Boren–McCurdy proposals

Last updated

The Boren-McCurdy intelligence reform proposals were two legislative proposals from Senator David Boren and Representative Dave McCurdy in 1992 (102nd Congress). Both pieces of legislation proposed the creation of a National Intelligence Director. Neither bill passed into law.

Contents

Background

The Congressional Research Service’s report groups the Boren-McCurdy proposal under "Recommendations to Centralize and Strengthen IC Leadership". [1] The following are recommendations for centralization before the Boren–McCurdy proposals, and the descriptions are directly from "The Proposed Authorities of a National Intelligence Director: Issues for Congress and Side-by-Side Comparison of S. 2845, H.R. 10 and Current Law", last updated in 2004:

Second Hoover Commission, 1955

The Commission on Organization of the Executive Branch of the Government, also known as the Second Hoover Commission and chaired by former President Herbert Hoover, recommended that management of the CIA be turned over to an "executive officer", so that the DCI could focus attention on the IC.

The Schlesinger Report, 1971

President Nixon tasked the Office of Budget and Management to recommend changes in the IC's organization. Deputy OMB Director James R. Schlesinger, a future DCI, headed the effort and in his report considered the creation of an NID, but in the end recommended that "a strong DCI who could bring intelligence costs under control and intelligence production to an adequate level of quality and responsiveness." Schlesinger criticized the IC's failure to coordinate resources, blaming the deficiency on the lack of a strong, central IC leadership that could "consider the relationship between cost and substantive output from a national perspective."

Murphy Commission, 1975

The Commission on the Organization of the Government for the Conduct of Foreign Policy, chaired by former Deputy Secretary of State Robert D. Murphy, noted that the DCI exercised direct control over the CIA but had only limited influence over the IC as a whole. But rather than recommending a structural change, the Commission said it was neither possible nor desirable to extend the DCI's control to the large part of the intelligence community that lies outside the CIA.

Church Committee, 1976

The Senate Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities, known as the Church Committee and headed by Senator Frank Church, did not recommend establishing an NID but urged that DCI authorities be strengthened by appropriating intelligence dollars directly to the DCI and by defining in statute DCI reprogramming authorities. The Committee also recommended that consideration be given to enhancing the DCI's management of the IC by relieving him of day-to-day management of the CIA.

Pike Committee, 1976

The House Select Committee on Intelligence, chaired by Congressman Otis G. Pike, recommended that the DCI should manage the IC as a whole and not exclusively the CIA. The Commission said the DCI should receive budget proposals from intelligence agencies comprising the community but did not indicate whether the DCI should have budget authority.

Clifford/Cline, 1976

Clark Clifford, a former Secretary of Defense under President Lyndon B. Johnson who had earlier participated in drafting legislation establishing the CIA, recommended that a new position of Director of General Intelligence be established and that a separate CIA director be responsible for managing the CIA. Ray Cline, a former Deputy Director of the CIA, recommended that the DCI be given cabinet rank and broad supervisory authorities over the IC.

Charter Legislation, 1978

Following the establishment of the intelligence oversight committees in the Senate (1976) and in the House (1977), Congress considered charter legislation that, among other things, would have created an NID to manage the IC. A presidentially selected deputy would manage CIA. In the face of strong opposition to the overall legislation, which also included language governing covert actions, the Committees did not report the respective bills.

Executive Branch Orders, 1976–1981

In an effort to head off further congressional action, President Gerald Ford in 1976 issued Executive Order (E.O.) 11905 naming the DCI as the President's primary intelligence advisor responsible for developing the NFIP.

President Jimmy Carter in 1978 issued E.O. 12036 (superseding E.O. 11905) more clearly defining the DCI's community-wide authority in areas relating to the budget, tasking, intelligence review, coordination, intelligence dissemination and foreign liaison.

President Ronald Reagan in 1981 continued the expansion of the DCI's community responsibilities and authorities, issuing E.O. 12333 (superseding E.O. 12036), which detailed the roles, responsibilities, missions, and activities of the IC. Executive Order 12333, which remains in effect today, granted the DCI more explicit authority over the development, implementation, and evaluation of the NFIP.

Turner Proposal, 1985

Admiral Stansfield Turner, former DCI under President Carter, recommended establishing an NID to oversee the IC, and leaving responsibility for CIA day-to-day operations to a separate director of CIA.

McCurdy Recommendations (The National Security Act of 1992)

Director Of National Intelligence

The McCurdy proposal wanted to rename the Director of Central Intelligence to the Director of National Intelligence (DNI). [2] The President with consent from the Senate would appoint the Director of National Intelligence, under the McCurdy proposal. The Director could not be an active duty Armed Forces officer. [2]

Responsibilities

The Director would be responsible for providing intelligence to the President, heads of departments and agencies of the executive branch, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, senior military commanders, the Senate, the House of Representatives, and their appropriate respective committees. [2]

Another responsibility of the DNI would be the development and presentation of an annual budget for the National Foreign Intelligence Program (NFIP). [2]

Authorities

The DNI would have access to any collection capability and national security intelligence collected by the IC. [2] The DNI would also have the power to temporarily reassign any individual from one National Foreign Intelligence Program (NFIP) to another NFIP. The DNI would lead coordination efforts with foreign governments for issues pertaining to intelligence or security services of foreign governments.). [2] Allocation and direction of the expenditure of funds would also be under the purview of the DNI. [2] Changes in funding distribution would require approval from the DNI. In order to reduce costs, the DNI would be able to rotate, consolidate, and standardize personnel and programming. [2]

Intelligence Evaluation Board

The director would be required to establish an Intelligence Evaluation Board to objectively evaluate the quality and timeliness of the intelligence provided to the government, and to assist the director in carrying out his responsibilities. [2]

Deputy Director Of National Intelligence For The Intelligence Community

The Deputy Director for the National Intelligence Community would be appointed by the President with approval from the Senate. [2] The Deputy Director would carry out duties assigned by the DNI, and oversee the Office for Warning and Crisis Support. [2]

Office For Warning And Crisis Support

The Office for Warning and Crisis Support would be established under the Deputy Director of National Intelligence and be composed of full-time senior representatives chosen by the DNI. [2] The director of the office would also be chosen by the DNI. [2] The Office for Warning and Crisis Support would be responsible for identifying immediate national security threats or any area where United States intervention may become necessary or desirable. [2] The office would also be responsible for providing intelligence support for President and other senior officials in times of crisis, as wells as assisting the DNI in areas or warning and crisis support. [2]

Deputy Director Of National Intelligence For Estimates And Analysis

The Deputy Director of National Intelligence would carry out duties assigned by the DNI. The Deputy Director would be appointed by the President with approval from the Senate and could not be an active duty officer. [2]

Office Of Intelligence Analysis

The Office of Intelligence Analysis would be under the deputy director for estimates and analysis. [2] The office would be composed of analysts from the IC, and the DNI would appoint its director. [2] Responsibilities would include correlating, evaluating, and distributing all available national security intelligence, and the preparation and dissemination of all current intelligence. [2]

Office Of Open Source Information

The Office of Open Source Information would be established under the Deputy Director of National Intelligence for Estimates and Analysis. [2] All current open source entities would be consolidated under this Act, and be led by a DNI appointed director. [2] The office would manage a single open source program and budget, coordinate collection, analysis, and dissemination of information with potential intelligence value. [2] Under McCurdy's proposal, the Office of Open Source Information would be the sole entity for all open source activity. [2]

Establishment Of National Imagery Agency

A National Imagery Agency would be established under the Department of Defense and its director appointed by the Secretary of Defense. [2] The director may be an active officer, and must be a lieutenant general or vice admiral. [2]

Imagery Intelligence Activities

The National Imagery Agency would be responsible for collection, exploitation and analysis, and dissemination of imagery intelligence. The agency would also set product and dissemination standards to fulfill its collection, analysis, and dissemination functions. [2]

Boren Recommendations (The Intelligence Reorganization Act of 1992)

Director of National Intelligence

The President with approval from the Senate would appoint the Director of National Intelligence. The DNI would serve as the head of the IC and be the principal advisor to the President. [3] The DNI would also “exercise authority, direction, and control over the Central Intelligence Agency”. [3]

The positions of Deputy Director of National Intelligence for the Intelligence Community and Deputy Director of National Intelligence for Estimates and Analysis would be created to assist the DNI. [3] The president with approval from the Senate would appoint both deputy directors. Only one of the deputy directors could be an Armed Forces officer (active or retired) at a given time. An Armed Forces candidate must have reached the status of general or admiral, or be promoted upon appointment to deputy director. [3]

Responsibilities

The DNI would be responsible for timely, independent, and objective intelligence to the president, and where appropriate, heads of departments and agencies, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, senior military commanders, and the Senate and House of Representatives. [3] The DNI would develop and present an annual budget, manage the collection capabilities if the IC, evaluate the utility of the intelligence, eliminate waste and duplication, provide direction and approval for overhead reconnaissance systems, and protect sources and methods. [3]

The Deputy Director of National Intelligence for the Intelligence Community would be responsible for an Office for Warning and Crisis Support. The Office would be composed of senior IC members with a director appointed by the DNI. [3] The Office for Warning and Crisis Support would identify any immediate threat to US national security, and provide options of intervention or involvement. The Deputy Director would also establish a board to evaluate the objectivity, quality, and timeliness of intelligence provided to the government by the IC. [3]

Authorities

The DNI would have access to any intelligence related to national security, be responsible for the allocation and expenditure of funds, and have authority to temporarily (up to 180 days) reassign IC members. Intelligence prioritization and coordination with foreign governments would also be under the DNI authority. [3]

Establishment of a Committee on Foreign Intelligence

Within the National Security Council would be the Committee on Foreign Intelligence. The Committee would be composed of “the Director of National Intelligence, the Secretary of State, the Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of Commerce, or their respective deputies, the Assistant to the President for National Security Affairs, and such other members as the President may designate”. [3] The Assistant to the President for National Security Affairs would serve as the chairman. The Committee would establish national security priorities and evaluate the effectiveness of the IC. [3]

Establishment of National Imagery Agency

The Department of Defense would establish a National Imagery Agency with a director appointed by the Secretary of Defense (with consultation from the DNI). The Agency would be the sole entity for overhead reconnaissance collection and operation for the entire IC. The National Imagery Agency would also be responsible for collecting, analyzing, and disseminating its own intelligence products. [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Director of Central Intelligence</span> Head of the US Central Intelligence Agency (1946–2005)

The director of central intelligence (DCI) was the head of the American Central Intelligence Agency from 1946 to 2005, acting as the principal intelligence advisor to the president of the United States and the United States National Security Council, as well as the coordinator of intelligence activities among and between the various US intelligence agencies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Director of National Intelligence</span> US Cabinet-level government official

The director of national intelligence (DNI) is a senior, cabinet-level United States government official, required by the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004 to serve as executive head of the United States Intelligence Community (IC) and to direct and oversee the National Intelligence Program (NIP). All IC agencies report directly to the DNI. The DNI also serves, upon invitation, as an advisor to the president of the United States, the National Security Council and the Homeland Security Council on all intelligence matters. The DNI, supported by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), produces the President's Daily Brief (PDB), a top-secret document including intelligence from all IC agencies, handed each morning to the president of the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States Intelligence Community</span> Collective term for US federal intelligence and security agencies

The United States Intelligence Community (IC) is a group of separate United States government intelligence agencies and subordinate organizations that work both separately and collectively to conduct intelligence activities which support the foreign policy and national security interests of the United States. Member organizations of the IC include intelligence agencies, military intelligence, and civilian intelligence and analysis offices within federal executive departments.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bureau of Intelligence and Research</span> Intelligence agency in the U.S. State Department

The Bureau of Intelligence and Research (INR) is an intelligence agency in the United States Department of State. Its central mission is to provide all-source intelligence and analysis in support of U.S. diplomacy and foreign policy. INR is the oldest civilian element of the U.S. Intelligence Community and among the smallest, with roughly 300 personnel. Though lacking the resources and technology of other U.S. intelligence agencies, it is "one of the most highly regarded" for the quality of its work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Director of the Central Intelligence Agency</span> Head of the Central Intelligence Agency

The director of the Central Intelligence Agency (D/CIA) is a statutory office that functions as the head of the Central Intelligence Agency, which in turn is a part of the United States Intelligence Community.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Directorate of Operations (CIA)</span>

The Directorate of Operations (DO), less formally called the Clandestine Service, is a component of the US Central Intelligence Agency. It was known as the Directorate of Plans from 1951 to 1973; as the Directorate of Operations from 1973 to 2005; and as the National Clandestine Service (NCS) from 2005 to 2015.

The National Intelligence Board (NIB), formerly the National Foreign Intelligence Board and before that the United States Intelligence Board is a body of senior U.S. Intelligence Community leaders currently led by the Director of National Intelligence (DNI). The Board is tasked with reviewing and approving National Intelligence Estimates (NIEs).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Porter Goss</span> American politician and former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency

Porter Johnston Goss is an American politician and government official who served as a Republican member of the U.S. House of Representatives from 1989 until 2004, when he became the last Director of Central Intelligence (DCI) and the first Director of the Central Intelligence Agency following the passage of the 2004 Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act, which abolished the DCI position and replaced it with the Director of National Intelligence on April 21, 2005.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence and Security</span>

The under secretary of defense for intelligence and security or USD(I&S) is a high-ranking civilian position in the Office of the Secretary of Defense (OSD) within the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) that acts as the principal civilian advisor and deputy to the secretary of defense (SecDef) and deputy secretary of defense (DepSecDef) on matters relating to military intelligence and security. The under secretary is appointed as a civilian by the president and confirmed by the Senate to serve at the pleasure of the president.

The Open Source Enterprise (OSE) is a United States Government organization dedicated to open-source intelligence that was established by Assistant Deputy Director of National Intelligence for Open Source (ADDNI/OS), Eliot A. Jardines. They provide material to the National Technical Information Service (NTIS) and other government officials through the online news service World News Connection.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Office of Intelligence and Counterintelligence</span> US government agency

The Office of Intelligence and Counterintelligence (OICI), also abbreviated IN, DOE-IN, DOE/IN, I&CI, or OIC, was established in 2006 by the merger of pre-existing Energy Department intelligence and security organizations. It is an office of the United States Department of Energy (DOE) responsible for all intelligence and counterintelligence activities throughout the DOE complex; due to this central role, OICI is designated DOE's Headquarters Intelligence. As a component of the United States Intelligence Community in addition to the Department of Energy, OICI reports to both the Director of National Intelligence and Secretary of Energy.

The Public Interest Declassification Board (PIDB) is an advisory committee established by the United States Congress with the official mandate of promoting the fullest possible public access to a thorough, accurate, and reliable documentary record of significant U.S. national security decisions and activities. The Board is composed of nine individuals: five appointed by the President of the United States and one each appointed by the Speaker of the House, House Minority Leader, Senate Majority Leader, and Senate Minority Leader. Appointees must be U.S. citizens preeminent in the fields of history, national security, foreign policy, intelligence policy, social science, law, or archives.

The Dulles–Jackson–Correa Report was one of the most influential evaluations of the functioning of the United States Intelligence Community, and in particular, the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). The report focused primarily on the coordination and organization of the CIA and offered suggestions that refined the US intelligence effort in the early stages of the Cold War.

The Eberstadt Report, officially known as the Task Force Report on National Security Organization, was a study conducted by the United States government which evaluated the structure and operations of the United States Department of Defense and United States Intelligence Community. The report was created by the Task Force on National Security Organization, chaired by Ferdinand Eberstadt, from 1948–49 under the Commission on Organization of the Executive Branch of the Government, also known as the First Hoover Commission. The most important findings of the report include recommendations for better cooperation within the US Intelligence Community, improvement in the internal structure and operations of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), and the growing need for the development of scientific intelligence in the background of the Cold War. Despite its submission to US Congress, the report was not widely read due to being overshadowed by the Intelligence Survey Group and its report, the Dulles Report.

United States Intelligence Community Oversight duties are shared by both the executive and legislative branches of the government. Oversight, in this case, is the supervision of intelligence agencies, and making them accountable for their actions. Generally oversight bodies look at the following general issues: following policymaker needs, the quality of analysis, operations, and legality of actions.

The Schlesinger Report, originally titled A Review of the Intelligence Community, was the product of a survey authorized by U.S. President Richard Nixon late in 1970. The objective of the survey was to identify and alleviate factors of ineffectiveness within the United States Intelligence Community (IC) organization, planning, and preparedness for future growth. The report, prepared by James Schlesinger, Deputy Director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), was submitted to Nixon on 10 March 1971.

At various times since the creation of the Central Intelligence Agency, the Federal government of the United States has produced comprehensive reports on CIA actions that marked historical watersheds in how CIA went about trying to fulfill its vague charter purposes from 1947. These reports were the result of internal or presidential studies, external investigations by congressional committees or other arms of the Federal government of the United States, or even the simple releases and declassification of large quantities of documents by the CIA.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Organizational structure of the Central Intelligence Agency</span>

The CIA publishes organizational charts of its agency. Here are a few examples.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2014</span> United States Law

The Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2014 is a U.S. public law that authorizes appropriations for fiscal year 2014 for intelligence activities of the U.S. government. The law authorizes there to be funding for intelligence agencies such as the Central Intelligence Agency or the National Security Agency, but a separate appropriations bill would also have to pass in order for those agencies to receive any money.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Sherman (intelligence)</span> American intelligence government official in United States

John Bradley Sherman is an American intelligence official who has served as the Chief Information Officer at the Department of Defense since December 17, 2021. Prior to that, he served from June 2020 to January 2021 as the Principal Deputy DOD Chief Information Officer. Between 2017 and 2020 he served as Associate Director and Chief Information Officer of the Intelligence Community (IC) at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.

References

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.