2009 Pel-Air Westwind ditching

Last updated

2009 Pel-Air Westwind ditching
Pel-Air (VH-KNR) IAI 1124A Westwind parked at Sydney Airport.jpg
A Pel-Air Westwind II, sister aircraft to that involved in the accident
Accident
Date18 November 2009 (2009-11-18)
SummaryDitching

Pilot error (ATSB)/(CASA)

Pilot error, ATC error, operational issues within Pel-Air (TSB)
Site Norfolk Island
29°04′30″S167°57′00″E / 29.075°S 167.95°E / -29.075; 167.95
Aircraft
Aircraft type IAI 1124A Westwind II
Operator Pel-Air
Call signVICTOR HOTEL NOVEMBER GOLF ALPHA
Registration VH-NGA
Flight origin Apia, Samoa
Stopover Norfolk Island
Destination Melbourne
Passengers4
Crew2
Fatalities0
Survivors6

The 2009 Pel-Air Westwind ditching or Norfolk Island ditching was an aircraft accident on 18 November 2009 near Norfolk Island, Australia. A Westwind II jet operated by Pel-Air was conducting an air ambulance flight for CareFlight International when it was forced to ditch after being unable to land in bad weather and not having sufficient fuel to divert to an alternate destination.

Contents

The official accident report issued 2+12 years later by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) attracted wide criticism, and resulted in an Australian Senate Enquiry that found both the ATSB and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) had failed to carry out their responsibilities with respect to the accident investigation. In response to the criticism, the ATSB requested that the Transportation Safety Board of Canada review the ATSB's investigation methodologies and processes, [1] and subsequently reopened the investigation on 8 December 2014. [2] The final report of the reopened investigation was released on 23 November 2017, and contained 531 pages and 36 safety factors. [3]

Flight details

On 18 November 2009, an IAI 1124A Westwind II conducted an air ambulance flight from Apia, Samoa to Melbourne on behalf of CareFlight. The aircraft was scheduled to land at Norfolk Island to refuel, but weather conditions deteriorated while it was en route. The aircraft did not carry enough fuel to divert to an alternate destination. [4]

After not being able to make visual observation of the runway after four instrument approaches, [4] the crew ditched the aircraft in open sea 6 kilometres (3.2 nmi) west of Norfolk Island in darkness and bad weather. [4] A pocket torch that the captain had in his possession and used as a distress signal was spotted from land in an area of the sea where the search and rescue effort was initially not concentrated; all six occupants were rescued by local fishermen after 90 minutes in the water. [3] [5]

Investigation

The accident report by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) states "At Apia, the pilot in command submitted a flight plan by telephone to Airservices Australia. At that time, the forecast weather conditions at Norfolk Island for the arrival did not require the carriage of additional fuel for holding, or the nomination of an alternate airport". The ATSB report further states that the main tanks of the aircraft were full "which would provide sufficient fuel and reserves for the flight". [6] The press reported that the pilot was suspended pending the outcome of the official investigation. [7] The Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) investigated the flight planning, fuel planning and management, and decision-making that contributed towards the accident. [7]

Senate inquiry and controversy

On 23 May 2013 a report was released by the Australian Senate following an inquiry into the ATSB investigation of the ditching. [8] This inquiry was sparked by a Four Corners documentary that aired allegations of misconduct by the ATSB and CASA. [9] The Senate's report found that the ATSB accident report was deeply flawed and unfairly blamed the pilot wholly for the accident, and as a consequence the Senate recommended that the accident report be withdrawn and re-done.

"It is disappointing that CASA and the ATSB continue to assert, in the face of evidence to the contrary, that the only part of the system with any effect on the accident sequence was the pilot.."

Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee [10]

The Senate committee determined that the ATSB's decision not to retrieve the flight recorders was incongruous with its responsibilities under International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Chicago Convention Annex 13. [11] It also found evidence of collusion between the agencies; that CASA deliberately withheld the Chambers Report from the ATSB; and that the heads of both agencies gave testimony that wasn't credible. The committee made a total of 26 recommendations covering the accident, the operations of the ATSB and the operations of CASA. The committee also passed evidence to the Australian Federal Police, pending the possibility of charges being laid against individuals from CASA who were involved in breaching the Transport Safety Investigation Act 2003. [12]

Subsequent actions

In response to the criticism, the ATSB requested the Transportation Safety Board of Canada (TSB) to review the Australian investigation methodologies and processes. The TSB review concluded that the ATSB's methodologies and processes met or exceeded the recommended practices described in ICAO Annex 13, but its application to the accident at Norfolk Island fell short of the ATSB's own standards. [1] On 8 December 2014, the ATSB reopened the investigation. On 11 November 2015 the flight recorders were retrieved from the wreckage on the seabed. [2] [3] Both flight recorders contained valid data. [3] The final report of the reopened investigation was released on 23 November 2017. [3]

In the 531-page final report, most of the responsibility was still placed on the pilot for inadequate fuel planning and weather checking. [13] However, the report also acknowledged that the pilot was operating within company rules and regulatory guidance, both of which were lax. [13] [3] In particular, air ambulance flights were classified as "aerial work" rather than "charter", resulting in such flights being subjected to looser requirements than other passenger-carrying flights. [3] It also commented that air traffic controllers at Nadi and Auckland failed to inform the pilot of the deteriorating weather conditions at Norfolk Island before the flight reached the point of no return, although the pilot also did not proactively request such information. [3]

Footnotes

  1. 1 2 "Independent review of the Australian Transport Safety Bureau's investigation methodologies and processes". Transportation Safety Board of Canada. 1 December 2014.
  2. 1 2 "ATSB begins action on Canadian review". Australian Transport Safety Bureau. 8 December 2014.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Australian Transport Safety Bureau Aviation Safety Investigation Report – IAI 1124A VH-NGA. Retrieved 4 April 2017.
  4. 1 2 3 "Ditching – Norfolk Island – 18 November 2009" (PDF). Australian Transport Safety Bureau. 13 January 2010. Archived from the original on 24 March 2010. Retrieved 7 March 2010.
  5. "CareFlight/Pel-Air Medical Evacuation Incident – Samoa to Melbourne" (Press release). Regional Express Holdings. 19 November 2009. Retrieved 20 November 2009.
  6. Veness 2010.
  7. 1 2 Robinson 2010.
  8. Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee 2013, p. 59.
  9. Thompson & Masters 2012.
  10. Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee 2013, p. xxi.
  11. Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee 2013, pp. 29–30.
  12. Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee 2013.
  13. 1 2 Higgins, Ean (23 November 2017). "Pel-Air pilot who ditched plane in sea acted 'within lax guidelines'". The Australian .

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moorabbin Airport</span> Municipal airport serving Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Moorabbin Airport is a mostly general aviation airport for light aircraft located in between the southern Melbourne suburbs of Heatherton, Cheltenham, Dingley Village and Mentone. It also receives commercial airline service. The airport grounds are treated as their own suburb, and share the postcode 3194 with the neighbouring suburb of Mentone. With a total of 274,082 aircraft movements, Moorabbin Airport was the second busiest airport in Australia for the calendar year 2011.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robinson R44</span> Family of American light helicopters

The Robinson R44 is a four-seat light helicopter produced by Robinson Helicopter Company since 1992. Based on the company's two-seat Robinson R22, the R44 features hydraulically assisted flight controls. It was first flown on 31 March 1990 and received FAA certification in December 1992, with the first delivery in February 1993.

Rex Airlines Pty Ltd is an Australian regional airline based in Mascot, New South Wales. It operates scheduled regional and domestic services. It is Australia's largest regional airline outside the Qantas group's companies and serves all 6 states across Australia. It is the primary subsidiary of Regional Express Holdings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Australian Transport Safety Bureau</span> National transport safety investigator in Australia

The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) is Australia's national transport safety investigator. The ATSB is the federal government body responsible for investigating transport-related accidents and incidents within Australia. It covers air, sea and rail travel. The ATSB is an independent Commonwealth Government statutory agency, governed by a Commission and is separate from transport regulators, policy makers and service providers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pel-Air</span> Australian airline

Pel-Air Aviation Pty Ltd is an airline based in Mascot, Sydney, Australia. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Regional Express Holdings, which also owns Australian airline Rex Airlines.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bathurst Airport (New South Wales)</span> Airport

Bathurst Airport is an airport serving Bathurst, New South Wales, Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Garuda Indonesia Flight 200</span> 2007 passenger plane crash in Yogyakarta, Indonesia

Garuda Indonesia Flight 200(GA200/GIA 200) was a scheduled domestic passenger flight of a Boeing 737-400 operated by Garuda Indonesia between Jakarta and Yogyakarta, Indonesia. The aircraft overran the runway, crashed into a rice field and burst into flames while landing at Adisucipto International Airport on 7 March 2007. Twenty passengers and one flight attendant were killed. Both pilots survived, and were fired shortly after the accident occurred. It was the fifth hull-loss of a Boeing 737 in Indonesia within less than six months and was the most recent accident with fatalities involving the airline.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Qantas Flight 30</span> 2008 aviation incident

Qantas Flight 30, on 25 July 2008, a Boeing 747-438 operated by Qantas, construction number 25067, registration VH-OJK, was a scheduled flight from London Heathrow to Melbourne with a stopover in Hong Kong. The flight was interrupted on the Hong Kong leg by an exploding oxygen tank that ruptured the fuselage just forward of the starboard wing root. 53-year-old Captain John Bartels and his co-pilots, Bernd Werninghaus and Paul Tabac, made an emergency descent to a breathable altitude of about 10,000 feet (3,048 m) and diverted to Ninoy Aquino International Airport, Metro Manila, Philippines. There were no injuries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cootamundra Airport</span> Airport in Cootamundra, New South Wales

Cootamundra Airport is a small airport in Cootamundra, New South Wales, Australia. The airport is also the venue for the annual GTR Challenge and Drag Battle motorsport event.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2000 Australia Beechcraft King Air crash</span> Aviation accident in Australia

On 4 September 2000, a chartered Beechcraft 200 Super King Air departed Perth for a flight to the mining town of Leonora, Western Australia. The aircraft crashed near Burketown, Queensland, Australia, resulting in the deaths of all eight occupants. During the flight, the aircraft climbed above its assigned altitude. When air traffic control (ATC) contacted the pilot, the pilot's speech had become significantly impaired, and he was unable to respond to instructions. Three aircraft intercepted the Beechcraft, but were unable to make radio contact. The aircraft continued flying on a straight north-easterly heading for five hours, before exhausting its fuel and crashing 40 mi (65 km) south-east of Burketown. The crash became known in the media as the "ghost flight".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lockhart River air disaster</span> 2005 aviation accident

The Lockhart River air disaster occurred on 7 May 2005, when Aero-Tropics Air Services Flight 675 crashed while on approach to land at Lockhart River Airport in Queensland, Australia, on a ridge known as South Pap 6 nautical miles (11 km) north-west of the airport. All fifteen on board died as the aircraft was completely destroyed by impact forces and subsequent fire. The Fairchild Swearingen Metroliner commuter aircraft, registered VH-TFU, was owned by Transair Ltd and operated by Aero-Tropics. The flight was scheduled from Bamaga on Cape York to the regional centre of Cairns, with a stopover in Lockhart River. It was the worst air crash in Australia in 36 years since MacRobertson Miller Airlines Flight 1750 on 31 December 1968.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Qantas Flight 72</span> 2008 aircraft incident

Qantas Flight 72 (QF72) was a scheduled flight from Singapore Changi Airport to Perth Airport by an Airbus A330. On 7 October 2008, the flight made an emergency landing at Learmonth Airport near the town of Exmouth, Western Australia, following an inflight accident that included a pair of sudden, uncommanded pitch-down manoeuvres that caused severe injuries—including fractures, lacerations and spinal injuries—to several of the passengers and crew. At Learmonth, the plane was met by the Royal Flying Doctor Service of Australia and CareFlight. Fourteen people were airlifted to Perth for hospitalisation, with 39 others also attending hospital. In all, one crew member and 11 passengers suffered serious injuries, while eight crew and 99 passengers suffered minor injuries. The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) investigation found a fault with one of the aircraft's three air data inertial reference units (ADIRUs) and a previously unknown software design limitation of the Airbus A330's fly-by-wire flight control primary computer (FCPC).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emirates Flight 407</span> 2009 aviation accident in Melbourne, Australia

Emirates Flight 407 was a scheduled international passenger flight operated by Emirates from Auckland to Dubai with a stopover in Melbourne, operated by an Airbus A340-500 aircraft. On 20 March 2009, the flight failed to take off properly at Melbourne Airport, hitting several structures at the end of the runway before climbing and then returning to the airport for a safe landing. Although no fatalities or injuries resulted, damage to the aircraft was severe enough for the event to be classified by Australian Transport Safety Bureau as an "accident". It was subsequently determined that a data-entry error resulted in insufficient engine thrust during take off. It has been described "as close as we have ever come to a major aviation catastrophe in Australia" by aviation officials.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Qantas Flight 32</span> 2010 Airbus A380 engine incident

Qantas Flight 32 was a regularly scheduled passenger flight from London to Sydney via Singapore. On 4 November 2010, the aircraft operating the route, an Airbus A380, suffered an uncontained failure in one of its four Rolls-Royce Trent 900 engines. The failure occurred over the Riau Islands, Indonesia, four minutes after takeoff from Singapore Changi Airport. After holding for almost two hours to assess the situation, the aircraft made a successful emergency landing at Changi. No injuries occurred to the passengers, crew, or people on the ground, despite debris from the aircraft falling onto houses in Batam.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Angel Flight</span> Public benefit flying organizations

Angel Flight is the name used by a number of groups whose members provide free air transportation for passengers in need of medical treatment far from home and perform other missions of community service. Such a non-profit organization may be located in the United States, Europe, Australia, or Canada. Transportation is provided by volunteer pilots, often using their own general aviation aircraft. In most of Canada, the Volunteer Pilot Program of Hope Air provides a similar service, along with Angel Flight of Vancouver.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2012 Queensland DH.84 Dragon crash</span> Air accident in Australia

On 1 October 2012, Riama, a 1934 vintage de Havilland DH.84 Dragon passenger aircraft, crashed in Queensland, Australia, while flying from Monto to Caboolture. Radio contact was lost about an hour after the pilot reported to be in cloud with zero visibility. The wreckage was found in heavily wooded, hilly terrain two days later. The pilot and five passengers were killed in the accident.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Whyalla Airlines Flight 904</span> 2000 aviation accident

Whyalla Airlines Flight 904 was a scheduled commuter flight, operated by a Piper PA-31 Navajo which crashed while attempting to ditch in the Spencer Gulf, South Australia after suffering failures of both engines on the evening of 31 May 2000. All 8 people on board the aircraft were killed as a result of the accident. The findings of a subsequent investigation by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau highlighting the airline's operating procedures as a key factor leading to the accident were later overturned after they were contradicted by evidence presented at a coronial inquiry into the deaths of those on board the flight. The safety implications arising from the accident were subject to a recall by engine manufacturer Textron Lycoming which saw close to 1000 aircraft grounded worldwide while defects were rectified at an estimated cost of $A66 million. Australia's aviation regulator, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority also mandated lifejackets be carried on all aircraft operating over water after the crash.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2017 Essendon Airport Beechcraft King Air crash</span>

On 21 February 2017, at 8:59 am local time, a Beechcraft B200 King Air aircraft operating a charter flight, carrying a pilot and four passengers bound for King Island, crashed seconds after taking off from Essendon Airport in Melbourne, Australia.

Aviair Pty Ltd, previously known as Slingair Heliwork, is an airline and air charter company based in Kununurra, Western Australia. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of HM Consolidated Pty Ltd. It operates air charter services and regular passenger services. Its main bases are Kununurra Airport, Broome International Airport and Karratha Airport.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1994 South Pacific Airmotive DC-3 crash</span> Douglas DC-3 crash in Sydney, New South Wales

The 1994 South Pacific Airmotive DC-3 crash took place on 24 April 1994, when a Douglas DC-3 airliner operated by South Pacific Airmotive, tail number VH-EDC, ditched into Botany Bay shortly after takeoff from Sydney Airport in Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. The cause of the crash was determined by the Bureau of Air Safety Investigation to have been a power loss in the aircraft's left engine caused by an inlet valve being stuck in the open position, compounded by inadequate action on the part of the pilots; Rod Lovell, the pilot in command of the flight, has disputed BASI's conclusions.

References