Schlieren photography

A schlieren photograph showing the compression in front of an unswept wing at Mach 1.2

Schlieren image of a shotshell projectile exiting a barrel

Schlieren photography is a process for photographing fluid flow. Invented by the German physicist August Toepler in 1864 to study supersonic motion, it is widely used in aeronautical engineering to photograph the flow of air around objects.

The process works by allowing normally unobservable changes in a fluid's refractive index to be seen, ^[1] and is accomplished by viewing the deflections that occur when light is refracted by a moving fluid. Because changes to flow rate directly impact the refractive index of a fluid, one can therefore photograph a fluid's flow rate (as well as other changes to density, temperature, and pressure) by viewing changes to it's refractive index. ^[2]

Using the Schlieren photography process, other unobservable fluid changes can also be seen, such as convection currents, and the standing waves used in acoustic levitation. ^[1]

Classical optical system

The classical implementation of an optical schlieren system uses light from a single collimated source shining on, or from behind, a target object. Variations in refractive index caused by density gradients in the fluid distort the collimated light beam. This distortion creates a spatial variation in the intensity of the light, which can be visualised directly with a shadowgraph system.

Optical layout of a single-mirror schlieren system.

Classical schlieren imaging systems appear in two configurations, using either one or two mirrors. In each case, a transparent object is illuminated with collimated or nearly-collimated light. Rays that are not deflected by the object proceed to their focal point, where they are blocked by a knife edge. Rays that are deflected by the object, have a chance of passing the knife edge without being blocked. As a result, one can place a camera after the knife edge such that the image of the object will exhibit intensity variations due to the deflections of the rays. The result is a set of lighter and darker patches corresponding to positive and negative fluid density gradients in the direction normal to the knife edge. When a knife edge is used, the system is generally referred to as a schlieren system, which measures the first derivative of density in the direction of the knife edge. If a knife edge is not used, the system is generally referred to as a shadowgraph system, which measures the second derivative of density.

In the two-mirror schlieren system (sometimes called the Z-configuration), the source is collimated by the first mirror, the collimated light traverses the object and then is focused by the second mirror. This generally allows higher resolution imaging (seeing finer details in the object) than is possible using the single-mirror configuration.

• Schlieren system designs
• 
  Optical layout of a two-mirror schlieren system, showing only the undeviated rays.
• 
  Optical layout of a two-mirror schlieren system, showing the deviated rays imaged at the camera's detector.

If the fluid flow is uniform, the image will be steady, but any turbulence will cause scintillation, the shimmering effect that can be seen over heated surfaces on a hot day. To visualise instantaneous density profiles, a short-duration flash (rather than continuous illumination) may be used.

Focusing schlieren optical system

In the mid 20th century, R. A. Burton developed an alternative form of schlieren photography, which is now usually called focusing schlieren or lens-and-grid schlieren, ^[3] based on a suggestion by Hubert Schardin. ^[4] Focusing schlieren systems generally retain the characteristic knife edge to produce contrast, but instead of using collimated light and a single knife edge, they use an illumination pattern of repeated edges with a focusing imaging system.

Basic diagram of a focusing schlieren system

The basic idea is that the illumination pattern is imaged onto a geometrically congruent cutoff pattern (essentially a multiplicity of knife edges) with focusing optics, while density gradients lying between the illumination pattern and the cutoff pattern are imaged, typically by a camera system. Like in classical schlieren, the distortions produce regions of brightening or darkening corresponding to the position and direction of the distortion, because they redirect rays either away from or onto the opaque part of the cutoff pattern. While in classical schlieren, distortions over the whole beam path are visualized equally, in focusing schlieren, only distortions in the object field of the camera are clearly imaged. Distortions away from the object field become blurred, so this technique allows some degree of depth selection. It also has the advantage that a wide variety of illuminated backgrounds can be used, since collimation is not required. This allows construction of projection-based focusing schlieren systems, which are much easier to build and align than classical schlieren systems. The requirement of collimated light in classical schlieren is often a substantial practical barrier for constructing large systems due to the need for the collimating optic to be the same size as the field of view. Focusing schlieren systems can use compact optics with a large background illumination pattern, which is particularly easy to produce with a projection system. For systems with large demagnification, the illumination pattern needs to be around twice larger than the field of view to allow defocusing of the background pattern. ^{[5] [6]}

Background-oriented techniques

Shock waves produced by a T-38 Talon during flight using analog background-oriented schlieren

Background-oriented schlieren technique relies on measuring or visualizing shifts in focused images. In these techniques, the background and the schlieren object (the distortion to be visualized) are both in focus and the distortion is detected because it moves part of the background image relative to its original position. Because of this focus requirement, they tend to be used for large-scale applications where both the schlieren object and the background are distant (typically beyond the hyperfocal distance of the optical system). Since these systems require no additional optics aside from a camera, they are often the simplest to construct but they are usually not as sensitive as other types of schlieren systems, with the sensitivity being limited by the camera resolution. The technique also requires a suitable background image. In some cases, the background may be provided by the experimenter, such as a random speckle pattern or sharp line, but naturally occurring features such as landscapes or bright light sources such as the sun and moon can also be used. ^[7] Background-oriented schlieren is most often performed using software techniques such as digital image correlation and optical flow analysis to perform synthetic schlieren, but it is possible to achieve the same effect in streak imaging with an analog optical system.

Variations and applications

Colour schlieren image of the thermal plume from a burning candle, disturbed by a breeze from the right

Schlieren image showing the thermal convection plume rising from an ordinary candle in still air. This photograph clearly shows the transition from laminar to turbulent flow.

Variations on the optical schlieren method include the replacement of the knife-edge by a coloured target, resulting in rainbow schlieren which can assist in visualising the flow. Different edge configurations such as concentric rings can also give sensitivity to variable gradient directions, and programmable digital edge generation has been demonstrated as well using digital displays and modulators. The adaptive optics pyramid wavefront sensor is a modified form of schlieren (having two perpendicular knife edges formed by the vertices of a refracting square pyramid).

Complete schlieren optical systems can be built from components, or bought as commercially available instruments. Details of theory and operation are given in Settles' 2001 book. ^[8] The USSR once produced a number of sophisticated schlieren systems based on the Maksutov telescope principle, many of which still survive in the former Soviet Union and China.^{[ citation needed ]}

Schlieren photography is used to visualise the flows of the media, which are themselves transparent (hence, their movement cannot be seen directly), but form refractive index gradients, which become visible in schlieren images either as shades of grey or even in colour. Refractive index gradients can be caused either by changes of temperature/pressure of the same fluid or by the variations of the concentration of components in mixtures and solutions. A typical application in gas dynamics is the study of shock waves in ballistics and supersonic or hypersonic vehicles. Flows caused by heating, physical absorption ^[9] or chemical reactions can be visualised. Thus schlieren photography can be used in many engineering problems such as heat transfer, leak detection, study of boundary layer detachment, and characterization of optics.

See also

• Laser schlieren deflectometry
• Mach–Zehnder interferometer
• Moire deflectometry
• Schlieren
• Schlieren imaging
• Shadowgraph

References

1. Harvard Natural Sciences Lecture Demonstrations.
2. RolfeFollow 2015.
3. Burton, Ralph A. (1949-11-01). "A Modified Schlieren Apparatus for Large Areas of Field". Journal of the Optical Society of America. The Optical Society. 39 (11): 907. doi:10.1364/josa.39.000907. ISSN   0030-3941. PMID   15393811.
4. Schardin, Hubert (1942). "Die Schlierenverfahren und ihre Anwendungen". Ergebnisse der Exakten Naturwissenschaften. Vol. 20. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg. pp. 303–439. doi:10.1007/bfb0111981. ISBN   978-3-540-77206-4.
5. Goulding, J. S. (2006). A Study of Large-Scale Focusing Schlieren Systems (Masters Thesis). University of Witwatersrand.
6. Weinstein, L.M. (2010). "Review and update of lens and grid schlieren and motion camera schlieren". The European Physical Journal Special Topics. Springer Science and Business Media LLC. 182 (1): 65–95. doi:10.1140/epjst/e2010-01226-y. ISSN   1951-6355. S2CID   120530340.
7. Kamlet, Matt (2016-04-13). "Photographic Shockwave Research Reaches New Heights with BOSCO Flights". NASA Website. Retrieved 2016-05-05.
8. Settles, G. S. (2001). Schlieren and shadowgraph techniques: Visualizing phenomena in transparent media. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-56640-0. ISBN   978-3-642-63034-7. S2CID   135790075.
9. Okhotsimskii, Andrei; Hozawa, Mitsunori (1998). "Schlieren visualization of natural convection in binary gas–liquid systems". Chemical Engineering Science. Elsevier BV. 53 (14): 2547–2573. doi:10.1016/s0009-2509(98)00092-x. ISSN   0009-2509.

External links

• Grady, Denise (2008-10-28). "The Mysterious Cough, Caught on Film". The New York Times . p. D3. Retrieved 2008-10-28.
• "Schlieren Photography – How Does It Work?". ian.org. 2010-01-22. Retrieved 2020-04-04.
• "High-speed Ballistics Imaging: A Guest Blog from Nathan Boor of Aimed Research". mousegunaddict.blogspot.com. 2013-06-10. Retrieved 2020-04-04.
• Buckner, Benjamin D.; L’Esperance, Drew (2013). "Digital synchroballistic schlieren camera for high-speed photography of bullets and rocket sleds". Optical Engineering. 52 (8): 083105. doi:10.1117/1.OE.52.8.083105. ISSN   0091-3286.
• Archived at Ghostarchive and the Wayback Machine : "Schlieren Optical System & Aerodynamic Tests 1958 Shell Oil Co. Educational Film XD13174". PeriscopeFilm. 2020-04-03 – via YouTube.
• "Schlieren Optics". Harvard Natural Sciences Lecture Demonstrations. Retrieved 2024-02-03.
• RolfeFollow, Bryan (2015-11-25). "Schlieren Imaging: How to See Air Flow!". Instructables. Retrieved 2024-02-03.