| Year | Film | Director | Ref |
|---|
| 2010 | The Whistleblower | Larysa Kondracki | [16] |
| Good Neighbours | Jacob Tierney | [17] |
| Hard Core Logo 2 | Bruce McDonald |
| Jo for Jonathan (Jo pour Jonathan) | Maxime Giroux |
| Small Town Murder Songs | Ed Gass-Donnelly |
| Wrecked | Michael Greenspan |
Craft awards: • Raphaël Lacaille (Jo for Jonathan) and Martha Plimpton (Small Town Murder Songs), Best Performance | [16] |
| 2011 | Keyhole | Guy Maddin | [18] |
| 388 Arletta Avenue | Randall Cole | [19] |
| Café de Flore | Jean-Marc Vallée |
| Doppelgänger Paul | Dylan Akio Smith, Kris Elgstrand |
| Marilyn | Christopher Petry |
| Monsieur Lazhar | Philippe Falardeau |
| Craft awards: None presented this year. | [18] |
| 2012 | Picture Day | Kate Melville | [20] |
| All That You Possess (Tout ce que tu possèdes) | Bernard Émond | [21] |
| Blood Pressure | Sean Garrity |
| Fair Sex (Les Manèges humains) | Martin Laroche |
| Home Again | Sudz Sutherland |
| Mad Ship | David Mortin |
| My Awkward Sexual Adventure | Sean Garrity |
| Still Mine | Michael McGowan |
Craft awards: • Marie-Evelyne Lessard (Fair Sex) and Tatiana Maslany (Picture Day), Best Performance | [20] |
| 2013 |
| The Husband | Bruce McDonald | [22] |
| Cas & Dylan | Jason Priestley | [23] |
| Louis Cyr (Louis Cyr, l'homme le plus fort du monde) | Daniel Roby |
| Patch Town | Craig Goodwill |
| Siddharth | Richie Mehta |
| Uvanga | Marie-Hélène Cousineau, Madeline Ivalu |
Craft awards: • Tatiana Maslany (Cas & Dylan), Best Performance | [22] |
| 2014 | Felix and Meira (Félix et Meira) | Maxime Giroux | [24] |
| After the Ball | Sean Garrity | [25] |
| Bang Bang Baby | Jeffrey St. Jules |
| Mountain Men | Cameron Labine |
| Relative Happiness | Deanne Foley |
| Wolves | David Hayter |
Craft awards: • Hadas Yaron (Felix and Meira), Best Performance • Maxime Giroux (Felix and Meira), Best Director, Best Screenplay | [24] |
| 2015 | River | Jamie M. Dagg | [26] |
| Basic Human Needs | Matthew Yim | [27] |
| The Birdwatcher | Siobhan Devine |
| The Colossal Failure of the Modern Relationship | Sergio Navarretta |
| The Demons (Les Démons) | Philippe Lesage |
| The Diary of an Old Man (Le Journal d’un vieil homme) | Bernard Émond |
| Forsaken | Jon Cassar |
| FSM | Melanie M. Jones |
| He Hated Pigeons | Ingrid Veninger |
| The Hotel Dieu | Adrian Thiessen |
| The Mirage (Le Mirage) | Ricardo Trogi |
| Natasha | David Bezmozgis |
| Nestor | Daniel Robinson |
| Numb | Jason R. Goode |
| Patterson's Wager | O. Corbin Saleken |
| The Sabbatical | Brian Stockton |
| The Steps | Andrew Currie |
| The Sublet | John Ainslie |
| Suspension | Jeffery Scott Lando |
Craft awards: • Paul Savoie (The Diary of an Old Man), Best Performance • Jamie M. Dagg (River), Best Director, Best Screenplay • Dylan Macleod (He Hated Pigeons), Best Cinematography | [26] |
| 2016 | Before the Streets (Avant les rues) | Chloé Leriche | [28] |
| An American Dream: The Education of William Bowman | Ken Finkleman | [29] |
| The Cyclotron (Le Cyclotron) | Olivier Asselin |
| The Death (and Life) of Carl Naardlinger | Katherine Schlemmer |
| Grand Unified Theory | David Ray |
| Hunting Pignut | Martine Blue |
| It's Not My Fault and I Don't Care Anyway | Chris Craddock |
| Lost Solace | Chris Scheuerman |
| Lovesick | Tyson Caron |
| Menorca | John Barnard |
| Population Zero | Adam Levins |
| Raw | David I. Strasser |
| Red Mile | Justin McConnell |
| The Second Time Around | Leon Marr |
| The Space Between | Amy Jo Johnson |
| The Squealing Game | Steve Kerr |
| The Sun at Midnight | Kirsten Carthew |
| The 3 L'il Pigs 2 (Les 3 p'tits cochons 2) | Jean-François Pouliot |
| The Void | Jeremy Gillespie, Steven Kostanski |
Craft awards: • Kawennáhere Devery Jacobs (The Sun at Midnight), Best Performance • Chloé Leriche (Before the Streets), Best Director • Olivier Asselin (The Cyclotron), Best Screenplay • Mathieu Laverdière (The Cyclotron), Best Cinematography | [28] |
| 2017 | All You Can Eat Buddha | Ian Lagarde | [30] |
| Allure | Carlos and Jason Sanchez |
| 8 Minutes Ahead | Ben Hoskyn | [31] |
| Becoming Burlesque | Jackie English |
| The Cannon | Marshall Axani |
| Cardinals | Grayson Moore, Aidan Shipley |
| The Definites | Hannah Cheesman, Mackenzie Donaldson |
| Hochelaga, Land of Souls (Hochelaga, terre des âmes) | François Girard |
| Juggernaut | Daniel DiMarco |
| Mobile Homes | Vladimir de Fontenay |
| Never Saw It Coming | Gail Harvey |
| Nobody Famous | Sarah Rotella |
| Porcupine Lake | Ingrid Veninger |
| The Prodigal Dad | Robert Wenzek |
| Prodigals | Michelle Ouellet |
| Santa Stole Our Dog | Bryan Michael Stoller |
| Someone Else's Wedding | Pat Kiely |
| Trench 11 | Leo Scherman |
| Tulipani, Love, Honour and a Bicycle | Mike van Diem |
| Venus | Eisha Marjara |
Craft awards: • Evan Rachel Wood (Allure), Best Performance • Ian Lagarde (All You Can Eat Buddha), Best Director • Grayson Moore (Cardinals), Best Screenplay • Sara Mishara (Allure), Best Cinematography | [30] |
| 2018 | A Colony (Une colonie) | Geneviève Dulude-De Celles | [32] |
| Acquainted | Natty Zavitz | |
| An Audience of Chairs | Deanne Foley |
| Bella Ciao! | Carolyn Combs |
| The Dancing Dogs of Dombrova | Zack Bernbaum |
| Falls Around Her | Darlene Naponse |
| Family First (Chien de garde) | Sophie Dupuis |
| The Fireflies Are Gone (La Disparition des lucioles) | Sébastien Pilote |
| Honey Bee | Rama Rau |
| In God I Trust | Maja Zdanowski |
| Nose to Tail | Jesse Zigelstein |
| Red Rover | Shane Belcourt |
| Roobha | Lenin M. Sivam |
| Les Salopes, or the Naturally Wanton Pleasure of Skin (Les salopes ou le sucre naturel de la peau) | Renée Beaulieu |
| Sashinka | Kristina Wagenbauer |
| Stockholm | Robert Budreau |
| Trouble in the Garden | Roz Owen |
| Woodland | Jon Silverberg |
Craft awards: • Émilie Bierre (A Colony), Best Performance • Geneviève Dulude-De Celles (A Colony), Best Director • Robert Budreau (Stockholm), Best Screenplay • Michel La Veaux (The Fireflies Are Gone), Best Cinematography | [32] |
| 2019 | Antigone | Sophie Deraspe | [33] |
| Apapacho | Marquise Lepage | [34] |
| Black Conflux | Nicole Dorsey |
| Body and Bones | Melanie Oates |
| Canadian Strain | Geordie Sabbagh |
| The Cuban | Sergio Navarretta |
| Dreamland | Bruce McDonald |
| Entangled | Gaurav Seth |
| Fall Back Down | S. B. Edwards |
| From the Vine | Sean Cisterna |
| Guilt (Le Coupable) | Onur Karaman |
| Hammer | Christian Sparkes |
| The Marijuana Conspiracy | Craig Pryce |
| Promiseland | Kirk Caouette |
| Queen of the Morning Calm | Gloria Ui Young Kim |
| Spinster | Andrea Dorfman |
| Things I Do for Money | Warren P. Sonoda |
| Thunderbird | Nicholas Treeshin |
| Volition | Tony Dean Smith |
| We Had It Coming | Paul Barbeau |
Craft awards: • Nahéma Ricci (Antigone), Best Performance • Sophie Deraspe (Antigone), Best Director, Best Screenplay • Celiana Cárdenas (The Cuban), Best Cinematography | [33] |