1871 Melbourne Cup

Last updated

1871 Melbourne Cup
Melbourne Cup
Location Flemington Racecourse
Date9 November 1871
Distance2 miles
Winning horse The Pearl
Winning time3:39.00
Final odds100/1
Jockey John Kavanagh
Trainer John Tait
OwnerJohn Tait
SurfaceTurf
Attendance40,000
  1870
1872  

The 1871 Melbourne Cup was a two-mile handicap horse race which took place on Thursday, 9 November 1871. [1]

Contents

This year was the eleventh running of the Melbourne Cup. It was the third Melbourne Cup win for owner and trainer John Tait. [2]

The Pearl was one of four horses to win the Melbourne Cup at 100/1. Wotan (1936), Old Rowley (1940) and Prince of Penzance (2015) being the other three.

Before the day of the race, Pyrrhus was heavily backed and was the favoured of the two runners owned and trained by John Tait. Previous winner Nimblefoot wasn't as favoured, although the horse that it beat by a half head in 1870, Lapdog was said to have been better prepared for a good run. [3] Lapdog's stablemate Romula would start favourite. Following a win in the Essendon Stakes during November, Mermaid was fancied by a few punters, while the lightly-raced Cleolite also attracted attention following the death of owner John Moffatt in the months prior to the race. Small grey horse Saladin was high on the betting sheets following a win in the Hotham Handicap. Previous winners Warrior and Glencoe were less fancied to feature in the placings, while Little Dick was noted as one to watch. [3]

After morning showers, the weather didn't brighten much for the race in the afternoon. Due to a public holiday, [4] the attendance at Flemington Racecourse was one of the largest seen, with the course crowded hours before the commencement of the race. [5]

There was be 23 starters for the race following the withdrawals of Lottery and Hamlet. [5] Saladin led the field ahead towards the first turn, but as the field rounded the turn, The Monk fell and Lord of Lynne threw its jockey. Both jockeys needing medical attention. [5] The fall almost took out Glencoe and a couple of other runners. [4] Barbelle took the lead down the back straight, with Saladin retaking the lead before the turn for home. Under the whip entering the Flemington straight, The Pearl dashed clear with Romula gamely keeping up, and it would be the 100/1 outsider The Pearl that was in front by two lengths at the winning post. [4] It was John Tait's third Melbourne Cup triumph as owner/trainer, following wins with The Barb (1866) and Glencoe (1868). [5] [4]

Following the race, the owner of second-placed finisher Romula protested against the winner, claiming that jockey John Kavanagh had struck Romula's jockey James Wilson Jr, but the protest was dismissed after a short deliberation by the stewards. Irish King was awarded third place ahead of Saladin. [5]

A training accident had seemingly discounted The Pearl's chances in the Melbourne Cup, with Tait uncertain that the horse would start. [6]

The Melbourne Cup was The Pearl's fourth win in 21 races, [5] while winning jockey John Kavanagh also won the 1865 Melbourne Cup riding Toryboy. [7] [8] Writing in The Age Kavanagh described the finish of the race:

The horse was covered with froth about the shoulders, and I kept saying to myself "I wish this was the post. I wish this was the post." I could feel Romula's breath puffing hot on my right leg. All at once I knew we were past the post by a tremendous big shout. I felt just as if I could fall off the horse. Then I dropped back upon the saddle, and the horse eased off with the rest. Almost before I could turn, there was a monster crowd of people all around me cheering, and so we went back to the stand. [9]

Full results

This is the list of placegetters for the 1871 Melbourne Cup. [10] [11] [1] [7] [3] [5] [4]

PlaceHorseAge
Gender
JockeyWeightTrainerOwnerOddsMargin
1 The Pearl 5y hJohn Kavanagh7 st 3 lb (45.8 kg)John TaitJohn Tait100/12 lengths
2Romula4y m James Wilson Jr 7 st 10 lb (49.0 kg) James Wilson Joe Thompson3/1 fav.1 length
3Irish King3y cHaughey6 st 0 lb (38.1 kg)Mr J.J. Miller50/1½ neck
4SaladinAged gDan Robinson6 st 7 lb (41.3 kg)Dan RobinsonMr J.R. Crocke7/1
5Little Dick5y gT. Brown8 st 8 lb (54.4 kg)Mr W. Winch7/1
6Mermaid5y mWilliam Simpson8 st 10 lb (55.3 kg) [a] James Wilson Mr E. Twomey14/1
7Pyrrhus4y hShields6 st 12 lb (43.5 kg)John TaitJohn Tait10/1
8Cleolite4y m Johnny Day 6 st 9 lb (42.2 kg) [b] John Moffatt (deceased)5/1
9The Baron6y gBryan7 st 5 lb (46.7 kg)Mr W. Winch33/1
N/aDuke of MontroseAged hFleeson6 st 12 lb (43.5 kg)Mr J. Brown33/1
N/a Glencoe Aged hWilliam Lang9 st 8 lb (60.8 kg)William LangHoratio Huntly Hoskins25/1
N/a Nimblefoot 8y gCharles Stanley9 st 2 lb (58.1 kg)William LangHoratio Huntly Hoskins33/1
N/aBarbelle6y mJoe Kean8 st 0 lb (50.8 kg)Mr E. Lee25/1
N/aBylongAged hBennett7 st 7 lb (47.6 kg)Thomas Ivory18/1
N/a Warrior Aged gWilliam Yeomans8 st 10 lb (55.3 kg)Robert Standish SeviorAustin Saqui20/1
N/aValentine6y mHiram Howard7 st 0 lb (44.5 kg)Henry Bowler25/1
N/aArumaAged mJ. Sherringham6 st 9 lb (42.2 kg)Mr J. Ilhffe25/1
N/aRamblerAged gChalker6 st 8 lb (41.7 kg)Phil Glenister100/1
N/aLapdogAged gSavage7 st 12 lb (49.9 kg) James Wilson Mr J. Gilbert5/1
N/aThe Foam5y mMcInnes7 st 5 lb (46.7 kg)William LangMr J. Arthur100/1
N/aPraetorAged hMathieson7 st 0 lb (44.5 kg)Mr P. Lewis25/1
FellThe Monk7y hWilliam Enderson7 st 2 lb (45.4 kg)Mr F. Henty50/1
FellLord of Lynne3y cCarey5 st 7 lb (34.9 kg)Messrs H. & B. Allen50/1
SCRLottery5y hN/a7 st 7 lb (47.6 kg)N/aMr T. LamondN/a
SCRHamlet3y cN/a6 st 10 lb (42.6 kg)N/aMr P. LewisN/a
SCRMiss Jessie3y fN/a5 st 12 lb (37.2 kg) James Wilson James Wilson N/a

Prizemoney

First prize £1040, second prize £50, third prize £20. [1]

See also

Notes

  1. Was supposed to carry 8st 8lb
  2. Was supposed to carry 6st 6lb

References

  1. 1 2 3 "1871 Melbourne Cup MillersGuide". millersguide.identika.com.au. Archived from the original on 23 March 2022. Retrieved 22 December 2025.
  2. Rutledge, Martha (1976). "Tait, John (1813–1888)". Australian Dictionary of Biography . Australian National University . Retrieved 27 May 2022.
  3. 1 2 3 "THE VRC Spring Meeting - The Cup Day". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 9 November 1871. p. 7. Retrieved 22 December 2025.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 "The Cup Day". The Australasian. Melbourne, Victoria. 11 November 1871. pp. 10–11.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 "THE VRC Spring Meeting - The Cup Day". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 10 November 1871. pp. 5–6. Retrieved 22 December 2025.
  6. Rolfe, Costa (2008). Winners of the Melbourne Cup. Fitzroy, Australia: Red Dog. pp. 29–30. ISBN   9781742035093.
  7. 1 2 "Melbourne Cup Winners - 1861-1880". Victoria Racing Club. Retrieved 5 November 2025.
  8. Kelly, Jen (28 October 2021). "Cup mystery solved". Herald-Sun. Melbourne, Victoria: News Corporation Australia. p. 57.
  9. "How the Melbourne Cup was won - The winning jockey's account of Pearl's victory". The Empire. Sydney, New South Wales. 20 November 1871. p. 3. Retrieved 22 December 2025.
  10. "1861 to 1870 Melbourne Cup Winners". races com au. Retrieved 27 May 2022.
  11. Cavanough, Maurice (1978). The Melbourne Cup (8 ed.). p. 445. ISBN   0727004859.