 | Bobby Rownd (a) | Cedar Rocks, Elm Grove | |
| 1933 | Johnny Javins | — | I.C. Schorr | Kanawha Country Club, South Charleston | Javins and Schorr tied, with both men splitting the prize money and Javins taking the trophy. |
