Selections
| ^ | Denotes players who are still active in the BAL |
| * | Elected to the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame |
| Player (X) | Denotes the number of times the player has been selected |
| Player (in bold text) | Indicates the player who won the BAL Most Valuable Player in the same year |
2021 to 2023
From 2021 to 2023, the BAL announced the first team selection.
| Season | Pos. | Player | Team | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | G | Walter Hodge | Zamalek | [1] |
| G | Wael Arakji | US Monastir | ||
| G | Omar Abada | US Monastir | ||
| F | Makrem Ben Romdhane | US Monastir | ||
| C | Anas Mahmoud | Zamalek | ||
| 2022 [a] | G | Édgar Sosa | Zamalek | [3] |
| G | Terrell Stoglin | AS Salé | ||
| F | Carlos Morais | Petro de Luanda | ||
| F | Radhouane Slimane | US Monastir | ||
| C | Ater Majok ^ | US Monastir | ||
| 2023 | G | Chris Crawford^ | AS Douanes | [4] |
| G | Jean Jacques Boissy^ | AS Douanes | ||
| F | Dane Miller Jr.^ | SLAC | ||
| F | Nuni Omot ^ | Al Ahly | ||
| C | Aliou Diarra^ | Stade Malien |
2024–present
| Season | First team | Second team | Ref. | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Player | Team | Player | Team | ||
| 2024 | Chris Crawford (2)^ | US Monastir | Abdoulaye Harouna^ | AS Douanes | [5] [2] |
| Will Perry^ | Rivers Hoopers | Ehab Amin^ | Al Ahly | ||
| Samkelo Cele^ | Cape Town Tigers | Kelvin Amayo^ | Rivers Hoopers | ||
| Jo Lual-Acuil^ | Al Ahly Ly | Devine Eke^ | Rivers Hoopers | ||
| Aliou Diarra (2)^ | FUS Rabat | Majok Deng^ | Al Ahly Ly | ||
| 2025 | Jean Jacques Boissy (2)^ | Al Ahli Tripoli | Mohamed Sadi^ | Al Ahli Tripoli | [6] [7] |
| Jaylen Adams^ | Al Ahli Tripoli | Babacar Sané | US Monastir | ||
| Majok Deng (2)^ | Al Ittihad Alexandria | Ivan Almeida | Kriol Star | ||
| Patrick Gardner^ | Petro de Luanda | Taefale Lenard | MBB | ||
| Aliou Diarra (3)^ | APR | Youssou Ndoye | APR | ||
