A Signal of Peace

Last updated
A Signal of Peace
IndianPeace.JPG
Artist Cyrus Edwin Dallin
Year1890
Type Bronze
Dimensions150 cm× 76 cm× 150 cm(5 ft× 2.5 ft× 5 ft)
Location Chicago, Illinois, United States
Coordinates 41°56′00″N87°37′53″W / 41.9332°N 87.63145°W / 41.9332; -87.63145

A Signal of Peace is an 1890 bronze equestrian sculpture by Cyrus Edwin Dallin located in Lincoln Park, Chicago. Dallin created the work while studying in Paris and based the figure on a member of Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show, which he attended often. He exhibited the original plaster version of the sculpture at the Paris Salon of 1890, where it won honorable mention. [1]

Contents

In 1893, Lambert Tree bought the bronze version of the statue at the World's Columbian Exposition for $10,000, and donated it to Lincoln Park in Chicago, where it has stood since the summer of 1894. [2]

Despite Dallin's admiration for Indigenous people and his objection to their mistreatment by white settlers, the monument has sometimes been criticized as reinforcing stereotypes about Native Americans as "savages" and a "dying race." [3]

Background

Dallin grew up in Springville, Utah, where he lived in a settlement near the Paiute and Ute tribes. His English father, Thomas Dallin, encouraged Cyrus and his siblings to play with children from the tribes in the area. From these experiences, Dallin learned how to use a bow and arrow, ride a horse, and play Paiute and Ute games. Dallin cited this upbringing as the source of his interest in Indigenous people and culture. [1]

The Epic of the Indian

A Signal of Peace is one of Dallin's four most prominent sculptures of Indigenous people, alongside The Medicine Man (1899), Protest of the Sioux (1904), and Appeal to the Great Spirit (1908). The four works are sometimes described as a series known as The Epic of the Indian.

Dallin himself did not refer to the four sculptures as a series, but critics have often interpreted the works as a narrative about the fate of Native Americans. According to this reading, the series begins with A Signal of Peace depicting the "naive" welcome of Europeans by the Indian chief. This moment is followed by hesitancy and the realization that white settlers may cause harm in The Medicine Man. With The Protest of the Sioux, the American Indian is seen as fighting back against mistreatment from settlers. Appeal to the Great Spirit is then interpreted to represent the defeat of Indigenous people, as the Native American adopts a pose of surrender. [3]

Design process and funding

The Buffalo Bill Wild West Show in 1890, taking place in the Bois de Boulogne in Paris, France. Buffalo Bills Wild West Show, 1890.jpg
The Buffalo Bill Wild West Show in 1890, taking place in the Bois de Boulogne in Paris, France.

Dallin conceived the sculpture while studying in Paris at the Académie Julian with Henri Michel Chapu from 1888-1890. During this time, he made frequent visits to Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show, which was playing in the Bois de Boulogne. Rosa Bonheur, who worked alongside Dallin during this time, was similarly intrigued by the show and made sketches of Buffalo Bill with other Indigenous people, horses, and buffalo. Dallin elected to create a life-size equestrian statue depicting a Sioux Indian chief, using Philip, son of Kicking Bear, as the model for the statue. [2]

He first completed a plaster version of the statue and entered it into the Paris Salon of 1890, where it won honorable mention, which was uncommon for an American artist to receive at the time. [1] He then paid for a bronze version of the sculpture to be cast in Paris. [3] :11 The bronze was later exhibited at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition. The Chicago judge Lambert Tree purchased this version of the sculpture and donated it to Lincoln Park, where it was dedicated on June 9, 1894. [3] :11

Visual properties

View of Lake Michigan from Lincoln Park in Chicago, Illinois. Lincoln Park By Lake Michigan.jpg
View of Lake Michigan from Lincoln Park in Chicago, Illinois.

The monument is a life-size bronze statue that depicts a Native American man who is barely clothed with just moccasins, a loincloth, and a feathered headpiece, riding on top of a horse. His left arm rests on the horse's neck, while his other hand is stretched upward holding a long spear. The expression on the individual's face is one of a friendly and welcoming nature, thought to be representing the first meeting with the Europeans who were colonizing North America.[ citation needed ] The statue is raised on a high granite pedestal, with a plaque reading: "A SIGNAL OF PEACE" with "The Gift of Lambert Tree" directly underneath. The statue overlooks the shore of Lake Michigan. [4]

Political contestation

A Signal of Peace displayed at the Paris Salon of 1890. Signalofpeace.gif
A Signal of Peace displayed at the Paris Salon of 1890.

A Signal of Peace, along with the three other monuments that make up The Epic of the Indian, has been criticized as contributing to the depiction of Native Americans as a "defeated and dying race," supporting the "vanishing race mythology."[ citation needed ]

However, Dallin's unpublished manuscripts, newspaper interviews, and old letters have been used as evidence that he was an advocate for the American indigenous people, and critiqued their mistreatment by white settlers. A reviewer in 1909 even praised Dallin for his work with Native Americans, saying that "Mr. Dallin knows the Indian psychically as well as physically. He has not only put himself inside his skin, as we say, but he has climbed into his consciousness and studied the way his kind works." [3]

While Dallin's intentions in representing Native Americans were initially viewed in positive terms, more recently his work has been critiqued as art that silences the voices of Native Americans, and overshadows their agency.[ citation needed ] It has also been pointed out that Dallin has made several generalizations in blending together different tribal cultures.[ citation needed ] For example, The Protest of the Sioux is intended to represent the struggles and adversity of all of the western tribes in the U.S., but the end-title of the work just represents the Sioux people. Since Dallin never made any published statement regarding the correct interpretation of these works, it shows that he did not immediately strike down the interpretations that involved the "vanishing race mythology," possibly to gain favor with white patrons and increase the marketability of his work.[ citation needed ]

The art historian Emily C. Burns argues that it is important to distinguish between the "intention and reception" of Dallin's work. She emphasizes that Dallin's statues were created as "ambivalent monuments that posed a subtle political challenge for those willing to engage in imaginative, critical looking." But she acknowledges that they have come to be perceived by many as problematic and disrespectful to the Native American people. [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Earle Fraser (sculptor)</span> American sculptor (1876-1953)

James Earle Fraser was an American sculptor during the first half of the 20th century. His work is integral to many of Washington, D.C.'s most iconic structures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alexander Phimister Proctor</span> American sculptor

Alexander Phimister Proctor was an American sculptor with the contemporary reputation as one of the nation's foremost animaliers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Solon Borglum</span> American sculptor (1868–1922)

Solon Hannibal de la Mothe Borglum was an American sculptor. He is most noted for his depiction of frontier life, and especially his experience with cowboys and native Americans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henri Chapu</span> French sculptor

Henri-Michel-Antoine Chapu was a French sculptor in a modified Neoclassical tradition who was known for his use of allegory in his work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cyrus Edwin Dallin</span> American sculptor (1861–1944)

Cyrus Edwin Dallin was an American sculptor best known for his depictions of Native Americans. He created more than 260 works, including the Equestrian Statue of Paul Revere in Boston; the Angel Moroni atop Salt Lake Temple in Salt Lake City; and Appeal to the Great Spirit (1908), at the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. He was also an accomplished painter and an Olympic archer.

<i>Appeal to the Great Spirit</i> Equestrian statue by Cyrus Dallin in Boston, Massachusetts, US

Appeal to the Great Spirit is a 1908 equestrian statue by Cyrus Dallin, located in front of the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. It portrays a Native American on horseback facing skyward, his arms spread wide in a spiritual request to the Great Spirit. It was the last of Dallin's four prominent sculptures of Indigenous people known as The Epic of the Indian, which also include A Signal of Peace (1890), The Medicine Man (1899), and Protest of the Sioux (1904).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Francis Edwin Elwell</span> American sculptor

Francis Edwin Elwell was an American sculptor, teacher, and author.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National American Indian Memorial</span>

The National American Indian Memorial or North American Indian Memorial was a proposed monument to Native Americans to be erected on a bluff overlooking the Narrows, the main entrance to New York Harbor. The major part of the memorial was to be a 165-foot-tall (50 m) statue of a representative American Indian warrior atop a substantial foundation building housing a museum of native cultures, similar in scale to, but higher than, the Statue of Liberty several miles to the north. Ground was broken to begin construction in 1913 but the project was never completed and no physical trace remains today.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas W. Evans</span> American dentist (1823–1897)

Thomas Wiltberger Evans was an American dentist. He performed dental procedures on many heads of state, including Napoleon III, and received numerous medals for his dentistry, including the Grand Croix of the Légion d'honneur. He is noted for popularizing a number of techniques that have since become standard, including the use of amalgam fillings and of nitrous oxide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brigham Young Monument</span> Sculpture by Cyrus Edwin Dallin

The Brigham Young Monument is a bronzed historical monument located on the north sidewalk of the intersection at Main and South Temple Streets of Salt Lake City, Utah. It was erected in honour of pioneer-colonizer, Utah governor, and LDS Church president Brigham Young who led the Mormon pioneers into the Utah Territory in 1847. The base of the twenty-five-foot monument has the bronze figure of an Indian facing east and that of a bearded fur trapper facing west, both of which preceded the Mormon settlers. On the south side is a bronze bas-relief of a pioneer man, woman, and child, while another bronze plaque has a list of the pioneers who arrived in the Salt Lake Valley on July 24, 1847, and their equipment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John J. Boyle (sculptor)</span> American sculptor

John J. Boyle was an American sculptor active in Philadelphia in the last decades of the 19th century, known for his large-scale figurative bronzes in public settings, and, particularly, his portraiture of Native Americans.

<i>The Medicine Man</i> (Dallin) Sculpture by Cyrus Edwin Dallin installed in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, U.S.

The Medicine Man is an 1899 bronze equestrian statue by Cyrus Edwin Dallin located on Dauphin Street, west of 33rd Street, in Fairmount Park in Philadelphia. The statue portrays an indigenous American medicine man.

The End of the Trail is a sculpture by James Earle Fraser. Fraser created the original version of the work in 1894, and he subsequently produced numerous replicas in both plaster and bronze. The sculpture depicts a weary Native American man, wearing only the remains of a blanket and carrying a spear. He is hanging limp as his weary horse with swollen eyes comes to the edge of the Pacific Ocean. The wind blowing the horse's tail suggests they have their backs to the wind. The man in the statue is based on Seneca Chief John Big Tree, and the horse was adapted from one in another work, In the Wind. The statue is a commentary on the damage Euro-American settlement inflicted upon Native Americans. The main figure embodies the suffering and exhaustion of people driven from their native lands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pioneer Monument (San Francisco)</span> Monument in San Francisco, California, U.S.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cyrus Dallin Art Museum</span> United States historic place

The Cyrus Dallin Art Museum (CDAM) in Arlington, Massachusetts, United States is dedicated to displaying the artworks and documentation of American sculptor, educator, and Indigenous rights activist Cyrus Dallin, who lived and worked in the town for over 40 years. He is well known for his sculptural works around the US including The Scout in Kansas City, Missouri, TheSoldiers' and Sailors' Monumentin Syracuse, New York and The Signal of Peace in Chicago. Locally, he is best known for his iconic Appeal to the Great Spirit and Paul Revere Monument statues, both located in Boston.

John David Brcin was an American sculptor and artist.

<i>Protest of the Sioux</i>

Protest of the Sioux, also known as The Protest, is a 1904 equestrian statue by Cyrus Dallin. It was the third of four important statues of indigenous people on horseback commonly known as The Epic of the Indian, which also includes A Signal of Peace (1890), The Medicine Man (1899), and Appeal to the Great Spirit (1908).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Statue of Anne Hutchinson</span> Statue in Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.

A statue of Anne Hutchinson by Cyrus Edwin Dallin is installed outside the Massachusetts State House, in Boston, Massachusetts, United States.

<i>Massasoit</i> (statue) Statue in Plymouth, Massachusetts, U.S.

Massasoit is a statue by the American sculptor Cyrus Edwin Dallin in Plymouth, Massachusetts. It was completed in 1921 to mark the three hundredth anniversary of the Pilgrims' landing. The sculpture is meant to represent the Pokanoket leader Massasoit welcoming the Pilgrims on the occasion of the first Thanksgiving. Several replicas of the statue exist across the United States, including numerous small-scale souvenir reproductions.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Ewers, John C. (Winter 1968). "Cyrus E. Dallin, Master Sculptor of the Plains Indian". Montana The Magazine of Western History. 18 (1): 34–43. JSTOR   4517220 via JSTOR.
  2. 1 2 Francis, Rell (1976). Cyrus E. Dallin: Let Justice Be Done. Cyrus Dallin Art Museum: Springville Museum of Art. pp. 39–40. ASIN   B001P4T6JQ.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Burns, Emily C. (Spring 2018). "Political Contestation Cyrus Dallin's American Indian Monuments". Archives of American Art Journal. 57 (1): 4–21. doi:10.1086/698333. S2CID   158388796 via The University of Chicago Press Journals.
  4. Pomeroy, E. Wilbur (February 1914). "Cyrus E. Dallin and the North American Indian: Four Statues Which Express the Fate of a Dying Race". Arts & Decoration (1910-1918). 4 (4): 152–153. JSTOR   43807357.