1878 Melbourne Cup

Last updated

1878 Melbourne Cup
Melbourne Cup
Location Flemington Racecourse
Date5 November 1878
Distance2 miles
Winning horseCalamia
Winning time3:35.75
Final odds10/1
Jockey Thomas Brown
Trainer Etienne de Mestre
Owner Etienne de Mestre
SurfaceTurf
Attendance≈80,000
  1877
1879  

The 1878 Melbourne Cup was a two-mile handicap horse race which took place on Tuesday, 5 November 1878. [1]

Contents

This year was the eighteenth running of the Melbourne Cup. Won by five-year-old Calamia, it was the fifth time a horse trained by Etienne de Mestre had won the Melbourne Cup. [2]

1877 cup winner Chester fell and collided with a post during the race. Chester's veteran jockey Joe Morrison was seriously injured in the fall, suffering a badly broken leg, an injury from which he never really recovered. [3] [4] [5]

Entries and odds

Highly fancied runner First King had suffered an injury prior to the race and had to be withdrawn by James Wilson ahead of the day of the race, while previous year's winner Chester had shown good form again in the lead-up, winning the Melbourne Stakes on the Saturday before the Melbourne Cup, easily beating both Cap-a-pie and Device. Savanaka, who had come second the previous year was not well-backed by its stable a year later, eventually being withdrawn from the race on the day. [6] Columbus had been heavily backed following the Victoria Derby which was won by Wellington. But the most backed runner was Wilson's Melita, taking favouritism ahead of Wellington and Firebell. [6] Many believed that Chester would be able to repeat its win from the year before. [7]

The race

Cup Day dawned under grey skies, but brightened as the morning progressed, and by the time the race was run the weather had turned to pleasant sunshine, albeit with a cool wind. [8] Following a number of withdrawals, 30 runners were sent to the start. Rapidity jumped clear after the flag fell, leading the field for more than the first mile of the race, Tom Kirk the only runner to match the speed of the leader. When Chester fell rounding a post, its jockey Joe Morrison was badly injured. The fall caused Glengarry to bolt inside the course. Wellington and Fireball looked in good position as the field tried to catch Rapidity, but it was Calamia that lead from beyond the final turn to ease home win by more than two lengths. Tom Kirk and Waxy finished in the minor placings, while the favourite Melita was never really in the race, having been run wide around much of the course. [8] [7]

For jockey Thomas Brown it was his first win in the Melbourne Cup. He would return as a trainer to win the race in 1880 with Grand Flaneur. The fifth win in the race for Etienne de Mestre confirmed his standing as Australia's first outstanding racehorse trainer, and his stables at Terrara near Nowra to be the finest in the country. [5] [9] [10] In typical style, de Mestre had backed his other runner Firebell to win the race, despite expressing confidence in Calamia. [11]

As a three-year-old, Calamia had previously won the Randwick Plate over three miles, as well as the Canterbury Plate. In other races, Calamia finished second in the VRC Champion Stakes and the Australian Cup. It was unplaced in a number of races earlier in 1878, having not raced since the autumn race meetings in Sydney. [12] [7] [11]

Attendances at the racecourse were estimated to be at a similar level to the previous years, [13] with thousands of visitors from the other colonies making their way to Melbourne. [7] Reporters questioned whether the VRC would need to extend the grandstands before the next running of the Melbourne Cup as "for every additional mile of railway that is constructed to connect the country districts with Melbourne an increase in the number of visitors at carnival times may be expected." [7]

Full results

This is the list of placegetters for the 1878 Melbourne Cup. [3] [14] [1] [15] [6] [8] [7] [11]

PlaceHorseAge
Gender
JockeyWeightTrainerOwnerOddsMargin
1Calamia5y hThomas Brown8 st 2 lb (51.7 kg) Etienne de Mestre Etienne de Mestre 10/12½ lengths
2Tom Kirk7y hWilliam Murphy7 st 8 lb (48.1 kg)Ike CarslakeMr C. James [a] 33/11¼ lengths
3Waxy6y hBraithwaite6 st 11 lb (43.1 kg)Ike CarslakeJames Liddell Purves16/1
4Swiveller4y hWilliam Yeomans7 st 13 lb (50.3 kg)Walter HickenbothamCharles Madden Lloyd25/1
5Wellington3y cJ. King5 st 13 lb (37.6 kg) [b] Edward Alfred Johnson-Boe8/1
6Strathearn4y hC. Gordon7 st 12 lb (49.9 kg)John TaitJohn Tait33/1
7Newminster5y hBrickwood Colley8 st 8 lb (54.4 kg)Andrew Chirnside25/1
8Glenormiston4y hGeorge Williams7 st 12 lb (49.9 kg)William FilgateWilliam Filgate25/1
9K.C.B.3y cEmsworth5 st 10 lb (36.3 kg)John TaitJohn Tait50/1
10Warlock3y cR. Walker6 st 7 lb (41.3 kg)Mr J. Paterson33/1
11Lockleys4y hJohn Kilduff [c] 8 st 5 lb (53.1 kg)Tom JordanTom Jordan33/1
12Riverton3y cC. Hutchins5 st 12 lb (37.2 kg)John Whittingham50/1
N/aCap-a-pie4y hW. Huxley8 st 8 lb (54.4 kg)Mr G. Hill20/1
N/aMacaroni6y gPaddy Pigott8 st 6 lb (53.5 kg)Thomas Ivory20/1
N/aRapidity4y hWeston7 st 5 lb (46.7 kg)Mr W. Brown33/1
N/aBurwood8y gSamuel Davis7 st 4 lb (46.3 kg)Mr S. Bradbury50/1
N/aColumbus6y hT. Aspinall7 st 3 lb (45.8 kg)Edward Alfred Johnson-Boe16/1
N/aDevilshoof4y hPearson7 st 2 lb (45.4 kg) Joe Thompson 100/1
N/aThe King6y hWilliam Samuel Cox Jr6 st 10 lb (42.6 kg) William Samuel Cox 50/1
N/aDarriwell4y hSam Cracknell8 st 8 lb (54.4 kg)William Algernon Guesdon [d] 20/1
N/aEmily3y fJ. Williamson6 st 6 lb (40.8 kg) Hercules Robinson 16/1
N/aGlengarry5y hDonald Nicholson6 st 6 lb (40.8 kg) Louis Lawrence Smith 100/1
N/aAuckland (late Maori)4y hCornwell6 st 5 lb (40.4 kg)Mr A.E. Cornwell12/1
N/aMelita3y f Peter St Albans 5 st 7 lb (34.9 kg) James Wilson Henry J. Bowler4/1 fav.
N/aNuma Pompilius4y gG. Poole5 st 7 lb (34.9 kg)Mr C.G. Baldock100/1
N/aFirebell4y hG. Burton5 st 7 lb (34.9 kg) William Samuel Cox 8/1
N/aPride Of The Vale3y fGeoghegan6 st 0 lb (38.1 kg)Mr R.T. Reid100/1
N/aFranciscan3y cJ. Deasy6 st 8 lb (41.7 kg)Stephen MahonStephen Mahon100/1
N/aDevice4y m Tom Hales 7 st 5 lb (46.7 kg)Tom JordanWilliam Pile50/1
FellChester4y hJoe Morrison9 st 0 lb (57.2 kg) Etienne de Mestre James White 12/1
SCRSavanaka4y hN/a8 st 1 lb (51.3 kg) James Wilson Herbert Power16/1
SCRDemocrat5y hN/a8 st 0 lb (50.8 kg) Etienne de Mestre James White
SCRHis Lordship3y cN/a7 st 4 lb (46.3 kg) Charles Brown Fisher
SCRVulcan3y cN/a7 st 3 lb (45.8 kg) Etienne de Mestre Etienne de Mestre
SCRRoodee3y cN/a7 st 1 lb (44.9 kg) Etienne de Mestre James White
SCRJasper3y cN/a6 st 6 lb (40.8 kg) Etienne de Mestre Etienne de Mestre
SCRMurrabinna4y hN/a6 st 5 lb (40.4 kg)John Crozier Jr
SCRCoongoola3y cN/a6 st 2 lb (39.0 kg)Mr F. Williams
SCRLillian3y fN/a5 st 8 lb (35.4 kg)Mr W. Kite

Prizemoney

First prize £1790, second prize £50, third prize £20. [1]

See also

Notes

  1. Alias of Friedrich Wilhelm Prell, a Melbourne businessman. [16]
  2. Was supposed to carry 5st 11lb
  3. Also known as Jack Kilduff
  4. A Tasmanian businessman, Guesdon used the alias "W. Rawlinson" for his racehorse ownership. [17]

References

  1. 1 2 3 "1878 Melbourne Cup MillersGuide". millersguide.identika.com.au. Archived from the original on 14 March 2022. Retrieved 12 January 2026.
  2. "The Cup Day". The Argus (Melbourne) . No. 10, 106. Victoria, Australia. 6 November 1878. p. 5. Retrieved 5 November 2021 via National Library of Australia.
  3. 1 2 "1871 to 1880 Melbourne Cup Winners". races com au. Retrieved 4 November 2021.
  4. "WINNERS AND PLACED HORSES IN MELBOURNE CUP. 1861-1913". Winner. Melbourne, Victoria. 28 October 1914. p. 4. Retrieved 12 January 2026.
  5. 1 2 Ibbett, Ian (21 December 2017). "1877 - The Defeat of Chester!". Kings of the Turf. Retrieved 12 January 2026.
  6. 1 2 3 "The Cup Race". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 5 November 1878. p. 6. Retrieved 13 January 2026.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "THE VRC Spring Meeting - Second (The Cup) Day". The Age. Melbourne, Victoria. 6 November 1878. p. 3. Retrieved 15 January 2026.
  8. 1 2 3 "The Cup Day". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 6 November 1878. pp. 5–6. Retrieved 15 January 2026.
  9. Walsh, G.P. "Etienne Livingstone de Mestre (1832–1916)". Australian Dictionary of Biography. Retrieved 15 January 2026.
  10. Rolfe, Costa (2008). Winners of the Melbourne Cup. Fitzroy, Australia: Red Dog. pp. 44–45. ISBN   9781742035093.
  11. 1 2 3 "Second (Cup) Day - Tuesday, Nov. 5". The Australasian. Melbourne, Victoria. 9 November 1878. pp. 10–11. Retrieved 15 January 2026.
  12. "The Melbourne Cup". South Australian Register. Adelaide, South Australia. 1 October 1878. p. 6. Retrieved 15 January 2026.
  13. "Melbourne Cup Day". Australasian Sketcher. Melbourne, Victoria. 23 November 1878. pp. 138–139. Retrieved 15 January 2026.
  14. Cavanough, Maurice (1978). The Melbourne Cup (8 ed.). p. 445. ISBN   0727004859.
  15. "Melbourne Cup Winners - 1861-1880". Victoria Racing Club. Retrieved 5 November 2025.
  16. "Death of Mr F.W. Prell". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 29 April 1912. p. 13. Retrieved 14 January 2026.
  17. "Darriwell". The Tasmanian. Launceston, Tasmania. 15 November 1879. p. 9. Retrieved 15 January 2026.