Holography

Last updated

Two photographs of a single hologram taken from different viewpoints Holomouse2.jpg
Two photographs of a single hologram taken from different viewpoints

Holography is a technique that enables a wavefront to be recorded and later reconstructed. It is best known as a method of generating three-dimensional images, and has a wide range of other uses, including data storage, microscopy, and interferometry. In principle, it is possible to make a hologram for any type of wave.

Contents

A hologram is a recording of an interference pattern that can reproduce a 3D light field using diffraction. In general usage, a hologram is a recording of any type of wavefront in the form of an interference pattern. It can be created by capturing light from a real scene, or it can be generated by a computer, in which case it is known as a computer-generated hologram, which can show virtual objects or scenes. Optical holography needs a laser light to record the light field. The reproduced light field can generate an image that has the depth and parallax of the original scene. [1] A hologram is usually unintelligible when viewed under diffuse ambient light. When suitably lit, the interference pattern diffracts the light into an accurate reproduction of the original light field, and the objects that were in it exhibit visual depth cues such as parallax and perspective that change realistically with the different angles of viewing. That is, the view of the image from different angles shows the subject viewed from similar angles.

A hologram is traditionally generated by overlaying a second wavefront, known as the reference beam, onto a wavefront of interest. This generates an interference pattern, which is then captured on a physical medium. When the recorded interference pattern is later illuminated by the second wavefront, it is diffracted to recreate the original wavefront. [2] The 3D image from a hologram can often be viewed with non-laser light. However, in common practice, major image quality compromises are made to remove the need for laser illumination to view the hologram.

A computer-generated hologram is created by digitally modeling and combining two wavefronts to generate an interference pattern image. This image can then be printed onto a mask or film and illuminated with an appropriate light source to reconstruct the desired wavefront. [2] Alternatively, the interference pattern image can be directly displayed on a dynamic holographic display. [3]

Holographic portraiture often resorts to a non-holographic intermediate imaging procedure, to avoid the dangerous high-powered pulsed lasers which would be needed to optically "freeze" moving subjects as perfectly as the extremely motion-intolerant holographic recording process requires. Early holography required high-power and expensive lasers. Currently, mass-produced low-cost laser diodes, such as those found on DVD recorders and used in other common applications, can be used to make holograms. They have made holography much more accessible to low-budget researchers, artists, and dedicated hobbyists.

Most holograms produced are of static objects, but systems for displaying changing scenes on dynamic holographic displays are now being developed. [4] [5]

The word holography comes from the Greek words ὅλος (holos; "whole") and γραφή ( graphē ; "writing" or "drawing").

History

Introduction to Holography (1972 educational film)

The Hungarian-British physicist Dennis Gabor invented holography in 1948 while he was looking for a way to improve image resolution in electron microscopes. [6] [7] [8] Gabor's work was built on pioneering work in the field of X-ray microscopy by other scientists including Mieczysław Wolfke in 1920 and William Lawrence Bragg in 1939. [9] The formulation of holography was an unexpected result of Gabor's research into improving electron microscopes at the British Thomson-Houston Company (BTH) in Rugby, England, and the company filed a patent in December 1947 (patent GB685286). The technique as originally invented is still used in electron microscopy, where it is known as electron holography. Gabor was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1971 "for his invention and development of the holographic method". [10]

Horizontal symmetric text, by Dieter Jung III-BIBI BEI BOB.jpg
Horizontal symmetric text, by Dieter Jung

Optical holography did not really advance until the development of the laser in 1960. The development of the laser enabled the first practical optical holograms that recorded 3D objects to be made in 1962 by Yuri Denisyuk in the Soviet Union [11] and by Emmett Leith and Juris Upatnieks at the University of Michigan, US. [12]

Early optical holograms used silver halide photographic emulsions as the recording medium. They were not very efficient as the produced diffraction grating absorbed much of the incident light. Various methods of converting the variation in transmission to a variation in refractive index (known as "bleaching") were developed which enabled much more efficient holograms to be produced. [13] [14] [15]

A major advance in the field of holography was made by Stephen Benton, who invented a way to create holograms that can be viewed with natural light instead of lasers. These are called rainbow holograms. [8]

Basics of holography

Recording a hologram Holograph-record.svg
Recording a hologram
Reconstructing a hologram Holography-reconstruct.svg
Reconstructing a hologram
This is a photograph of a small part of an unbleached transmission hologram viewed through a microscope. The hologram recorded an image of a toy van and car. It is no more possible to discern the subject of the hologram from this pattern than it is to identify what music has been recorded by looking at a CD surface. The holographic information is recorded by the speckle pattern. Structure of a holographic recording.jpg
This is a photograph of a small part of an unbleached transmission hologram viewed through a microscope. The hologram recorded an image of a toy van and car. It is no more possible to discern the subject of the hologram from this pattern than it is to identify what music has been recorded by looking at a CD surface. The holographic information is recorded by the speckle pattern.

Holography is a technique for recording and reconstructing light fields. [16] :Section 1 A light field is generally the result of a light source scattered off objects. Holography can be thought of as somewhat similar to sound recording, whereby a sound field created by vibrating matter like musical instruments or vocal cords, is encoded in such a way that it can be reproduced later, without the presence of the original vibrating matter. [17] However, it is even more similar to Ambisonic sound recording in which any listening angle of a sound field can be reproduced in the reproduction.

Laser

In laser holography, the hologram is recorded using a source of laser light, which is very pure in its color and orderly in its composition. Various setups may be used, and several types of holograms can be made, but all involve the interaction of light coming from different directions and producing a microscopic interference pattern which a plate, film, or other medium photographically records.

In one common arrangement, the laser beam is split into two, one known as the object beam and the other as the reference beam. The object beam is expanded by passing it through a lens and used to illuminate the subject. The recording medium is located where this light, after being reflected or scattered by the subject, will strike it. The edges of the medium will ultimately serve as a window through which the subject is seen, so its location is chosen with that in mind. The reference beam is expanded and made to shine directly on the medium, where it interacts with the light coming from the subject to create the desired interference pattern.

Like conventional photography, holography requires an appropriate exposure time to correctly affect the recording medium. Unlike conventional photography, during the exposure the light source, the optical elements, the recording medium, and the subject must all remain motionless relative to each other, to within about a quarter of the wavelength of the light, or the interference pattern will be blurred and the hologram spoiled. With living subjects and some unstable materials, that is only possible if a very intense and extremely brief pulse of laser light is used, a hazardous procedure which is rarely done outside of scientific and industrial laboratory settings. Exposures lasting several seconds to several minutes, using a much lower-powered continuously operating laser, are typical.

Apparatus

A hologram can be made by shining part of the light beam directly into the recording medium, and the other part onto the object in such a way that some of the scattered light falls onto the recording medium. A more flexible arrangement for recording a hologram requires the laser beam to be aimed through a series of elements that change it in different ways. The first element is a beam splitter that divides the beam into two identical beams, each aimed in different directions:

Several different materials can be used as the recording medium. One of the most common is a film very similar to photographic film (silver halide photographic emulsion), but with much smaller light-reactive grains (preferably with diameters less than 20 nm), making it capable of the much higher resolution that holograms require. A layer of this recording medium (e.g., silver halide) is attached to a transparent substrate, which is commonly glass, but may also be plastic.

Process

When the two laser beams reach the recording medium, their light waves intersect and interfere with each other. It is this interference pattern that is imprinted on the recording medium. The pattern itself is seemingly random, as it represents the way in which the scene's light interfered with the original light source – but not the original light source itself. The interference pattern can be considered an encoded version of the scene, requiring a particular key – the original light source – in order to view its contents.

This missing key is provided later by shining a laser, identical to the one used to record the hologram, onto the developed film. When this beam illuminates the hologram, it is diffracted by the hologram's surface pattern. This produces a light field identical to the one originally produced by the scene and scattered onto the hologram.

Comparison with photography

Holography may be better understood via an examination of its differences from ordinary photography:

Physics of holography

For a better understanding of the process, it is necessary to understand interference and diffraction. Interference occurs when one or more wavefronts are superimposed. Diffraction occurs when a wavefront encounters an object. The process of producing a holographic reconstruction is explained below purely in terms of interference and diffraction. It is somewhat simplified but is accurate enough to give an understanding of how the holographic process works.

For those unfamiliar with these concepts, it is worthwhile to read those articles before reading further in this article.

Plane wavefronts

A diffraction grating is a structure with a repeating pattern. A simple example is a metal plate with slits cut at regular intervals. A light wave that is incident on a grating is split into several waves; the direction of these diffracted waves is determined by the grating spacing and the wavelength of the light.

A simple hologram can be made by superimposing two plane waves from the same light source on a holographic recording medium. The two waves interfere, giving a straight-line fringe pattern whose intensity varies sinusoidally across the medium. The spacing of the fringe pattern is determined by the angle between the two waves, and by the wavelength of the light.

The recorded light pattern is a diffraction grating. When it is illuminated by only one of the waves used to create it, it can be shown that one of the diffracted waves emerges at the same angle at which the second wave was originally incident, so that the second wave has been 'reconstructed'. Thus, the recorded light pattern is a holographic recording as defined above.

Point sources

Sinusoidal zone plate Zonenplatte Cosinus.png
Sinusoidal zone plate

If the recording medium is illuminated with a point source and a normally incident plane wave, the resulting pattern is a sinusoidal zone plate, which acts as a negative Fresnel lens whose focal length is equal to the separation of the point source and the recording plane.

When a plane wave-front illuminates a negative lens, it is expanded into a wave that appears to diverge from the focal point of the lens. Thus, when the recorded pattern is illuminated with the original plane wave, some of the light is diffracted into a diverging beam equivalent to the original spherical wave; a holographic recording of the point source has been created.

When the plane wave is incident at a non-normal angle at the time of recording, the pattern formed is more complex, but still acts as a negative lens if it is illuminated at the original angle.

Complex objects

To record a hologram of a complex object, a laser beam is first split into two beams of light. One beam illuminates the object, which then scatters light onto the recording medium. According to diffraction theory, each point in the object acts as a point source of light so the recording medium can be considered to be illuminated by a set of point sources located at varying distances from the medium.

The second (reference) beam illuminates the recording medium directly. Each point source wave interferes with the reference beam, giving rise to its own sinusoidal zone plate in the recording medium. The resulting pattern is the sum of all these 'zone plates', which combine to produce a random (speckle) pattern as in the photograph above.

When the hologram is illuminated by the original reference beam, each of the individual zone plates reconstructs the object wave that produced it, and these individual wavefronts are combined to reconstruct the whole of the object beam. The viewer perceives a wavefront that is identical with the wavefront scattered from the object onto the recording medium, so that it appears that the object is still in place even if it has been removed.

Applications

Art

Early on, artists saw the potential of holography as a medium and gained access to science laboratories to create their work. Holographic art is often the result of collaborations between scientists and artists, although some holographers would regard themselves as both an artist and a scientist.

Salvador Dalí claimed to have been the first to employ holography artistically. He was certainly the first and best-known surrealist to do so, but the 1972 New York exhibit of Dalí holograms had been preceded by the holographic art exhibition that was held at the Cranbrook Academy of Art in Michigan in 1968 and by the one at the Finch College gallery in New York in 1970, which attracted national media attention. [18] In Great Britain, Margaret Benyon began using holography as an artistic medium in the late 1960s and had a solo exhibition at the University of Nottingham art gallery in 1969. [19] This was followed in 1970 by a solo show at the Lisson Gallery in London, which was billed as the "first London expo of holograms and stereoscopic paintings". [20]

During the 1970s, a number of art studios and schools were established, each with their particular approach to holography. Notably, there was the San Francisco School of Holography established by Lloyd Cross, The Museum of Holography in New York founded by Rosemary (Posy) H. Jackson, the Royal College of Art in London and the Lake Forest College Symposiums organised by Tung Jeong. [21] None of these studios still exist; however, there is the Center for the Holographic Arts in New York [22] and the HOLOcenter in Seoul, which offers artists a place to create and exhibit work.

During the 1980s, many artists who worked with holography helped the diffusion of this so-called "new medium" in the art world, such as Harriet Casdin-Silver of the United States, Dieter Jung of Germany, and Moysés Baumstein of Brazil, each one searching for a proper "language" to use with the three-dimensional work, avoiding the simple holographic reproduction of a sculpture or object. For instance, in Brazil, many concrete poets (Augusto de Campos, Décio Pignatari, Julio Plaza and José Wagner Garcia, associated with Moysés Baumstein) found in holography a way to express themselves and to renew Concrete Poetry.

A small but active group of artists still integrate holographic elements into their work. [23] Some are associated with novel holographic techniques; for example, artist Matt Brand [24] employed computational mirror design to eliminate image distortion from specular holography.

The MIT Museum [25] and Jonathan Ross [26] both have extensive collections of holography and on-line catalogues of art holograms.

Data storage

Holographic data storage is a technique that can store information at high density inside crystals or photopolymers. The ability to store large amounts of information in some kind of medium is of great importance, as many electronic products incorporate storage devices. As current storage techniques such as Blu-ray Disc reach the limit of possible data density (due to the diffraction-limited size of the writing beams), holographic storage has the potential to become the next generation of popular storage media. The advantage of this type of data storage is that the volume of the recording media is used instead of just the surface. Currently available SLMs can produce about 1000 different images a second at 1024×1024-bit resolution which would result in about one-gigabit-per-second writing speed. [27]

In 2005, companies such as Optware and Maxell produced a 120 mm disc that uses a holographic layer to store data to a potential 3.9  TB, a format called Holographic Versatile Disc. As of September 2014, no commercial product has been released.

Another company, InPhase Technologies, was developing a competing format, but went bankrupt in 2011 and all its assets were sold to Akonia Holographics, LLC.

While many holographic data storage models have used "page-based" storage, where each recorded hologram holds a large amount of data, more recent research into using submicrometre-sized "microholograms" has resulted in several potential 3D optical data storage solutions. While this approach to data storage can not attain the high data rates of page-based storage, the tolerances, technological hurdles, and cost of producing a commercial product are significantly lower.

Dynamic holography

In static holography, recording, developing and reconstructing occur sequentially, and a permanent hologram is produced.

There also exist holographic materials that do not need the developing process and can record a hologram in a very short time. This allows one to use holography to perform some simple operations in an all-optical way. Examples of applications of such real-time holograms include phase-conjugate mirrors ("time-reversal" of light), optical cache memories, image processing (pattern recognition of time-varying images), and optical computing.

The amount of processed information can be very high (terabits/s), since the operation is performed in parallel on a whole image. This compensates for the fact that the recording time, which is in the order of a microsecond, is still very long compared to the processing time of an electronic computer. The optical processing performed by a dynamic hologram is also much less flexible than electronic processing. On one side, one has to perform the operation always on the whole image, and on the other side, the operation a hologram can perform is basically either a multiplication or a phase conjugation. In optics, addition and Fourier transform are already easily performed in linear materials, the latter simply by a lens. This enables some applications, such as a device that compares images in an optical way. [28]

The search for novel nonlinear optical materials for dynamic holography is an active area of research. The most common materials are photorefractive crystals, but in semiconductors or semiconductor heterostructures (such as quantum wells), atomic vapors and gases, plasmas and even liquids, it was possible to generate holograms.

A particularly promising application is optical phase conjugation. It allows the removal of the wavefront distortions a light beam receives when passing through an aberrating medium, by sending it back through the same aberrating medium with a conjugated phase. This is useful, for example, in free-space optical communications to compensate for atmospheric turbulence (the phenomenon that gives rise to the twinkling of starlight).

Hobbyist use

Peace Within Reach, a Denisyuk DCG hologram by amateur Dave Battin Contest3.jpg
Peace Within Reach, a Denisyuk DCG hologram by amateur Dave Battin

Since the beginning of holography, many holographers have explored its uses and displayed them to the public.

In 1971, Lloyd Cross opened the San Francisco School of Holography and taught amateurs how to make holograms using only a small (typically 5 mW) helium-neon laser and inexpensive home-made equipment. Holography had been supposed to require a very expensive metal optical table set-up to lock all the involved elements down in place and damp any vibrations that could blur the interference fringes and ruin the hologram. Cross's home-brew alternative was a sandbox made of a cinder block retaining wall on a plywood base, supported on stacks of old tires to isolate it from ground vibrations, and filled with sand that had been washed to remove dust. The laser was securely mounted atop the cinder block wall. The mirrors and simple lenses needed for directing, splitting and expanding the laser beam were affixed to short lengths of PVC pipe, which were stuck into the sand at the desired locations. The subject and the photographic plate holder were similarly supported within the sandbox. The holographer turned off the room light, blocked the laser beam near its source using a small relay-controlled shutter, loaded a plate into the holder in the dark, left the room, waited a few minutes to let everything settle, then made the exposure by remotely operating the laser shutter.

In 1979, Jason Sapan opened the Holographic Studios in New York City. Since then, they have been involved in the production of many holographs for many artists as well as companies. [29] Sapan has been described as the "last professional holographer of New York".

Many of these holographers would go on to produce art holograms. In 1983, Fred Unterseher, a co-founder of the San Francisco School of Holography and a well-known holographic artist, published the Holography Handbook, an easy-to-read guide to making holograms at home. This brought in a new wave of holographers and provided simple methods for using the then-available AGFA silver halide recording materials.

In 2000, Frank DeFreitas published the Shoebox Holography Book and introduced the use of inexpensive laser pointers to countless hobbyists. For many years, it had been assumed that certain characteristics of semiconductor laser diodes made them virtually useless for creating holograms, but when they were eventually put to the test of practical experiment, it was found that not only was this untrue, but that some actually provided a coherence length much greater than that of traditional helium-neon gas lasers. This was a very important development for amateurs, as the price of red laser diodes had dropped from hundreds of dollars in the early 1980s to about $5 after they entered the mass market as a component of DVD players in the late 1990s. Now, there are thousands of amateur holographers worldwide.

By late 2000, holography kits with inexpensive laser pointer diodes entered the mainstream consumer market. These kits enabled students, teachers, and hobbyists to make several kinds of holograms without specialized equipment, and became popular gift items by 2005. [30] The introduction of holography kits with self-developing plates in 2003 made it possible for hobbyists to create holograms without the bother of wet chemical processing. [31]

In 2006, a large number of surplus holography-quality green lasers (Coherent C315) became available and put dichromated gelatin (DCG) holography within the reach of the amateur holographer. The holography community was surprised at the amazing sensitivity of DCG to green light. It had been assumed that this sensitivity would be uselessly slight or non-existent. Jeff Blyth responded with the G307 formulation of DCG to increase the speed and sensitivity to these new lasers. [32]

Kodak and Agfa, the former major suppliers of holography-quality silver halide plates and films, are no longer in the market. While other manufacturers have helped fill the void, many amateurs are now making their own materials. The favorite formulations are dichromated gelatin, Methylene-Blue-sensitised dichromated gelatin, and diffusion method silver halide preparations. Jeff Blyth has published very accurate methods for making these in a small lab or garage. [33]

A small group of amateurs are even constructing their own pulsed lasers to make holograms of living subjects and other unsteady or moving objects. [34]

Holographic interferometry

Holographic interferometry (HI) is a technique that enables static and dynamic displacements of objects with optically rough surfaces to be measured to optical interferometric precision (i.e. to fractions of a wavelength of light). [35] [36] It can also be used to detect optical-path-length variations in transparent media, which enables, for example, fluid flow to be visualized and analyzed. It can also be used to generate contours representing the form of the surface or the isodose regions in radiation dosimetry. [37]

It has been widely used to measure stress, strain, and vibration in engineering structures.

Interferometric microscopy

The hologram keeps the information on the amplitude and phase of the field. Several holograms may keep information about the same distribution of light, emitted to various directions. The numerical analysis of such holograms allows one to emulate large numerical aperture, which, in turn, enables enhancement of the resolution of optical microscopy. The corresponding technique is called interferometric microscopy. Recent achievements of interferometric microscopy allow one to approach the quarter-wavelength limit of resolution. [38]

Sensors or biosensors

The hologram is made with a modified material that interacts with certain molecules generating a change in the fringe periodicity or refractive index, therefore, the color of the holographic reflection. [39] [40]

Security

Identigram as a security element in a German identity card Hologramm.JPG
Identigram as a security element in a German identity card
Dove hologram used on some credit cards Visa Dove Hologram Rainbow.jpg
Dove hologram used on some credit cards

Holograms are commonly used for security, as they are replicated from a master hologram that requires expensive, specialized and technologically advanced equipment, and are thus difficult to forge. They are used widely in many currencies, such as the Brazilian 20, 50, and 100-reais notes; British 5, 10, 20 and 50-pound notes; South Korean 5000, 10,000, and 50,000-won notes; Japanese 5000 and 10,000 yen notes, Indian 50, 100, 500, and 2000 rupee notes; and all the currently-circulating banknotes of the Canadian dollar, Croatian kuna, Danish krone, and Euro. They can also be found in credit and bank cards as well as passports, ID cards, books, food packaging, DVDs, and sports equipment. Such holograms come in a variety of forms, from adhesive strips that are laminated on packaging for fast-moving consumer goods to holographic tags on electronic products. They often contain textual or pictorial elements to protect identities and separate genuine articles from counterfeits.

Holographic scanners are in use in post offices, larger shipping firms, and automated conveyor systems to determine the three-dimensional size of a package. They are often used in tandem with checkweighers to allow automated pre-packing of given volumes, such as a truck or pallet for bulk shipment of goods. Holograms produced in elastomers can be used as stress-strain reporters due to its elasticity and compressibility, the pressure and force applied are correlated to the reflected wavelength, therefore its color. [41] Holography technique can also be effectively used for radiation dosimetry. [42] [43]

High security registration plates

High-security holograms can be used on license plates for vehicles such as cars and motorcycles. As of April 2019, holographic license plates are required on vehicles in parts of India to aid in identification and security, especially in cases of car theft. Such number plates hold electronic data of vehicles, and have a unique ID number and a sticker to indicate authenticity. [44]

Holography using other types of waves

In principle, it is possible to make a hologram for any wave.

Electron holography is the application of holography techniques to electron waves rather than light waves. Electron holography was invented by Dennis Gabor to improve the resolution and avoid the aberrations of the transmission electron microscope. Today it is commonly used to study electric and magnetic fields in thin films, as magnetic and electric fields can shift the phase of the interfering wave passing through the sample. [45] The principle of electron holography can also be applied to interference lithography. [46]

Acoustic holography enables sound maps of an object to be generated. Measurements of the acoustic field are made at many points close to the object. These measurements are digitally processed to produce the "images" of the object. [47]

Atomic holography has evolved out of the development of the basic elements of atom optics. With the Fresnel diffraction lens and atomic mirrors atomic holography follows a natural step in the development of the physics (and applications) of atomic beams. Recent developments including atomic mirrors and especially ridged mirrors have provided the tools necessary for the creation of atomic holograms, [48] although such holograms have not yet been commercialized.

Neutron beam holography has been used to see the inside of solid objects. [49]

Holograms with x-rays are generated by using synchrotrons or x-ray free-electron lasers as radiation sources and pixelated detectors such as CCDs as recording medium. [50] The reconstruction is then retrieved via computation. Due to the shorter wavelength of x-rays compared to visible light, this approach allows imaging objects with higher spatial resolution. [51] As free-electron lasers can provide ultrashort and x-ray pulses in the range of femtoseconds which are intense and coherent, x-ray holography has been used to capture ultrafast dynamic processes. [52] [53] [54]

False holograms

A Pepper's ghost illusion made from a clear plastic frustum Pyramid holographic 3D holographic projection phone projector 3D holographic projection 3D mobile phone naked eye 3D pyramid.jpg
A Pepper's ghost illusion made from a clear plastic frustum
Shows making using of projected images are erroneously marketed as "holographic"

There are many optical effects that are falsely confused with holography, such as the effects produced by lenticular printing, the Pepper's ghost illusion (or modern variants such as the Musion Eyeliner), tomography and volumetric displays. [55] [56] Such illusions have been called "fauxlography". [57] [58]

The Pepper's ghost technique, being the easiest to implement of these methods, is most prevalent in 3D displays that claim to be (or are referred to as) "holographic". While the original illusion, used in theater, involved actual physical objects and persons, located offstage, modern variants replace the source object with a digital screen, which displays imagery generated with 3D computer graphics to provide the necessary depth cues. The reflection, which seems to float mid-air, is still flat however, thus less realistic than if an actual 3D object was being reflected.

Examples of this digital version of Pepper's ghost illusion include the Gorillaz performances in the 2005 MTV Europe Music Awards and the 48th Grammy Awards; and Tupac Shakur's virtual performance at Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival in 2012, rapping alongside Snoop Dogg during his set with Dr. Dre. [59] Digital avatars of the Swedish supergroup ABBA were displayed on stage in May 2022. [60] The ABBA performance used technology that was an updated version of Pepper's Ghost created by Industrial Light & Magic. [61] American rock group KISS unveiled similar digital avatars in December 2023 to tour in their place at the conclusion of the End of the Road World Tour using the same Pepper's Ghost technology as the ABBA avatars. [62]

An even simpler illusion can be created by rear-projecting realistic images into semi-transparent screens. The rear projection is necessary because otherwise the semi-transparency of the screen would allow the background to be illuminated by the projection, which would break the illusion.

Crypton Future Media, a music software company that produced Hatsune Miku, [63] one of many Vocaloid singing synthesizer applications, has produced concerts that have Miku, along with other Crypton Vocaloids, performing on stage as "holographic" characters. These concerts use rear projection onto a semi-transparent DILAD screen [64] [65] to achieve its "holographic" effect. [66] [67]

In 2011, in Beijing, apparel company Burberry produced the "Burberry Prorsum Autumn/Winter 2011 Hologram Runway Show", which included life size 2-D projections of models. The company's own video [68] shows several centered and off-center shots of the main 2-dimensional projection screen, the latter revealing the flatness of the virtual models. The claim that holography was used was reported as fact in the trade media. [69]

In Madrid, on 10 April 2015, a public visual presentation called "Hologramas por la Libertad" (Holograms for Liberty), featuring a ghostly virtual crowd of demonstrators, was used to protest a new Spanish law that prohibits citizens from demonstrating in public places. Although widely called a "hologram protest" in news reports, [70] no actual holography was involved – it was yet another technologically updated variant of the Pepper's ghost illusion.

Holography is distinct from specular holography which is a technique for making three-dimensional images by controlling the motion of specularities on a two-dimensional surface. [71] It works by reflectively or refractively manipulating bundles of light rays, not by using interference and diffraction.

Tactile holograms

In fiction

Holography has been widely referred to in movies, novels, and TV, usually in science fiction, starting in the late 1970s. [72] Science fiction writers absorbed the urban legends surrounding holography that had been spread by overly-enthusiastic scientists and entrepreneurs trying to market the idea. [72] This had the effect of giving the public overly high expectations of the capability of holography, due to the unrealistic depictions of it in most fiction, where they are fully three-dimensional computer projections that are sometimes tactile through the use of force fields. [72] Examples of this type of depiction include the hologram of Princess Leia in Star Wars, Arnold Rimmer from Red Dwarf , who was later converted to "hard light" to make him solid, and the Holodeck and Emergency Medical Hologram from Star Trek . [72]

Holography has served as an inspiration for many video games with science fiction elements. In many titles, fictional holographic technology has been used to reflect real life misrepresentations of potential military use of holograms, such as the "mirage tanks" in Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 that can disguise themselves as trees. [73] Player characters are able to use holographic decoys in games such as Halo: Reach and Crysis 2 to confuse and distract the enemy. [73] Starcraft ghost agent Nova has access to "holo decoy" as one of her three primary abilities in Heroes of the Storm. [74]

Fictional depictions of holograms have, however, inspired technological advances in other fields, such as augmented reality, that promise to fulfill the fictional depictions of holograms by other means. [75]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diffraction</span> Phenomenon of the motion of waves

Diffraction is the interference or bending of waves around the corners of an obstacle or through an aperture into the region of geometrical shadow of the obstacle/aperture. The diffracting object or aperture effectively becomes a secondary source of the propagating wave. Italian scientist Francesco Maria Grimaldi coined the word diffraction and was the first to record accurate observations of the phenomenon in 1660.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Microscopy</span> Viewing of objects which are too small to be seen with the naked eye

Microscopy is the technical field of using microscopes to view objects and areas of objects that cannot be seen with the naked eye. There are three well-known branches of microscopy: optical, electron, and scanning probe microscopy, along with the emerging field of X-ray microscopy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Interferometry</span> Measurement method using interference of waves

Interferometry is a technique which uses the interference of superimposed waves to extract information. Interferometry typically uses electromagnetic waves and is an important investigative technique in the fields of astronomy, fiber optics, engineering metrology, optical metrology, oceanography, seismology, spectroscopy, quantum mechanics, nuclear and particle physics, plasma physics, biomolecular interactions, surface profiling, microfluidics, mechanical stress/strain measurement, velocimetry, optometry, and making holograms.

The photorefractive effect is a nonlinear optical effect seen in certain crystals and other materials that respond to light by altering their refractive index. The effect can be used to store temporary, erasable holograms and is useful for holographic data storage. It can also be used to create a phase-conjugate mirror or an optical spatial soliton.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Holographic data storage</span> Data storage technology

Holographic data storage is a potential technology in the area of high-capacity data storage. While magnetic and optical data storage devices rely on individual bits being stored as distinct magnetic or optical changes on the surface of the recording medium, holographic data storage records information throughout the volume of the medium and is capable of recording multiple images in the same area utilizing light at different angles.

Interference lithography is a technique for patterning regular arrays of fine features, without the use of complex optical systems or photomasks.

Electron holography is holography with electron matter waves. It was invented by Dennis Gabor in 1948 when he tried to improve image resolution in electron microscope. The first attempts to perform holography with electron waves were made by Haine and Mulvey in 1952; they recorded holograms of zinc oxide crystals with 60 keV electrons, demonstrating reconstructions with approximately 1 nm resolution. In 1955, G. Möllenstedt and H. Düker invented an electron biprism, thus enabling the recording of electron holograms in off-axis scheme. There are many different possible configurations for electron holography, with more than 20 documented in 1992 by Cowley. Usually, high spatial and temporal coherence of the electron beam are required to perform holographic measurements.

Holographic interferometry (HI) is a technique which enables the measurements of static and dynamic displacements of objects with optically rough surfaces at optical interferometric precision. These measurements can be applied to stress, strain and vibration analysis, as well as to non-destructive testing and radiation dosimetry. It can also be used to detect optical path length variations in transparent media, which enables, for example, fluid flow to be visualised and analyzed. It can also be used to generate contours representing the form of the surface.

Digital holography is the acquisition and processing of holograms with a digital sensor array, typically a CCD camera or a similar device. Image rendering, or reconstruction of object data is performed numerically from digitized interferograms. Digital holography offers a means of measuring optical phase data and typically delivers three-dimensional surface or optical thickness images. Several recording and processing schemes have been developed to assess optical wave characteristics such as amplitude, phase, and polarization state, which make digital holography a very powerful method for metrology applications .

Computer-generated holography (CGH) is a technique that uses computer algorithms to generate holograms. It involves generating holographic interference patterns. A computer-generated hologram can be displayed on a dynamic holographic display, or it can be printed onto a mask or film using lithography. When a hologram is printed onto a mask or film, it is then illuminated by a coherent light source to display the holographic images.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Low-energy electron microscopy</span>

Low-energy electron microscopy, or LEEM, is an analytical surface science technique used to image atomically clean surfaces, atom-surface interactions, and thin (crystalline) films. In LEEM, high-energy electrons are emitted from an electron gun, focused using a set of condenser optics, and sent through a magnetic beam deflector. The “fast” electrons travel through an objective lens and begin decelerating to low energies near the sample surface because the sample is held at a potential near that of the gun. The low-energy electrons are now termed “surface-sensitive” and the near-surface sampling depth can be varied by tuning the energy of the incident electrons. The low-energy elastically backscattered electrons travel back through the objective lens, reaccelerate to the gun voltage, and pass through the beam separator again. However, now the electrons travel away from the condenser optics and into the projector lenses. Imaging of the back focal plane of the objective lens into the object plane of the projector lens produces a diffraction pattern at the imaging plane and recorded in a number of different ways. The intensity distribution of the diffraction pattern will depend on the periodicity at the sample surface and is a direct result of the wave nature of the electrons. One can produce individual images of the diffraction pattern spot intensities by turning off the intermediate lens and inserting a contrast aperture in the back focal plane of the objective lens, thus allowing for real-time observations of dynamic processes at surfaces. Such phenomena include : tomography, phase transitions, adsorption, reaction, segregation, thin film growth, etching, strain relief, sublimation, and magnetic microstructure. These investigations are only possible because of the accessibility of the sample; allowing for a wide variety of in situ studies over a wide temperature range. LEEM was invented by Ernst Bauer in 1962; however, not fully developed until 1985.

A holographic display is a type of 3D display that utilizes light diffraction to display a three-dimensional image to the viewer. Holographic displays are distinguished from other forms of 3D displays in that they do not require the viewer to wear any special glasses or use external equipment to be able to see the image, and do not cause the vergence-accommodation conflict.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electronic speckle pattern interferometry</span>

Electronic speckle pattern interferometry (ESPI), also known as TV holography, is a technique that uses laser light, together with video detection, recording and processing, to visualise static and dynamic displacements of components with optically rough surfaces. The visualisation is in the form of fringes on the image, where each fringe normally represents a displacement of half a wavelength of the light used.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ptychography</span>

Ptychography is a computational method of microscopic imaging. It generates images by processing many coherent interference patterns that have been scattered from an object of interest. Its defining characteristic is translational invariance, which means that the interference patterns are generated by one constant function moving laterally by a known amount with respect to another constant function. The interference patterns occur some distance away from these two components, so that the scattered waves spread out and "fold" into one another as shown in the figure.

Speckle, speckle pattern, or speckle noise is a granular noise texture degrading the quality as a consequence of interference among wavefronts in coherent imaging systems, such as radar, synthetic aperture radar (SAR), medical ultrasound and optical coherence tomography. Speckle is not external noise; rather, it is an inherent fluctuation in diffuse reflections, because the scatterers are not identical for each cell, and the coherent illumination wave is highly sensitive to small variations in phase changes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Digital holographic microscopy</span>

Digital holographic microscopy (DHM) is digital holography applied to microscopy. Digital holographic microscopy distinguishes itself from other microscopy methods by not recording the projected image of the object. Instead, the light wave front information originating from the object is digitally recorded as a hologram, from which a computer calculates the object image by using a numerical reconstruction algorithm. The image forming lens in traditional microscopy is thus replaced by a computer algorithm. Other closely related microscopy methods to digital holographic microscopy are interferometric microscopy, optical coherence tomography and diffraction phase microscopy. Common to all methods is the use of a reference wave front to obtain amplitude (intensity) and phase information. The information is recorded on a digital image sensor or by a photodetector from which an image of the object is created (reconstructed) by a computer. In traditional microscopy, which do not use a reference wave front, only intensity information is recorded and essential information about the object is lost.

A common-path interferometer is a class of interferometers in which the reference beam and sample beams travel along the same path. Examples include the Sagnac interferometer, Zernike phase-contrast interferometer, and the point diffraction interferometer. A common-path interferometer is generally more robust to environmental vibrations than a "double-path interferometer" such as the Michelson interferometer or the Mach–Zehnder interferometer. Although travelling along the same path, the reference and sample beams may travel along opposite directions, or they may travel along the same direction but with the same or different polarization.

Holographic interference microscopy (HIM) is holographic interferometry applied for microscopy for visualization of phase micro-objects. Phase micro-objects are invisible because they do not change intensity of light, they insert only invisible phase shifts. The holographic interference microscopy distinguishes itself from other microscopy methods by using a hologram and the interference for converting invisible phase shifts into intensity changes.

Optical holography is a technique which enables an optical wavefront to be recorded and later re-constructed. Holography is best known as a method of generating three-dimensional images but it also has a wide range of other applications.

The time-domain counterpart of spatial holography is called time-domain holography. In other words, the principles of spatial holography is surveyed in time domain. Time-domain holography was inspired by the theory known as space-time duality which was introduced by Brian H. Kolner in 1994.

References

  1. "What is Holography? | holocenter" . Retrieved 2 September 2019.
  2. 1 2 Jesacher, Alexander; Ritsch-Marte, Monika (2 January 2016). "Synthetic holography in microscopy: opportunities arising from advanced wavefront shaping". Contemporary Physics. 57 (1): 46–59. Bibcode:2016ConPh..57...46J. doi:10.1080/00107514.2015.1120007. ISSN   0010-7514.
  3. Sahin, Erdem; Stoykova, Elena; Mäkinen, Jani; Gotchev, Atanas (20 March 2020). "Computer-Generated Holograms for 3D Imaging: A Survey" (PDF). ACM Computing Surveys. 53 (2): 32:1–32:35. doi:10.1145/3378444. ISSN   0360-0300.
  4. Blanche, P.-A.; Bablumian, A.; Voorakaranam, R.; Christenson, C.; Lin, W.; Gu, T.; Flores, D.; Wang, P.; et al. (2010). "Holographic three-dimensional telepresence using large-area photorefractive polymer". Nature. 468 (7320): 80–83. Bibcode:2010Natur.468...80B. doi:10.1038/nature09521. PMID   21048763. S2CID   205222841.
  5. Smalley, D. E.; Nygaard, E.; Squire, K.; Van Wagoner, J.; Rasmussen, J.; Gneiting, S.; Qaderi, K.; Goodsell, J.; Rogers, W.; Lindsey, M.; Costner, K.; Monk, A.; Pearson, M.; Haymore, B.; Peatross, J. (25 January 2018). "A photophoretic-trap volumetric display". Nature. 553 (7689): 486–490. Bibcode:2018Natur.553..486S. doi: 10.1038/nature25176 . ISSN   1476-4687. PMID   29368704. S2CID   4451867.
  6. Gabor, Dennis (1948). "A new microscopic principle". Nature. 161 (4098): 777–8. Bibcode:1948Natur.161..777G. doi: 10.1038/161777a0 . PMID   18860291. S2CID   4121017.
  7. Gabor, Dennis (1949). "Microscopy by reconstructed wavefronts". Proceedings of the Royal Society. 197 (1051): 454–487. Bibcode:1949RSPSA.197..454G. doi: 10.1098/rspa.1949.0075 . S2CID   123187722.
  8. 1 2 Blanche, Pierre-Alexandre (2014). Field guide to holography. SPIE field guides. Bellingham, Wash: SPIE Press. p. 1. ISBN   978-0-8194-9957-8.
  9. Hariharan, P. (1996). Optical Holography. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   9780521433488.
  10. "The Nobel Prize in Physics 1971". Nobelprize.org. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  11. Denisyuk, Yuri N. (1962). "On the reflection of optical properties of an object in a wave field of light scattered by it". Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR . 144 (6): 1275–1278.
  12. Leith, E.N.; Upatnieks, J. (1962). "Reconstructed wavefronts and communication theory". J. Opt. Soc. Am. 52 (10): 1123–1130. Bibcode:1962JOSA...52.1123L. doi:10.1364/JOSA.52.001123.
  13. Upatnieks, J; Leonard, C (1969). "Diffraction efficiency of bleached, photographically recorded interference patterns". Applied Optics. 8 (1): 85–89. Bibcode:1969ApOpt...8...85U. doi:10.1364/ao.8.000085. PMID   20072177.
  14. Graube, A (1974). "Advances in bleaching methods for photographically recorded holograms". Applied Optics. 13 (12): 2942–6. Bibcode:1974ApOpt..13.2942G. doi:10.1364/ao.13.002942. PMID   20134813.
  15. Phillips, N. J.; Porter, D. (1976). "An advance in the processing of holograms". Journal of Physics E: Scientific Instruments. 9 (8): 631. Bibcode:1976JPhE....9..631P. doi:10.1088/0022-3735/9/8/011.
  16. Hariharan, P (2002). Basics of Holography. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   9780511755569.
  17. Richards, Keith L. (2018). Design engineer's sourcebook. Boca Raton. ISBN   978-1-315-35052-3. OCLC   990152205.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  18. "The History and Development of Holography". Holophile.com. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  19. Coyle, Rebecca (1990). "Holography – Art in the space of technology". In Hayward, Philip (ed.). Culture, Technology & Creativity in the Late Twentieth Century. London, England: John Libbey and Company. pp. 65–88. ISBN   978-0-86196-266-2.
  20. "Margaret Benyon Holography". Lisson Gallery. Retrieved 4 February 2016.
  21. Integraf. "Dr. Tung J. Jeong Biography". Integraf.com. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  22. "holocenter". holocenter. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  23. "The Universal Hologram". Cherry Optical Holography.
  24. Holographic metalwork http://www.zintaglio.com
  25. "MIT Museum: Collections – Holography". Web.mit.edu. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  26. "The Jonathan Ross Hologram Collection". Jrholocollection.com. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  27. Lang, M.; Eschler, H. (1 October 1974). "Gigabyte capacities for holographic memories". Optics & Laser Technology. 6 (5): 219–224. Bibcode:1974OptLT...6..219L. doi:10.1016/0030-3992(74)90061-9. ISSN   0030-3992.
  28. R. Ryf et al. High-frame-rate joint Fourier-transform correlator based on Sn2P2S6 crystal, Optics Letters 26, 1666–1668 (2001)
  29. Strochlic, Nina (27 May 2014). "New York's Hologram King is Also the City's Last Pro Holographer". The Daily Beast.
  30. Stephen Cass: Holiday Gifts 2005 Gifts and gadgets for technophiles of all ages: Do-It Yourself-3-D . In IEEE Spectrum, November 2005
  31. Chiaverina, Chris: Litiholo holography – So easy even a caveman could have done it (apparatus review) Archived 8 February 2012 at the Wayback Machine . In The Physics Teacher, vol. 48, November 2010, pp. 551–552.
  32. "A Holography FAQ". HoloWiki. 15 February 2011. Archived from the original on 6 November 2010. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  33. "Many methods are here". Holowiki.com. Archived from the original on 7 March 2012. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  34. "Jeff Blyth's Film Formulations". Cabd0.tripod.com. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  35. Powell, RL; Stetson, KA (1965). "Interferometric Vibration Analysis by Wavefront Reconstruction". J. Opt. Soc. Am. 55 (12): 1593–8. Bibcode:1965JOSA...55.1593P. doi:10.1364/josa.55.001593.
  36. Jones, Robert; Wykes, Catherine (1989). Holographic and Speckle Interferometry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   0-521-34417-4.
  37. Beigzadeh, A.M.; Vaziri, M.R. Rashidian; Ziaie, F. (2017). "Modelling of a holographic interferometry based calorimeter for radiation dosimetry". Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research A. 864: 40–49. Bibcode:2017NIMPA.864...40B. doi:10.1016/j.nima.2017.05.019.
  38. Y.Kuznetsova; A.Neumann, S.R.Brueck (2007). "Imaging interferometric microscopy–approaching the linear systems limits of optical resolution". Optics Express . 15 (11): 6651–6663. Bibcode:2007OExpr..15.6651K. doi: 10.1364/OE.15.006651 . PMID   19546975.
  39. Yetisen, AK; Butt, H; da Cruz Vasconcellos, F; Montelongo, Y; Davidson, CAB; Blyth, J; Carmody, JB; Vignolini, S; Steiner, U; Baumberg, JJ; Wilkinson, TD; Lowe, CR (2013). "Light-Directed Writing of Chemically Tunable Narrow-Band Holographic Sensors". Advanced Optical Materials. 2 (3): 250–254. doi:10.1002/adom.201300375. S2CID   96257175.
  40. MartíNez-Hurtado, J. L.; Davidson, C. A. B.; Blyth, J.; Lowe, C. R. (2010). "Holographic Detection of Hydrocarbon Gases and Other Volatile Organic Compounds". Langmuir. 26 (19): 15694–15699. doi:10.1021/la102693m. PMID   20836549.
  41. 'Elastic hologram' pages 113–117, Proc. of the IGC 2010, ISBN   978-0-9566139-1-2 here: http://www.dspace.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/225960
  42. Beigzadeh, A.M. (2017). "Modelling of a holographic interferometry based calorimeter for radiation dosimetry". Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment. 864: 40–49. Bibcode:2017NIMPA.864...40B. doi:10.1016/j.nima.2017.05.019.
  43. Beigzadeh, A.M. (2018). "Double-exposure holographic interferometry for radiation dosimetry: A new developed model". Radiation Measurements. 119: 132–139. Bibcode:2018RadM..119..132B. doi:10.1016/j.radmeas.2018.10.010. S2CID   105842469.
  44. "Why has the government made high security registration plates mandatory". The Economic Times. ET Online. Retrieved 18 July 2021.
  45. R. E. Dunin-Borkowski et al., Micros. Res. and Tech. vol. 64, pp. 390–402 (2004)
  46. Ogai, K.; et al. (1993). "An Approach for Nanolithography Using Electron Holography". Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 32 (12S): 5988–5992. Bibcode:1993JaJAP..32.5988O. doi:10.1143/jjap.32.5988. S2CID   123606284.
  47. "Acoustic Holography". Bruel and Kjaer. Retrieved 3 September 2022.
  48. F. Shimizu; J.Fujita (March 2002). "Reflection-Type Hologram for Atoms". Physical Review Letters . 88 (12): 123201. Bibcode:2002PhRvL..88l3201S. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.88.123201. PMID   11909457.
  49. Swenson, Gayle (20 October 2016). "Move Over, Lasers: Scientists Can Now Create Holograms from Neutrons, Too". NIST. Retrieved 4 April 2017.
  50. Eisebitt, S.; et al. (2004). "Lensless imaging of magnetic nanostructures by X-ray spectro-holography". Nature. 432 (7019): 885–888. Bibcode:2004Natur.432..885E. doi:10.1038/nature03139. PMID   15602557. S2CID   4423853.
  51. Pfau, B.; et al. (2014). "Influence of stray fields on the switching-field distribution for bit-patterned media based on pre-patterned substrates" (PDF). Applied Physics Letters. 105 (13): 132407. Bibcode:2014ApPhL.105m2407P. doi:10.1063/1.4896982. S2CID   121512138.
  52. Chapman, H. N.; et al. (2007). "Femtosecond time-delay X-ray holography" (PDF). Nature. 448 (7154): 676–679. Bibcode:2007Natur.448..676C. doi:10.1038/nature06049. PMID   17687320. S2CID   4406541.
  53. Günther, C.M.; et al. (2011). "Sequential femtosecond X-ray imaging". Nature Photonics. 5 (2): 99–102. Bibcode:2011NaPho...5...99G. doi:10.1038/nphoton.2010.287.
  54. von Korff, Schmising; et al. (2014). "Imaging Ultrafast Demagnetization Dynamics after a Spatially Localized Optical Excitation" (PDF). Physical Review Letters. 112 (21): 217203. Bibcode:2014PhRvL.112u7203V. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.217203. Archived (PDF) from the original on 7 December 2023.
  55. "Holographic announcers at Luton airport". BBC News. 31 January 2011. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  56. Farivar, Cyrus (16 April 2012). "Tupac "hologram" merely pretty cool optical illusion". Ars Technica. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  57. "Holographic 3D Technology: From Sci-fi Fantasy to Engineering Reality". International Year of Light Blog. 28 September 2015. Archived from the original on 30 October 2017.
  58. Gordon, Marcus A. (2017). Habitat 44º (MFA). OCAD University. doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.30421.88802 .
  59. Sung, Carolyn; Gauk-Roger, Topher; Quan, Denise; Iavazzi, Jessica (16 April 2012). "Tupac returns as a hologram at Coachella". The Marquee Blog. CNN Blogs. Archived from the original on 4 May 2012. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  60. Brause; Mills (27 May 2022). "Super Trouper: ABBA returns to stage as virtual avatars for London gigs". Reuters. Retrieved 4 June 2022.
  61. Carter, Ninian (27 November 2018). "ABBA's mysterious "Abbatars" revealed". Graphic News. Retrieved 4 June 2022.
  62. Amorosi, A. D. (3 December 2023). "KISS Says Farewell at Madison Square Garden, Before Passing the Torch to Band's Avatar Successors: Concert Review". Variety . Retrieved 3 December 2023.
  63. "Crypton" クリプトン (in Japanese). Crypton.co.jp. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  64. G., Adrian. "LA's Anime Expo hosting Hatsune Miku's first US live performance on 2 July" . Retrieved 20 April 2012.
  65. ""We can invite Hatsune Miku in my room!", Part 2 (video)". Youtube.com. 7 September 2011. Archived from the original on 30 October 2021. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  66. "Technically incorrect: Tomorrow's Miley Cyrus? A hologram live in concert!" . Retrieved 29 April 2011.
  67. "Hatsune Miku – World is Mine Live in HD". YouTube . Retrieved 29 April 2011.
  68. "Burberry Beijing – Full Show". Youtube.com. Archived from the original on 4 October 2011. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  69. "Burberry lands in China" . Retrieved 14 June 2011.
  70. "First Hologram Protest in History Held Against Spain's Gag Law". revolution-news.com. Archived from the original on 13 April 2015. Retrieved 13 April 2015.
  71. "specular holography: how". Zintaglio.com. Retrieved 21 April 2012.
  72. 1 2 3 4 Johnston, Sean (2006). "The Hologram and Popular Culture". Holographic Visions: a History of New Science . Oxford: Oxford University Press, UK. pp.  405–408. ISBN   978-0191513886. OCLC   437109030.
  73. 1 2 Johnston, Sean F. (2015). "11 - Channeling Dreams". Holograms: A Cultural History. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0191021381.
  74. "Nova - Heroes of the Storm". us.battle.net. Retrieved 20 October 2019.
  75. Richardson, Martin (13 November 2017). The Hologram: Principles and Techniques. Wiltshire, John D. Hoboken, NJ. ISBN   978-1119088905. OCLC   1000385946.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)

Bibliography

Further reading