Battle of Khasauka

Last updated

Battle of Khasauka
Part of the Caucasian War and Russo-Circassian War
Bitva u gory Khotsek'(Khasauka)..jpg
Geevsky E.P. "Battle of Mount Chotzek 19 October 1828"
Date17 – 29 October 1828
Location
Result Russian victory
Belligerents
Qaracay-Malqar bayraq.jpg Karachay troops
Flag K'arachaia 1828g.jpg Balkar volunteers
Flag of Russia.svg  Russian Empire
Commanders and leaders
Oliy Islam Krymshamkhalov General Georgi Emmanuel
Strength
About 500–700 About 3,000, 13 guns, 2 mortars
Casualties and losses
UnknownOn 20 October:
~44 killed and 120 wounded
After the whole expedition:
~69 killed and 193 wounded
or
~800 killed and wounded

The Battle of Khasauka (Battle of the Khasauka Pass, Battle of Mount Khasauka, Karach-Balk.-Khasauka Urush) was a battle during the Caucasian War between the Russian imperial troops and the Karachay militia, which took place from 17 October (29 October) till 29 October (10 November), 1828 near the village of Kart-Dzhurt. It ended with the defeat of the mountaineers, but Karachay would remain independent until the formal annexation of Karachay to the Russian Empire in 1834. [1] [2] [3]

Contents

Background

Mountainous, high-altitude Karachay were located at the source of the Kuban River. Its geographical position allowed the Karachays to periodically intervene in the course of the Caucasian War. In 1826, an agreement was reached between representatives of Karachay and the tsarist administration on the neutrality of Karachay in the Caucasian War. [4] However, it no longer suited the Russian administration, which was determined to completely annex the region through which the Western and Eastern Caucasus communicated. The Karachay also threatened the stability of the imperial presence in the region, as many of them felt a stronger allegiance to the Ottoman empire, with whom they shared the Islamic faith with. in 1826, even before the arrival of General Emmanuel with a Russian army in the Caucasus, the Karachais had "sworn allegiance to the Ottoman Empire and gave amanates there in opposition to the peace treaty between Russia and the Porte...". [5]

Aware of the importance of the Karachais' dependence on the Ottoman Empire, Anapa Pasha made every effort to ensure that the Karachais were "subjects of the Turkish Empire", and one of these propaganda made a strong impression on the Karachais, and they "showed especially lively activity in raids on our line in during the war with Persia ...". [6]

After the conquest of Kabarda and the annexation of Balkaria to the Russian Empire, a number of gorges in Balkaria and Karachay remained refuges for Kabardian, Karachay, Balkar and other mountain detachments that continued resistance to the Russian administration. [7]

In 1826, Mohammed (Amantish) Dudov fled from Karachay, who subsequently, on the eve of Emmanuel's campaign in Karachay, was in Nalchik. Due to disagreements with Oliy Islam Krymshamkhalov, Dudov agreed to cooperate with the Russians and gave important information about the approaches to Karachay and acted as a guide for Russian troops. [4] [8]

On 11 January (23), 1827, the Balkar-Digor delegation arrived in Stavropol and in January took the oath before the commander of the Russian troops in the North Caucasus, General Georgiy Emmanuel, as a result of which the Balkars and Digors were accepted into Russian citizenship. From that time on, the Karachays living in inaccessible gorges began to pose the greatest danger to some Russian possessions in the Caucasus. [9]

The warlike population of Karachay, relying on their natural strongholds, could always represent a formidable force for us, but the lack of convenient places for arable farming and the lack of convenient pastures forced them to enter into trade relations with the Cossacks settled on the Caucasian line. With its geographical location, Karachay separated the Trans-Kuban mountain peoples from the Kabardians and other tribes who lived in the center of the Caucasian line, not allowing them to help each other and act against us with their combined forces... [10] In the journal of military operations for the month of June 1827, there is evidence that the Karachais, having formed a "party" of 300 people, stole Cossack cattle from the Baksan River and other places. In the same magazine for the month of November, a case of correspondence between the Russian authorities and the Anapa Pasha was noted. Informing him that the Karachais, as living on the right side of the Kuban, are considered, according to the treaty between Russia and Turkey, to be "Russian subjects," the Russian authorities asked the Turkish Pasha to keep the "fugitive Kabardians" who lived in Karachay from inciting the Karachais against the Russians and their raids on Russian possessions. [11]

Taking advantage of the inaccessible terrain, the Karachais not only carried out "daring raids" themselves, but in June 1828 they "took part in the destruction of villages. Gentle ", and in their villages for a long time there were parties of abreks and other Circassians who fought against Russia. [5] At the same time of the Circassian raid on the village of Nezlobnaya, another "detachment of predators", consisting of Kabardians and Karachais, numbering about three thousand, was noticed in the zone between Urup and B. Zelenchuk, and was advancing towards Batalpashinsk. From the morning of 8 June 1828 until dusk, there was a skirmish between this detachment and Russian troops. [6]

In the "most loyal report" of Count Ivan Paskevich dated 16 November 1828, the following was subsequently noted about the reasons for the campaign against the Karachays [12]

General Emanuel reports that in order to ensure calm on the line, he considered it necessary to undertake an expedition against the Karachais: „a people living on the snowy heights of the Caucasus, in the peaks of the Kuban, who, in the hope of the inaccessibility of their lands, fearlessly gave shelter and assistance to all Trans-Kuban predators who passed through their lands for carrying out raids in the space between Kuban and Terek. Therefore, in the fall of 1828, under the leadership of General Emmanuel, a military campaign was undertaken against the Karachay people. The Russian detachment, among other officers, included the commander of the Mountain Cossack Regiment , Major P. S. Verzilin.[ citation needed ]

Order of battle

The combined strength of the Russian Empire's detachments was about 3000 combat units with 13 guns and 2 mortars. These were divided between four leaders:

Colonel Lukovkin, with 250 Cossacks of the Khopersky regiment, 120 Don Cossacks, 433 infantry, 2 battery guns, 2 horse guns, total forces of the column: 803 combat units with 4 guns. [5]

Major General Turchaninov, with 550 infantry, 300 Cossacks of different regiments, 4 guns and 2 mortars, the total forces of the column: 850 combat units with 4 guns and 2 mortars. [5]

Major Romashev, with 100 Cossacks of the Khopersky regiment, 2 infantry companies, 2 guns, the total forces of the column: about 610 combat units with 2 guns. [5]

Major General Andropov, with 2 companies of rangers, 250 Cossacks, 3 guns total forces of the column: about 730 combat units with 3 guns [5] [13]


The army of Karachay was significantly smaller. According to the military historian V.A. Potto, the forces of the Karachays concentrated in Khasauka were "only 500 people"; also, by the end of the battle, "a new party of two hundred people" arrived; most likely, these were those who defended at the Stone Bridge (KCR). The army also included a number of volunteers from the Balkarian communities. [13]

Battle

The military campaign began on 17 October (29), 1828. Two columns were drawn up for the campaign: the first, under the command of Colonel Lukovkin, assembled near the village of Borgustan, consisted of 250 Cossacks of the Khopyor Regiment, 120 Don Cossacks, 443 infantry, 2 battery and 2 horse guns. The second concentrated near the river. Malki, at the "Stone Bridge", under the command of Major General Turchaninov, including 550 infantry, 300 Cossacks from line and Don various regiments, 4 guns and 2 hand mortars. [5]

General Emmanuel himself was with the first column. In addition, Major General Antropov was ordered with a small detachment allocated from the Kuban reserves to go to another "Stone Bridge", in Kuban, and cover the columns; another detachment of hundreds of Khopers, 2 companies of infantry, and 2 guns, located in the Ukrainian. Ust-Dzhegutinsky, under the command of Major Romashev, was ordered to join Lukovkin's column and take part in the campaign against the Karachais. [5]

The route was chosen thanks to Emmanuel's guides, Magomet Dudov, and the Abaza prisoner, assimilated by the Kabardians, Atazhuko Abukov, the latter was often, but erroneously, identified with the Kabardian prince Atajuko Atazhukin. [14]

On 20 October (1 November), 1828, Russian troops began the approach to the pass near Mount Khasauka near the village of Kart-Dzhurt, where at the foot of the mountain they were met by troops of the Karachay people's militia. In the vanguard of the Russians, under the command of Major Verzilin, followed a hundred Khoper Cossacks, 80 people of the Volga Cossacks, a company of Navagintsev and 100 riflemen of the Tenginsky regiment, one horse gun and two kegorn mortars, the rest of the infantry moved behind the vanguard, with the Cossacks in the tail; the rearguard consisted of 30 infantry and 30 Cossacks. When climbing Mount Khotsekoy, the Karachais met the vanguard with strong fire, trying to delay its movement. After an hour and a half bayonet battle, the mountain was captured.

At noon, the troops descended to the Khudes River, crossed the river, and, with difficulty installing one gun and both mortars, fired at the forest ahead, from where the Karachais greatly harassed the enemy. Next, we had to overcome the last obstacle - the pass to Karachay, a mountain called "Donkey Saddle". Behind a strong stone blockade blocking the path to the mountain, a detachment of 50 Karachais poured a hail of bullets on the advancing vanguard, but after shots from a gun, the Karachais were forced to leave the forward blockage. [5]

Having strengthened the vanguard, General Emmanuel moved all the troops to the pass; 100 Cossack horse breeders were walking in the rear. Taking advantage of the position, the Karachais met the troops with "deadly fire and a mass of stones"; this stubborn battle lasted for 6 hours, where they had to overcome seven mountain ranges over 2–3 miles in order to capture the last height. Finally, the Karachais were forced to leave the last pass and retreat through forests and rocks to the opposite side of the gorge towards the Kuban.

At seven in the morning a battle began, which lasted for 12 hours and ended at seven in the evening. The number of troops of General Emmanuel in the Khasauki Pass - 1653 soldiers and officers, with 8 guns and 2 kegorn mortars, in addition, another detachment, under the command of Major Romashev, with about 610 soldiers and officers with 2 guns - arrived at the Khasauki Pass towards the end of the battle, at the same time, another detachment of Major General Andropov was operating at the Kamenny Bridge in the Kuban, about 730 soldiers and officers with 3 guns. The detachment of which Potto mistakenly confuses with the detachment of Major General Turchaninov due to the similar names of the strongholds in the Kuban and Malka - "Stone Bridge". The number of Karachais led by Islam Krymshamkhalov is not known exactly; the estimated number is about 500-700 people.

U. Aliyev states that: "The Karachais, shrouded in the darkness of the coming night, retreated through such terrain where the troops could easily lose the fruits of a dearly won victory if the mountaineers, having come to their senses, made a night attack (tradition says that in This is the fault of the mountain princes, who vilely provoked the fighting Karachays with the alleged decision of the ruler of Karachay, the prince of "Islam", to lay down arms...)". [15]

As a result of the battle, the mountain formations were pushed back beyond the pass. The next day, Russian troops moved deep into the territory of Karachay to the village of Kart-Dzhurt . On 21 October ( 2 November ) Karachay parliamentarians came to the general, on the 22nd Oliy Krymshamkhalov visited Emmanuel’s camp, "with all the elders and submitted a petition attached in the name of the entire people," and on the 23rd "the entire Karachay people swore an oath of allegiance to citizenship Sovereign Emperor" with a presentation from both Islam Krymshamkhalov and three more "first families" of amanats, that is, honorary hostages. [16] According to Karachay legends.

Casualties

According to military historian A.L. Ghisetti, losses during the entire expedition amounted to 69 killed and 193 wounded from 17 October (29) till 29 October (10 November). [17] Emmanuel's biographer N.B. Golitsyn indicates the loss of 44 killed and 120 wounded directly in the battle on 20 October (1 November). [18] The hundred riflemen of the Tenginsky regiment, which were in the vanguard, lost 6 and wounded 26. [10] According to Caucasus newspaper, 1869 the casualty losses go up to 800 killed and wounded. [19] According to Ghisetti's estimates, the battle of Khasauka accounted for about a quarter of all losses of Russian forces in the Caucasus in 1828. The losses of the highlanders were not counted.

Aftermath

On 23 October (4 November), the Karachay deputation led by Oliy Islam Krymshamkhalov signed with the troops of General Emmanuel, who approached the village of Kart-Jurt, "A petition from the Karachays to the commander of the Caucasian line G. A. Emanuel to accept them into Russian citizenship and provide patronage." - a document according to which Karachay was part of the Russian Empire. [20]

Some authors note that the Karachays impeccably complied with the terms of the treaty and did not violate its provisions throughout the subsequent period of the Caucasian War. [21] [22]

General Emmanuel wrote to St. Petersburg about the results of the battle: [23] [24]

Thermopylae of the North Caucasus was taken by our troops, and the stronghold of Karachay, at the foot of Elbrus, for all mountain peoples hostile to Russia, with the help of God and the bravery of the troops, under my personal leadership, was destroyed... In the St. Petersburg newspaper " Northern Bee " on 22 November (4 December), 1828, it was written about this battle. [25]

Brilliant success paves the way for the calm of the entire Caucasian region... The example of the conquest of this people, considered the most invincible among all mountain residents, will give others the opportunity to think about the possibility of repeating the same incident with them. The final annexation of Karachay occurred in 1834, which was reported on 24 September in his report from Tiflis, the commander of the separate Caucasian Corps G.V. Rosen to the Minister of War A.I. Chernyshev, about the negotiations of Prince I.V. Shakhovsky with the Karachais, "on the resumption oath of allegiance to Russia": [26]

Due to their position, the Karachais can contribute very much to ensuring the peace of the surroundings of Mineral Waters and Kabarda, in order to convince them of this, I allowed the staff captain, Prince Shakhovsky, to promise them that their former amanates will be returned if they again submit to the conditions that are beneficial to us conditions...During the ongoing negotiations between Prince Shakhovsky and the elders, this Karachay people proved by experience their zeal and the benefits that can be expected from their sincere devotion. A party of predators, having crossed the Kuban, stole 6 rams and 60 cattle from Kabarda and carried away three boys into captivity; the most honorable of the elders of the Karachays, the seventy-year-old old man Krymshamkhalov with 30 of his people rushed in pursuit, caught up with the predators and, despite the fact that there were 140 of them, stopped and held until he received reinforcements from the people, then, having recaptured all the prey from them, returned to the Kabardians according to their ownership.

Folklore

The Battle of Khasauka has been memorialized in Karachay and Balkar folklore, with songs and oral traditions preserving the memory of the Karachay warriors who fought in the battle. Songs such as "Khasauqa" and "Song of Umar" celebrate the bravery and sacrifice of those who resisted Russian conquest. These cultural expressions have helped maintain a sense of identity and resistance among the Karachay people, even as they became part of the Russian Empire.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mountain Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic</span> 1921-1924 autonomous republic in the Russian SFSR

The Mountain Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic or Mountain ASSR was a short-lived autonomous republic within the Russian SFSR in the Northern Caucasus that existed from 20 January 1921, to 7 July 1924. The Mountainous Republic of the Northern Caucasus was created from parts of the Kuban and Terek Oblasts by the indigenous nationalities after the Russian Revolution; however, Soviet rule was installed on this territory after the Red Army conquered the Northern Caucasus in the course of the Russian Civil War, and the former republic was transformed into a Soviet one. The area of the republic was over 73,000 square kilometres (28,000 sq mi), and the population was about 800,000. It comprised six okrugs: Balkar, Chechen, Kabardian, Karachay, Nazran (Ingushetia), and Vladikavkaz Okrug (Ossetia) and had two cities: Grozny and Vladikavkaz. In addition, a special autonomy was provided to the Terek Cossacks: Sunzha Cossack Okrug, which included a large enclave in northern Ingushetia, and a smaller one bordering Grozny. Its boundaries approximated those of classical Zyx.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karachays</span> North Caucasian Turkic ethnic group

The Karachays or Karachais are an indigenous North Caucasian-Turkic ethnic group native to the North Caucasus. They are primarily located in their ancestral lands in Karachay–Cherkess Republic, a republic of Russia in the North Caucasus. They have a common origin, culture, and language with the Balkars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Balkars</span> North Caucasian Turkic ethnic group

Balkars are a Turkic ethnic group in the North Caucasus region, one of the titular populations of Kabardino-Balkaria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kuban Cossacks</span> Ethnic group

Kuban Cossacks, or Kubanians, are Cossacks who live in the Kuban region of Russia. Most of the Kuban Cossacks are descendants of different major groups of Cossacks who were re-settled to the western Northern Caucasus in the late 18th century. The western part of the region was settled by the Black Sea Cossack Host who were originally the Zaporozhian Cossacks of Ukraine, from 1792. The eastern and southeastern part of the host was previously administered by the Khopyour and Kuban regiments of the Caucasus Line Cossack Host and Don Cossacks, who were re-settled from the Don from 1777.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Sarikamish</span> Battle between Russia and the Ottoman Empire

The Battle of Sarikamish was an engagement between the Russian and Ottoman empires during World War I. It took place from December 22, 1914, to January 17, 1915, as part of the Caucasus campaign.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Terek Cossacks</span> Cossack host

The Terek Cossack Host was a Cossack host created in 1577 from free Cossacks who resettled from the Volga to the Terek River. The local aboriginal Terek Cossacks joined this Cossack host later. In 1792 it was included in the Caucasus Line Cossack Host and separated from it again in 1860, with the capital of Vladikavkaz. In 1916 the population of the Host was 255,000 within an area of 1.9 million desyatinas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kabardia</span> Historical country in the North Caucasus

The Grand Principality of Great Kabarda, also known as East Circassia or Karbardia, was a historical country in the North Caucasus corresponding partly to modern-day Kabardino-Balkaria. It existed as a political community from the fifteenth century until it came under Russian control in the early nineteenth century after the Russo-Circassian War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ethnic groups in the Caucasus</span> Diverse group comprising more than 50 ethnic groups

The peoples of the Caucasus, or Caucasians, are a diverse group comprising more than 50 ethnic groups throughout the Caucasus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Russo-Circassian War</span> Russian invasion and annexation of Circassia (1763–1864)

The Russo-Circassian War, also known as the Russian invasion of Circassia, was the 101-year-long invasion of Circassia by the Russian Empire. The conflict started in 1763 (O.S.) with Russia assuming authority in Circassia, followed by Circassian refusal, and ended with the last army of Circassia defeated on 21 May 1864 (O.S.). It was exhausting and casualty-heavy for both sides. The Russo-Circassian War was the longest war both Russia and Circassia have ever fought and the longest war in the Caucasus region.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Russian conquest of the Caucasus</span> 19th-century conquest of the Caucasus by the Russian Empire

The Russian conquest of the Caucasus mainly occurred between 1800 and 1864. The Russian Empire sought to control the region between the Black Sea and Caspian Sea. South of the mountains was the territory that is modern Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, and parts of Iran and Turkey. North of the mountains was the North Caucasus region of modern Russia. The difficult conquest of the intervening mountains is known as the Caucasian War. Multiple wars were fought against the local rulers of the regions, as well as the dominant powers, the Ottoman Empire and Qajar Iran, for control. By 1864 the last regions were brought under Russian control.

Balkar and Karachay nationalism is the national sentiment among the Balkars and Karachai. It generally manifests itself in:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1st Caucasus Army Corps</span> Military formation of the Russian Empire

The 1st Caucasus Army Corps was a military formation of the Russian Empire which existed between 1847 and 1918, including the period during World War I.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Choloki</span> 1854 battle of the Crimean War

The Battle of Choloki took place on 4 June 1854 on the outskirts of village Kakuti in Guria during the Crimean War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jembulat Boletoqo</span> Circassian nobleman, military commander, and politician

Jembulat Boletoqo was a Circassian military commander, politician, nobleman and leader of the Temirgoy region. He was one of the most influential figures in the Russo-Circassian War. He had a big influence on the entire Trans-Kuban region. He was famous for his courage and tough will. He had great influence among all Circassians, including the Abadzekhs, with whom he was associated with.

The Battle of Gordali was one of the fiercest battles of the Caucasian War. The battle between the Separate Caucasian Corps of the Caucasian Army under the command of Colonel Baklanov and the Chechen troops under the leadership of Naibs Eski and Talkhig took place on August 11, 1852, near the village of Gurdali, located on the Michik River. The purpose of the campaign was to destroy the village of Gordali. The Russians managed to break into the village, but due to heavy losses Baklanov was forced to retreat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Anapa (1791)</span> 1791 battle of the Russo-Turkish War (1787–1792)

The siege of Anapa or the storming of Anapa was a siege that took place on July 3, 1791, when the Russian Empire attacked the Turkish-regulated Anapa fort in Circassia as part of the Russo-Turkish War and the Russo-Circassian War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Khankala (1807)</span> Military action of Caucasian War

The battle of Khankala happened on 17 February 1807. In this action, the Khankala fortification was taken by storm. Russian forces entered Chechnya from three directions under the command of General of Infantry S. A. Bulgakov. The purpose of the expedition was to establish control over the strategically important Khankala Gorge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sheikh Mansur movement</span>

The Sheikh Mansur movement, was a major war between the Russian Empire and the North Caucasians, caused by the Chechen religious and military leader Sheikh Mansur, who opposed the Russian expansionist policies and wanted to unite the North Caucasians under one, single, Islamic state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Capture of Abbasabad</span>

The Capture of Abbasabad - the siege and capture by Russian troops of the Persian fortress Abbasabad, in the Nakhichevan Khanate, during the Russo-Persian War of 1826-1828 The siege lasted from July 13 to 19 July, during which Russian troops defeated the Persian troops of the crown prince Abbas-Mirza. Soon after this, the fortress capitulated.

The Karachay Uprising of 1855 was a rebellion by the Karachay people and other Circassian mountain tribes against the Russian Empire during the Caucasian War. This uprising took place in August 1855 in what is now the Karachay-Cherkess Republic. It was organized by the naib (deputy) of Imam Shamil, Muhammad Amin, alongside Magomet Efendi Hubiev, a spiritual leader of the Karachay people. The primary goal was to expel Russian influence from the region and unite the local forces with those of Imam Shamil.

References

  1. "The accession of the Karachay territory to thе Russian Empire in 1828" (PDF).
  2. "Chronology of Wars in the Contemporary Age: Third Decade of the 19th Century, p. 16" (PDF).
  3. "Susana Noemí Tomasi, World Economic History: The Relationship Between Economic Crises and Wars, Volume VIII: In the Contemporary Age, Chapter VII - Third Decade of the 19th Century, p. 361" (PDF).
  4. 1 2 "Karachay in the Caucasian War of the XIX century". www.elbrusoid.org. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Tolstov V. (1900). City History of the Khopyor Regiment /Kuban Cossack Army. 1696 -1896: in 2 parts (PDF) (Vol. 1. ed.). C A. Potto. - TF.: Type. Headquarters of the Caucasian Military District. pp. 205–209.
  6. 1 2 Puzanov V. C (1913). History of the 5th Don Cossack Military Ataman Vlasov Regiment... pp. 397–399.
  7. "1827 January 11. - Appeal of the Balkar and Ossetian elders" . Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  8. "KARACHAY AND BALKARIA IN THE RUSSIAN-CAUCASIAN WAR - Barazbiev M.I. - History - Articles - Karachay and Balkars". karachai.ucoz.ru. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  9. "Karachays awarded orders in the Second World War. Messengers of Karachai are the defenders of the fatherland on Belarusian soil. You have to work to survive". my-kross.ru. Retrieved 10 October 2024.
  10. 1 2 Rakovich D. C. "Tengin regiment in the Caucasus. 1819-1846 / Ed. C A. Potto. - Tf.: Type. Kanz. Chief of the city part in the Caucasus, 1900. - p. 17, 81—82". rusneb.run - National e-Bibliothek (in Russian). Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  11. Shcherbina F. A. History of the Kuban Cossack army. Vol 2. - Ekaterinodar, 1913. - p. 385-388.
  12. "Hotko S. H. Karachay is a country on the top of the Caucasus. Essays on the history and culture of Karachay. P. 83" . Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  13. 1 2 Potto V. A. Conquest of Karachai residents // Caucasian War in separate essays, episodes, legends and biographies: in 5 volumes. p. 320.
  14. Z.B. Kipkeeva. Descendants of Genghis Khan in the history of the North Caucasus of the XVIII-XIX centuries. - Stavropol, 2017. - S. 178-179. - ISBN 978-5-9296-0891-9.
  15. Umar Aliyev. Karachay (Historical, ethnological and cultural and economic essay). - 2nd. - Cherkessk, 1991. - p. 94.
  16. "Socio-economic, political and cultural development of the peoples of Karachay-Cherkessia. 1790-1917. Collection of documents. p. 39". www.elbrusoid.org. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  17. "Gisetti A. L. Collection of information on the losses of Caucasian troops during the wars of the Caucasus-mountain, Persian, Turkish and in the Trans-Caspian region. 1801-1885. p. 22-23". runivers.ru. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  18. "Golitsyn N. B. Biography of the general from Emmanuel's cavalry". www.vostlit.info. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  19. Caucasus newspaper, Wednesday, 18 June (30), 1869
  20. Socio-economic, political and cultural development of the peoples of Karachay-Cherkessia. 1790-1917. Collection of documents. - Rostov-on-Don, 1985. - p. 40.
  21. "Customary law in the North Caucasus (May 16, 2013)".
  22. т Хатуев, Р.; т Лайпанов, К.; м Шаманов, И. (2009). Laipanov K. T., Khatuev R. T., Shamanov I. Min Karachay from ancient times to 1917: historical and ethnographic essays. - Alan Hermitage, 2009. - 269 p. (in Russian). ИКО "Аланский Эрмитаж". ISBN   978-5-86494-021-1.
  23. "Laipanov Bilal. Islam in the history and self-consciousness of the Karachay people // Islam in Eurasia". 4 March 2016. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  24. All our gods are with us and for us: ethnic identity and ethnic mobilization in the contemporary art of the peoples of Russia (in Russian). ЦИМО. 1999. ISBN   978-5-201-13730-4.
  25. Note // Northern Bee : newspaper. - St. Petersburg, 1828, 22 November. - Issue. 140.
  26. Socio-economic, political and cultural development of the peoples of Karachay-Cherkessia. 1790-1917. Collection of documents. - Rostov-on-Don, 1985. - p. 48-49.