1920 Rock Island Independents season

1920 Rock Island Independents season
General manager	Walter Flanigan
Head coach	Rube Ursella
Home field	Douglas Park
Results
Record	6–2–2
League place	T-4th in APFA
AP All-Pros	7 Fred Denfield Dewey Lyle Ed Novak Obe Wenig (2nd) Ed Shaw (2nd) Walt Buland (3rd) Freeman Fitzgerald (3rd)
←  1919 Rock Island Independents 1921  →

The 1920 Rock Island Independents season was the American football franchise's thirteenth season and inaugural season in the American Professional Football Association (APFA). The Independents hosted first ever APFA/National Football League contest on September 26, 1920. After the AFPA had been formed on September 17, 1920, Douglas Park was the venue as the Independents hosted the St. Paul Ideals, winning 48-0 in the new league's first contest. ^{[1] [2]}

The Independents entered the season coming off a nine-win, one-loss, one-tie (9–1–1) record in 1919 as an independent team, which the team proclaimed to be the "Champions of the USA". After the 1919 season, several representatives from the Ohio League, another American football league, wanted to form a new professional league; thus, the APFA was created.

A majority of the team stayed from the 1919 team, including the coaching staff, but Keith Dooley was added to the roster. The Independents opened the season with a win against the St. Paul Ideals, a non-APFA team. This was the first game in the history of the APFA. The team played all but one game at their home field, Douglas Park, and ended the season with a 6–2–2 record, which placed the team tied-for-fourth in the league standings.

The sportswriter Bruce Copeland compiled the All-Pro list for the 1920 season. Fred Denfield, Dewey Lyle, and Ed Novak made the first-team; Obe Wenig and Ed Shaw made the second-team; and Walt Buland and Freeman Fitzgerald made the third-team. Of all the players on the roster, only Ed Healey has been enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Background

Team photograph of the 1919 Rock Island Independents, when the team claimed the USA Championship.

The Rock Island Independents finished 9–1–1 in their 1919 season, claiming the National Championship. ^{[3] [4]} For the 1920 season, the Independents added multiple players to its roster: Keith Dooley, who previously played from 1912 to 1916; Fred Denfield, Mark Devlin, and Harry Gunderson, who previously played in 1917; Ed Healey, Polly Koch, George Magerkurth, Ed Shaw, Ben Synhorst, Harry Webber, Obe Wenig, and Arnie Wyman. The team lost Wes Bradshaw, Leland Dempsey, Al Jorgenson, Loyal Robb, Fats Smith, Red Swanson, and co-coach John Roche. ^{[5] [6] [7]}

After the 1919 season, representatives of the Canton Bulldogs, the Cleveland Tigers, the Dayton Triangles, and the Akron Pros met on August 20, 1920, to discuss the formation of a new league. At the meeting, they tentatively agreed on a salary cap and pledged not to sign college players or players already under contract with other teams. They also agreed on a name for the circuit: the American Professional Football Conference. ^{[8] [9]} They then invited other professional teams to a second meeting on September 17.

At that meeting, held at Bulldogs owner Ralph Hay's Hupmobile showroom in Canton, representatives of the Rock Island Independents, the Muncie Flyers, the Decatur Staleys, the Racine Cardinals, the Massillon Tigers, the Chicago Cardinals, and the Hammond Pros agreed to join the league. Representatives of the Buffalo All-Americans and Rochester Jeffersons could not attend the meeting, but sent letters to Hay asking to be included in the league. ^[10] Team representatives changed the league's name slightly to the American Professional Football Association and elected officers, installing Jim Thorpe as president. ^{[10] [11] [12]} Under the new league structure, teams created their schedules dynamically as the season progressed, so there were no minimum or maximum number of games needed to be played. ^{[13] [14]} Also, representatives of each team voted to determine the winner of the APFA trophy. ^[15]

Schedule

Douglas Park, home of the Independents, circa 1920

1920 Rock Island Independents season ^{[6] [16]}

Week	Date	Opponent	Result	Venue	Attendance	Record
1	September 26	vs. St. Paul Ideals †	W 48–0	Douglas Park	800	1–0
2	October 3	vs. Muncie Flyers	W 45–0	Douglas Park	3,110	2–0
3	October 10	vs. Hammond Pros	W 26–0	Douglas Park	2,554	3–0
4	October 17	vs. Decatur Staleys	L 0–7	Douglas Park	7,000	3–1
5	October 24	vs. Chicago Cardinals	W 7–0	Douglas Park	4,000	4–1
6	October 31	vs. Chicago Tigers	W 20–7	Douglas Park	—	5–1
7	November 7	vs. Decatur Staleys	T 0–0	Douglas Park	4,991	5–1–1
8	November 11	at Chicago Thorn-Tornadoes†	T 7–7	Monmouth College Athletic Park	—	5–1–2
	November 14	vs. Dayton Triangles	L 0–21	Douglas Park	—	5–2–2
9	No game scheduled
10	November 28	vs. Pittsburgh All-Collegians	W 48–7	Douglas Park	2,500	6–2–2
11	No game scheduled
12	No game scheduled
13	No game scheduled

Game summaries

Week 1: vs. St. Paul Ideals

	1	2	3	4	Total
Ideals	0	0	0	0	0
Independents	14	14	14	6	48

September 26, 1920, at Douglas Park, Rock Island, Illinois

To start its 1920 season, the Independents played the first game in the history of the league against the non-APFA St. Paul Ideas.^{[ citation needed ]} This was the Ideals' second game of the season, coming off a 14–7 victory the week prior. ^[17] Coach Flanigan had Fred Chicken, Bobby Marshall, and Freeman Fitzgerald—the 1919 Independents' main stars—in reserve in case he needed to play them. ^[18] The Independents shutout the Ideals, winning 48–0. ^[19] Every touchdown by the Independents were rushing. In the first quarter, Ed Novak and Chicken both scored; Novak and Jerry Mansfield scored in the second quarter.^{[ citation needed ]} The Independents scored 14 points in the third quarter with touchdowns from Ray Kuehl and Mansfield.^{[ citation needed ]} In the final quarter, Kuehl scored the Independents' last points of the game. ^[18]

Week 2: vs. Muncie Flyers

	1	2	3	4	Total
Flyers	0	0	0	0	0
Independents	21	10	7	7	45

October 3, 1920, at Douglas Park

Rock Island Independents played against the Muncie Flyers after their victory. It is considered to be one of the first games played with two APFA teams. ^[20] The Columbus Panhandles played against the Dayton Triangles on the same day; however, in 1920, starting times were not standardized. Thus, it is unknown which of the two games started first. In the first quarter, the Independents scored three touchdowns: two from Arnold Wyman and one from Rube Ursella. In the second quarter, Ursella scored kicked a 25-yard (23 m) field goal, and Wyman scored from an 86-yard (79 m) kickoff return. In the third quarter, Sid Nichols had a 5-yard (4.6 m) rushing touchdown, and Waddy Kuehl scored a 7-yard (6.4 m) rushing touchdown. The final score of the game was 45–0. ^[21] This game was the only one that counted towards the Flyers' standing for the entire 1920 season.

Week 3: vs. Hammond Pros

	1	2	3	4	Total
Pros	0	0	0	0	0
Independents	0	13	0	13	26

October 10, 1920, at Douglas Park

This was the Pros' first game of the 1920 season. There were no scores by either team in the first or third quarters, but the Independents scored 13 points in the second and fourth. ^[22] Back Fred Chicken scored a 1-yard (0.91 m) rushing touchdown; back Ray Kuehl scored two touchdowns: a 5-yard (4.6 m) rushing touchdown and a 35-yard (32 m) receiving touchdown from back Pudge Wyman; and back Gerald Mansfield caught a 20-yard (18 m) receiving touchdown from Wyman.^{[ citation needed ]} Hammond started to purposely injure their opponents during the game. As a result, Rube Ursella suffered a twisted knee. Duey Lyle was kicked in the face and required seven stitches. Lastly, Ed Healey was kicked in the face and needed five stitches in the cheek. ^[22]

Week 4: vs. Decatur Staleys

	1	2	3	4	Total
Staleys	0	7	0	0	7
Independents	0	0	0	0	0

October 17, 1920, at Douglas Park

In week 4, the Independents played the Decatur Staleys. After two games against non-APFA teams, the Staleys played against an APFA team. Late in the first quarter, the Independents' Freeman Fitzgerald forced a fumble on Jimmy Conzelman; Fitzgerald retrieved it at the 49-yard (45 m) line. The Independents drove the ball down the field, and the Staleys' players were tired. As a result, they called a timeout. With possession on the 23-yard (21 m) line, Arnie Wyman rushed for 10-yard (9.1 m), and the Independents were in the Red zone. The first quarter ended there. Wyman took the next snap and fumbled as he was tackled. George Trafton recovered the ball at the 8-yard (7.3 m) line. Later in the quarter, Conzelman scored the only touchdown in the game. ^[23]

In the third quarter, Fred Chicken intercepted a Staley pass on the Independents' 28-yard (26 m) line. Early in the fourth quarter, the Staleys drove to the Independents' 14-yard (13 m) line, where they lined up for a field goal. Wyman blocked the kick, however. The Independents next possession resulted in a punt, and the Staleys started the possession at their own 7-yard (6.4 m) line. On this possession, Kuehl intercepted a pass. The Independents attempted a Hail Mary pass late in the game, but it was unsuccessful. The game ended a few minutes later with the Staleys with possession. ^[23]

Week 5: vs. Chicago Cardinals

	1	2	3	4	Total
Cardinals	0	0	0	0	0
Independents	0	7	0	0	7

October 24, 1920, at Douglas Park

Coming off their first loss of the season, the Independents played against the Chicago Cardinals in week 5, with 4,000 spectators in attendance.^{[ citation needed ]} The Independents out-gained the Cardinals in yards; the Independents had 263 total yards while the opponent had 153. ^[24] The only score was in the second quarter when Wyman caught a 6-yard (5.5 m) receiving touchdown from Nichols, making the final score 7–0.^{[ citation needed ]} This was the first loss of the season for the Cardinals. ^[25]

Week 6: vs. Chicago Tigers

	1	2	3	4	Total
Tigers	0	7	0	0	7
Independents	6	0	7	7	20

October 31, 1920, at Douglas Park

In week six, the Independents played the Chicago Tigers. The Independents out-gained the Tigers in first downs, 14 to 3. ^[26] The first score of the game was a 6-yard (5.5 m) rushing touchdown by Chicken; however, the extra point was missed, so the score was only 6–0.^{[ citation needed ]} The Tigers took the lead in the second quarter after Dunc Annan had a 2-yard (1.8 m) rushing touchdown.^{[ citation needed ]} Chicken ended up having two rushing touchdowns, and Wyman had another rushing touchdown, as the Independents beat the Tigers 20–7. ^[26]

Week 7: vs. Decatur Staleys

	1	2	3	4	Total
Staleys	0	0	0	0	0
Independents	0	0	0	0	0

November 7, 1920, at Douglas Park

On a five-game winning streak, the Staleys played against the Independents again. The game ended in a 0–0 tie. Several injuries occurred throughout the game for the Independents. Sid Nichols, Fred Chicken, and Oak Smith injured their knees on different plays. Harry Gunderson was hit late by George Traften and the former had to get thirteen stitches on his face, and his hand was broken. ^[27]

Week 8: at Chicago Thorn-Tornadoes

	1	2	3	4	Total
Independents	0	0	0	7	7
Thorn-Tornadoes	0	0	0	7	7

November 11, 1920, at Monmouth College Athletic Park

In the Independents' first road game of the season, they traveled to Monmouth, Illinois, to play the Chicago Thorns-Tornadoes. The Thorns' players decided to have 10-minute quarters. The game was a tie for the first three quarters. In the fourth quarter, however, Kuehl muffed a punt while standing at his own 20-yard (18 m) line. Mooney of the Thorn-Tornadoes picked up the football and ran it back for a touchdown with only 3 minutes left in the game. At this time, Ursella was substituted for Kuehl. After a kickoff return to the 44-yard (40 m) line, the Independents used Novak, Mansfield, and Jordan to help score before time expired. Ursella kicked the game-tying extra point to end the game a 7–7 tie. ^[28]

Week 8: vs. Dayton Triangles

	1	2	3	4	Total
Triangles	7	0	0	14	21
Independents	0	0	0	0	0

November 14, 1920, at Douglas Park

For their second game in week eight, the Independents played against the Dayton Triangles. The Independents had six players returning from injuries this game. ^[29] In the first quarter, Rube Ursella for the Independents fumbled a punt on the 40-yard (37 m) line, and the Triangles gained possession. ^[29] On that possession, Frank Bacon scored a rushing touchdown.^{[ citation needed ]} The Independents controlled the football for a majority of the second quarter. On their final possession of the half, they traveled to the Triangles' 4-inch (100 mm) line, but the referee signaled to end the first half. ^[29] In the fourth quarter, Ed Novack and Arnold Wyman left the game due to injury. ^[29] The Triangles scored two passing touchdowns in the final 10 minutes of the game; the first was caught by Dave Reese, and the second was caught by Roudebush.^{[ citation needed ]}

Week 10: vs. Pittsburgh All-Collegians

	1	2	3	4	Total
All-Collegians	0	0	7	0	7
Independents	14	20	7	7	48

November 28, 1920, at Douglas Park

In their final game that counted for the standings, the Independents played the Pittsburgh All-Collegians. There were three names for this team, the Pittsburgh All-Collegians, ^[30] the Wheeling Collegians, ^[16] and the Washington and Jefferson All-Stars.^{[ citation needed ]} This game was originally supposed to be played against the Canton Bulldogs, but it was cancelled. ^[16] Most players from the All-Collegians did not show up for the game, and the coach used people from the crowd to form a team. ^[30] The first score of the game came in the first quarter when Wenig blocked a punt and returned it for a touchdown.^{[ citation needed ]} The only points the All-Collegians scored was a blocked punt from Morris, who returned it for a touchdown. ^[30] This was the only points the team scored all year. ^[31] The game ended with a 48–7 victory for the Independents.^{[ citation needed ]}

Post season

Since there were no playoff system in the APFA until 1932, ^[32] a meeting was held to determine the 1920 APFA Champions. ^[33] Each team that showed up had a vote to determine the champions. The Akron Pros were awarded the Brunswick-Balke Collender Cup on April 30, 1921. ^[15] Ties were not counted in standings until 1972, which is why Akron is credited with a 1.000 winning percentage. ^[34] The Independents tied for fourth place in the standings. The sportswriter Bruce Copeland compiled the All-Pro list for the 1920 season. Denfield, Lyle, and Novak made the first-team; Wenig and Shaw made the second-team; and Buland and Fitzgerald made the third-team. ^[35] Of all the players on the roster, only Healey has been enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. ^[36]

Standings

Walter Flanigan, manager of the 1920 Rock Island Independents

1920 APFA standings [37]
view talk edit	W	L	T	PCT	DIV	DPCT	PF	PA	STK
Akron Pros†	8	0	3	1.000	6–0–3	1.000	151	7	T2
Decatur Staleys	10	1	2	.909	5–1–2	.833	164	21	T1
Buffalo All-Americans	9	1	1	.900	4–1–1	.800	258	32	T1
Chicago Cardinals	6	2	2	.750	3–2–2	.600	101	29	T1
Rock Island Independents	6	2	2	.750	4–2–1	.667	201	49	W1
Dayton Triangles	5	2	2	.714	4–2–2	.667	150	54	L1
Rochester Jeffersons	6	3	2	.667	0–1–0	.000	156	57	T1
Canton Bulldogs	7	4	2	.636	4–3–1	.571	208	57	W1
Detroit Heralds	2	3	3	.400	1–3–0	.250	53	82	T2
Cleveland Tigers	2	4	2	.333	1–4–2	.200	28	46	L1
Chicago Tigers	2	5	1	.286	1–5–1	.167	49	63	W1
Hammond Pros	2	5	0	.286	0–3–0	.000	41	154	L3
Columbus Panhandles	2	6	2	.250	0–4–0	.000	41	121	W1
Muncie Flyers	0	1	0	.000	0–1–0	.000	0	45	L1

 †  Awarded the Brunswick-Balke Collender Cup and named APFA Champions.
Note: Tie games were not officially counted in the standings until 1972.

Roster

Rock Island Independents 1920 roster [38]
	Quarter Backs Mark Devlin Sid Nichols Rube Ursella Running backs Fred Chicken Tom Henry Waddy Kuehl Jerry Mansfield FB Ed Novak Paddy Quinn Ed Shaw Arnold Wyman		Linemen Walt Buland RT Fred Denfield LT Freeman Fitzgerald C Harry Gunderson C Ed Healey T Polly Koch RG Dewey Lyle LT George Magerkurth LG Bobby "Rube" Marshall RE Charlie Mockmore G Ben Synhorst T Oak Smith LE Harry Webber E Obe Wenig E Guido Wyland LG		Coaching Staff Rube Ursella – Head Coach Walter Flanagan – Manager

• FB – Fullback
• RT – Right tackle
• LT – Left tackle
• C – Center
• RG – Right guard
• LG – Left guard

Notes

1. "NFL founded in Canton | Pro Football Hall of Fame Official Site".
2. "St. Paul Ideals at Rock Island Independents - September 26th, 1920". Pro-Football-Reference.com .
3. Braunwart & Carroll 1983 , p. 7
4. "1919 Rock Island Independents". The Pro Football Archives. Maher Sports Media. Retrieved November 29, 2012.
5. Herrera, Simon. "Giant Tackle Answers the Call of Cleveland". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved November 29, 2012.
6. Herrera, Simon. "1920 Season Schedule". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved December 5, 2012.
7. Herrera, Simon. "1919 Season Schedule". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved March 23, 2013.
8. PFRA Research 1980 , pp. 3–4
9. Siwoff, Zimmber & Marini 2010 , pp. 352–353
10. PFRA Research 1980 , p. 4
11. "Thorpe Made President" (PDF). The New York Times. September 19, 1920.
12. "Organize Pro Gridders; Choose Thorpe, Prexy". The Milwaukee Journal . September 19, 1920. p. 24. Archived from the original on July 11, 2012.
13. Peterson 1997 , p. 74
14. Davis 2005 , p. 59
15. Price, Mark (April 25, 2011). "Searching for Lost Trophy". Akron Beacon-Journal . Retrieved June 23, 2012.
16. "1920 Rock Island Independents (APFA)". The Pro Football Archives. Maher Sports Media. Retrieved December 5, 2012.
17. "1920 St. Paul Ideals". The Pro Football Archives. Maher Sports Media. Retrieved November 23, 2012.
18. Herrera, Simon. "Game Showing Consistency of Best Pro Team in World". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved November 23, 2012.
19. "1920 Rock Island Independents". Pro-Football-Reference.com . Sports Reference. Retrieved November 23, 2012.
20. Braunwart & Carroll 1981 , p. 1
21. Herrera, Simon. "Wyman's Play too much for Hoosier Team". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved November 30, 2012.
22. Herrera, Simon. "Independents Outplayed and Outclass Beefy 'Stars". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved October 29, 2012.'
23. Herrera, Simon. "Lack of Practice and Poor Physical Condition Account for First Upset of Season". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved November 30, 2012.
24. Herrera, Simon. "Independents Beat Cardinals from Chicago". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved December 6, 2012.
25. "1920 Chicago Cardinals (APFA)". The Pro Football Archives. Maher Sports Media. Retrieved December 6, 2012.
26. Herrera, Simon. "Chicago Tigers Prove no Match for Locals". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved December 6, 2012.
27. Herrera, Simon. "Lack of Practice and Poor Physical Condition Account for First Upset of Season". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved November 30, 2012.
28. Herrera, Simon. "Injured Independents Fight to a Tie with Thorns". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved December 5, 2012.
29. Herrera, Simon. "Lack of Practice and Poor Physical Condition Account for First Upset of Season". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved November 30, 2012.
30. Herrera, Simon. "Independents Use All Star Team to Get Back on Track". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved December 5, 2012.
31. "1920 Wheeling Collegians". The Pro Football Archives. Maher Sports Media. Retrieved December 5, 2012.
32. "History: The First Playoff Game". Pro Football Hall of Fame. Archived from the original on June 3, 2011. Retrieved June 10, 2011.
33. Carroll 1982 , p. 3
34. Siwoff, Zimmber & Marini 2010 , p. 360
35. Hogrogian 1984 , pp. 1–2
36. "Ed Healey". Pro Football Hall of Fame. Archived from the original on August 29, 2012. Retrieved December 6, 2012.
37. "NFL – 1920 Regular Season". National Football League . Retrieved January 6, 2013.
38. Herrera, Simon. "1920 R.I. Independents". RockIslandIndependents.com. Retrieved November 30, 2012.

References

• Carroll, Bob (1982). "Akron Pros 1920" (PDF). The Coffin Corner . 4 (12). Professional Football Researchers Association. Archived from the original (PDF) on March 11, 2012.
• Braunwart, Bob; Carroll, Bob (1981). "The First NFL Game(s)" (PDF). The Coffin Corner . 3 (2). Professional Football Researchers Association. Archived from the original (PDF) on March 11, 2012.
• Braunwart, Bob; Carroll, Bob (1983). "The Rock Island Independents" (PDF). The Coffin Corner . 5 (3). Professional Football Researchers Association. Archived from the original (PDF) on October 22, 2012. Retrieved November 29, 2012.
• Davis, Jeff (2005). Papa Bear, The Life and Legacy of George Halas. McGraw-Hill. ISBN   0-07-146054-3.
• Hogrogian, John (1984). "1920 All-Pros" (PDF). The Coffin Corner. 6 (1). Professional Football Researchers Association. Archived from the original (PDF) on August 8, 2014.
• Peterson, Robert (1997). Pigskin: The Early Years of Pro Football. Oxford University Press. ISBN   0-19-507607-9.
• PFRA Research (1980). "Happy Birthday NFL?" (PDF). The Coffin Corner . 2 (8). Professional Football Researchers Association. Archived from the original (PDF) on March 11, 2012.
• Siwoff, Seymour; Zimmber, Jon; Marini, Matt (2010). The Official NFL Record and Fact Book 2010. National Football League. ISBN   978-1-60320-833-8.

External links

• Rock Island Independents website
• Rock Island Independents at Pro Football Reference