1884 Melbourne Cup

Last updated

1884 Melbourne Cup
Melbourne Cup
Malua.jpg
1884 Melbourne Cup winner Malua
Location Flemington Racecourse
Date4 November 1884
Distance2 miles
Winning horse Malua
Winning time3:31.75
Final odds6/1
Jockey Alec Robertson
Trainer Isaac Foulsham
OwnerJohn Ord Inglis
SurfaceTurf
Attendance≈100,000
  1883
1885  

The 1884 Melbourne Cup was a two-mile handicap horse race which took place on Tuesday, 4 November 1884. [1]

Contents

This year was the twenty-fourth running of the Melbourne Cup. The race was won by five-year-old stallion Malua, owned by John Ord Inglis. [2]

Entries and odds

Praised before the race as "the greatest horse in the country" and as "having the greatest dash of foot of any horse we have seen this season," [3] Malua was the pundits pick to win the race after winning the Melbourne Stakes on the Saturday before the race. [3] The only query was whether it could finish strongly across the two miles. [4]

Finishing a strong second in the Hotham Handicap, Hastings was seen as a strong chance across the two mile distance, with the horse eventually starting as the 5/1 favourite. Coming off a third placed finish in the Victoria Derby, Bargo was considered the strongest colt in the field following good form in Sydney, including winning the AJC Derby. [5] After winning the Caulfield Cup at long odds, Tasmanian horse Blink Bonny showed that it would be hard to beat in the race, having beaten short-priced favourite Vergy. [6] Of the other runners, there was some support for Off Colour, Hilltop and Claptrap. [7] [4]

Missing from the field were 1883 runners Le Grand, Despot and winner Martini-Henry, [7] with Martini-Henry retired to stud after being injured running unplaced in the 1884 Caulfield Cup. [8] [9] Also not in the field was 1884 Metropolitan Handicap winner Sir Modred, [4] while five-time winning trainer Etienne de Mestre was a notable absentee after financial and health problems saw his estate auctioned off in late 1883. [10]

For the second year in a row, Commotion was the top-weighted runner, carrying 9 st 12 lb (62.6 kg), slightly less than what it had been handicapped when finishing third in 1883. [4]

The race

Illustrations of the 1884 Melbourne Cup published in The Illustrated Australian News 1884 Melbourne Cup.tif
Illustrations of the 1884 Melbourne Cup published in The Illustrated Australian News

From the initial entry of 134 runners, [11] 24 horses headed to the start under cloudless skies with a hint of a breeze. [12] [13]

An even start saw Hill Top find its way to the front of the field, in front of Vergy, Signor and Anchorite. [14] Off Colour and Plausible brought up the rear of the field. Signor led the field past the stands and around the first turn, maintaining a lead of a length ahead of The Broker down the riverside part of the course. [14] The Plunger made a move at the top of the course, but was running against Lord Clifden while trying to go forward. Able to shake loose, The Plunger took the lead as Signor faded, leading a pack which included Bargo, Hill Top, The Broker, Commotion, Plausible, Malua and Hastings. At the final turn, The Plunger led by three lengths from Commotion. [12] [14] Down the Flemington straight, The Plunger tired badly with Commotion taking the lead ahead of Plausible. [12] To some observers it looked like Commotion had the race in its control, [12] but down the outside Malua came with a rush, taking the lead in the final stages to win by half a length from a gallant Commotion. [15] Plausible was third by more than two lengths having lost ground by swerving on the straight, [12] heading a large group of runners. Bristol, Tremando, Claptrap and Merrimu the last to cross the line. [2] The finishing time was the third fastest in the Melbourne Cup's history. [12]

A brown-bay five-year-old stallion, Malua was bred in Tasmania and purchased by Thomas Reibey as a yearling where it raced under the moniker of Bagot. [12] [16] The horse was sold at auction to John Ord Inglis for £500 in November 1882. Malua won the Newmarket Handicap earlier in 1884, also winning the Oakleigh Handicap and Adelaide Cup, then the Spring Stakes at Randwick in the spring season before the Melbourne Cup. [12]

As described in The Leader:

The Melbourne Cup of 1884 will long remain memorable for being associated with the victory of one of the best, if not the best, racehorses that ever tred Australia's turf. The performance was an equine triumph of the most pronounced order, and the style in which Malua cut down his field at the end of a severe two mile struggle under the crushing impact of 9st 9lb will not easily be obliterated from the memories of the thousands and tens of thousands who witnessed the spectacle. It was the conquest of a great horse in a great race and under what more judges of racing considered an annihilating burden. Nevertheless Malua accomplished the task assigned to him with comparitive ease, for there can be no mistaking that electric dash of his when he cut down the stable associates Commotion and Plausible in the last furlong, as if they were nothing more than a pair of common hacks. [15]

It was the first Melbourne Cup win for owner John Ord Inglis, trainer Isaac Foulsham and jockey Alec Robertson. It was reported that Robertson rode "with commendable patience" to win the race in the final stages. [14]

It was again estimated that a crowd of over 100,000 patrons attended the racecourse, with the "national holiday... rapidly becoming of wide intercolonial significance." [14] At least half of those in attendance had made their way to the racecourse via railway using Melbourne's Spencer Street railway station. [14]

Full results

This is the list of placegetters for the 1884 Melbourne Cup. [17] [18] [19] [20] [1] [16] [8] [2] [4] [12] [14]

PlaceHorseAge
Gender
JockeyWeightTrainerOwnerOddsMargin
1Malua5y hAlec Robertson [a] 9 st 9 lb (61.2 kg)Isaac FoulshamJohn Ord Inglis7/1½ length
2Commotion6y hPower9 st 12 lb (62.6 kg)Francis Dakin William Pearson 20/12½ lengths
3Plausible5y gMurphy6 st 13 lb (44.0 kg)Francis Dakin William Pearson 10/14 lengths
4Hastings (late Waterloo)5y hTeddy McGrade7 st 13 lb (50.3 kg)C.T. RobertsMr T. Sampson5/1 fav.
5Boolka5y hOlds7 st 7 lb (47.6 kg)H. BellamyMr S. Miller33/1
6Battalious (late Brisbane)5y hJ. Kelso7 st 7 lb (47.6 kg)DugganMr M. Griffin33/1
7Bargo3y c Tom Hales 7 st 6 lb (47.2 kg)Michael Fennelly James White 14/1
8The Plunger5y hPaddy Piggott8 st 11 lb (55.8 kg)J. RedfearnMr J. Redfearn12/1
9Lord Clifden8y hR. Davis7 st 0 lb (44.5 kg) [b] E. KeysMr E. Keys33/1
10Anchorite4y hT. Williams6 st 11 lb (43.1 kg) [c] J.D. RobertsonMr D.M. Robertson50/1
11Lord Wilton4y hSanders6 st 11 lb (43.1 kg)F. McNamaraMr E.W. Ellis50/1
12Brown and Rose3y fJim Gough7 st 3 lb (45.8 kg)J. BainesArthur F. Smart50/1
13Vergy4y hM. O'Brien7 st 6 lb (47.2 kg)William LangMr J.A. Lang12/1
14Off Colour4y hMoore8 st 10 lb (55.3 kg) James Wilson William Branch12/1
15Bonnie Bee8y gTrahan7 st 5 lb (46.7 kg)J. McDonaldMr W.J. Forrester50/1
16Hill Top5y hDonald Nicholson7 st 2 lb (45.4 kg)J. RedfearnMr M. Jacobs12/1
17Blink Bonny6y mJohn Williamson [d] 7 st 7 lb (47.6 kg)T. WilsonMr R.G. Talbot25/1
N/aThe Broker3y cEttridge7 st 1 lb (44.9 kg)Joe MorrisonMr A.R. Robertson50/1
N/aSignor4y hG. Williams6 st 13 lb (44.0 kg)W. DoyleMr E.P. Wilson50/1
N/aHippogriff3y cSam Cracknell6 st 11 lb (43.1 kg)W.H. GrayMr W.H. Gray33/1
N/aBristol4y hBrickwood Colley8 st 1 lb (51.3 kg)D. LawsonMr J. Mondy50/1
N/aClaptrap5y hCharles Ivimy7 st 4 lb (46.3 kg)J.R. CrookeJohn Whittingham25/1
N/aTremando3y cEllis6 st 9 lb (42.2 kg)Michael Fennelly James White 20/1
LastMerrimu3y cBacchus6 st 8 lb (41.7 kg)J.R. CrookeJohn Whittingham50/1
SCRGuesswork5y hN/a8 st 12 lb (56.2 kg) James Wilson Jr. James Wilson Jr.
SCRWarwick4y hN/a8 st 8 lb (54.4 kg)J. BainesArthur F. Smart
SCRSir Garnet (late The Hebrew)5y hN/a7 st 8 lb (48.1 kg)C.L. McDonaldMr T. Barnfield
SCRSeahorse3y cN/a6 st 7 lb (41.3 kg)Robert HowieRobert Howie
SCRSilver King3y cN/a7 st 0 lb (44.5 kg) James Wilson William Branch

Prizemoney

First prize £1977, second prize £300, third prize £200. [1]

See also

Notes

  1. Sometimes spelled Alick Robertson
  2. Was supposed to carry 6st 12lb
  3. Was supposed to carry 6st 9lb
  4. Also known as Jack Williamson

References

  1. 1 2 3 "1884 Melbourne Cup MillersGuide". millersguide.identika.com.au. Archived from the original on 14 March 2022. Retrieved 4 February 2026.
  2. 1 2 3 Reubertstein. The History of the Melbourne Cup from 1861 to 1894 (1895 ed.). Melbourne, Australia: James J. Miller. pp. 40–42.
  3. 1 2 "The Melbourne Cup". Sportsman. Melbourne, Victoria. 3 November 1884. p. 1. Retrieved 5 February 2026.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 "The Eve of the Cup". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 4 November 1884. p. 7. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  5. Ibbett, Ian (29 December 2017). "1884 – Newmarket – and the Hon. James White!". Kings of the Turf. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  6. "Caulfield Cup Day". Sportsman. Melbourne, Victoria. 22 October 1884. p. 1 (supplement). Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  7. 1 2 "The Melbourne Cup". The Age. Melbourne, Victoria. 4 November 1884. p. 5. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  8. 1 2 Rolfe, Costa (2008). Winners of the Melbourne Cup. Fitzroy, Australia: Red Dog. pp. 55–59. ISBN   9781742035093.
  9. "In the days of Martini-Henry". Sporting Judge. Melbourne, Victoria. 2 November 1914. p. 1. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  10. Ibbett, Ian (27 December 2017). "1882 – The Fall of the Master of Terrara!". Kings of the Turf. Retrieved 28 January 2026.
  11. "Racing - The Melbourne Cup and Champion Entries". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 3 June 1884. p. 6. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 "Cup Day". The Argus. Melbourne, Victoria. 5 November 1884. pp. 5–7. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  13. "Cup Day". The Leader. Melbourne, Victoria. 8 November 1884. p. 7. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  14. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 "The Second (Cup) Day". The Leader. Melbourne, Victoria. 8 November 1884. pp. 19–20. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  15. 1 2 "Turf Topics and Anticipatons". The Leader. Melbourne, Victoria. 8 November 1884. p. 17. Retrieved 6 February 2026.
  16. 1 2 "Melbourne Cup Winners - 1881-1900". Victoria Racing Club. Retrieved 5 November 2025.
  17. "1881 to 1890 Melbourne Cup Winners". races com au. Retrieved 21 September 2021.
  18. "1881 to 1890 Melbourne Cup Winners". races com au. Retrieved 12 November 2021.
  19. "WINNERS AND PLACED HORSES IN MELBOURNE CUP. 1861-1913". Winner. Melbourne, Victoria. 28 October 1914. p. 4. Retrieved 12 January 2026.
  20. Cavanough, Maurice (1978). The Melbourne Cup (8 ed.). p. 445. ISBN   0727004859.